HCLSIG/SWANSIOC/Actions/RhetoricalStructure/meetings/20100111

Rhetorical Document Structure Group HCLS SIG W3C, Phone Meeting January 11th 2010

Attendees: Tudor Groza (TG), Paolo Ciccarese (PC), Keith Gutfreund (KG), Anita de Waard (AdW - chair + scribe), Alexandre Passant (AP), Jodi Schneider (JS)

Agenda

• Tudor: update the Introduction of the working group
• Tim: update use case (including some links) with the major classes of publications; look at existing DTDs:
  • NLM DTD: http://dtd.nlm.nih.gov/
  • Elsevier journal DTD: http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find/authorsview.authors/dtds_htm#sec1
  • Highwire DTD: http://schema.highwire.org/public/arthw/
  • Biomed central DTD: http://www.biomedcentral.com/xml/dtdtaggingspec.html
• Keith: markup and/or test the tools on documents looking at the automated tools (Anita will send him the test documents).

Discussions

• Where do references fit in?
  • References should be linked from within rhetorical blocks, but their modeling is not in the scope of the group
  • Connection with the CITO + SWAN citation module that do model references
• Replace the use of the term ontology with model or set of rhetorical elements
• Refinement of objectives
  • Addition of O3 - practical application of the resulted model on scientific documents
  • Addition of O4 - dissemination of achievements
• Consider not-objectives
  • Domain-specific knowledge modeling
  • References modeling

Action items

• Tudor: create ABCDE table for discussions
• Tudor: create draft group roadmap
• Keith: share references on arguments modeling

Dates

• Next call: January 25th 2010 , 9AM Boston / 2PM Irish / 3PM Amsterdam ??