14:56:31 RRSAgent has joined #swd 14:56:31 logging to http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc 14:56:34 rrsagent, bookmark 14:56:34 See http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T14-56-34 14:56:39 zakim, this will be swd 14:56:39 ok, TomB, I see SW_SWD()11:00AM already started 14:57:12 Clay has joined #swd 14:57:14 Meeting: SWD WG 14:57:18 Chair: Tom 14:57:48 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2008Mar/0060.html 14:57:55 +[LC] 14:57:58 zakim, LC is Clay 14:57:58 +Clay; got it 14:58:00 Previous: http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html 14:58:28 +Ralph 14:58:31 aliman has joined #swd 14:58:40 zakim, who's on the call? 14:58:40 On the phone I see ??P12, Clay, Ralph 14:58:46 zakim, ??p12 is Tom 14:58:52 +Tom; got it 14:59:52 Antoine has joined #swd 14:59:58 Regrets: Elisa, Vit 15:00:12 rrsagent, please make record public 15:00:52 seanb has joined #swd 15:00:54 edsu has joined #swd 15:01:20 +[CTIC] 15:01:26 zakim, [CTIC] is me 15:01:34 +berrueta; got it 15:01:41 Quentin has joined #swd 15:02:02 Scribenick: Clay 15:02:11 Scribe: Clay 15:02:26 +??P39 15:02:36 + +0122427aaaa 15:02:38 +[LC] 15:02:39 dlrubin has joined #swd 15:02:42 zakim, [LC] is edsu 15:02:45 zakim, ??P39 is me 15:02:50 +??P49 15:02:58 +??P59 15:03:14 zakim, vrije is Antoine 15:03:17 zakim, +0122427aaaa is me 15:03:19 Guus has joined #swd 15:03:20 +edsu; got it 15:03:26 +seanb; got it 15:03:30 +??P61 15:03:36 +[VrijeUni] 15:03:42 sorry, Ralph, I do not recognize a party named 'vrije' 15:03:44 +Quentin; got it 15:03:45 zakim, ??P61 is me 15:03:47 zakim, vrije is Antoine 15:03:56 +Guus; got it 15:03:58 sorry, Ralph, I do not recognize a party named 'vrije' 15:04:05 zakim, Guus is really Antoine 15:04:10 +Antoine; got it 15:04:15 zakim, vrije is Guus 15:04:15 sorry, Ralph, I do not recognize a party named 'vrije' 15:04:18 zakim, vrijeuni is Guus 15:04:18 +Guus; got it 15:04:43 Hi all. I'm on the call but I don't know which number I am. 15:04:54 Topic: Admin 15:05:26 ACTION: Chairs to draft charter extension proposal for SKOS until July 1st [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/26-swd-minutes.html#action01] 15:05:30 --continues 15:05:35 +??P5 15:05:42 ACTION: Guus to set up a poll for a meeting 6-8 May with different possible venues Amsterdam, Boston, London or Washington [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action02] 15:05:45 --continues 15:06:53 JonP has joined #swd 15:07:11 Tom: Glitch in March 11 minutes re: pending actions not appearing in agenda or meeting minutes 15:07:35 ... action on Guus re: ISSUE-71 15:07:48 s/action/re: action/ 15:07:53 +Jon_Phipps 15:08:20 zakim, Jon_Phipps is me 15:08:20 +JonP; got it 15:08:20 RESOLVED: Minutes from March 11 accepted 15:09:24 ...action on Alistair to clarify which aspects of extension should be in scope 15:09:32 ... not recorded as closed 15:09:52 Topic: SKOS 15:10:05 ACTION: Alistair and Guus to check the text in the primer on relationship between Concept Schemes and OWL Ontologies. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/29-swd-minutes.html#action13] 15:10:18 --continues 15:10:33 ACTION: Sean to propose a way to handle deprecated properties (updating RDF schema) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/12-swd-minutes.html#action06] 15:10:36 --continues 15:10:42 +Ben_Adida 15:10:45 ACTION: Ralph to check whether the common interpretation of rdfs isDefinedBy fits the reasoning that was made in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2007Oct/0141.html [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/12/18-swd-minutes.html#action10] 15:11:01 --continues 15:11:26 Alistair: re: SKOS-XL 15:11:34 zakim, seanb is really Alistair 15:11:34 +Alistair; got it 15:11:40 zakim, ??p49 is SeanB 15:11:40 +SeanB; got it 15:11:58 ... suggesting that it doesn't have to be in-scope for the current document, can be done afterward 15:12:34 Tom: feedback from ISO11642 group that would like to see this folded into the SKOS reference 15:12:50 zakim, ??p59 is probably dlrubin 15:12:50 +dlrubin?; got it 15:13:18 zakim, who's on the call? 15:13:18 On the phone I see Tom, Clay, Ralph, berrueta, Alistair, Quentin, edsu, SeanB, dlrubin?, Antoine, Guus, Margherita, JonP, Ben_Adida 15:13:20 ... comments from Japanese colleague who needs support for Yomi transcription (alt. forms of a label in transcribed form) 15:14:06 Alistair: possibly leave it for ISO 16642 15:14:13 s/11642/16642/ 15:14:28 ... re Yomi: leave it to labelRelations? 15:15:56 ... the relationship between this class of labels and rdf literals, does what we model in this extension fit these other folks? 15:16:15 s/rdf literals/rdf plain literals/ 15:16:46 Antoine: could we move back label relationship w/r/t SKOS-XL? 15:17:35 ... if some people prefer to use XL, it gives freedom of choice 15:18:00 Alistair: they're not either/or, mutually exclusive 15:18:44 ... what's in the extension builds on the existing label relationship 15:20:28 SKOS-XL -> http://www.w3.org/2006/07/SWD/wiki/SkosDesign/SKOS-XL 15:20:32 Clay: using xl:prefLabel and skos:prefLabel in conjunction was a nice option 15:21:22 ... and skos:LabelRelation 15:22:12 ACTION: Antoine will review a list of proposals w/r/t the relationship between the existing solution and the extensioin 15:22:29 s/a list of/Alistair's 15:23:08 Tom: important to decide if it's in scope or not. Antoine was suggesting it should be in scope. 15:23:24 Ralph: purpose of Antoine's action is to ??? 15:23:53 Antoine: it's more about possibly moving back the existing label relationship to accoomodate the functionality of the extension 15:24:07 q+ 15:24:17 Tom: Antoine, you're suggesting that they both be seen as extensions? 15:24:19 s/???/decide whether Alistair's proposal should be considered for the CR draft 15:24:25 Antoine: yes 15:25:03 Alistair: XL was designed to possibly live in the same space as the existing solution 15:25:33 ... if they live in the same reference the local names would have to change 15:25:50 Tom: designed not to live in the same namespace? 15:26:21 Alistair: if they do live in the same namespace you'd use different local names 15:27:03 Tom: Open SKOS issues 15:27:27 ... re: Alistair and ISSUE-40 15:27:39 ACTION: Alistair to make a proposal for Issue 40 (Concept Coordination) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/29-swd-minutes.html#action09] 15:28:13 --continues 15:28:44 Tom: re: ISSUE-37 for Guus 15:29:04 Alistair: thought that Guus would discuss with Sean 15:29:26 -> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2008Mar/0037.html 15:29:36 Guus: would be useful to discuss 15:30:31 Sean: make broaderGeneric ??? subclassOf 15:31:13 q+ 15:31:42 Guus: if you look at the broader definition it's not clear 15:31:47 ... need more dicussion 15:32:18 Alistair: if you have broaderGeneric as a subproperty of subclassOf 15:32:25 ... through broaderGeneric 15:32:30 ... requires more thought 15:32:46 Sean: no theoretical reason for having super as transitive 15:33:03 Guus: proposal was to write some primer text on it and should be fine 15:33:55 ACTION: Guus to write primer text re: broaderGeneric and equivalence w/r/t subclass 15:34:42 q+ to mention meta-modeling issue 15:36:18 ack aliman 15:36:18 aliman, you wanted to mention meta-modeling issue 15:36:20 Alistair: when you write the part of the primer, consider how it fits with ConceptSchemes and OWL ontologies 15:37:23 Tom: re: ISSUE-67 15:37:39 ... supports the proposed resolution 15:38:39 ... propose to accept issue 67 15:38:54 RESOLVED: StatingFormalDefinitions ISSUE-67 accepted 15:38:56 [[PROPOSED: To state formal aspects of the SKOS data model in the main 15:38:56 body of the SKOS Reference as sentences of prose following the style of 15:38:56 prose used in the RDF Schema specification 15:38:56 . An OWL ontology 15:38:56 will also be given as an appendix to the SKOS Reference, however the 15:38:57 prose in the main body of the SKOS Reference will take precedence. 15:38:59 ]] 15:39:03 -- http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2008Mar/0027.html 15:40:06 Tom: issue-71 and ISSUE-74 15:40:23 ...re: ParallelMappingVocabulary and MappingPropertyConventions 15:40:23 [issue 74 is in Alistair's top 10, 71 is not] 15:40:41 s/not/there as related to 74/ 15:41:17 Alistair:iGuus and broaderMatch as subproperty of broader 15:41:34 -> http://www.w3.org/2006/07/SWD/track/issues/74 "issue 74" MappingPropertyConventions 15:41:37 Guus: nothing happened afterward 15:41:53 -> http://www.w3.org/2006/07/SWD/track/issues/71 "issue 71" ParallelMappingVocabulary 15:42:12 Alistair: if we can fix this it gets a big piece of work out of the way for the reference 15:42:30 ... Guus' proposal is a middle ground and is interesting 15:45:25 ACTION: Alistair to review Antoine and Guus' emails to move ISSUE-71 and -74 15:45:44 I created the ftf poll: 15:45:47 http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/39408/FTF-May-2008-poll/ 15:45:56 -> http://www.w3.org/2006/07/SWD/track/issues/80 "issue 80" SKOS-OWL-Patterns 15:46:05 Tom: re: ISSUE-80...do we need an action associated? 15:46:12 -> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2008Jan/0198.html 15:46:24 Ed: Guus sent a chunk of HTML to be included in primer? 15:46:30 Antoine: issue is more recent 15:47:23 Tom: forwards without an action (re: SKOS-OWL-Patterns (Alistair)) 15:47:41 Guus: I'll try to have this for discussion before next telecon 15:47:55 ... will come back to this after my action 15:48:02 Topic: RDFa 15:48:31 Ben: Ralph, status on primer? 15:48:47 -> http://www.w3.org/News/2008#item44 RDFa Primer updated 15:49:08 Ben: will have several implementations ready before going to candidate rec 15:49:17 -> http://www.w3.org/TR/2008/WD-xhtml-rdfa-primer-20080317/ RDFa Primer W3C Working Draft 17 March 2008 15:49:33 ACTION: Ralph and Ben to publish web version of the new RDFa Primer [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action06] 15:49:35 -- don 15:49:36 -- done 15:49:42 ... I had an action to update the schedule, but haven't had a chance to look 15:49:59 ... had a request to extend deadline to do some XSLT work 15:50:17 -> http://www.w3.org/2008/03/13-rdfa-minutes 13-March RDFa telecon record 15:50:32 ACTION: Ben to prepare draft implementation report for RDFa (with assistance from Michael) [recorded in [recorded in 15:50:34 http://www.w3.org/2008/01/22-swd-minutes.html#action14] 15:50:36 --continues 15:50:58 Ben: date of April 21 for review of primer for WG 15:51:11 ... if it works on our end it's a date we can match 15:51:17 ACTION: Ben to clarify target date of publication of primer as note and update deliverables page [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/04-swd-minutes.html#action08] 15:51:18 --done 15:52:00 -Ben_Adida 15:52:00 Topic: Recipes 15:52:26 Diego: re: Cool URIs 15:52:41 ... I raised three comments , third was a mistake 15:53:16 ... I agree with sprit of first two and his view is better than ours but more complex to implement in Apache 15:53:41 ... decide if we want to change our current recipes or keep as is 15:53:56 s/decide/we need to decide/ 15:54:24 Ralph: i haven't discussed this with Tim 15:54:43 ... I think it might be a mistake to complicate the recipes 15:55:00 q+ to say on q-value 15:55:27 Ed: my only suggestion was to explicitly state that this was for Apache and .htaccess and mod_rewrite 15:56:30 Tom: perhaps sounds like a good solution as well 15:57:13 ... if the authors wish to keep the technical scope the same as it is now, that is good 15:57:30 Jon: inclined to agree with Ralph to not make the doc more complex 15:58:11 ... scope of this doc was for relative simplicity 15:59:38 ACTION: recipes editors to clarify and write some sentences for the title that spells out the points Ed made for .htaccess and Apache 16:00:47 q- 16:01:06 ACTION: Diego, Jon and Ralph to coordinate Recipes examples for w3c site [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action09] 16:01:09 --continues 16:01:16 ACTION: Ralph propose resolution to ISSUE-16 "Default behavior" [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/01/22-swd-minutes.html#action14] 16:01:18 --continues 16:01:23 ACTION: Ralph/Diego to work on Wordnet implementation [of Recipes implementations] [recorded in [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/22-swd-minutes.html#action20] 16:01:25 --continues 16:01:33 Topic: Vocabulary Management 16:01:34 -> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2008Mar/0061.html new Vocab Mgmnt editor's draft 16:01:44 Tom: Elisa has posted a doc for review 16:01:54 s/draft/draft published/ 16:02:03 -> http://www.w3.org/2006/07/SWD/Vocab/principles-20080316 16-March Vocab Mgmnt Editor's draft 16:02:10 ... need reviewers for completion 2 weeks from now 16:02:26 Diego: I volunteer. 16:02:54 Guus: Tom? 16:03:08 Tom: will review, but would like antoher reviewer 16:03:21 Guus: Mark from Wordnet to review possibly? 16:03:24 Tom: that's fine 16:04:39 ACTIO: Guus to ask Mark van Assem to review VM Editor's Draft 16:04:56 Tom: please respond to Guus' poll about dates 16:05:01 s/ACTIO:/ACTION:/ 16:05:08 -dlrubin? 16:05:12 -edsu 16:05:12 seanb has left #swd 16:05:14 -Ralph 16:05:15 -Alistair 16:05:18 -Antoine 16:05:19 -Quentin 16:05:19 -SeanB 16:05:21 -berrueta 16:05:22 -JonP 16:05:23 -Margherita 16:05:29 dlrubin has left #swd 16:05:35 zakim, list attendees 16:05:35 As of this point the attendees have been Clay, Ralph, Tom, berrueta, edsu, Quentin, Antoine, Guus, Margherita, JonP, Ben_Adida, Alistair, SeanB, dlrubin? 16:05:45 [ah, thanks, Guus; I mis-heard "Mark van Assem" -- thought you'd mentioned a different Mark] 16:05:54 rrsagent, please draft minutes 16:05:54 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-minutes.html Clay 16:07:19 Ralph: I might email with you some questions, but no need to rejoin. Thanks. 16:07:27 great 16:08:37 -Clay 16:09:54 edsu has left #swd 16:18:40 -Guus 16:18:43 -Tom 16:18:44 SW_SWD()11:00AM has ended 16:18:45 Attendees were Clay, Ralph, Tom, berrueta, edsu, Quentin, Antoine, Guus, Margherita, JonP, Ben_Adida, Alistair, SeanB, dlrubin? 16:58:25 zakim, bye 16:58:25 Zakim has left #swd 16:58:27 rrsagent, bye 16:58:27 I see 16 open action items saved in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-actions.rdf : 16:58:27 ACTION: Chairs to draft charter extension proposal for SKOS until July 1st [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/26-swd-minutes.html#action01] [1] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-05-26 16:58:27 ACTION: Guus to set up a poll for a meeting 6-8 May with different possible venues Amsterdam, Boston, London or Washington [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action02] [2] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-05-42 16:58:27 ACTION: Alistair and Guus to check the text in the primer on relationship between Concept Schemes and OWL Ontologies. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/29-swd-minutes.html#action13] [3] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-10-05 16:58:27 ACTION: Sean to propose a way to handle deprecated properties (updating RDF schema) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/12-swd-minutes.html#action06] [4] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-10-33 16:58:27 ACTION: Ralph to check whether the common interpretation of rdfs isDefinedBy fits the reasoning that was made in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2007Oct/0141.html [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/12/18-swd-minutes.html#action10] [5] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-10-45 16:58:27 ACTION: Antoine will review a list of proposals w/r/t the relationship between the existing solution and the extensioin [6] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-22-12 16:58:27 ACTION: Alistair to make a proposal for Issue 40 (Concept Coordination) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/29-swd-minutes.html#action09] [7] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-27-39 16:58:27 ACTION: Guus to write primer text re: broaderGeneric and equivalence w/r/t subclass [8] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-33-55 16:58:27 ACTION: Alistair to review Antoine and Guus' emails to move ISSUE-71 and -74 [9] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-45-25 16:58:27 ACTION: Ralph and Ben to publish web version of the new RDFa Primer [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action06] [10] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-49-33 16:58:27 ACTION: Ben to prepare draft implementation report for RDFa (with assistance from Michael) [recorded in [recorded in [11] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-50-32 16:58:27 ACTION: Ben to clarify target date of publication of primer as note and update deliverables page [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/04-swd-minutes.html#action08] [12] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-51-17 16:58:27 ACTION: recipes editors to clarify and write some sentences for the title that spells out the points Ed made for .htaccess and Apache [13] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T15-59-38 16:58:27 ACTION: Diego, Jon and Ralph to coordinate Recipes examples for w3c site [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/11-swd-minutes.html#action09] [14] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T16-01-06 16:58:27 ACTION: Ralph propose resolution to ISSUE-16 "Default behavior" [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/01/22-swd-minutes.html#action14] [15] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T16-01-16 16:58:27 ACTION: Ralph/Diego to work on Wordnet implementation [of Recipes implementations] [recorded in [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/01/22-swd-minutes.html#action20] [16] 16:58:27 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/03/18-swd-irc#T16-01-23