16:18:40 RRSAgent has joined #aria 16:18:40 logging to http://www.w3.org/2016/03/17-aria-irc 16:18:42 RRSAgent, make logs world 16:18:42 Zakim has joined #aria 16:18:44 Zakim, this will be 16:18:44 I don't understand 'this will be', trackbot 16:18:45 Meeting: Accessible Rich Internet Applications Working Group Teleconference 16:18:45 Date: 17 March 2016 16:18:50 chair: Rich 16:19:05 RRSAgent, make log public 16:23:46 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-aria/2016Mar/0124.html 16:29:02 fesch has joined #aria 16:29:48 present+ Michiel_Bijl Fred_Esch Ja_Eun_Ku Rich_Schwerdtfeger 16:30:51 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-aria/2016Mar/0124.html 16:32:17 present+ Joanmarie_Diggs 16:35:26 clown has joined #aria 16:36:31 mck has joined #aria 16:37:27 scribe: jongund 16:38:06 present+ Joseph_Scheuhammer 16:38:21 cyns has joined #aria 16:38:36 Topic: Technical Plenary 16:38:39 Technical Plenary - 2016 (September 19-23; Lisbon, Portugal). Who will be able to attend? 16:38:48 I will be there. 16:38:51 RS: WHois coming? 16:39:00 CS: I can come 16:39:11 MB: I can come 16:39:18 I will try 16:39:20 FE: I can 16:39:22 RS: I am 16:39:29 MK: Maybe 16:39:39 JG: no 16:39:50 MC: Yes 16:40:10 JN: I will try - if i can get approvals 16:40:17 RS: We have enough to do real work 16:40:27 JD: I will definitely be there 16:40:53 MC: Definiateley, I was assuming, the main question is who we want to meet with 16:41:12 RS: I am hoping september we will be well into testing 16:41:22 RS: We need to hook up with web apps 16:41:35 RS: CS what is going on with the community group 16:41:43 CS: Not a whole lot 16:41:57 RS: What to do something joint? 16:42:05 CS: Let me get back to you on that 16:42:44 RS: What are we going to do on personalization, if media queries are off the table, then we need an API 16:42:51 CS: What type? 16:43:33 RS: In order for us to address cognitive im[airments we need to know what the user needs, this can be done other ways but we need something from the browser 16:44:01 RS: We need to detect things like S/N are low and captions are needed 16:44:17 RS: Smarter apps need more information 16:44:30 RS: Doesn't mean that the API comes out of this group 16:44:42 bgaraventa1979 has joined #aria 16:44:46 CS: I am not sure rosen is the right person 16:44:55 RS: I need to setup a page 16:45:03 present+ Bryan_Garaventa 16:45:15 MC: There is a survey of chairs what they are planning for there working group 16:46:06 RS: We can split things with the .... 16:46:37 MC: You and JS coordinate on meeting schedule 16:46:44 RS: JS needs to be there the whole week 16:47:11 MK: If ARIA can be Thursday and Friday it would be better for me 16:47:31 RS: I don't have a problem 16:47:45 CS: I will be their the whole week 16:48:00 JN: It is in September 16:48:32 RS: RS: I will ask for thursday and friday 16:48:44 MC: You need to fill out the survey 16:49:38 RS: There will be no ARIA working group meeting March 24th 16:49:47 https://www.w3.org/2016/09/TPAC/ 16:50:03 RS: Where is JG on the testing 16:50:28 present+ janina 16:50:56 scribe: matt_king 16:51:24 TOPIC: ARIA 1.1 test effort 16:51:55 rs: Michael has created exit criteria identifiying aria 1.1 changes 16:52:10 rs: defines what is needed for test statements 16:53:05 rs: We need people who have volunteered to write test statements 16:53:18 q+ to ask if the exit criteria delimits what needs to be tested. 16:53:18 rs: It is a bit of an art to do it. 16:53:52 draft status for CR with exit criteria: https://rawgit.com/w3c/aria/CR-pub/aria/aria.html#sotd 16:54:11 jg: In this round, things that have not changed from 1.0, will they be tested? 16:54:35 rs: Right, however, we have a new col in AAM for UIA 16:54:38 Zakim, ack me 16:54:38 clown, you wanted to ask if the exit criteria delimits what needs to be tested. 16:54:40 I see no one on the speaker queue 16:54:56 So, we need to test all aria features for Edge , including 1.0 16:55:16 CS: We are automating that and making good progress. 16:55:41 Joanie: I have added about 200 assertions to webkit 16:55:56 Fred and I need to talk for SVG 16:56:27 RS: Joanie, do you we can automate IA2 or Ma? 16:57:04 CS: Should be easy to port the UIA automated testing to other platforms; will be able to say more in a couple weeks. 16:57:22 Joanie: I will look into Mac 16:57:47 rs: Has MS created 1.1 test cases, or just 1.0? 16:57:47 q+ to note DPub also starting to think test cases 16:58:02 CS: we have done some of 1.1 16:58:15 RS: can you shar with JF? 16:58:24 s/shar/share/ 16:58:50 rs: Have we heard more from Alex about IA2 Express? 16:58:59 CS: No 16:59:40 RS: I don't think we are going to need that if we go to common mappings in the future; not good use of time. 16:59:56 s/IA2 Express/MSAA UIA Express/ 17:00:28 rs: The exit criteria section includes everything we need testable statements for 17:01:19 RS: Where is CRPub? Can we get it with git pull? 17:01:31 MC: Us git sync 17:01:55 rs: John circle back with cynthia and JF's team. 17:02:10 CS: can we talk about it at CSUN? 17:02:24 TOPIC: Combobox 17:02:48 http://rawgit.com/w3c/aria/action1490-combobox/aria/aria.html#combobox 17:02:53 MK: Jaws versions causing crashing problems 17:03:36 MK: Action 1490 branch 17:04:07 MK: To make this time most useful, I would like to go through the changes from discussion at least weeks meeting 17:04:46 MK: I want to go through this section of without discussing everything anout tree, gird and dialog 17:05:14 MK: The first think is that you didn't like listbox being a popup 17:05:27 RS: I think that's good 17:05:46 MK: Second paragraph is all about the test box element 17:06:26 MK: I think every body agrees it should be a single line text box 17:06:40 RS: A textbox by default is single line 17:06:58 MK: We need to explicitly define it is single line 17:07:09 JS: Or you could say line terminators 17:07:21 MK: I think it is OK the way it is 17:07:37 MK: Next is about expand collapse 17:08:03 MK: We elevated this from should to must, put on textbox element 17:08:43 MK: When a combobox is expanded, authors MUST ensure it contains or owns an element that has a role of listbox, tree, grid, or dialog. This element is the combobox popup. Elements with the role combobox have an implicit aria-haspopup value of true. 17:09:01 RS: exapnd goes on the combobox 17:09:06 MK Correct 17:09:17 MK: The fourth one is about focus... 17:09:48 MK: Authors should put focus on the textbox, authors should move focus.... 17:10:01 MK: To be keyboard accessible, authors SHOULD manage focus of descendants for all instances of this role, as described in Managing Focus. When a combobox receives focus, authors SHOULD ensure focus is placed on the textbox element. Authors SHOULD provide keyboard mechanisms for moving focus to and from the textbox element and the pop-up. For example, one common convention is that Down Arrow... 17:10:03 ...moves focus from the text input to the first focusable descendant of the pop-up element. If the popup element supports aria-activedescendant, authors MAY specify a value for aria-activedescendant on the textbox element that refers to a descendant of the popup element. 17:11:11 MK: ARIA activedescendant can point to the element in the list box that it owns 17:11:23 RS: They could put it on the combobox? 17:11:37 MK: The listbox does not have focus 17:12:01 RS: When you say it maybe on the textbox or the list 17:12:27 MK: If you put DOM focus on the listbox it meets the current requirement 17:12:42 MK: They can put DOM focus on the UL element 17:12:58 RS: You don't think authors will get confused 17:13:14 MK: In this particular spec language 17:13:28 RS: I understand it, but new users might get confused 17:13:32 q? 17:13:39 CS: I have another question 17:13:46 ack me 17:13:46 MichaelC, you wanted to note DPub also starting to think test cases 17:13:57 MK: Maybe in the last sentence I can add 17:14:46 MK: It starts with if the element the author wants to keep focus on the textbox ..... 17:14:56 RS: We have people on the cue 17:15:25 MC: Deque is testing accessibility API mappings 17:15:51 CS: So would you expect autocomplete on Google or bing would use this pattern 17:16:25 +q 17:16:26 MK: I am not familiar with bing, but they should work with facebook and google 17:16:38 CS: You think of them as comboboxes? 17:16:56 MK: If you want to talk about the definition of combobox 17:17:04 CS: That is not where I was going 17:17:21 MK: I wrote it in broad terms about down arrow.... 17:18:05 CS: There is a feature in Narrator that if can a textbox or autocompelete, but if there could be an aria-controls 17:18:50 MK: The AT vendors wanted some siblings relationship, they didn't care about controls, if it is an authoring requirement.. 17:19:11 CS: If it is an authoring practices and examples it will most likely be there 17:19:36 MK: We don;'t have aria-controls on grids for sorting 17:19:52 RS: I don't think it is alot of work 17:20:27 MK: It is a decision related to making is easier for authors or for ATs 17:21:06 CS: It this author doesn't use autocomplete then there is DOM inspection that is fragile 17:21:16 CS: autocomplete is a may 17:21:46 MK: There are plenty of examples where autocomplete is not needed 17:22:18 MK: The main thing for the browser is that it is in the expanded state that there are two controls, that is a must 17:22:30 CS: I need a controller relationship 17:22:50 MK: Your advocating an author should for aria-controls 17:23:06 CS: On the listbox and listbox 17:23:19 RS: Or anything that is open 17:23:30 RS: The textbox could be a search box 17:23:41 MK: Good point I forgot the search role 17:24:05 MK: The way it is written it is OK, searchbox is a descendant of textbox 17:24:19 RS: I think we need to make that explicit 17:24:30 RS: We are running out of time 17:24:54 RS: I don't have a problem with this, but I don't think you want a controls for a switch 17:25:07 MK There is an author must... 17:26:12 q? 17:26:12 MK: Is everything is OK with the example, we have consensus on anything else 17:26:19 q+ 17:26:20 JS: I sent an editorial comment 17:26:45 mck: my editorial suggestions are here: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-aria/2016Mar/0191.html 17:26:51 BG: COuld I get an answer to the questions I asked earlier today 17:27:03 MK: I have not got to the email yet 17:27:15 RS: I think we need to tightened 17:27:26 MK: This is not wide open 17:27:52 MK: We have an author must statement, on exactly on how it should be constructed 17:27:57 chaals has joined #aria 17:28:21 RS: Authors must have owns...., I guess it is in two separate sentences 17:28:38 RS: Is everyone OK with the dialog box 17:28:47 q+ 17:28:53 MK: CSUN is a good place to talk about this 17:29:22 RS: I am not a big fan of dialog box, there are some people who are not comfortable with it 17:30:09 q- 17:30:09 MK: We want to limit unnecessary role proliferation, I am happy we have made this much progress, .... 17:30:13 Date picker is an example of dialog right? 17:30:19 TOPIC: Action 1743 17:30:24 action-1743 17:30:24 action-1743 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Put aria-activedescendant on application and request wg review -- due 2016-02-17 -- PENDINGREVIEW 17:30:24 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/1743 17:30:56 RS: Putting aria-activedescendant on role=application 17:31:14 JOANIE: I ahve not done anything with this 17:31:28 MK: Can we put that on the agenda for after CSUN 17:31:39 RS: Joanie has a branch 17:31:54 RS: Can we assign these to you MK 17:32:08 JOANIE: Fell free to make changes in my brand 17:32:35 MK: ONly in application and activedesendant 17:32:48 RS: What date can you come back to the group 17:32:51 MK: 2 weeks 17:33:21 RS: Need to find the agenda 17:33:45 TOPIC: Password Role 17:33:48 https://rawgit.com/w3c/aria/password-role/aria/aria.html#password 17:33:50 action-2004 17:33:50 action-2004 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Create proposal for password role -- due 2016-03-10 -- PENDINGREVIEW 17:33:50 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/2004 17:34:00 RS: Joanie you want to put int he branch 17:34:10 https://rawgit.com/w3c/aria/password-role/aria/aria.html#password 17:34:45 RS: Issues with supported properties and states 17:34:59 RS: This looks ok to me 17:35:11 JS: What would you put in for placeholder 17:35:36 Joanie: That would change the taxonomy 17:35:55 RS: HTML5 type=password support placeholder 17:36:07 JN: Yes people use it all the time 17:36:12 s/taxonomy/how ATs would want to see the role exposed/ 17:36:33 RS: I can see where you would use it 17:36:38 Stefan has joined #aria 17:36:41 JN: Make and model of a car 17:37:02 RS: Goven that do people have issues with the new Password role? 17:37:09 MK: I am still reading the text 17:38:02 JOANIE: I thought we said haspopup should not be supported 17:38:08 RS: It could be help information 17:38:15 MK: Looks good to me 17:38:41 RESOLUTION: Accept joanie's proposal, and close action 17:40:38 RESOLUTION: Accept joanie's proposal for new ROLE=PASSWORD, and close action 2004 17:41:10 JOANIE: I'll close it when its merged 17:41:20 MC: They are not at the top of the page 17:41:30 MC: But they are there 17:42:13 MC: These are no W3C announcements on working draft changes 17:42:31 MC: But the groups can publicize them and send them to people 17:42:58 JOANIE: Did you what me to remove ... 17:43:16 JOANIE: Input for entering the password 17:43:19 MK: yes 17:43:33 TOPIC: ACTION 1489 17:43:52 https://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/1489 17:43:57 RS: Move one 17:44:07 https://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/2040 17:44:18 issue-686 17:44:19 issue-686 -- need a getComputedLabel or getComputedName -- open 17:44:19 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/issues/686 17:44:27 TOPIC: Computed name and role 17:44:41 RS: We met witht he group 2 years ago 17:44:53 RS: No action in 2 years, so move to ARIA 2.0 17:44:58 MK: We kind of have to 17:45:59 Proposed moving Issue 686 on APIs on roles and accessible name to ARIA 2.0 17:46:12 MC: We don't need a CFC for moving it 17:46:30 https://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/issues/686 17:46:30 RESOLUTION: MOve Issue 686 to ARIA 2.0 17:46:54 TOPIC: ACTION 1624 17:47:01 action-1624 17:47:01 action-1624 -- Michael Cooper to Work with shane to develop publication strategy and solution that would exclude abstract roles for authors -- due 2016-03-17 -- OPEN 17:47:01 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/1624 17:47:13 MC: Can you put this higher on list after CSUN 17:48:01 MK: What do links do .... 17:48:09 JS: Point to the full spec 17:48:25 MC: We have to sort out in the process of doing the actions 17:48:39 action-2023 17:48:39 action-2023 -- Joanmarie Diggs to Write a proposal about how to modify the definition of role text to limit its use. -- due 2016-02-23 -- OPEN 17:48:39 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/actions/2023 17:48:43 TOPIC: ACTION 2023 Role=Text 17:49:06 issue-1011 17:49:06 issue-1011 -- For role="text", there needs to be requirements on user agents for overrides, such as controls, events, and other global aria properties, like there is for role="presentation". -- open 17:49:06 http://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/issues/1011 17:49:09 ACTION-2023: Write a proposal about how to modify the definition of role text to limit its use. 17:49:09 Notes added to ACTION-2023 Write a proposal about how to modify the definition of role text to limit its use.. 17:49:11 Write a proposal about how to modify the definition of role text to limit its use. 17:49:26 RS: When you have text content a bit differently 17:49:37 RS: I know you can put this in button 17:50:08 RS: If you put a link inside a role=text, that that would be dangerous 17:50:46 RS: ***** role=text with aria-label="4 stars" 17:51:02 RS: IN the case of buttons the roles are presentations 17:51:15 q? 17:51:16 RS: role=text can not have interactive elements 17:51:20 q+ 17:51:20 ack Rich 17:51:22 q+ 17:51:28 ack bgaraventa 17:51:51 ack fesch 17:51:54 FE: I want to make sure it can work in SVG with a path used for text 17:52:01 RS: That would not be an issue 17:52:13 q+ to say it could be handled as exceptions to role presentation. 17:52:31 q+ 17:52:34 ack jamesn 17:52:50 JN: I want to make sure we solve the problem for people who write good code, bad coders will always do bad things 17:53:14 q? 17:53:27 MK: My understanding of the role=text is making content easier to listen to, so it is getting into the realm ... 17:54:06 MK: Realm of presentation, so the author is making a judgement that is different structure or roles 17:54:08 +1 17:54:31 MK: I want to make sure that the original content is available tot he AT user 17:54:51 ack clown 17:54:51 clown, you wanted to say it could be handled as exceptions to role presentation. 17:54:55 q? 17:55:02 MK: FOr example if it is a graphic I can get to the original image 17:55:32 JS: If you put presentation on a link it the browser will ignore the role and present the link 17:55:34 q? 17:55:38 RS: I would go with that 17:56:12 ack cyns 17:56:17 CS: I have a cautious approval, I have concerns about authoring 17:56:50 RS: The next question is this...., Joanie had the action 17:57:06 RS: Should Joanie come back with a proposal? 17:57:28 +1 17:57:35 +1 17:57:41 +1 17:57:48 RS: Anything that is a descendant that is interactive will invalidate the role 17:58:06 +1 17:58:13 JN: What it is has tabindex=-1 and aria-hidden? 17:58:24 CS: We need to look at a draft 17:58:39 JN: James put ... 17:59:01 Joanie: I don't like the role, so I need everyones comments 17:59:15 jemma has joined #aria 17:59:46 q? 17:59:55 MK: The text role provides an alternative presentation, user agents must not hide the accessible 18:00:02 JS: What about title attribute? 18:00:09 MK: It is kind of like that 18:00:27 RS: We are out of time 18:00:49 rrsagent, draft minutes 18:00:49 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2016/03/17-aria-minutes.html jongund 18:01:02 JOANIE: What is my next step? 18:01:12 https://www.w3.org/WAI/ARIA/track/issues/1011 18:01:16 RS: JN can get you a link 18:01:38 JN: I can't because W3C is blocking Oracle 18:02:00 MC: This happens, there is page that explains it 18:02:01 joanie: inside that issue is the link to github where the discussion occurred (in a note) 18:02:14 i get directed here - https://www.w3.org/Help/abuse-info/re-reqs.html 18:03:34 RRSAgent, draft minutes 18:03:34 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2016/03/17-aria-minutes.html Rich 18:04:50 I published the minutes 18:05:19 zakim, bye 18:05:19 leaving. As of this point the attendees have been Michiel_Bijl, Fred_Esch, Ja_Eun_Ku, Rich_Schwerdtfeger, Joanmarie_Diggs, Joseph_Scheuhammer, Bryan_Garaventa, janina 18:05:19 Zakim has left #aria 18:05:25 RRSAgent, make minutes 18:05:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2016/03/17-aria-minutes.html Rich 18:12:32 MichaelC: can you complain to the webmaster about that for me - or tell me who I can moan to? 18:14:16 oh - it is not useful - i have seen it before. It is just something to moan about :) 18:14:46 it may be useful if I had any way to contact someone in our networking group 18:15:07 aha 18:15:07 with 120,000 employees we probably make a lot of requests to stuff from w3c 18:15:13 https://www.w3.org/Help/Webmaster#block 18:15:21 Where do I send comments about w3.org? 18:15:21 There are two ways to reach us by email: 18:15:21 We encourage you to let us know by sending a message to site-comments@w3.org with the URI (that is, the Web address) of the page(s) in question. That is a publicly archived mailing list. 18:15:25 If you prefer to send us comments that are not publicly visible, please use web-human@w3.org 18:16:08 thanks 18:16:12 Why is W3C blocking my IP? 18:16:12 W3C is most likely blocking your IP because of excessive traffic; often this is due to requesting the same resource from us repeatedly (e.g. a DTD, Schema, Entity, or Namespace document.) We give extensive caching directives and there really is no reason to request the same resource over and over when it is not going to change. Your XML library or utility probably has a means to use a XML catalog and/or have a caching mechanism; please consult that documen[CUT] 18:16:47 yeah. We have proxy servers which i am guessing cache stuff but it seems that is not enough 18:17:19 https://www.w3.org/blog/systeam/2008/02/08/w3c_s_excessive_dtd_traffic/ 18:17:37 the last is linked to from the paragraph pasted above 18:17:40 yeah - can't get to that one :) 18:18:02 but now you have email addresses and content for your IT dept. 18:19:08 LOL - like I can contact my IT department - laughs 18:19:31 set up a proxy and they'll contact you 18:19:46 hah - yeah that might work 18:20:03 or plug in a router and start providing IP addresses to folks :) 18:20:10 hahaha 18:21:06 what about a tor browser 18:22:52 https://www.torproject.org/download/download-easy.html 18:25:25 i'm willing to bet i am blocked from torproject 18:25:41 try it 18:26:11 get a security warning which means i have a redirect someehere 18:41:03 Rich has joined #aria 18:57:22 clown has joined #aria 20:20:54 Rich has joined #aria 20:54:56 clown has left #aria 22:14:35 Rich has joined #aria 23:18:38 Rich has joined #aria