From RDF Data Shapes Working Group
Jump to: navigation, search
Thursday at 2pm US Eastern time for 90 minutes
  Beware US and Europe Daylight Saving Time in effect check your timezone: -- 
 WebEx (for audio):
  To join by phone: +1-617-324-0000 US Toll Number
  Access code/Meeting number: 646 464 360
IRC channel: #shapes on on port 6665 (irc link, W3C web irc link)
To start meeting (ignore errors related to Zakim not knowing what teleconf this is): trackbot, start meeting
Zakim instructions:
RRSAgent instructions:


  • Chair: Arnaud
  • Scribe: Karen Coyle, first available on the scribe list.

Minutes of last meeting

PROPOSED: Approve minutes of the 1 October Telecon:

Next meeting

  • Telecon 2015.10.15

Disposal of Raised Issues


ISSUE-95: Template Simplifications

PROPOSED: Close ISSUE-95, adopting Holger's proposed simplifications

ISSUE-91: default cardinality

PROPOSED: Close ISSUE-91, keep defaults as 0 and unbound, in line with resolution of ISSUE-59

ISSUE-57: group cardinality

Discuss ISSUE-57: Cardinalities on expressions or groups of triple constraints

ISSUE-86: ontology association

Discuss ISSUE-86: Associating shapes with ontologies or vocabularies

ISSUE-92: additive repeated properties

Discuss ISSUE-92: Should repeated properties be interpreted as additive or conjunctive?

ISSUE-93: engine / language

Discuss ISSUE-93: SHACL engine vs. SHACL instance requirements

ISSUE-94: separate syntax and semantics

Discuss ISSUE-94: Should RDF syntax requirements be separated from SHACL semantics

ISSUE-96: Violation IDs

Discuss ISSUE-96: Should the validation results contain stable IDs to indicate the type of violation