14:01:12 RRSAgent has joined #dpub 14:01:12 logging to http://www.w3.org/2014/09/29-dpub-irc 14:01:14 RRSAgent, make logs public 14:01:14 Zakim has joined #dpub 14:01:16 Zakim, this will be dpub 14:01:17 Meeting: Digital Publishing Interest Group Teleconference 14:01:17 Date: 29 September 2014 14:01:18 ok, trackbot; I see DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM scheduled to start in 59 minutes 14:01:18 halindrome has joined #dpub 14:01:23 Chair: Markus 14:02:39 Bert has joined #dpub 14:04:08 Agenda: http://www.w3.org/mid/5424F804.6080000@gmail.com 14:04:28 ivan has changed the topic to: Meeting Agenda for 2014-09-29: http://www.w3.org/mid/5424F804.6080000@gmail.com 14:53:15 dauwhe has joined #dpub 14:56:30 mgylling has joined #dpub 14:56:54 clapierre has joined #DPUB 14:56:58 dkaplan3 has joined #dpub 14:57:26 DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM has now started 14:57:33 + +1.206.675.aaaa 14:57:45 zakim, code? 14:57:45 the conference code is 3782 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), fjh 14:57:45 zakim, aaaa is me 14:57:47 +astearns; got it 14:58:08 +clapierre 14:58:23 +[IPcaller] 14:58:25 zakim, ipcaller is me 14:58:25 +fjh; got it 14:58:40 +dauwhe 14:59:00 +[Safari] 14:59:15 +Markus 14:59:28 + +1.217.300.aabb 14:59:29 murakami has joined #dpub 14:59:45 zakim, [Safari] is me 14:59:45 +dkaplan3; got it 14:59:48 +MikeMiller 15:00:28 +??P30 15:00:32 +[Ugent] 15:00:38 pkra has joined #dpub 15:00:42 zakim, ??P30 is me 15:00:42 +murakami; got it 15:00:43 AH_Miller has joined #DPUB 15:01:01 +pkra 15:01:03 david_stroup has joined #dpub 15:01:33 zakim, code? 15:01:33 the conference code is 3782 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), ivan 15:01:48 +Ivan 15:01:56 zakim, who is here? 15:01:56 On the phone I see astearns, clapierre, fjh, dauwhe, dkaplan3, Markus, +1.217.300.aabb, MikeMiller, murakami, [Ugent], pkra, Ivan 15:01:58 On IRC I see david_stroup, AH_Miller, pkra, murakami, dkaplan3, clapierre, mgylling, dauwhe, Bert, ShaneM, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, astearns, fjh, liam, plinss, trackbot 15:01:59 +david_stroup 15:02:14 astein has joined #dpub 15:02:25 bjdmeest has joined #dpub 15:02:27 + +33.4.92.38.aacc - is perhaps Bert? 15:02:31 zakim, mute me 15:02:31 sorry, bjdmeest, I do not know which phone connection belongs to you 15:02:36 + +1.917.770.aadd 15:02:40 +Bill_Kasdorf 15:02:51 zakim, aabb is astein 15:02:51 +astein; got it 15:02:57 Bill_Kasdorf has joined #dpub 15:02:57 zakim, bjdmeest is me 15:02:57 sorry, bjdmeest, I do not recognize a party named 'bjdmeest' 15:03:00 + +1.201.236.aaee 15:03:04 regrets: Luc, Graham, Phil, Thierry, Vladimir, Rob, Julie 15:03:12 zakim, who is here? 15:03:12 On the phone I see astearns, clapierre, fjh, dauwhe, dkaplan3, Markus, astein, MikeMiller, murakami, [Ugent], pkra, Ivan, david_stroup, Bert, +1.917.770.aadd, Bill_Kasdorf, 15:03:15 ... +1.201.236.aaee 15:03:15 On IRC I see Bill_Kasdorf, bjdmeest, astein, david_stroup, AH_Miller, pkra, murakami, dkaplan3, clapierre, mgylling, dauwhe, Bert, ShaneM, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, astearns, fjh, 15:03:15 ... liam, plinss, trackbot 15:03:19 pbelfanti has joined #dpub 15:03:19 zakim, Ugent is me 15:03:19 +bjdmeest; got it 15:03:24 zakim, mute me 15:03:24 bjdmeest should now be muted 15:03:45 zakim, aaee is pbelfanti 15:03:45 +pbelfanti; got it 15:04:00 zakim, aadd is laura 15:04:00 +laura; got it 15:04:09 LauraD has joined #DPUB 15:04:29 zakim, laura is LauraD 15:04:29 +LauraD; got it 15:04:40 scribenick: dauwhe 15:04:52 tzviya has joined #dpub 15:04:52 correct link for last weeks minutes: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-digipub-ig/2014Sep/0077.html 15:04:54 mgylling: discussing last week's minutes 15:05:02 mgylling: any objections? 15:05:07 tmichel has joined #dpub 15:05:10 mgylling: minutes approved. 15:05:11 +madi 15:05:19 +Liam 15:05:20 mgylling: two things on agenda 15:05:22 liza has joined #dpub 15:05:25 +Tzviya 15:05:30 ... PF collaboration will have to wait 15:05:35 ... update on STEM from Peter 15:05:39 ... then TPAC agenda 15:05:41 madi has joined #dpub 15:05:48 +[Safari] 15:05:50 +??P12 15:05:55 zakim, Safari is me 15:05:55 +liza; got it 15:06:18 zakim,??P12 is me 15:06:18 +tmichel; got it 15:06:56 pkra: hammer out a richer questionairre based on early interviews 15:07:18 ... I've summarized the interviews but haven't published yet 15:07:30 ... hope to finish by end of month 15:07:57 ... it has been interesting... the first four have given me a very different angle 15:08:11 ... those four were forward-thinking, cutting edge 15:08:27 mgylling: we're curious about observations 15:08:45 pkra: suprised by [a] big focus on authoring side and what OWP can do there 15:09:00 q+ 15:09:05 ... it would be better world if web was much more involved in authoring 15:09:17 ... contenteditable is an issue 15:09:32 ... how to create print representation of web doc 15:09:35 ack Bill_K 15:09:41 Bill_Kasdorf: can you summarize who these people were? 15:09:44 TimCole has joined #dpub 15:09:52 pkra: Peter ??? who was a researcher 15:10:04 ... came up with CML, does data mining 15:10:30 ... Fernando ???, working on scientific computation, ipython notebook format 15:10:37 +TimCole 15:10:42 ... machine readable but also creates human readable 15:11:00 ... Dan ??? from hypothesis, working on annotations 15:11:12 ... Ian ??? from ???, a publisher of open-access journal 15:11:24 q+ 15:11:31 [ Peter Murray-Rust ] 15:11:53 ((Sounds OK to me) 15:11:58 s/Dan ???/Dan Whaley/ 15:11:58 s/Peter ???/Peter Murray-Rust/ 15:12:23 pkra: themes were need for community building 15:12:32 ... community group for reasearchers and authors 15:12:41 ... this IG to educate about technologies 15:12:52 ... the third big theme was about PDF 15:12:55 s/???/eLife/ 15:13:05 ... something everyone has to deal with 15:13:21 ... pdf creation, being able to use pdf better in web context, tools like PDFjs 15:13:27 q- 15:13:33 ... another issue is peer review and search 15:13:59 mgylling: thanks for summary. Has there been discussion of native rendering of STEM content? 15:14:07 pkra: not so much. 15:14:37 ... so little agreement standards that could lead to native rendering that community group is needed 15:14:45 ... they felt its too early 15:15:05 q+ 15:15:26 ... there's dismay at static content 15:15:44 ... when author comes with SVG, but publisher asks for TIFF 15:15:58 ... so people are cautious, focusing on baby steps 15:16:13 ... it's not like MathML, where people are already using it 15:16:18 q+ 15:16:24 ack Bill_K 15:16:54 Bill_Kasdorf: STEM publishing is one of the earliest sectors to go digital 15:16:59 ... they did that using PDF 15:17:10 ... for them, digital = PDF 15:17:22 ... that whole population takes that for granted, its a limiting factor 15:17:25 +1 to Bill's comment 15:17:44 ... the people were very progressive, so startling to hear about PDF 15:17:45 ack tzviya 15:18:22 pkra: this came up in positive way. 2 problems: we have an output problem, our users want PDF 15:18:42 ... the first problem is Word. 15:18:50 ... JATS is the other issue 15:19:00 ... then you have to generate PDF out of this 15:19:21 ... if input is HTML in future, and out put HTML in future, then pipeline could be simpler 15:19:46 Bill_Kasdorf: I'm aware of some initiatives to move in HTML direction, but can't name them right now. 15:19:50 Bill_Kasdorf: the tide is turning 15:20:03 tzviya: did you provide a link to doc? 15:20:08 pkra: still working on it 15:20:31 tzviya: until recently, primary output has been PDF but lots of pubs are looking at HTML now 15:20:43 ... CUP, for example, has option to look at both HTML and PDF 15:20:52 ... we're seeing that more and more in STEM world 15:21:02 ... which means we need math rendering!!! 15:21:08 ... this is becoming urgent. 15:21:42 Bill_Kasdorf: this literate is distributed through hosting services. All have JATS at their core, but they all have HTML 'cause they're online. 15:21:49 s/literate/literature/ 15:22:11 tzviya: not everything is a journal 15:22:21 ... i've been converting STEM books to EPUB 15:22:43 ... but because of math I'm having trouble, we've done them as images but this can't continue 15:23:19 mgylling: you mentioned MathML. Is it a more generic problem? Chemistry, electronics, other subjects with graphic needs? 15:23:26 q+ 15:23:30 tzviya: it's a broader problem. Chemistry is worse. 15:23:45 ... physics is an issue, and even advanced math 15:23:55 q? 15:23:56 mgylling: on what level should we attack the problem? 15:24:00 ack ivan 15:24:04 tzviya: mathml isn't a quick win 15:24:24 q+ 15:24:27 ivan: in metadata task force, talking mostly about ONIX and metadata in ONIX 15:24:47 ... worth talking to STEM folks about the metadata that community uses, which may be different 15:25:02 ... from traditional publishers 15:25:14 ... STEM publishing includes conference proceedings 15:25:25 STEM metadata is dominated by CrossRef deposits and metadata required by the hosting services--not typically ONIX 15:25:37 ... all the ID mechanisms are different, but we need different metadata structure than for whole book 15:25:48 +1 15:25:49 ... we should not let go of this issue 15:26:18 Bill_Kasdorf: many stem publishers view metadata as solved problem. they use crossref and their hosting services 15:26:23 ... also fundref 15:26:44 ... onix only on the book side 15:26:58 ack pkra 15:27:00 +q 15:27:14 q? 15:27:28 there is an ONIX for serials but it is less ubiquitous than Onix for Books 15:27:51 pkra: other standards also came up, but people are cautious. Even the author of CML is cautious about a standard 15:28:25 ... also talked about linked data 15:28:29 ack TimCole 15:28:44 TimCole: ivan mentioned metadata issues 15:29:04 ... there was a report about the important about describing metadata at equation level 15:29:13 ... for discovery and linking 15:29:19 ... derived from MathML 15:29:28 ... searching for math equations or linking to them 15:30:15 ... digitizing renaissance books with emblems, there's a vocabulary for defining them, need to apply to individual emblem 15:30:31 q+ 15:30:38 ... if stuff is in PDF, it's harder to find and you can't properly describe the metadata 15:30:41 ack pkra 15:31:29 Must drop, apologies 15:31:29 pkra: tools like PDF.js allow people to mix PDF and HTML 15:31:33 -pbelfanti 15:31:54 mgylling: how many more interviews? 15:32:05 pkra: I want to do 3 or 4 more 15:32:12 ... plus work on the questionairres 15:33:00 mgylling: any advice for Peter? 15:33:12 Bill_Kasdorf: make sure you have representative sample of types of people that you interview 15:33:34 ... the first interviews are cutting-edge folks, but may not be representative of average scholarly publisher 15:33:39 ivan has joined #dpub 15:33:44 ... the questionairre is intended to do that 15:33:51 pkra: I agree. 15:34:15 ... "strong opinions" is an understatement :) 15:34:19 :) 15:34:31 ... I will follow your advice 15:34:37 q? 15:34:43 mgylling: any more questions for peter? 15:34:57 TPAC agenda is here: https://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/TPAC2014-F2F 15:34:58 Topic: TPAC agenda 15:35:18 https://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/TPAC2014-F2F#Participation 15:35:24 mgylling: I will lean on Tzviya, who has been running calls 15:35:35 ... who will attend in person, who will attend virtually 15:35:56 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35125/TPAC2014/registrants#DP 15:36:53 mgylling: did we discuss agenda items in the last two calls? 15:37:00 tzviya: I'm going to pull up minutes 15:37:28 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-digipub-ig/2014Sep/0001.html 15:37:36 ... we had a rough sketch of the meetings 15:38:13 http://www.w3.org/2014/09/08-dpub-minutes.html 15:40:22 tzviya: want to talk with PF 15:41:09 CSS has offered to meet on open time Monday 15:42:13 mgylling: if our primary topic is pagination and box tree 15:43:48 Peter Linss is registered for AC/Testing on Thurs and Fri 15:44:17 ... we could be looking at spending a full half day on pagination both internally and with CSS 15:44:32 (I'll be there the whole week, too.) 15:44:41 ... this is both requirements doc for DOM pagination, CSS box tree, and publishers requirements 15:45:36 ... for IG's own agenda 15:46:09 ... 25% to pagination cluster (req, css, dom) but we don't know when yet. Waiting to hear from dauwhe on getting CSS participation 15:46:22 ... I'll put tentatively on thursday morning pagination 15:46:27 ... we can move later 15:46:49 ... regarding PF / a11y / role 15:46:57 tzviya: I can reach out to PF folks 15:47:18 ... focused on integrating DPUB terminology 15:48:09 dkaplan3: a joint session could be useful, we'd want to talk about what form that would take 15:48:24 tzviya: not sure how much time we should take 15:48:53 mgylling: if we get meeting with PF, would be good to summarize our next steps 15:49:30 tzviya: we might work with people other than PF 15:49:48 dkaplan3: we have meeting with WAI and mobile team to talk about road map mobile used 15:49:59 ... might help us avoid some dead ends 15:50:28 -dkaplan3 15:50:38 mgylling: what other themes for IG meetings? 15:50:47 tzviya: metadata 15:51:03 Bill_Kasdorf: we now have github draft up for discussion 15:51:12 ... I'll be there thursday friday 15:51:17 ... madi can't attend 15:51:39 madi: I'll try to call in, depending on the time 15:51:45 ivan: what times would work for you 15:51:52 madi: earliest meetings are better 15:52:01 for metadata, I will only be there Thursday and would like to hear about metadata that day if possible 15:52:07 mgylling: I'll put metadata on friday morning 15:52:14 ... do we have clear deliverable here? 15:52:31 +[Safari] 15:52:32 Bill_Kasdorf: want to get discussion going on list based on starter draft on github 15:52:39 q+ 15:52:41 q+ 15:52:42 ... designed to stimulate discussion 15:52:47 zakim, [Safari] IS ME 15:52:47 +dkaplan3; got it 15:53:05 ... would like clarity on what we're working towards 15:53:32 ivan: 2 things: 1: github doc will eventually become publication, but it also includes recommendations for further work 15:53:45 ... and that further work may happen as part of the IGs work for the coming year 15:53:53 ... it's both document and planning 15:54:30 Bill_Kasdorf: let a week or two go by for discussion, then I can provide an agenda for that discussion 15:55:03 ... maybe by the 13th 15:55:24 mgylling: pagination, metadata, possibly a11y, what else? 15:55:38 tzviya: having update on STEM 15:56:04 mgylling: update on STEM task force? 15:56:20 tzviya: annotations work is now in its own group 15:56:29 Annotation WG will have meeing on Tuesday at TPAC 15:56:33 ivan: we should publish annotations use cases as note, then close task force 15:56:42 ... this is on Rob's shoulders 15:57:15 ... the annotation use cases doc should be closed, and not be on agenda any more 15:57:24 ... we don't need f2f time for this 15:57:32 mgylling: do we need F2F time for STEM? 15:57:35 q? 15:57:40 ack everyone 15:57:45 ack ivan 15:57:49 ack pkra 15:57:51 pkra: I cannot make it, can dial in 15:58:21 ... there was nothing planned. 15:58:35 have to drop for my next meeting, sorry 15:58:41 -astearns 15:58:58 ... might connect with math group 15:59:34 tzviya: we can get update at weekly meetings 15:59:47 -liza 16:00:16 mgylling: we can certainly use F2F time if it will help 16:00:58 mgylling: agenda now beginning to appear on wiki 16:01:07 ivan: update on chinareq 16:01:22 ... lot of overlap with i18n 16:01:27 ... also in korean 16:01:45 ... discussions with Indian community about typesetting requirements 16:01:53 ... we should discuss with Richard Ishidia 16:02:15 s/Ishidia/Ishida/ 16:02:26 mgylling: can we put placeholder? 16:02:34 ivan: I'll check with them, if you ask nicely 16:02:57 Meeting with SVG? 16:02:59 mgylling: pagination, metadata, i18n, possibly a11y, possibly STEM 16:03:20 tzviya: we have talked about HTML WG about validation issues but not ready yet 16:03:20 -david_stroup 16:03:30 -fjh 16:03:34 tzviya: Charles had talked about meeting with SVG group 16:03:40 I changed On: Peter and Madi to On: Bill and Madi for Friday morning metadata session at TPAC 16:03:49 clapierre: I don't know what the status is there 16:04:01 . . . in the agenda on the wiki 16:04:15 ... since they're there we could find out about a11y in SVG 16:04:32 mgylling: anyone here on that group? I'll take the action 16:04:46 ACTION: mgylling to reach out to SVG about a11y 16:04:47 Created ACTION-26 - Reach out to svg about a11y [on Markus Gylling - due 2014-10-06]. 16:05:28 q? 16:05:41 mgylling: if you have more agenda items, let us know 16:05:49 ... sorry to be over time. 16:05:50 -madi 16:05:51 -dkaplan3 16:05:51 -Markus 16:05:53 -Tzviya 16:05:53 -Bill_Kasdorf 16:05:54 -astein 16:05:54 -TimCole 16:05:55 -pkra 16:05:55 -clapierre 16:05:56 TimCole has left #dpub 16:05:58 -bjdmeest 16:05:58 -Bert 16:05:58 -Ivan 16:05:59 -LauraD 16:05:59 -dauwhe 16:05:59 clapierre has left #dpub 16:06:00 -murakami 16:06:07 dkaplan3 has left #dpub 16:06:07 -Liam 16:06:22 murakami has left #dpub 16:06:47 -MikeMiller 16:11:47 disconnecting the lone participant, tmichel, in DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM 16:11:49 DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM has ended 16:11:49 Attendees were +1.206.675.aaaa, astearns, clapierre, fjh, dauwhe, Markus, +1.217.300.aabb, dkaplan3, MikeMiller, murakami, pkra, Ivan, david_stroup, +33.4.92.38.aacc, 16:11:50 ... +1.917.770.aadd, Bill_Kasdorf, astein, Bert, +1.201.236.aaee, bjdmeest, pbelfanti, LauraD, madi, Liam, Tzviya, liza, tmichel, TimCole 16:47:01 Bert has left #dpub 17:33:20 rrsagent, draft minutes 17:33:20 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/09/29-dpub-minutes.html tmichel 18:26:40 Zakim has left #dpub 19:28:59 pkra1 has joined #dpub 20:19:13 Karen has joined #dpub 21:44:48 dauwhe has joined #dpub 22:15:42 dauwhe has joined #dpub 22:45:35 dauwhe has joined #dpub