FINAL REPORT
DE 4105 - WAI

 

 

Appendix/Deliverable 5.4 - Part of WP05

User Review Campaign report

 

WEB ACCESSIBILITY INITIATIVE

W3C WAI

 

Daniel Dardailler

 

 

TELEMATICS APPLICATIONS PROGRAMME (DISABLED & ELDERLY SECTOR)

Telematics Applications Programme



 

 



 

 

 



Report on Letters to Webmasters sent

From October 1998 to June 1999 some letters have been sent to webmasters of interesting web sites to inform them about the accessibility problems encountered on their web sites. Some design improvements were suggested and it was referred to the BrailleNet white paper and the WAI web site so that then can check the accessibility of their site and understand what could be changed to improve this accessibility. The following table shows the results of the letter actions.

Site name

Site url

Answer

Bibliothèque Nationale de France

www.bnf.fr

No answer but the site has become more accessible

Les trois Suisses

www.3suisses.fr

No answer, no improvement

Reporters sans frontières

www.rsf.fr

No answer

Futuroscope

www.futuroscope.org

We are aware of the problem but it is difficult to solve. Moreover those users belong to a small category of users and we cannot take everyone into account.

Le livre de jeunesse

www.cplj.fr

They wanted to do their best to make the site accessible, and the site has become more accessible.

5th French Television Channel

www.lacinquieme.fr

Positive answer, but no results yet.

French Parliament

www.assemblee-nat.fr

Positive answer. The site will be more accessible.

Mairie of Villeurbanne

www.mairie-villeurbanne.fr

No answer

The Newspaper Libération

www.liberation.com

They are aware of the problem but...

Autonomic exhibition

www.autonomic-expo.com

An answer but no changes

News agency AFP

www.afp.com

The answer was not clear, no changes.

Poste office

www.laposte.fr

No answer

Site of the Prime Minister

www.premier-ministre.gouv.fr

Positive answer, meeting with the person in charge of the site.

Chilian Newspaper

www.lanacion.com

Positive answer. An evaluation of the accessibility of the site has been sent, waiting for results.

Newspaper Le Monde

www.lemonde.fr

Positive answer. Improvements on the site

Webcity, leisure newspaper for Paris

www.cyberparis.com

No positive answer, no interest

The Quid, encyclopedia

www.quid.fr

no answer

Railway company

www.sncf.fr

no answer

Television Newspaper

www.telerama.fr

No answer

Literary magazine

www.magazine-litteraire.fr

no answer

Newspaper l'est républicain

www.estrepublicain.fr

no answer

French German Office for the Youth

www.ofaj.com

no answer

In summary we can say that for many of these sites the accessibility is not a priority but the commercial benefits. Nevertheless we had some good results with some of them, which lead to a co-operation between Braillenet/INSERM and their webmasters to improve the site accessibility.

Level of accessibility of the sites reviewed in the study

Very accessible ***

Medium Accessible **

Merely accessible *

Not accessible -/P>

 

 

 

Site Name

URL

Accessibility

 

L'Humanité

www.humanite.presse.fr

***

 

The New York Times

www.nytimes.com

***

 

The Washington Post

www.washingtonpost.com

***

 

Boston

www.boston.com

***

 

Radio France Internationale

www.rfi.fr

***

 

Le Monde

www.lemonde.fr

**

 

Libération

www.liberation.com

**

 

Le progrès de Lyon

www.leprogres.fr

**

 

Sud Ouest

www.sudouest.com

**

 

Puntofinal

www.puntofinal.cl

**

 

Agence France Presse

www.afp.fr

*

 

Le Parisien

www.leparisien.fr

*

 

Bien Public

www.bienpublic.com

*

 

Le Dauphiné Libéré

www.dauphine-libere.com

*

 

L'Express

www.lexpress.fr

*

 

La Montagne

www.centrefrance.com/iam/

*

Media

L'Alsace

www.alsapresse.com

*

 

Nice Matin

www.nicematin.fr

*

 

France-Ouest

www.france-ouest.com/

*

 

Républicain Lorrain

www.republicain-lorrain.fr

*

 

La Provence

www.laprovence-presse.fr

*

 

TF1

www.tf1.fr

*

 

La Cinquième

www.lacinquieme.fr

*

 

Canal +

www.cplus.fr

*

 

La Naciòn

www.lanacion.com

*

 

Clarín

www.clarin.com

*

 

La Tribune

www.latribune.fr

-

 

La Dépêche du Midi

www.ladepeche.com

-

 

Radio France Outre-Mer

www.rfo.fr

-

 

Europe 1

www.europe1.fr

-

 

France 2

www.france2.fr

-

 

France 3

www.france3.fr

-

 

Métro

www.multimania.com/metro

**

Misc

Site sur les Etoiles

www.heritage.stsci.edu

*

 

 

 

 

 

 

Médecins Sans Frontières

www.msf.org

***

 

One World

www.oneworld.org

***

 

L'ONU

www.un.org

***

 

Union of International Associations

www.uia.org

***

 

Unesco

www.unesco.org

***

 

Banque Mondiale

www.worldbank.org

***

 

Amnesty International

www.amnesty.org

***

National

La Banque Européenne d'Investissement

http://bei.eu.int

***

 

Le Conseil Constitutionnel

www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr

***

&

L'Elysée

www.elysee.fr

**

 

Le Sénat

www.senat.fr

**

 

Assemblée Nationale

www.assemblee-nat.fr

**

International

Union Européenne

http://europa.eu.int

**

 

Site internet Premier Ministre

www.internet.gouv.fr

**

 

Site Premier Ministre

www.premier-ministre.gouv.fr

**

 

Site Commerce Extérieur

www.commerce-exterieur.gouv.fr

*

Institutions

Ministère des affaires Etrangères

www.diplomatie.gouv.fr

*

 

Education Nationale

www.education.gouv.fr

*

 

Ministère des Finances

www.finances.gouv.fr

*

 

Légifrance

www.legifrance.gouv.fr

*

 

Admifrance

www.admifrance.gouv.fr

*

 

Centre Français du commerce Extérieur

www.cfce.fr

*

 

Site Télécommunication

www.telecom.gouv.fr

*

 

Site sur l'An 2000

www.an2000.gouv.fr

*

 

Reporters Sans Frontières

www.rsf.fr

-

 

La Documentation Française

www.ladocfrancaise.gouv.fr

-

 

La Poste

www.laposte.fr

*

 

La SNCF

www.sncf.fr

*

Computing

Air France

www.airfrance.fr

-

 

Les Trois Suisses

www.3suisses.fr

-

Services

Annuaire du shareware

www.anshare.com

***

&

Site sur les listes de diffusion

www.cru-listes.fr/listes

**

Internet

L'Ecole Multimédia

www.ecole-multimedia.com

*

Sites

Handimag

www.handimag.com

***

Specific

Lestrade

http://perso.wanadoo.fr/Lestrade/

**

To

Site du Salon Autonomic

www.autonomic.expo.com

**

Disability

Site de l'UNAPEI

www.unnapei.org

*

 

 

 

INIST

www.inist.fr

***

 

Bibliothèque Nationale de France

www.bnf.fr

**

Public

Centre Georges Pompidou

www.centrepompidou.fr

**

Service

Bibliothèque Publique d'Information

www.bpi.fr

**

 

Cyber Jeunes Emploi

www.paris-jeunes-emploi.org

**

 

Catalogue Collectif de France

www.ccfr.bnf.fr

*

 

Site Gallica de la BNF

 

-

 

Paris Balades

www.parisbalades.com

***

 

Web City

www.webcity.fr

**

 

London Net

www.londonnet.co.uk

**

 

Depeche Mode

www.depechemode.com

**

 

Cyber Paris

www.cyberparis.com

*

Leisure

La Belle d'Oléron

www.labelledoleron.com

*

 

The Rolling Stones

www.the-rolling-stones.com

*

 

Pariscope

www.pariscope.fr

*

 

Le Futuroscope

www.futuroscope.org

-

 

France Loisirs

www.franceloisirs.com

-

 

Télérama

www.telerama.fr

-

 

Site de Jean Louis Aubert

www.jeanlouisaubert.tm.fr

-

 

Site de IAM

www.iam.fr

-

 

Musicanet

www.musicanet.org

***

 

Lafontaine

www.lafontaine.net

***

 

Deutsches Historisches Museum

www.dhm.de/lemo

***

 

Histoire de l'Ile d'Oléron

www.cabuzel.com/oleron

***

Culture

L'Académie Charles Cros

www.tele3.net/cros/index.htm

**

 

Tournesol

www.tournesol-theatre.asso.fr/moliere/sommolie.html

**

 

Zéro Heure

www.00h00.com

*

 

Le Quid

www.quid.fr

*

 

Musiques du Monde

www.mondomix.org

*

 

Amazon

www.amazon.com

*

 

SNV

www.snv.jussieu.fr

***

 

CNED

www.cned.fr

**

Education

CNOUS

www.cnous.fr

*

 

CNED Campus

www.campus-electronique.tm.fr/ie3.htm

*

&

Centre National de Documentation Pédagogique

www.cndp.fr

*

 

Okapi

www.okapi.bayardpresse.fr

-

Training

Okapi web

ww.okapi.bayardprese/f_web.html

-

 

Livre de jeunesseL

www.cplj.fr

-

 

CNED

www.alaska.fr/ead

-

 

CIDJ

www.cidj.asso.fr

-