This is a text version of the public questionnaire: "IMSC1 Implementation Questionnaire" We recommend that you only use this review form if you are unable to use the online questionnaire, which is available at: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/1/IMSC1-implementation/ If you choose to send in this questionnaire form instead of using the online questionnaire, please mail the completed form to tmichel@w3.org by 1 January 2017 at 23:59 Boston Time. The online questionnaire helps the W3C Team reduce errors and to compute results automatically. If you believe there is a technical reason why you are unable to use the online questionnaire, please send the relevant information to w3t-sys@w3.org, but in the meantime we welcome your email response to this form. Thank you. ===================== Questionnaire starts I, > > > > --------------------------------- > Contact information > > ---- > Please let us know your contact information. > We require at least your email address. > You may also give us your telephone and address. > > This information will enable the W3C Team to get in touch with you if we > need further information about your implementation experience. > > > Email address (*): Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Company name > > ---- > Please provide your company name developping the implementation you are > reporting in this questionaire. > > Company name (*): > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Implementation Information > > ---- > Please provide your implementation name or code name, version number (if > any). > You may also provide more information about your implementation > (technology, language code used, operating system it is running on. > > Implementation name (*): Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Implementation availability > > ---- > > Is your implementation publicly available? > If yes, can you please provide a link to it, in the following comment > field. > > > * ( ) Yes * ( ) No link to implementation: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Anonymized information > > ---- > The results of this questionaire will be used to draft an Implementation > Report to demonstrate adequate implementation experience and allow IMSC1 > specification to move forward to Proposed Recommendation. > This Implementation Report will be made public. > If you want to anonymize your Company name and your Implementation name > (or code name) and version in the Implementation Report, please let us > know by choosing the appropriate answer: > Your personal information (Name, email) will not be published in the > Implementation Report. > > > [ ] Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > frameSync-1 > > ---- > > > * Test: frameSync1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile > > * Section: Synchronization (Section 6.6) > > > * Description: When played against a 24 fps related video object (see > [2] for example), each subtitle should appear on the frame specified in > its text, with frame 0 corresponding to the related video object frame at > t=0s within the instance document timeline. > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-1 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > > * Description: Maintains 4:3 aspect ratio when rendering the caption > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-2 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio2.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > > * Description: Maintains 16:9 aspect ratio when rendering the caption > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-3 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio3.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > * Description: Maintains 4:3 aspect ratio when rendering the caption > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-4 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio4.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > * Description: Maintains 16:9 aspect ratio when rendering the caption > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-5 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio5.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > > * Description: Fills the related video object when rendering the caption > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > aspectRatio-6 > > ---- > > * Test: aspectRatio6.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile, ittp:aspectRatio > > * Section: ittp:aspectRatio (Section 6.7) > > > * Description: Fills the related video object when rendering the > caption > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > altText-1 > > ---- > > * Test: altText1.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile, ittm:altText > > * Section: ittm:altText (Section 6.7.4) > > > * Description: The contents of altText should not be displayed > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > forcedDisplay-1 > > ---- > > * Test: forcedDisplay1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, itts:forcedDisplay > > * Section: itts:forcedDisplay (Section 6.7.3) > > > * Description: The display of one of the two captions is controlled > through the displayForcedOnlyMode application parameter. > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > linePadding-1 > > ---- > > * Test: linePadding1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ebutts:linePadding > > * Section: ebutts:linePadding (Section 7.4 - Extensions) > > > * Description: See Annex D at https://tech.ebu.ch/docs/tech/tech3380.pdf > The rendered captions should match linePadding1_16x9.png assuming a 16:9 > ratio root container or linePadding1_4x3.png for a 4:3 root container; > the font does not need to be identical. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > multiRowAlign-1 > > ---- > > * Test: multiRowAlign1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ebutts:multiRowAlign > > * Section: ebutts:multiRowAlign (Section 7.4 - Extensions) > > > * Description: See Annex C at https://tech.ebu.ch/docs/tech/tech3380.pdf > The rendered captions should match multiRowAlign1_16x9.png assuming a > 16:9 ratio root container or multiRowAlign1_4x3.png for a 4:3 root > container; the font does not need to be identical. > > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > progressivelyDecodable-1 > > ---- > > * Test: progressivelyDecodable1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, ittp:progressivelyDecodable > > * Section: ittp:progressivelyDecodable (Section 6.7.2) > > > * Description: The presence of the ittp:progressivelyDecodable parameter > should not affect rendering. > > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > referenceFonts-1 > > ---- > > * Test: referenceFonts1.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile, Reference Fonts > > * Section: Reference Fonts (Section 7.3) > > > * Description: The rendered captions should match > referenceFonts1-reference.png. > > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-1 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag0-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: [3] > . > > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-2 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag1-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: > [4]. > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-3 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag2-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: [5]. > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-5 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag4-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: [7]. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-6 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag5-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: [8]. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px)-7 > > ---- > > * Test: track6-frag0-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (640px x 480px) created from > Solekai022_854_29_640x75_MaxSdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > * Description: [9]. > View results in video. > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px)-1 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag0-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px) created from > Solekai023_1920_23_1x1_MaxHdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > > * Description: [10]. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px)-2 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag1-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px) created from > Solekai023_1920_23_1x1_MaxHdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > > * Description: [11]. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px)-3 > > ---- > > * Test: track5-frag2-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Image Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px) created from > Solekai023_1920_23_1x1_MaxHdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > > * Description: [12]. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px)-4 > > ---- > > * Test: track6-frag0-sample1-subs0.ttml > > * Features: Text Profile > > * Section: Maximum rate subtitles (1920px x 1080px) created from > Solekai023_1920_23_1x1_MaxHdSubtitle_v7_subtitles (Section 8.4 - > Extension @) > > > > * Description: [13] , View results in video. > > > > > * ( ) Pass * ( ) Fail * ( ) Not tested Additional comments: > > > These answers were last modified on > by >