ACTION-1: Thomas Roessler to re-run tests with revised schema
ACTION-2: Thomas Roessler to Update XML Signature errata to reflect RFC version's reference changes, based on input from Don Eastlake
ACTION-3: Thomas Roessler to RNG Schema: Check on status with customer.
ACTION-4: Frederick Hirsch to Arrange joint F2F meetings
ACTION-5: Frederick Hirsch to Check how the formal OASIS liasion is working.
ACTION-6: Sean Mullan to Investigate ebxml liasion
ACTION-7: Bruce Rich to Informally liase with WS-Fed
ACTION-8: Thomas Roessler to Read this action's number
ACTION-9: Thomas Roessler to Fix Tracker
ACTION-10: Frederick Hirsch to Update wg page to include issues link
ACTION-11: Frederick Hirsch to Ask for XPath 2.0 presentation to group
ACTION-12: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Review archive from maint. group to revisit type issue
ACTION-13: Konrad Lanz to Review streaming using 2nd edition Signature
ACTION-14: Frederick Hirsch to Ask about namespaces/undeclarations in xml coordination group
ACTION-15: Brian LaMacchia to Provide proposal on xmlsec namespace approach to identify elements to be processed
ACTION-16: Konrad Lanz to Write up proposal regarding use of transform that has parameter for passing xml model
ACTION-17: to test from vivien (please disregard)
ACTION-18: Thomas Roessler to test
ACTION-19: Gerald Edgar to Evaluate Issues and Actions for appropriate placement
ACTION-20: Frederick Hirsch to Draft message about XPath 2 presentation to mailing list
ACTION-21: Kelvin Yiu to Propose ways to reduce dependencies on XML specs
ACTION-22: Ed Simon to Review EXI docs that were published
ACTION-23: Frederick Hirsch to Contact EXI re signature/verification use cases
ACTION-24: Scott Cantor to Review schema for improvements
ACTION-25: Frederick Hirsch to Give feedback on xml schema best practice in xml-cg
ACTION-26: Frederick Hirsch to Define products in tracker and associate with actions/issues
ACTION-27: Robert Miller to contact crypto hardware and suiteB experts in NSA regarding XML Security WG and possible involvement
ACTION-28: Thomas Roessler to update OASIS liaison information recorded at W3C: http://www.w3.org/2001/11/StdLiaison#OASIS
ACTION-29: Gerald Edgar to test Issues entry and list generation
ACTION-30: Shivaram Mysore to Update xmlsec public page to include top information like original xml security public pages
ACTION-31: Thomas Roessler to Investigate ebXML liaison (see ACTION-6)
ACTION-32: Kelvin Yiu to Document requirements and assumptions in simple signing strawman
ACTION-33: Frederick Hirsch to Do something
ACTION-34: Thomas Roessler to Set up questionnaire for next meeting
ACTION-35: Frederick Hirsch to Contact XML Processing WG
ACTION-36: Brian LaMacchia to Take a look at NIST document
ACTION-37: Scott Cantor to Write up scenario for simple sign
ACTION-38: Brian LaMacchia to Enlist kelvin to write up scenarios he's interested in; split of classes
ACTION-39: Hal Lockhart to Contribute web service related scenario
ACTION-40: Chris Solc to Solicit and contribute long-time archival requirements
ACTION-41: Chris Solc to Solicit and contribute requirements and assumptions from workflow scenarios
ACTION-42: Thomas Roessler to Elaborate on "any document" requirement vs canonicalizing xml:base
ACTION-43: Pratik Datta to Write about constrained nodesets requirement
ACTION-44: Frederick Hirsch to Send email on ordering and layering of xml signatures
ACTION-45: Thomas Roessler to Produce template for requirements document
ACTION-46: Thomas Roessler to Arrange CVS access for Brad Hill
ACTION-47: Thomas Roessler to Add error noted in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec-maintwg/2008Jun/0021.html to c14n 1.1 errata page
ACTION-48: Thomas Roessler to Put the link for the proposed errata
ACTION-49: Bradley Hill to Edit the best practices document
ACTION-50: Pratik Datta to Draft a strawman for alternative to xpath transform
ACTION-51: Konrad Lanz to Provide proposal on list regarding transform primitives
ACTION-52: Konrad Lanz to Attempt summarizing recent discussions as input for design document
ACTION-53: Pratik Datta to Review comments from Scott and propose document change, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2008Aug/0054.html
ACTION-54: Robert Miller to Provide a presentation to the working group introducing NVDL.
ACTION-55: Bruce Rich to Check with WS-Federation regarding XML Signature 2nd edition references
ACTION-56: Scott Cantor to Propose text for KeyInfo processing in best practices. http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2008Sep/0014.html
ACTION-57: Bruce Rich to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-58: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-59: Pratik Datta to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-60: Konrad Lanz to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-61: Brian LaMacchia to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-62: Sean Mullan to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-63: Robert Miller to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-64: Chris Solc to Review best practices document from implementation standpoint
ACTION-65: Chris Solc to Document use case and semantics of byte-range signatures.
ACTION-66: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up with xsl to get documents related to serialization
ACTION-67: Sean Mullan to Edit best practices to implement Scott's and his own changes; see http://www.w3.org/2008/09/23-xmlsec-irc#T14-20-33
ACTION-68: Sean Mullan to Implement http://www.w3.org/2008/09/23-xmlsec-irc#T14-25-06, http://www.w3.org/2008/09/23-xmlsec-irc#T14-24-47
ACTION-69: Frederick Hirsch to Propose text to address concern of non-naive implementations not being vulnerable to attack
ACTION-70: Thomas Roessler to Propose disclaimer for SOTD
ACTION-71: Pratik Datta to Update examples with absolute namespace URIs and regenerate signatures
ACTION-72: Frederick Hirsch to Contribute synopsis for each best practice
ACTION-73: Magnus Nyström to Provide proposal to adapt Requirements scope
ACTION-74: Konrad Lanz to Summarize recursive retrievalmethod point
ACTION-75: Frederick Hirsch to Schedule XProc follow-up at Cannes F2F
ACTION-76: Konrad Lanz to Provide best practices reference for XAdES
ACTION-77: Sean Mullan to Update best practices document for section titles
ACTION-78: Pratik Datta to Will add the time stamp reference to the best practices
ACTION-79: Frederick Hirsch to Apply edits proposed in ISSUE-53, ISSUE-55 and ACTION-70
ACTION-80: Konrad Lanz to Propose answer to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2008Oct/0003.html
ACTION-81: Konrad Lanz to Provide draft answer to hoylen, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2008Oct/0003.html
ACTION-82: Thomas Roessler to Propose specific erratum for ISSUE-50
ACTION-83: Thomas Roessler to Prepare best practices for publication
ACTION-84: Frederick Hirsch to Edit proposed principles section, update title and document contents
ACTION-85: Chris Solc to Update the proposal on a ByteRange Transform
ACTION-86: Kelvin Yiu to Clean up proposal http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2008Oct/0032.html
ACTION-87: Thomas Roessler to Add link to comment list to public page
ACTION-88: Ed Simon to Look at the EXI use cases
ACTION-89: Thomas Roessler to Update homepage with information test suites
ACTION-90: Kelvin Yiu to Provide a draft for the requirements document of the simple signing requirements.
ACTION-91: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Provide a draft for the requirements document for long term signatures.
ACTION-92: Kelvin Yiu to Propose text for note providing an index to XML Security URIs
ACTION-93: Frederick Hirsch to Write a draft for w3c note outlining Signature transform simplification for v.next
ACTION-94: Kelvin Yiu to Provide draft note on new algorithms for 1.1
ACTION-95: Thomas Roessler to Introduce Kelvin to W3C spec editing
ACTION-96: Thomas Roessler to Send kelvin information about editing tools
ACTION-97: Pratik Datta to Add transforms requirements material to requirements draft
ACTION-98: Konrad Lanz to Draft database certificate use case and requirements for document, share on mail list
ACTION-99: Konrad Lanz to Email list with specifics on this performant implementaiton
ACTION-100: Konrad Lanz to Email proposal regarding 2 ds:References, old and new
ACTION-101: Frederick Hirsch to Provide roadmap for XML Security releases
ACTION-102: Frederick Hirsch to Check on DTDs with W3C
ACTION-103: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Provide updated email on best practices issue
ACTION-104: Robert Miller to Investigate NVDL constraints, such as ordering of schema sections
ACTION-105: Kelvin Yiu to Get in touch with RFC 4050 authors
ACTION-106: Magnus Nyström to Work the text in the proposal to the req doc
ACTION-107: Pratik Datta to Look at XSL streaming
ACTION-108: Scott Cantor to Provide Proposal re Consolidated Certificate Encoding Proposal
ACTION-109: Frederick Hirsch to Add Magnus' work to Requirements Document
ACTION-110: Magnus Nyström to Draft Proposal re Schema Defaults and Best Practices
ACTION-111: Frederick Hirsch to Add default attribute language to Best Practices doc
ACTION-112: Brian LaMacchia to Draft text on DSA issues for 1.1
ACTION-113: Thomas Roessler to Suggest text re versioning and namespaces for XML Signature
ACTION-114: Scott Cantor to Propose language improvements for 1.1 draft
ACTION-115: Sean Mullan to Craft language on encouraging XPath2 Filter for Best Practices doc
ACTION-116: Frederick Hirsch to Add approved certificate encoding text to drafts
ACTION-117: Scott Cantor to Propose a schema and language for bare key encoding in KeyInfo
ACTION-118: Frederick Hirsch to Add web services text from Hal to Requirements draft
ACTION-119: Frederick Hirsch to Add pointer to Transforms note to Requirements draft
ACTION-120: Kelvin Yiu to Review SP 800-57 for HMAC-SHA256 item
ACTION-121: Kelvin Yiu to Add new algorithms to XML Encryption for 1.1
ACTION-122: Pratik Datta to Write up more detailed proposal in time for January F2F
ACTION-123: Frederick Hirsch to Add Juan Carlos material on long term sigs to Requirements Document
ACTION-124: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up with Juan Carlos on ISSUE-56
ACTION-125: Sean Mullan to draft best practice around xpath filter 2
ACTION-126: Ken Graf to Call out local system access risks regarding XSLT
ACTION-127: Thomas Roessler to draft text on trade-off between different extensibility mechanisms, for BP draft
ACTION-128: Konrad Lanz to document e-gov use cases
ACTION-129: Frederick Hirsch to Update signature properties based on feedback
ACTION-130: Frederick Hirsch to Create template for algorithm note
ACTION-131: Thomas Roessler to Ping Tim Polk about likely 186-3 timing expectations
ACTION-132: Brian LaMacchia to Add wording around DSAwithSHA1 for 1.1 to draft
ACTION-133: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practice with timestamp proposed changes
ACTION-134: Kelvin Yiu to Update conformance document for RSA-SHA256
ACTION-135: Kelvin Yiu to Add requirements for RSA-SHA256
ACTION-136: Thomas Roessler to Propose stronger language on MD5 for 6.2
ACTION-137: Kelvin Yiu to Change URN= to URI=
ACTION-138: Phillip Hallam-Baker to Compare 4.4.2.3 to RFC 3279 to determine if they are consistent
ACTION-139: Kelvin Yiu to <complexType name=\"NameCurveType\" must be \"NamedCurveType\"
ACTION-140: Kelvin Yiu to Change text in 6.2 to remove statement that there is only one digest
ACTION-141: Kelvin Yiu to Change URI in 6.2.3 to be SHA-384
ACTION-142: Brian LaMacchia to Come up with identifiers and add to the algs doc for the new DSA algorithms
ACTION-143: Kelvin Yiu to Summarize the i2os function and put it in the doc
ACTION-144: Kelvin Yiu to Drop the addresses section
ACTION-145: Kelvin Yiu to Change language to 4,4.2.3.2 to say if you need to interoperate with 4050 implementations then may do this.
ACTION-146: Kelvin Yiu to Add rfc 3279 to references
ACTION-147: Kelvin Yiu to Dtd isremove ref to ECDSAKeyValue in dtd in 4.0
ACTION-148: Kelvin Yiu to Close the conplex type element in 5.5.4
ACTION-149: Kelvin Yiu to Change reference X.9.63 to section G
ACTION-150: Sean Mullan to Check Java API dependencies/compatibility
ACTION-151: Thomas Roessler to Propose changes
ACTION-152: Brian LaMacchia to Implement versioning change in sig and encryption 1.1
ACTION-153: Thomas Roessler to Take issue to the schema working group
ACTION-154: Kelvin Yiu to Fix the URI in the document to www.w3.org/2009/xmldsig-ecc#
ACTION-155: Brian LaMacchia to Update text on 6.2 to reflect contemporary cryptanalysis on MD5, SHA1
ACTION-156: Bradley Hill to Propose best practices for defending against collision generation...
ACTION-157: Bradley Hill to Draft proposal for ISSUE-84
ACTION-158: Frederick Hirsch to Take pass through references in Dsig Core - update, split into normative/informative
ACTION-159: Brian LaMacchia to Include errata into the 1.1 documents
ACTION-160: Thomas Roessler to Check on possibility for external RF commitments under patent policy
ACTION-161: Kelvin Yiu to Fix AES 256 reference in block cipher table
ACTION-162: Kelvin Yiu to Section 9 to be headed RetrievalMethd Type Values
ACTION-163: Kelvin Yiu to Section 3 to be headed MAC
ACTION-164: Scott Cantor to Write headings for each section to expand definition, explain not normative etc.
ACTION-165: Thomas Roessler to Propose changes to algorithms draft
ACTION-166: Scott Cantor to Address X.509 issuer serial number length
ACTION-167: Thomas Roessler to Set up questionnaire about meeting locations and times
ACTION-168: Scott Cantor to Contribute additional text for transform note, to make clear what this document gets at
ACTION-169: Pratik Datta to Update draft - Transform Note
ACTION-170: Bradley Hill to Write about C14n and DTD processing
ACTION-171: Konrad Lanz to Draft a proposal for canonicalization improvements
ACTION-172: Frederick Hirsch to Update the Publication Status page on the Wiki
ACTION-173: Scott Cantor to Draft some text in response to ISSUE-51
ACTION-174: Pratik Datta to Update the transforms related to ISSUE-69
ACTION-175: Konrad Lanz to Send an email summarizing the points he's raised with the cut-and-paste in the chat.
ACTION-176: Scott Cantor to Draft text for v1.1 signaling possible deprecation of Transforms in RetrievalMethod in 2.0
ACTION-177: Scott Cantor to Document requirements for RetrievalMethod
ACTION-178: Sean Mullan to Draft text for v1.1 on OCSPResponse subelement for X509Data
ACTION-179: Brian LaMacchia to Either update the v1.1 draft with a consistent namespace URI suitable for ECC and OCSPResponse, or come back with technical reasons why that isn't possible
ACTION-180: Frederick Hirsch to Answer re status of RNG schema
ACTION-181: Frederick Hirsch to Update RelaxNG schemea for 1.1
ACTION-182: Brian LaMacchia to Update 1.1 namespace
ACTION-183: Frederick Hirsch to update widget signature and signature property drafts based on f2f discussion
ACTION-184: Frederick Hirsch to Fix spelling in xml signature 1.1 and xml encryption 1.1
ACTION-185: to ECC can't be REQUIRED
ACTION-186: Brian LaMacchia to Update proposal language for approval next meeting
ACTION-187: Magnus Nyström to Look into discussion archives behind x.962 changes
ACTION-188: Magnus Nyström to Provide additional arguments for schema change
ACTION-189: Magnus Nyström to Provide additional arguments for schema change
ACTION-190: Brian LaMacchia to Update schema to make ecc changes from integer to cryptobinary and make changes to doc
ACTION-191: Brian LaMacchia to Research Appendix A.5.7 (\"Point to Octet String\") conversions for ECC
ACTION-192: Brian LaMacchia to Review suggestion to change reference for EC point to OCtet string proposed by magnus
ACTION-193: Thomas Roessler to Add base64 clarification to dsig 1.1 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jan/0047.html
ACTION-194: Brian LaMacchia to Add FIPS 180-2 reference to signature 1.1. document
ACTION-195: Frederick Hirsch to Update requirements document with algorithms proposal
ACTION-196: Thomas Roessler to Draft text on section 6.1 about XPath, XPath Filter 2 and XSLT best practices
ACTION-197: Frederick Hirsch to Add first paragraph from Scott's RetrievalMethod proposal to section 4.4.3
ACTION-198: Frederick Hirsch to Add exc c14n to 6.1 of XML Sig 1.1
ACTION-199: Frederick Hirsch to Make changes to examples for 1.1
ACTION-200: Magnus Nyström to Send an email showing details on how proposal is different
ACTION-201: Konrad Lanz to Make concrete proposal on whitespace removal c14n for XMLDSIG 1.1
ACTION-202: Thomas Roessler to Check on issue with referencing informational RFCs for material in XML Encryption
ACTION-203: Brian LaMacchia to Check on proper EC Point conversion reference
ACTION-204: Brian LaMacchia to Review new 962 and review hash proposal from magnus
ACTION-205: Brian LaMacchia to Review new version of 962 and work with magnus on proposal
ACTION-206: Frederick Hirsch to Make long-lived signatures a new best practices topic
ACTION-207: Frederick Hirsch to Incorporate Scotts proposal on schema normalization best practice
ACTION-208: Thomas Roessler to Draft editor's note concerning ECDSAKeyValueTyp
ACTION-209: Thomas Roessler to Incorporate ACTION-178 into draft
ACTION-210: Thomas Roessler to Put RetrievalMethod Types from RFC 4051 into xmlsec-algorithms
ACTION-211: Brian LaMacchia to Update elliptic key value to magnus approach after checking that no major issue
ACTION-212: Magnus Nyström to Provide bal hash text
ACTION-213: Thomas Roessler to Fix algorithm links in 6.1 (see e-mail just sent to list)
ACTION-214: Thomas Roessler to Write down a note summarizing discussion on algorithms to be included in the draft to be made public -due 17/02/2209
ACTION-215: Thomas Roessler to Fix contributors' list
ACTION-216: Thomas Roessler to Add the text proposed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Feb/0055.html in the introductory section of the use case document
ACTION-217: Thomas Roessler to Add boilerplate language about optional algorithms
ACTION-218: Thomas Roessler to Send proposed changes to properties document on mail list
ACTION-219: Thomas Roessler to Change schema according to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2009Feb/0005.html
ACTION-220: Brian LaMacchia to Say on maling list how the EC point is to be converted
ACTION-221: Thomas Roessler to Send e-mail on short names; WG review by EOB next day
ACTION-222: Konrad Lanz to Make proposal RIPE algorithms
ACTION-223: Magnus Nyström to Magnus and Frederick to check on hosting
ACTION-224: Thomas Roessler to Add as Optional AES Key Wrap with padding as proposed by tlr for editors draft of 1.1 post FPWD
ACTION-225: Kelvin Yiu to Propose text for a note potentially to be added to XMLDSIG provide recommendation for the two higher security level curves with reference
ACTION-226: Bruce Rich to Send an announcement to ws federaion tc about published security drafts
ACTION-227: Brian LaMacchia to Draft text encryption algorithms regarding ECC algorithms and what curves should be used
ACTION-228: Gerald Edgar to Send a message to the list of closed issues and how they were closed
ACTION-229: Magnus Nyström to Work with Brian on how to express verifiable randomness of curves in XML schema
ACTION-230: Thomas Roessler to Prepare registration questionnaire for face-to-face
ACTION-231: Brian LaMacchia to Update XML Encryption 1.1 for ACTION-227 proposal
ACTION-232: Magnus Nyström to Update XML Dsig document for schema and semantics for curve validation
ACTION-233: Magnus Nyström to Propose text covering semantics for curve validation
ACTION-234: Frederick Hirsch to Update XMLDsig with mandating exclusive c14n
ACTION-235: Scott Cantor to Propose to the list new proposal on including ASN.1 encoded SubjPubKeyInfo
ACTION-236: Magnus Nyström to Add ECKey value as child of KeyValueType
ACTION-237: Scott Cantor to Highlight critical issues around the proposed c14n simplifications - maybe frame as questions for group to think about.
ACTION-238: Thomas Roessler to Draft proposal to add identifiers for ECDSA-RIPEMD, RSA-WHIRLPOOL, ECDSA-WHIRLPOOL to XML Security Algorithms Cross-Reference (follow up to ACTION-222)
ACTION-239: Magnus Nyström to Investigate alternative source for material in X9.62
ACTION-240: Magnus Nyström to Add proposed text to 1.1
ACTION-241: Frederick Hirsch to Reach out to people on DTD question
ACTION-242: Magnus Nyström to Add schema comment regarding ECKeyValue
ACTION-243: Scott Cantor to Update 1.1 draft with DEREncodedKeyValue proposal
ACTION-244: Pratik Datta to Update transforms note sec. 4.5
ACTION-245: Gerald Edgar to Update issues
ACTION-246: Gerald Edgar to Update Issues
ACTION-247: Gerald Edgar to Rework ISSUE-45
ACTION-248: Thomas Roessler to Put together strawman for additional algorithm RFC
ACTION-249: Frederick Hirsch to Send messages to wg regarding issues that probably can be closed, based on Pratiks proposal, ISSUE-27, ISSUE-29, ISSUE-30
ACTION-250: Frederick Hirsch to Send msg to wg noting that ISSUE-47 should result in new requirement for requirements doc and then be closed
ACTION-251: Frederick Hirsch to Send msg to wg that ISSUE-45 can be addressed with multiple ds:Siganature elements. Is this good enough or is new requirement needed?
ACTION-252: Frederick Hirsch to Place on agenda item for ISSUE-61, ISSUE-63, ACTION-13
ACTION-253: Frederick Hirsch to Ask for action to review BSP, close ISSUE-9 when done
ACTION-254: Frederick Hirsch to Add ISSUE-68 to agenda, follow up on bals proposal with editorial change to 1.1?
ACTION-255: Scott Cantor to Add retreival method type URI for DER encoded keyvalue
ACTION-256: Thomas Roessler to Update xref note with addtl type Uris
ACTION-257: Konrad Lanz to Randomized Hashing (RMX) and Signing (RSA-PSS) provide a Proposal
ACTION-258: Frederick Hirsch to Share with web apps pointer to suite b docs
ACTION-259: Konrad Lanz to Propoal for the C14N spec change
ACTION-260: Pratik Datta to Respond to the proposed change
ACTION-261: Thomas Roessler to Update xmlsec-algorithms draft to include aes key wrap with padding uris
ACTION-262: Thomas Roessler to Provide interop script for producing result tables as used before
ACTION-263: Ed Simon to Generate working examples for ISSUE-115 and review how toolkits handle the issue
ACTION-264: Frederick Hirsch to Make publication request for signature properties for this thursday, 30 April
ACTION-265: Thomas Roessler to Update signature properties for publication and place in proper location
ACTION-266: Pratik Datta to Start email discussion on how different inputs to canonicalization could start ...
ACTION-267: Konrad Lanz to Simplify canonicalization note
ACTION-268: Magnus Nyström to Draft some text for revision of 1.1 per above resolution
ACTION-269: Thomas Roessler to propose SIgnature 1.0 erratum on SHA 256
ACTION-270: Magnus Nyström to compare text of IEFT encryption to that in current draft
ACTION-271: Brian LaMacchia to compare text of IEFT encryption to that in current draft
ACTION-272: Magnus Nyström to Update editor's draft of Derived Key spec to reference the schema with TR URI
ACTION-273: Thomas Roessler to Followup on PLAIN variant
ACTION-274: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practices with proposal from Ken Graf, to call out local system access risks regarding XSLT
ACTION-275: Frederick Hirsch to Update Best Practices doc with Best practice on XPath Filter 2.0 preference, if available to 1.0 implementation.
ACTION-276: Thomas Roessler to Include keywrap-pad in 5.1
ACTION-277: Thomas Roessler to Send note template to Konrad
ACTION-278: Magnus Nyström to Update derived key draft to point to schema
ACTION-279: Pratik Datta to Create interop matrix
ACTION-280: Magnus Nyström to Produce test cases for derived keys
ACTION-281: Sean Mullan to Try to find an old apache impl without optimizations that we can use to compare performance numbers
ACTION-282: Thomas Roessler to Check on state of DSA-sha256
ACTION-283: Thomas Roessler to Update algorithm xref draft to note new status of sha-1
ACTION-284: Thomas Roessler to Implement resolution concerning SHA-1 OIDs in 6.4.2 of XML Signature
ACTION-285: Pratik Datta to Write a draft of an XML Digital Signature 2.0 specification
ACTION-286: Scott Cantor to Remove references to DTDs from the specification
ACTION-287: Magnus Nyström to Align XMLENC 1.1 with XMLDSIG 1.1
ACTION-288: Magnus Nyström to Make updated to 5.6.2 and 5.6.3 to remove the explicit algorithm descriptions and add references to the IETF RFCs
ACTION-289: Frederick Hirsch to Propose text on serialization issue for xml signature 1.1
ACTION-290: Magnus Nyström to Investigate how to fit in Key Encapsulation, possibly provide proposal for 1.1
ACTION-291: Scott Cantor to Draft a proposed fix for E02 for exc c14n
ACTION-292: Frederick Hirsch to Update Section 5.6 in Encryption for issue 99
ACTION-293: Frederick Hirsch to Update Associate product list in Open Actions tracker to include all docs
ACTION-294: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practices for this
ACTION-295: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practices to update best practice 1 to refer to best practice 2
ACTION-296: Frederick Hirsch to Send email about roadmap
ACTION-297: Konrad Lanz to Propose change to 1.1 to address issue-105
ACTION-298: Konrad Lanz to Propose change for HMAC output length to pad with leading 0s to octet boundary
ACTION-299: Scott Cantor to Look at issue-110 and errata document for exc-c14n
ACTION-300: Kelvin Yiu to Create sample to illustrate ECDH-ES with AES key wrap
ACTION-301: Magnus Nyström to Provide example of KEM message with the steps to get to the message.
ACTION-302: Frederick Hirsch to Add note re ACTION-289 to document
ACTION-303: Kelvin Yiu to Correct doc on length of r and s
ACTION-304: Kelvin Yiu to Share information on status of RIPEMD-160 and strength to mailing list
ACTION-305: Magnus Nyström to Remove 5.8 (and corresponding text in 5.1) from XMLEnc.
ACTION-306: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Signature 1.1 table of contents with missing entries
ACTION-307: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml encryption 1.1 table of contents with missing entries
ACTION-308: Frederick Hirsch to Implement resolutions to remove material from section 9 in XML Signature 1.1 other than schema and rename section, from http://www.w3.org/2009/05/12-xmlsec-minutes.html#item09
ACTION-309: Frederick Hirsch to Create errata for XML Second Edition to remove material from section 9 other than schema, per http://www.w3.org/2009/05/12-xmlsec-minutes.html#item09
ACTION-310: Magnus Nyström to Add text to XMLDsig 1.1 discouraging use of RSA-SHA1 and ECDSA-SHA1
ACTION-311: Thomas Roessler to Teach Frederick how to tame the pubrules dragon
ACTION-312: Magnus Nyström to Check with IETF SMIME on KEM normative statements
ACTION-313: Thomas Roessler to Update errata document for XML Signature, adding E02 as distributed by Frederick Hirsch and marking E01 and E02 accepted
ACTION-314: Magnus Nyström to Implement SEC 1 resolution to update SEC 1 reference in Signature 1.1 to version 2.0, remove X.962 reference and refer to SEC 1 v2 instead
ACTION-315: Frederick Hirsch to Add byte range use case and requirements
ACTION-316: Thomas Roessler to Introduce nazeera and aleksey; find out xmlsec release dates
ACTION-317: Magnus Nyström to Move derived key spec into XML Enc 11 and create separate KDF section with mandatory 800-56
ACTION-318: Magnus Nyström to Create new draft recommendation spec on Key Encapsulation; use proposal on list as basis
ACTION-319: Kelvin Yiu to And brian to update DH & ECDH sections to take advantage of new KDF section
ACTION-320: Brian LaMacchia to Draft language for HMAC section, 6.3.1
ACTION-321: Frederick Hirsch to Implement RESOLUTION: accept change proposed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jun/0040.html with modification of last sentence to DSA with 1024-bit prime moduli SHOULD NOT be used for signatures that will be verified beyond 2010 , also changing REQUIRES signature verifiers to implement DSA only for keys of 1024 bits
ACTION-322: Frederick Hirsch to Implement RESOLUTION: Add Camellia identifiers to algorithm cross reference
ACTION-323: Magnus Nyström to Write a proposal for use of Alg IDs for KDF key
ACTION-324: Cynthia Martin to Review http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jun/att-0044/xmlenc-ref.html for normative and informative
ACTION-325: Cynthia Martin to Propose changes to Signature references
ACTION-326: Brian LaMacchia to Update ACTION 319 for explicit URI
ACTION-327: Frederick Hirsch to Update DSS security warning
ACTION-328: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml encryption references
ACTION-329: Frederick Hirsch to Review and update explain documents for xml signature and encryption
ACTION-330: Thomas Roessler to Update algorithms doc per http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jul/0013.html
ACTION-331: Konrad Lanz to Review E07 and E02 for Exclusive C14n
ACTION-332: Konrad Lanz to Review wording http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jun/0075.html
ACTION-333: Thomas Roessler to Draft one-pager that says "derived key stuff has been folded into encryption
ACTION-334: Magnus Nyström to Update KDF3 name to ConcatKDF
ACTION-335: Magnus Nyström to Integrate http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jul/0034.html into XMLEnc
ACTION-336: Thomas Roessler to Update xml signature references and update explain.html for those changes
ACTION-337: Frederick Hirsch to Update explain documents with material from Cynthia
ACTION-338: Frederick Hirsch to Check in explain documents with material from Cynthia
ACTION-339: Konrad Lanz to Review proposed exclusive c14n errata E02, E07
ACTION-340: Thomas Roessler to Fold upcoming signature erratum into 1.1 working draft
ACTION-341: Thomas Roessler to Update exc-c14n errata
ACTION-342: Thomas Roessler to Post updated exc-c14n schema
ACTION-343: Thomas Roessler to Provide link to updated schema in exclusive c14n document
ACTION-344: Frederick Hirsch to Transition request for fpwd of generic hybrid
ACTION-345: Ed Simon to Review 2.0 sig docs
ACTION-346: Kelvin Yiu to Review 2.0 sig docs
ACTION-347: Scott Cantor to Review 2.0 sig docs
ACTION-348: Brian LaMacchia to Review 2.0 sig docs
ACTION-349: Pratik Datta to Add section on extensibility and byte ranges to signature 2.0
ACTION-350: Ed Simon to Propose text to align node set result treatment for XSLT and XPath in 1.1 spec
ACTION-351: Pratik Datta to Summarize design rationale for xsd:any in note in spec
ACTION-352: Ed Simon to Propose concrete examples for multiple nodeset cases
ACTION-353: Ed Simon to Draft text explaining meaning of URI attribute on Reference element
ACTION-354: Pratik Datta to Circulate draft schema for Transform
ACTION-355: Ed Simon to Send list of detailed comments to mail list on signature 2.0 and c14n2.0
ACTION-356: Ed Simon to Send revised version of 2009Jul/0067 e-mail
ACTION-357: Frederick Hirsch to Add warning to implementation wiki
ACTION-358: Sean Mullan to Add jdk7 implementation to wiki
ACTION-359: Frederick Hirsch to Respond to Anders once ACTION-360 completed
ACTION-360: Brian LaMacchia to Make change to schema for use=required
ACTION-361: Pratik Datta to Edit 2.0 spec to remove material from previous version unless incorporated in 2.0, specifically old transform model. Make clear 1.1 still allowed..
ACTION-362: Frederick Hirsch to Edit best practices to incorporate change for ACTION-127 as in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Aug/0012.html
ACTION-363: Scott Cantor to Respond on substantive comments on XSD schema in RelaxNG email.
ACTION-364: Pratik Datta to Get feedback from implementers on XPath approach
ACTION-365: Scott Cantor to Propose extension point for include/exclude grammar in 2.0 draft
ACTION-366: Thomas Roessler to And bal to coordinate offline
ACTION-367: Brian LaMacchia to Remove note in section 4.4.2.3 in XML Signature 1.1
ACTION-368: Pratik Datta to Update XPath in XML Signature 2.0
ACTION-369: Scott Cantor to Draft a proposal for using URI to identify section syntax
ACTION-370: Pratik Datta to Update signature 2.0 draft and remove URI from selection element and keep it in reference only
ACTION-371: Pratik Datta to Add id and position handling in step in draft
ACTION-372: Ed Simon to Create an issue for the discussion in email
ACTION-373: Frederick Hirsch to Discuss ISSUE-124 with tlr
ACTION-374: Frederick Hirsch to Review ISSUE-135
ACTION-375: Frederick Hirsch to Last call with ISSUE-137 discussion
ACTION-376: Ed Simon to Start a discusson on the list to schema XMLDSIG-1.1 validation
ACTION-377: Brian LaMacchia to Edit the reference to RFC-5649
ACTION-378: Frederick Hirsch to Add Implementations link to public home page
ACTION-379: Frederick Hirsch to Ask on list about interop participation and which topics can be tested
ACTION-380: Thomas Roessler to See if xmlspec can include strikeouts and inserts markup
ACTION-381: Pratik Datta to Locate original c14n test case applicable to ISSUE-141 and update ISSUE-141 with link
ACTION-382: Pratik Datta to Add guidance on semantic equivalence to Signature 2.0 related to ISSUE-131, which defaults, how equivalent does it get
ACTION-383: Sean Mullan to Provide reference to performance paper
ACTION-384: Frederick Hirsch to Ask xml coordination about use of multiple schemas and validation
ACTION-385: Frederick Hirsch to Implement change in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Oct/0007.html , adding "to" before "obtain"
ACTION-386: Hal Lockhart to Look at WS-I BSP constraints on DSig
ACTION-387: Gerald Edgar to Propose text for requirements for issue-45
ACTION-388: Gerald Edgar to Propose text for requirements for issue-60
ACTION-389: Gerald Edgar to Propose requirements text for issue-63
ACTION-390: Frederick Hirsch to Consolidate ISSUE-127 and issue-60
ACTION-391: Gerald Edgar to See if issue-131 is covered in requirements doc
ACTION-392: Gerald Edgar to See if issue-131 is covered in requirements doc
ACTION-393: Frederick Hirsch to Announce 2.0 to oasis security tcs, draw attention to points
ACTION-394: Thomas Roessler to Update permissions and style for approved minutes at http://www.w3.org/2009/09/29-xmlsec-minutes.html
ACTION-395: Thomas Roessler to Copy minutes from http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2009Oct/att-0010/06-xmlsec-minutes-fjh.html to http://www.w3.org/2009/10/06-xmlsec-minutes.html
ACTION-396: Thomas Roessler to Implement suggestion on multiple schemas http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Oct/0023.html
ACTION-397: Gerald Edgar to review xml signature 1.1 explain document and errata
ACTION-398: Cynthia Martin to review xml encryption 1.1 explain document and errata
ACTION-399: Thomas Roessler to Ask Ed Simon to review /TR/exi-impacts
ACTION-400: Hal Lockhart to propose concrete next steps to address ISSUE-63 in 2.0
ACTION-401: Thomas Roessler to Send note to WG calling for volunteers on randomized hashing
ACTION-402: Frederick Hirsch to Document issue-136 requirement, prefix rewriting
ACTION-403: Thomas Roessler to Introduce Pratik D, Michael Kay
ACTION-404: Brian LaMacchia to Draft language that codifies history why DERKeyValue is not child of KeyValue (for section 4.4 of xmldsig-core1)
ACTION-405: Thomas Roessler to Update xml signature 1.0 errata page with proposed text
ACTION-406: Magnus Nystrom to Make proposal on list to address SP80056AConcatKDF in XML Encryption 1.1 concern
ACTION-407: Frederick Hirsch to Contact Michael Kay re F2F or call in
ACTION-408: Frederick Hirsch to See if WS-Fragment joint discussion possible at TPAC
ACTION-409: Pratik Datta to Revisit text() with regards to XPath profile
ACTION-410: Ed Simon to Review updated relaxng schema
ACTION-411: Pratik Datta to Perform measurement related to transform octet conversion
ACTION-412: Ed Simon to Review ISSUE-115
ACTION-413: Thomas Roessler to Update approved minutes for 20 Oct - move location and restyle/permission
ACTION-414: Frederick Hirsch to Review requirements to see if we can split into 1.1 and 2.0 requirements
ACTION-415: Frederick Hirsch to Check on status of Makoto email list access
ACTION-416: Frederick Hirsch to Ask Makoto re 1.1 relax ng schema
ACTION-417: Frederick Hirsch to Update requirements as proposed
ACTION-418: Thomas Roessler to Copy draft minutes from http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2009Oct/att-0022/27-xmlsec-minutes.html to http://www.w3.org/2009/10/27-xmlsec-minutes.html
ACTION-419: Brian LaMacchia to Implement the KDF change
ACTION-420: Frederick Hirsch to Share with Norm the RELAX schema
ACTION-421: Ed Simon to Look at the 1.1 schema
ACTION-422: Cynthia Martin to Propose wording to improve KEYINFO explanation
ACTION-423: Frederick Hirsch to Add reference to "best practices" to XML digial signature 1.1
ACTION-424: Frederick Hirsch to Share performance information with the EXI group
ACTION-425: Sean Mullan to Indicate sources of implementaitons
ACTION-426: Pratik Datta to Run performance tests on non-optimized Signature implementation
ACTION-427: Frederick Hirsch to Look if correct style sheet is used for http://www.w3.org/2008/xmlsec/Drafts/transform-note/Overview.html
ACTION-428: Frederick Hirsch to Edit requirements 2.0 removing design section and exmples
ACTION-429: Frederick Hirsch to Make change to section 2.1 adding new sentence
ACTION-430: Frederick Hirsch to Edit the XML Encryption explanation document to make changes identified by Cynthia.
ACTION-431: Thomas Roessler to Fix "they" in RFC2119 section throughout all documents
ACTION-432: Thomas Roessler to Talk to sean about possible resources
ACTION-433: Thomas Roessler to Propose C14N erratum to address http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Sep/0009.html issue
ACTION-434: Scott Cantor to Propose "final" disposition of Referencing syntax
ACTION-435: Frederick Hirsch to confirm or cancel 16/17 June face-to-face
ACTION-436: Thomas Roessler to Review requirements for issue-63 text
ACTION-437: Frederick Hirsch to Move sig/enc core 1.1 specs to respec; resolve ISSUE-147 as side effect
ACTION-438: Shivaram Mysore to check 1.1 requirements against enc, sig EDs
ACTION-439: Thomas Roessler to Draft text for xml encryption 1.1 for handing EXI
ACTION-440: Thomas Roessler to Proposed a resolution to issue-141
ACTION-441: Cynthia Martin to Review BSP 1.1 (http://www.ws-i.org/Profiles/BasicSecurityProfile-1.1.html) with respect to Signature 1.1 and Encryption 1.1
ACTION-442: Brian LaMacchia to Propose text for RSA for Issue-82 (DSA already done)
ACTION-443: Thomas Roessler to Glue together the two pieces of today's irc log & minutes, and remove his twitter link while he's at it
ACTION-444: Thomas Roessler to Post minutes from both days of F2F.
ACTION-445: Frederick Hirsch to Update shortnames in requirement docs
ACTION-446: Frederick Hirsch to Update publication wiki
ACTION-447: Cynthia Martin to Review wrapping attack article, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Nov/0019.html
ACTION-448: Frederick Hirsch to Hand 1.1 bibliography to Cynthia when converted to respec
ACTION-449: Cynthia Martin to Review 1.1 bibliographies (depends on ACTION-448)
ACTION-450: Brian LaMacchia to Check on Suite B AES-GCM
ACTION-451: Magnus Nystrom to Review the Pratik AES-GCM proposal with Magnus
ACTION-452: Scott Cantor to Review the XML ENC v1.1 document
ACTION-453: Ed Simon to Review XML ENC v1.1
ACTION-454: Thomas Roessler to Introduce Ed Simon and joerg Schwenk
ACTION-455: Frederick Hirsch to Review plans for RNG schema
ACTION-456: Scott Cantor to Review workshop papers regarding strengthening id based references with respect to wrapping attacks
ACTION-457: Frederick Hirsch to add RNG Schema to XML Signature 1.1
ACTION-458: Frederick Hirsch to Forward bsp comments to paul cotton
ACTION-459: Frederick Hirsch to Edit Signature 1.1 with the MgmtData changes
ACTION-460: Frederick Hirsch to Look if diff of 1.1 editors draft from 2nd edition is possible
ACTION-461: Bruce Rich to Start a discussion on the list about concatKDF bit string hash interoperability issues
ACTION-462: Thomas Roessler to Add ISSUE-141 erratum to C14N 1.1 errata
ACTION-463: Thomas Roessler to Add HMAC erratum to signature 1.0 errata
ACTION-464: Frederick Hirsch to Implement MgmtData change proposed by Sean, and to change title to 4.5.8
ACTION-465: Thomas Roessler to Help with understanding if we can go to last call for 1.1 and then structure separate conformance clause document after last call?
ACTION-466: Frederick Hirsch to Incorporate RSA key size text into document
ACTION-467: Frederick Hirsch to Add action-404 proposal into editors draft, history why DERKeyValue is not child of KeyValue
ACTION-468: Thomas Roessler to Confirm whether optional features require 2+ implementations or only one.
ACTION-469: Frederick Hirsch to Add aes-gcm to enc 1.1
ACTION-470: Frederick Hirsch to Change "see below" to link to section 6.2 in xml sig 1.1
ACTION-471: Frederick Hirsch to Add SHA-1 warning to 6.2.1 and fix DSS reference in sig 1.1
ACTION-472: Frederick Hirsch to Add ConcatKDF note
ACTION-473: Thomas Roessler to Update xml enc processing proposal with more detail and addressing wg concerns
ACTION-474: Frederick Hirsch to Review xml signature 1.1
ACTION-475: Frederick Hirsch to Review xml encryption 1.1
ACTION-476: Frederick Hirsch to Review xml signature 2.0
ACTION-477: Frederick Hirsch to Fix links and editorial issues for xml enc 1.1
ACTION-478: Frederick Hirsch to Fix links and editorial issues for xml sig 1.1
ACTION-479: Frederick Hirsch to Send agenda for 5 Jan
ACTION-480: Frederick Hirsch to Create issues for 2.0 from 1.1 review
ACTION-481: Frederick Hirsch to Check on follow-up status on WS-RA discussion
ACTION-482: Thomas Roessler to Update approved minutes from 15 december, permissions and style - http://www.w3.org/2009/12/15-xmlsec-minutes.html
ACTION-483: Frederick Hirsch to Update HMAC output warning with text from Brian: "Signatures must be deemed invalid if the truncation length is below the larger of (a) half the underlying hash algorithm's output length, and (b) 80 bits"
ACTION-484: Frederick Hirsch to Review Cynthia comments on best practices, update best practices
ACTION-485: Thomas Roessler to Review actions assigned to Konrad and summarize which can be closed and which need further action
ACTION-486: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Signature Properties to correct schema, add stand-alone schema file
ACTION-487: Scott Cantor to Test validation of examples against rnc schema for signature properties
ACTION-488: Thomas Roessler to Rephrase ECC note as appropriate, if needed
ACTION-489: Thomas Roessler to Cause another ping to Certicom
ACTION-490: Frederick Hirsch to Attempt to validate signature properties against rnc schema
ACTION-491: Hal Lockhart to Suggest reference for SHA-1 to list for XML Signature 1.1, indicating weakness of SHA-1
ACTION-492: Thomas Roessler to Review XSD Signature 1.1 schema snippets vs standalone XSD 1.1 schema
ACTION-493: Frederick Hirsch to Add text to documents regarding authoritative schema (ISSUE-165) to drafts listed in issue
ACTION-494: Frederick Hirsch to Add revision of AES-GCM to xml encryption 1.1
ACTION-495: Frederick Hirsch to Ask makoto regarding RNG schema for generic hybrid ciphers
ACTION-496: Pratik Datta to Update 2.0 draft based on scott's proposal for 2.0 mode references
ACTION-497: Frederick Hirsch to Update signature properties to state where properties must be placed, ISSUE-173
ACTION-498: Thomas Roessler to Check namespace document and signature algorithms check
ACTION-499: Thomas Roessler to Check in on IANA media type *update* procedures
ACTION-500: Thomas Roessler to Update namespace section in Encryption 1.1
ACTION-501: Frederick Hirsch to Make minor editorial updates noted in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Jan/0084.html
ACTION-502: Scott Cantor to Propose new model for RetrievalMethod in 2.0
ACTION-503: Scott Cantor to Raise use of XML Signature 1.1 in OASIS SSTC
ACTION-504: Hal Lockhart to Remind ws-sx of xml signature 1.1
ACTION-505: Thomas Roessler to Update acknowledgements in Requirements 1.1 and 2.0, also for Signature Properties
ACTION-506: Thomas Roessler to Update sotd and note in document with change for ISSUE-179
ACTION-507: Brian LaMacchia to Review XML Encryption 1.1, including proposed processing model changes
ACTION-508: Pratik Datta to Review Encryption 1.1, including proposed processing model changes
ACTION-509: Frederick Hirsch to Help with updating XML Signature 2.0 bibliography
ACTION-510: Pratik Datta to Propose explanation of use of content vs. element in implementations
ACTION-511: Thomas Roessler to Propose next steps on media type registration (ISSUE-180)
ACTION-512: Ed Simon to Look at XML Encryption content vs. element options when content equals element
ACTION-513: Frederick Hirsch to Announce last call outside w3
ACTION-514: Thomas Roessler to Remind RIM/Certicom of Last Call time period
ACTION-515: Aldrin J D'Souza to Propose the schema addition for issue-186
ACTION-516: Scott Cantor to Make last call comment and proposed change
ACTION-517: Frederick Hirsch to Provide proposed update to Signature Properties document
ACTION-518: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Draft email and check with tlr regarding it before sending
ACTION-519: Scott Cantor to review C14N 2.0 draft
ACTION-520: Pratik Datta to Circulate list of differences on xmlsec mailing list
ACTION-521: Thomas Roessler to Check with EXI group on Type parameter
ACTION-522: Pratik Datta to Review action-13 results
ACTION-523: Ed Simon to review C14N 2.0 draft
ACTION-524: Frederick Hirsch to Update Signature Properties with changes referring to XAdES as agreed on 16 Feb 2010 call
ACTION-525: Frederick Hirsch to Incorporate RNG schema update into RNG schemas draft
ACTION-526: Frederick Hirsch to Implement change agreed on 16 Feb for ISSUE-187 resolution
ACTION-527: Frederick Hirsch to Share pubrules info with pratik
ACTION-528: Magnus Nystrom to Review issue-188 related to xenc:Agreement referenced from XML Signature 1.1
ACTION-529: Pratik Datta to Add KeyInfoReference to Signature 2.0 (ISSUE-182)
ACTION-530: Frederick Hirsch to Check generic hybrid cipher RNG section
ACTION-531: Thomas Roessler to Review algorithms cross reference and update the document
ACTION-532: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption 1.1 editors draft with resolution proposed by Magnus in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Mar/0001.html
ACTION-533: Aldrin J D'Souza to Implement proposed change to XML Encryption 1.1 per proposal to resolve ISSUE-186
ACTION-534: Magnus Nystrom to Implement proposed generic hybrid cipher changes
ACTION-535: Frederick Hirsch to Add section on RNG schema to Generic Hybrid Cipher
ACTION-536: Thomas Roessler to Propose revised C14N20 URI (with Pratik)
ACTION-537: Pratik Datta to And thomas to work out mutually agreeable 2.0 URIs
ACTION-538: Meiko Jensen to Provide proposal related to namespace wrapping attacks once XPath profile available
ACTION-539: Meiko Jensen to Review C14N20 draft
ACTION-540: Frederick Hirsch to Ask Makoto regarding implementations and interop
ACTION-541: Frederick Hirsch to Review sha384 with tlr, re cross-ref, sig
ACTION-542: Scott Cantor to Check on issue related to other and any in XML Enc, see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Mar/0053.html
ACTION-543: Scott Cantor to Make proposals for the last two points noted in ISSUE-43 comments
ACTION-544: Pratik Datta to Review ISSUE-162, regarding Object/Manifests language and transforms
ACTION-545: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml signature 1.1 and xml encryption 1.1 to replace ECPublicKey with ECKeyValue, for ISSUE-194
ACTION-546: Frederick Hirsch to Respond regarding ISSUE-134
ACTION-547: Pratik Datta to Confirm that RetrievalMethod warning remains in 2.0 draft of signature
ACTION-548: Ed Simon to Ed to review XPath Profile
ACTION-549: Scott Cantor to Provide proposal related to generic parameter relatedto xsiTypeAware
ACTION-550: Pratik Datta to Implement editorial changes from scott and ed
ACTION-551: Frederick Hirsch to Ask Dom about URI sorting question
ACTION-552: Frederick Hirsch to Ask on list about interop and implemention plans for 1.1 features, including encryption and also 2.0
ACTION-553: Thomas Roessler to Contact implementers known from hmac affair regarding potential interop participation
ACTION-554: Pratik Datta to Review c14n comments from meiko, incorporate into doc, flagging with email any concerns for discussion
ACTION-555: Pratik Datta to Add clarifications re sorting into c14n2 document
ACTION-556: Pratik Datta to Review text related to Object tag for consistency with 2.0 model
ACTION-557: Scott Cantor to Edit ISSUE-162 to reflect need to include object and manifest in 2.0
ACTION-558: Frederick Hirsch to Draft charter extension request
ACTION-559: Ed Simon to Investigate schema vs. DTD
ACTION-560: Pratik Datta to Add digest to example in Section 2.5
ACTION-561: Thomas Roessler to Review ISSUE-196
ACTION-562: Meiko Jensen to Provide streaming-canonicalization proposal
ACTION-563: Pratik Datta to Remove xml:lang and xml:space from example in 2.4.2
ACTION-564: Pratik Datta to Remove the second sentence in the default namespace definition in Sec. 2.5
ACTION-565: Meiko Jensen to Come up with a proposal for inspecting the IncludedXPath and ExcludedXPath for prefixes and marking them as visibility utilized
ACTION-566: Magnus Nystrom to Update XML Encryption 1.1 with changes from Frederick and his proposed changes, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010May/0009.html , also to give value to PartyVInfo="" should have value in example
ACTION-567: Magnus Nystrom to Change generic hybrid ciphers namespace to /2010/ghc
ACTION-568: Magnus Nystrom to And bal to review relationship between ghc and material in encryption
ACTION-569: Magnus Nystrom to Implement changes to Generic Hybrid Ciphers as proposed by Frederick, and revisions from Magnus, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010May/0010.html
ACTION-570: Thomas Roessler to Revise gh namespace section
ACTION-571: Frederick Hirsch to Review references in generic hybrids and encryption 1.1
ACTION-572: Frederick Hirsch to Get encryption 1.1 and GHC pubrules-ready
ACTION-573: Scott Cantor to Create issue on DTDs, entities, defaulting, schema validation for C14N 2.0
ACTION-574: Scott Cantor to Send his proposal on prefix rewriting to the list
ACTION-575: Frederick Hirsch to Update algorithm cross-reference for GHC namespace change
ACTION-576: Pratik Datta to Add "high performance profile" to c14n2
ACTION-577: Scott Cantor to Propose more general mechanism for QNames in content
ACTION-578: Thomas Roessler to Provide signature best practice proposal related to external references
ACTION-579: Pratik Datta to Update c14n2 with proposal from ACTION-574
ACTION-580: Pratik Datta to Review c14n 2.0 for parsing-related options; propose removal (or add octet-stream processing to 2.0)
ACTION-581: Scott Cantor to make proposal around IDness of attributes
ACTION-582: Thomas Roessler to Update best practices with ACTION-578 text
ACTION-583: Scott Cantor to Create qnames issue, link to ACTION-549
ACTION-584: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml encryption with change for LC-2386
ACTION-585: Thomas Roessler to Review proposal for LC-2387
ACTION-586: Meiko Jensen to Draft text about XPath risks for BP document
ACTION-587: Pratik Datta to Add X509IssuerSerial text as proposed by Scott, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010May/0067.html
ACTION-588: Thomas Roessler to Update signature schema with X509IssuerSerial change, and provide warning text
ACTION-589: Pratik Datta to Create 2.0 schema with X509IssuerSerial change
ACTION-590: Pratik Datta to Create separate XPath profile document (from XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-591: Frederick Hirsch to Add XPath profile document to roadmap
ACTION-592: Thomas Roessler to Set up dial-in v attendance questionnaire for TPAC 2010
ACTION-593: Frederick Hirsch to Fix formatting of element names in section 4.5.2.3
ACTION-594: Scott Cantor to Write detailed proposal, not including xsi:type, based on http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Jun/0020.html
ACTION-595: Thomas Roessler to Send pointer to RDFa work on qname-like constructs
ACTION-596: Pratik Datta to Add single xmlAncestors parameter that only supports inherit or none values to c14n2
ACTION-597: Pratik Datta to Add proposed text in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Jun/0015.html to end of section 2.1 in C14N2
ACTION-598: Frederick Hirsch to Close LC-2390 with resolution no action via email with scott and list.
ACTION-599: Pratik Datta to Incorporate Object tag proposal as per http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Jun/0012.html
ACTION-600: Thomas Roessler to Draft proposal of how update to 1.0 schema will work practically for existing implementations
ACTION-601: Thomas Roessler to Copy http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2010Jun/att-0007/minutes-2010-06-22.html to http://www.w3.org/2010/06/22-xmlsec-minutes.html
ACTION-602: Frederick Hirsch to to figure out what ACTION-597 is
ACTION-603: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practice for ISSUE-207
ACTION-604: Hal Lockhart to Propose change for best practices for ISSUE-170
ACTION-605: Pratik Datta to Update references for C14N2, placing into normative vs informative to resolve ISSUE-200
ACTION-606: Scott Cantor to See if we can extend ds:Reference with length of digested data without breaking backward compatibility
ACTION-607: Frederick Hirsch to Add to agenda item to remove id function from XPath profile
ACTION-608: Hal Lockhart to Initiate feedback response to Magic Signatures
ACTION-609: Ed Simon to Review Magic Signatures and comment
ACTION-610: Cynthia Martin to Review magic signatures and comment
ACTION-611: Pratik Datta to Update c14n2 with proposal and CURIE reference
ACTION-612: Scott Cantor to Extend section 3 of C14N2 to deal with options related to ACTON-594 proposal
ACTION-613: Pratik Datta to Add verification step for length verification in Signature 2.0 transform
ACTION-614: Meiko Jensen to Review XPath Profile
ACTION-615: Pratik Datta to Update URI for XPath in XML Signature 2.0
ACTION-616: Pratik Datta to Check that Oracle interop keys are available in the repository
ACTION-617: Frederick Hirsch to Discuss interop with thomas, including ConcatKDF
ACTION-618: Frederick Hirsch to Make sure Makoto listed as author of RNG schema
ACTION-619: Ed Simon to Review Meiko proposal for ACTION-538
ACTION-620: Cynthia Martin to Review C14N2 references, ISSUE-200
ACTION-621: Thomas Roessler to Propose ECC-related refactoring of spec
ACTION-622: Thomas Roessler to Propose wording for response to EXI WG on LC-2386 LC-2387
ACTION-623: Magnus Nystrom to Review schema update plan, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0017.html
ACTION-624: Frederick Hirsch to Test action handling
ACTION-625: Meiko Jensen to Review c14n2 parameters with regards to conformance and optionality
ACTION-626: Pratik Datta to Remove <dsig2:DigestData> from 4.4.3.9 The dsig2:Verification element in Signature 2
ACTION-627: Pratik Datta to Add id verification proposal from meiko to Signature 2.0, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0030.html
ACTION-628: Meiko Jensen to Send email address book example of 1-pass vs 2-pass to list
ACTION-629: Frederick Hirsch to Summarize discussion on issues and streaming use cases on email list
ACTION-630: Frederick Hirsch to Remove or update the change log in best practices
ACTION-631: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare RNG Schema and Best Practices for publication
ACTION-632: Frederick Hirsch to Fix agenda to change Sean affiliation from Sun to Oracle
ACTION-633: Frederick Hirsch to Review pubrules readiness of xpath 2.0, c14n2, sig 2
ACTION-634: Pratik Datta to Run pubrules check on xpath 2, c14n2, sig2 after completing edits
ACTION-635: Thomas Roessler to Copy http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2010Aug/att-0011/2010-08-10-xmlsec-minutes.html to http://www.w3.org/2010/08/10-xmlsec-minutes.html , remove "draft" notation, and make public style and permissions
ACTION-636: Pratik Datta to Add dsig2:IDAttributes child of the dsig2:Verification element as proposed by Scott Cantor in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0044.html
ACTION-637: Pratik Datta to Update URI per http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0053.html
ACTION-638: Scott Cantor to Make proposal for ISSUE-210, see also http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0043.html (uncomplicate section)
ACTION-639: Pratik Datta to Implement changes suggested in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0047.html , also add note in core validation section
ACTION-640: Frederick Hirsch to Update references per Cynthia review http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0056.html
ACTION-641: Frederick Hirsch to Generate updated publication drafts after reference updates
ACTION-642: Pratik Datta to Update Streaming XPath Profile with changes in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0055.html
ACTION-643: Meiko Jensen to Propose text for best practices re ISSUE-212, attack noted in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Aug/0020.html
ACTION-644: Meiko Jensen to Propose text for Streaming XPath Profile to note that 1-pass not always possible, giving examples where 1-pass is not possible
ACTION-645: Frederick Hirsch to Request publication FPWD of Streamable XPath Profile
ACTION-646: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare manifest for publication
ACTION-647: Pratik Datta to Implement Cantor's proposed text to identify all attributes
ACTION-648: Pratik Datta to Flesh out 6.8, shuffle order of sections, define URI for C14N2, see ISSUE-160
ACTION-649: Thomas Roessler to Check in with Michael Sperberg-McQueen about decimal and bignums
ACTION-650: Thomas Roessler to propose choices for X509SerialNumber fix
ACTION-651: Thomas Roessler to Summarize errata process and RESOLUTION A versus C
ACTION-652: Thomas Roessler to Request conference bridge for XML Security TPAC F2F meeting
ACTION-653: Frederick Hirsch to Review status of ISSUE-183
ACTION-654: Meiko Jensen to Provide some performance data related to implementing entire c14n2 with all options, to influence choices regarding conformance
ACTION-655: Pratik Datta to Start email thread on which parameters to be treated as group
ACTION-656: Frederick Hirsch to Contact aleksey re review of 2.0 specs and optionality/conformance
ACTION-657: Frederick Hirsch to Initiate use case review for c14N2
ACTION-658: Pratik Datta to Provide proposal on scanning option
ACTION-659: Pratik Datta to Review newTransformModel URI and does URI need correct? http://www.w3.org/2010/xmldsig2#newTransformModel in Signature 2.0
ACTION-660: Scott Cantor to Propose changes to C14N2 to support enveloped signature
ACTION-661: Pratik Datta to Summarize issue related to use of ID without DTD for discussion and resolution
ACTION-662: Pratik Datta to Add verification element to 2.0 schema
ACTION-663: Frederick Hirsch to Add decisions to next week's agenda from Meiko on Streaming Profile http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Sep/0013.html and Best Practices http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Sep/0014.html
ACTION-664: Meiko Jensen to Propose examples for 2.0 mode in XML Signature 2.0
ACTION-665: Scott Cantor to Devise proposal for X509SerialNumber that does not involve changes to the /2000/09/xmldsig schema.
ACTION-666: Thomas Roessler to Propose edits to XML Encryption examples wrt EXI response
ACTION-667: Pratik Datta to Add text regarding potential 1-pass issues to XPath document, using proposal from Meikohttp://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Sep/0013.html
ACTION-668: Frederick Hirsch to Update best practices with proposal from Meiko
ACTION-669: Frederick Hirsch to Update list of tracker products to be more sensible
ACTION-670: Frederick Hirsch to Add link to Meiko's paper (member only) and reference to web site
ACTION-671: Frederick Hirsch to Update RELAX NG schemas with new contribution from Makoto
ACTION-672: Thomas Roessler to Answer whether W3 can make formal request for IPR disclosure without creating a PAG, and if so, does this happen when entering CR or earlier
ACTION-673: Thomas Roessler to Outline process for starting a PAG and share with WG
ACTION-674: Scott Cantor to Update 1.1 with change for X509SerialNumber
ACTION-675: Pratik Datta to Incorporate X509Data element into 2.0 schema and document
ACTION-676: Frederick Hirsch to Discuss XPath profile roadmap with tlr
ACTION-677: Pratik Datta to Remove .. from XPath subset, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Oct/0010.html
ACTION-678: Pratik Datta to Add editorial warning about potential future changes to XPath subset
ACTION-679: Pratik Datta to Update XPath profile to allow assertion to include all id references utilized by reference
ACTION-680: Pratik Datta to Add proposal to document, with clarification regarding double quotes and still allowing approach #3, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Oct/0016.html
ACTION-681: Frederick Hirsch to Send magnus email re running additional test cases, including ghc
ACTION-682: Frederick Hirsch to Review Signature Properties testing
ACTION-683: Frederick Hirsch to Review newTransformModel URI, ACTION-659
ACTION-684: Scott Cantor to Propose text related to mixed content for ISSUE-43
ACTION-685: Gerald Edgar to Review 2.0 examples from meiko, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Sep/0024.html
ACTION-686: Pratik Datta to Add sections on top-level expressions and predicate to XPath profile
ACTION-687: Meiko Jensen to Produce top level grammar for XPath profile
ACTION-688: Meiko Jensen to Add id function at XPath top level
ACTION-689: Pratik Datta to Limit to xpath profile during xml signature 2.0 generation in 2.0 mode
ACTION-690: Meiko Jensen to Make explicit in grammar difference of included and excluded xpath, - ExcludedXpath can select attributes and element, whereas IncludedXPath can only select elements
ACTION-691: Pratik Datta to Add security considerations section to xpath profile
ACTION-692: Pratik Datta to Add editorial note to c142 indicated only exclusive
ACTION-693: Frederick Hirsch to Ask EMC/Aldrin about Generic Hybrid Cipher implementation at EMC
ACTION-694: Frederick Hirsch to Ask Magnus/Microsoft about Generic Hybrid Cipher implementation/interop
ACTION-695: Pratik Datta to Update XPath profile from changes proposed during joint session with XSLT/XQuery
ACTION-696: Magnus Nystrom to Update interop wiki with test cases for PBKDF2 and ConcatKDF, http://www.w3.org/2008/xmlsec/wiki/Interop
ACTION-697: Magnus Nystrom to Update PBKDF2 for SHA2 URI
ACTION-698: Frederick Hirsch to Check with sean on ECKeyValue
ACTION-699: Cynthia Martin to Update interop wiki with suite B organization
ACTION-700: Frederick Hirsch to Review xml signature properties interop status re widget signature
ACTION-701: Frederick Hirsch to Check with sean on status of implementations wiki
ACTION-702: Frederick Hirsch to Check with scott re interop, in particulars DEREncodedKeyValue, OCSP, KeyInfoReference
ACTION-703: Frederick Hirsch to Send cfc on resolutions
ACTION-704: Scott Cantor to Indicate if there are alternative means to xml:space to indicate preserving space, and to comment on actual use of xml:space
ACTION-705: Juan Carlos Cruellas to Confirm suitability of exclusive
ACTION-706: Scott Cantor to Propose definition section text for Included/ExcludedXPath elements for XML Signature 2.0
ACTION-707: Pratik Datta to Remove EnvelopedSignature from section 6.7.1, http://www.w3.org/2008/xmlsec/Drafts/xmldsig-core-20/#sec-Type-xml
ACTION-708: Pratik Datta to Fix typo in XML Signature 2.0 in DigestDataLength description purpose c)
ACTION-709: Pratik Datta to Incorporate Meiko's examples in the document - ISSUE-217
ACTION-710: Pratik Datta to Add reference to XPath profile in the XML Signature 2.0 doc
ACTION-711: Meiko Jensen to Add QnameAware elements and IDAttributes element to the examples (or check whether they're in and correct)
ACTION-712: Pratik Datta to XPathAware child element of QNameAware to C14n2
ACTION-713: Bruce Rich to Review XML Signature 2.0 requirements, http://www.w3.org/2008/xmlsec/Drafts/xmlsec-reqs2/Overview.html
ACTION-714: Pratik Datta to Add warning in c14n 2.0 about not parsers not allowing to redefine xml* prefixes
ACTION-715: Pratik Datta to Add content on scanning algorithm (augment to remove duplicates), and information on where to emit the namespace declaration
ACTION-716: Meiko Jensen to Propose text for xpath and best practices
ACTION-717: Pratik Datta to Document the Performance improvements with 2.0
ACTION-718: Frederick Hirsch to Create performance data draft
ACTION-719: Thomas Roessler to Prepare for additional XML Signature 1.1 Last Call starting 9 November and ending 30 November 2010
ACTION-720: Thomas Roessler to Update SOTD for XML Signature 1.1 Last Call publication
ACTION-721: Thomas Roessler to Review proposal for change to XML Encryption in response to EXI comment, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Oct/0045.html
ACTION-722: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption with proposal noted in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Oct/0045.html
ACTION-723: Pratik Datta to Incorporate changes to XPath profile based on joint xslt/xquery F2F meeting, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2010Nov/att-0000/minutes-2010-11-01.html#item07
ACTION-724: Frederick Hirsch to Update change explanation for XML Signature 1.1
ACTION-725: Frederick Hirsch to Update change explanation for XML Encryption
ACTION-726: Frederick Hirsch to Complete last call comment processing for exi, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010May/0062.html
ACTION-727: Magnus Nystrom to Share updated PBKDF2 and concatkdf test cases to list
ACTION-728: Pratik Datta to Send summary of differences of xslt and xml security streamability and XPath profiling to list
ACTION-729: Pratik Datta to Highlight potential issue with non-support for xml:base through removal of inclusive in xml signature and c14n2 drafts
ACTION-730: Thomas Roessler to Check if 1.0 comment list for xml signature is forward to our active errata list
ACTION-731: Frederick Hirsch to Respond to Sampo re http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Nov/0010.html
ACTION-732: Frederick Hirsch to Add example to signature 2.0 once Meiko shares text on list, see ACTION-711
ACTION-733: Scott Cantor to Implement change for ACTION-638
ACTION-734: Frederick Hirsch to Contact Meiko re actions and schedule
ACTION-735: Pratik Datta to Share original interop test for exclusive c14n that relates to issue
ACTION-736: Pratik Datta to Add grammar to XPath profile
ACTION-737: Pratik Datta to Summarize streamability issues and proposal for resolution to list
ACTION-738: Frederick Hirsch to Summarize roadmap if we were to have multiple document approach for 2.0 with respect to 1.1
ACTION-739: Frederick Hirsch to Update 2.0 processing rules to separate 2.0 and compatibility mode as proposed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2010Dec/0017.html
ACTION-740: Scott Cantor to Provide proposal for change to selection section use of type/subtype, algorithm usages
ACTION-741: Scott Cantor to Summarize schema issues with Verification elements
ACTION-742: Scott Cantor to Propose text regarding 6.7.1.1 and use of c14n2
ACTION-743: Hal Lockhart to Look for soap example from sx examples document suitable for 2.0, showing qnames, eg. xsi:type and use of ids
ACTION-744: Frederick Hirsch to Implement change to 2.0 requirements document, to Remove section 3.2.3, Replace "some grammar" with "a mechanism" in section 3.2.2
ACTION-745: Thomas Roessler to Update errata for exclusive c14n per http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2010Nov/0031.html
ACTION-746: Frederick Hirsch to Implement 2.0 mode name change
ACTION-747: Pratik Datta to Update XPath profile for Option 1 in proposal associated with ACTION-737
ACTION-748: Scott Cantor to Update XML Signature 2.0 for Option 1 as proposed for ACTION-737
ACTION-749: Frederick Hirsch to Create conformance section and move 6.1 material to it
ACTION-750: Scott Cantor to Implement change to schema and document for Verification element proposal as noted in message 47 for ACTION-741
ACTION-751: Scott Cantor to Implement change for ACTION-742
ACTION-752: Frederick Hirsch to Implement change to move compatibility material to new section
ACTION-753: Meiko Jensen to Work on creating 2.0 example for Signature 2.0
ACTION-754: Frederick Hirsch to Add new section in 2.0 requirements regarding rational for new XPath profile based on Pratik's proposal
ACTION-755: Thomas Roessler to Send notice of pending CR of XML Signature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 to IETF
ACTION-756: Frederick Hirsch to Share notice of pending CR with OASIS
ACTION-757: Frederick Hirsch to Review section references in 1.1
ACTION-758: Pratik Datta to Update abstract and intro of c14N2 to remove relationship to C14N1 and exclusive in abstract and explain relationship in intro
ACTION-759: Pratik Datta to Update requirements section of c14n2 with context/exclusive c14n requirement and description
ACTION-760: Thomas Roessler to Help simplify and clarify processing for Curie in C14N2
ACTION-761: Thomas Roessler to Explain importance and need for Curie support
ACTION-762: Frederick Hirsch to Clarify ACTION-729
ACTION-763: Pratik Datta to Review ISSUE-198 and where algorithm should be placed
ACTION-764: Brian LaMacchia to Review placement of base64 alg in 1.1/2.0, should it be under transforms?
ACTION-765: Frederick Hirsch to Review 1.1 requirements and signature 1.1 and encryption 1.1 explain documents
ACTION-766: Brian LaMacchia to Implement change for base64
ACTION-767: Magnus Nystrom to Review XML Encryption 1.1 references to external document sections, explain document and requirements
ACTION-768: Meiko Jensen to Follow up on ISSUE-226 and byte range with Henrich
ACTION-769: Pratik Datta to Add note to XML SIgnature to clarify use of id with URI versus XPath
ACTION-770: Thomas Roessler to Figure out publication mechanics around CR & ECC
ACTION-771: Frederick Hirsch to Review 1.1 requirements issues with Magnus
ACTION-772: Scott Cantor to Add wording about using IncludedXPath in favor of PositionAssertion
ACTION-773: Pratik Datta to Update signature 2.0 related to id and XPath
ACTION-774: Pratik Datta to Apply ID/IncludedXPath change to additional selection type
ACTION-775: Pratik Datta to Research XPath 1 vs 2 differences
ACTION-776: Frederick Hirsch to Ask xml cg about xpath 1, 2, 3
ACTION-777: Frederick Hirsch to Check with Magnus re Microsoft and streaming implementation, XPath version choice
ACTION-778: Pratik Datta to Propose changes to the XPath profile related to using XPath 2.0
ACTION-779: Gerald Edgar to Review test cases for 1.1 and summarize which are missing
ACTION-780: Frederick Hirsch to Bring base64 work forward to 2.0, ISSUE-224
ACTION-781: Thomas Roessler to Check on commit message mechanism for xmlsec
ACTION-782: Scott Cantor to Update draft with change to 10.7.2
ACTION-783: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare publication drafts for validity, links and initial pubrules
ACTION-784: Thomas Roessler to Prepare 2.0 drafts for publication on 24 March 2011
ACTION-785: Meiko Jensen to Confirm that best practices have been documented for ISSUE-159
ACTION-786: Thomas Roessler to Update PAG charter to fix broken link to mailing list archive, Archive is misspelled, correct link is http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec-pag/
ACTION-787: Frederick Hirsch to Update algorithms cross reference including impact of 2.0 on algorithms cross-reference, ISSUE-208
ACTION-788: Frederick Hirsch to Contact Juan Carlos re XML Security 2.0 review
ACTION-789: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up with XML Coordination WG re XML Security 2.0 review
ACTION-790: Frederick Hirsch to Ask Makoto re XML Security 2.0 security review, with ePub consideration
ACTION-791: Thomas Roessler to Request SAAG review of XML Sec 2.0 once spec is in LC
ACTION-792: Thomas Roessler to Prepare Last Call publication, for publication by next week
ACTION-793: Gerald Edgar to Review 1.1 interop to determine which gaps we have in 1.1 testing itself
ACTION-794: Pratik Datta to Add test case prefix rewriting
ACTION-795: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare documents for publication
ACTION-796: Thomas Roessler to Review xml sec charter extension, see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-xmlsec/2011Apr/0001.html, with possibility of 9 months vs 1 year
ACTION-797: Frederick Hirsch to Coalesce performance actions
ACTION-798: Frederick Hirsch to Update publications page and web page with 2.0 Last call and updated publications
ACTION-799: Pratik Datta to Update C14N2 draft with note to clarify whitespace definition as XML definition, provide warning re using other libraries like Java
ACTION-800: Pratik Datta to Update C14N for 1-1 prefix to uri mapping
ACTION-801: Frederick Hirsch to Review C14N2 test case document
ACTION-802: Pratik Datta to Review comments from XML Core WG and formulate response, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Jun/0005.html
ACTION-803: Frederick Hirsch to Propose language re xmlsec required for suite b description by Cynthia
ACTION-804: Frederick Hirsch to Send email to set up offline interop discussion with Microsoft, Oracle, Signature 1.1, Encryption 1.1
ACTION-805: Frederick Hirsch to Review ISSUE-132
ACTION-806: Frederick Hirsch to Review ISSUE-132, whether we need XML Encryption update to reflect changes in Signature 2.0 transform model
ACTION-807: Frederick Hirsch to Create draft for use of 2.0 transforms in XML Encryption 1.1
ACTION-808: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC for publication of encryption 2.0 transform draft
ACTION-809: Pratik Datta to Fix examples in signature 2.0
ACTION-810: Pratik Datta to Review and respond to additional XML Core WG comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Jun/0005.html
ACTION-811: Cynthia Martin to Update wiki with suite b changew
ACTION-812: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare XML Enc 2.0 transforms for publication
ACTION-813: Thomas Roessler to Update errata for XML Enc 1.1 with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Jun/0047.html
ACTION-814: Magnus Nystrom to Make namespace ("&xenc;") related edits in XML Encryption 1.1
ACTION-815: Frederick Hirsch to Respond to marcos re cert order
ACTION-816: Frederick Hirsch to Update SIgnature 1.1 and 2.0 with change of SHOULD in 4.5
ACTION-817: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare and submit best practices draft for publication
ACTION-818: Frederick Hirsch to Check in test cases document distributed by Gerald
ACTION-819: Pratik Datta to Update 2.0 11.3 text, including changes discussed in email http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Aug/0000.html
ACTION-820: Thomas Roessler to Remind WG how to deprecate RetrievalMethod in 1.1 and disallow in 2.0 appropriately
ACTION-821: Frederick Hirsch to Post suite b interop material from Cynthia
ACTION-822: Frederick Hirsch to Propose XML Encryption 1.1 changes
ACTION-823: Frederick Hirsch to Update 2.0 spec to treat RetrievalMethod same as in 1.1, specifically not disallow Transform within RetrievalMethod
ACTION-824: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml encryption schema and specification with addition of type for Algorithm in AlgorithmIdentifierType
ACTION-825: Frederick Hirsch to Make formal response, import is for ds:Digest which is from original schema, hence no change needed
ACTION-826: Frederick Hirsch to Check with tlr re removing (and archiving) section 8 from xml encryption 1.1
ACTION-827: Thomas Roessler to Advise on how to close LC-2372 if no response received from submitter of comment for resolution
ACTION-828: Hal Lockhart to Propose additional text for security considerations of xml encryption
ACTION-829: Scott Cantor to Provide additional proposal text regarding xml encryption changes for pkcs1.5
ACTION-830: Pratik Datta to Compose draft response for LC-4288 and share on xmlsec list for review
ACTION-831: Frederick Hirsch to Update xsd schemas with copyright and update RNG schema copyrights
ACTION-832: Frederick Hirsch to Respond to makoto re schema issue
ACTION-833: Frederick Hirsch to Send response re canonical xml
ACTION-834: Thomas Roessler to Review XML Signature 1.1 and 2.0 treatment of RetrievalMethod
ACTION-835: Frederick Hirsch to Check documents for up to date IETF references
ACTION-836: Thomas Roessler to Close this action
ACTION-837: Brian LaMacchia to Provide guidance text and to review SHA-1 with OAEP
ACTION-838: Frederick Hirsch to Update explanation of changes for XML Signature 1.1
ACTION-839: Frederick Hirsch to Update explanation of changes for XML Encryption 1.1
ACTION-840: Pratik Datta to Update XML Signature 1.1 and 2.0 with change in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Oct/0006.html
ACTION-841: Pratik Datta to Add link to canonical XML 2.0 samples into the spec
ACTION-842: Frederick Hirsch to Propose updated spec language to address OAEP and SHA-1 issue
ACTION-843: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up on possible additional interop participants
ACTION-844: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption 1.1 with changes in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Oct/0024.html
ACTION-845: Frederick Hirsch to Propose URI for sha 2 for mgf function
ACTION-846: Frederick Hirsch to Update algorithm cross-reference to reflect changes for xml encryption 1.1
ACTION-847: Pratik Datta to Propose update to 2.0 algorithm requirements to encourage authenticating mode
ACTION-848: Bruce Rich to Contact OASIS ebXML community regarding large data issue and GCM
ACTION-849: Frederick Hirsch to Contact Microsoft re GCM and WS-Policy
ACTION-850: Hal Lockhart to Review XML Encryption 1.1 security considerations and propose changes in light of today's discussion
ACTION-851: Pratik Datta to Propose text regarding KeyLength and PBKDF2, assuming we do not change the schemna
ACTION-852: Frederick Hirsch to C14n2 and enc 1.1 test cases to publication list
ACTION-853: Frederick Hirsch to Add new security issue later this week
ACTION-854: Frederick Hirsch to Talk with thomas about encouraging implementation support for AES-GCM in existing algorithms
ACTION-855: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption 1.1 draft for AES-GCM mandatory to implement
ACTION-856: Brian LaMacchia to Discuss with magnus possible encryption algorithms suitable for streaming
ACTION-857: Pratik Datta to Ask regarding risk of use of GCM without checking tag during processing
ACTION-858: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC for resolution to Publish CR drafts of Canonical XML 2.0, XML Signature 2.0 and Streaming Profile of XPath 1.0 this month
ACTION-859: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC to move XML Encryption 1.1 CipherReference Processing using 2.0 Transforms to LC
ACTION-860: Frederick Hirsch to Review ACTION-841
ACTION-861: Frederick Hirsch to Send message re closing ISSUE-230
ACTION-862: Hal Lockhart to Review FIPS and RSA-OAEP question in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2011Dec/0001.html
ACTION-863: Frederick Hirsch to Confirm correctness of C14N2 test case reference after publication
ACTION-864: Frederick Hirsch to Implement CR transition
ACTION-865: Frederick Hirsch to Contact parties re participation in interop for 2.0
ACTION-866: Scott Cantor to Review XML Encryption 1.1 for schema and text description consistency and clarity
ACTION-867: Frederick Hirsch to Review XML Encryption 1.1 for schema and text description consistency and clarity
ACTION-868: Frederick Hirsch to Raise RFC 6476 with magnus
ACTION-869: Frederick Hirsch to Contact Brian/Magnus re 1.1 interop
ACTION-870: Scott Cantor to Check with John Bradley re JSON plans re MAC+CBC
ACTION-871: Frederick Hirsch to Check with Microsoft regarding plans for JSON
ACTION-872: Gerald Edgar to update interop status tables to reflect additional tests that need to be added
ACTION-873: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare XML Encryption 1.1 and CipherReference Processing drafts for CR publication, make transition request etc
ACTION-874: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption 1.1 (including draft for CR publication) with changes for ACTION-867
ACTION-875: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Signature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 to reference developer explain from sotd, including draft being prepared for CR publication
ACTION-876: Gerald Edgar to Update test cases tables and send update to public list
ACTION-877: Frederick Hirsch to Review 1.1 interop test document against explain summariy
ACTION-878: Frederick Hirsch to Update developer explain documents as on Note track
ACTION-879: Frederick Hirsch to Create draft interop test report, run assumptions by the team
ACTION-880: Pratik Datta to Contact sean regarding signature 1.1 interop and whether x509 enhancements were implemented
ACTION-881: Frederick Hirsch to Ask magnus re xml encryption 1.1 test cases document
ACTION-882: Frederick Hirsch to Ask bruce rich about xml encryption 1.1 interop
ACTION-883: Frederick Hirsch to Review C14N 20 test cases document
ACTION-884: Frederick Hirsch to Review CR features at risk for Signature Properties
ACTION-885: Pratik Datta to Update test cases document and send email clarifying changes
ACTION-886: Frederick Hirsch to Update XMLSignature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 interop test reports to remove unneeded tests
ACTION-887: Hal Lockhart to Draft text on HMAC truncation for XML Signature best practices
ACTION-888: Pratik Datta to Distribute test case and result for testing XML Signature 1.1 HMACOutputLength minimum length
ACTION-889: Frederick Hirsch to Arrange publication of XML Signature Best Practices
ACTION-890: Thomas Roessler to Check with team whether CR draft can have features marked as at risk during CR without an additional LC cycle
ACTION-891: Pratik Datta to Put SHA-224 test cases and results for interop into CVS
ACTION-892: Pratik Datta to Check on adding KeyInfoReference
ACTION-893: Magnus Nystrom to Check on AES-128-GCM interop test
ACTION-894: Thomas Roessler to Discuss with team and director process issues about Signature 1.1/Encryption 1.1 to rec with some optional URIs for algorithms that do not have 2 implementations
ACTION-895: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC to list to close out interop on RSA-OAEP key transport as we have it for one MGF function, question is that enough
ACTION-896: Frederick Hirsch to Share AES-128-GCM on list and add to the test cases document
ACTION-897: Thomas Roessler to Confirm whether two implementations from one author are ok for DEREncodedKeyValue and KeyInfoReference specifically
ACTION-898: Frederick Hirsch to Draft proposal and CfC on list to change algorithm requirement for RSA v1.5
ACTION-899: Frederick Hirsch to Review and propose changes related to 2010 wording
ACTION-900: Pratik Datta to Contact Magnus regarding key agreement test cases and interop
ACTION-901: Frederick Hirsch to Send message to list regarding OCSPResponse and AES-128/192/256-pad Symmetric Key Wrap
ACTION-902: Scott Cantor to Check whether he can resource an additional implementer (Brent) to complete implementation and interop of XML Signature 1.1 X509Digest; DEREncodedKeyValue, KeyInfoReference, to eliminate issue of same author and to obtain two implementations for these
ACTION-903: Pratik Datta to Look into creating KeyInfoReference implementation and interop with Scott
ACTION-904: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up to fix formatting of XML Signature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 schema and examples
ACTION-905: Frederick Hirsch to Edit XML Encryption 1.1 to change RSA 1.5 from Required to Optional
ACTION-906: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Signature for key size language changes
ACTION-907: Frederick Hirsch to Update xml enc reference for SP800-56A
ACTION-908: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Encryption 1.1 to move AES Key Wrap with Padding algorithm material to an informative appendix
ACTION-909: Frederick Hirsch to Update schema formatting in XML Signature 2.0
ACTION-910: Pratik Datta to Update test cases document with new tests, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2012Sep/0020.html
ACTION-911: Frederick Hirsch to Remove OCSPResponse element from XML Signature 1.1 and 2.0 as outlined in the CfC and also remove from the interop test report
ACTION-912: Frederick Hirsch to Put XML Signature 1.1 test case material from wiki into XML Signature 1.1. interop test report
ACTION-913: Frederick Hirsch to Merge XML Encryption 1.1 test case document into XML Encryption 1.1 interop test result document, once Pratik concludes updating XML Encryption 1.1 test case document (ACTION-910)
ACTION-914: Frederick Hirsch to Consult with XML Coordination Group to see if there is a community that would be interested in XML Security 2.0 and how to reach them
ACTION-915: Frederick Hirsch to Bring up issue of XML maintenance at XML Coordination group
ACTION-916: Frederick Hirsch to Outline timeline for completing 1.1 Rec and share with XML Security WG and PAG
ACTION-917: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare XML Signature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 for Last Call publication and make publication request
ACTION-918: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare for FPWD publication of "XML Signature 1.1 Interop Test Report" and "XML Encryption 1.1 Interop Test Report"
ACTION-919: Frederick Hirsch to Prepare XML Signature 1.1 and XML Encryption 1.1 functional explanation documents for publication
ACTION-920: Frederick Hirsch to Check with W3C team on ISSUE-236
ACTION-921: Frederick Hirsch to Update XML Signature 1.1 to address LC-2721
ACTION-922: Frederick Hirsch to Propose additional security consideration for XML Encryption 1.1 key separation and update draft
ACTION-923: Frederick Hirsch to Update Roadmap page to reflect current status
ACTION-924: Thomas Roessler to Confirm ok to add security consideration to XML Encryption 1.1 before PR
ACTION-925: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC to agree to put additional features in potential 1.2 if interest
ACTION-926: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC that WG accepts the added XML Encryption 1.1 security consideration section as currently drafted
ACTION-927: Frederick Hirsch to Make CfC for proposed RESOLUTION: The XML Security working group agrees to progress XML Signature 1.1 to Proposed Recommendation, using the latest editors draft of 13 November 2012 that includes an update in response to LC-2721.
ACTION-928: Frederick Hirsch to Submit transition request to Proposed Recommendation for XML Encryption 1.1, XML Signature 1.1 and XML Signature Properties once Exclusion Period for XML Encryption 1.1 is completed, after 17 December and CfCs approved
ACTION-929: Frederick Hirsch to update XML Signature Best Practices to add latest key separation concern
ACTION-930: Frederick Hirsch to Send CfC for publishing these Notes
ACTION-931: Pratik Datta to Check with Jim D re use of C14N1 in streaming way
ACTION-932: Pratik Datta to Produce a C14N1.2 draft for next week
ACTION-933: Frederick Hirsch to Help Jim get setup with C14N2 source and editing
ACTION-934: Frederick Hirsch to Share link for updating phone numbers for group
ACTION-935: James Dovey to draft use cases and clarifying material for new canonicalization draft
ACTION-936: Thomas Roessler to Share draft charter for XML Security maintenance with WG, clarify whether this will require re-joining
ACTION-937: Frederick Hirsch to Follow up with XML CG about interest and possibility of doing this work in another WG, such as XML Core.
ACTION-938: Pratik Datta to Share XML Normalization with Oracle XML team to determine interest, especially in interop