Minutes WS Choreography WG conference call 10 December 2004


To review final comments on 8th December Editors draft and discuss progression to Last Call.

Dec 8th versions at: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-archive/2004Dec/0019.html


Martin Chapman scribed

IRC log at: http://www.w3.org/2004/12/10-ws-chor-irc

Roll Call:

Martin Chapman
Steve Ross-Talbot
Yves Lafon
Gary Brown
Nickolas Kavantzas
Jeff Mishkinsky
Greg Ritzinger
Charlton Barreto
Anthony Fletcher

Comments on document

Gary's comments: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor/2004Dec/0029.html 
Gary, interaction syntax changed to MAY on exception
nick, need this as cannot guarantee end point projections
SRT, Why not SHOULD then? 
Gary, cdl represents description, impls on each side not relevant
both parties must go into exception state
 nick, cdl is like an interface in wsdl, with a throw declaration you are not sure if it actually happens or can enforce it
mc, difference between declaration and runtime, may is a declaration
SRT, I vote for MUST 
mc, choose between must and should
any objections to MUST?
Approved, change may to must 

Tony's comments
1: typo in example
agree to correction

2: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor/2004Dec/0030.html
need to clarify short circuit evaluation

Gary's response: And in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor/2004Dec/0031.html 

Tony may send in last call comment

SRT comments: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor/2004Dec/0028.html
1: add references - yves will do this before publication
2: sec 1.5 minor rewording - accepted
3: section 2, why was peer to peer removed - no reason but agreed no change
 no more comments

Tony motions to make dec 8 plus agreed changes above to WD,
2nd by Charlton
Passed unanimously

 Nick motions to go into last call with the agreed working draft
Charlton seconds
amendment for last call period to end Jan 31st

unanimous agreement to go into last call with deadline of 31st January 2005
editors to rev and produce xml/html

Next meetings on 14th deck and 4th Jan
mc, need to clean up bugzilla issues
SRT, talk about primer

mc,  last call comment component added to bugzilla so these can be tracked

Chairs thank the editors, and Nick in particular, for their efforts in getting to last call.

Meeting closed