ISSUE-57: Whether to or not to, and are there circumstances in which the order of xsi:type and xsi:nil attributes can be relaxed?

Whether to or not to, and are there circumstances in which the order of xsi:type and xsi:nil attributes can be relaxed?

State:
CLOSED
Product:
EXI Spec
Raised by:
Takuki Kamiya
Opened on:
2010-06-22
Description:
Are there any circumstances in which we can comfortably relax the order constraint of xsi:type and xsi:nil attributes?
Related Actions Items:
No related actions
Related emails:
  1. xsi:nil ordering (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2011-01-11)
  2. RE: EXI: Completed spec. update action from today's telcon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2011-01-07)
  3. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2011-01-07)
  4. RE: EXI: Completed spec. update action from today's telcon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2011-01-06)
  5. Re: EXI: Completed spec. update action from today's telcon (from hmoribe@us.fujitsu.com on 2011-01-06)
  6. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2011-01-06)
  7. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2011-01-06)
  8. EXI: Completed spec. update action from today's telcon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2011-01-05)
  9. Agenda for Tomorrow's telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2011-01-04)
  10. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from liam@w3.org on 2010-12-23)
  11. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-22)
  12. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-22)
  13. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-22)
  14. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from liam@w3.org on 2010-12-22)
  15. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-22)
  16. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from liam@w3.org on 2010-12-22)
  17. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-22)
  18. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-12-22)
  19. RE: Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-12-21)
  20. RE: Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-21)
  21. Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (updated) (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-21)
  22. RE: Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-12-21)
  23. RE: Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-21)
  24. RE: Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-12-21)
  25. Agenda for 22 Dec EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-21)
  26. RE: Agenda for 15 Dec EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-17)
  27. RE: Agenda for 15 Dec EXI Telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-12-17)
  28. RE: Agenda for 15 Dec EXI Telecon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-12-17)
  29. Agenda for 15 Dec EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-14)
  30. Telecon Agenda for Today (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-12-08)
  31. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-12-03)
  32. RE: impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-12-01)
  33. Today's Telecon Agenda (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-12-01)
  34. impact review of ISSUE-57 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-11-24)
  35. AW: Agenda for 24 Nov EXI Telecon (from daniel.peintner.ext@siemens.com on 2010-11-24)
  36. Agenda for 24 Nov EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-11-23)
  37. RE: Agenda for 17 Nov EXI Telecon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-11-16)
  38. Agenda for 17 Nov EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-11-16)
  39. RE: EXI Telecon Agenda, Wednesday, 10 November 2010 (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-11-09)
  40. RE: EXI Telecon Agenda, Wednesday, 10 November 2010 (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-11-09)
  41. RE: EXI Telecon Agenda, Wednesday, 10 November 2010 (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-11-09)
  42. RE: EXI Telecon Agenda, Wednesday, 10 November 2010 (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-11-09)
  43. EXI Telecon Agenda, Wednesday, 10 November 2010 (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-11-09)
  44. RE: Agenda for 02 Nov EXI Telecon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-11-04)
  45. Agenda for 02 Nov EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-11-02)
  46. Re: Agenda for 27 Oct EXI Telecon (from carine@w3.org on 2010-10-27)
  47. RE: Agenda for 27 Oct EXI Telecon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-10-27)
  48. AW: Agenda for 27 Oct EXI Telecon (from daniel.peintner.ext@siemens.com on 2010-10-27)
  49. Agenda for 27 Oct EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-10-26)
  50. Agenda for 13 Oct *Extended* EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-10-19)
  51. Agenda for 13 Oct EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-10-12)
  52. RE: Agenda for 06 Oct EXI Telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-10-06)
  53. RE: Agenda for 06 Oct EXI Telecon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-10-06)
  54. Agenda for 06 Oct EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-10-05)
  55. Agenda for 29 Sep EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-09-28)
  56. Telecon Agenda for today (22 Sept) (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-09-22)
  57. Agenda for 15 Sep EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-09-14)
  58. Agenda for 08 Sep EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-09-07)
  59. Agenda for 01 Sep EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-08-31)
  60. Agenda for 25 Aug EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-08-24)
  61. Agenda for 17 Aug EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-08-17)
  62. Agenda for Tomorrow's Telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-08-10)
  63. Agenda for 28 July EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-07-27)
  64. Agenda for 21 July EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-07-20)
  65. Agenda for 14 July EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-07-13)
  66. RE: Regrets for 7 July telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-07-07)
  67. Regrets for 7 July telecon (from daniel.peintner.ext@siemens.com on 2010-07-07)
  68. Agenda for 7 July telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-07-06)
  69. RE: Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from richroll@agiledelta.com on 2010-07-01)
  70. RE: Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-07-01)
  71. Re: Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from john.schneider@agiledelta.com on 2010-07-01)
  72. RE: Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from msc@mitre.org on 2010-07-01)
  73. RE: Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from Youenn.Fablet@crf.canon.fr on 2010-07-01)
  74. Agenda for 30 June EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-06-29)
  75. Agenda for 23 June EXI Telecon (from tkamiya@us.fujitsu.com on 2010-06-22)
  76. ISSUE-57: Whether to or not to, and are there circumstances in which the order of xsi:type and xsi:nil attributes can be relaxed? [EXI Spec] (from sysbot+tracker@w3.org on 2010-06-22)

Related notes:

Impact review done by TK.
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Nov/0130.html

Takuki Kamiya, 30 Nov 2010, 20:52:26

Two proposals have been made.
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Dec/0007.html (TK)
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Dec/0140.html (JS)

AgileDelta implementation has a problem implementing TK proposal.

On the other hand, TK pointed out negative impact implied by JS's
proposal.
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Dec/0141.html

Takuki Kamiya, 23 Dec 2010, 02:49:41

LQ articulated the criteria W3C team uses in determining
whether changes at this point would require going back to Working Draft.
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Dec/0145.html

Takuki Kamiya, 5 Jan 2011, 00:58:00

On the 1/5/2010 telcon, we resolved to adopt the changes proposed at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2010Dec/0140.html with the phrase "in advance" removed.

John Schneider, 5 Jan 2011, 19:21:10

Youenn created and distributed a test case exercising the changes.
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-exi-wg/2011Jan/0006.html

Takuki Kamiya, 8 Jan 2011, 16:09:00

Display change log ATOM feed

Chair, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: 57.html,v 1.1 2018/11/23 13:51:33 carine Exp $