XProc Last Call Comments

Last updated: 13 Nov 2008 at 18:38:00 UTC

67 comments, 67 closed (100.00%)

Hide closed

closed issues and issues where consensus on a resolution has been reached are colour-coded.

Siblings are date-ordered, the more recent the higher up.

Hover over a [+] to see the message date. Click on a [+]/[-] to toggle inline display of a message; Click on a subject to switch to the message itself in the archive.


067.[+] PSVI - err:XD0022 vs. err:XD0023 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: PSVI - err:XD0022 vs. err:XD0023 from Norman Walsh
066.[+] err:XS0012 not needed? from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: err:XS0012 not needed? from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: err:XS0012 not needed? from Norman Walsh
065.[+] Dynamic error for reporting XPath errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Dynamic error for reporting XPath errors from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: Dynamic error for reporting XPath errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Resending - Re: Dynamic error for reporting XPath errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Resending - Re: Dynamic error for reporting XPath errors from Norman Walsh
064.[+] Test namespaces-004 from Norman Walsh on 09-Nov-2008
[+]  RE: Test namespaces-004 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Test namespaces-004 from Norman Walsh
063.[+] Versioning and nested declarations from Norman Walsh on 08-Nov-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Versioning and nested declarations from Norman Walsh
062.[+] No path specified in p:directory-list from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 07-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: No path specified in p:directory-list from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: No path specified in p:directory-list from Norman Walsh
061.[+] Handling of relative URIs in option values from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 07-Nov-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Handling of relative URIs in option values from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: Handling of relative URIs in option values from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: Handling of relative URIs in option values from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: Handling of relative URIs in option values from Norman Walsh
060.[+] Default auth-method in p:http-request from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: Default auth-method in p:http-request from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Default auth-method in p:http-request from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Default auth-method in p:http-request from Norman Walsh
059.[+] p:http-request - base64 encoded response c:body from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: p:http-request - base64 encoded response c:body from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: p:http-request - base64 encoded response c:body from Norman Walsh
058.[+] err:XS0036 vs. err:XS0054 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: err:XS0036 vs. err:XS0054 from mozer
[+]  Re: err:XS0036 vs. err:XS0054 from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: err:XS0036 vs. err:XS0054 from Norman Walsh
057.[+] p:namespace-rename question from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: p:namespace-rename question from mozer
[+]  [closed] Re: p:namespace-rename question from Norman Walsh
056.[+] p:data errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: p:data errors from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: p:data errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: p:data errors from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: p:data errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: p:data errors from Norman Walsh
055.[+] Storing binary data from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 06-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: Storing binary data from Rui Lopes
[+]  Re: Storing binary data from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Storing binary data from Norman Walsh
054.[+] err:XS0043 and err:XS0045 from Norman Walsh on 04-Nov-2008
[+]  RE: XS0043 and err:XS0045 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: XS0043 and err:XS0045 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: XS0043 and err:XS0045 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: err:XS0043 and err:XS0045 from Norman Walsh
053.[+] Creating elements from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 03-Nov-2008
[+]  Re: Creating elements from mozer
[+]  [closed] Re: Creating elements from Norman Walsh
052.[+] Possible problems with unsupported steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 31-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Possible problems with unsupported steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Possible problems with unsupported steps from James Fuller
051.[+] err:XS0003 and err:XS0022 - duplicates? from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 27-Oct-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: err:XS0003 and err:XS0022 - duplicates? from Norman Walsh
050.[+] p:viewport-source - err:XD0006 or err:XD0003? from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 27-Oct-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: p:viewport-source - err:XD0006 or err:XD0003? from Norman Walsh
049.[+] Standard C14N method or option for serialization? from Norman Walsh on 21-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Standard C14N method or option for serialization? from mozer
[+]  [closed] Re: Standard C14N method or option for serialization? from Norman Walsh
048.[+] p:log on atomic steps? from Norman Walsh on 20-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: p:log on atomic steps? from Josh Matthews
[+]  Re: p:log on atomic steps? from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: p:log on atomic steps? from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:wrap-sequence : the context should have access to position() and last() from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: p:wrap-sequence : the context should have access to position() and last() from Norman Walsh
046.[+] href on p:store from Norman Walsh on 19-Oct-2008
[+]  RE: href on p:store from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: href on p:store from Norman Walsh
045.[+] split-sequence: position() and last() from Norman Walsh on 16-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: split-sequence: position() and last() from mozer
[+]  [closed] Re: split-sequence: position() and last() from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: split-sequence: position() and last() from Norman Walsh
044.[+] source on p:error from Norman Walsh on 14-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: source on p:error from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: source on p:error from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: source on p:error from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: source on p:error from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: source on p:error from Norman Walsh
043.[+] Explicit vs. implicit parameter bindings from Norman Walsh on 12-Oct-2008
[+]  RE: Explicit vs. implicit parameter bindings from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Explicit vs. implicit parameter bindings from Norman Walsh
042.[+] Detecting errors from Norman Walsh on 09-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Detecting errors from mozer
[+]  RE: Detecting errors from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Detecting errors from Josh Matthews
[+]  Re: Detecting errors from Josh Matthews
[+]  Re: Detecting errors from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Detecting errors from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Detecting errors from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Detecting errors from Norman Walsh
041.[+] Steps with no input/output ports from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 09-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Steps with no input/output ports from Alex Milowski
[+]  [closed] Re: Steps with no input/output ports from Norman Walsh
040.[+] C14N remark from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 08-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: C14N remark from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: C14N remark from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: C14N remark from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
039.[+] Mutually recursive calling from Innovimax SARL on 06-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Mutually recursive calling from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Mutually recursive calling from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Mutually recursive calling from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Mutually recursive calling from Innovimax SARL
038.[+] On the interpretation of match= from Norman Walsh on 05-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from mozer
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: On the interpretation of match= from Josh Matthews
037.[+] Self importing from Innovimax SARL on 05-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Self importing from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Self importing from Norman Walsh
036.[+] Make 5.7.2 consistent wrt context node from Norman Walsh on 01-Oct-2008
[+]  Re: Make 5.7.2 consistent wrt context node from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Make 5.7.2 consistent wrt context node from Norman Walsh
035.[+] Another look at validate-with-xml-schema from Vasil Rangelov on 28-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: Another look at validate-with-xml-schema from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another look at validate-with-xml-schema from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: Another look at validate-with-xml-schema from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Proposal for XProc: add output port to p:validate-with-xml-schema from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: Proposal for XProc: add output port to p:validate-with-xml-schema from Norman Walsh
033.[+] p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Florent Georges on 24-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Florent Georges
[+]  [closed] Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Rui Lopes
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:validate-with-schematron report defect from Norman Walsh
032.[+] LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Jirka Kosek on 24-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Dave Pawson
[+]  Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Jirka Kosek
[+]  Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: LCWD comment on p:validate-with-schematron from Norman Walsh
031.[+] .xpl? bah humbug from Norman Walsh on 23-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: .xpl? bah humbug from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: .xpl? bah humbug from Norman Walsh
030.[+] LCWD comments from XML Query and XSL WGs from Andrew Eisenberg on 22-Sep-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: LCWD comments from XML Query and XSL WGs from Norman Walsh
029.[+] p:wrap and group-adjacent from Norman Walsh on 21-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: p:wrap and group-adjacent from mozer
[+]  [closed] Re: p:wrap and group-adjacent from Norman Walsh
028.[+] simple rewording in 2.1 Steps from James Fuller on 20-Sep-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: simple rewording in 2.1 Steps from Norman Walsh
027.[+] sync p:option and p:with-option from James Fuller on 19-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: sync p:option and p:with-option from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: sync p:option and p:with-option from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: sync p:option and p:with-option from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: sync p:option and p:with-option from James Fuller
026.[+] justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Dan Connolly on 11-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from mozer
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Dan Connolly
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Dan Connolly
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Dan Connolly
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Dan Connolly
[+]  [closed] Re: justify or remove aliases: base-uri, resolve-uri from Norman Walsh
025.[+] determining an xproc extension attributes from James Fuller on 01-Sep-2008
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from mozer
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from James Fuller
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: determining an xproc extension attributes from Norman Walsh
024.[+] p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL on 28-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: p:option not required without default value from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: p:option not required without default value from Norman Walsh
023.[+] p:pipe convention from James Fuller on 26-Aug-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: p:pipe convention from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:pipe convention from James Fuller
[+]  Re: clarify the difference of usage of p:input in section 5.1.1. from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: clarify the difference of usage of p:input in section 5.1.1. from Norman Walsh
021.[+] foreign namespaces from James Fuller on 26-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from James Fuller
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from mozer
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from James Fuller
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from mozer
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from James Fuller
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from James Fuller
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: foreign namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: foreign namespaces from James Fuller
020.[+] p:encrypt and p:decrypt from James Fuller on 26-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: p:encrypt and p:decrypt from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: p:encrypt and p:decrypt from Norman Walsh
019.[+] Format of hashed values from Norman Walsh on 23-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: Format of hashed values from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Format of hashed values from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Format of hashed values from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: Format of hashed values from Norman Walsh
018.[+] Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh on 21-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Names for p:* steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: Names for p:* steps from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Names for p:* steps from Norman Walsh
017.[+] Re: UUID : add reference from Innovimax SARL on 21-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: UUID : add reference from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: UUID : add reference from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: UUID : add reference from Norman Walsh
016.[+] Re: Kind of node matched from Innovimax SARL on 21-Aug-2008
[+]  RE: Kind of node matched from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Kind of node matched from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Kind of node matched from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Kind of node matched from Innovimax SARL
[+]  ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: ACTION-2008-08-28-03: the kinds of nodes that are legal for all steps from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: Kind of node matched from Norman Walsh
015.[+] Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Innovimax SARL on 21-Aug-2008
[+]  Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: add p:encrypt and p:decrypt optional step from Norman Walsh
014.[+] (still few) troubles with p:namespaces from Innovimax SARL on 21-Aug-2008
[+]  RE: (still few) troubles with p:namespaces from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: (still few) troubles with p:namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: (still few) troubles with p:namespaces from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: (still few) troubles with p:namespaces from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: what about option values on directly invoked p:declare-step from Norman Walsh
012.[+] Re: more PSVI from Norman Walsh on 21-Aug-2008