14:02:53 RRSAgent has joined #dpub 14:02:53 logging to http://www.w3.org/2014/04/14-dpub-irc 14:02:55 RRSAgent, make logs public 14:02:55 Zakim has joined #dpub 14:02:57 Zakim, this will be dpub 14:02:57 I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, trackbot 14:02:58 Meeting: Digital Publishing Interest Group Teleconference 14:02:58 Date: 14 April 2014 14:04:52 mgylling has joined #dpub 14:06:57 zakim, this will be 3782 14:06:57 I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, ivan 14:07:27 restarting in 1 minute to recover full bridge state 14:08:14 ivan, our call starts 52 minutes from now right? 14:08:58 yes 14:09:03 ok, good 14:09:05 but zakim is sick:-( 14:09:10 bot restarting; /invite bot in 1 minute if you wish 14:09:30 we had some internal issues due to heartbleed, had to change certificates 14:09:32 :-( 14:09:38 ah 14:09:44 damn security issues 14:09:57 but you see that zakim is rebooting, hopefully that will work 14:21:25 Zakim has joined #dpub 14:27:18 zakim, this will be 3782 14:27:18 ok, ivan; I see DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM scheduled to start in 33 minutes 14:48:25 gcapiel has joined #dpub 14:48:40 fjh has joined #dpub 14:55:37 liza has joined #dpub 14:56:00 DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM has now started 14:56:08 +??P21 14:56:13 david_stroup has joined #dpub 14:56:14 + +1.617.453.aaaa 14:56:23 gcapiel has joined #dpub 14:56:30 -??P21 14:56:39 + +1.917.207.aabb 14:56:45 Zakim, aabb is me 14:56:45 +dauwhe; got it 14:56:47 +??P21 14:57:00 AH_Miller has joined #dpub 14:57:40 zakim, code? 14:57:40 the conference code is 3782 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), fjh 14:57:46 Zakim, ??P21 is me 14:57:46 +gcapiel; got it 14:57:51 +[IPcaller] 14:57:56 zakim, ipcaller is me 14:57:56 +fjh; got it 14:58:11 Present+ Frederick_Hirsch 14:58:19 +[IPcaller] 14:58:26 + +1.505.603.aacc 14:58:45 tzviya has joined #dpub 14:58:50 azaroth has joined #DPUB 14:58:56 brady_duga has joined #dpub 14:59:00 zakim, who is here? 14:59:00 On the phone I see +1.617.453.aaaa, dauwhe, gcapiel, fjh, [IPcaller], +1.505.603.aacc 14:59:02 On IRC I see brady_duga, azaroth, tzviya, AH_Miller, gcapiel, david_stroup, liza, fjh, Zakim, mgylling, RRSAgent, pbelfanti, Bert, dauwhe, ivan, liam, trackbot, plinss, astearns 14:59:09 zakim, aacc is azaroth 14:59:09 +azaroth; got it 14:59:18 + +1.201.387.aadd 14:59:30 zakim, aadd is tzviya 14:59:30 +tzviya; got it 14:59:42 zakim, aaaa is me 14:59:42 +liza; got it 14:59:47 +??P32 14:59:55 zakim, P32 is me 14:59:55 sorry, mgylling, I do not recognize a party named 'P32' 15:00:05 + +1.201.236.aaee 15:00:06 +Ivan 15:00:11 zakim, ??P32 is me 15:00:11 +mgylling; got it 15:00:15 +duga 15:00:26 +Bert 15:00:44 zakim, who is here 15:00:44 mgylling, you need to end that query with '?' 15:00:47 zakim, who is here? 15:00:47 On the phone I see liza, dauwhe, gcapiel, fjh, [IPcaller], azaroth, tzviya, mgylling, +1.201.236.aaee, Ivan, duga, Bert 15:00:49 On IRC I see brady_duga, azaroth, tzviya, AH_Miller, david_stroup, liza, fjh, Zakim, mgylling, RRSAgent, pbelfanti, Bert, dauwhe, ivan, liam, trackbot, plinss, astearns 15:01:16 zakim, aaee is pbelfanti 15:01:16 +pbelfanti; got it 15:01:19 + +1.917.447.aaff 15:01:34 +Karen_Myers 15:01:52 + +1.585.217.aagg 15:02:18 regrets: Thierry, Alan, Julie 15:02:28 gcapiel has joined #dpub 15:02:53 benjaminsko has joined #dpub 15:02:57 karen has joined #dpub 15:03:26 Zakim, IPcaller is AH_Miller 15:03:26 +AH_Miller; got it 15:03:29 zakim, aaff is benjaminsko 15:03:29 +benjaminsko; got it 15:03:35 zakim, IPcaller is AH_Miller 15:03:35 sorry, ivan, I do not recognize a party named 'IPcaller' 15:04:02 zakim, aagg is david_stroup 15:04:02 +david_stroup; got it 15:04:20 scribenick: dauwhe 15:04:35 + +1.303.475.aahh 15:04:43 +1 scribes 15:05:17 mgylling: before agenda, Michael Miller has joined W3C from Antenna House 15:05:21 zakim, aahh is casey 15:05:21 +casey; got it 15:05:37 AH_Miller: From Antenna House for 11 years 15:05:41 gcapiel has joined #dpub 15:05:52 TomDN has joined #dpub 15:05:55 ... we work with paged media 15:05:56 Vlad has joined #dpub 15:06:01 ... interested in EPUB as well 15:06:02 + +329331aaii 15:06:21 ... been wanting to participate for some time, we finally convinced the president to join W3C 15:06:21 Zakim, +32 is me 15:06:21 +TomDN; got it 15:06:33 ... to work with the standards that influence our business so much 15:06:41 +Vlad 15:06:50 mgylling: I expect that CSS and layouts are primary interests 15:06:54 Sorry I am late 15:06:58 ... are you aware of Latinreq 15:07:20 AH_Miller: I've just started looking at it, along with Mr. Murakami 15:07:23 +Suzanne_Taylor 15:07:41 mgylling: great, and welcome! 15:07:52 st has joined #dpub 15:08:22 mgylling: next Monday, major holiday in Sweden and most Euro countries 15:08:25 regrets for next week 15:08:33 regrets for next week too 15:08:49 regrets for next week 15:08:57 ... easy choice. Next monday's meeting is cancelled 15:09:08 ... quick question about organizing a metadata call 15:09:15 ... should we discuss this here? 15:09:37 Ivan: Bill Kasdorf is out this week, so not being organized yet 15:09:43 ... I was travelling 15:10:03 ... We should wait for Bill Kasdorf to come back, then organize call 15:10:27 ... many emails recently from Luc and Julie Morris about mini-ONIX. Looks promising 15:10:47 mgylling: Good. One upcoming meeting will be review of Bill/Madi interview sessions. 15:10:54 .... we could have metadata orgy in two weeks :) 15:11:04 ... two topics for today 15:11:34 ... Thierry is not here today 15:11:41 ... but with Ivan and Karen here we can talk about 15:11:55 ... Topic: w3c specs of interest to digital publishing community 15:12:04 https://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/W3C_specs_for_DPUB 15:12:19 ... this is one of the deliverables we were charted to produce 15:12:26 ... first sentence quotes charter 15:12:43 ... how is this intended to be used? 15:12:58 ... it's already exceedingly large, and such things become difficult to work with 15:13:12 Ivan: w3c doesn't have any more say than anyone else 15:13:19 ... what's useful? 15:13:27 ... what information is useful for the community? 15:13:57 ... I would probably separate recommendations (cast in concrete) 15:13:59 Luc has joined #dpub 15:14:08 ... perhaps separate primers, tutorials (???) 15:14:29 ... most important thing is probably documents that are important to community but haven't reached rec status 15:14:39 ... maybe get current plans on status 15:14:56 ... references to Editor's drafts as well as published versions 15:15:12 + +33.6.48.38.aajj 15:15:26 ... which of these are implemented? IDPF and BISG are already dealing with this on some level 15:15:44 ... goal is getting info out of the maze of w3c pages, make it more accessible to the publishing community 15:15:47 q+ 15:15:53 ... leave it to the group to decide what is useful 15:15:56 zakim, aajj is Luc 15:15:56 +Luc; got it 15:15:59 mgylling: right 15:16:20 ...this could be a living resource, stay as wiki page 15:16:42 ... usually what happens is that when a WG closes, wiki pages become read-only 15:16:48 s/.../Ivan 15:17:05 Ivan: we might need to move to different wiki outside of DPUB, after DPUB closes 15:17:14 + +1.609.216.aakk 15:17:18 mgylling: you mentioned palatibility 15:17:32 ... the intended audience isn't exclusively w3c working groups and members 15:17:41 Ivan: meant for publishing community, NOT w3c 15:18:19 zakim, aakk is Laura_Fowler 15:18:19 +Laura_Fowler; got it 15:18:33 ???: target is general pub community, so it needs to be less technical 15:18:46 ... to set context, etc. then have links to deeper content 15:18:54 s/???/pbelfanti/ 15:19:03 mgylling: some kind of overlay as gentle introduction? 15:19:18 pbelfanti: in layout and styling, the order is not how you'd want to digest 15:19:25 ... some organization along those lines would be good 15:19:38 ... plus high-level description of what sections are about, who would be interested 15:19:51 ... under the premise that the target audience is the publishing community 15:20:00 ... including non-technical users 15:20:15 Ivan: I would try to put it in priority order 15:20:32 ... the first target audience is the more technical folks within the publishing community 15:21:06 ... how to I find latest version of X CSS module? That's hard to do now. 15:21:27 ... each document does have an abstract, per w3c pub rules. We could add that to table 15:21:40 ... going way beyond that, eventually that might make sense, but is lots of work 15:21:53 pbelfanti: the abstracts are pretty clear 15:22:08 ... let's have a bit more heirarchy to guide people in a larger sense 15:22:15 mgylling: multiple tables 15:22:34 ... one more question - this looks both forward and backward in time 15:22:36 q- 15:22:57 ... we have XML namespaces listed. I don't know if that's interesting information, since it's already a rec 15:23:14 ... it's not something people need to work on going forward 15:23:23 +1 15:23:25 ... should we remove stuff that's not forward looking 15:23:34 ... xml events, SMIL 3... 15:23:45 ... it's not expected that SMIL 3 will evolve 15:23:48 suggest breaking it in two, foward looking list and list of completed relevant work 15:24:11 Ivan: If I look at xproc, it's not even used by anything in epub 15:24:19 ... may be used by back-end process 15:24:26 q+ 15:24:36 ... there is already a separation of back-end technologies vs front end 15:24:44 ... that's one high level cut 15:24:56 ... I don't know if XML events are even used 15:25:03 ... there is a need for a filter 15:25:34 mgylling: Paul wants multiple tables, Ivan wants separation with back-end tech vs front-end 15:25:54 ... some aren't really related to vision and problems of publishing industry 15:25:55 q- 15:26:03 ... so we can make it smaller 15:26:22 mgylling: as far as doing the work, any volunteers to refactor as proposed? 15:26:35 Ivan: I think that we cannot expect Thierry to do filtering 15:27:01 ... first step should be one of you guys to go through the list, exclude and define large categories 15:27:22 ... Neither he nor I can do the filtering. 15:27:33 mgylling: Liza and I could work directly on wiki page 15:27:45 ... we won't be nervous due to history :) 15:27:57 ... more questions on our beloved table? 15:28:11 Luc: don't get rid of things too soon 15:28:26 ... some might not be used now, but should be left here for future use 15:28:33 mgylling: example please? 15:28:39 Luc: xproc. 15:28:50 ... I hope epub won't be static 15:29:08 ???: Let's keep the original as reference, valuable to have both focused short list 15:29:18 s/???/fjh:/ 15:29:25 mgylling: ready to move on? 15:29:43 Topic: Accessibility and personalization task force 15:29:47 ... Topic: discuss a11y task force from perspective of focus areas 15:30:02 Apoloigies, I need to drop now 15:30:03 ... we defined small sets of goals, which a11y group did 15:30:08 -pbelfanti 15:30:16 ... we want to focus on use cases, and discussion around those 15:30:36 ... the approach is to consider the question of what exactly in a11y use cases is specific to publishing 15:30:44 ... reading through the use cases so far 15:30:52 ... all of them are important and valid 15:31:05 ... but many are general use cases, not specific to publishing 15:31:26 ... also, in terms of focus areas, if we want to seize the opportunity here, what would be highest priority? 15:31:33 ... that's the questions we want to ask. 15:31:42 ... how can we clean up or restructure the use cases 15:31:54 ... and focus on publishing-specific problems 15:32:11 ... and what should be our highest priority to affect w3c work 15:32:35 gcapiel: there's further work in fleshing these out 15:32:43 ... this was a first pass before TPAC 15:33:05 ... these are general use cases and gaps for OWP, not specific to DPUB 15:33:13 ... the only one you could debate 15:33:22 ... is timed text (???) 15:33:32 ... it's already digital content 15:33:50 ... content with media overlays 15:34:05 ... timed text is the only specification that [dropout] 15:34:14 mgylling: we lost gerardo 15:34:18 ... we can't hear you 15:34:50 gcapiel: I'm back. 15:35:21 ... that's the one area where there isn't any great way to deal with that syncronized audio and text, and its very specific to digital publishing 15:35:49 mgylling: so that would indicate it would be nice to have a group of use cases that focus on hybrid, multiple-modality books 15:35:51 gcapiel: yes 15:36:03 mgylling: we could approach DAISY to contribute use cases 15:36:12 ... unless you have something up your sleeve 15:36:27 gcapiel: Daniel was involved in timed text and knows about this 15:36:33 ... DAISY knows a lot more about this 15:36:51 mgylling: action on document-wide text synchronization 15:37:06 ... SMIL might not be best solution 15:37:11 ... those are design issues 15:37:25 ... that's one nice area where we can provide use cases 15:37:39 ... what other kinds of things, even if not unique 15:37:52 ... what are particularly critical to digital publishing 15:38:06 ... media overlays are unlikely to be widely used in browsers 15:38:12 ... are there other such areas? 15:38:39 SuzanneT: the personalization use cases fall in that category 15:38:55 ... Pre-K through middle schools: what to do with captions 15:39:08 ... specialized subject areas like chemistry, poetry, grammar 15:39:17 ... more critical for textbooks 15:39:36 mgylling: these are most critical? 15:39:52 SuzanneT: we must solve these issues as an educational publisher 15:40:11 mgylling: in educational environ, you have timing of tests 15:40:25 zakim, who is noisy? 15:40:36 mgylling, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: mgylling (84%), Suzanne_Taylor (24%) 15:40:37 SuzanneT: I can flesh those out 15:41:00 mgylling: would be good to see a complete set, I do see some that are not yet linked 15:41:16 ... can you give overview of allowing versions? 15:41:24 SuzanneT: Gerardo put that in 15:41:37 gcapiel: I should look at that 15:41:54 ... the issue with image descriptions allowing them to be improved over time 15:42:08 mgylling: then we have general a11y use cases 15:42:20 ... the specialized subject area categories 15:42:24 ... want to ask about infographics 15:42:37 ... is that an area where DPUB has a more significant issue 15:42:43 q+ 15:42:51 SuzanneT: probably very important to publishers 15:43:10 ... also can be interactive infographics, which makes it more complex 15:43:17 -casey 15:43:26 mgylling: Gerardo, you've worked with SVG folks on use cases 15:43:37 ... should we hone in on infographics in education problem? 15:43:51 ... presumably the solution is the same for OWP and publishing 15:44:04 ... this is a big pain point for educational publishers 15:44:20 ... this is a black hole where people don't know where to go 15:44:32 SuzanneT: say you publish an infographic for chemists 15:45:06 ... can give data tables as backup, which is OK for professional chemist 15:45:17 ack Tzviya 15:45:19 ... but that won't work for 4th grader, where that data would not be helpful 15:46:16 tzviya: Image descriptions have been harder for business books, like graphics designed to make stock trading fun. Hard to do an image 15:46:25 ... description that keeps the tone 15:46:54 gcapiel: that graphic may be best conveyed using a combo of text and embossed material 15:47:18 ... we've been looking at how to enhance ARIA roles in SVG to be able to provide that type of experience 15:47:23 -duga 15:47:44 mgylling: we should publish a note on a11y and personalization in publishing 15:47:51 ... this is the kind of stuff we need in the use cases 15:47:58 ... without going too far in solution space 15:48:12 ... SuzanneT, you've offered to flesh out the first three 15:48:20 ... Gerardo, you will work on versions 15:48:34 gcapiel has joined #dpub 15:48:35 ... DAISY will help with audio sync 15:48:53 SuzanneT: there's one on highlighting text, adding notes and items 15:49:00 ... we've put that into the annotations use cases 15:49:13 §q 15:49:25 ... this category is accesibility of ebook features 15:49:33 -q 15:49:35 mgylling: can OWP help solve that? 15:49:51 SuzanneT: with annotations, we need more data to make annotations fully a11y 15:50:00 ... don't have other examples right now 15:50:05 mgylling: OK 15:50:24 ... Gerardo, can you look into infographics restructuring? 15:50:26 gcapiel: sure 15:50:52 mgylling: it would be good if we could get the wiki main page to resemble the eventual structure of the note 15:51:01 ... right now doesn't give me a quick overview 15:51:18 q+ 15:51:18 gcapiel: we have to take out the general use cases, not specific to DPUB 15:51:29 mgylling: good question 15:51:39 gcapiel: like math, that's a problem not specific to dpub 15:51:45 ack ivan 15:51:48 myglling: mentioned all the time as pain point 15:52:07 tzviya: lots aren't specific to publishing, but they are so common it's worth mentioning 15:52:32 Ivan: the math is a wrong example, in that publishing needs math way more than anyone else 15:52:37 ... so we should keep math 15:52:44 ... if it's on the borderline 15:52:55 ... Suzanne, are you on WAI working group? 15:53:11 ... ask them where these use cases should go 15:53:25 ... at end of the day, this doc would be very valuable for those groups 15:53:32 ... so we should sync with those groups 15:53:51 SuzanneT: we can move general use cases into a category 15:54:06 ... we can hand off some things 15:54:16 mgylling: there is a gap 15:54:31 ... whoever added them is right. Added descriptions are one-dimensional 15:54:52 SuzanneT: You mean user chooses that they want short descriptions? 15:55:06 mgylling: Maybe annotations can play a role, where tech is more adaptible 15:55:24 ... first, let's create a bucket of general stuff 15:55:37 ... then categories we populate first for publishing 15:55:48 gcapiel1 has joined #dpub 15:55:57 SuzanneT: the categories are infographics, educational enviornment, specialized subject areas 15:56:03 ... we should keep math separate 15:56:10 ... and then maybe ebook feature a11y 15:56:15 mgylling: we can try that 15:56:26 gcapiel: there was also the syncronized multimedia content 15:56:38 ... we haven't talked about semantics stuff much 15:56:50 ... for braille, the semantics we have today in OWP may not be sufficient 15:56:59 mgylling: exactly, even with role attribute 15:57:17 ... links with Tzviya and my working group on role attribute 15:57:32 SuzanneT: can that be under ebook feature, or should that be a separate category 15:57:38 mgylling: let's wait. 15:57:56 ... we're behind on the wiki re: the role attribute 15:58:03 ... will be easier to see later 15:58:14 ... we'll punt for now 15:58:49 SuzanneT: infographics, math, specialized subject areas, media sync, ??? 15:59:09 gcapiel: reviewing user agent a11y guidelines? 15:59:15 Ivan: separate thing. 15:59:32 ... Madi etc. would like to get feedback on that. 15:59:43 mgylling: should we ask for participation in that review? 15:59:51 s/Madi/Shawn, Shadi/ 15:59:52 ... some new folks on public list 16:00:06 ... we're out of time 16:00:17 ... we have prototype restructuring of wiki 16:00:30 ... more questions or remarks on a11y? 16:00:32 infographics, synchronized multimedia, eBook Feature A11y, Ed Environment, Math, Specialized Subject Areas 16:00:53 -gcapiel 16:00:54 -liza 16:00:55 -Karen_Myers 16:00:56 -fjh 16:00:58 -Laura_Fowler 16:00:58 -Suzanne_Taylor 16:00:58 -tzviya 16:00:59 -benjaminsko 16:00:59 -Vlad 16:01:00 -Luc 16:01:00 -TomDN 16:01:01 -azaroth 16:01:02 -dauwhe 16:01:03 -AH_Miller 16:01:04 rrsagent, draft minutes 16:01:04 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/04/14-dpub-minutes.html ivan 16:01:04 -mgylling 16:01:07 -Ivan 16:01:13 -david_stroup 16:01:14 -Bert 16:01:15 DPUB_DPUBIG()11:00AM has ended 16:01:15 Attendees were +1.617.453.aaaa, +1.917.207.aabb, dauwhe, gcapiel, fjh, +1.505.603.aacc, azaroth, +1.201.387.aadd, tzviya, liza, +1.201.236.aaee, Ivan, mgylling, duga, Bert, 16:01:15 ... pbelfanti, +1.917.447.aaff, Karen_Myers, +1.585.217.aagg, AH_Miller, benjaminsko, david_stroup, +1.303.475.aahh, casey, +329331aaii, TomDN, Vlad, Suzanne_Taylor, 16:01:16 ... +33.6.48.38.aajj, Luc, +1.609.216.aakk, Laura_Fowler 16:01:38 trackbot, end telcon 16:01:38 Zakim, list attendees 16:01:38 sorry, trackbot, I don't know what conference this is 16:01:46 RRSAgent, please draft minutes 16:01:46 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2014/04/14-dpub-minutes.html trackbot 16:01:47 RRSAgent, bye 16:01:47 I see no action items