REFEREE Sample Policy 4

Defer trust to GoodMouseClicking

Scenario
The alternate in sample policy 2 explicitly trusted a single rater of content, Alice. A more likely situation is that we would trust a single auditor (or a small number of auditors) and accept only labels from raters unknown to us but endorsed by the auditor. In this example, we assume that the user trusts GoodMouseClicking to endorse raters. The user sets a policy of trusting reviews from those reviewers for which GoodMouseClicking vouches.
Policy in English
Get the PICS labels about the document as well as GoodMouseClicking's endorsement about the label raters from the label bureau "http://label.com". Allow viewing this URL only if the endorsement is found and the violin rating is less than 2.
Output
TRUE because all conditions stated above match. The PICS label with the endorsement is returned.
Explanation
The module endorse-label is a separate program that handles requests for deferral of trust. It takes a rater and a label bureau as arguments and contacts the label bureau to request labels from the specified rater that vouch for the author of each of the statements on STATEMENT-LIST. When GoodMouseClicking is found to vouch for a statement's author, GoodMouseClicking's identifier is added to the beginning of that statement, and the new statement is returned, to be added to the caller's STATEMENT-LIST. As in the previous examples, the match expression then searches the statement list, in this case for a statement added by the endorse-label program that begins with "mailto:GoodMouseClicking@w3.org."

The same principle can be used to insist on signed labels, in case we are worried about forgeries. Instead of invoking endorse-labels, we could invoke a module that checks a digital signature or performs other types of cryptographic checks.

DIY: Do-It-Yourself
You can either delete "alice@rater.org" from the raters in which GoodMouseClicking vouches for, or change the PICS label's rater to "charles@rater.org". Now you should get 'FALSE' as returned value.

Action: URL:

Corresponding Profiles-0.92 policy for the action:

PICS labels being fetched:

Raters in which GoodMoouseClicking vouches for:


Yang-Hua Chu
Last modified: Fri Dec 13 14:32:33 EST