14:25:23 RRSAgent has joined #rd 14:25:23 logging to http://www.w3.org/2013/10/30-rd-irc 14:25:25 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:25:27 Zakim, this will be 7394 14:25:27 ok, trackbot; I see WAI_RDWG()10:30AM scheduled to start in 5 minutes 14:25:28 Meeting: Research and Development Working Group Teleconference 14:25:28 Date: 30 October 2013 14:25:37 zakim, this is rd 14:25:37 ok, shadi; that matches WAI_RDWG()10:30AM 14:25:46 zakim, who is online? 14:25:46 I don't understand your question, shadi. 14:25:49 Justin has joined #rd 14:26:01 zakim, who is on the phone? 14:26:01 On the phone I see [IPcaller], [IPcaller.a] 14:26:14 Zakim, IPcaller is me 14:26:14 +Vivienne; got it 14:26:22 zakim, IPcaller.a is me 14:26:22 +Justin; got it 14:26:59 +??P28 14:27:15 klaus has joined #rd 14:27:31 +[IPcaller] 14:27:39 zakim, IPcaller is me 14:27:39 +Peter_Thiessen; got it 14:27:44 zakim, mute me 14:27:44 Peter_Thiessen should now be muted 14:28:18 +[IPcaller] 14:28:25 sharper has joined #rd 14:28:31 annika has joined #rd 14:28:32 Luz has joined #rd 14:28:52 trackbot, start meeting 14:28:54 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:28:55 zakim, please clear the agenda 14:28:55 agenda cleared 14:28:56 Zakim, this will be 7394 14:28:56 ok, trackbot; I see WAI_RDWG()10:30AM scheduled to start in 2 minutes 14:28:57 Meeting: Research and Development Working Group Teleconference 14:28:57 Date: 30 October 2013 14:29:16 Chair: Harper_Simon 14:29:22 zakim, unmute me 14:29:22 sorry, Peter_Thiessen, I don't know what conference this is 14:29:22 Agenda+ Welcome & Logistics (Regrets, Agenda Requests, Comments) [sharper] 14:29:31 Agenda+ User Note Draft [yehya christos] 14:29:39 Agenda+ E-Learning Symposium Progress http://goo.gl/bbjL92 [justin silvia] 14:29:42 markel has joined #rd 14:29:46 Agenda+ Accreditation of Websites Status [vivienne] 14:29:53 Agenda+ Next Catalogue Topic [sharper] 14:30:00 Agenda+ Next Symposium Topic [sharper] 14:30:07 Agenda+ Tips for AAR http://goo.gl/PTzghe [david] 14:30:14 Agenda+ PENDING - Draft Charter http://goo.gl/Dz0nct [shadi] 14:30:22 Agenda+ PENDING - Metrics W3C Note Status [shadi] 14:30:26 silvia_mirri has joined #rd 14:30:28 Agenda+ PENDING - Mobile W3C Note Public Release this Week [shadi] 14:30:35 Agenda+ PENDING - Easy to Read W3C Note Status [klaus] 14:30:40 Agenda+ PENDING - Text Customisation W3C Note Status [shawn/david] 14:30:57 Agenda+ PENDING - Close the Loop on the symposium L&F [shadi] 14:31:00 christos has joined #rd 14:31:05 zakim, save agenda 14:31:11 ok, sharper, the agenda has been written to http://www.w3.org/2013/10/30-rd-agenda.rdf 14:31:11 zakim, take up item 1 14:31:13 agendum 1. "Welcome & Logistics (Regrets, Agenda Requests, Comments)" taken up [from sharper] 14:31:14 zakim, this is rd 14:31:14 ok, shadi; that matches WAI_RDWG()10:30AM 14:31:16 Zakim, mute me 14:31:16 sorry, Luz, I do not know which phone connection belongs to you 14:31:26 regrets: Yehya, david, Mark 14:31:34 +Shadi 14:31:48 +??P20 14:31:59 zakim, who is on the call? 14:31:59 On the phone I see Vivienne, Justin, ??P28, Peter_Thiessen (muted), [IPcaller], ??P31, Shadi, ??P20 14:32:01 zakim, ??P20 is me 14:32:02 +christos; got it 14:32:11 zakim, [IPcaller] is me 14:32:11 +Luz; got it 14:32:36 zakim, ??P28 is me 14:32:36 +klaus; got it 14:32:44 +??P21 14:32:50 zakim, mute me 14:32:50 klaus should now be muted 14:32:55 zakim, ??P21 is sharper 14:32:55 +sharper; got it 14:32:56 zakim, ack 14:32:56 I don't understand 'ack', Peter_Thiessen 14:33:34 the half kilo one :) 14:33:35 41# 14:33:42 zakim, un mute me 14:33:42 I don't understand 'un mute me', Peter_Thiessen 14:33:46 zakim, unmute me 14:33:46 Peter_Thiessen should no longer be muted 14:34:06 sorry, but I have trouble with the connection, so I can join just the IRC chat 14:34:37 how many doctorates in the house ? 14:35:04 someone find a 15 year old 14:35:06 zakim, ??P31 is markel 14:35:06 +markel; got it 14:35:13 q- klaus 14:35:17 zakim, who is on the call? 14:35:17 On the phone I see Vivienne, Justin, klaus (muted), Peter_Thiessen, Luz, markel, Shadi, christos, sharper 14:35:32 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/scribes 14:36:10 Zakim, mute me 14:36:10 Luz should now be muted 14:36:13 zakim, scribe is me 14:36:13 sorry, Peter_Thiessen, I do not recognize a party named 'scribe' 14:36:22 scribe: Peter Thiessen 14:36:34 scribe: Peter 14:36:36 zakim, mute me 14:36:36 Vivienne should now be muted 14:36:39 zakim, mute me 14:36:39 Peter_Thiessen should now be muted 14:36:39 scribenick: Peter_Thiessen 14:36:50 zakim, close item 1 14:36:50 agendum 1, Welcome & Logistics (Regrets, Agenda Requests, Comments), closed 14:36:53 I see 12 items remaining on the agenda; the next one is 14:36:53 2. User Note Draft [from yehya christos via sharper] 14:36:56 zakim, take up next 14:36:56 agendum 2. "User Note Draft" taken up [from yehya christos] 14:37:53 christos: waiting on comments and minor changes for User Draft Note 14:38:05 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/2013/user-modeling/note/ED-UM4A 14:38:16 sharper: which one are we looking at? 14:38:29 ..has anyone had a chance to look through this? 14:38:40 ..if you've looked through it could you +1 in IRC 14:38:50 ..else I'll put this in a survey for next week 14:38:51 - 1 14:39:22 ACTION ITEM: group read the Note 14:39:22 Error finding 'ITEM'. You can review and register nicknames at . 14:39:59 zakim, take up next 14:39:59 agendum 3. "E-Learning Symposium Progress http://goo.gl/bbjL92" taken up [from justin silvia] 14:40:37 sharper: justin and silvia wher are we with the e-learning.. 14:41:05 justin: we're spreading the word and scientific committee - Gary Gay, David Sloan, and a few more form this group 14:41:06 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/wiki/E-learning_Accessibility 14:41:26 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/2013/e-learning/ 14:41:26 ..we're hoping the scientific is done and now it's a matter of people reading this and submitting papers 14:41:31 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/2013/e-learning/cfp 14:41:32 sharper: when is the deadline? 14:41:43 15th november 14:41:46 15 November 2013: Deadline for paper submissions 14:41:46 2 December 2013: Author notifications 14:41:46 6 December 2013: Deadline for publication-ready papers 14:41:46 9 December 2013: Registration opens 14:41:46 16 December 2013: Online symposium event at 15:00-17:30 UTC 14:42:01 sharper: looks good 14:42:25 ..I've had some enquires from people about submitting to this 14:42:38 q+ 14:42:53 justing: silvia and I will be sending this out to anyone we can think of (universities, ..) 14:43:16 sharper: anyone else have anything to say? have we missed any lists? 14:43:19 q+ 14:43:33 ack shadi 14:43:57 shadi: please send me the list of the SC as soon possible so we can put it on line 14:44:14 ..simon can we go through the list and look for other places for outreach 14:44:44 +??P1 14:44:47 sharper: talking to myself on mute here 14:44:58 zakim, ??P1 is annika 14:44:58 +annika; got it 14:45:07 ..ok shouldn't be a problem. I'll do that after the session. 14:45:11 zakim, mute me 14:45:11 annika should now be muted 14:45:16 ..put that in an email (suggestions for lists) 14:45:38 ..sent this to a number of lists 14:45:46 http://www.w3.org/WAI/RD/wiki/Distribution_Lists 14:45:52 (could you paste those in IRC) 14:46:53 shadi: simon could you add the list details to the wiki (link above) 14:47:06 sharper: yes but that could take longer 14:47:30 zakim, ack me 14:47:30 unmuting Vivienne 14:47:31 I see no one on the speaker queue 14:47:32 Yes, no problem. 14:47:33 ack Viv 14:47:34 shadi: a couple of lists that belong to yeliz, luz and klaus - if you could take care of that as well 14:47:57 vivien: i've been using the wiki.. (too much echo to hear rest) 14:48:17 thanks all 14:48:18 Just said that I've sent it to the 4 Perth universities 14:48:21 zakim, take up next 14:48:21 agendum 4. "Accreditation of Websites Status" taken up [from vivienne] 14:48:41 regrets: Giorgio, Mark, Yehya, David, Silvia, Kerstin 14:48:50 sharper: this is from vivien and she sent around some updates. 14:49:05 zakim, mute me 14:49:05 Vivienne should now be muted 14:49:26 zakim, ack me 14:49:26 unmuting Vivienne 14:49:27 I see no one on the speaker queue 14:49:30 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-wai-rd/2013Oct/0051.html 14:49:38 ..vivien: could you tell us how this was created 14:50:18 vivien: this document started off by transcribing the conversations and then went through and tidied up the wording. 14:50:36 ..if I have miss-transcribed anything please let me know. 14:50:47 ..I've taken out the questions we didn't have time to cover 14:51:12 ..I'm looking for feedback on stuff should come in, length, conciseness 14:52:12 sharper: we haven't had time to look through this yet. I'm thinking how we should handle this now and in the future. We need to make sure the quality is there and this is going to published as part of a larger catalog of research 14:52:22 q+ 14:52:25 ..so looking at the length - do we think this looks right? 14:52:29 ack shad 14:53:06 shadi: I think we want a super brief catalog items that describe the topic and link to additional resources like the wiki or a symposium or a discussion log 14:53:19 ..in this case the length, I think it looks good 14:53:40 ..in terms of here is a discussion that took place in addition to the stale content like in the wiki 14:53:48 ..we still need a super brief synopsys 14:53:57 vivien: how long do you see that beeing? 14:54:06 shadi: klaus this may be a question for you as well 14:54:20 ..I'm thinking of maybe a paragraph 5-10 sencences 14:54:38 vivien: i could prepare something like that 14:54:51 ..just a couple of sentences long is that what you're looking for? 14:55:19 shadi: initially we invisioned the catalog items would be more generic about the topic 14:55:35 ..I don't know. Let's back up 14:56:42 ..the idea of the catalog is to help researchers find and coordinate people in different fields that might be interested in a particular research item 14:57:11 ..so annotate those items with more information that we have or might not yet for additional information 14:57:14 +[IPcaller] 14:58:00 ..a small synopsis that describes the research topic and a sub section talking about the status where we are right now with this catalog item. At this stage we only have the information on the wiki or this discussion.. 14:58:10 yeliz has joined #rd 14:58:23 ..so we have this brief synopsis that is neutral etc. and then something that describes what we know.. 14:58:41 sharper: similar for me, I'd focus on the take home messages for the symposium 14:58:50 I was late, because of my class, sorry 14:59:01 ..so we can do that quite short and then link out to a wider discussion 14:59:07 zakim, ipcaller is yeliz 14:59:07 +yeliz; got it 14:59:11 ..i think the information on the word document should be included 14:59:14 zakim, mute me 14:59:14 yeliz should now be muted 14:59:31 ..i'm worried about linking to the wiki because it's a work in progress 15:00:06 ..does anyone else have any opinions? 15:00:18 zakim, unmute me 15:00:18 klaus should no longer be muted 15:00:52 klaus: i can only share what you said: a short summary that allows people to connect and a first status overview of the item as a starting point 15:01:24 shadi: i'm a bit sure about mixing.. i'd prefer to have a general description and then the findings from the group or something of that nature 15:01:33 ..for many catalog items that might be empty 15:01:58 klaus: I was not considering about we as a group but in general what the status of research in this is - very few sentences 15:02:04 shadi: do you have a template? 15:02:13 klaus: we can prepare one and sent it around 15:02:29 sharper: that would be useful 15:02:36 ..vivien would you find that useful? 15:03:06 vivien: yes, i'm feeling a little fuzzy what it will look. so I was planning to start with the two things shadi was talking about 15:03:48 ..i'm not sure how this will be used so i'm not really sure how it will be used in the future 15:04:38 ..some guidance would be useful 15:05:07 shadi: it is evolving, this catalog idea. so their will probably be a little back and forth. so it would be good for you to work with klaus on that 15:05:50 ..i want to be careful about any key messages or statements - it is important that we present this as the groups findings, the outcome of the discusssion 15:06:37 ..i don't know what kind of a role those discussion will have as way to back certain things 15:06:46 vivien: i think we're going to have to feel our way 15:06:55 sharper: yes i agree 15:07:05 ..i think a template is a good starting point 15:07:25 zakim, mute me 15:07:25 klaus should now be muted 15:07:29 zakim, take up next 15:07:29 agendum 5. "Next Catalogue Topic" taken up [from sharper] 15:07:44 sharper: we need to think about this one 15:08:06 ..i've got feedback about the topic and people enjoyed it 15:08:27 ..do we have any ideas about catalog topics we'd like to run? 15:08:46 ..does anyone on the call have any suggestions? 15:09:16 q+ 15:09:21 ack viv 15:09:40 vivien: .. research .. (faded out) 15:09:54 sharper: david was talking about running one on research 15:10:03 zakim, mute me 15:10:03 Vivienne should now be muted 15:10:12 ..we need people to put one of these discussions together (volunteers) 15:10:35 ..if we don't have any volunteers we'll just have to not have any research meetings 15:10:38 +1 15:10:43 q+ 15:10:48 ack just 15:11:10 justin: in the new year, i have a couple of ideas 15:11:15 q+ 15:11:23 ack me 15:11:23 ack shad 15:11:42 thanks Shadi! 15:11:44 shadi: yah and maybe encourage people not to be shy. i know vivien set the bar high 15:12:03 ..i know many of you do (faded) research 15:12:24 s/(faded)/really exciting 15:12:30 sharper: i'll keep running back to this topic on these calls 15:12:45 zakim, take up next 15:12:45 agendum 6. "Next Symposium Topic" taken up [from sharper] 15:13:11 sharper: this about the next symposium and we're lining up for after christmas 15:13:32 ..any people have any thoughts about how to run or what or who is willing to run a symposium? 15:13:33 q+ 15:13:39 zakim, ack me 15:13:39 unmuting Vivienne 15:13:39 ack viv 15:13:40 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:14:00 vivien: did we have some topics that were short listed? 15:14:25 zakim, mute me 15:14:25 Vivienne should now be muted 15:14:39 sharper: so we have some from (missed name) but I haven't heard back so I'm assuming (faded) 15:14:48 q+ 15:14:55 ..i'm assuming a number of people have topics that need to be finalised 15:15:06 ack viv 15:15:08 zakim, ack me 15:15:08 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:15:22 vivien: one topic in the wiki is on user testing 15:15:42 ..that one is close to my hear that i would *love* to help after christmas 15:16:09 sharper: yes definitely. i think that would be a good one to look at and if we could get one of those setup for after the new year 15:16:21 ..we'd like to start planning now 15:16:55 vivien: i'm hoping by march i'll still be re-writing my thesis but i hope for january 15:17:03 sharper: so i'm thinking more june time 15:17:11 ..in my head we still need something for march 15:17:31 ..does anyone have any thoughts or people to coop into the group for a symposium 15:17:45 vivien: what about putting out to a survey 15:18:01 sharper: that is a good idea but my only worry is that it takes someone to commit to it 15:18:23 ..but yah maybe a survey is a good idea. i just don't want to keep delaying it 15:18:41 zakim, take up next 15:18:41 agendum 7. "Tips for AAR http://goo.gl/PTzghe" taken up [from david] 15:18:56 sharper: david is not here so we'll move on 15:18:59 zakim, take up next 15:18:59 agendum 7 was just opened, Peter_Thiessen 15:19:00 zakim, mute me 15:19:00 Vivienne should now be muted 15:19:13 hmm 15:19:15 zakim, close agendum 7 15:19:15 agendum 7, Tips for AAR http://goo.gl/PTzghe, closed 15:19:16 I see 6 items remaining on the agenda; the next one is 15:19:16 8. PENDING - Draft Charter http://goo.gl/Dz0nct [from shadi via sharper] 15:19:27 zakim, take up next 15:19:27 agendum 8. "PENDING - Draft Charter http://goo.gl/Dz0nct " taken up [from shadi] 15:19:50 shadi: not for a while, it's under AC review since charters are being reviewed 15:20:05 ..we can take it off the agenda unless we get comments.. 15:20:28 RESOLVE: we're going to remove this from the agenda 15:20:40 zakim, take up next 15:20:40 agendum 9. "PENDING - Metrics W3C Note Status " taken up [from shadi] 15:20:58 shadi: still pending 15:21:03 zakim, take up next 15:21:03 agendum 9 was just opened, Peter_Thiessen 15:21:16 zakim, close item 9 15:21:16 agendum 9, PENDING - Metrics W3C Note Status , closed 15:21:17 I see 4 items remaining on the agenda; the next one is 15:21:17 10. PENDING - Mobile W3C Note Public Release this Week [from shadi via sharper] 15:21:20 zakim, take up next 15:21:20 agendum 10. "PENDING - Mobile W3C Note Public Release this Week " taken up [from shadi] 15:21:26 shadi: still pending 15:21:33 zakim, close item 10 15:21:33 agendum 10, PENDING - Mobile W3C Note Public Release this Week , closed 15:21:35 I see 3 items remaining on the agenda; the next one is 15:21:35 11. PENDING - Easy to Read W3C Note Status [from klaus via sharper] 15:21:41 zakim, unmute me 15:21:41 klaus should no longer be muted 15:22:11 klaus: not a lot new. i think in my opinion all the feed back has been added and needs to added to the up to date version 15:22:21 ..based on this i do think we can finalise 15:22:26 sharper: excellent news 15:22:39 zakim, close item 11 15:22:39 agendum 11, PENDING - Easy to Read W3C Note Status , closed 15:22:40 I see 2 items remaining on the agenda; the next one is 15:22:40 12. PENDING - Text Customisation W3C Note Status [from shawn/david via sharper] 15:22:44 zakim, mute me 15:22:44 klaus should now be muted 15:22:57 zakim, take up next 15:22:57 agendum 12. "PENDING - Text Customisation W3C Note Status" taken up [from shawn/david] 15:23:10 hmm the scribe is lost :) 15:23:43 shadi: still pending 15:23:49 zakim, close item 12 15:23:49 agendum 12, PENDING - Text Customisation W3C Note Status, closed 15:23:50 I see 1 item remaining on the agenda: 15:23:50 13. PENDING - Close the Loop on the symposium L&F [from shadi via sharper] 15:24:05 shadi: i need to back check the latest status on this 15:24:12 zakim, close item 13 15:24:12 agendum 13, PENDING - Close the Loop on the symposium L&F, closed 15:24:13 I see nothing remaining on the agenda 15:24:24 (thanks shadi) 15:24:35 sharper: any other business to discuss now? 15:24:52 good night all 15:24:52 zakim, unmute me 15:24:53 Peter_Thiessen should no longer be muted 15:24:54 toodles 15:24:54 ack me 15:24:59 byee 15:25:00 bye 15:25:01 -christos 15:25:03 bye 15:25:04 bye 15:25:05 bye 15:25:07 -yeliz 15:25:08 -Vivienne 15:25:08 -annika 15:25:09 zakim, mute me 15:25:10 -markel 15:25:10 Peter_Thiessen should now be muted 15:25:11 bye bye 15:25:12 -klaus 15:25:17 markel has left #rd 15:25:18 -Justin 15:25:28 -sharper 15:25:31 -Peter_Thiessen 15:25:32 -Shadi 15:35:01 disconnecting the lone participant, Luz, in WAI_RDWG()10:30AM 15:35:02 WAI_RDWG()10:30AM has ended 15:35:02 Attendees were Vivienne, Justin, Peter_Thiessen, Shadi, christos, Luz, klaus, sharper, markel, annika, yeliz 16:01:58 trackbot, end meeting 16:01:58 Zakim, list attendees 16:01:58 sorry, trackbot, I don't know what conference this is 16:02:06 RRSAgent, please draft minutes 16:02:06 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/10/30-rd-minutes.html trackbot 16:02:07 RRSAgent, bye 16:02:07 I see 1 open action item saved in http://www.w3.org/2013/10/30-rd-actions.rdf : 16:02:07 ACTION: ITEM to group read the Note [1] 16:02:07 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2013/10/30-rd-irc#T14-39-22