Disposition of comments for XML 1.1 (Candidate Recommendation)

2003 July 15

Comment ID	Commenter	Comment	WG response	Outcome
Tobin-01	Richard Tobin	requiring the escaping of C1	rejected	accepted
Tobin-02	"	ascii only in xml decl	accepted	accepted
Tobin-03	"	double escaping of control characters	accepted	accepted
Tobin-04	"	production for Char plus the escapable controls	obsolete	accepted
Lewis-01	Amelia A Lewis	inconsistency of S production	accepted-in-principle	accepted
Jeswin-01	Jeswin P	newline problems	rejected	accepted
Stevenson-01	Adam Stevenson	do not support NEL	rejected	-
Cowan-01	John Cowan	Newline mapping	obsolete	accepted
IBM-01	Arnaud Le Hors	NameStartChar not a subset of Char	accepted	accepted
Jelliffe-01	Rick Jelliffe	ambiguity of chars	accepted-in-principle	-
Yergeau-01	François Yergeau	Definition of SHOULD	accepted	accepted
Yergeau-02	"	Unicode normalization of IRIs	accepted	accepted
Harold-01	Elliotte Rusty Harold (via John Cowan)	XML 1.1 isn't worth it	rejected	-
Harold-02	"	normalization in XML 1.1	rejected	No objection but concerned
Carlisle-01	David Carlisle (via John Cowan)	requirement to report non-normalization	(observation only) explained	accepted
Carlisle-02	"	several unclear shoulds	explained	accepted
Waclawek-01	Karl Waclawek (via John Cowan)	doing normalization in the application	(observation only) explained	accepted
Lesch-01	Susan Lesch	minor editorial comments	accepted-in-principle	-
deZeeuw-01	Wout de Zeeuw	Allow hex format for integer types	explained	-
Jelliffe-02	Rick Jelliffe (by way of Paul Grosso)	non-letter characters in Unicode Latin1 block	accepted	accepted
Tang-01	Frank Yung-Fong Tang (by way of John Cowan)	non-letter characters in Unicode Latin1 block	rejected	-
Tang-02	"	non-letter characters in Unicode Latin1 block	accepted-in-part	partial acceptance