16:58:51 RRSAgent has joined #html-wg 16:58:51 logging to http://www.w3.org/2009/12/03-html-wg-irc 16:58:53 RRSAgent, make logs public 16:58:53 Zakim has joined #html-wg 16:58:55 Zakim, this will be HTML 16:58:55 ok, trackbot, I see HTML_WG()12:00PM already started 16:58:56 Meeting: HTML Weekly Teleconference 16:58:56 Date: 03 December 2009 16:59:03 zakim, mute dsinger 16:59:03 dsinger should now be muted 16:59:12 +Gregory_Rosmaita 16:59:20 zakim, mute cardona507 16:59:20 sorry, cardona507, I do not know which phone connection belongs to cardona507 16:59:26 janina has joined #html-wg 16:59:36 - +1.831.454.aaaa 16:59:48 zakim, who is here? 16:59:48 On the phone I see dsinger (muted), Rich, Gregory_Rosmaita 16:59:50 rubys1 has joined #html-wg 16:59:50 On IRC I see janina, Zakim, RRSAgent, richardschwerdtfe, dsinger_, Stevef, MichaelC, cardona507, myakura, mjs, Laura, LeifHS, oedipus, aroben, miketaylr, kliehm, MikeSmith, gavin, 16:59:53 zakim, call janina 16:59:54 ... tlr, tH, JoePeck, ROBOd, trackbot, Julian, karl, dsinger, krijnh, shepazu, anne, Yudai, gavin_, hsivonen, Dashiva, jmb, inimino, syp, pimpbot, hober, jgraham, matt, Hixie, 16:59:56 ... gsnedders, Philip, CIA-1, ed_work, xover 16:59:57 ok, janina; the call is being made 16:59:57 +Janina 17:00:01 +Sam 17:00:39 weinig has joined #html-wg 17:00:40 Zakim, call Mike-Mobile 17:00:40 ok, MikeSmith; the call is being made 17:00:41 +Mike 17:00:48 +[IPcaller] 17:00:52 + +1.831.454.aabb 17:01:10 zakim, +1.831.454.aabb is me 17:01:10 +cardona507; got it 17:01:11 zakim, [IPcaller] is me 17:01:11 +Stevef; got it 17:01:12 + +1.617.324.aacc 17:01:14 +kliehm 17:01:17 zakim, mute me 17:01:17 cardona507 should now be muted 17:01:22 zakim, aacc is Michael_Cooper 17:01:22 +Michael_Cooper; got it 17:02:22 + +49.251.280.aadd 17:02:53 Zakim, +49.251.280.aadd is me 17:02:53 +Julian; got it 17:03:10 +[Microsoft] 17:03:17 +Matt_May 17:04:17 + +1.415.595.aaee 17:04:21 -[Microsoft] 17:04:31 Zakim, +1.415.595.aaee is me 17:04:31 +mjs; got it 17:04:39 + +1.715.718.aaff 17:05:12 ny volunteers to scribe? 17:05:36 - +1.715.718.aaff 17:05:37 zakim, pick a script 17:05:38 I don't understand 'pick a script', rubys1 17:05:43 Zakim, choose victim 17:05:43 I don't understand 'choose victim', mjs 17:05:46 zakim, pick a scribe 17:05:46 Not knowing who is chairing or who scribed recently, I propose Michael_Cooper 17:05:49 zakim, victim? 17:05:49 I don't understand your question, oedipus. 17:06:18 scribe: MichaelC 17:06:38 trackbot, start meeting 17:06:40 RRSAgent, make logs public 17:06:42 Zakim, this will be HTML 17:06:42 ok, trackbot, I see HTML_WG()12:00PM already started 17:06:43 Meeting: HTML Weekly Teleconference 17:06:43 Date: 03 December 2009 17:06:44
  • li has joined #html-wg 17:07:14 zakim, unmute dsinger 17:07:14 dsinger should no longer be muted 17:07:18 agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html-wg-announce/2009OctDec/0019.html 17:07:19 Title: {agenda} HTML WG telcon 2009-12-3: issues, action items, calls for consensus/proposals, task force reports from Maciej Stachowiak on 2009-12-02 (public-html-wg-announce@w3.org from October to December 2009) (at lists.w3.org) 17:07:44 chair: Maciej_Stachowiak 17:07:59 zakim, mute dsinger 17:07:59 dsinger should now be muted 17:07:59 trackbot: close ACTION-130 17:08:00 ACTION-130 Review status of video codec positions closed 17:08:11 topic: Review of due and overdue action items 17:08:13 + +1.715.718.aagg 17:08:33 ACTION-130 done 17:09:25 img Element Change Proposal 17:09:27 http://esw.w3.org/topic/HTML/ChangeProposals/ImgElement20091203 17:09:27 ACTION-131: Change proposal sent http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html/2009Dec/0101.html 17:09:27 ACTION-131 Draft ALT spec notes added 17:09:28 Title: HTML/ChangeProposals/ImgElement20091203 - ESW Wiki (at esw.w3.org) 17:09:29 Title: change proposal:modification to section 4.8.2.1 the img element from Steven Faulkner on 2009-12-03 (public-html@w3.org from December 2009) (at lists.w3.org) 17:09:33
  • li has joined #html-wg 17:09:56 CGI163 has joined #html-wg 17:09:58 Lachy has joined #html-wg 17:10:02 sf: 17:10:10 trackbot: close ACTION-131 17:10:10 ACTION-131 Draft ALT spec closed 17:10:11 ms: can close action now that proposal posted 17:10:43 gavin has joined #html-wg 17:10:56 ACTION-138 still ongoing 17:11:07 +li 17:11:11 sf: Discussed matrix in A11Y TF just before this call 17:11:21 Zakim, aagg is me 17:11:22 +Laura; got it 17:11:33 +[Microsoft] 17:11:38 actively working on in TF 17:11:49 ms: timeline to completion? 17:11:58 sf: Today was first discussion in TF, not sure of timeline 17:12:14 perhaps 1 month? should coordinate with A11Y TF facilitators 17:12:16 http://www.w3.org/2009/12/03-html-a11y-minutes.html 17:12:17 Title: HTML Accessibility Task Force Teleconference -- 03 Dec 2009 (at www.w3.org) 17:12:50 MikeS: Planning to discuss over next week in A11Y TF 17:12:51 kliehm has joined #html-wg 17:13:04 could give an update next week, though it probably won't be complete then 17:13:23 Maciej: this has bumped week to week for months, would prefer to have a single deadline 17:13:47 Gregory: Task force just starting... 17:14:18 Janina: Early-mid January is earliest feasible time 17:14:34 MikeS: January 14 2010 17:15:03 SteveF: much work already done, some ready for review now 17:15:40 Maciej: helpful to post what you have as soon as possible 17:15:50 know some issues in play that good to discuss 17:16:06 updating due date of action 17:16:44 ACTION-158 not complete yet 17:17:04 SteveF: action from TPAC, haven't gotten to yet 17:17:31 need extra time to work on some things, and also want to bring to A11Y TF 17:17:41 +Masinter 17:17:56 Maciej: deadline? 17:18:06 SteveF: 31 December 2010 17:18:07 masinter has joined #html-wg 17:18:23 topic: Review of submitted change proposals 17:18:42 oedipus has joined #html-wg 17:19:13 mhakkinen has joined #html-wg 17:19:22 richardschwerdtfe has joined #html-wg 17:19:33 i have a question 17:19:38 ==ISSUE-4 (html-versioning)== 17:19:41 I am on mute so I will type 17:20:01 i am kind of unlclear - is stll ok? 17:20:09 yes 17:20:15 and recommended in most situations 17:20:19 thanks larry 17:20:23 +[Apple] 17:20:31 zakim, [apple] has dsinger 17:20:31 +dsinger; got it 17:20:36 Maciej: change proposal makes versioning optional but not mandatory, so yes to above question 17:20:37 -dsinger 17:20:55 ==ISSUE-30 (longdesc)== 17:21:19 Maciej: Charles submitted a change proposal a while back 17:21:30 makes longdesc nonconforming but optional 17:21:38 ==ISSUE-32 (table-summary)== 17:21:51 Maciej: Cynthia posted a proposal with a number of changes 17:22:00 chairs have given structural feedback, expect revision soon 17:22:18 ==ISSUE-56 (urls-webarch)== 17:22:44 Maciej: Proposal to change normative references 17:22:50 some discussion has taken place 17:23:40 speaker1: Suggest people join IRI mailing list to help resolve some of the issues 17:23:49 ==ISSUE-76 (Microdata/RDFa)== 17:23:53 s/speaker1/Larry/ 17:24:22 Maciej: Proposal was to publish separate draft 17:24:33 now there's a propsal to retain within HTML 17:24:39 there's been discussion on the mailing list 17:24:41 my phone is dying - will rejoin soon 17:24:45 -Gregory_Rosmaita 17:24:47 q+ 17:25:09 speaker2: Was proposal to move to separate draft, or just remove altogether? 17:25:30 Maciej: Proposal was to move to external document but not remove altogether 17:25:37 ==ISSUE-83 (dt-dd-semantics)== 17:26:07 Maciej: Proposal to not use dt/dd for
    17:26:17 proposed a new element in place 17:26:23 chairs have sent structural feedback 17:26:40 http://dev.w3.org/html5/status/issue-status.html 17:26:41 Title: Change Proposal Status (at dev.w3.org) 17:27:15 Maciej: above link shows status is change proposals in play 17:27:24 probably won't go through individually each week 17:27:32 just new ones going forward 17:27:46 q- 17:27:47 speaker3: What are next steps? 17:28:05 s/speaker3/Julian/ 17:28:27 Maciej: chairs to review level of consensus and strength of arguments 17:28:45 help decide which ones to advance 17:29:01 Julian: What is a change proposal that proposes not doing anything? 17:29:27 Maciej: Originated with ones in response to editor action on a bug entry 17:30:01 Julian: Would there be counter-proposals for each proposal? 17:30:18 Maciej: We might expect this 17:30:30 s/Julian/Larry/ (in the last two lines) 17:30:49 Larry: Is this part of the documented decision process 17:30:58 s/Julian: Would/Larry: Would/ 17:31:07 s/Julian: What/Larry: What/ 17:31:27 -Mike 17:31:35 Zakim, call Mike-Mobile 17:31:35 ok, MikeSmith; the call is being made 17:31:37 +Mike 17:31:46 Maciej: , but let's take questions offline 17:32:10 topic: Review of Chair calls for consensus / proposals 17:32:25 ==ISSUE-7 (video-codecs)== 17:32:44 If we don't receive change proposal by today (3 Dec) will close issue without prejudice 17:33:17 speaker4: There was a proposal to move video element to a separate document 17:33:28 Maciej: haven't yet received a formal change proposal on that 17:33:38 people can submit if they want, by end of today 17:33:42 Change Proposal Template: http://esw.w3.org/topic/HTML/ChangeProposalTemplate 17:33:43 Title: HTML/ChangeProposalTemplate - ESW Wiki (at esw.w3.org) 17:34:12 speaker4: thought that would be a way to resolve the codec issue on a different schedule from the rest of HTML 17:34:32 ==ISSUE-63 (origin-req-scope)== 17:34:51 Maciej: due today 3 Dec, will close without prejudice if no change proposal received 17:35:02 ==ISSUE-76 (Microdata/RDFa) counter-proposals== 17:35:13 maciej: received one counter-proposal yesterday 17:35:28 ==ISSUE-1 (PINGPOST)== 17:35:39 Maciej: Need change proposals by 17 Dec 17:35:55 ==ISSUE-2 (PINGUI)== 17:35:57 Maciej: Need change proposals by 17 Dec 17:36:05 ==ISSUE-27 (rel-ownership)== 17:36:10 Maciej: Need change proposals by 17 Dec 17:36:17 frankolivier has joined #html-wg 17:36:18 Paul Cotton has volunteered to submit one 17:36:30 ==ISSUE-87 (attr-normalization)== 17:36:34 Maciej: Need change proposals by 17 Dec 17:36:44 ==ISSUE-88 (content-language-multiple)== 17:37:04 Maciej: Leif Halvard Silli has volunteered to submit a proposal by 17 Jan 2010 17:37:15 that's more than a month but the holidays intervene 17:37:33 If you care about the issues above, please take action by the deadlines 17:37:46 speaker4: Clarify closed without prejudice? 17:38:03 s/speaker4: Clarify/Larry: Clarify/ 17:38:05 Maciej: Will close in Tracker, and won't consider the issue a blocker for advancement to LC 17:38:25 if a proposal later comes in, it can be considered 17:39:02 we need a clear proposal and rationale 17:39:10 chairs will not try to dig up old discussions 17:39:16 topic: New issues this week 17:39:21 Maciej: none we know of 17:39:30 topic: Status of task forces 17:39:49 ==HTML Accessibility Task Force== 17:40:03 Janina: First teleconference was today 17:40:08 started out mostly procedural 17:40:16 then started scoping issues to review first 17:40:25 taking ARIA integration / mapping issues first 17:40:35 (relates to Steve's action discussed earlier) 17:40:45 taking 24 and 31 Dec 2009 meetings off 17:40:51 mailing list is active on a few issues 17:40:57 video sub-group is forming 17:41:22 issues and possible solutions were covered in a pre-meeting before TPAC 17:41:37 q+ 17:41:39 ==Testing Task Force== 17:41:53 Chris: Mailing list active 17:42:00 starting a teleconference slot 17:42:16 q+ to ask about timezone and date of meeting? 17:42:35 planning to come back in early Jan with some preliminary activity 17:42:41 meeting is 8am next week 17:43:05 17:43:08 q- 17:43:13 regrets next week -- during TAG meeting 17:43:19 topic: Scribe for next week 17:43:27 17:43:42 topic: Other business 17:43:51 http://www.w3.org/html/wg/tracker/issues/80 17:43:52 Title: ISSUE-80 - HTML Weekly Tracker (at www.w3.org) 17:44:08 Steve: how do we hold issues open that are being actively open? 17:44:29 Maciej: when a change proposal comes in, move issue and associated issues to open status 17:44:39 HTML Testing Task Force Conf Call -> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html-testsuite/2009Dec/0001.html 17:44:41 Title: RE: Testing Task Force Conf Call from Kris Krueger on 2009-12-03 (public-html-testsuite@w3.org from December 2009) (at lists.w3.org) 17:44:51 s/Chris:/Kris:/ 17:45:10 -Janina 17:45:11 -mjs 17:45:11 -Mike 17:45:12 bye 17:45:12 -li 17:45:12 -[Apple] 17:45:13 -Julian 17:45:13 -Matt_May 17:45:16 -Michael_Cooper 17:45:20 -Masinter 17:45:23 -cardona507 17:45:28 -Sam 17:45:32 -Stevef 17:45:34 -kliehm 17:45:35 -[Microsoft] 17:45:37 -Laura 17:45:47 -Rich 17:45:49 HTML_WG()12:00PM has ended 17:45:51 Attendees were +1.831.454.aaaa, dsinger, Rich, Gregory_Rosmaita, Janina, Sam, Mike, cardona507, Stevef, +1.617.324.aacc, kliehm, Michael_Cooper, Julian, [Microsoft], Matt_May, mjs, 17:45:53 ... +1.715.718.aaff, +1.715.718.aagg, li, Laura, Masinter 17:46:06 rrsagent, make minutes 17:46:06 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2009/12/03-html-wg-minutes.html MichaelC 18:07:55 mjs: http://www.w3.org/html/wg/wiki/Main_Page 18:07:56 Title: Main Page - HTML WG Wiki (at www.w3.org) 18:08:21 MikeSmith: woot! 18:08:44 MikeSmith: do you know if MediaWiki supports templates like we had on the ESW wiki? 18:08:56 yeah, it does 18:09:00 though I not sure how to do it 18:10:01 btw, I *think* the edit perms are automatically tied by LDAP to the actual W3C database 18:10:15 such that only members of the HTML WG can edit pages there 18:11:54 "W3C Accounts" means the login we use for pages on w3.org behind http auth? 18:12:08 hober: yep 18:12:23 same username and password 18:12:27 I believe 18:12:35 hober: btw, great posting 18:12:38 on your blog 18:12:42 the most recent one 18:12:50 hmmm. going to http://www.w3.org/html/wg/wiki/ doesn't work. 18:12:51 oh, thanks. 18:13:06 it was languishing in my drafts folder for a long time, mostly-done 18:14:27 I don't know if you saw, but I added your blog to the Planet HTML5 aggregation a while back 18:14:45 yeah, I don't know why http://www.w3.org/html/wg/wiki doesn't work 18:15:16 but I think I can just add a redirect myself to make it redirect to the main page 18:15:59 plh has joined #html-wg 18:25:52 myakura: http://www.w3.org/html/ig/jp/wiki/ 18:25:53 Title: Main Page - HTML5 JP IG (at www.w3.org) 18:25:57 for JPIG5 18:26:15 that one is currently editable by anybody with a W3C account 18:26:33 JPIG seems like a name asking for puns 18:26:47 yeah, that's why I like it 18:26:57 we need a pig character as a mascot 18:27:08 And it should be a .jpg 18:27:25 true that too 18:27:50 we can make a pig the circled 5 symbol 18:28:02 *pig with the 18:28:10 Like a branding mark 18:28:26 yeah, branded pig 18:28:40 MikeSmith: speaking of planet html5, I could provide you a feed of just my posts tagged html5 if you'd like 18:28:42 smoking a peace pipe 18:29:58 hober: that would be good, though maybe not worth the trouble if you've not set it up already. Because I have a filter that just causes any posts that don't have the string HTML5 or "HTML 5" in them to just be ignored 18:30:41 ahh. ok then 18:31:28 MikeSmith: goody! thanks a lot! 18:33:07 日本語でどうぞ 18:33:13 :) 18:33:31 I've not tried adding content in Japanese to any of our MediaWiki instances 18:33:43 but I assume there should be no problems 18:35:26 myakura: btw, thanks seriously a lot for doing the interpreter stuff today 18:35:36 I hope it didn't put you on the spot 18:35:48 but you rock mightily at thinking on your feett 18:35:50 feet 18:35:54 drunknbass_work has joined #html-wg 18:36:26 does the jpig5 folks need an irc channel btw? 18:36:43 plh: we did not decide on one yet 18:37:32 btw, selectors api is an other draft for your list I think 18:37:34 myakura: sorry about dropping "full duplex" without a heads-up.. but I don't think most people have any idea what it means in English anyway 18:37:42 the webapps are trying to move it to CR 18:37:43 MikeSmith: my pleasure. to me it was quite interesting talk. 18:37:44 plh: yeah, good point 18:38:09 myakura: I think I should just say "fully bidirectional network communication" 18:38:13 or something 18:38:14 isntead 18:38:32 plh: understood 18:39:01 so it would be a good time to get the JPIG a heads-up about it too 18:39:09 and see what feedback we might collect 18:39:40 myakura: maybe a message about Selectors API to the list? 18:40:28 or wait until the cr is published? 18:40:38 drunknbass_work has joined #html-wg 18:40:42 or we could do that, yeah 18:40:46 current draft is one year old. 18:41:01 holy mackerel 18:41:09 didn't realize it'd be that long 18:41:41 "W3C Working Draft 14 November 2008" wow. 18:42:03 blast from the past 18:42:36 you need to remove the dust before starting reading it :) 18:43:34 though the new version won't have significant changes in it 18:43:51 only 2 editorial updates in fact 18:45:20 so it is in a state of near-perfection 18:45:39 indeed 18:45:48 OK, http://www.w3.org/html/wg/wiki/ now redirects properly as well 18:45:49 Title: Main Page - HTML WG Wiki (at www.w3.org) 18:46:15 think I did the translation (a year ago), so jpig5 folks could read it in detail. 18:46:35 that would be good 18:52:25 planet: Take Five with HTML5: Device Orientation & Geolocation on the Nokia N900 <11http://missmobile.wordpress.com/2009/12/03/take-five-with-html5-device-orientation-geolocation-on-the-nokia-n900/> 4** How to add mime-type for