13:53:12 RRSAgent has joined #lld 13:53:12 logging to http://www.w3.org/2010/07/08-lld-irc 13:53:27 meeting: Library Linked Data XG 13:53:37 chair: Antoine 13:53:47 agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-lld/2010Jul/0020.html 13:54:16 regrets: Tom, Tod, Jodi, Wolfgang, Herbert, William, Martin, Guenther 13:54:22 invite Zakim #lld 13:55:19 michaelp has joined #lld 13:56:06 I can't see LLD on the calendar http://www.w3.org/Guide/1998/08/teleconference-calendar.html#s_4061 13:56:37 i am not being admitted to the call with the code 55394 13:57:51 GordonD has joined #lld 13:58:33 oreste has joined #lld 13:58:57 dlukose has joined #lld 13:59:11 ray has joined #lld 13:59:54 http://www.w3.org/Guide/1998/08/TeleconferenceHowTo.htm#how requires 2 business days 14:00:15 @ everyone: we're stuck because our call is not registered in the W3C calendar for some reason 14:00:22 ... we do not have zakim for the moment 14:00:37 ... as you probably experienced from not being able to connect 14:01:15 fumi has joined #lld 14:01:21 kcoyle has joined #lld 14:01:36 digikim has joined #lld 14:01:53 rsinger has joined #lld 14:02:07 thanks! 14:02:09 hmm, not able to call in to boston number: "staff code is not valid"? 14:02:13 same here 14:02:26 talking to the operator 14:02:28 @ everyone: we're stuck because our call is not registered in the W3C calendar for some reason 14:02:35 ... we do not have zakim for the moment 14:02:41 she did not find it registered.. 14:02:41 ... as you probably experienced from not being able to connect 14:02:46 believed it was a one time only 14:02:47 heh 14:02:48 hmm... the key is not vorking 14:02:58 ah you noticed it already :( 14:03:05 and is trying to set it up ad hoc 14:03:09 stu: ok, so i guess i don't need to hold for the operator :-) 14:03:10 give her a couple minutes 14:03:29 YES, please advice when the conf code will be registered 14:03:30 marcia has joined #lld 14:03:43 Isaac, you may want to contact her and tell her you are the one to notify when its ready? 14:03:58 Monica has joined #lld 14:04:21 present: Monica, marcia, rsinger, digikim, kcoyle, fumi, ray, dlukose, oreste, GordonD, michaelp, RRSAgent, stu, AlexanderH, Zakim, fsasaki, antoine, jeff_, Nico, emma, kai, edsu, ww 14:04:35 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/07/08-lld-minutes.html fsasaki 14:04:36 I have trouble to call in. 14:05:03 ok we have stu trying to launch it via phone and felix having sent mail 14:05:14 let's wait five minutes 14:05:31 ... if we don't receive news then we cancel it 14:06:40 sorry everyone for this mess :-( 14:07:03 Q: How many Linked Data people are needed to fix a broken conference call? -- A: None. The Linked Data just works. :) 14:07:15 antoine: no worries 14:07:18 :-) 14:07:32 I was told by the operator to ring back in 3 minutes 14:08:01 the conference call is valid now. However when I called I was the only one. 14:08:04 if we cancel it will give me a chance to rebut edsu's blog posting ;) 14:08:05 oh well 14:08:07 its up! 14:08:11 I 14:08:16 +[LC] 14:08:18 I'm in 14:08:18 -[LC] 14:08:18 +[LC] 14:08:20 amy has joined #lld 14:08:25 Zakim, LC is edsu 14:08:25 +edsu; got it 14:08:32 this is amy from W3C. the bridge should be working 14:08:42 there was a problem with the scheduling, we'll try to sort it out later 14:08:50 thank amy! 14:08:52 Felix! hi! great 14:08:55 thank you! 14:08:55 :) 14:08:56 + +1.423.463.aaaa 14:08:57 + +1.330.289.aabb 14:08:58 sure thing 14:09:03 +[IPcaller.a] 14:09:13 + +1.614.764.aacc 14:09:17 +Oreste 14:09:23 +[IPcaller.aa] 14:09:39 Zakim, I am +1.423.463.aaaa 14:09:39 +rsinger; got it 14:09:48 +[IPcaller.aaa] 14:09:49 +??P30 14:09:53 amy has joined #lld 14:09:53 jar has joined #lld 14:09:57 Zakim, mute me 14:09:57 rsinger should now be muted 14:10:05 +??P26 14:10:05 I just called in, but how did I say its me? 14:10:08 scribe: fsasaki 14:10:23 + +81.35.937.aadd 14:10:29 Zakim, who is on the phone? 14:10:29 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), +1.330.289.aabb, [IPcaller.a], michaelp, Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], [IPcaller.aaa] (muted), Felix (muted), ??P26, +81.35.937.aadd 14:10:32 zakim, aadd is me 14:10:32 - +1.330.289.aabb 14:10:32 +fumi; got it 14:10:55 +[IPcaller.aaaa] 14:10:56 kcoyle has joined #lld 14:10:58 zakim, [IPcaller.aaa] is me. 14:10:58 +kai; got it 14:11:11 Zakim, who is on the phone? 14:11:11 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), [IPcaller.a], michaelp, Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], kai, Felix (muted), ??P26, fumi (muted), [IPcaller.aaaa] 14:11:15 + +1.330.289.aaee 14:11:16 +[LC] 14:11:28 +michaelp.a 14:11:30 is boston working now? 14:11:38 zakim, who is here? 14:11:38 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), [IPcaller.a], michaelp, Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], kai, Felix (muted), ??P26, fumi (muted), [IPcaller.aaaa], +1.330.289.aaee, 14:11:41 ... [LC], michaelp.a 14:11:42 On IRC I see kcoyle, jar, amy, Monica, marcia, rsinger, digikim, fumi, ray, dlukose, oreste, GordonD, michaelp, RRSAgent, stu, AlexanderH, Zakim, fsasaki, antoine, jeff_, Nico, 14:11:45 ... emma, kai, edsu, ww 14:11:45 +[IPcaller.aaa] 14:11:58 oreste has changed the topic to: LLD XG telecon 2010-07-08 (oreste) 14:12:26 +Jonathan_Rees 14:12:45 +??P37 14:12:54 zakim, who is here? 14:12:55 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), [IPcaller.a], michaelp, Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], kai, Felix (muted), ??P26, fumi (muted), [IPcaller.aaaa], +1.330.289.aaee, 14:12:59 ... [LC], michaelp.a, emma (muted), Jonathan_Rees, ??P37 14:13:00 On IRC I see kcoyle, jar, amy, Monica, marcia, rsinger, digikim, fumi, ray, dlukose, oreste, GordonD, michaelp, RRSAgent, stu, AlexanderH, Zakim, fsasaki, antoine, jeff_, Nico, 14:13:02 ... emma, kai, edsu, ww 14:13:03 +??P38 14:13:07 zakim, ??P37 is me 14:13:07 +GordonD; got it 14:13:08 amy has left #lld 14:13:21 zakim, ??P26 is me 14:13:21 +antoine; got it 14:14:53 zakim, ???p26 is kcoyle 14:14:56 sorry, kcoyle, I do not recognize a party named '???p26' 14:15:03 topic: Minutes of previous telecon 14:15:11 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-lld/2010Jun/0131.html 14:15:29 Antoine: any objection to the minutes of last call? 14:15:37 RESOLUTION: approved minutes from last call 14:15:46 topic: F2F meeting @Pittsburgh 23 and 24 October 14:15:53 http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/F2F 14:16:02 zakim, who is here? 14:16:02 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), [IPcaller.a], michaelp, Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], kai, Felix (muted), antoine, fumi (muted), [IPcaller.aaaa], +1.330.289.aaee, 14:16:05 ... [LC], jeff_? (muted), emma (muted), Jonathan_Rees, GordonD, ??P38 14:16:06 On IRC I see kcoyle, jar, Monica, marcia, rsinger, digikim, fumi, ray, dlukose, oreste, GordonD, michaelp, RRSAgent, stu, AlexanderH, Zakim, fsasaki, antoine, jeff_, Nico, emma, 14:16:09 ... kai, edsu, ww 14:16:11 Antoine: have this item to keep you informed, but nothing to report here 14:16:17 topic: Summer teleconferences schedule 14:16:25 Antoine: see agenda, as a reminder 14:16:36 zakim, ??P38 is probably me 14:16:36 +GordonD?; got it 14:16:50 topic: community wiki 14:16:56 http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/wiki/LLD 14:17:22 antoine: idea of wiki is different from our group wiki 14:17:34 .. a free space for any public contriubtion to the library linked data topic 14:17:43 .. may also be completely outside the scope of the group 14:18:03 .. meant as a means to invite people from outside the group to contribute 14:18:07 .. any questions? 14:18:27 .. there are two wikis: the group wiki, and the group wiki 14:18:43 XYZ: could we have a link between the two wikis, explaining their relation? 14:18:56 +1 cross-links 14:18:57 antoine: yes 14:18:59 +1 14:19:13 -GordonD 14:19:16 antoine: to check cross linking between the two wikis 14:19:23 (stu was asking for links between the two wikis with a brief explanation) 14:19:23 action: antoine to check cross linking between the two wikis 14:19:48 topic: Use cases and case studies 14:20:01 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-lld/2010Jun/0032.html 14:20:24 antoine: based on the template from the provenancy XG 14:20:28 + +44.194.346.aaff 14:20:33 +??P40 14:20:48 \me .aaff is me 14:20:55 .. stu and others had an action to produce that template 14:21:05 .. has been progress on that action 14:21:11 ACTION: Stu takes the lead on understanding UC approach better (with help of Emmanuelle Jodi Bernard and Jeff) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/06/24-lld-minutes.html#action05] 14:21:28 \me Zakim mute me 14:21:33 s/to produce that template/to work on the template/ 14:21:34 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Dimensions 14:22:32 stu: the assignment was not because of my conclusion of how to do use cases 14:22:43 .. templates from the provenance gropu were quite useful 14:22:56 .. also had other input on how to make the template 14:23:13 .. this I think is a pretty good start of how to do that 14:24:53 discussion of use case template 14:25:14 antoine: about the dimensions (categories) in here: I see some very general dimensions here 14:25:27 .. might be dangerous if we go too much into details 14:25:40 .. we should not take too much time to work on the template 14:26:41 stu: I will send a link to the group with my proposal, people can look at it and see what they think about it 14:26:43 antoine: sure 14:26:51 .. every material is welcome to discuss 14:27:12 .. but we need to move that forward, we need to finalize something 14:27:38 .. looking at your proposal, there was an overlap with the work from kai 14:29:00 kai: looked at the dimensions, I now probably would start with them 14:29:19 Nico has joined #lld 14:29:22 (I just commented that it is quite complementary, we can try to use the dimensions with Kai's template as is) 14:29:32 +1 do a few use cases to test out UC and dimensions 14:29:38 kai +1 ... 14:29:46 +1 14:29:50 +1 14:29:53 +1 14:29:58 important thing is for people to create use cases 14:30:00 edsu: question about the dimensions 14:30:12 .. I thought the dimensions were used to analyse the use cases which came in 14:30:29 .. but it looks like it is something wider .. could someone clarify? 14:31:01 antoine: I think that the dimensions are a guide for the use case provider to structure the UC 14:31:06 q+ 14:31:21 ack k 14:31:34 kai: maybe we should find some not so specific dimensions and just refine them 14:32:05 I think the dimensions are to stimulate, NOT limit, people's thinking on use cases 14:32:17 +1 14:32:17 kai: it is ok to start with a broad set 14:32:20 +1 14:33:13 stu: I see that if we try to figure out the dimensions in detail, that may foster specific kinds of answer from the provider 14:33:28 + +34.92.38.aagg 14:33:30 antoine: agree 14:33:41 +1 14:33:52 etsu: we don't want to prevent people from providing use cases just because the UC does not fit into the template 14:34:00 +1 for broad set of examples 14:34:33 .aagg is me 14:34:33 s/examples/dimension examples/ 14:34:55 antoine: we should start to merge the templates, within one week, and start internal contributions 14:35:08 .. e.g. Alexander filling that template 14:35:29 .. for the next call we could make a final decision about the form of the template, and then send them to the wider community 14:35:35 .. is that OK? 14:35:35 +1 14:35:36 +1 14:35:38 +1 14:35:41 +1 14:35:43 +1 14:35:43 +1 14:35:43 +1 14:35:44 +1 14:35:49 +1 14:36:22 +1 14:36:34 +1 14:36:35 RESOLUTION: merge the template proposal within one week, start internal contributions, make a final decision about the form of the template until next call, and then send them to the wider community 14:36:43 +1 (but I have a conflicting meeting, I will send comments) 14:36:44 +1 14:36:49 +1 14:37:25 kai: would be good to have a 2nd example. The 1st concentrated on VIAF 14:37:33 antoine: good idea 14:37:43 s/kai/alexander/ 14:37:57 kai: sure, maybe some other people can help as well? 14:38:06 emma: happy to contribute another example 14:38:07 i think folks at LC could probaby agree on populating one 14:38:37 +1 14:38:48 Zakim, +34.92.38.aagg is me 14:38:48 +Nico; got it 14:38:50 -emma 14:39:07 action: Alexander and the whole group people on the group to populate the template for use cases 14:39:22 kai: emma, alexander and I can make a small subgroup to work out examples 14:39:25 antoine: good point 14:39:52 kai: happy to do that 14:40:02 +[IPcaller.aaa] 14:40:05 s/good point/good idea, so let's do that/ 14:40:26 s/Alexander and the whole group people on the group to populate the template for use cases/Alexander, kai, emma group people on the group to populate the template for use cases/ 14:40:33 ACTION: Alexander to populate the template for VIAF UC http://outgoing.typepad.com/outgoing/2009/09/viaf-as-linked-data.html [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/06/24-lld-minutes.html#action06] 14:40:40 antoine: and we drop the action from last call, which was for alexander only 14:40:45 --DROPPED 14:41:12 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/07/08-lld-minutes.html emma 14:42:51 OK for me 14:42:55 action: stu, alexander, kai and emma to suggest another version of the template? 14:42:56 ok for me 14:43:07 trackbot has joined #lld 14:43:07 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 14:43:07 If you want to associate this channel with an existing Tracker, please say 'trackbot, associate this channel with #channel' (where #channel is the name of default channel for the group) 14:43:09 ACTION: stu, alexander, kai and emma to suggest another version of the template 14:43:09 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 14:43:14 s/?/. 14:43:44 I'm logging. I don't understand 'drop ACTION 3', fsasaki. Try /msg RRSAgent help 14:44:51 zakim, who is making noise? 14:45:03 kai, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: antoine (25%), Jonathan_Rees (11%) 14:45:17 zakim, mute me 14:45:17 sorry, jar, I do not know which phone connection belongs to you 14:45:20 topic: Use cases at ALA meeting 14:45:30 zakim, mute Jonathan_Rees 14:45:30 Jonathan_Rees should now be muted 14:45:36 antoine: keep that in our agenda, will discuss that during next call 14:46:21 zakim, who is noisy 14:46:21 I don't understand 'who is noisy', antoine 14:46:27 zakim, zho is noisy? 14:46:27 sorry, antoine, I do not understand your question 14:46:50 topic: Topic list 14:47:07 ACTION: ALL: Edit the topics for our work at the wiki: http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Topics [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/06/03-lld-minutes.html#action02] 14:47:07 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 14:47:13 --CONTINUES 14:47:20 antoine: action for everbody to contribute to the wiki is being continued 14:48:23 abc: Antoine did a first pass and did a good job 14:48:29 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Topics2 14:48:36 s/abc/Karen/ 14:48:44 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Topics3 14:48:46 Karen's list: http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Topics3 14:48:58 karen: topic list is in a way very suggestive 14:49:09 karen+1 for provoking discussions 14:49:18 .. idea was to have a set of categories which people can think about 14:49:31 .. not sure how to do this, we may want to do this in mail 14:49:43 .. if everybody starts editing that may be a bit messy 14:49:57 .. we should first decide what our main topic areas are, and how to assign them 14:51:09 .. there were many issues that may be hard to understand, e.g. how to manage linked data, how to apply linked data to the library world 14:51:18 kcoyle++ # i like these high level groups 14:51:21 .. and how to educate our community 14:51:29 kcoyle, this (topic3) is really good work, thanks 14:51:39 .. there is the best place to make a discussion 14:51:54 s/there/where 14:52:01 +1, Topic3 is really good 14:52:17 karen: we need to agree on upper level categories first, after that people can add what they want 14:52:37 s/first/first (before having everybody editing)/ 14:52:49 antoine: so let's first have a discussion on the mailing list 14:53:21 .. I am not touching the existing version, but we should dicuss the organization 14:53:32 would it be helpful to assign an editor for this part of the Wiki who might consolidate the suggestions? 14:53:37 antoine: both mail and other discussion is fine, we just need to do it 14:53:43 karen: both fine with me 14:54:02 edsu: what is the reason to write this document? 14:54:19 karen: to have use cases, and guide the educational document which we are going to write 14:54:50 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/07/08-lld-minutes.html fsasaki 14:56:30 antoine: from a practical point of view, we have seen this as a set of guidelines for the technical deliverable which we are going to produce 14:57:42 edsu: looks very good to me 14:57:48 antoine: yes 14:58:35 stu: if somebody could mangage the structure, people could send suggestions to that person 14:58:51 -emma 14:58:51 i wonder if it's worth publishing it as a w3c draft? 14:59:03 karen: happy to do that 14:59:28 +[IPcaller.aaa] 14:59:37 edsu: is it OK to write this up to become a W3C document, e.g. a NOTE 14:59:47 antoine: for the moment we can keep it as wiki 15:00:09 .. as soon as we are starting putting content into it, we can move gently to another workspace 15:00:28 karen: many items were very concise 15:00:42 where is the appropriate place to expand on the topics? 15:00:46 .. would be good if these items would be extended 15:01:34 antoine: should we have an "action: everyone to elaborate on the topics in the wiki"? 15:01:44 karen: which document should they edit? 15:01:50 antoine: just send mails? 15:02:06 karen: people can edit what they are responsible for, and I can ask questions 15:02:31 antoine: if you are the official responsible person for the wiki page, you can organize that as you want 15:02:42 topic: wrap up (action review) 15:02:57 action: everyone to elaborate on topics in the wiki 15:02:57 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 15:03:23 RESOLUTION: karen to be the editor of the topic list 15:03:43 s/action review/action and resolution/ 15:03:50 ACTION: ALL: Edit the topics for our work at the wiki: http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Topics [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/06/03-lld-minutes.html#action02] 15:03:50 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 15:03:53 --DROPPED 15:04:05 ACTION: Antoine to ask Karen Coyle to start curating topics list. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/06/24-lld-minutes.html#action08] 15:04:05 Sorry... I don't know anything about this channel 15:04:08 --DONE 15:04:21 should topics3 become topics? 15:04:32 topic: Other topics 15:04:55 antoine: just links to areas which are not so active at the moment 15:05:39 zakim, who is here? 15:05:39 On the phone I see [IPcaller], edsu, rsinger (muted), [IPcaller.a], michaelp (muted), Oreste, [IPcaller.aa], kai, Felix (muted), antoine, fumi (muted), [IPcaller.aaaa], 15:05:42 ... +1.330.289.aaee, [LC], jeff_? (muted), Jonathan_Rees (muted), GordonD?, +44.194.346.aaff (muted), GordonD, Nico, emma 15:05:43 stu was on the call 15:05:46 On IRC I see trackbot, Nico, kcoyle, jar, Monica, marcia, rsinger, digikim, fumi, ray, dlukose, oreste, michaelp, RRSAgent, stu, AlexanderH, Zakim, fsasaki, antoine, jeff_, emma, 15:05:48 kcoyle on call 15:05:48 ... kai, edsu, ww 15:05:55 Michael Panzer was on the call. 15:05:56 antoine 15:06:03 jeff_ 15:06:04 present+ michaelP 15:06:09 Jonathan Rees was on the call, as zakim says 15:06:11 marcia is on the call 15:06:12 rsinger 15:06:16 emmanuelle was on the call 15:06:21 s'up y'all 15:06:30 topic: wrap up 15:06:31 Nico was on the call 15:06:32 kim was on the call 15:06:40 fumi was 15:06:44 -[IPcaller] 15:06:45 Monica was on teh call 15:06:47 ray here 15:06:47 Alexander was on the coll 15:06:47 I volunteer to clean up whatever mess I created by inviting trackbot 15:06:49 -GordonD? 15:06:50 bye 15:06:51 - +1.330.289.aaee 15:06:52 -jeff_? 15:06:52 -michaelp 15:06:53 -edsu 15:06:55 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/07/08-lld-minutes.html fsasaki 15:06:56 bye 15:06:59 -[IPcaller.aa] 15:07:05 -Oreste 15:07:09 -fumi 15:07:09 jeff_ has left #lld 15:07:10 stu has left #lld 15:07:11 -Nico 15:07:13 - +44.194.346.aaff 15:07:13 bye 15:07:17 -[LC] 15:07:19 -Felix 15:07:20 digikim has left #lld 15:07:20 zakim, unmute Jonathan_Rees 15:07:23 -kai 15:07:25 -[IPcaller.aaaa] 15:07:29 -rsinger 15:07:31 Jonathan_Rees should no longer be muted 15:07:34 -[IPcaller.a] 15:07:46 -GordonD 15:08:30 trackbot, bye 15:08:30 trackbot has left #lld 15:08:36 oreste has left #lld 15:10:17 michaelp has left #lld 15:10:55 -Jonathan_Rees 15:12:34 Nico has left #lld 15:15:42 -antoine 15:15:43 -emma 15:15:43 INC_LLDXG()10:00AM has ended 15:15:45 Attendees were [IPcaller], edsu, +1.423.463.aaaa, +1.330.289.aabb, Oreste, michaelp, rsinger, Felix, +81.35.937.aadd, fumi, kai, +1.330.289.aaee, [LC], emma, Jonathan_Rees, 15:15:48 ... antoine, jeff_?, GordonD?, +44.194.346.aaff, GordonD, Nico 15:18:25 Nico has joined #lld 15:18:31 Nico has left #lld 17:27:23 Zakim has left #lld