13:55:51 RRSAgent has joined #wcag2ict 13:55:51 logging to http://www.w3.org/2013/05/31-wcag2ict-irc 13:55:53 RRSAgent, make logs world 13:55:53 Zakim has joined #wcag2ict 13:55:55 Zakim, this will be 2428 13:55:55 ok, trackbot; I see WAI_(WCAG2ICT)10:00AM scheduled to start in 5 minutes 13:55:56 Meeting: WCAG2ICT Task Force Teleconference 13:55:56 Date: 31 May 2013 13:56:47 David has joined #wcag2ict 13:59:03 zakim, this will be WCAG2ICT 13:59:03 ok, andisnow, I see WAI_(WCAG2ICT)10:00AM already started 13:59:22 +??P10 13:59:32 Mike_P has joined #wcag2ict 13:59:36 greggvanderheiden has joined #wcag2ict 13:59:57 +Andi_Snow_Weaver 14:00:16 zakim, ??P10 is Mike_Pluke 14:00:16 +Mike_Pluke; got it 14:00:25 +Gregg_Vanderheiden 14:00:31 Loic has joined #wcag2ict 14:00:46 +[Microsoft] 14:01:05 agenda+ Discuss the Revisiting Programmatically Set and Programmatically Determined survey 14:01:06 +??P14 14:01:19 zakim, Microsoft has Alex_Li 14:01:19 +Alex_Li; got it 14:01:42 Zakim, ??P14 is me 14:01:42 +Loic; got it 14:01:52 zakim, ??P14 is Loic_Normand_Martinez 14:01:52 I already had ??P14 as Loic, andisnow 14:02:19 MaryJo has joined #wcag2ict 14:02:29 +bruce 14:02:38 zakim, i am bruce 14:02:38 ok, BBailey, I now associate you with bruce 14:02:42 agenda+ Discuss the Revisiting Programmatically Set and Programmatically Determined survey 14:02:48 zakim, mute me 14:02:48 bruce should now be muted 14:02:51 chair: Andi_Snow-Weaver 14:02:57 janina has joined #wcag2ict 14:03:01 regrets: Judy_Brewer 14:03:06 zakim, who is on the phone 14:03:06 I don't understand 'who is on the phone', andisnow 14:03:08 +Mary_Jo_Mueller 14:03:16 scribe: Mary_Jo_Mueller 14:03:26 +??P16 14:03:28 scribenick: MaryJo 14:03:33 evisitingProgrammaticallySetDetermined/results 14:03:38 zakim, ??P16 is Janina_Sajka 14:03:38 +Janina_Sajka; got it 14:03:38 korn has joined #wcag2ict 14:03:41 zakim, next item 14:03:41 agendum 1. "Discuss the Revisiting Programmatically Set and Programmatically Determined survey" taken up [from andisnow] 14:03:45 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/55145/RevisitingProgrammaticallySetDetermined/results 14:04:21 We had general agreement on the proposals, with a slight edit from Peter. 14:06:03 +Peter_Korn 14:06:20 alex_ has joined #wcag2ict 14:07:09 q+ 14:07:23 q+ 14:07:35 q+ 14:08:43 zakim, who is on the phone? 14:08:43 On the phone I see David_MacDonald, Mike_Pluke, Andi_Snow_Weaver, Gregg_Vanderheiden, [Microsoft], Loic, bruce (muted), Mary_Jo_Mueller, Janina_Sajka, Peter_Korn 14:08:46 [Microsoft] has Alex_Li 14:09:58 greggvanderheiden has joined #wcag2ict 14:10:07 q+ 14:11:52 q- 14:12:49 q- 14:13:24 Discussion on the placement of the phrase 'including user agents' in the note. 14:13:43 q- 14:14:29 +Peter_Korn.a 14:14:41 -Peter_Korn 14:15:47 q+ 14:16:11 Note: Software, INCLUDING USER AGENTS, typically makes content programmatically determinable through the use of accessibility services of the platform, INCLUDING APPLICATION OR USER AGENT SOFTWARE ACTING AS A PLATFORM" 14:16:34 ack gregg 14:16:51 ack korn 14:17:43 The key point we need to convey in the note is that the path to 'programmatically determined' is through the use of platform accessibility services. 14:18:03 q+ 14:18:45 q- 14:18:53 ack gregg 14:18:56 Documents get this done through software that interprets the markup and maps it to the platform accessibility services (a user agent). 14:19:09 Software typically makes content programmatically determinable through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Documents typically makes content programmatically determinable through the use of accessibility services of the user agent. 14:21:32 s/(a user agent)/(a user agent acting as a platform) 14:22:03 q+ 14:22:14 ack alex 14:22:53 q+ 14:23:05 ack gregg 14:23:46 Note: Software typically makes content programmatically determinable through the use of accessibility services of the platform.  Non-Web documents typically make content programmatically determinable through markup, and the document's user agent then typically exposes that markup through the use of accessibility services of the platform. 14:24:27 +1 to Peter's proposal 14:24:44 q+ 14:24:56 +1 to Peter's proposal 14:25:02 q+ 14:27:21 For "set": Note: Software typically enables content to be programmatically set through the use of accessibility services of the platform.  Non-Web documents typically enables content to be programmatically set through markup, and the document's user agent then typically modifies that markup a the direction of use of accessibility services of the platform. 14:27:32 Note: Software typically makes content programmatically determinable through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically make content programmatically determinable through markup, and the document's user agent then typically exposes that markup to assistive technology through the use of accessibility services of the platform or other accessibility supported means. 14:28:31 q- 14:28:35 +1 to Andi's augmented explanation 14:29:34 Software typically enables content to be programmatically set through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically enables content to be programmatically by using the accessibility services of the user agent, which serves as the intermediate platform for the non-web content. 14:32:05 +q 14:33:42 andisnow_ has joined #wcag2ict 14:33:56 Just correcting some typos in GV's proposal: Software typically enables content to be programmatically DETERMINED through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically ENABLE content to be programmatically DETERMINED by using the accessibility services of the user agent, which serves as the intermediate platform for the non-web DOCUMENT. 14:35:56 q- 14:36:02 q- 14:36:26 For non-Web documents, the user agent serves as the intermediate platform for the non-web DOCUMENT. 14:37:59 Software typically enables content to be programmatically DETERMINED through the use of accessibility services of the platform. For non-Web documents, the user agent serves as the intermediate platform for the non-web DOCUMENT. 14:40:12 q+ 14:40:17 q+ 14:41:27 q- 14:43:19 Just correcting some typos in GV's proposal: Software typically enables content to be programmatically DETERMINED through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically ENABLE content to be programmatically DETERMINED by using the accessibility services of the user agent, which serves as the intermediate platform for the non-web DOCUMENT. 14:44:21 A computing platform includes a hardware architecture and a software framework (including application frameworks), where the combination allows software to run. Typical platforms include a computer architecture, operating system and Runtime libraries.[1] 14:44:28 wikipedia 14:44:31 ack david 14:45:12 Note: Software typically enables content to be programmatically determined through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically enable content to be programmatically determined by using the accessibility services of the user agent. 14:47:20 RESOLUTION: Accept the proposal for 'programmatically determined' as amended in the meeting. 14:47:59 For programmatically set: Note: Software typically enables content to be programmatically set through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically enable content to be programmatically set by using the accessibility services of the user agent. 14:48:33 RESOLUTION: Accept the proposal for 'programmatically set' as amended in the meeting. 14:48:39 zakim, next item 14:48:39 agendum 2. "Discuss the Revisiting Programmatically Set and Programmatically Determined survey" taken up [from andisnow] 14:48:45 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/55145/misc20130531/results 14:49:55 zakim, unmute me 14:49:55 bruce should no longer be muted 14:50:03 zakim, mute me 14:50:03 bruce should now be muted 14:50:14 Sometimes content is primarily intended to create a specific sensory experience that words cannot fully capture. One example could be a symphony performance where the intent is to allow the user to hear that particular performance. Another example could be the image of a painting, where the INTENT of the image is to let users know what [a painter's work] look like. For such content, text alternatives at least identify the non-text content with a descr[CUT] 14:50:15 label and where possible, additional descriptive text. If there is another reason for including the content in the page (for example [as an exercise to identify] an impressionist painting) and the intended information can be described it is helpful to include that information as part of the text alternative(s). 14:52:41 Sometimes content is primarily intended to create a specific sensory experience that words cannot fully capture. One example could be a symphony performance where the intent is to allow the user to hear that particular performance. Another example could be the image of a painting, where the INTENT of the image is to let users know what [a painter's work] looks like. For such content, text alternatives at least identify the non-text content with a desc[CUT] 14:52:41 label and where possible, additional descriptive text. If there is another reason for including the content in the page (for example [as an exercise to identify] an impressionist painting) and the intended information can be described THE SUCCESS CRITERIA REQUIRES that information TO BE INCLUDED as part of the text alternative(s). 14:54:03 then it is no longer a pure sensory experience 14:54:28 Sometimes content is primarily intended to create a specific sensory experience that words cannot fully capture. One example could be a symphony performance where the intent is to allow the user to hear that particular performance. Another example could be the image of a painting, where the INTENT of the image is to let users know what [a painter's work] looks like. For such content, text alternatives at least identify the non-text content with a desc[CUT] 14:54:28 label and where possible, additional descriptive text. If there is another reason for including the content in the page (for example [as an exercise to identify] an impressionist painting) and the intended information can be described THEN IT IS NO LONGER A PURE SENSORY EXPERIENCE. 14:55:26 RESOLUTION: Accept the proposal for 1.1.1 INTENT as amended in the meeting. 14:55:34 Note: Software typically enables content to be programmatically set through the use of accessibility services of the platform. Non-Web documents typically enable content to be programmatically THROUGH THE USE OF accessibility services of the user agent. 14:56:26 s/programmatically THROUGH THE USE/programmatically set THROUGH THE USE/ 14:57:14 The above is an editorial change to 'programmatically set' and 'programmatically determined'. 14:58:57 s/de[CUT]/descriptive.../ 15:00:35 The items in this survey are to go to the WCAG working group to update the INTENT for these SC. 15:01:23 SC 3.3.4: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/55145/misc20130531/results#xq1 15:03:03 q+ 15:04:08 This success criterion does not intend to cover scenarios where the legal commitments or financial transactions are made that cannot be controlled even with a properly designed page. An example could be data usage charges from Internet service providers that happen just by accessing any Web page. Another example could be the use of a web-based mail service to send an e-mail that confirms a product purchase. The web-based mail service cannot know that the 15:04:09 e-mail sent will cause a financial transaction. 15:05:49 ack alex 15:06:02 RESOLUTION: Accept the proposal for 3.3.4 INTENT as amended in the meeting. 15:06:57 SC 3.2.2 Intent: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/55145/misc20130531/results#xq2 15:07:38 3.2.3 Consistent Navigation: Navigational mechanisms that are repeated on multiple Web pages within a set of Web pages occur in the same relative order each time they are repeated, unless a change is initiated by the user. (Level AA) 15:07:51 3.2.2 On Input: Changing the setting of any user interface component does not automatically cause a change of context unless the user has been advised of the behavior before using the component. (Level A) 15:08:32 q+ 15:08:37 q+ 15:08:53 q+ 15:10:17 Users might be alerted during data entry automatically without submitting the data, which is helpful as the user gets feedback right away and can fix the problem without submitting a full form. 15:10:22 ack gregg 15:11:26 q+ 15:11:43 However, if focus is automatically moved away from the field (.eg. it is moved to a dialog), it might be confusing to the user if they aren't warned about this behavior. 15:12:02 s/.eg./e.g./ 15:12:44 ack andi 15:12:54 There are WAI-ARIA methods to provide error messages, such as a live region, to let them know they made the error without moving focus away from the field. 15:13:22 ack david 15:13:50 q- 15:14:24 q+ 15:14:41 rrsagent, make minutes 15:14:41 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/05/31-wcag2ict-minutes.html andisnow 15:16:48 ack gregg 15:17:17 q+ 15:19:50 ack korn 15:20:25 q+ 15:20:55 q- 15:21:04 ack gregg 15:21:36 +1 15:24:10 This proposal wasn't accepted by the group. 15:24:37 q+ 15:24:51 Software typically enables content to be programmatically determined through the use of accessibility services of software. Non-Web documents typically enable content to be programmatically determined through the use of accessibility services of the user agent 15:25:22 ack gregg 15:30:40 We are re-opening programmaticaly set, determined; accessibility services, principal 4 and guideline 4.1 15:30:50 Also to look at defining "platform" 15:31:08 And that work would include moving "accessibility services of sw" to be "accessibility services of the paltform" 15:31:21 s/programaticaly set/programmatically set/ 15:31:29 s/paltform/platform/ 15:32:32 RESOLUTION: Re-open "programmatically determined", "programmatically set", and "accessibility services of software" (to use platform), and principal 4 and guideline 4.1 15:32:58 There are six remaining action items. 15:33:01 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/WCAG2ICT-TF/track/actions/open 15:33:15 zakim, next item 15:33:15 I do not see any more non-closed or non-skipped agenda items, MaryJo 15:33:23 topic: Action items 15:34:14 -Loic 15:35:37 -[Microsoft] 15:36:20 Action 81 - Andi made a proposal to remove a phrase so this needs to be brought up in a survey. 15:36:20 Error finding '81'. You can review and register nicknames at . 15:36:40 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/WCAG2ICT-TF/track/actions/81 15:40:03 RESOLUTION: Accept proposal in Action 81 as written. 15:41:18 AI-81 is in https://sites.google.com/site/wcag2ict/edits-for-michael-post-2nd-public-draft now 15:42:29 For action 95 Andi made a proposal to the list that sounds reasonable, so editors will have to take a look at that and incorporate into our document. 'Task force' is also something that need to be addressed as well as part of this action. 15:46:48 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/55145/glossary5/results#xq7 15:50:16 The change of context in action 96 is not a change of user agents (from FF to IE), but a change of context within the user agent (e.g. FF to Adobe reader). 15:50:31 zakim, who is on the phone? 15:50:31 On the phone I see David_MacDonald, Mike_Pluke, Andi_Snow_Weaver, Gregg_Vanderheiden, bruce (muted), Mary_Jo_Mueller, Janina_Sajka, Peter_Korn.a 15:55:10 Is it considered a change of context if you're in a Word document and when you step to an imbedded spreadsheet the chrome of the program changes to the context of Excel for spreadsheet interaction so you can edit the spreadsheet? 15:58:12 -Janina_Sajka 15:58:41 This would be a change of context, so would fail the SC. So the user should have to tab to the embedded element, and press enter or do some action to cause the chrome to change to allow editing. 15:58:59 -Mike_Pluke 16:02:24 -Andi_Snow_Weaver 16:02:51 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/UNDERSTANDING-WCAG20/complete-diff.html#content-structure-separation-programmatic 16:03:12 Peter will work on a note for either 'change of context' or for 3.2.1. 16:05:48 http://www.w3.org/TR/2008/REC-WCAG20-20081211/#structuredef 16:07:34 We're working on trying to remember Gregg's final AI. 16:07:39 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/WCAG2ICT-TF/track/actions/97 16:08:09 The problem is the glossary term says: 16:08:10 structureThe way the parts of a Web page are organized in relation to each other; andThe way a collection of Web pages is organized 16:08:14 s/We're working on trying to remember Gregg's final AI.// 16:08:28 And 1.3.1 says: "Information, structure, and relationships conveyed through presentation can be programmatically determined or are available in text." 16:08:38 But 1.3.1 doesn't apply to "sets of web pages" 16:08:46 s/structureThe/structure - The/ 16:09:08 s/andThe/and the' 16:09:33 from the 3 May minutes: PACKAGING TEXT: the WCAG2ICT was examining the definition of STRUCTURE and had trouble understanding how structure of pages related, since there was no mention of structure of pages in the success criteria themselves. The following example was put forward by one member. It this an example of what you meant? If so can you add it to Understanding WCAG 2.0 ? If not, what did it mean? 16:10:07 Andi - I'm thinking this might have been a WCAG errata 16:10:10 but I think it should be "structure of A COLLECTION of pages", not just the structure of pages 16:10:34 Andi - MaryJo is trying to bring you in. 16:10:57 Andi - Sicne "structure" is ONLY used in 1.3.1 and 1.3.1 doesn't speak to sets / collections of pages, bullet 2 of "structure" should be dropped. 16:11:03 and here is the example that is referenced in the above text: For example, a web page that shows a site map depicting the structure of the web site visually must present the information in text or markup so that the structure of the site is programmatically determinable or presented in text 16:11:04 And I think it might have been in the WCAG errata 16:11:27 Yes, but that is of the PRESENTATION of a set of pages, as presented on a single page. 16:11:35 s/Andi - MaryJo is trying to bring you in.// 16:11:48 s/Sicne/Since/ 16:12:23 zakim, unmute me 16:12:23 bruce should no longer be muted 16:12:54 -Gregg_Vanderheiden 16:13:26 everyone please go to 1. You can join the meeting FREE by using the following URL 16:13:27 https://www3.gotomeeting.com/join/705233502 16:13:32 Ah, OK... 16:13:57 -Peter_Korn.a 16:14:15 yes Go To Meeting will allow us to talk and prep for next weeks meeting so we can close these 16:14:29 I need to understand my Action item to work on it 16:14:29 -Mary_Jo_Mueller 16:15:09 OK take your time 16:15:15 you can also call in 16:15:22 1. You can join the meeting FREE by using the following URL 16:15:23 https://www3.gotomeeting.com/join/705233502 16:15:25 Use your microphone and speakers (VoIP) - a headset is recommended. 16:15:26 BE SURE TO SET THE AUDIO TO "Microphone and Speaker" if it is set to Telephone when you sign on. 16:15:27 2. Or, call in using your telephone. 16:15:28 Meeting ID: 705-233-502 16:15:29 United States: +1 (786) 358-5410 16:16:01 -David_MacDonald 16:16:25 United Kingdom: +44 (0) 203 535 0621 16:16:32 Canada: +1 (416) 900-1165 16:16:42 anyone else need a call in number 16:17:05 I'm coming 16:17:51 ./me let's keep this irc for minutes 16:18:26 -bruce 16:18:27 WAI_(WCAG2ICT)10:00AM has ended 16:18:27 Attendees were David_MacDonald, Andi_Snow_Weaver, Mike_Pluke, Gregg_Vanderheiden, Alex_Li, Loic, bruce, Mary_Jo_Mueller, Janina_Sajka, Peter_Korn 16:19:00 s/ I'm coming// 16:19:24 http://www.w3.org/WAI/WCAG20/errata/ 16:22:55 s/OK take your time// 16:23:17 s/you can also call in// 16:23:39 s/Ah, OK...// 16:25:14 andisnow has joined #wcag2ict 16:28:16 zakim, bye 16:28:16 Zakim has left #wcag2ict 16:28:26 rrsagent, make minutes 16:28:26 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/05/31-wcag2ict-minutes.html MaryJo 16:29:57 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AlmostFinal/ 16:30:17 s/anyone else need a call in number// 16:33:03 s/./me let's keep this irc for minutes// 16:38:35 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Antepenultimate 16:42:11 http://www.w3.org/2013/05/14-wai-wcag-minutes.html#item03 16:43:28 s/1. You can join the meeting FREE by using the following URL// 16:43:58 s/Use your microphone and speakers (VoIP) - a headset is recommended.// 16:44:10 s/BE SURE TO SET THE AUDIO TO "Microphone and Speaker" if it is set to Telephone when you sign on.// 16:44:19 s/2. Or, call in using your telephone.// 16:44:29 s/Meeting ID: 705-233-502// 16:44:38 s/United States: +1 (786) 358-5410// 16:44:50 s/United Kingdom: +44 (0) 203 535 0621// 16:44:59 s/Canada: +1 (416) 900-1165// 16:45:08 rrsagent, make minutes 16:45:08 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/05/31-wcag2ict-minutes.html MaryJo 16:54:27 http://www.w3.org/TR/2008/REC-WCAG20-20081211/#structuredef 17:10:21 http://www.w3.org/TR/UNDERSTANDING-WCAG20/text-equiv-all.html 17:13:31 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/2012/WD-UNDERSTANDING-WCAG20-20121213/minimize-error-reversible#minimize-error-reversible-intent-head 17:32:12 https://sites.google.com/site/wcag2ict/to-do-before-3rd-final-public-draft 17:43:57 http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/WCAG2ICT-TF/track/actions/97 18:10:05 greggvanderheiden has left #wcag2ict 19:02:24 korn has left #wcag2ict 19:48:49 andisnow has joined #wcag2ict