- From: Carlos Iglesias <carlos.iglesias@fundacionctic.org>
- Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2006 16:28:01 +0100
- To: "Shadi Abou-Zahra" <shadi@w3.org>
- Cc: <public-wai-ert-tsdtf@w3.org>
Hi Shadi, everybody. > Thanks for completing your action items! I think you've shown > a couple of inconsistencies and issues with the checklists > that we need to discuss on the teleconference and update. > > Do you have other observations or ideas from carrying out > these reviews? Some random thoughts: - There is a technology dependency (JS) in the sc2.5.1_l1_002 test sample. In this case the related technique is specifically about client-side validation, so it's quite obvious we should need client-side technology, but do we need to explicitly say it in the metadata? (the baseline again) - Right now I still don't get the whole ruleset thing for the objectives of this TF. In the uploaded test cases the rule elements point to an xml document with a series of rulesets. I think we should think about restricting these pointers to direct WCAG2 references. - I'm not sure about how minimal should the test samples be, I mean the sc2.5.1_l1_002 test sample is compound just of a label and an input, it's minimal and complete from the point of view of automatic validation, but it doesn't look complete at all from an user perspective. > Approximately how long did each review take? Let's say between half an hour and three quarters, which I think is too much time, but we should take into consideration that it was a "first review" and it's expected that this time will decrease. > Do you have > ideas for improving the process and reducing the effort > needed for reviews? IMO trying to scrutinize the XML directly is quite a rough work. It may help if we provide a web interface to see the metadata. Obviously as much automatic verification as we can do will also be helpful. Step 3 is a more light process but I think it could also be lightly facilitated if the links to relevant techniques and test procedures are directly provided (instead of having to scrutinize inside the XML again) Regards, CI. -------------------------------------- Carlos Iglesias CTIC Foundation Science and Technology Park of Gijón 33203 - Gijón, Asturias, Spain phone: +34 984291212 fax: +34 984390612 email: carlos.iglesias@fundacionctic.org URL: http://www.fundacionctic.org
Received on Monday, 18 December 2006 15:28:52 UTC