14:52:52 RRSAgent has joined #gld 14:52:52 logging to http://www.w3.org/2011/12/15-gld-irc 14:52:54 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:52:54 Zakim has joined #gld 14:52:56 Zakim, this will be EGOV_GLD 14:52:56 I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, trackbot 14:52:57 Meeting: Government Linked Data Working Group Teleconference 14:52:57 Date: 15 December 2011 14:53:00 zakim, this will be gld 14:53:01 ok, sandro; I see T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM scheduled to start in 7 minutes 14:53:43 hello 14:55:51 Scribe: BenediktKaempgen 14:56:15 T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM has now started 14:56:22 +davidwood 14:56:29 zakim, davidwood is me 14:56:29 +bhyland; got it 14:56:53 olyerickson has joined #GLD 14:57:08 +George 14:57:13 +[IPcaller] 14:57:17 I'll be on in a second... busy day at #TWCRPI ;) 14:57:28 George has joined #gld 14:57:39 If anyone wanted to share what RDF is with their kids, here is something fun for you to share, see  http://3roundstones.com/linked-data-101/rdf-explained/ 14:57:40 +HadleyBeeman 14:58:09 gatemezin has joined #gld 14:58:29 rrsagent, make records public 14:58:42 Scribe: BenediktKaempgen 14:58:50 Chair: bhyland 14:59:17 Mike_Pendleton has joined #gld 14:59:31 tgheen has joined #gld 14:59:32 martin has joined #gld 14:59:55 + +1.202.566.aaaa 15:00:04 trackbot-ng, start telcon 15:00:06 RRSAgent, make logs world 15:00:08 Zakim, this will be EGOV_GLD 15:00:08 I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, trackbot 15:00:09 Meeting: Government Linked Data Working Group Teleconference 15:00:09 Date: 15 December 2011 15:00:24 scribe: BenediktKaempgen 15:00:34 chair: bhyland 15:00:43 LuisBermudez has joined #gld 15:00:46 zakim, who is on the call? 15:00:46 I notice T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM has restarted 15:00:48 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, +1.202.566.aaaa, [LC] 15:00:58 Did we just kicked off the call? 15:01:03 Zakim, [LC] is me 15:01:03 +tgheen; got it 15:01:09 +sandro 15:01:17 + +1.267.481.aabb 15:01:26 +raphael 15:01:30 +DanG 15:01:32 zakim, aaaa is Mike_Pendleton 15:01:32 +Mike_Pendleton; got it 15:01:38 agenda: http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Meetings:Telecon2011.12.15#Agenda 15:01:47 zakim, who is on the call? 15:01:47 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, Mike_Pendleton, tgheen, sandro, +1.267.481.aabb, raphael, DanG 15:02:08 DanG has joined #gld 15:02:25 zakim, aabb is luisbermudez 15:02:27 +luisbermudez; got it 15:02:31 zakim, aabb is LuisBemudez 15:02:34 sorry, bhyland, I do not recognize a party named 'aabb' 15:02:40 rreck has joined #GLD 15:02:45 BenediktKaempgen is connected through Skype. Hope it will stay connected. 15:03:32 +??P38 15:03:34 bhyland: one more call on 22nd of December? 15:03:37 I'm travelling on 22 Dec, unfortunately 15:03:49 I can make the 22nd 15:03:51 q+ 15:03:54 Druidsmith has joined #gld 15:03:55 zakim, who is on the call? 15:03:55 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, Mike_Pendleton, tgheen, sandro, luisbermudez, raphael, DanG, ??P38 15:04:03 -??P38 15:04:05 I cannot 15:04:14 +??P38 15:04:18 I can make also on the 22nd 15:04:22 GeraldSteeman has joined #GLD 15:04:29 +rreck 15:04:34 zakim, ?p38 is benediktkempgen 15:04:34 sorry, HadleyBeeman, I do not recognize a party named '?p38' 15:04:38 I probably can't attend next week. Don't count on me. 15:04:43 zakim, p38 is benediktkempgen 15:04:43 sorry, HadleyBeeman, I do not recognize a party named 'p38' 15:05:00 zakim, +??P38 is benediktkempgen 15:05:01 sorry, HadleyBeeman, I do not recognize a party named '+??P38' 15:05:05 zakim, who's here 15:05:05 HadleyBeeman, you need to end that query with '?' 15:05:09 zakim, who's here? 15:05:09 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, Mike_Pendleton, tgheen, sandro, luisbermudez, raphael, DanG, ??P38, rreck 15:05:12 On IRC I see GeraldSteeman, Druidsmith, rreck, DanG, LuisBermudez, martin, tgheen, Mike_Pendleton, gatemezin, George, olyerickson, Zakim, RRSAgent, HadleyBeeman, BenediktKaempgen, 15:05:14 Accept last minutes? 15:05:16 ... trackbot, bhyland, danbri, sandro 15:05:22 +??P41 15:05:31 zakim, mute me 15:05:32 zakim, ??P38 is benediktkempgen 15:05:35 sorry, martin, I do not know which phone connection belongs to you 15:05:39 +benediktkempgen; got it 15:05:40 PROPOSED: accept minutes 15:05:46 zakim, ??p41 is me 15:05:46 zakim, who's here? 15:05:47 +martin; got it 15:05:47 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/meeting/2011-12-08 15:05:51 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, Mike_Pendleton, tgheen, sandro, luisbermudez, raphael, DanG, benediktkempgen, rreck, martin 15:05:56 On IRC I see GeraldSteeman, Druidsmith, rreck, DanG, LuisBermudez, martin, tgheen, Mike_Pendleton, gatemezin, George, olyerickson, Zakim, RRSAgent, HadleyBeeman, BenediktKaempgen, 15:06:01 ... trackbot, bhyland, danbri, sandro 15:06:08 confirmed :) 15:06:14 +1 15:06:21 zakim, who is on the phone? 15:06:21 On the phone I see bhyland, George, [IPcaller], HadleyBeeman, Mike_Pendleton, tgheen, sandro, luisbermudez, raphael, DanG, benediktkempgen, rreck, martin 15:06:22 +1 15:06:23 Yigal has joined #gld 15:06:26 zakim, who is talking? 15:06:37 someone is breathing quite loudly 15:06:37 sandro, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: bhyland (5%), George (29%) 15:06:45 +GeraldSteeman 15:06:53 Action Item review, see http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/open 15:06:53 Sorry, couldn't find user - Item 15:07:18 zakim, who is talking? 15:07:19 +[IPcaller.a] 15:07:21 minutes accepted? 15:07:22 zakim, who is speaking? 15:07:29 sandro, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: bhyland (5%), benediktkempgen (8%), ??P46 (5%) 15:07:34 zakim, IPcaller.a i sme 15:07:34 I don't understand 'IPcaller.a i sme', Yigal 15:07:39 bhyland, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: bhyland (18%), sandro (15%), benediktkempgen (5%), [IPcaller.a] (9%) 15:07:44 zakim, IPcaller.a is me 15:07:45 +Yigal; got it 15:07:53 I am muted. 15:07:55 zakim, mute BenediktKaempgen 15:07:56 sorry, sandro, I do not know which phone connection belongs to BenediktKaempgen 15:08:06 Zakim, mute benediktkempgen 15:08:06 benediktkempgen should now be muted 15:08:12 zakim, who is talking? 15:08:13 zakim, mute IPcaller.a 15:08:13 sorry, sandro, I do not know which phone connection belongs to IPcaller.a 15:08:21 +DruidSmith_ 15:08:22 bhyland, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: sandro (14%) 15:08:23 Zakim, mute gatemezin 15:08:23 sorry, gatemezin, I do not know which phone connection belongs to gatemezin 15:08:23 zakim, who is making noise? 15:08:25 zakim, who is muted? 15:08:25 I see benediktkempgen muted 15:08:34 sandro, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: DruidSmith_ (60%), bhyland (44%), sandro (33%) 15:08:45 zakim, mute Druidsmith_ 15:08:45 DruidSmith_ should now be muted 15:08:47 + +1.518.276.aacc 15:08:55 zakim aacc is me 15:08:55 Zakim, mute raphael 15:08:57 raphael should now be muted 15:09:01 zakim, who is muted? 15:09:01 I see raphael, benediktkempgen, DruidSmith_ muted 15:09:12 zakim, aacc is me. 15:09:12 +olyerickson; got it 15:09:20 the noise is NOT me 15:09:35 * The Zakim bridge has the capability to mute conferees. (Muting blocks sound on a conferee's line from being heard on the conference.) Conferees can mute themselves by dialing 61#. In that case, unmute is 60#. 15:09:43 RESOLVED: accept minutes 15:10:10 zakim, mute me 15:10:11 rreck should now be muted 15:10:12 Topic: Community Directory update 15:10:20 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/9 15:10:39 I muted for a few seconds, but the sound continued anyway. 15:10:46 zakim, who is a talking? 15:10:46 I don't understand your question, bhyland. 15:10:51 bhyland: acton-9 still open 15:11:13 s/acton/action 15:11:24 zakim, mute martin 15:11:24 martin should now be muted 15:11:35 martin, it was you making the noise. 15:12:00 zakim, unmute me 15:12:01 rreck should no longer be muted 15:12:02 action-13: will be send soon 15:12:02 ACTION-13 Post OGV docs as input to GLD on GLD wiki notes added 15:12:06 zakim, who is muted? 15:12:06 I see raphael, benediktkempgen, martin, DruidSmith_ muted 15:12:17 Zakim, unmute benediktkempgen 15:12:17 benediktkempgen should no longer be muted 15:12:23 zakim, unmute DruidSmith_ 15:12:23 DruidSmith_ should no longer be muted 15:12:31 ??: will send documents for action-13 very soon 15:12:39 s/??/DanG/ 15:13:02 -benediktkempgen 15:13:45 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/16 15:13:46 can i be involved in that please? 15:13:59 thanks gatemezin 15:14:01 bhyland: discussion started 15:14:04 my good friend Ken Sall talks to me about NIEM all the time 15:14:20 topic: Action Items 15:14:37 let's hope it doesnt use anonymous nodes 15:14:43 ... with Cory.. planning to model and use of conversion programme to RDF 15:14:55 ... not sure whether good rdf 15:15:17 action-16 is closed 15:15:44 subtopic: action-18 15:15:48 close action-16 15:15:48 ACTION-16 Agreed to facilitate NIEM discussion and get outline started working with bhyland. closed 15:16:13 jerrickson: action item community draft supersedes it? 15:16:28 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/18 15:16:32 ACTION-18: Agreed to facilitate initial wiki draft on Vocab page on VCAT. 15:16:33 ACTION-18 Agreed to facilitate initial wiki draft on Vocab page on VCAT. notes added 15:16:50 olyerickson: what means wiki draft 15:16:51 ? 15:17:13 ??: create a Community draft for that, it is the focus 15:17:33 ..may be that action should be closed 15:17:47 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/open 15:18:16 s/??/olyerickson 15:18:39 olyerickson: vcat, ok. 15:19:02 ... remains open 15:19:27 bhyland: olyerickson please ping George or bhyland to clarify 15:19:45 I posted the Open Government Vocabularies documents on 7 December 15:19:48 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/20 15:20:01 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/21 15:20:03 action-20 still open 15:20:24 action-21 will be talked about later 15:20:41 subtopic: action-22 15:20:44 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/22 15:20:59 ??: wiki content will be synthesized 15:21:15 ... will have something relatively substantial. 15:21:26 s/??/rreck 15:21:40 action-23 - anyone heard from TopQuadrant 15:22:00 action-24 - community draft, dcat 15:22:02 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/24 15:22:24 olyerrickson: should be done rather soon 15:22:48 ... sill some issues in discussion, e.g., language issue 15:22:49 ??: still have some issues in discussion, like the language issue 15:23:19 s/??/olyerickson 15:23:34 s/olyerrickson/olyerickson 15:23:56 ... people might be surprised that not much has changed 15:24:13 bhyland: enough open discussion 15:24:26 olyerickson: yes, there was some discussion 15:24:43 bhyland: waht does the deadline mean? 15:24:47 that's a semic.eu deadline i believe 15:25:11 olyerickson: put something readable on W3C page 15:25:26 s/waht/what 15:25:47 action-25 15:25:49 https://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/25 15:26:21 George: part of data.gov discussion. 15:26:33 Relevant to procurement section, therefore included. 15:26:51 ... Should be easy for Richard to recapture 15:27:02 Re DCAT discussions, see e.g. http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-gld-wg/2011Dec/thread.html 15:27:28 action-26 - what does it mean? 15:27:37 action-26? 15:27:37 ACTION-26 -- Bernadette Hyland to pull the list of things to check and notify the group -- due 2011-12-15 -- OPEN 15:27:37 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/track/actions/26 15:27:39 bhyland: maybe f2f? 15:28:02 ... scribes please create understandable action items 15:28:03 ... notice the dcat:language thread 15:28:15 topic: Community Directory update 15:28:18 http://dir.w3.org/ 15:28:26 action-26: not understanding what does it mean... 15:28:27 ACTION-26 Pull the list of things to check and notify the group notes added 15:28:33 Stats on community directory, http://dir.w3.org/page/number-of-organizations-by-country.xhtml?view 15:28:44 bhyland: stats are interesting 15:29:08 ... information about deployments is not necessarily understandable 15:29:19 ... more feedback appreciated 15:29:26 ... ?? is much into it 15:29:57 ... aim - vibrant list of what each one in the group is doing 15:30:10 Someone suggested adding this, http://www4.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/latc/toollibrary/ 15:30:31 ... maybe maintained by DERI folks? 15:31:01 chris bizer - most of these tools appear to be what's in http://stack.lod2.eu 15:31:09 ... makes it sense to reach out to them? 15:31:35 up to 200 companies that do something with Linked Data 15:32:11 George: thinks, yes. 15:32:17 olyerickson: yes 15:32:18 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Best_Practices_Discussion_Summary 15:32:27 +1 15:32:32 Topic: Best Practices update 15:32:58 bhyland: please make clear if you work on the wiki. Provide links and update. 15:33:33 mike: give preliminary overview. During next weeks. John Sherridon will be asked. 15:33:53 bhyland: John Sherridon will have a lot to say about this. 15:34:01 s/Sherridon/Sheridan 15:34:34 s/mike/Mike_Pendleton 15:34:48 suptopic: Vocabulary Selection update 15:35:06 q+ 15:35:07 bhyland: anything happening with this? 15:35:15 ... none on the call 15:35:30 subtopic: URI Construction update 15:35:42 subtopic: Stability, see http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Best_Practices_Discussion_Summary#2.2.5_Stability 15:35:43 Zakim, unmeted raphael 15:35:43 I don't understand 'unmeted raphael', gatemezin 15:36:03 Zakim, raphael unmuted 15:36:04 I don't understand 'raphael unmuted', gatemezin 15:36:04 Ron: Trying to figure out what is missing. 15:36:16 ... problem space needs to be defined 15:36:48 bhyland: does rather look like a draft not descriptive enough 15:36:50 Zakim, who is muted? 15:36:50 I see raphael, martin muted 15:37:15 bhyland: any guidance? 15:37:32 Ron referred to another page, I think it is http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Best_Practices_Discussion_Stability 15:38:03 Includes discussion of "conservation", "preservation of access" and "preservation of content" 15:38:19 is this http://www.mementoweb.org/ relevant? 15:38:26 Ron: topics - conservation, preservation of access, preservation of content 15:38:36 q? 15:38:42 bhyland: sounds good. 15:39:03 Recommend you look at this page for ideas on suggesting best practices, http://www.w3.org/TR/2010/REC-mwabp-20101214/ 15:39:31 bhyland: has been useful for the cook book also 15:40:27 ... really short but gives good pointers 15:40:48 ... a starting point 15:41:05 Ron: Struggling rather with organisation and writing in descriptive manner 15:41:09 q? 15:41:12 than with the content. 15:41:23 q+ 15:41:28 ack gatemezin 15:41:35 zakim, who is muted? 15:41:35 I see raphael, martin muted 15:41:45 who can unmuted me? 15:41:59 +1 to format in http://www.w3.org/TR/2010/REC-mwabp-20101214/ 15:42:13 please asgain? 15:42:23 press 4 1 # 15:42:45 sorry... 15:42:52 subtopic: Cook book 15:43:01 hyland: boris and I have added something 15:43:11 topic: Schedule & milestones review 15:43:14 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/charter 15:43:30 zakim, who is muted? 15:43:30 I see raphael, martin muted 15:43:33 bhyland: Some things to do in December. 15:44:18 ... bhyland: f2f in January. Anyone wants to comment? 15:44:23 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/charter#timeline 15:44:41 ... Someone wants to share thoughts? 15:44:54 MacTed has joined #gld 15:44:54 George: Middle ground regarding size. 15:45:09 That is Sandro speaking, not George 15:45:17 ... Difficult to balance. 15:45:24 s/George/Sandro 15:45:28 thanks 15:45:32 np 15:45:55 ??: did not know what to expect 15:45:59 All new to me as well. Not sure where to plug in. 15:46:02 s/??/DanG/ 15:46:05 DanG: RE: making progress & meeting deliverables, I haven't been one of these before & don't know what to expect 15:46:16 I think it's about what I expected...simply dealing with multiple time demands 15:47:14 bhyland: more often technical aspects, which helps with guidance. This is quite a different WG. 15:47:30 I do think that "critical mass" is an issue, since the group has several important deliverables and they only slightly overlap, thus requiring multiple sub-groups/teams working on individual tasks 15:47:33 ... we have a lot of invited experts. 15:47:45 Same here. I haven't been that involved -- but my intention was to become better acquainted with this community, and to find places where I *can* contribute. 15:48:16 ... More about pulling things together and checking whether up-to-date. 15:48:36 ... Trying less to create new things. 15:49:00 ... Recommends all to put together efforts. People are looking for help with Linked Data. 15:49:03 q? 15:49:37 Sandro: Are there people on the call that do not know where to help? 15:50:16 bhyland: cendi talk or similar are very useful for the group. 15:50:38 ... encourages all to make available such information 15:50:53 Will do. 15:51:00 Who is Cendi? any pointer? 15:51:30 http://cendi.gov 15:51:51 @GeralSteeman: Thanks 15:52:02 bhyland: cendi is user's group of it people that are interested in preservation of science information 15:52:22 ... very interesting use cases. bhyland gave talk about rdf. 15:52:27 http://cendi.gov/minutes/pa_1111.html 15:52:32 @bernadette: Walt Warnick at Dept of Energy still wants to talk to you 15:52:38 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/F2F2 15:52:47 topic: F2F2 Plans 15:53:23 ??: not have an answer today 15:53:46 DanG: Need to start F2F very early morning. Caviat. May make offer untenable. 15:54:02 bhyland: maybe start f2f later 15:54:07 s/??/DanG 15:54:28 bhyland: 5 hour time difference is a problem 15:54:45 DanG: Security is not an issue. 15:55:06 DanG: tries to have a resolution today. 15:55:13 ACTION: DanG to confirm when US Bureau of Labor Stats can be open for our meeting 15:55:13 Created ACTION-27 - Confirm when US Bureau of Labor Stats can be open for our meeting [on Dan Gillman - due 2011-12-22]. 15:56:13 What is the address for the BLS, by the way? 15:56:31 It is work on the part of the hosts so we should confirm attendance, see http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/F2F2#Who 15:56:35 bhyland: Anyone interested to confirm that he/she will be there? 15:56:56 Benedikt will be at DERI. 15:56:59 I confirm that I'll be there... 15:57:22 bhyland: community building would be very helpful for deliverables. 15:57:27 My organization needs the agenda for administrative protocole 15:57:59 bhyland: versioning, legacy part in charter needs to be better framed. 15:58:22 cygri has joined #gld 15:58:25 ... will be taking it to the mailing list 15:58:35 No announcements at this time ;) 15:58:47 So, finally we meet next week? 15:59:11 bhyland: many calls 15:59:25 +1 15:59:26 I can make it 15:59:33 i can 15:59:37 I can 15:59:38 I cannot, sorry. 15:59:49 I can make it to the call 16:00:19 I can make it 16:00:22 bhyland: We will have a call next week. Half a dozen people is good. 16:01:12 ... lots of things discuss (f2f, f2f venue, framing of charter topics) 16:01:34 thanks!! 16:01:39 thanks! 16:01:39 Yigal has left #gld 16:01:40 bubye 16:01:58 -Mike_Pendleton 16:02:01 -martin 16:02:03 -olyerickson 16:02:04 DanG: Please add name of any hotel that may have gov't rate on offer, you can update http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/F2F2 16:02:05 -DanG 16:02:07 -HadleyBeeman 16:02:07 thanks 16:02:11 -DruidSmith_ 16:02:15 -luisbermudez 16:02:19 -Yigal 16:02:21 -George 16:02:22 -sandro 16:02:24 Bye! 16:02:25 -tgheen 16:02:26 Benedikt, do you need any help with writing the minutes? 16:02:27 -bhyland 16:02:28 olyerickson has left #GLD 16:02:31 -rreck 16:02:33 -GeraldSteeman 16:02:37 -raphael 16:02:42 maybe, thanks for asking. I am about to try it. 16:03:01 See http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Meetings:Telecon2011.12.15#Scribe.27s_End_of_Meeting_Checklist 16:03:04 for instructions 16:03:21 I'm here if you need any help ... 16:03:29 or have any trouble ... 16:03:31 thanks 16:04:18 RRSAgent, set logs world-visible 16:04:34 RRSAgent, generate minutes 16:04:34 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2011/12/15-gld-minutes.html BenediktKaempgen 16:06:10 rrsagent, bye 16:06:10 I see 1 open action item saved in http://www.w3.org/2011/12/15-gld-actions.rdf : 16:06:10 ACTION: DanG to confirm when US Bureau of Labor Stats can be open for our meeting [1] 16:06:10 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2011/12/15-gld-irc#T15-55-13