12:48:02 RRSAgent has joined #dwbp 12:48:02 logging to http://www.w3.org/2014/06/20-dwbp-irc 12:48:15 zakim, this will be DWBP 12:48:15 ok, PhilA; I see DATA_DWBP()9:00AM scheduled to start in 12 minutes 12:48:21 chair: Hadley 12:49:10 agenda: https://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/wiki/Meetings:Telecon20140620 12:49:30 regrets+ Antoine, Christophe, Jeremy, Bernadette 12:50:26 HadleyBeeman has joined #dwbp 12:56:33 laufer has joined #DWBP 12:57:18 BartvanLeeuwen has joined #dwbp 12:57:29 regrets+ Carlos, Steve, Ivan 12:58:57 HadleyBeeman has joined #dwbp 12:59:09 trackbot, start meeting 12:59:11 RRSAgent, make logs 351 12:59:13 Zakim, this will be DWBP 12:59:13 ok, trackbot; I see DATA_DWBP()9:00AM scheduled to start in 1 minute 12:59:14 Meeting: Data on the Web Best Practices Working Group Teleconference 12:59:14 Date: 20 June 2014 13:00:07 try again, bartvanleeuwen 13:00:13 I've just started the meeting properly 13:00:32 JoaoPauloAlmeida has joined #dwbp 13:00:34 MTCarrasco has joined #dwbp 13:00:36 DATA_DWBP()9:00AM has now started 13:00:43 +??P8 13:01:01 zakim, ??P8 is me 13:01:01 +MTCarrasco; got it 13:01:14 +[IPcaller] 13:01:18 zakim, ipcaller is me 13:01:18 +PhilA; got it 13:01:24 +HadleyBeeman 13:01:39 HadleyBeeman has changed the topic to: agenda: https://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/wiki/Meetings:Telecon20140620 13:01:49 BartvanLeeuwen - is that with Skype 13:01:50 +[IPcaller] 13:01:57 Zakim, IPcaller is me 13:01:57 +JoaoPauloAlmeida; got it 13:01:59 ericstephan has joined #dwbp 13:02:20 PhilA, nope voip 13:02:23 + +1.617.646.aaaa 13:02:31 I will be on a listen-only mode today, because I am in a shared room. So, I will be muted and intervene on IRC when necessary 13:02:32 EricKauz has joined #dwbp 13:02:44 PhilA, zakim@voip.w3.org simply does not allow to connect 13:02:45 Zakim, mute me 13:02:45 JoaoPauloAlmeida should now be muted 13:02:59 + +1.509.375.aabb 13:03:05 Ig_Bittencourt has joined #DWBP 13:03:29 zakim, +.509.375 is me 13:03:29 sorry, ericstephan, I do not recognize a party named '+.509.375' 13:03:38 MakxDekkers has joined #DWBP 13:03:38 :-) 13:03:40 zakim, +1.509.375 is me 13:03:40 +ericstephan; got it 13:03:42 I can type 13:03:49 markharrison has joined #dwbp 13:03:59 deirdrelee has joined #dwbp 13:04:03 +[IPcaller] 13:04:14 zakim, ipcaller is me 13:04:14 +laufer; got it 13:04:19 Makx_Dekkers has joined #DWBP 13:05:03 SumitPurohit has joined #dwbp 13:05:03 zakim, who is here? 13:05:04 On the phone I see MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida (muted), +1.617.646.aaaa, ericstephan, laufer 13:05:07 On IRC I see SumitPurohit, Makx_Dekkers, deirdrelee, markharrison, Ig_Bittencourt, EricKauz, ericstephan, MTCarrasco, JoaoPauloAlmeida, HadleyBeeman, BartvanLeeuwen, laufer, 13:05:07 ... RRSAgent, Zakim, PhilA, trackbot 13:05:28 Yaso has joined #dwbp 13:05:40 zakim, who is here? 13:05:40 On the phone I see MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida (muted), +1.617.646.aaaa, ericstephan, laufer 13:05:44 On IRC I see Yaso, SumitPurohit, Makx_Dekkers, deirdrelee, markharrison, Ig_Bittencourt, EricKauz, ericstephan, MTCarrasco, JoaoPauloAlmeida, HadleyBeeman, BartvanLeeuwen, laufer, 13:05:44 ... RRSAgent, Zakim, PhilA, trackbot 13:05:44 zakim,aaaa is me 13:05:46 +SumitPurohit; got it 13:05:47 + +44.122.374.aacc 13:06:07 zakim, aacc is me 13:06:07 +markharrison; got it 13:06:12 + +1.609.557.aadd 13:06:22 +[IPcaller] 13:06:25 -laufer 13:06:38 zakim, aacc is me 13:06:38 sorry, EricKauz, I do not recognize a party named 'aacc' 13:06:43 zakim, [ipcaller] is me 13:06:43 +deirdrelee; got it 13:06:46 zakim, who is here? 13:06:46 On the phone I see MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida (muted), SumitPurohit, ericstephan, markharrison, +1.609.557.aadd, deirdrelee 13:06:48 On IRC I see Yaso, SumitPurohit, Makx_Dekkers, deirdrelee, markharrison, Ig_Bittencourt, EricKauz, ericstephan, MTCarrasco, JoaoPauloAlmeida, HadleyBeeman, BartvanLeeuwen, laufer, 13:06:49 ... RRSAgent, Zakim, PhilA, trackbot 13:06:55 zakim, aadd is me 13:06:55 +EricKauz; got it 13:07:04 +[IPcaller] 13:07:06 +??P18 13:07:13 zakim, ipcaller is me 13:07:13 +laufer; got it 13:07:16 Zakim, +P18 is Yaso 13:07:16 sorry, Yaso, I do not recognize a party named '+P18' 13:07:34 Zakim, P18 is Yaso 13:07:34 sorry, Yaso, I do not recognize a party named 'P18' 13:07:37 +??P19 13:07:46 Zakim, ??p19 is me 13:07:46 +BartvanLeeuwen; got it 13:08:01 Zakim, ??p18 is me 13:08:01 +Yaso; got it 13:08:43 zakim, pick a victim 13:08:43 Not knowing who is chairing or who scribed recently, I propose PhilA 13:09:02 atemezi has joined #dwbp 13:09:06 scribe: PhilA 13:09:17 zakim, mute me 13:09:17 laufer should now be muted 13:09:30 hi ghislain 13:09:34 HadleyBeeman: I need to leave early today so we'll either end early or Yaso will take over before the end 13:09:56 PROPOSED: Accept last week's minutes http://www.w3.org/2013/meeting/dwbp/2014-06-13 13:10:05 +1 13:10:06 Hi, today I am going to stay only on the irc. 13:10:07 +1 13:10:08 +1 13:10:12 +1 13:10:12 +1 13:10:16 +1 13:10:21 +1 13:10:26 +1 13:10:30 RESOLVED: Accept last week's minutes http://www.w3.org/2013/meeting/dwbp/2014-06-13 13:10:58 HadleyBeeman: Reminder to book for TPAC. Our f2f meeting is Thursday and Friday 13:11:18 I’ll be there 13:11:19 Probably yes 13:11:23 PhilA: See announcement of 20th anniversary stuff at http://www.w3.org/blog/news/archives/3898 13:11:27 will depend on the funding 13:11:32 I am planning 13:11:38 hopefully 13:11:40 Phila: I'll be there all week (plane booked and everything) 13:11:46 I will depend on funding too 13:11:49 not sure yet 13:11:58 I will probably be there. 13:12:05 I checked flights and hotel rates: I will not be able to come to TPAC 13:12:14 Hi, HadleyBeeman. :) 13:12:32 topic: Actions 13:12:46 I will confirm later. 13:12:49 action-32? 13:12:49 action-32 -- Hadley Beeman to Write email on discoverable data vs data catalogues -- due 2014-05-16 -- OPEN 13:12:49 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/32 13:12:49 action-32? 13:12:49 action-32 -- Hadley Beeman to Write email on discoverable data vs data catalogues -- due 2014-05-16 -- OPEN 13:12:50 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/32 13:13:09 action-41? 13:13:09 action-41 -- Mark Harrison to Add skos recommendations into controlled vocabularies -- due 2014-05-23 -- OPEN 13:13:09 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/41 13:13:18 HadleyBeeman: Where are you on that? 13:13:32 markharrison: I've added some more material, it's as complete as I can make it unless Antoine has more to add 13:13:39 HadleyBeeman: So we can close the action for now? 13:13:47 close action-41 13:13:47 Closed action-41. 13:13:58 action-45? 13:13:58 action-45 -- Eric Stephan to Review ucr with closed data in mind -- due 2014-06-13 -- OPEN 13:13:58 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/45 13:14:32 ericstephan: I looked at the UCR and there are some references to types of closed data that I thought were good, but I need to follow up... Sumit, do you have time to work on these? 13:14:37 SumitPurohit: Yep. 13:14:56 ericstephan: OK, so we'll put a wiki page together showing other examples of closed data that may not be in the UCR 13:15:25 action: ericstephan to work with SumitPurohit to put a wiki page together showing other examples of closed data that may not be in the UCR 13:15:25 Created ACTION-51 - Work with sumitpurohit to put a wiki page together showing other examples of closed data that may not be in the ucr [on Eric Stephan - due 2014-06-27]. 13:15:25 action-46? 13:15:25 action-46 -- Yaso Córdova to Generate/collate further use cases concerning iot, transport, privacy -- due 2014-06-13 -- OPEN 13:15:26 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/46 13:15:32 close action-45 13:15:32 Closed action-45. 13:15:44 zakim, who is here? 13:15:44 On the phone I see MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida (muted), SumitPurohit, ericstephan, markharrison, EricKauz, deirdrelee, laufer (muted), Yaso, BartvanLeeuwen 13:15:47 On IRC I see atemezi, Yaso, SumitPurohit, Makx_Dekkers, deirdrelee, markharrison, Ig_Bittencourt, EricKauz, ericstephan, MTCarrasco, JoaoPauloAlmeida, HadleyBeeman, BartvanLeeuwen, 13:15:47 ... laufer, RRSAgent, Zakim, PhilA, trackbot 13:15:51 Ohhhn. 13:15:52 :/ 13:16:05 now you can hear me? 13:16:17 Well, I've been traveling during this week, so can not finish. But I suggest that the action remains open until next week. 13:16:19 No we can't - sorry! 13:16:27 +q 13:16:33 ack ericstephan 13:16:34 ack eric 13:16:39 Yes I can! 13:16:49 ericstephan: Dunno if Yaso can hear me, but I;m extremely interested in teh IoT work 13:17:03 ... we work a lot with instrumentation in sci experiments 13:17:04 q+ 13:17:10 Eric, you can help me on that? 13:17:10 ack phila 13:17:14 ericstephan: Glad to help Use cases 13:17:16 It’s great if you can 13:17:26 PhilA: http://www.w3.org/2014/02/wot/agenda.html 13:17:48 phila: IoT is relevant at the moment: Next week, I'll get to meet EricKauz in Berlin, at the Web of Things. 13:18:04 anyone at #iotweek in London this week? 13:18:12 +q to say that there might be some use cases in the former W3C Semantic Sensor Network activity. EricKauz and I have some background on IoT through the GS1 / Auto-ID Labs activities and the EPC Network architecture 13:18:13 … It's the Web of Services, built on the Web of Data. I'll be looking at how this WG and others can support services online. 13:18:23 … May be new use cases for us from that meeting. 13:18:30 q+ 13:18:41 The RFORE use case I provided does cover this to some extent PhilA 13:18:41 … Web of Things work is in a different department at W3C than ours. So I'm not on those calls. 13:19:00 I just didn't bring out any details yet... 13:19:06 url to iotweek in london http://www.iot-week.eu/ I know some Insight researchers are over there 13:19:13 … IoT also touches the Geospatial work I've been doing this week: semantic sensors, sensor networks, etc. 13:19:28 q+ 13:19:29 ack markharrison 13:19:30 markharrison, you wanted to say that there might be some use cases in the former W3C Semantic Sensor Network activity. EricKauz and I have some background on IoT through the GS1 / 13:19:30 ... Auto-ID Labs activities and the EPC Network architecture 13:19:46 markharrison: There might be some use cases from IoT from former SSN activity 13:20:11 Geo charter http://www.w3.org/2014/05/geo-charter 13:20:23 that would be interesting markharrison 13:21:18 +Makx_Dekkers 13:21:35 ack Yaso 13:21:38 I’m gonna be in Berlin for the IoT W3C Workshop also. I’ve been reading a lot and trying to “connect the points” between inovation and data… the discussions around data preservation, best protocols, Semantic Web, all this issues are adressed to data usage. People are building new protocols to exchange data in litle packages (on mobile), for example. 13:21:43 I can talk :-/ 13:21:47 ops 13:21:48 can’t 13:21:55 PhilA: We should have had a f2f meeting in Berlin! 13:22:01 hahaha 13:22:12 ack mt 13:22:13 It’s because the summer, I think, Phil 13:22:15 ack MTCarrasco 13:22:42 yeah, it could have been good idea having a f2f in Berlin :) 13:22:43 MTCarrasco: In our own institutions, some of our URIs are kilometres long and we need to sort that. 13:22:58 ... on preservation, we need to think about what sensor data needs to be stored 13:23:19 ... not every bit of data needs to be kept but what to keep. These should be addressed early in the IoT 13:23:27 +q to suggest that Keio University researchers may have useful contributions on geo-charter, in connection with their efforts on disaster relief co-ordination (demand vs supply) in Japan using Linked Open Data 13:23:34 ack markharrison 13:23:34 markharrison, you wanted to suggest that Keio University researchers may have useful contributions on geo-charter, in connection with their efforts on disaster relief co-ordination 13:23:34 ack mark 13:23:37 ... (demand vs supply) in Japan using Linked Open Data 13:24:29 action-47? 13:24:29 action-47 -- Bernadette Farias Loscio to Discuss with eric data usage meaning for the use case requirements, and for the vocabulary and finding consensus in the group -- due 2014-06-20 -- OPEN 13:24:29 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/47 13:24:30 markharrison: on the geo charter http://www.w3.org/2014/05/geo-charter, some have been using LOD to work with Geo WG. GS1 also has conections via Keio 13:24:46 HadleyBeeman: Do you know about this ericstephan? 13:25:42 ericstephan: Yes. This past week I've been attending a workshop in japan (remotely) which is a high energy physics event... my way of saying why I haven't done this. But Bernadette did send an e-mail asking for feedback so I encourage people to do that 13:25:48 ... she and I hope to meet on Tuesday 13:25:56 ... outr combined vocab call will be this Thursday 13:26:11 Note also that some GS1 staff are working closely with the Red Cross on use of data to help with relief efforts - EricKauz or I can find those connections too in case they can contribute use cases for geo-charter 13:26:15 HadleyBeeman: I think there'll be something on use cases in the vocab call on Thursday 13:26:17 action-48? 13:26:17 action-48 -- Newton Calegari to Will talk with other members to improve this versioning doc. in the next week i'll meet with flavio to discuss about it -- due 2014-06-20 -- OPEN 13:26:17 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/48 13:26:36 Today is holliday in Brazil 13:26:50 And there’s the WorldCup… 13:26:56 action-49? 13:26:56 action-49 -- Newton Calegari to Follow the DAURI doc proposed by tomas (bp - uri doc) -- due 2014-06-20 -- OPEN 13:26:56 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/49 13:27:26 MTCarrasco: I'm working on @@@ 13:27:36 s/@@@/that document 13:27:46 action-50? 13:27:46 action-50 -- Bernadette Farias Loscio to Organise a discussion by email on https://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/wiki/best_practices_guidelines#general_guidelines -- due 2014-06-20 -- OPEN 13:27:46 http://www.w3.org/2013/dwbp/track/actions/50 13:27:46 MTCarrasco: I believe sometime this week there will be something to show 13:28:11 +q 13:28:14 HadleyBeeman: Happy to discuss it or leave it until Bernadette is here 13:28:21 ack ericstephan 13:28:37 ericstephan: That action links to the feedback request that Bernadette made 13:28:54 do we need an action item for new action items? 13:29:30 topic: Steve's Thoughts on the process 13:29:46 HadleyBeeman: We have ways to check with the community, find evidence that suggestions are being used and validated 13:30:01 .. but we don't have a way to combine each doc and for them to inform each other 13:30:18 ... so his suggestion ... was that software development methodologies might be useful 13:30:40 ... think in terms of an agile sprint. Discovery (UCR) and then we create a minimum viable product (initial draft) 13:30:45 ... and we iterate 13:31:03 ... he was talking about that makes it easier to think of other use cases and it's easier to add in new ones 13:31:09 q+ 13:31:14 ... have them feed into new parts of the doc 13:31:19 ... does this help editors? 13:31:22 ack BartvanLeeuwen 13:31:41 BartvanLeeuwen: as one of the editors, this might be helpful, as it's not clear where to start 13:31:57 ... but the problem I see is that if you want the docs reviewed then you need the reviewers to keep pace 13:32:08 ... getting reviews can be hard - finding enough people who are motivated 13:32:16 q+ 13:32:36 HadleyBeeman: Would it be easier if reviewers understood where the docs were in the process 13:32:37 +q 13:32:41 ack Yaso 13:32:46 tks 13:32:50 just a suggestion, but, maybe using git can help us with the reviews 13:33:04 q+ 13:33:10 since only people with w3c login can change the wiki 13:33:33 using git we can have review and suggestions irt 13:33:34 HadleyBeeman: I've been assuming that editing on the wiki is easier than github. But for her, GitHub is easier... 13:33:37 in real tme 13:33:39 time 13:33:40 q+ 13:33:57 PhilA :-) 13:33:59 HadleyBeeman: using GitHub makes it easier for outsiders to make contributions 13:34:16 HadleyBeeman: But we can probably find ways to make this work 13:34:34 ericstephan: It's an interesting idea. Is this of itself a DWBP use case. Is this a dog food opportunity 13:34:49 ... we have GitHub and we've been using it in the CSVW 13:34:58 +1 to the proposal of an agile approach by using software methodologies and the definition of sprints. 13:35:03 ... it has its own issue tracker etc 13:35:18 +1 13:35:38 ericstephan: We could look for ways to exercise some of the things we talk about 13:35:41 ack eric 13:35:42 ack BartvanLeeuwen 13:36:08 BartvanLeeuwen: I'm not sure what the W3C regs are on this, but if you take issues on GitHub, how do we track them 13:36:38 ack PhilA 13:36:45 re: archiving comments: see example: https://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/DCAT_Comments 13:36:53 q+ 13:37:01 q+ 13:37:25 CSVW is using the issue and action tracker 13:38:03 ack Yaso 13:38:05 tks! just a question to PhilA: do we have to obey these rules? http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt 13:38:06 +q 13:38:30 ok 13:39:14 ok! Thank you 13:39:18 ack HadleyBeeman 13:39:27 https://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/DCAT_Comments 13:39:37 HadleyBeeman: `I wanted to answer Bart's comment 13:39:54 HadleyBeeman: We need to show who commented, what they said and that we sorted it with them 13:40:12 -q 13:40:13 ... we have to demonstrate that they got our reply and that they're happy with it 13:40:25 ... so if we used GitHub then we'd need to link to those 13:40:36 HadleyBeeman: We need to be able to present this content somewhere 13:40:48 BartvanLeeuwen: Sounds good to me 13:41:20 HadleyBeeman: I feel like we're opening the topic today but we may not resolve it today 13:41:36 ... if all of you are comfortable with it, I'd like to talk about it again next week 13:41:42 sounds like a provenance use case 13:41:48 ... do what you'd like but please share with us what you're doing 13:42:21 ericstephan: If you have some comments in GH, if you're using Issue Tracker... I see a graph in my mind. I want to see everything associated, the comments, the changes etc 13:42:51 ericstephan: To me it's just a reakl world example of document transclusion and how you would piece it together for someone to understand 13:43:02 HadleyBeeman: +1 13:43:30 +1 for provanance 13:43:34 q+ 13:43:40 ack BartvanLeeuwen 13:43:53 http://www.w3.org/2013/meeting/dwbp/2014-06-12 13:44:00 -MTCarrasco 13:44:09 BartvanLeeuwen: I had a quick look at the products... in the vocab group meeting, we said we'd keep issues on main maling list 13:44:36 action: phil to update tracker products 13:44:36 Created ACTION-52 - Update tracker products [on Phil Archer - due 2014-06-27]. 13:44:59 -HadleyBeeman 13:45:26 I can scribe, Phil 13:45:31 I can’t talk 13:45:44 scribe: Yaso 13:45:44 no problem 13:46:04 +q 13:46:16 ack ericstephan 13:46:39 Ericstephan: I changed emails with Steve this week, about the white house, 13:47:18 … I think we have an opportunity. Steve mentioned standard organizations that we can work with 13:47:38 … we can see if there’s any intersections with our work 13:48:19 PhilA: one of the problems that we have is that w3c doesn’t have staff in Washington 13:48:57 …so.. Bernadette Hyland can help Steve to get there 13:51:08 -JoaoPauloAlmeida 13:51:56 …there’s a new guy on ?? 13:52:06 s/??/NIH/ 13:52:22 ericstephan: that’s a very influential organization 13:53:53 PhilA: anything else? 13:54:11 … I’m gonna have to regrets the next week 13:54:30 thx phill 13:54:33 bye all, nice weekend 13:54:37 -ericstephan 13:54:39 -EricKauz 13:54:39 Thanks 13:54:41 -PhilA 13:54:42 -BartvanLeeuwen 13:54:46 RSSagent: make minutes 13:54:46 -SumitPurohit 13:54:48 Bye! 13:54:49 -deirdrelee 13:54:49 -laufer 13:54:53 -Makx_Dekkers 13:54:56 trackbot end meeting 13:54:56 Zakim, list attendees 13:54:56 As of this point the attendees have been MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida, +1.617.646.aaaa, +1.509.375.aabb, ericstephan, laufer, SumitPurohit, +44.122.374.aacc, 13:54:56 q- 13:54:59 ... markharrison, +1.609.557.aadd, deirdrelee, EricKauz, BartvanLeeuwen, Yaso, Makx_Dekkers 13:55:04 RRSAgent, please draft minutes 13:55:04 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/06/20-dwbp-minutes.html trackbot 13:55:05 RRSAgent, bye 13:55:20 -SumitPurohit 13:55:24 rrsagent, make logs public 13:56:31 Yaso has left #dwbp 13:57:27 -Yaso 13:58:44 regrets: Antoine, Christophe, Jeremy, Bernadette, Carlos, Steve, Ivan 13:59:18 -markharrison 13:59:19 DATA_DWBP()9:00AM has ended 13:59:19 Attendees were MTCarrasco, PhilA, HadleyBeeman, JoaoPauloAlmeida, +1.617.646.aaaa, +1.509.375.aabb, ericstephan, laufer, SumitPurohit, +44.122.374.aacc, markharrison, 13:59:19 ... +1.609.557.aadd, deirdrelee, EricKauz, BartvanLeeuwen, Yaso, Makx_Dekkers 14:10:52 zakim, bye 14:10:52 Zakim has left #dwbp 14:10:56 rrsagent, bye 14:10:56 I see 2 open action items saved in http://www.w3.org/2014/06/20-dwbp-actions.rdf : 14:10:56 ACTION: ericstephan to work with SumitPurohit to put a wiki page together showing other examples of closed data that may not be in the UCR [1] 14:10:56 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2014/06/20-dwbp-irc#T13-15-25 14:10:56 ACTION: phil to update tracker products [2] 14:10:56 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2014/06/20-dwbp-irc#T13-44-36