08:01:14 RRSAgent has joined #mlw-lt 08:01:14 logging to http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-irc 08:01:22 Zakim has joined #mlw-lt 08:02:18 Arle has joined #mlw-lt 08:02:21 present+ Arle 08:04:14 meeting: mlw-lt f2f 08:04:16 chair: felix 08:04:22 agenda: http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/PragueJan2013f2f#Thursday 08:04:24 Jirka has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:24 daveL has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:25 tadej has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:30 present+ tadej 08:04:33 leroy has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:33 Ankit has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:33 Marcis has joined #mlw-lt 08:04:35 present+ Jirka 08:04:37 present+ DaveLewis 08:04:41 present+ Marcis 08:04:41 present+ Ankit 08:04:42 present+ leroy 08:05:25 Yves_ has joined #mlw-lt 08:05:33 present+ Yves 08:05:44 mdelolmo has joined #mlw-lt 08:05:59 present+ mdelolmo 08:07:44 truedesheim has joined #mlw-lt 08:08:20 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-multilingualweb-lt-comments/2013Jan/0123.html 08:08:58 pnietoca has joined #mlw-lt 08:09:24 present+ pnietoca 08:10:55 kfritsche has joined #mlw-lt 08:11:05 present+ Karl 08:11:12 topic: issue-113 08:11:12 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-multilingualweb-lt-comments/2013Jan/0123.html 08:11:47 swalter has joined #mlw-lt 08:12:05 present+ swalter 08:12:59 action: arle to do copy-edtiing on the spec - due 1 april 08:12:59 Created ACTION-422 - do copy-edtiing on the spec [on Arle Lommel - due 2013-04-01]. 08:13:40 present+ truedesheim 08:17:36 action: felix to to edits for issue-113 08:17:36 Created ACTION-423 - To edits for issue-113 [on Felix Sasaki - due 2013-01-31]. 08:17:37 dF has joined #mlw-lt 08:27:35 "Information (e.g. "translate this") captured by ITS markup (e.g. its:translate='yes') always pertains to one or more XML or HTML nodes (primarily element and attribute nodes). " 08:28:00 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 08:28:05 scribe: fsasaki 08:38:01 I found another typo 08:38:32 on section 5.8 the paragraph before example 26 08:38:40 says: On any given node, the information provided by this mechanism is a space-separated list of the accumulated references found "it" the annotatorsRef attributes declared in the enclosing elements and sorted by data category identifiers. For each data category, the IRI part is the one of the inner-most "declarartion". 08:39:21 found "it" the annotatorsRef > it should be in 08:39:35 declarartion should be declaration 08:42:55 I just raised an issue for what you found: https://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/issues/114 08:55:43 Action: Arle to fix section 8.9 note: "since the extra training resources does not justify the improvement in the output." -> "since the extra training resources do not justify the improvement in the output." 08:55:44 Created ACTION-424 - Fix section 8.9 note: "since the extra training resources does not justify the improvement in the output." -> "since the extra training resources do not justify the improvement in the output." [on Arle Lommel - due 2013-01-31]. 08:58:02 https://github.com/finnle/ITS-2.0-Testsuite/blob/master/its2.0/inputdata/domain/html/domain1htmlrules.xml 09:00:12 action: ankit to change test suite for domain in HTML https://github.com/finnle/ITS-2.0-Testsuite/tree/master/its2.0/inputdata/domain/html , that is have "keywords" instead of "description" in the HTML and rules files 09:00:12 Created ACTION-425 - Change test suite for domain in HTML https://github.com/finnle/ITS-2.0-Testsuite/tree/master/its2.0/inputdata/domain/html , that is have "keywords" instead of "description" in the HTML and rules files [on Ankit Srivastava - due 2013-01-31]. 09:02:11 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-multilingualweb-lt-comments/2013Jan/0158.html 09:04:04 thanks Arle 09:08:52 topic: rome + xml prague prep 09:09:28 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-multilingualweb-lt/2013Jan/0000.html 09:12:23 Arle: I will be submitting new templates for the posters. They had been A1 size, but we are going for A0. Links will be sent out soon. 09:31:26 action: arle to create an indicator for poster relations 09:31:26 Created ACTION-426 - Create an indicator for poster relations [on Arle Lommel - due 2013-01-31]. 09:32:20 action: felix to nudge people for a first poster draft - 28 february 09:32:20 Created ACTION-427 - Nudge people for a first poster draft - 28 february [on Felix Sasaki - due 2013-01-31]. 10:00:30 Arle has joined #mlw-lt 10:00:45 topic: disambiguation and terminology again 10:03:39 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-multilingualweb-lt-comments/2013Jan/0163.html 10:03:45 scribe: fsasaki 10:05:04 scribe: dF 10:05:24 Tadej: showing slides 10:05:41 .. seems there is a way that would not compromise ITS 1.0 term 10:06:07 .. several different attributes, now with two categories 10:06:55 .. simultaneous annotations on multiple granularity levels are not possible 10:07:26 .. currecntly, fragment is in relationship with a URI 10:07:43 .. but term is flag 10:07:58 .. Scenario A 10:08:28 .. term remains flag, but becomes a new granularity within disambiguation. 10:08:35 Issues: 10:08:57 .. multiple annotations still not possible 10:09:25 Felix: clarification, this should be possible through concatenated values 10:09:48 Tadej: Ugly but doable as an excercise.. 10:10:08 Marcis: we discussed that 10:10:20 Tadej: did not seem a good idea 10:10:50 Another suggestion leading to B 10:11:17 .. granularitoes make sense indepenedently 10:11:26 .. terminology is just one level 10:11:49 .. having a set of attributes for every level 10:12:04 .. lots of new attributes 10:12:47 .. BUT everything can be done simultaneously and independently 10:13:23 .. multivalues seemed to require black magic to implement, gets ugly fast 10:13:39 .. decided to keep cardinality at 1 10:13:44 Scenario B 10:14:05 .. Keep terminology, drop granularity 10:14:37 .. encode the levels stright in attributes 10:15:17 Felix: clarification, separate data category identifier for each level? 10:15:39 Tadej: basically, yes, oterwise we would need subcategories 10:15:58 .. but the same pattern is always repeated, this should be good for adoption 10:16:58 .. it would be just a refactoring job 10:17:54 swalter: danger of semantic contradictions 10:18:33 chriLi_ has joined #mlw-lt 10:18:42 .. but it id not the formats issue to try and prevent this 10:19:27 Tadej: we were trying to avoid the host of the different attributes by introducing glanurity 10:19:50 Yves: is it a single data category, or four? 10:20:32 Tadej: technically they are different from the modelling point of view, but they have same pattern, so can be grouped 10:21:03 .. but they are independent in a sence and can go standalone.. 10:21:45 Felix: What about implementation commitments? Do we enforce implementing all four, if one committs for one? 10:22:12 tadej: all it seems, but it is not requesting too much as they really are the same mechanism 10:22:17 mdelolmo has joined #mlw-lt 10:22:40 (Off topic, but poster templates are here: https://dl.dropbox.com/u/223919/lt-web/RomeWorkshop/PosterTemplateA0.pptx [PowerPoint] and https://dl.dropbox.com/u/223919/lt-web/RomeWorkshop/PosterTemplateA0.pdf [PDF].) 10:22:44 .. they do not have different behaviors 10:23:07 scribe: fssaki 10:23:09 scribe: Felix 10:23:18 scribe: fssaki 10:23:47 Felix: are Christian's concerns addressed with this? 10:24:26 .. the starting point was wondering about the relationship between term and disambiguation 10:24:29 tadej: we would simply rename things, but not break the model of term 10:24:39 q+ 10:25:07 felix: how does scneario b relate to terminology? 10:25:30 tadej: terminolgoy already conforms to the pattern of scenario b, that is why we said we keep it as is 10:25:44 dave: we could not touch terminology at all 10:25:57 .. the use cases that we want could all be done in disambiguation 10:26:16 .. so we keep terminology but say that we can do everything now in disambiguation 10:26:38 tadej: if there is a know term, would you use termInfoRef or disambigXxxRef? 10:26:52 .. the relationships in disambiguation is in one pattern 10:27:00 .. and term already follows the pattern already 10:27:11 .. how to handle that in terms of data categories is a differetent aspect 10:27:31 ack chr 10:30:16 scribe: daveL 10:31:32 christian: core of my point related to different levels of attribute for different annotaiton, ontology, lexical etc 10:32:06 ... confirms that the proposal related to different data categories for these different levels 10:32:40 tadej: one exception to common pattern in entity class ref beign part of entity class 10:33:24 christian: to be satisfied, is what do we do with the current class of terminology 10:34:01 ... would suggest giving guidance by deprecating term through best practice advice 10:34:43 felix: why would we deprecate the term option 10:35:38 christian: meant depricating the current data term category 10:36:27 felix: thing to proposal is that term is already following the pattern the proposed pattern, so it wouldn't changed 10:39:43 tadej: suggested options are having term as a disambig option or as keep term as it is for this 10:41:19 dave: could have both and as christian suggests give guideance on which oen to adopt of how to transation from term to term in disambiugate 10:42:26 tadej: having both raises the issue that term could say 'yes' while disambig term option sa no, how should this be handled 10:43:01 stephan: could be addressed at a schematron validation level 10:44:17 felix: asks for input from implementors, but no strong perferences forthcoming 10:45:03 tadej: note that this approach results in lots of new attribute 10:45:50 ... also propose a catch all 'keyword' for things that don't fit into the defined categories 10:47:00 .. some fragement of text that is important for someone 10:47:54 christian: its good to consider support additional classes of analysis, but this isn't part of the comment to date 10:49:56 felix: summarise, we don't have examples, spec text and commitment to implement for this proposal 10:50:50 ... this requires some considerable effort before we are in a position to gt consensus 10:52:04 ... asks do the proposers have time to work on this to get it mature enough to even ask on consensus 10:52:17 Christian: allocating time for me is difficult 10:53:41 q+ 10:54:32 felix: as chair we really need to see this topic advance before we can ask concensus. It really needed by next week or two. 10:54:59 ... in order to hit a last call draft end february 10:56:17 Christian: does this proposal address the hiearchical NER issue raised by colleagues in India 10:56:51 tadej: this is orthogonal, so ti doesn't solve problem 10:57:41 stephan: can we agree on name, an acronym is really useful 10:59:13 felix: can people complete work in the time 11:01:57 yves: sceptical that this can be done in time given the amount of time and work involved in disambig to date 11:05:28 yves: suggest that we go forward with other comments related to dismabig anyway, so these are not held up by looking at this proposal 11:06:10 chriLi has joined #mlw-lt 11:07:20 dF: this would be a definite substantive change requiring a frther last call 11:07:47 felix: there are other that are borderline 11:08:32 rrsagent, generate minutes 11:08:32 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html daveL 11:15:33 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:15:59 present+ christian(11-12) 11:16:00 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:21:54 present+ felix 11:21:55 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:22:24 s/scribe: Felix// 11:22:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:22:56 s/scribe: fssaki// 11:22:57 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:23:37 s/scribe: fssaki// 11:23:39 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 11:27:39 issue-67: DECISION-DETAILS: substantive borderline change 11:27:39 Notes added to ISSUE-67 Change definition of regular expression for allowed characters. 11:28:13 issue-68: DECISION-DETAILS: under discussion 11:28:13 Notes added to ISSUE-68 Disambiguation (and term). 11:30:56 issue-71: DECISION-DETAILS: resolution to be clarified 11:30:56 Notes added to ISSUE-71 Section 5.8 (annotatorsRef). 11:31:42 issue-72: DECISION-DETAILS: follow-up needed 11:31:42 Notes added to ISSUE-72 Section 8.12 (Provenance Data Category). 11:31:57 issue-73: DECISION-DETAILS: follow-up needed 11:31:57 Notes added to ISSUE-73 NIF comments. 11:32:33 issue-73: DECISION-DETAILS: follow-up needed 11:32:33 Notes added to ISSUE-73 NIF comments. 11:32:46 issue-72: DECISION-DETAILS: clarification 11:32:46 Notes added to ISSUE-72 Section 8.12 (Provenance Data Category). 11:35:05 issue-102: DECISION-DETAILS: borderline substantive 11:35:05 Notes added to ISSUE-102 I18N-ISSUE-242: Clarify case-insensitive match for domains [ITS-20]. 11:37:40 issue-110: DECISION-DETAILS: borderline substantive 11:37:40 Notes added to ISSUE-110 change to langRule: precedence of xml:lang and lang. 11:51:39 Jirka has left #mlw-lt 12:06:24 Jirka has joined #mlw-lt 13:01:15 tadej has joined #mlw-lt 13:05:18 Ankit has joined #mlw-lt 13:05:38 mdelolmo has joined #mlw-lt 13:12:30 topic: action item and issue review 13:12:39 Arle has joined #mlw-lt 13:12:46 close action-36 13:12:46 Closed ACTION-36 Ongoing social media outreach of mlw. 13:13:02 action-215? 13:13:02 ACTION-215 -- David Filip to generate a sample of testing involving XLIFF -- due 2013-02-04 -- OPEN 13:13:02 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/actions/215 13:13:35 Milan has joined #mlw-lt 13:14:14 close action-309 13:14:14 Closed ACTION-309 pick up disambiguation granuliartiy best practices topic later. 13:14:25 covered by ongoing disambig+term discussion 13:16:45 close actoin-342 13:16:50 close action-342 13:16:50 Closed ACTION-342 create mt confidence score example as described in http://www.w3.org/2012/11/29-mlw-lt-irc#T14-50-33. 13:16:57 above not needed anymore 13:17:32 close action-352 13:17:32 Closed ACTION-352 Prepare status report on Task 5.1. 13:17:34 close action-353 13:17:34 Closed ACTION-353 Prepare status report on Task 5.2. 13:17:35 close action-354 13:17:35 Closed ACTION-354 provide input about wp1. 13:17:47 above done or tracked by felix 13:18:14 close action-374 13:18:14 Closed ACTION-374 Distribute action items to define these tests and to provide guideance of how to formulate these tests against rcf2119 table. 13:18:49 leroy has joined #mlw-lt 13:19:01 close action-376 13:19:01 Closed ACTION-376 Pull this material on best practice together onto wiki for people to comment on. 13:19:31 not needed for BP work now, covered with new tracker product https://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/products/9 13:23:20 close action-384 13:23:20 Closed ACTION-384 Make agenda proposal for Prague meeting about the XML prague day. 13:24:12 close action-386 13:24:12 Closed ACTION-386 Contact original commenter and see whether Yves additions to comment are what was meant there. 13:24:30 above done 13:24:34 close action-387 13:24:34 Closed ACTION-387 Contact original commenter about real need of timestamp. 13:24:38 above done 13:24:52 close action-388 13:24:52 Closed ACTION-388 Come back to chase and kevin about discussion of issue-71 http://www.w3.org/2013/01/23-mlw-lt-irc#T08-34-49. 13:24:54 above done 13:28:52 Zakim has left #mlw-lt 13:30:47 close action-402 13:30:47 Closed ACTION-402 Fix text and algo for domain case mapping. 13:30:58 above done, including test cases 13:31:12 close action-403 13:31:12 Closed ACTION-403 Check availability of Berlin on 17–18 June for face-to-face meeting.. 13:31:36 close action-406 13:31:37 Closed ACTION-406 Resize templates for posters from A1 to A0.. 13:32:48 close action-409 13:32:49 Closed ACTION-409 Follow up with Richard and Norbert on issue-92 and issue-103.. 13:35:40 topic: issue review 13:37:53 borderline "another last call cases": issue-63, issue-67 13:38:05 issue-71 13:38:05 ISSUE-71 -- Section 5.8 (annotatorsRef) -- open 13:38:05 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/issues/71 13:38:20 issue-102 13:38:20 ISSUE-102 -- I18N-ISSUE-242: Clarify case-insensitive match for domains [ITS-20] -- open 13:38:20 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/issues/102 13:38:22 issue-110 13:38:22 ISSUE-110 -- change to langRule: precedence of xml:lang and lang -- open 13:38:22 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/issues/110 13:38:40 and, in addition: 13:38:42 issue-68 13:38:42 ISSUE-68 -- Disambiguation (and term) -- open 13:38:42 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/issues/68 13:40:11 truedesheim has joined #mlw-lt 13:40:53 daveF: quite a number of borderline, so we might need another last call, let's check with the mgmt 13:43:30 felix: two unknowns: ruby and directionality related comments 13:44:17 daveF: even if we went to antother LC, I wouldn't change term and dissambiugation 13:46:43 felix: worried about implementation committments for terminology and dissambig 13:47:00 marcis: we have three for both terminology and disambiguation 13:47:42 daveF: clean solution would require 4 categories 13:47:53 marcis: and at the end it would be dropped 13:48:42 felix: I don't see consensus on how to move forward 13:51:24 .. let's see what the next weeks bring 14:03:09 topic: BP publications 14:03:28 discussing where to publish BP documents - TR space, via i18n WG, via ITS IG 14:05:03 topic: meeting schedule 14:05:07 f2f in bled and dublin confirmed 14:28:42 Send any presentations missing from http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/2012-annual-report/presentations.html to Arle 14:31:06 action: felix to come back to links to implemenations - due 28 Feburary 14:31:06 Created ACTION-428 - come back to links to implemenations [on Felix Sasaki - due 1970-01-01]. 15:03:59 topic: final event ideas 15:04:51 yves: would be difficiutl to gather same crowd we have in rome 6 months later in europe 15:05:16 .. there are events at the end of the year in the states, e.g. Uncode / locworld etc. wich we could target 15:05:47 .. so we could try to do something as a group 15:06:15 .. use that as a complement to the european outreach we will do in Rome 15:08:41 unicode conf. is 21-13 october 15:09:52 topic: best practices 15:10:14 https://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/products/9 15:10:55 daveL has joined #mlw-lt 15:11:03 present+ DaveLewis 15:11:03 https://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/track/products/8 15:11:22 xliff - ITS relation 15:11:35 disambiguation vs. term (depending on current discussion) 15:11:54 present+ leroy 15:12:03 present+ Milan 15:12:09 mapping to provenance - dave 15:12:31 xliff vs. ITS - dave, david, yves 15:13:12 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/XLIFF_Mapping 15:26:59 localization quality issue / rating related BP - arle, this summer, related to QTLaunchpad 15:28:27 how to use (populate & consume) mt-confidence and domain - ankit 15:30:35 above would include about m4loc 15:33:12 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/Use_cases_-_high_level_summary 15:35:37 how to use storage size - stefan 15:35:45 s/stefan/stephan/ 15:36:00 high level summary based on http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/Use_cases_-_high_level_summary - felix 15:37:01 http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/Deliverables 15:38:26 co-ordinate EU reports http://www.w3.org/International/multilingualweb/lt/wiki/Deliverables with BP documents 15:45:56 http://www.w3.org/2008/12/its-extensions 15:48:15 action: felix to check xliff ITS mapping namespace hosting in w3c 15:48:15 Created ACTION-429 - Check xliff ITS mapping namespace hosting in w3c [on Felix Sasaki - due 2013-01-31]. 15:51:41 use of term - stephan, tadej and marcis. Depends on how we proceed with term vs. disambiguation issue 15:52:54 topic: disambiguation again 15:53:05 tadej: need to clarify: do we need granularity at all? 15:53:24 .. if not, we don't need to merge disambiguation and terminonlogy 15:53:33 .. will ask that question on the list 15:56:53 truedesheim has left #mlw-lt 15:57:39 thanks to all for the meeting, adjourned! 15:57:42 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2013/01/24-mlw-lt-minutes.html fsasaki 15:59:25 Jirka has left #mlw-lt 16:35:47 dF has left #mlw-lt