edit

Digital Publishing Interest Group

Minutes of 24 July 2015

Seen
Charles LaPierre, Tzviya Siegman
Scribe
Charles LaPierre
IRC Log
Original
Resolutions

None.

Topics
14:58:02 <RRSAgent> logging to http://www.w3.org/2015/07/24-dpub-irc

RRSAgent IRC Bot: logging to http://www.w3.org/2015/07/24-dpub-irc

15:00:08 <clapierre> zakim, who is here?

Charles LaPierre: zakim, who is here?

15:00:08 <Zakim> sorry, clapierre, I don't know what conference this is

Zakim IRC Bot: sorry, clapierre, I don't know what conference this is

15:00:10 <Zakim> On IRC I see clapierre, RRSAgent, Zakim, tzviya, astearns, mihnea_____, iank, rego, liam, dkaplan3, plinss, trackbot

Zakim IRC Bot: On IRC I see clapierre, RRSAgent, Zakim, tzviya, astearns, mihnea_____, iank, rego, liam, dkaplan3, plinss, trackbot

15:00:19 <clapierre> zakim, will be DPub_Dpub

Charles LaPierre: zakim, will be DPub_Dpub

15:00:20 <Zakim> I don't understand 'will be DPub_Dpub', clapierre

Zakim IRC Bot: I don't understand 'will be DPub_Dpub', clapierre

15:00:28 <clapierre> zakim, this is DPub_Dpub

Charles LaPierre: zakim, this is DPub_Dpub

15:00:28 <Zakim> sorry, clapierre, I do not see a conference named 'DPub_Dpub' in progress or scheduled at this time

Zakim IRC Bot: sorry, clapierre, I do not see a conference named 'DPub_Dpub' in progress or scheduled at this time

15:00:48 <clapierre> zakim, this will be Dpub_Dpub

Charles LaPierre: zakim, this will be Dpub_Dpub

15:00:48 <Zakim> I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, clapierre

Zakim IRC Bot: I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, clapierre

15:01:06 <clapierre> rrsagent, make logs public

Charles LaPierre: rrsagent, make logs public

15:01:21 <clapierre> scribe: clapierre

(Scribe set to Charles LaPierre)

15:05:48 <clapierre> DescribedAt meeting tentative August 13 @ 12:30 eastern

DescribedAt meeting tentative August 13 @ 12:30 eastern

15:08:07 <clapierre> paul, will describedAT be part of ePub spec?

paul, will describedAT be part of ePub spec?

15:08:33 <clapierre> tzviya, well it will be contingent on ARIA 1.1 keeping it in the spec.

tzviya, well it will be contingent on ARIA 1.1 keeping it in the spec.

15:10:00 <clapierre> tzviya, we need more publishers, and we will reach out to Benetech.. who should I contact regarding Bookshare supporting describedAt?

tzviya, we need more publishers, and we will reach out to Benetech.. who should I contact regarding Bookshare supporting describedAt?

15:10:12 <clapierre> charles, probably Ahn Bui.

charles, probably Ahn Bui.

15:10:48 <clapierre> topic: Note A11Y DPUB

1. Note A11Y DPUB

15:11:06 <clapierre> deborah, we should review of where we were with the Note.

deborah, we should review of where we were with the Note.

15:11:17 <tzviya> http://w3c.github.io/dpub-accessibility/

Tzviya Siegman: http://w3c.github.io/dpub-accessibility/

15:12:07 <clapierre> …, we had a skeleton of the Note and and then had a meeting with Jean Spellman, and then got derailed with ARIA.describedAt

…, we had a skeleton of the Note and and then had a meeting with Jean Spellman, and then got derailed with ARIA.describedAt

15:12:49 <tzviya> present+Tzviya_Siegman

Tzviya Siegman: present+Tzviya_Siegman

15:12:52 <clapierre> tzviya, we should review the current Note as

tzviya, we should review the current Note as

15:13:01 <clapierre> present+Charles_LaPierre

present+Charles_LaPierre

15:13:16 <clapierre> present +Deborah Kaplan

present +Deborah Kaplan

15:13:26 <clapierre> present +Mia Lipner

present +Mia Lipner

15:13:48 <clapierre> present +Paul Belfanti

present +Paul Belfanti

15:14:11 <clapierre> deborah, we have some formatting which was auto generated.

deborah, we have some formatting which was auto generated.

15:14:43 <clapierre> …, initially we are talking about WCAG and DPUB.  Should also look at ATAG and UAG

…, initially we are talking about WCAG and DPUB. Should also look at ATAG and UAG

15:16:08 <clapierre> …, content creator side is usually huge and disorganized, UAG should be pushed more since they are more organized smaller and they should implement what is standardized.

…, content creator side is usually huge and disorganized, UAG should be pushed more since they are more organized smaller and they should implement what is standardized.

15:17:10 <clapierre> …, we looked at what currently isn't addressed in WCAG, (eg. footnotes, dropcat, phonetic spellings, heading levels best practices, escapability / skipability, …)

…, we looked at what currently isn't addressed in WCAG, (eg. footnotes, dropcat, phonetic spellings, heading levels best practices, escapability / skipability, …)

15:17:41 <clapierre> …, we think this is more UAG driven, and should adjust the NOTE initial focus potentially.

…, we think this is more UAG driven, and should adjust the NOTE initial focus potentially.

15:19:00 <clapierre> …, appendix: charles is looking into bringing all the WCAG google docs we created into that appendix.

…, appendix: charles is looking into bringing all the WCAG google docs we created into that appendix.

15:19:28 <clapierre> tzviya, not sure if this should be a separate document or keep it as an appendix.

tzviya, not sure if this should be a separate document or keep it as an appendix.

15:19:49 <clapierre> mia, thinks this should be kept in the appendix so it can be found.

mia, thinks this should be kept in the appendix so it can be found.

15:21:23 <clapierre> deborah, this note keeps changing, was aimed at publishers and now it has switched to be more W3C focused.

deborah, this note keeps changing, was aimed at publishers and now it has switched to be more W3C focused.

15:21:46 <clapierre> …, modern digital publishing is websites so WCAG is relavent.

…, modern digital publishing is websites so WCAG is relavent.

15:22:15 <tzviya> http://w3c.github.io/wai-quick-start/

Tzviya Siegman: http://w3c.github.io/wai-quick-start/

15:22:20 <clapierre> tzviya, W3C education outreach is working on their own documentation,

tzviya, W3C education outreach is working on their own documentation,

15:22:36 <clapierre> … this may be starting a whole new rabbit hole

… this may be starting a whole new rabbit hole

15:22:50 <clapierre> … there is a section on writing accessibility.

… there is a section on writing accessibility.

15:23:11 <clapierre> … she knows Robin and Julie from BISG will share this information.

… she knows Robin and Julie from BISG will share this information.

15:23:55 <clapierre> …, we already did the WCAG review but we may need to review this and make links to this note from our note.

…, we already did the WCAG review but we may need to review this and make links to this note from our note.

15:24:55 <clapierre> deborah, this is why this is a W3C note, and we should be working with WAI, and we should get Shawn on board with the issues we want addressed, and if they will support that would be great.

deborah, this is why this is a W3C note, and we should be working with WAI, and we should get Shawn on board with the issues we want addressed, and if they will support that would be great.

15:25:44 <clapierre> …, the reason why the appendix is there is that we did this work and it should be recognized.

…, the reason why the appendix is there is that we did this work and it should be recognized.

15:26:04 <clapierre> …, we don't want to create a new note describing WCAG.

…, we don't want to create a new note describing WCAG.

15:26:55 <clapierre> …, and our note to publishers is:  here are all the documents you should be be looking at and here is all the quickstart guides, and here is the note we submitted to the W3C

…, and our note to publishers is: here are all the documents you should be be looking at and here is all the quickstart guides, and here is the note we submitted to the W3C

15:27:52 <clapierre> deborah, we don't want to loose the data / information we have in our google docs.

deborah, we don't want to loose the data / information we have in our google docs.

15:28:51 <clapierre> …, 1. out of the things we are talking about that is not in our list (eg. mathml etc..), 2. write text (ie. fill out the body of the note), 3. We need help with making it W3C pretty

…, 1. out of the things we are talking about that is not in our list (eg. mathml etc..), 2. write text (ie. fill out the body of the note), 3. We need help with making it W3C pretty

15:30:02 <clapierre> …, we are basically saying: "Browser manufacturers you need to address these issues"

…, we are basically saying: "Browser manufacturers you need to address these issues"

15:34:18 <clapierre> tzviya, focus on first part of the document, and worry about the appendix initially

tzviya, focus on first part of the document, and worry about the appendix initially

15:35:07 <clapierre> …, and if there is something specific we should then pull into the main note.

…, and if there is something specific we should then pull into the main note.

15:35:45 <clapierre> …, with every document we are working on.  We need to prioritize the specific issues

…, with every document we are working on. We need to prioritize the specific issues

15:36:33 <clapierre> …, annotations is huge and maybe we need to reach out to that new working group and say this is something crucial to DPUB.

…, annotations is huge and maybe we need to reach out to that new working group and say this is something crucial to DPUB.

15:36:46 <clapierre> …, there is a CSS spec for DROPCAP

…, there is a CSS spec for DROPCAP

15:38:21 <clapierre> deborah, how to organize the Note… list out the WCAG, and UAG this what we want you to do, and Unaddressed items list them out specifically.

deborah, how to organize the Note… list out the WCAG, and UAG this what we want you to do, and Unaddressed items list them out specifically.

15:38:47 <clapierre> tzviya, also fill out the information.

tzviya, also fill out the information.

15:39:06 <clapierre> deborah, agreed this is just a skeleton.

deborah, agreed this is just a skeleton.

15:39:24 <clapierre> deborah, should we give people chunks on their own?

deborah, should we give people chunks on their own?

15:39:57 <clapierre> tzviya, lets remember we are writing to a non-publishing audience.

tzviya, lets remember we are writing to a non-publishing audience.

15:40:07 <clapierre> …, I can do footnotes and list-heads

…, I can do footnotes and list-heads

15:40:26 <clapierre> mia, I am willing to do one or two…but don't have the doc infront of me.

mia, I am willing to do one or two…but don't have the doc infront of me.

15:41:05 <clapierre> tzviya, nesting headers will be mine too.

tzviya, nesting headers will be mine too.

15:41:44 <clapierre> mia, I can do page #'s, layout & comprehension

mia, I can do page #'s, layout & comprehension

15:42:39 <clapierre> charles, diagrammer I will take this on.

charles, diagrammer I will take this on.

15:43:02 <clapierre> george should take on skipability / escapability.

george should take on skipability / escapability.

15:43:15 <clapierre> deborah, who should take on annotations?

deborah, who should take on annotations?

15:43:29 <clapierre> tzviya Rob Sandersons, or Markus.

tzviya Rob Sandersons, or Markus.

15:44:09 <clapierre> …, I have a vague understanding there … it may just be review the recomendations

…, I have a vague understanding there … it may just be review the recomendations

15:44:34 <clapierre> …, Ivan may also be able too.

…, Ivan may also be able too.

15:45:19 <clapierre> pual, Johnathan Thurstan has joined Pearson.

pual, Johnathan Thurstan has joined Pearson.

15:45:36 <clapierre> …, may be able to recruit people to help

…, may be able to recruit people to help

15:46:19 <clapierre> deborah, I can take on phonetic spelling, dropcap

deborah, I can take on phonetic spelling, dropcap

15:47:00 <clapierre> deborah, positional location… unclear ones, and I will take that on.

deborah, positional location… unclear ones, and I will take that on.

15:47:19 <clapierre> deborah, should we talk about mathml?

deborah, should we talk about mathml?

15:47:33 <clapierre> tzviya, we will discuss this Monday during our DPUB meeting.

tzviya, we will discuss this Monday during our DPUB meeting.

15:47:57 <clapierre> mia, we need to keep this in our note

mia, we need to keep this in our note

15:48:21 <clapierre> deborah, I will take on that to add a generic topic about mathML.

deborah, I will take on that to add a generic topic about mathML.

15:49:16 <clapierre> +1 on non formal!

+1 on non formal!

15:51:11 <clapierre> …, hopefully we can do this by mid-august.

…, hopefully we can do this by mid-august.

15:51:57 <clapierre> charles, will be giving a diagrammer talk August 11, and will let people know if they want to join in :)

charles, will be giving a diagrammer talk August 11, and will let people know if they want to join in :)

15:53:16 <clapierre> rrsagent, draft minutes

rrsagent, draft minutes

15:53:16 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2015/07/24-dpub-minutes.html clapierre

RRSAgent IRC Bot: I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2015/07/24-dpub-minutes.html clapierre

15:55:52 <clapierre> rrsagent, bye

rrsagent, bye

15:55:52 <RRSAgent> I see no action items

RRSAgent IRC Bot: I see no action items



Formatted by CommonScribe