16:52:41 RRSAgent has joined #aria 16:52:41 logging to http://www.w3.org/2014/09/15-aria-irc 16:52:43 RRSAgent, make logs member 16:52:43 Zakim has joined #aria 16:52:45 Zakim, this will be WAI_PF 16:52:45 ok, trackbot; I see WAI_PFWG(ARIA)1:00PM scheduled to start in 8 minutes 16:52:46 Meeting: Protocols and Formats Working Group Teleconference 16:52:46 Date: 15 September 2014 16:53:10 regrets: Rich_Schwerdtfeger, James_Craig, Stefan_Schnabel 16:53:28 agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-pfwg/2014Sep/0065.html 16:53:28 chair: Michael_Cooper 16:53:39 meeting: WAI-PF ARIA Caucus 16:53:46 rrsagent, make log world 17:01:18 WAI_PFWG(ARIA)1:00PM has now started 17:01:25 +??P2 17:01:49 +??P3 17:01:54 zakim, ??P3 is me 17:01:54 +janina; got it 17:02:06 +[IPcaller] 17:02:08 -[IPcaller] 17:02:18 +[GVoice] 17:02:22 + +1.703.978.aaaa 17:02:25 zakim, GVoice is Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:02:25 +Joseph_Scheuhammer; got it 17:02:32 + +1.603.882.aabb 17:02:33 zakim, I am Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:02:34 ok, clown, I now associate you with Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:02:34 +[IPcaller] 17:02:36 -[IPcaller] 17:02:51 Zakim, aabb is Joanmarie_Diggs 17:02:51 +Joanmarie_Diggs; got it 17:02:59 jongund has joined #aria 17:03:06 LJWatson has joined #aria 17:03:08 Zakim, I am Joanmarie_Diggs 17:03:08 ok, joanie, I now associate you with Joanmarie_Diggs 17:03:14 mattking has joined #aria 17:03:25 zakim, aaaa is Fred_Hesch 17:03:25 +Fred_Hesch; got it 17:03:41 +Jon_Gunderson 17:05:27 +Cynthia_Shelly 17:05:43 + +1.541.678.aacc 17:05:56 zakim, aacc is Matt_King 17:05:56 +Matt_King; got it 17:07:36 +[IPcaller] 17:08:17 LJWatson has joined #aria 17:08:30 zakim, who is on the phone? 17:08:30 On the phone I see Michael_Cooper, janina, Joseph_Scheuhammer, Fred_Hesch, Joanmarie_Diggs, Jon_Gunderson, Cynthia_Shelly, Matt_King, [IPcaller] 17:09:11 zakim, IPcaller is Léonie_Watson 17:09:11 +Léonie_Watson; got it 17:09:54 +[IPcaller] 17:09:56 zakim, Fred is Fred_Esch 17:09:56 +Fred_Esch; got it 17:11:01 zakim, IPcaller is Lisa_Seeman 17:11:01 +Lisa_Seeman; got it 17:12:02 Lisa_Seeman has joined #aria 17:14:36 scribe: matt_king 17:14:59 + +1.415.624.aadd 17:15:13 scribeNick: mattking 17:15:36 zakim, aadd is Bryan_Garaventa 17:15:36 +Bryan_Garaventa; got it 17:15:52 zakim, next item 17:15:52 I see nothing on the agenda 17:15:54 bgaraventa1979 has joined #aria 17:16:27 zakim, I am Bryan_Garaventa 17:16:27 ok, bgaraventa1979, I now associate you with Bryan_Garaventa 17:16:30 topic: Status on wiki for tracking user agent defects on ARIA 1.1 features 17:16:53 TOPIC: Status using wiki for tracking aria 1.1 features 17:17:34 No news on this topic. 17:17:45 Will be discussed tues night at f2f 17:18:36 CS: please see if we can get a room with a whiteboard. 17:18:51 topic: Issue 631 Property to provide keyboard help when element has focus 17:18:58 issue-631? 17:18:58 issue-631 -- Property to provide keyboard help when element has focus -- open 17:18:58 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/issues/631 17:19:24 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-pfwg-comments/2012JanMar/0010.html 17:19:30 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-pfwg-comments/2012JanMar/0011.html 17:20:33 MC: Comment on 1.0; response is that we would consider in 1.1. 17:21:15 MC: Help for SR users that explains how to operate when uncommon key commands are required. 17:21:31 MC: would prefer a dedicated attribute for this purpose. 17:22:02 LW: Would this be an author provided attribute? 17:22:54 MC: Yes. The comment says this could be at times long so comment recommended that a reference to a description. 17:22:54 q? 17:23:03 q+ 17:23:44 q+ 17:23:58 Q+ 17:24:05 LS: You can not use aria-label for this purpose. 17:24:09 q+ 17:24:09 +q 17:24:14 q+ 17:24:19 ack lisa 17:24:20 ack li 17:24:20 q+ 17:25:47 ack ma 17:26:48 q+ to mention context sensitive help 17:27:01 ack l 17:28:11 mk: don´t want to encourage bad design by providing a way to explain around it. Authors should design well from the start, and use aria-describedby or something in the few situations they truly have to explain it. IndieUI is the long term solution. 17:28:23 LW: There is a problem to solve b/c it is difficult for SR users to know what is scripted. 17:28:37 LW: but there would be no easy to visually represent the attribute. 17:29:08 ack jan 17:29:11 ack me 17:29:28 -Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:29:53 +[GVoice] 17:29:57 JS: Indie UI needs to be considered and so we should probably postpone to 2.0 b/c Ineie UI is not ready yet. 17:30:00 ack brya 17:30:02 zakim, GVoice is Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:30:02 +Joseph_Scheuhammer; got it 17:30:12 zakim, I am Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:30:12 ok, clown, I now associate you with Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:30:14 JS: we do not want to have to re-do it in 2.0. 17:31:27 BG: I support it. Often there are too many key commands on a single widget, e.g., a tree that supports both drag/drop and context menus 17:31:36 q+ to ask about the Access Module approach 17:33:32 q+ 17:33:38 BG: You can add aria-drop but there is not a standard command for that. 17:35:37 q+ cynthia 17:35:43 ack jo 17:35:49 ack Joan 17:35:56 MK: I do not understand why ctrl+v or command+v can not be scripted for drop. 17:36:09 q+ matt to explore use cases 17:36:16 Q+ 17:36:42 Joanie: I agree there is a problem to solve, but I too think that Indie UI is the path. Strings alone do not provide a robust answer. 17:37:00 Joanie: action interfaces also help with globalization 17:37:01 ack me 17:37:01 MichaelC, you wanted to mention context sensitive help and to ask about the Access Module approach 17:37:47 BG: Does Indie UI solution provide the ability to provide context-specific interaction information? 17:38:14 CS: The patterns proposed for 2.0 do exactly what Brian described. 17:39:01 LW: Can we take the recommended kb actins in APG it make a more visible reference and perhaps also provide a touch guide as well. 17:39:05 ack me 17:39:45 MC: there is a separate proposal for a form control specific help and they may be a better attribute to overload if we implement it. 17:40:34 http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml-access/ 17:40:52 q+ to ask whether Brian is solving a problem from a specific toolkit? 17:40:58 ack lisa 17:41:43 LS: When aria-controledby is used,the UA should be able to provide help on how to use it. 17:42:17 ack cy 17:42:21 q+ 17:42:25 LW: Can we explore how to mkae the relationship information more useful in the UAs? 17:43:06 q+ 17:43:28 CS: I think that some kind of aria-help or something like that could be valuable. For example, in Windows, thre is a separate key help field 17:43:42 CS: In IE, this is not visually rendered at this time. 17:44:11 CS: The purpose for pattern is self-describing controls. 17:44:37 CS: the bigger issue really should be a 2.0 time frame solution so we can exploit patterns. 17:44:53 CS: The web apps group could benefit from the xhtml module. 17:45:12 ack jan 17:45:12 janina, you wanted to ask whether Brian is solving a problem from a specific toolkit? 17:45:25 q+ 17:45:40 JS: Brian, are you trying to solve a problem that come from a particular web dev toolkit. 17:45:57 BG: Yes 17:46:10 JS: Is this a broken toolkit or a general problem? 17:46:33 BG: I think there are general problems. 17:46:53 BG: I see aria-haspopu used everywhere but there is not a consistent way for activating them. 17:48:21 i need to go... 17:48:24 MK: there should not be help required to open a standard context menu 17:48:30 -Lisa_Seeman 17:50:24 -janina 17:51:18 BG: What about the example of drag/drop that Joseph provided where ctrl left/right is used. How would this be communicated in the wild. 17:51:25 JS: the help is right on the page. 17:51:31 ack jon 17:51:35 BG: designers resist putting on on the page. 17:51:57 JG: This would likely be a redudntat way of mapping to eh a11y api 17:52:16 JG: if it just goes to aria-describedby on some platforms, then it doesn't really help\ 17:52:25 ack lis 17:52:36 +??P3 17:52:41 zakim, ??P3 is me 17:52:41 +janina; got it 17:52:47 ack jos 17:53:20 JS: We adivse people to put a help button in their app that describes keyboard help. 17:53:38 JS: you do not need special aria properties for that. 17:53:43 ack cy 17:54:09 CS: A mechanism for mapping markup to platoform kb mappings is definitely needed. 17:54:24 CS: The answer is needed but it may not be an aira thing. 17:55:00 CS: There are api fields for keybaord help on windows and having an aria mapping for that would be nice. 17:55:25 q- matt 17:56:33 MC: there is no consensus that this is apppropriate for aria 1.1 or even aria. 17:57:09 MC: do we want to do thin in the aria 1.1 time frame? 17:59:40 -Fred_Esch 17:59:48 RESOLUTION: A specific solution for keyboard guidance is not in scope for ARIA 1.1. 18:01:11 MC: If there were a solution for help text, would it be a adequate solution to the keyboard guidance problem? 18:02:00 q+ 18:02:25 issue-406? 18:02:25 issue-406 -- Proposal for new aria-hint property. (Previously proposed as @aria-help) -- open 18:02:25 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/issues/406 18:03:13 CS: On windows this owuld be nice b/c it would be parallel to how native apps work. 18:03:24 zakim, ack me 18:03:24 I see no one on the speaker queue 18:03:28 JS: issue 406 is on the 1.1 agenda 18:04:32 RESOLUTION: Resolving issue 631 could be explored as part of resolving issue 406. 18:05:30 CS: Do we want this issue solved post aria 1.1? 18:05:42 s/CS/MC/ 18:06:22 s/owuld/would/ 18:06:38 Consensus that a future solution is needed. 18:07:06 MC: propose we move the issue to 2.0 18:07:18 issue-406: consider whether this feature can also address the use case raised by issue-631 18:07:19 Notes added to issue-406 Proposal for new aria-hint property. (Previously proposed as @aria-help). 18:07:51 RESOLUTION: Reassign issue 631 to ARIA 2.0 and add a note to issue 406 TO LOOK FOR INTERUM SOLUTIONS. 18:08:15 issue-631: Will explore again in ARIA 2.0, including question of whether to solve in ARIA or another technology 18:08:15 Notes added to issue-631 Property to provide keyboard help when element has focus. 18:08:33 s/INTERUM/INTERIM/ 18:09:47 TOPIC: review open action items 18:10:08 action-1322? 18:10:08 action-1322 -- Jon Gunderson to Make some examples for aria-hidden="false" (including a hidden live region) -- due 2013-12-23 -- OPEN 18:10:08 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1322 18:10:19 action-1322? 18:10:19 action-1322 -- Jon Gunderson to Make some examples for aria-hidden="false" (including a hidden live region) -- due 2013-12-23 -- OPEN 18:10:19 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1322 18:10:35 JG: can I have 2 more weeks? 18:10:36 action-1322 due 2 weeks 18:10:36 Set action-1322 Make some examples for aria-hidden="false" (including a hidden live region) due date to 2014-09-29. 18:10:42 MC: yes, pls post to list. 18:10:55 action-1389? 18:10:55 action-1389 -- Cynthia Shelly to Gather more information about secondary information (desc, tooltip, etc) -- due 2014-03-03 -- OPEN 18:10:55 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1389 18:10:58 action-1389? 18:10:58 action-1389 -- Cynthia Shelly to Gather more information about secondary information (desc, tooltip, etc) -- due 2014-03-03 -- OPEN 18:10:58 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1389 18:11:21 action-1389 due 3 weeks 18:11:21 Set action-1389 Gather more information about secondary information (desc, tooltip, etc) due date to 2014-10-06. 18:11:24 CS: not yet done. Need 3 more weeks.. 18:11:33 actin-1397? 18:11:34 action-1397? 18:11:34 action-1397 -- Jon Gunderson to Create proposal to fill out aria table semantics (tfoot, rowspan, colspan, thead, caption, etc.) -- due 2014-03-10 -- OPEN 18:11:34 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1397 18:11:57 JG: this should be closed. 18:12:06 close action-1397 18:12:06 Closed action-1397. 18:12:16 action-1423? 18:12:16 action-1423 -- Cynthia Shelly to Ask developers about group, none, and generic roles and whether it would be helpful for implementatation of e.g., narrator -- due 2014-05-16 -- OPEN 18:12:16 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1423 18:12:33 action-1423 due 1 week 18:12:33 Set action-1423 Ask developers about group, none, and generic roles and whether it would be helpful for implementatation of e.g., narrator due date to 2014-09-22. 18:12:44 CS: I have the information but need to compile; need 1 more week. 18:12:57 action-1438 due 15 october 18:12:57 Set action-1438 Set up auto publish to GH Pages for editors' drafts https://pages.github.com due date to 2014-10-15. 18:13:09 action-1442? 18:13:09 action-1442 -- Léonie Watson to Create spec. text for aria-currentfor="IDREF" and aria-current="true/false", related to issue-587 -- due 2014-05-26 -- OPEN 18:13:09 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1442 18:14:09 LW: I will pick out the feedback from the thread and start a clean thread. 18:14:47 MC: Discussion needs to be added a a call agenda. 18:15:09 action-1461 due 1 week 18:15:09 Set action-1461 Ask an html-aapi editor to bring question of @inert to html a11y tf due date to 2014-09-22. 18:15:11 action-1461? 18:15:11 action-1461 -- Michael Cooper to Ask an html-aapi editor to bring question of @inert to html a11y tf -- due 2014-09-22 -- OPEN 18:15:11 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1461 18:15:20 action-1462? 18:15:20 action-1462 -- Cynthia Shelly to Discuss computed role with ie team -- due 2014-06-30 -- OPEN 18:15:20 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1462 18:15:30 action-1462 due 1 week 18:15:30 Set action-1462 Discuss computed role with ie team due date to 2014-09-22. 18:15:31 CS: need 1 more week. 18:15:41 action-1463? 18:15:41 action-1463 -- Joseph Scheuhammer to Keep issue-427 on radar for aapi meetings -- due 2014-06-30 -- OPEN 18:15:41 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1463 18:15:55 action-1463 due 1 week 18:15:55 Set action-1463 Keep issue-427 on radar for aapi meetings due date to 2014-09-22. 18:15:56 JS: dependent on Cynthia. 18:16:08 MC: Moving due date out 18:16:10 action-1464 due 1 week 18:16:10 Set action-1464 Discuss implications of Element.computedRole() with Blink team due date to 2014-09-22. 18:16:24 action-1471? 18:16:24 action-1471 -- Jon Gunderson to Start list of requirements for aria 1.1 -- due 2014-07-07 -- OPEN 18:16:24 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1471 18:17:03 action-1471 due 3 weeks 18:17:03 Set action-1471 Start list of requirements for aria 1.1 due date to 2014-10-06. 18:17:04 JG: Need 3 weeks. 18:17:11 MC: want before f2f. 18:17:16 action-1473 18:17:16 action-1473 -- Cynthia Shelly to Prepare recommendation on automation of tracking of bugs filed with various implementers -- due 2014-07-07 -- OPEN 18:17:16 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1473 18:17:50 action-1473 due 30 oct 18:17:50 Set action-1473 Prepare recommendation on automation of tracking of bugs filed with various implementers due date to 2014-10-30. 18:18:05 action-1474? 18:18:05 action-1474 -- Joseph Scheuhammer to Work with joseph s. and david b. to rewrite text alternative computation for both the aria spec. and the core accessibility api mappings specification. -- due 2014-09-04 -- OPEN 18:18:05 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1474 18:18:37 action-1474 due 30 oct 18:18:37 Set action-1474 Work with joseph s. and david b. to rewrite text alternative computation for both the aria spec. and the core accessibility api mappings specification. due date to 2014-10-30. 18:18:40 Joseph: should te a tpac doc 18:19:14 action-1485? 18:19:14 action-1485 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Raise issue-397 with moz/nvda devs regarding aria-setsize="999+" format -- due 2014-08-18 -- OPEN 18:19:14 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1485 18:19:17 action-1485? 18:19:17 action-1485 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Raise issue-397 with moz/nvda devs regarding aria-setsize="999+" format -- due 2014-08-18 -- OPEN 18:19:17 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1485 18:19:20 action-1486? 18:19:20 action-1486 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Inspect webkit backwards-compatibility regarding aria-setsize="999+" format for issue-397 -- due 2014-07-28 -- OPEN 18:19:20 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1486 18:19:37 issue-397? 18:19:37 issue-397 -- Need a way to specify an indeterminate set size -- open 18:19:37 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/issues/397 18:19:40 action-1485 due 2 weeks 18:19:40 Set action-1485 Raise issue-397 with moz/nvda devs regarding aria-setsize="999+" format due date to 2014-09-29. 18:19:45 action-1486 due 2 weeks 18:19:45 Set action-1486 Inspect webkit backwards-compatibility regarding aria-setsize="999+" format for issue-397 due date to 2014-09-29. 18:19:45 Joanie: need 3 weeks. 18:20:04 action-1487 due 1 weeks 18:20:04 Set action-1487 Raise issue-397 with ie/trident devs regarding aria-setsize="999+" format (mainly, would the format change break backwards-compalibility with ie source?) due date to 2014-09-22. 18:20:14 action-1489? 18:20:14 action-1489 -- Michael Cooper to Propose spec text to limit what aria attributes can be overridden by strong native semantics (e.g., aria-label and aria-labelledby) -- due 2014-07-28 -- OPEN 18:20:14 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1489 18:20:31 action-1489 due 4 weeks 18:20:31 Set action-1489 Propose spec text to limit what aria attributes can be overridden by strong native semantics (e.g., aria-label and aria-labelledby) due date to 2014-10-13. 18:20:43 MC: need 4 weeks 18:20:50 action-1493? 18:20:50 action-1493 -- Joseph Scheuhammer to Propose spec text allowing ¨implicit value for role¨ to provide default values for required properties -- due 2014-09-09 -- OPEN 18:20:50 https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/Group/track/actions/1493 18:21:06 action-1493 due 2 weeks 18:21:06 Set action-1493 Propose spec text allowing ¨implicit value for role¨ to provide default values for required properties due date to 2014-09-29. 18:21:09 Joseph: 2 more weeks. 18:21:40 rrsagent, make minutes 18:21:40 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/09/15-aria-minutes.html mattking 18:22:21 TOPIC: Other discussion 18:22:56 JG: is there other test case work that needs to be done? 18:23:15 CS: there are test cases that didn't get run b/c we already met conformance. 18:23:38 CS: some cases are not run for IE, and that info would be helpful. 18:24:17 MC: Getting test cases for new features created in a more timely manner would be helpful. 18:25:00 JG: Right now I have people that want to do stuff and do not want to lose their interest. 18:25:22 Lisa: Is PF meeting at the F2F? 18:25:37 MC: no PF specific meetings, but there are ARIA topics. 18:25:40 -Jon_Gunderson 18:25:44 -Bryan_Garaventa 18:25:49 -Léonie_Watson 18:25:54 -Joanmarie_Diggs 18:25:59 -Michael_Cooper 18:26:01 -Joseph_Scheuhammer 18:26:01 -Cynthia_Shelly 18:26:01 RRSAgent, make minutes 18:26:01 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/09/15-aria-minutes.html mattking 18:26:08 -janina 18:26:08 zakim, bye 18:26:08 Zakim has left #aria 18:26:09 leaving. As of this point the attendees were Michael_Cooper, janina, +1.703.978.aaaa, Joseph_Scheuhammer, +1.603.882.aabb, Joanmarie_Diggs, Fred_Hesch, Jon_Gunderson, 18:26:09 ... Cynthia_Shelly, +1.541.678.aacc, Matt_King, Léonie_Watson, Fred_Esch, Lisa_Seeman, +1.415.624.aadd, Bryan_Garaventa 18:26:46 rrsagent, make minutes 18:26:46 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/09/15-aria-minutes.html mattking