15:02:12 RRSAgent has joined #dpub 15:02:12 logging to http://www.w3.org/2013/12/09-dpub-irc 15:02:14 RRSAgent, make logs public 15:02:14 Zakim has joined #dpub 15:02:16 Zakim, this will be dpub 15:02:16 ok, trackbot; I see SW_DPUB-IG()11:00AM scheduled to start in 58 minutes 15:02:17 Meeting: Digital Publishing Interest Group Teleconference 15:02:17 Date: 09 December 2013 15:02:29 Bert has joined #dpub 15:43:35 mgylling has joined #dpub 15:46:24 fjh has joined #dpub 15:50:55 dshkolnik has joined #dpub 15:51:07 LauraFowler has joined #DPUB 15:52:33 SW_DPUB-IG()11:00AM has now started 15:52:40 +??P12 15:56:29 azaroth has joined #dpub 15:57:01 Luc has joined #dpub 15:57:03 +mijordan 15:57:25 zakim, code? 15:57:25 the conference code is 3782 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), ivan 15:57:45 tzviya has joined #dpub 15:57:55 Will be late driving boy into school 15:58:00 +ivan 15:58:09 +dauwhe 15:58:17 zakim, who is noisy? 15:58:28 Suzanne has joined #dpub 15:58:28 ivan, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: 4 (13%), ivan (9%) 15:58:32 +Tzviya 15:58:45 zakim, who is here? 15:58:45 On the phone I see ??P12, mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya 15:58:47 On IRC I see Suzanne, tzviya, Luc, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, dauwhe_, m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 15:58:55 +laudrain 15:59:04 +Suzanne_Taylor 15:59:19 +??P36 15:59:29 Zakim, ??P36 is mgylling 15:59:29 +mgylling; got it 15:59:52 TomDN has joined #dpub 15:59:55 zakim, ??P12 is gcapiel 15:59:55 +gcapiel; got it 15:59:55 walkley has joined #dpub 16:00:03 zakim, who is here? 16:00:03 On the phone I see gcapiel, mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain, Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling 16:00:05 On IRC I see walkley, TomDN, Suzanne, tzviya, Luc, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, dauwhe_, m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 16:00:06 +[Ugent] 16:00:09 Dmitry Shkolnik is on the phone too 16:00:15 + +1.505.603.aaaa 16:00:15 zakim, +[Ugent] is me 16:00:16 sorry, TomDN, I do not recognize a party named '+[Ugent]' 16:00:31 zakim, [Ugent] is me 16:00:31 +TomDN; got it 16:00:31 zakim, aaaa is azaroth 16:00:32 +azaroth; got it 16:00:37 zakim, mute me 16:00:37 TomDN should now be muted 16:00:38 Hajar has joined #dpub 16:00:42 -gcapiel 16:00:48 karen has joined #dpub 16:00:51 +??P38 16:01:01 Zakim, Hajar is with TomDN 16:01:01 +duga 16:01:02 +Hajar; got it 16:01:13 +??P39 16:01:16 brady_duga has joined #dpub 16:01:17 Sharad has joined #dpub 16:01:27 Zakim, P38 is walkley 16:01:27 sorry, walkley, I do not recognize a party named 'P38' 16:01:28 +Vlad 16:01:40 + +1.503.887.aabb 16:01:45 zakim, ??P38 is walkley 16:01:45 +walkley; got it 16:01:46 Vlad has joined #dpub 16:01:54 +Bert 16:01:56 zakim, who is here? 16:01:56 On the phone I see mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain, Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling, TomDN (muted), azaroth, walkley, duga, ??P39, Vlad, +1.503.887.aabb, Bert 16:01:59 TomDN has TomDN, Hajar 16:01:59 On IRC I see Vlad, Sharad, brady_duga, karen, Hajar, walkley, TomDN, Suzanne, tzviya, Luc, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, dauwhe_, 16:01:59 ... m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 16:02:05 zakim, who is here? 16:02:05 On the phone I see mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain, Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling, TomDN (muted), azaroth, walkley, duga, ??P39, Vlad, +1.503.887.aabb, Bert 16:02:09 TomDN has TomDN, Hajar 16:02:09 On IRC I see Vlad, Sharad, brady_duga, karen, Hajar, walkley, TomDN, Suzanne, tzviya, Luc, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, dauwhe_, 16:02:09 ... m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 16:02:09 -??P39 16:02:28 + +1.212.364.aacc 16:02:29 zakim, aabb is Sharad 16:02:29 +Sharad; got it 16:02:36 +??P42 16:02:58 Bill_Kasdorf has joined #dpub 16:03:02 +[IPcaller] 16:03:03 zakim, [IPcaller] is me 16:03:03 +fjh; got it 16:03:09 Present+ Frederick_Hirsch 16:03:16 tmichel has joined #dpub 16:03:17 +madi 16:03:17 zakim, ??P42 is gcapiel 16:03:17 +gcapiel; got it 16:03:21 zakim, who is here? 16:03:21 On the phone I see mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain, Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling, TomDN (muted), azaroth, walkley, duga, Vlad, Sharad, Bert, +1.212.364.aacc, gcapiel, fjh, 16:03:24 ... madi 16:03:24 TomDN has TomDN, Hajar 16:03:24 On IRC I see tmichel, Bill_Kasdorf, Vlad, Sharad, brady_duga, karen, Hajar, walkley, TomDN, Suzanne, tzviya, Luc, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, Zakim, 16:03:24 ... RRSAgent, ivan, dauwhe_, m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 16:03:26 +Bill_Kasdorf 16:04:12 +??P48 16:04:16 zakim, ??P48 is tmichel 16:04:16 +tmichel; got it 16:04:38 Zakim, unmute me 16:04:38 TomDN should no longer be muted 16:04:48 +q 16:04:49 zakim, aacc is Phil_Madans 16:04:50 +Phil_Madans; got it 16:05:15 scribe: TomDN 16:05:15 Zakim, mute me 16:05:15 TomDN should now be muted 16:05:48 mgylling: Asks Phil to introduce himself 16:06:21 ?: I am the director of publishing standard for ? book group 16:06:45 ... interested in metadata, and joined the taskforce because of this 16:06:57 mgylling: You are warmly welcome! 16:07:18 s/?/Phil_Madans/ 16:07:24 +Laura_Fowler 16:07:26 s/?/Hachette/ 16:07:42 Topic: CSS Shapes review - status 16:07:56 mgylling: We have an outstanding request to review CSS Shapes 16:07:59 Technically Hachette Book Group (HBG) 16:08:13 ... Is there anyone on the call who would like to volunteer for this? 16:08:16 benjaminsko has joined #dpub 16:08:35 dave: I can take a look, but best effort 16:09:10 madi_ has joined #dpub 16:09:23 ?: I had a look at it. Looks great. Happy to talk about it 16:09:40 s/?/azaroth/ 16:10:00 -> http://www.w3.org/mid/201311282205.16558.bert@w3.org Bert's mail about css-shapes 16:10:23 mgylling: please post findings to the list by Monday the 16th 16:10:50 Topic: This weeks focus theme: accessibility task force 16:11:18 philm has joined #dpub 16:11:57 mgylling: Last week we decided to have TF leads present some things for discussion for their own topic, to allow task forces to have an hour of quality discussion in their field 16:12:17 ... We will probably internally review this somewhere mid January. 16:12:23 +Stearns 16:12:26 ... This week: Accessibility 16:12:52 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/Task_Forces/Accessibility 16:13:05 Suzanne: Let;s take a look at some of the data 16:13:23 Suzanne: http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/Task_Forces/Accessibility is the TF's main page 16:13:43 q+ 16:13:49 ... if you are interested in joining, please sign up there 16:13:51 -TomDN 16:14:02 -q 16:14:31 tzviya: Don't know how my name got on there. 16:14:40 q- 16:14:49 Suzanne: No problem, we can take you off 16:15:11 Suzanne: Our primary output document is the Use Cases 16:15:11 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/UseCase_Directory#Accessibility_and_Personalization 16:15:41 gcapiel has joined #dpub 16:15:42 Suzanne: We have a category on WCAG 2.0 & Education Environment / Educational Publishing 16:15:55 .. also on Pre-School through Middle School 16:16:43 ... For example: a child might need to ask an application for more time, but might not know exactly how much time 16:17:01 Thea Eaton 16:17:05 DoodleDoo 16:17:32 Suzanne: going through the categories 16:17:44 ... Specialized Subject Areas (e.g. Chemistry, Grammar, Poetry) 16:18:06 ... What do we need in the standard for these? Especially for visual impairments 16:18:17 ... Next one is Allowing Versions 16:18:45 ... ideally it would be the same W3C mechanism to make them possible 16:18:59 ... Also we have General Accessibility Use Cases 16:19:33 ... One example might be different math pronunciations 16:20:00 s/Also we have General Accessibility Use Cases/ 16:20:45 Suzanne: section on General Accessibility Use Cases has a bit of everything in there 16:21:05 q+ 16:21:16 zakim, who is noisy? 16:21:27 astearns, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: ivan (15%), laudrain (72%), gcapiel (13%) 16:21:40 ?: One of the version use cases we have is crowdsourced based post-production 16:21:45 zakim, mute laudrain 16:21:45 laudrain should now be muted 16:21:54 s/?/gcapiel/ 16:22:03 ... e.g. A parent, expert, etc. could make additions after publication 16:22:03 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/SVGCrowdDesc 16:22:24 ... e.g., alternate descriptions to images 16:22:59 dauwhe has joined #dpub 16:23:03 ... won't go into too much detail here 16:23:23 ... Probably going to come some use cases out of the EDUPUB workshops 16:23:37 ... and Interactive Widgets group 16:23:57 Suzanne: Can you add the link? 16:24:15 gcapiel: Will do (or Marcus) 16:24:27 ... Another example is MathML inside of SVG 16:24:35 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/MathSVGA11y 16:24:57 ... They would at least show the graphical representation, and then the MathML underneath 16:25:11 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/MathSonifyA11y 16:25:44 ... There's some examples under the references on the wiki 16:26:00 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/SVGStructDesc 16:26:08 ... Other work on adding HTML to SVG 16:26:25 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/SVGMediaQueriesA11y 16:26:43 ... Also something like Media Queries for stylesheets, but then for SVG 16:27:09 ... The idea is that one SVG file would have multiple modalities 16:27:26 http://www.w3.org/dpub/IG/wiki/SVGReuse 16:27:40 gcapiel: We also want to make it easier to use SVG across documents 16:28:15 .., The whole idea is to better support the portability of image description 16:28:23 s/..,/... 16:29:33 ... We also need to think about best practices around the recent schema.org adaptibility metadata 16:29:46 q? 16:29:50 ... plus all the other things that we haven't addressed 16:29:57 mgylling: Thank you. 16:30:01 ack Bill_Kasdorf 16:30:34 Bill_Kasdorf: Amazing amount of content and detail 16:31:02 ... It's going to be important to keep in mind which of these are OWP issues and which are actually reading system implementation issues 16:32:07 ... When I say reading system I include assisting technology in this 16:32:17 q+ 16:32:43 Bill_Kasdorf: for example the multiple languages for Math 16:32:46 Suzanne: Indeed something we need to talk about. 16:32:50 ack gcapiel 16:33:00 ... but the /tagging/ definitly seems something for W3C 16:33:20 q+ 16:33:33 gcapiel: Not sure how quickly those problems will be solved. Which is why we are looking for things to solve them today. 16:33:43 ... Good point about the languages 16:33:57 ... also something to consider when doing alternative descriptions for images 16:34:18 ... Maybe describethat could be used for the languages? 16:35:08 Bill_Kasdorf: We must be careful to not bypass the natural accessibility of MathML 16:35:18 zakim, who is here? 16:35:19 On the phone I see mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain (muted), Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling, TomDN (muted), azaroth, walkley, duga, Vlad, Sharad (muted), Bert, Phil_Madans, 16:35:19 ... gcapiel, fjh, madi, Bill_Kasdorf, tmichel, Laura_Fowler, Stearns 16:35:19 TomDN has TomDN, Hajar 16:35:19 On IRC I see dauwhe, gcapiel, philm, madi_, tmichel, Bill_Kasdorf, Vlad, brady_duga, karen, walkley, TomDN, Suzanne, tzviya, azaroth, LauraFowler, dshkolnik, fjh, mgylling, Bert, 16:35:23 ... Zakim, RRSAgent, ivan, m4nu, astearns, trackbot, plinss 16:35:45 q+ 16:35:47 Suzanne: Good point. You would have a library for 4th grade math, 5th grade math, .... 16:36:03 mgylling: So there are multiple questions here to be answered 16:36:17 ... First is: how do you include the content? 16:36:18 aria-describedat https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/aria-unofficial/raw-file/tip/describedat.html 16:36:41 ... second is query. how does the reader get to the right branch? 16:36:43 https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/IndieUI/raw-file/default/src/indie-ui-context.html 16:37:01 s/describethat/describedat 16:37:42 mgylling: so 1: "how do you author the content?", 2: "how do you query it?" 16:38:26 ... One of the observations is that math languages might be considered a personalisation issue 16:38:29 q? 16:38:38 Suzanne: You could change allowing versions to personalisation 16:38:55 ... There's just some of the use cases that don't fit under that 16:38:56 ack ivan 16:39:06 ... Will look into dividing them up 16:39:29 mgylling: Suzanne, you know a lot about ?? 16:40:12 IDPF interactive widgets work: https://github.com/idpf/widgets 16:40:13 ... Could you work on some clear examples/use cases for it? It's not clear for a lot of people 16:40:39 Sharad has joined #dpub 16:40:50 could someone put a clear reference to what Markus is talking about on the IRC? 16:40:53 s/??/APIP 16:40:54 -Sharad 16:40:56 +Sharad_Garg 16:41:10 Plus a link, please 16:41:38 mgylling: just describe some scenarios where APIP would be the solution 16:41:48 q? 16:41:48 Suzanne: will provide some examples 16:42:03 ivan: coming back to the MathML issue. 16:42:12 ... Must disagree with Bill 16:42:30 ... MathML as it is used, is not language-agnostic (presentation mathML) 16:42:36 -> http://www.w3.org/TR/arabic-math/ MathML in arabic context 16:43:04 http://www.imsglobal.org/apip/ 16:43:22 ... e.g., MathML in arabic context. Includes examples of similar formulae in different languages 16:43:48 ... langauge-dependent stuff in presentation mathML is put in verbatim 16:43:59 indie UI user preferences: https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/IndieUI/raw-file/default/src/indie-ui-context.html 16:44:05 ... content MathML is extremely underused 16:44:07 s/langauge/language/ 16:44:31 gcapiel: It is used, for semantics 16:44:40 Bill_Kasdorf: Also in the browser? 16:45:06 gcapiel: Yes, the semantics part. Seems to be language-agnostic. 16:45:11 q? 16:45:37 Ivan: But what about e.g. if-then constructs? They are not the same in some languages 16:46:20 gcapiel: that is text, but that cannot be evaluated automatically. The semantic part can, and there is no text in there 16:46:23 ack Tzviya 16:46:36 tzviya: Another example: it's also based on culture 16:47:04 ... e.g. difference in cultural lingo 16:48:33 ?: We should probably look into EPUB overlays, APIP, ... 16:48:38 m4nu has left #dpub 16:48:44 s/?/gcapiel 16:48:57 LauraFowler: More than happy to work on some of the use cases 16:49:50 mgylling: Question for Laura in terms of next steps: Could you contribute a use case on semantics of ? 16:49:53 LauraFowler: sure 16:50:16 Suzanne: do you have an example of what's currently missing for Assessment? 16:50:32 s/Assessment/assessments 16:50:56 LauraFowler: Some came up at EDUPUB, and we will look into providing those in the course of this week 16:51:16 mgylling: We'll need to provide an appropriate slot on the wiki 16:51:35 ... Next activities for Accessibility TF? 16:51:52 Suzanne: Still entering use cases for another couple of weeks 16:52:02 ... then a few meetings with key participants 16:52:37 ... Might need some type of proposal towards solution, even though that's not our main task 16:52:59 ... with some technical details. Especially for layers, versions, ... 16:53:41 mgylling: Building flowcharts and such is always welcome 16:54:14 mgylling: Are there more placeholders coming to the wiki page from you? 16:54:24 Suzanne: Not much more, other than details 16:54:38 q? 16:54:52 ... the basic things have been mentioned on the call, or on the wiki 16:55:13 gcapiel: There's a lot of stuff that got started, that needs more detail underneath it 16:55:30 -duga 16:55:33 brady_duga has left #dpub 16:56:03 mgylling: Question to the group: Are there any specialists/experts that we need to bring to the table? 16:56:39 Suzanne: We need more input for [did not hear] 16:56:55 s/[did not hear]/K12 and Math 16:57:07 ivan: there's an overlay to the TF of Jean in that sense 16:57:25 rrsagent, draft minutes 16:57:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/12/09-dpub-minutes.html tmichel 16:57:29 Topic: Next weeks theme 16:57:59 mgylling: Who want to go next week? 16:58:07 ... Suggestion: Rob 16:58:42 -laudrain 16:58:52 Rob: sure. Would be good that the Annotation TF is bigger than it's current size by then (1 member) 16:59:34 ... especially publishers. Of course others also welcome 16:59:34 -fjh 17:00:20 mgylling: I would like to volunteer to read through it all 17:00:30 ... anyone else? 17:00:42 liza has joined #dpub 17:01:10 q+ 17:01:19 ivan: Question which might help people decide: ATM there are 3 places where annotation is being discussed: Rob's group, IDPF, and this TF 17:01:43 ack tzviya 17:01:47 ... Curious as to how these overlap/work together/ ... 17:01:59 I get "the conference is restricted" on the phone 17:02:27 ?: Comment: I know it's a very busy period for publishers. Maybe in January there will be more feedback 17:02:51 Whoops, timezones 17:02:54 -gcapiel 17:02:57 -madi 17:02:59 -Laura_Fowler 17:03:00 -Tzviya 17:03:00 rrsagent, draft minutes 17:03:05 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/12/09-dpub-minutes.html tmichel 17:03:05 -azaroth 17:03:05 -mgylling 17:03:05 Zakim, unmute me 17:03:05 -Sharad_Garg 17:03:05 TomDN should no longer be muted 17:03:05 -Bill_Kasdorf 17:03:05 -mijordan 17:03:05 -Phil_Madans 17:03:05 -dauwhe 17:03:05 -Suzanne_Taylor 17:03:05 -walkley 17:03:05 -Vlad 17:03:07 -Stearns 17:03:08 -ivan 17:03:08 -Bert 17:03:10 fjh has left #dpub 17:03:20 -tmichel 17:03:23 gcapiel has joined #dpub 17:03:40 Does anyone generate the minutes from here? 17:03:56 No, Markus, it's right, I was going from the last time I attended which must've been before DST changed 17:03:57 TomDN, yes, tmichel already did 17:04:08 My apologies 17:04:15 ok, thanks! 17:04:17 bye 17:04:22 -TomDN 17:04:24 SW_DPUB-IG()11:00AM has ended 17:04:24 Attendees were mijordan, ivan, dauwhe, Tzviya, laudrain, Suzanne_Taylor, mgylling, gcapiel, +1.505.603.aaaa, TomDN, azaroth, duga, Hajar, Vlad, +1.503.887.aabb, walkley, Bert, 17:04:24 ... +1.212.364.aacc, Sharad, fjh, madi, Bill_Kasdorf, tmichel, Phil_Madans, Laura_Fowler, Stearns, Sharad_Garg 17:04:26 TomDN gets massive amount of karma points for scribing 17:05:25 I'm an idiot! 17:06:37 oh, we've all done it ;-) 17:11:50 gcapiel has joined #dpub 18:46:16 st has joined #dpub 18:53:51 philm has joined #dpub 19:07:21 Bert has left #dpub 19:17:55 Zakim has left #dpub 19:19:21 gcapiel1 has joined #dpub 19:28:01 mgylling has joined #dpub 19:40:11 philm has joined #dpub 19:55:27 philm has joined #dpub 19:56:53 philm has joined #dpub 20:05:45 philm has joined #dpub 20:06:04 philm has left #dpub 20:27:10 gcapiel has joined #dpub 20:44:47 m4nu has joined #dpub 21:31:21 m4nu has left #dpub 21:32:12 m4nu has joined #dpub 21:40:14 liam has joined #dpub