16:13:03 RRSAgent has joined #ws-policy-eds 16:13:03 logging to http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc 16:14:10 maryann has joined #ws-policy-eds 16:15:17 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy-eds/2007May/0122.html 16:15:38 agenda pointer is above 16:15:47 chair: Maryann 16:16:25 Present: David O, Prasad, Asir, Maryann 16:16:36 Regrets: Toufic, Frederick 16:17:03 Present: David O, Prasad, Asir, Felix, Maryann 16:18:42 meeting: WS Policy WG (editor's f2f May 2007) 16:18:50 agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy-eds/2007May/0122.html 16:18:54 rrsagent, make log public 16:19:04 scribe: asir 16:21:25 Topic: Administrivia 16:22:06 dorchard has joined #ws-policy-eds 16:23:12 Last week minutes are okay 16:24:14 Next meeting arrangements: 16:24:20 Chair –Asir 16:24:20 Scribe - Maryann 16:24:41 Future Chair Rotation: Toufic, Frederick, Maryann, Asir, DaveO, Prasad 16:24:41 Scribe Rotation: DaveO, Toufic, Frederick, Maryann, Asir, Prasad 16:25:09 Action-249 Open 16:25:39 Action-265 closed 16:26:01 Action-268 is closed 16:27:40 Action-269 to 273 is Asir 16:28:09 Action-274 is Asir 16:29:42 Action-275 is Maryann 16:30:15 Action-267 is Maryann 16:30:44 Action-277 is dup 16:32:11 Action-278 is Prasad 16:32:45 Action-279 is Prasad 16:33:03 Action-280 is Prasad 16:35:47 Action-283 is Felix 16:37:55 Action-284 is DaveO 16:38:00 Action-285 is DaveO 16:38:38 Action-286 is Asir 16:39:01 fsasaki has joined #ws-policy-eds 16:39:02 Action-287 is closed 16:39:52 Action-288 is Prasad 16:39:56 Action-289 is Asir 16:41:16 Action-290, 291 is Prasad 16:41:35 Action-292 is Maryann 16:41:45 Action-293 is Maryann 16:43:06 Action-294 is Prasad 16:44:13 Action-295 is Asir 16:44:26 Action-296 is Prasad 16:46:32 We'll have a conference call next week 16:46:42 Tentative 16:51:34 Need to figure out when the Framework and Attachement drafts would be delivered (that includes current actions + 4544 16:56:52 Paul: plan to meet with Tim July 2nd 16:57:03 s/July/in July/ 16:57:34 Need updated drafts of the Framework and Attachment 2 weeks prior to July 2nd 17:01:22 Action: David to implement the resolution for issue 4544 17:01:23 Created ACTION-297 - Implement the resolution for issue 4544 [on David Orchard - due 2007-05-31]. 17:01:29 When the WG approves 17:03:48 Topic: Schedule 17:04:32 Deliver Framework and Attachment drafts to the WG by Wed May 30th 17:05:54 Deadline for Framework and Attachment related check ins is Tuesday May 29th 17:06:17 s/Tuesday/COB Tuesday/ 17:06:45 Action: Asir to generate diff docs for Framework and Attachment drafts by Tuesday May 29th 17:06:46 Created ACTION-298 - Generate diff docs for Framework and Attachment drafts by Tuesday May 29th [on Asir Vedamuthu - due 2007-05-31]. 17:07:19 Action: Maryann to deliver the updated Framework and Attachment drafts to the WG on Wednesday May 30th 17:07:19 Created ACTION-299 - Deliver the updated Framework and Attachment drafts to the WG on Wednesday May 30th [on Maryann Hondo - due 2007-05-31]. 17:13:26 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-minutes.html fsasaki 17:27:41 Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. 17:27:49 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. 17:28:00 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-minutes.html fsasaki 17:28:44 trackbot has joined #ws-policy-eds 17:28:50 Tracking ISSUEs and ACTIONs from http://www.w3.org/2005/06/tracker/wspolicyeds/ 17:29:09 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. 17:30:44 trackbot has joined #ws-policy-eds 17:30:50 Tracking ISSUEs and ACTIONs from http://www.w3.org/2005/06/tracker/wspolicyeds/ 17:31:20 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. 17:32:44 trackbot has joined #ws-policy-eds 17:32:50 Tracking ISSUEs and ACTIONs from http://www.w3.org/2005/06/tracker/wspolicyeds/ 17:36:49 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject - such as service, endpoint, operation and message. 17:36:49 Created ACTION-303 - [Guidelines] update the best practice \"Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject\" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject - such as service, endpoint, operation and message. [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:36:49 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the bumper sticker "Choose a Granular Policy Subject" with "Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject". 17:36:49 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject" with s/that the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies to/to which the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies/ 17:36:49 Created ACTION-304 - [Guidelines] Update the bumper sticker \"Choose a Granular Policy Subject\" with \"Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject\". [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:36:54 Created ACTION-305 - [Guidelines] Update the best practice \"Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject\" with s/that the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies to/to which the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies/ [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:45:23 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Specify Preferred Attachment Point for an Assertion" with s/multiple points/multiple attachment points/ 17:45:23 Created ACTION-306 - [Guidelines] Update the best practice \"Specify Preferred Attachment Point for an Assertion\" with s/multiple points/multiple attachment points/ [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:47:17 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice bump sticker with "Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type" 17:47:17 Created ACTION-307 - [Guidelines] Update the best practice bump sticker with \"Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type\" [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:48:13 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type" with s/A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion./A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion type/ 17:48:13 Created ACTION-308 - [Guidelines] Update the best practice \"Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type\" with s/A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion./A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion type/ [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 17:56:58 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update Section 5.8 to use the Arch of the WWW format plus add an example 17:56:58 Created ACTION-309 - [Guidelines] Update Section 5.8 to use the Arch of the WWW format plus add an example [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 18:00:15 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice bumper sticker "Use Independent Assertions for Multiple Versions of a Behavior" to "Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior" 18:00:15 Created ACTION-310 - [Guidelines] update the best practice bumper sticker \"Use Independent Assertions for Multiple Versions of a Behavior\" to \"Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior\" [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 18:01:20 Action: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior" to "An assertion author should use different assertions for modeling different versions of a behavior" 18:01:20 Created ACTION-311 - [Guidelines] update the best practice \"Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior\" to \"An assertion author should use different assertions for modeling different versions of a behavior\" [on Everyone Everyone - due 2007-05-31]. 18:40:20 Action: Asir to [Framework] implement the resolution for issue 4579 18:40:20 Created ACTION-312 - [Framework] implement the resolution for issue 4579 [on Asir Vedamuthu - due 2007-05-31]. 18:56:20 maryann has left #ws-policy-eds 20:49:55 rrsagent, bye 20:49:55 I see 16 open action items saved in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-actions.rdf : 20:49:55 ACTION: David to implement the resolution for issue 4544 [1] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-01-22 20:49:55 ACTION: Asir to generate diff docs for Framework and Attachment drafts by Tuesday May 29th [2] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-06-45 20:49:55 ACTION: Maryann to deliver the updated Framework and Attachment drafts to the WG on Wednesday May 30th [3] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-07-19 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. [4] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-27-49 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. [5] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-29-09 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject – such as service, endpoint, operation and message. [6] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-31-20 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Assertion Description Should Specify a Policy Subject" with Assertion authors should specify the set of relevant policy subjects with which the assertion may be associated. For instance, if a policy assertion is to be used with WSDL, the assertion description should specify a WSDL policy subject - such as service, endpoint, operation and message. [7] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-36-49 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the bumper sticker "Choose a Granular Policy Subject" with "Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject". [8] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-36-49-2 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Choose the Most Granular Policy Subject" with s/that the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies to/to which the behavior represented by a policy assertion applies/ [9] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-36-49-3 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Specify Preferred Attachment Point for an Assertion" with s/multiple points/multiple attachment points/ [10] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-45-23 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice bump sticker with "Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type" [11] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-47-17 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update the best practice "Describe Semantics of Multiple Assertions of Same Type" with s/A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion./A policy alternative can contain multiple instances of the same policy assertion type/ [12] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-48-13 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] Update Section 5.8 to use the Arch of the WWW format plus add an example [13] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T17-56-58 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice bumper sticker "Use Independent Assertions for Multiple Versions of a Behavior" to "Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior" [14] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T18-00-15 20:49:55 ACTION: Everyone to [Guidelines] update the best practice "Use Independent Assertions for Different Versions of a Behavior" to "An assertion author should use different assertions for modeling different versions of a behavior" [15] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T18-01-20 20:49:55 ACTION: Asir to [Framework] implement the resolution for issue 4579 [16] 20:49:55 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/05/24-ws-policy-eds-irc#T18-40-20 20:49:57 zakim, bye 20:50:06 fsasaki has left #ws-policy-eds