Input for Agenda Planning for the Tracking Protection Working Group

This is the view of actions grouped by issues ordered by due dates; see also the view of issues groups by products.

Open issues with open and pending review action items

Only showing action items due before

Grouped by issues

Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering (ISSUE-32)

ACTION-106 on Heather West: Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering, with Vincent Toubiana - due 2012-02-02 - pending review

Definition of and what/whether limitations around data append and first parties (ISSUE-170)

ACTION-229 on Chris Pedigo: Draft crisp definition [of data append] - due 2012-08-01 - pending review

Re-direction, shortened URLs, click analytics -- what kind of tracking is this? (ISSUE-97)

ACTION-196 on Justin Brookman: Draft text on whether url shorteners are first or third parties - due 2012-08-15 - pending review

ACTION-303 on Ian Fette: Draft definition of "visit" - due 2012-10-11 - pending review

Third party as first party - is a third party that collects data on behalf of the first party treated the same way as the first party? (ISSUE-49 service provider)

ACTION-161 on Shane Wiley: work on issue-49 - due 2012-09-05 - pending review

How should user agents be required to provide information about DNT? (ISSUE-172 user-education)

ACTION-212 on Shane Wiley: Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal - due 2012-09-26 - pending review

ACTION-280 on Shane Wiley: Draft updated text on UA requirements; explanatory text made more general; add 'prior to selecting DNT'; add examples; change MUST to SHOULD - due 2012-10-10 - pending review

Possible exemption for fraud detection and defense (ISSUE-24)

ACTION-279 on Ian Fette: Write an explanation of graduated response and a list of explanatory use cases - due 2012-10-10 - pending review

ACTION-293 on Jonathan Mayer: Draft non-normative examples illustrating graduated response - due 2012-10-11 - pending review

ACTION-339 on Walter van Holst: Propose a refinement to debugging permitted use - due 2012-11-21 - pending review

ACTION-408 on David Wainberg: Review security/fraud text (with chris mejia and dan auerbach) - due 2013-05-29 - open

Definition of de-identified (or previously, unlinkable) data (ISSUE-188 unlinkable-deidentified)

ACTION-289 on Walter van Holst: Define "unlinkable" related to section 3.6 on unlinkable data in compliance document - due 2012-10-10 - pending review

ACTION-286 on Rachel Thomas: Propose DAA text regarding de-identification (for unlinkability discussion) - due 2012-11-22 - pending review

Minimization -- to what extent will minimization be required for use of a particular exemption? (conditional exemptions) (ISSUE-31)

ACTION-298 on Jonathan Mayer: Draft examples for - due 2012-10-11 - pending review

Have an appendix of best practices? (ISSUE-175)

ACTION-325 on Nick Doty: Help re-factor into appendices (with justin, jmayer?) - due 2012-10-24 - pending review

How is audience measurement adressed under DNT? (permitted use or otherwise) (ISSUE-25 AudienceMeasurement)

ACTION-404 on Susan Israel: Further Fact finding on scope of audience measurement and the DAA exception (one page of text) - due 2013-06-19 - open

Interplay between UGE and out of band consent (ISSUE-201)

ACTION-424 on David Singer: Clarify UGEs and out of band consent - due 2013-06-26 - pending review

Action Items Pending Review

There are 131 pending review actions.

ID	State	Title	Person	Due Date	Associated with
ACTION-68	pending review	Provide text on ISSUE-54	Justin Brookman	2012-02-01	ISSUE-54
ACTION-69	pending review	Propose renaming issue-54	Sean Harvey	2012-02-03	ISSUE-54
ACTION-72	pending review	Draft text on issue-25, issue-74	Kathy Joe	2012-02-06	ISSUE-74
ACTION-91	pending review	Write text on fingerprinting risk (ISSUE-109, ISSUE-114), with Nick Doty	Andy Zeigler	2012-02-29	ISSUE-109
ACTION-97	pending review	Add similar protocol language to TPE spec	David Singer	2012-02-01	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-99	pending review	Write up automated discoverability of party relationships proposal (Nick and Bryan to help)	David Singer	2012-02-13
ACTION-100	pending review	Write up use of machine-readable party relationships for site-specific exceptions (Joanne and Kevin to help)	Amy Colando	2012-02-02
ACTION-105	pending review	Write-up "reasonably discoverable assertions" standard for party membership assertion for purposes of researcher/enforcement only	Jonathan Mayer	2012-02-02	Compliance Next
ACTION-106	pending review	Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering, with Vincent Toubiana	Heather West	2012-02-02	ISSUE-32
ACTION-110	pending review	Write proposal text for what it means to "not track"	Ninja Marnau	2012-02-10	ISSUE-119
ACTION-111	pending review	Follow up on JavaScript API and report hallway conversation with Shane	Thomas Roessler	2012-02-02
ACTION-116	pending review	Draft text prohibitng third parties from acting or representing themselves as first parties	Thomas Lowenthal	2012-03-06	ISSUE-123
ACTION-122	pending review	Draft possible use of site-specific exception API to test existence of DNT / ask for exceptions even without DNT turned on	Nick Doty	2012-02-15	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-133	pending review	Collect comparison criteria and summarize comparison in URIvsHeaders table	Matthias Schunter	2012-02-29
ACTION-135	pending review	Detail use case for ISSUE-111 (DNT;2)	Shane Wiley	2012-03-28	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-146	pending review	Review the proposed text for ISSUE-111 in the context of a redirect chain where some parties get 0, some parties get 1, and there is potentially some data sharing between the parties in the redirect chain	Ian Fette	2012-03-21
ACTION-147	pending review	Enumerate scenarios in which requesting exception[mysite,*] might not work, e.g. user says no, then how do you figure out what you can or cannot get exceptions for, such as if user is only saying no to facebook but you don't know which, if any, of their ad networks the user is objecting to	Ian Fette	2012-03-21
ACTION-154	pending review	Draft an unlinkable data/unidentifiable data/pick favorite term exception	Jonathan Mayer	2012-04-04
ACTION-157	pending review	Update logged-in consent proposal by April 24	Shane Wiley	2012-04-24	Compliance Next
ACTION-160	pending review	Work with Shane on common ground on unlinkability normative/non-normative text	Peter Eckersley	2012-05-23	Compliance Next
ACTION-161	pending review	work on issue-49	Shane Wiley	2012-09-05	service provider
ACTION-165	pending review	Draft example text around using the Geolocation API for non-normative text on "Geolocation compliance" section in Compliance	Ian Fette	2012-04-25	Compliance Next
ACTION-174	pending review	Write up implication of origin/* exceptions in EU context	Ninja Marnau	2012-06-06	ISSUE-129
ACTION-175	pending review	Draft API method for sites to remove, a la removeTrackingException()	Vincent Toubiana	2012-05-05	ISSUE-83
ACTION-176	pending review	Update site-specific exceptions text to note that embedded third-party javascript may make the call rather than the first party (even though it probably shouldn't do so without working it out with the publisher)	David Singer	2012-05-30	ISSUE-129
ACTION-177	pending review	Add an API to let a site request a web-wide exception	Shane Wiley	2012-05-05	ISSUE-130
ACTION-179	pending review	Draft section on seriousness of the request for a user-granted exception (with ninja)	Shane Wiley	2012-04-19	ISSUE-129
ACTION-180	pending review	Provide a text update to section 4.3 to resolve issue 116 and ISSUE-84	Nick Doty	2012-05-23	ISSUE-116
ACTION-185	pending review	Draft specific field proposal for optional auditors	Kevin Trilli	2012-05-26	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-186	pending review	Clarify non-normative text on making a public commitment (also in a privacy policy, e.g.)	Justin Brookman	2012-06-25
ACTION-187	pending review	Write text for ISSUE-99 around identity providers as first or third parties, DUE May 5 2012	Ian Fette	2012-06-06
ACTION-189	pending review	Differentiate observers from members in attendee list for DC minutes	Nick Doty	2012-05-02
ACTION-190	pending review	Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks	Ian Fette	2012-05-02	ISSUE-174
ACTION-191	pending review	Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks for ISSUE-142	Thomas Lowenthal	2012-05-05
ACTION-193	pending review	Document difficulties around well known URIs for large sites and propose alternatives	Ian Fette	2012-05-09
ACTION-194	pending review	Write up a proposal for transitive third party exceptions	Ian Fette	2012-05-09
ACTION-195	pending review	Clarify action items needed for issue-65	Justin Brookman	2012-08-15	ISSUE-65
ACTION-196	pending review	Draft text on whether url shorteners are first or third parties	Justin Brookman	2012-08-15	ISSUE-97
ACTION-197	pending review	Propose alternative media access policies	Jonathan Mayer	2012-05-16
ACTION-206	pending review	Integrate http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-tracking/2012May/0280.html by May 30	David Singer	2012-05-30	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-211	pending review	Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal	Justin Brookman	2012-06-13	Compliance Next
ACTION-212	pending review	Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal	Shane Wiley	2012-09-26	user-education
ACTION-213	pending review	Draft text perhaps with roy and ifette around notion of filtering out data that is received in large amounts that should be required to be filtered out	Jonathan Mayer	2012-07-15
ACTION-218	pending review	Write up proposal on issue-112 that we do exceptions based on origin	Nick Doty	2012-07-18
ACTION-220	pending review	Write up tl/matthias sub-group agreement on exception approach	Matthias Schunter	2012-06-29
ACTION-222	pending review	Document out-of-band js api	Ian Fette	2012-07-25
ACTION-224	pending review	Ensure that Section 4 reflects the latest DomAPI proposal by Nick	Nick Doty	2012-07-15	ISSUE-84
ACTION-225	pending review	Propose an alternative definition of first party (based on ownership? alternative to inference?)	Heather West	2012-08-22
ACTION-226	pending review	Spec update to address ISSUE/116	David Singer	2012-08-15	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-227	pending review	Collect input (from Tom, Jonathan, Ed, Rob) on needs for a service-provider flag and compare to current draft	David Singer	2012-07-25
ACTION-229	pending review	Draft crisp definition [of data append]	Chris Pedigo	2012-08-01	ISSUE-170
ACTION-232	pending review	Write a short proposal on issue-153	David Wainberg	2012-08-22
ACTION-235	pending review	Draft middle way draft on permitted uses	Nick Doty	2012-09-04
ACTION-237	pending review	Update Compliance spec with pointer regarding issue-21	Heather West	2012-08-15
ACTION-240	pending review	Insert a note on how sites can avoid repeatedly asking the user for an exception	David Singer	2012-08-22
ACTION-241	pending review	Propose changes regarding issue-116 (and also "general preference")	Nick Doty	2012-09-10
ACTION-246	pending review	draft proposal regarding making a public compliance commitment (with Alan, Ian)	David Wainberg	2012-10-10	ISSUE-45
ACTION-247	pending review	Re-insert values that specify what exceptions are actually in use to the TPE spec	David Singer	2012-08-30	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-249	pending review	Ensure that the qualifiers reflect the permissions documented in the compliance document, due 10 october	David Singer	2012-10-10	Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-252	pending review	Propose defining formerly-known-as absolutely-not-tracking via permitted uses	Nick Doty	2012-09-12
ACTION-253	pending review	Propose dropping any tracking status value for None/Anonymous	David Wainberg	2012-09-12
ACTION-254	pending review	Draft text on freq. capping that would avoid new definitions and/or remove redundant normative requirement (with nick and amy?)	Shane Wiley	2012-09-19
ACTION-255	pending review	Work on financial reporting text (with nick, ian) as alternative to legal requirements	Alan Chapell	2012-09-19
ACTION-256	pending review	Propose update on security/fraud regarding deception/ad fraud	David Wainberg	2012-09-19
ACTION-260	pending review	Update debugging text (add normative 'short term', 'diagnostic', expand on or replace "graduated response")	Nick Doty	2012-10-03
ACTION-261	pending review	Update draft to remove aggregate permitted use, highlight unlinkable section where discussion may continue	Justin Brookman	2012-10-03
ACTION-262	pending review	Draft text regarding existing contracts (with vinay)	Amy Colando	2012-10-03	ISSUE-28
ACTION-264	pending review	Draft updated 'share' definition to avoid concerns (with rigo and chris-p)	Amy Colando	2012-10-10
ACTION-265	pending review	Update text in 3.8.1 regarding bringing into compliance, not just deletion	Shane Wiley	2012-10-10
ACTION-266	pending review	Suggest retention related to a timed grace period (with dwainberg)	Ian Fette	2012-10-10	ISSUE-174
ACTION-267	pending review	Propose first/third party definitions from existing DAA documents	Rachel Thomas	2012-10-10
ACTION-268	pending review	Edit the TPE document to make sure that the final definition of parties is in sync across the two specifications	David Singer	2012-11-12
ACTION-269	pending review	Update 3.5.2 to expand beyond "Web site"	Justin Brookman	2012-10-10
ACTION-273	pending review	Propose text regarding multiple first parties	Rob Sherman	2012-11-02	ISSUE-181
ACTION-274	pending review	Propose non-normative text on service providers to clarify "independent use" (with rvaneijk)	Shane Wiley	2012-10-10
ACTION-275	pending review	Update middle way proposals to avoid relying on "tracking"	Nick Doty	2012-10-10
ACTION-277	pending review	Propose non-normative text regarding contracts/other specifications	David Singer	2012-10-10
ACTION-278	pending review	Suggest an alternative to debugging graduated response ('once identified a problem')	Thomas Lowenthal	2012-10-10	Compliance Next
ACTION-279	pending review	Write an explanation of graduated response and a list of explanatory use cases	Ian Fette	2012-10-10	ISSUE-24
ACTION-280	pending review	Draft updated text on UA requirements; explanatory text made more general; add 'prior to selecting DNT'; add examples; change MUST to SHOULD	Shane Wiley	2012-10-10	user-education
ACTION-282	pending review	Add to the TPE that at most one DNT header is permitted in any HTTP request (issue-150)	David Singer	2012-10-10
ACTION-284	pending review	Propose barring other software from altering a DNT signal if the browser already set it	Ian Fette	2012-10-10
ACTION-286	pending review	Propose DAA text regarding de-identification (for unlinkability discussion)	Rachel Thomas	2012-11-22	unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-287	pending review	Define "user expectation" as it's used in the context of the two documents.	Brendan Riordan-Butterworth	2012-11-14	Compliance Next
ACTION-288	pending review	Update unlinkable with non-normative text from Shane	Heather West	2012-10-10
ACTION-289	pending review	Define "unlinkable" related to section 3.6 on unlinkable data in compliance document	Walter van Holst	2012-10-10	unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-290	pending review	Remove incorrect terminology in TPE (top-level domain)	David Singer	2012-10-30	ISSUE-173
ACTION-291	pending review	update to 3.5.2 to address different requirements regarding screen size	Kevin Smith	2012-10-10
ACTION-292	pending review	Move global requirements above enumerated permitted uses	Justin Brookman	2012-10-18	Compliance Next
ACTION-293	pending review	Draft non-normative examples illustrating graduated response	Jonathan Mayer	2012-10-11	ISSUE-24
ACTION-294	pending review	Revise security/fraud based on existing proposals	Justin Brookman	2012-10-11
ACTION-298	pending review	Draft examples for	Jonathan Mayer	2012-10-11	ISSUE-31
ACTION-299	pending review	Revise data minimization (flip ONLY --> NOT, "had expired," non-norm examples, et alia.	Justin Brookman	2012-10-11	Compliance Next
ACTION-300	pending review	Add a service provider option (or condense with option 1) from jmayer	Heather West	2012-10-11
ACTION-301	pending review	Eijk to draft explanation on intermediaries and inserted headers	Rob van Eijk	2012-10-11	ISSUE-176
ACTION-302	pending review	Draft intermediary requirements, without implementation details (with Brendan)	Brendan Riordan-Butterworth	2012-11-14
ACTION-303	pending review	Draft definition of "visit"	Ian Fette	2012-10-11	ISSUE-97
ACTION-304	pending review	Draft proposal on url re-direction	Ian Fette	2012-10-11
ACTION-305	pending review	Remove 6.3.2 on logged in transactions	Justin Brookman	2012-10-11
ACTION-306	pending review	Define "declared" data	Shane Wiley	2012-10-11	ISSUE-54
ACTION-307	pending review	Propose non-normative text on 119 (with schunter)	David Singer	2012-10-11
ACTION-311	pending review	Merge definitions of "party"	Justin Brookman	2013-04-01	Compliance Next
ACTION-313	pending review	Draft normative text based on adrianba's exception proposal	Ian Fette	2012-10-12
ACTION-314	pending review	Draft non-normative examples of how a multi-domain site technically can ask for exceptions	Shane Wiley	2012-10-12
ACTION-316	pending review	Draft update on when service provider indication is necessary (with fielding)	David Singer	2012-10-12
ACTION-318	pending review	Update draft with JS window/navigator change (coordinate with dsinger/adrianba text)	Nick Doty	2012-10-12	ISSUE-116
ACTION-319	pending review	Draft non-normative text on how to accomplish non-JS third parties that want to request for exceptions (with lou)	Nick Doty	2012-10-12	ISSUE-138
ACTION-320	pending review	Write reference/examples as necessary for explaining out-of-band consent in TPE (with Joanne)	David Singer	2012-10-12
ACTION-323	pending review	Share results of what-the-response-is-for discussion	David Singer	2012-12-12
ACTION-324	pending review	Compile public compliance commitment options for potential Call	Aleecia McDonald	2012-10-24	ISSUE-45
ACTION-325	pending review	Help re-factor into appendices (with justin, jmayer?)	Nick Doty	2012-10-24	ISSUE-175
ACTION-334	pending review	Re-update on handling of sub-domains, clarify concrete options (issue-112, perhaps with Shane)	Nick Doty	2012-11-14
ACTION-339	pending review	Propose a refinement to debugging permitted use	Walter van Holst	2012-11-21	ISSUE-24
ACTION-341	pending review	Write up potential use cases for optional indication of service provider status, including points from Roy	David Singer	2012-12-05
ACTION-345	pending review	Condense non-norm examples on non-JS third parties and integrate into spec	David Singer	2012-12-12
ACTION-348	pending review	Ensure that the exception APIs do not preclude the UA from pending the set to get user approval	David Singer	2013-01-16
ACTION-349	pending review	Propose 'does my exception stand' APIs for both site and web exceptions	David Singer	2013-01-16
ACTION-351	pending review	Make updates to window/navigator version of doNotTrack (with Nick)	David Singer	2013-01-16
ACTION-353	pending review	Design the 'confirm exceptions' APIs	David Singer	2013-01-16
ACTION-357	pending review	Add service provider option text (with jmayer) as an issue in the draft with an option box	David Singer	2013-02-20	ISSUE-137
ACTION-360	pending review	Send email explaining why the proposal in ISSUE-152 is not needed and why issue 152 shall be closed	Nick Doty	2013-02-06	ISSUE-152
ACTION-363	pending review	Draft text for user agent flexibility on exceptions	Nick Doty	2013-02-20
ACTION-364	pending review	Draft section on best practices for sites requesting exceptions	David Singer	2013-02-20
ACTION-366	pending review	Draft text on another non-compliant/ignoring the expressed preference (by suggestion of WileyS)	David Singer	2013-02-20
ACTION-414	pending review	Propose new text regarding other software (perhaps building off of npdoty, dsinger)	Alan Chapell	2013-06-12
ACTION-415	pending review	Provide text proposal regarding limitations on using a Potential Consent signal	Justin Brookman	2013-06-12
ACTION-422	pending review	Introduce changes proposed by Nick	David Singer	2013-06-26	ISSUE-168
ACTION-423	pending review	integrate Alan's intermediary text	David Singer	2013-06-26	ISSUE-153
ACTION-424	pending review	Clarify UGEs and out of band consent	David Singer	2013-06-26	ISSUE-201
ACTION-429	pending review	Add wiki page regarding how-to, dashboard on our process for issues/change proposals	Nick Doty	2013-09-25
ACTION-467	pending review	Highlight where "tracking data" is used and proposed meaning in each place	Roy Fielding	2015-04-01

Overdue action items

There are 39 overdue actions.

ID	State	Title	Person	Due Date	Associated with
ACTION-285	open	Propose non-normative text to add on to action-231 (with nick)	David Singer	2012-10-10	ISSUE-153
ACTION-368	open	Work on updated "service provider"/"processor" definition (with vinay)	Chris Pedigo	2013-02-27
ACTION-369	open	Summarize texts, agreements, and uncertain bits to data around service providers (ideally with dsinger and perhaps npdoty, if willing)	Aleecia McDonald	2013-03-13
ACTION-375	open	Review TPE for updates necessary on multiple first parties (with Ed, Nick, RobS, possibly fielding)	Shane Wiley	2013-03-18
ACTION-376	open	(with justin) to propose updates on multiple first parties (distinguishing between the one site and platform)	Rob Sherman	2013-03-18
ACTION-377	open	(with rigo, peterswire) to follow up on service provider and independent rights clarification	Chris Pedigo	2013-03-18
ACTION-389	open	Organize german industry participation in the work of the delta between regulation and DNT	Thomas Schauf	2013-03-28	Delta
ACTION-397	open	Look into data around the impact of audience measurement / changes to census calibration	Richard Weaver	2013-05-13
ACTION-398	open	Work with ESOMAR folks on clarifying "otherwise support" in audience measurement proposed text	Richard Weaver	2013-06-19
ACTION-399	open	Propose text (with Rigo and Rob v.E.) on harmonizing audience measurement permitted use in EU context	Susan Israel	2013-05-13
ACTION-400	open	Explore how service providers (to 1st and 3rd parties) can provide transparency, and work through the use cases	David Singer	2013-05-14
ACTION-401	open	Update compliance standard to provide requirements for sending D tracking status signal when disregarding DNT:1 signals	Justin Brookman	2013-05-14	Compliance Next
ACTION-402	open	Work with Dan to follow up on defining the "yellow" to "green" transaction with strong enough measures	Shane Wiley	2013-05-28
ACTION-403	open	Write language on red / yellow / green	Justin Brookman	2013-06-12
ACTION-404	open	Further Fact finding on scope of audience measurement and the DAA exception (one page of text)	Susan Israel	2013-06-19	AudienceMeasurement
ACTION-406	open	Porpose a new set of names around yellow state	Rob van Eijk	2013-05-29
ACTION-407	open	(with Alan Chapell) to draft text regarding browser education as discussed in Sunnyvale (Item 6 in Draft Framework, also in consensus action summary)	Chris Mejia	2013-05-29
ACTION-408	open	Review security/fraud text (with chris mejia and dan auerbach)	David Wainberg	2013-05-29	ISSUE-24
ACTION-410	open	Review issue-184 with Walter and Rob before merging/pending review	Peter Swire	2013-05-29	ISSUE-184
ACTION-412	open	Draft directly/indirectly -identified language proposal	Peter Swire	2013-06-05
ACTION-416	open	Review potential consent proposal (including updates from justin), may provide alternative regarding control link	David Singer	2013-06-12
ACTION-421	open	Provide text on caching exceptions in cases of server-to-server communication (detail on the use case, in particular)	Shane Wiley	2013-06-19
ACTION-425	open	Validate / Comment on David Singer's email	Aleecia McDonald	2013-06-26	ISSUE-137
ACTION-427	open	Add non-normative text on graduated response	Justin Brookman	2013-07-24
ACTION-432	open	Implement editorial changes on compliance draft (with dsinger, npdoty)	Heather West	2013-09-27
ACTION-433	open	Move definitions of collection from issue-228 to issue-16 in 2 weeks	Vinay Goel	2013-11-13
ACTION-434	open	Propose an update on normal/abnormal on d signal	David Singer	2013-12-25
ACTION-435	open	Check that the compliance array is in the tpe spec	David Singer	2014-02-12
ACTION-447	open	Work with roy to find the right sentence for issue-153	David Singer	2014-04-16
ACTION-464	open	Write improved informative text around the synchronous api	David Singer	2014-11-19
ACTION-466	open	Move "transfer" concept/qualifier to tcs	Nick Doty	2015-03-18
ACTION-468	open	Start wiki page for gathering implementations	Nick Doty	2015-09-30
ACTION-469	open	Follow up regarding test suites and w3c infrastructure	Nick Doty	2015-09-30
ACTION-470	open	Design and post on the wiki a draft interoperability test matrix	Mike O'Neill	2015-10-07	TPE Implementation Report
ACTION-471	open	Raise bugs regarding eff interop	Nick Doty	2015-10-28
ACTION-473	open	Work with schunter on requirements for cr exit: uas, plugins, edge...?	Bert Bos	2017-03-13
ACTION-474	open	Remove expires from api in favor of just using maxage	Roy Fielding	2017-07-24
ACTION-475	open	Rephrase "at risk" on dnt-extensions	Roy Fielding	2017-07-24
ACTION-476	open	Talk to martin kurze about dnt implementations.	Matthias Schunter	2017-11-20

Action items due next week

There are 0 upcoming actions.

Issues discussed over the last week

There are 0 recently discussed issues listed in the system.

Raised Issues

There are 16 raised issues listed in the system.

ID	State	Title	Raised on	Product	Open Actions
ISSUE-135	RAISED	Draft Global Considerations document	2012-04-11	Global Considerations	0
ISSUE-147	RAISED	Transporting Consent via the Exception / DNT mechanisms	2012-05-14	Global Considerations	0
ISSUE-150	RAISED	DNT conflicts from multiple user agents	2012-05-30	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-183 Tk E	RAISED	Additional Tk header status value for EU	2012-10-21	Global Considerations	0
ISSUE-184	RAISED	3rd party dependencies in 1st party content	2012-10-24	Compliance Next	1
ISSUE-189 EUConsent	RAISED	Explicit informed consent mechanism needed	2012-11-22	Global Considerations	0
ISSUE-211	RAISED	Should we specify retention periods (extended with transparency) for permitted uses?	2013-06-27	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-212	RAISED	Naming of user-granted exceptions	2013-06-28	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-214	RAISED	Adding to last public working draft	2013-07-01	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-220 Proportionality	RAISED	Proportionality should be across the board	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-223 implementation criteria	RAISED	Define criteria now for the test/implementation phase of the compliance spec	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-226 Rules by context	RAISED	What rules apply for data collection/use, by context	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-227 User Agent Minimum Requirements	RAISED	User Agent requirements in UA Compliance vs. Scope section	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-230 New Definition	RAISED	Add a definition for "Web Browsing History"	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-238 Permitted uses	RAISED	Scope of Permitted uses	2013-10-07	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-265	RAISED	Status of referrals in navigation (is it tracking, is it permitted for dnt:1)	2014-08-20		0

Pending Review Issues

The following issues are candidate for closing.

There are 67 pending review issues listed in the system.

ID	State	Title	Raised on	Product	Open Actions
ISSUE-22	PENDING REVIEW	Still have "operational use" of data (auditing of where ads are shown, impression tracking, etc.)	2011-09-21	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-24	PENDING REVIEW	Possible exemption for fraud detection and defense	2011-09-21	Compliance Current	1
ISSUE-25 AudienceMeasurement	PENDING REVIEW	How is audience measurement adressed under DNT? (permitted use or otherwise)	2011-09-21	Compliance Current	1
ISSUE-31	PENDING REVIEW	Minimization -- to what extent will minimization be required for use of a particular exemption? (conditional exemptions)	2011-09-21	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-32	PENDING REVIEW	Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering	2011-09-21	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-49 service provider	PENDING REVIEW	Third party as first party - is a third party that collects data on behalf of the first party treated the same way as the first party?	2011-09-22	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-97	PENDING REVIEW	Re-direction, shortened URLs, click analytics -- what kind of tracking is this?	2011-10-31	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-99	PENDING REVIEW	How does DNT work with identity providers?	2011-11-05	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-148	PENDING REVIEW	What does DNT:0 mean?	2012-05-29	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-170	PENDING REVIEW	Definition of and what/whether limitations around data append and first parties	2012-10-03	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-172 user-education	PENDING REVIEW	How should user agents be required to provide information about DNT?	2012-10-03	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-175	PENDING REVIEW	Have an appendix of best practices?	2012-10-04	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-188 unlinkable-deidentified	PENDING REVIEW	Definition of de-identified (or previously, unlinkable) data	2012-11-14	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-194 user-consent	PENDING REVIEW	How should we ensure consent of users for DNT inputs?	2013-04-10	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-196	PENDING REVIEW	What compliance requirements apply when a signal has been disregarded?	2013-05-07	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-201	PENDING REVIEW	Interplay between UGE and out of band consent	2013-06-12	Compliance Next	0
ISSUE-202 geolocation	PENDING REVIEW	Limitations on geolocation by third parties	2013-06-22	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-203	PENDING REVIEW	Use of "tracking" in third-party compliance	2013-06-24	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-205	PENDING REVIEW	user agent compliance requirements; connections to TPE	2013-06-26	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-206	PENDING REVIEW	Service Provider name and requirements	2013-06-26	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-207	PENDING REVIEW	Conditions for dis-regarding (or not) DNT signals	2013-06-26	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-209	PENDING REVIEW	Description of scope of specification	2013-06-27	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-210	PENDING REVIEW	Interaction with existing privacy controls	2013-06-27	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-218	PENDING REVIEW	Data that is out of scope	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-219 Context separation	PENDING REVIEW	Limitations on use in a 3rd party context of data collected in a 1st party context	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-221 Context	PENDING REVIEW	Define collection and use by context rather than party	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-222 personalization	PENDING REVIEW	Tailoring or customizing of content should be allowed under certain collection/use limitations	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-233 Data Minimization	PENDING REVIEW	Data Minimization, Retention and Transparency	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-234 No Personalization	PENDING REVIEW	Remove "No Personalization" section	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-235 Auditability	PENDING REVIEW	Auditability requirement in Reasonable Security section	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-236	PENDING REVIEW	Profiling prohibition for frequency capping permitted use	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-237 Financial Logging	PENDING REVIEW	Revise Financial Logging section	2013-10-02	Compliance Current	0
ISSUE-243	PENDING REVIEW	origin/browsing context terminology	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-244	PENDING REVIEW	priority of local legislation	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-245	PENDING REVIEW	highlighting accessiblity in user interface guidelines	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-246	PENDING REVIEW	terminology of user-granted exception vs. user-granted permission	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-247	PENDING REVIEW	update HTTP draft references (httpbis)	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-248	PENDING REVIEW	using Unicode notation in ABNF	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-249	PENDING REVIEW	DNT-extension excludes should spell out control, space, double quote (or use Unicode code points)	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-250	PENDING REVIEW	Non-ASCII not permitted in extensions	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-251	PENDING REVIEW	Section title for 6.2.7 doesn't match earlier description	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-252	PENDING REVIEW	IRI/non-ASCII not permitted	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-253	PENDING REVIEW	Section 6.4.2: restriction to "URI-safe characters"	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-254	PENDING REVIEW	public access devices in intermediaries text	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-255	PENDING REVIEW	comments on doNotTrack property	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-256	PENDING REVIEW	comments on exception APIs (asynchronous/promise/parameter names)	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-257	PENDING REVIEW	ABNF to define a JSON based format	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-258	PENDING REVIEW	automatic expiration of a tracking preference	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-259	PENDING REVIEW	require public-facing statement of server response policy	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-260	PENDING REVIEW	method for validating DNT signal from user	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-262	PENDING REVIEW	guidance regarding server responses and timing	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-263	PENDING REVIEW	restriction on use of data by user agents	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-264	PENDING REVIEW	requirement on UAs for setting cookies	2014-07-13	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-266	PENDING REVIEW	automatic expiration of a tracking preference exception via API parameter	2014-09-25	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-267	PENDING REVIEW	registration of DNT/Tk header fields and ./well-known/dnt URI	2014-10-21	TPE Last Call	0
ISSUE-268	PENDING REVIEW	"does not override regulatory terminology"	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-269	PENDING REVIEW	interpretation of dnt:0/unset	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-270	PENDING REVIEW	deidentification and compliance with regulations	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-271	PENDING REVIEW	out of band consent and specified purpose	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-272	PENDING REVIEW	first- and third-party interactions	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-273	PENDING REVIEW	particular mechanisms for tracking	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-274	PENDING REVIEW	permitted uses: frequency capping and ad display auditing	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-275	PENDING REVIEW	length of retention periods	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-276	PENDING REVIEW	normativity of graduated response language	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-277	PENDING REVIEW	default to DNT:1?	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-278	PENDING REVIEW	repeating comments from TPE Last Call	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0
ISSUE-279	PENDING REVIEW	word count?	2015-11-06	TCS Last Call	0