16:23:15 RRSAgent has joined #css 16:23:15 logging to http://www.w3.org/2012/11/14-css-irc 16:23:20 Zakim, thiw ill be Style 16:23:20 I don't understand 'thiw ill be Style', glazou 16:23:27 Zakim, this will be Style 16:23:27 ok, glazou; I see Style_CSS FP()12:00PM scheduled to start in 37 minutes 16:23:32 RRSAgent, make logs public 16:54:34 dbaron has joined #css 16:54:36 SimonSapin has joined #css 16:56:16 I'm in another meeting, but I'll be here in IRC. 16:56:28 TabAtkins: noted 16:56:36 seems it's going to be low attendance anyway 16:56:40 many people sick 16:56:54 Zakim, code? 16:56:54 the conference code is 78953 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), glazou 16:57:05 Style_CSS FP()12:00PM has now started 16:57:13 +??P24 16:57:16 jdaggett has joined #css 16:57:18 Zakim, ??P24 is me 16:57:19 +glazou; got it 16:57:32 oyvind has joined #css 16:57:35 florian has joined #css 16:57:40 +plinss 16:58:01 plinss: cannot hear you 16:58:08 sylvaing_away has joined #css 16:58:18 +??P28 16:58:22 +[IPcaller] 16:58:27 emalasky has joined #css 16:58:29 zakim, ??p28 is me 16:58:31 +jdaggett; got it 16:58:41 Zakim, I am [IPcaller] 16:58:41 ok, florian, I now associate you with [IPcaller] 16:58:54 + +33.9.52.34.aaaa 16:59:00 arronei has joined #css 16:59:07 Zakim: I am aaaa 16:59:19 Zakim, aaaa is SimonSapin 16:59:19 +SimonSapin; got it 16:59:19 Zakim, I am aaaa 16:59:20 sorry, SimonSapin, I do not see a party named 'aaaa' 16:59:31 agenda: http://www.w3.org/mid/50A3AB1D.4090002@disruptive-innovations.com 16:59:53 +??P39 17:00:13 + +1.778.785.aabb 17:00:30 krit has joined #css 17:00:33 Zakim, ??P39 is leaverou 17:00:33 +leaverou; got it 17:00:42 + +1.415.832.aacc 17:00:43 +[Microsoft] 17:00:50 Zakim, [Microsoft] has me 17:00:50 +sylvaing_away; got it 17:00:54 zakim, aacc is me 17:00:54 +krit; got it 17:01:00 Zakim, Mozilla-YVR has dbaron 17:01:00 +dbaron; got it 17:01:07 +[Microsoft.a] 17:01:15 Zakim, who is on the phone? 17:01:15 On the phone I see glazou, plinss, jdaggett, [IPcaller], SimonSapin, leaverou, Mozilla-YVR, [Microsoft], krit, [Microsoft.a] 17:01:17 Mozilla-YVR has dbaron 17:01:17 [Microsoft] has sylvaing_away 17:01:39 + +1.619.846.aadd 17:02:23 Zakim, aadd is hober 17:02:23 +hober; got it 17:03:31 +SteveZ 17:03:41 rbetts has joined #css 17:03:48 + +1.604.312.aaee 17:04:07 Zakim, aaee is me. 17:04:07 +rbetts; got it 17:04:16 +??P54 17:04:48 -??P54 17:05:02 SteveZ has joined #css 17:05:53 +??P65 17:05:59 Zakim, who is on the phone ? 17:05:59 On the phone I see glazou, plinss, jdaggett, [IPcaller], SimonSapin, leaverou, Mozilla-YVR, [Microsoft], krit, [Microsoft.a], hober, SteveZ, rbetts, ??P65 17:06:03 Mozilla-YVR has dbaron 17:06:03 [Microsoft] has sylvaing_away 17:06:15 +Bert 17:06:15 -??P65 17:06:22 has the call been very quiet the last 2 minutes, or have I stopped hearing any sound? 17:06:31 I'm talking dbaron 17:06:40 Scribe: Bert 17:06:54 Topic: Agenda 17:07:12 +Mozilla-YVR.a 17:07:32 +??P70 17:07:38 Zakim, [Mozilla-YVR.a] has dbaron 17:07:38 sorry, dbaron, I do not recognize a party named '[Mozilla-YVR.a]' 17:07:41 Dirk: new props in compositing affect Backgrounds and borders 17:07:43 +[IPcaller.a] 17:07:45 Zakim, Mozilla-YVR.a has dbaron 17:07:45 +dbaron; got it 17:07:51 Zakim, IPcaller.a is me 17:07:51 +fantasai; got it 17:07:52 ... Can we move them, or should they stay in Compositing? 17:07:53 +Stearns 17:07:56 -??P70 17:07:57 Rossen has joined #css 17:08:17 Simon: Me as editor for page? 17:08:49 dbaron: another thread about viewport units and @page rules 17:09:04 Topic: ftf 17:09:15 glazou: I tried to ping molly. 17:09:22 ... No response, so I'm concerned. 17:09:35 ... Should we have a backup venue? 17:09:43 -Stearns 17:09:49 ... She posted something on wikie, but it was siubject to sponsoring. 17:09:49 +[Microsoft.aa] 17:09:57 ... So no firm date and location. 17:10:00 s/wikie/wiki 17:10:08 Zakim, [Microsoft.aa] is me 17:10:08 +Rossen; got it 17:10:22 +Stearns 17:10:26 johnd: In bay area, than multiple companies can sponsor. 17:10:57 -Stearns 17:10:58 florian: We considered japan ftf in winter earlier, but concern about AC in japan. 17:11:04 +1 for keeping japan in june 17:11:09 sylvaing: May be difficult for some 17:11:28 johnd: Jan/feb would be trickier for me [to sponsor in japan] 17:11:38 ... prefer spring, but maybe cane work on soemthing. 17:11:51 -fantasai 17:11:54 glazou: So let's look for spare location Bay Area in Feb. 17:12:03 +[IPcaller.a] 17:12:07 Zakim, IPcaller.a is me 17:12:07 +fantasai; got it 17:12:15 Topic: lea as co-editor for backgrounds & borders 17:12:40 +??P82 17:12:42 fantasai: lea had some interest, filed issues. 17:12:52 ... I thought why not have her co-edit with me. 17:13:01 -Mozilla-YVR 17:13:06 ... Good way to get a bit momentum, even if slow. 17:13:13 ... It remains a low-prio module. 17:13:20 ... And I can help Lea along. 17:13:40 glazou: You mentioned ytou need ack from Doug? 17:13:47 lea: Doug agrees. 17:14:00 RESOLVED: Lea co-editor for Backgrounds 4 17:14:16 Zakim: +??P82 is me 17:14:20 Topic; Simon co-editor for Paged Meda 17:14:42 Zakim, +??P82 is me 17:14:44 sorry, darktears, I do not recognize a party named '+??P82' 17:14:45 Simon: progress is slow. I'm discussion with [...] 17:14:51 glazou: Objections? 17:14:52 +Stearns 17:15:03 SimonSapin1 has joined #css 17:15:06 florian: What was prio for this module? No objection in principle. 17:15:31 fantasai: High prio for some, but not for browsers. 17:15:32 Zakim, ??P82 is me 17:15:32 +darktears; got it 17:15:40 ... Important to make progress. 17:16:09 SteveZ: Counter-example: anything with layout seems important. 17:16:17 ... It's part of the center of CSS. 17:16:25 fantasai: But doens't interact with other modules. 17:16:32 s/modules/layout models/ 17:16:34 SteveZ: But it should. Why not? 17:16:58 florian: In any case we need to make progress on it. 17:17:12 glazou: Is css3-page discussed at IDPF? 17:17:24 fantasai: Not much, they're using something else. 17:17:37 glazou: I guess it's important becaus eof e-books. 17:17:56 glazou: Objections to Simon as co-editor? 17:18:01 Bert: On the contrary! 17:18:16 dbaron: Browsers maybe not workng on it, but may do so in the future. 17:18:29 ... May start to interact later, is a danger. 17:18:40 .. We've had that problem in the past. 17:18:54 glazou: What does that mean? It should slow down? 17:19:19 dbaron: Not necessarily. Don't assume it won't need any changes in the future once browsers start needing it. 17:19:20 jet has joined #CSS 17:19:31 glazou: That doesn't seem acceptable. 17:19:57 dbaron: There is a difference between listen and comment and implements; and then actually find problems. 17:20:08 ... We've had this in the past. 17:20:35 florian: You say that going to pR with only implementations other than browsers is prpoblematic? 17:21:14 Present+ glenn (IRC only) 17:21:28 SteveZ: So dbaron says: if implemented in a product that does't have the whole stack of techs of a browser, it may not be compatible wioth that stack. 17:21:38 dbaron: And we have a set of priorities. 17:21:47 .. We can't comment on everything. 17:21:56 ... There is too much too comment on. 17:22:14 glazou: We discussed at ftf. We have 60 docs, too much. 17:22:30 ... Chairs are not dictators. 17:22:44 ... We cannot say trash everything beyond the first 15. 17:23:07 sylvaing: I don't disagree that it is difficult. But we should have that discussion before the poll. 17:23:27 SteveZ: One way out is to suggest that we set comment deadlines on things. 17:23:37 ... Low prio items have deadline further in future. 17:23:44 jdaggett: :) 17:23:48 ... People like to continue working on things. 17:24:03 ... dbaron says there are too many things to comment on. Agree. 17:24:23 ... But you have to keep working. No comments doesn't mean there aren't any. 17:24:47 i think the conclusion here is that css3-page needs group discussion 17:24:50 glazou: We never move docuemtns to next state without aking the members first. 17:25:00 i'm not sure more discussion is needed on this right now 17:25:18 ... We have all the sensors to avoid implementations by non-browsrs only and to avoid browser pbs in the futre. 17:25:50 florian: Even if we don't work on a modules, people may come up with something and that may be worse. Lesser evil to work on it. 17:25:52 wrap... up... discussion... 17:26:14 glazou: Important discussion, but let's do that later, maybe an hour. 17:26:14 mollyholzschlag has joined #css 17:26:24 .. so back to Simon as co-editor. 17:26:36 RESOLVED: Simon is co-editor for css3-page. 17:27:04 Topic: font issues 17:27:16 johnd: I made a few changes. 17:27:21 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Nov/0112.html 17:27:28 ... First is 'font-stretch' 17:27:40 ... I put the keyowrds in the font shorthand. 17:28:07 Zakim, code? 17:28:07 the conference code is 78953 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), glazou 17:28:10 ... Parsing font family names makes this tricky. 17:28:20 .. Font size thus always has to be there. 17:28:47 ... Other keywords don't conflict. 17:28:59 looks good to me 17:29:09 ... Is that Reasonable? 17:29:16 simon: I see no ambiguities. 17:29:22 glazou: Me neither. 17:29:38 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Nov/0114.html 17:29:39 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Nov/0114.html 17:29:39 RESOLVED: Add stretch keywords to font shorthand 17:30:21 johnd: In prev WD I made it so that a font-family name existing on a system gathers all faces in the family. 17:30:31 ... then you choose a specific face. 17:30:45 ... All these params choose a specifi face. 17:31:00 ... Prev WD said look for each character. 17:31:11 ... There are some subtle pbs with some faces. 17:31:19 +Molly_Holzschlag 17:31:20 ... Some lack support for a char. 17:31:33 ... So I changed to match the face first and then check for the char. 17:31:56 drublic has joined #css 17:31:57 ... When you download, you don't know what's in the faces until you download them all. 17:32:04 ... So this avoids downloading them all. 17:32:26 ... Some font faces have e.g., arabic in normal, but not in italic face. 17:32:32 ... Not common, but does occur. 17:32:42 ... In that case you should fallback to regular face. 17:32:54 ... I'd rather introduce exception like that than to have general rules. 17:33:13 Bert: What exceptions? 17:33:22 +SteveZ.a 17:33:24 -SteveZ 17:33:31 johnd: E.g., older Arial has arabic only in regular and not in italic. 17:33:48 ... Browsers would automatically use the regular and synthesize the italic. 17:34:05 ... They're exceptional cases and I'd like the spec to leave wiggle room for that. 17:34:34 i guess jdagget means "synthesize oblique (and pretend its italic)" 17:34:36 fantasai: Seems fine, but if UA is capable, what is the *better* behavior? 17:34:42 ... Allow both behaviors? 17:34:59 fantasai: You said practicval considerations. 17:35:04 s/jdagget means/jdaggett means/ 17:35:17 ... Can UAs deal with them in different ways, take the cost? 17:35:35 johnd: There are all these itneractions. E.g., witjh downlodable fonts. 17:35:50 ... Doing style matching for soem cases and not for others. 17:36:00 http://reference.sitepoint.com/css/propertyref 17:36:09 ... You may end up with wildly diofferent style, if that is the font that has the glyph. 17:36:18 ... Particularly on Windows. 17:36:32 ... Windows has ways to fold different fonts into a family. 17:36:39 ... Would rather stay away fom it. 17:37:10 ... Previous WD was just something I introduced. 17:37:25 ... I dont' think it is better. Solves some cases. 17:37:28 sylvaing_away: only surface splittable cover keyboard ? 17:37:39 ... Rather leave UAs some wiggle room than have a general rule. 17:37:47 sylvaing: What's the impact on [?] 17:37:57 s/[?]/existing content 17:37:58 johnd: None. 17:37:58 s/[?]/existing wefonts 17:38:27 ... When I thought through what the previous rule meant for downlodable fonts I thought: no. 17:39:47 RESOLVED: Wrt issue above: use the Editor's draft version. 17:39:55 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Sep/0507.html 17:40:01 Johnd: Next is syntax issue. 17:40:03 and http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Oct/0279.html 17:40:11 arno has joined #css 17:40:20 ... @font-feature-values rule 17:40:36 ... For features only in a certain font. 17:41:11 ... What you need is min-variable syntax, associate name with a selector value, only for a given font family. 17:41:20 s/min-/mini-/ 17:41:22 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Oct/0279.html 17:41:36 glazou: I agree with dbaron to prefer to @ sign. 17:41:47 johnd: Some concerns with that. 17:42:27 glazou said that he prefers Variation B, but with the @ sign 17:42:28 ... With @-signs (variation A in the message) doesn't look like property name. 17:42:37 .. I prefer that. 17:42:45 we have property-like descriptors in @font-face and @counter-style 17:42:49 doesn't like @ syntax 17:42:53 ... Because it *doesn't* look like something that already exists. 17:43:00 @keyframes already has "from" and "to" 17:43:23 etc 17:43:26 fantasai: Other thing is that the values cascade. 17:43:36 doesn't think it necessary to make it look different 17:43:37 ... That is not clear in the A syntax. 17:43:48 ... In the B syntax tht is clear. 17:44:10 johnd: It is not a cascade, just some override. 17:44:42 fantasai: In first syntax, in some cases an @rule sobliterates an earlioer rule. 17:44:54 ... In 2nd syntax it behaves very much like selectors. 17:45:03 ... No specificity, but otherwise the same. 17:45:23 glazou: We have font descriptors, they are not properties either. 17:45:37 johnd: in @font-face, yes. 17:45:58 fantasai: No pref either way. 17:46:07 every new sub-syntax requires additional cognitive load for users, negatives of which outweigh reuse of existing syntax 17:46:16 dbaron: No strong pref for A or B, but if B, then with @-sign. 17:46:30 johnd: So we go with B with @-sign? 17:46:34 no strong preference 17:46:42 strong pref against @ syntax 17:46:45 ... I'd like A, but don't care that strongly. 17:46:59 glazou: readability, coherence with rest of CSS. 17:47:15 ... Seems we have stronger pref for B overall. 17:47:30 RESOLVED: syntax B with an @-sign. 17:47:47 Topic: ftf (cont'd) 17:47:53 -fantasai 17:47:56 can't we separate adopting 2nd syntax and using @-sign? 17:48:00 molly: You can follow progress on the wiki. 17:48:05 http://wiki.csswg.org/planning/tucson-2013 17:48:40 ... We had incredible support from city and from university of Tucson. 17:48:46 jdaggett: suggest you make CSSFontFaceRule in ED a 'partial' interface 17:48:49 ... We've been offered a couple of locations. 17:49:10 ... We have the univ and the city fighting over who hosts us! 17:49:32 ... Constraints in Feb on dates. 17:49:32 is 1 day later possible? 17:49:39 ... Gem show, rodeo, etc. 17:49:43 -SimonSapin 17:49:46 because of fosdem 17:50:13 ... Challenge is finding the best political way between univ and city. 17:50:23 +SimonSapin 17:50:28 ... Biosphere 2 is just outside Tucson. 17:50:43 ... We have been offered it as a location, with private tour. 17:51:03 ... Including apartments with kitchens. 17:51:12 ... Beuatiful out there. 17:51:27 ... We could do a hybrid: 1st day at Univ on sight. 17:51:38 .. Mayor wants to provide a welcome and a banquet. 17:51:56 ... So which to choose. In town, we woul dneed multiple hotels. 17:52:07 ... Not very difficult, everything is aroudn the university. 17:52:13 i think the question is whether a sponsor is needed or not 17:52:15 ... Facilities are good 17:52:22 i.e. a sponsor for the venue 17:52:34 This sounds like we're going to end up spending a bunch of time listening to speeches in exchange for this sponsorship. 17:52:37 glazou: Dates: some people asked for a day later. 17:52:44 +[IPcaller.a] 17:52:58 ... So start on Tuesday. 17:53:11 molly: that would be fine. 17:53:22 florian: I can't, anyway. 17:53:45 what about the money... ? 17:54:04 Ted: as a 15-year old, [...] 17:54:15 Molly: Tuscon reaaly wants to be a good host for us. 17:54:33 ... Biospehere would be a differen model, but it is the Biospehre. 17:54:46 ... Can also do a day in town and take a shuttle the next day. 17:54:49 s/as a 15-year old/speaking not for Apple but for my inner 15-year-old/ 17:55:21 ... Money: you have to pay for you own travel and hotel nights. 17:55:29 ... But the facilities are donated. 17:55:50 ... I also want community involved. I'm looking for banquet sponsor, e.g. 17:56:02 ... we have funds coming in, form city, from local groups. 17:56:16 ... There has to be a formal photo op, etc. 17:56:37 glazou: We can thank the city like we did in Lyon: 17:56:43 ... We organize a Meet-up. 17:56:52 Molly: excelletn, I nknow where to do that. 17:57:15 lol 17:57:17 glazou: We present our work, my BluGriffon, Mozilla firefox, etc, 17:57:58 SteveZ: Biosphere: I need to be back on Friday. If we're too far out of town, catcjhing a flight on Thu may be difficult. 17:58:11 Molly: tehre are shuttles. May have to leave an hour earlier. 17:58:27 Biosphere looks like it's a 1 hour drive from the Tucson airport and a 2 hour drive from the Phoenix airport -- Phoenix may be a good option given the connections from it 17:58:32 SteveZ: Early leaving is OK, as long as I can do it. 17:58:52 molly: We need somebody to get you there. There is ample time, no stress. Not like CDG airport... 17:58:58 eheh 17:59:07 jdaggett: ROFL 17:59:15 ... Woulkd be helpful if people could put their needs, concerns on wiki. 17:59:24 ... Then I can respond. 17:59:33 jdaggett: in fact it means toothpaste is still forbidden but weapons are allowed :-) 17:59:48 .... Some kind of outreach event, as glazou suggested, would indeed be fabulous. 17:59:53 naturally... 17:59:59 in AZ the metal detector rings if you're not carrying a gun 18:00:02 ... My brother is excited. Other people, too. 18:00:31 ... We can also do everything on Univ campus and just go visit the Biosphere. 18:00:34 +1 for biosphere 18:00:48 ... But being there is awesome. 18:01:00 glazou: So one day in town and rest in Biospehereis possible? 18:01:06 molly: yes. 18:01:28 SteveZ: Meet-up might have to be *before* the CSS mneeting then. 18:01:56 molly: Another optionis two days at Bio and 3rd day in town. 18:02:16 glazou: People from aborad probabaly have to stay overnight anyway. 18:02:40 molly: We just need to figure out the days we're in town. 18:02:58 glazou: Can you deal with this input so far and report back asap? 18:03:08 florian: Maybe a doodle for the dates? 18:03:16 glazou: I think molly need firm dates. 18:03:47 molly: Please, use the wiki. It's easiest for me. Put your dates there, too. 18:03:54 ... any special needs. 18:04:19 glazou: So, if possible, try 5-7, if not possible keep 4-6. 18:04:22 -SteveZ.a 18:04:27 SimonSapin1 has joined #css 18:04:30 -Mozilla-YVR.a 18:04:31 -jdaggett 18:04:31 -[Microsoft.a] 18:04:32 -[Microsoft] 18:04:32 -krit 18:04:34 -[IPcaller] 18:04:34 -Molly_Holzschlag 18:04:36 -glazou 18:04:36 -rbetts 18:04:37 -leaverou 18:04:37 -hober 18:04:38 -Bert 18:04:38 -Stearns 18:04:39 -Rossen 18:04:39 -SimonSapin 18:04:41 -[IPcaller.a] 18:04:42 -plinss 18:05:06 I only hope they're not going to keep us in biosphere2 for months :-D 18:05:16 -darktears 18:05:17 Style_CSS FP()12:00PM has ended 18:05:17 Attendees were glazou, plinss, [IPcaller], jdaggett, +33.9.52.34.aaaa, SimonSapin, +1.778.785.aabb, leaverou, +1.415.832.aacc, sylvaing_away, krit, dbaron, [Microsoft], 18:05:17 ... +1.619.846.aadd, hober, SteveZ, +1.604.312.aaee, rbetts, Bert, Mozilla-YVR, fantasai, Stearns, Rossen, darktears, Molly_Holzschlag 18:07:12 krit1 has joined #css 18:10:28 alexmog_away has joined #css 18:10:32 florian has left #css 18:10:51 Ms2ger has joined #css 18:11:13 leaverou has joined #css 18:11:30 plinss has joined #css 18:12:08 mollyholzschlag has left #css 18:12:14 shans_away has joined #css 18:12:44 sylvaingz has joined #css 18:16:37 SimonSapin has joined #css 18:27:32 cabanier has joined #css 19:15:06 fantasai has left #css 19:16:39 fantasai has joined #css 19:20:06 SimonSapin has joined #css 19:40:22 sylvaing_away has joined #css 20:04:20 Zakim has left #css 20:06:52 Ms2ger has joined #css 20:29:17 SimonSapin has joined #css 21:14:34 krit has joined #css 21:20:56 antonp has joined #css 21:23:56 emalasky has left #css 21:38:18 qwe has joined #css 22:24:24 jarek_ has joined #css 23:12:50 glenn has joined #css 23:21:55 arno has joined #css 23:40:24 jet_ has joined #CSS 23:57:28 arronei has joined #css