14:55:46 RRSAgent has joined #rdf-wg 14:55:46 logging to http://www.w3.org/2012/10/10-rdf-wg-irc 14:55:48 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:55:48 Zakim has joined #rdf-wg 14:55:50 Zakim, this will be 73394 14:55:50 ok, trackbot; I see SW_RDFWG()11:00AM scheduled to start in 5 minutes 14:55:51 Meeting: RDF Working Group Teleconference 14:55:51 Date: 10 October 2012 14:58:34 zakim, this is 73394 14:58:34 ok, AndyS; that matches SW_RDFWG()11:00AM 14:58:44 zakim, who is on the phone? 14:58:44 On the phone I see [IPcaller], [IPcaller.a] 14:58:55 zakim, IPCaller.a is me 14:58:55 +AndyS; got it 14:59:01 (probably) 14:59:06 zakim, IPcaller is me 14:59:06 +tbaker; got it 14:59:17 +gavinc 14:59:20 + +31.20.598.aaaa 14:59:37 zakim, +31.20 is me 14:59:37 +Guus; got it 14:59:45 +Sandro 15:00:20 zakim, who is here? 15:00:20 On the phone I see tbaker, AndyS, gavinc, Guus, Sandro 15:00:21 On IRC I see RRSAgent, AndyS, gkellogg, ivan, MacTed, tbaker, Guus, SteveH, mischat, gavinc, Arnaud, davidwood, manu1, manu, yvesr, trackbot, ericP, sandro 15:00:21 +??P4 15:00:24 pchampin has joined #rdf-wg 15:00:26 cgreer has joined #rdf-wg 15:00:29 Zakim, ??P4 is me 15:00:29 +yvesr; got it 15:00:41 +??P6 15:01:26 AZ has joined #rdf-wg 15:01:37 zakim, code? 15:01:45 +cgreer 15:01:50 the conference code is 73394 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), ivan 15:02:10 +OpenLink_Software 15:02:16 Zakim, OpenLink_Software is temporarily me 15:02:17 Zakim, mute me 15:02:33 +MacTed; got it 15:02:34 MacTed should now be muted 15:02:50 +ivan 15:02:50 AlexHall has joined #rdf-wg 15:02:54 +??P15 15:03:07 Zakim, ??P15 is me 15:03:07 +AZ; got it 15:03:12 pfps has joined #rdf-wg 15:03:22 Souri has joined #rdf-wg 15:03:29 +pfps 15:03:50 +Arnaud 15:04:01 Zakim, who is here please? 15:04:01 On the phone I see tbaker, AndyS, gavinc, Guus, Sandro, yvesr, pchampin, cgreer, MacTed (muted), ivan, AZ, pfps, Arnaud 15:04:04 + +1.443.212.aabb 15:04:06 On IRC I see Souri, pfps, AlexHall, AZ, cgreer, pchampin, Zakim, RRSAgent, AndyS, gkellogg, ivan, MacTed, tbaker, Guus, SteveH, mischat, gavinc, Arnaud, davidwood, manu1, manu, 15:04:08 ... yvesr, trackbot, ericP, sandro 15:04:25 + +1.603.897.aacc 15:04:35 zakim, aacc is me 15:04:36 +Souri; got it 15:04:48 I can scribe 15:05:00 chair: Guus 15:05:02 scribenick: AndyS 15:05:38 agenda - http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/wiki/Meetings:Telecon2012.10.10 15:05:57 topic: admin 15:06:16 +??P32 15:06:20 +EricP 15:06:24 minutes of last meeting -- http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/meeting/2012-10-03 15:06:24 zakim, I am ??P32 15:06:24 +gkellogg; got it 15:06:30 minutes look ok 15:06:35 guus: accepted 15:06:58 RESOLVED to accept the minutes of 2012-10-03 (http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/meeting/2012-10-03) 15:07:14 subtopic: action items 15:08:08 no telecon 31 Oct (same week as face-to-face) 15:08:18 topic: Turtle Last Call 15:08:34 next meeting next week : 17 Oct 15:08:58 http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/wiki/I18n-Comments 15:09:01 http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/wiki/I18n-Comments 15:09:03 Guus: issue numbers are in I18N tracker. 15:09:42 zwu2 has joined #rdf-wg 15:10:07 (the proposals are linked to by Nack/ack) 15:10:20 + +1.650.265.aadd 15:10:34 zakim, +1.650.265.aadd is me 15:10:34 +zwu2; got it 15:10:48 zakim, mute me 15:10:48 ivan should now be muted 15:10:55 ericP: 178 -- BCP 47 reference 15:11:24 PROPOSAL: wedge in a not-too-contrived ref in section 7 Parsing: "and an optional language tag [BCP47] or datatype IRI" per editor's draft. 15:11:34 +1 already completed in ED 15:11:54 +PatH 15:11:55 Guus: any discussion? no ... 15:12:04 go for it 15:12:06 issue-178? 15:12:06 ISSUE-178 does not exist 15:12:18 ... resolved 15:12:19 I18N-ISSUE-178? 15:12:35 RESOLVED: wedge in a not-too-contrived ref in section 7 Parsing: "and an optional language tag [BCP47] or datatype IRI" per editor's draft. 15:12:52 Guus: 179 ... 15:13:04 patH has joined #rdf-wg 15:13:13 gavinc: scope of language e.g. common langauge for all doc. 15:13:20 PROPOSAL: Turtle will not add a method to declare the language of the document. 15:13:22 ... proposal - not to add 15:13:24 good idea to not do it 15:13:56 RESOLVED: Turtle will not add a method to declare the language of the document. 15:14:09 http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/rdf/raw-file/default/rdf-turtle/index.html#turtle-literals 15:14:15 zakim, mute me 15:14:15 PatH should now be muted 15:14:17 guus: next ... 180 ... 15:14:46 PROPOSAL: add this markup [[ (#005E)"]] to the first reference to each character per the editor's draft . 15:15:06 obnoxious, but probably a good idea 15:15:46 RESOLVED: add this markup [[ (#005E)"]] to the first reference to each character per the editor's draft . 15:15:58 good+obnoxious = medicinal? 15:16:05 guus: ... 181 ... 15:16:20 http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/rdf/raw-file/default/rdf-turtle/index.html#turtle-literals 15:16:26 sounds reasonable 15:17:01 PROPOSAL: add example of non-ASCII IRI 15:17:09 +1 15:17:16 RESOLVED: add example of non-ASCII IRI 15:17:32 guus: ... 182 ... 15:18:09 ericP: need a sublanguage example. Don't see how it can be better. 15:18:20 well for the record, we had this TV show in France :) 15:18:28 q+ 15:18:30 ok by me 15:18:32 agree this is a good example. 15:19:23 ??: could use colour/color in @en 15:19:37 s/??/pchampin/ 15:19:47 ack pchampin 15:19:54 PROPOSAL: 182 -- No change 15:20:03 RESOLVED: 182 -- No change 15:20:14 http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/rdf/raw-file/default/rdf-turtle/index.html#abbrev 15:21:02 ericP: 183 -- work in progress 15:21:18 my:productInStock :hasQuantity 10 15:21:26 you could always cheat and have the property be something like usdebtindollars 15:22:25 gavinc: good relations as a source of examples? Need xsd:double as well. 15:22:30 Avagadro's Number? 15:22:34 engineering data uses doubles somewhere? 15:23:03 Check out ISO definition of a mole. 15:23:27 Aaaarghhhh 15:23:35 I will attempt it. 15:23:51 along the same lines, one could use dimensionless constants 15:24:04 gavinc: 183 still open at the moment 15:24:09 guus: need a plan 15:24:29 ericP: ping with nack unless you (i18n) have an example 15:24:37 fine, as long as we close the issue pending further input 15:24:52 +1 to pfps 15:25:24 PROPOSED: i18n-183 -- EricP to respond with "no change unless you have further input" 15:25:37 RESOLVED: i18n-183 -- EricP to respond with "no change unless you have further input" 15:25:46 guus: ... 184 ... 15:25:51 http://www.w3.org/mid/20121002044103.GD27799@w3.org 15:26:14 +1 15:26:33 +1 15:26:39 RESOLVED: i18n-184 -- Use the text U+xx form [[ U+B7, U+300 to U+36F and U+203F to U+2040 are permitted anywhere except the first character. ]] per the editor's draft 15:27:03 ACTION EricP Respond to i18n for issue 183 15:27:03 Created ACTION-188 - Respond to i18n for issue 183 [on Eric Prud'hommeaux - due 2012-10-17]. 15:27:42 ericP: line terminators 185 15:27:45 PROPOSAL: Alter the text introducing the 4th example in §3 to say " The line breaks in this example are LINE FEED characters (U+0A)." per editor's draft 15:27:47 picky, but works for me 15:28:03 RESOLVED: Alter the text introducing the 4th example in §3 to say " The line breaks in this example are LINE FEED characters (U+0A)." per editor's draft 15:28:29 PROPOSAL: Turtle will continue to use \u \U escape syntax. 15:28:32 gavinc: 187 -- \u escape 15:28:35 agreed, we are not going to fix this issue 15:28:40 +1 15:28:58 RESOLVED: Turtle will continue to use \u \U escape syntax. 15:29:07 well, we are following the crowd, which may not be going in the "right" direction 15:29:50 ericP: 188 - special handling of % in IRI 15:30:19 ... what we have is correct - discussion has happened already. 15:30:28 damn, ISSUE-186 is for us 15:31:01 http://www.w3.org/2011/rdf-wg/wiki/I18n-Comments#189:_.5BS.5D_reference_obs-language-tag_instead_of_defining_your_own 15:31:08 RESOLVED: i18n-188 no change -- special handling of % in IRI 15:31:51 ericP: ... 189 ... advice from BCP 47 for language tags 15:32:07 ... ABNF is quite complicated and much more than RFC. 15:32:43 ... historical was 8 char/numbers per section between the "-" 15:33:24 PROPOSAL: Use {1,8} in lang tag production and {..} for \u \U escapes 15:33:51 (variation to SPARQL) Minor 15:33:51 +q to say nothing is wrong 15:34:48 gavinc: adding {1,8} does not make full checking happen so nothing changes really. 15:35:08 ... already have to do further checking so little value in adding to Turtle 15:35:15 could pont that out in the prose, though. 15:35:18 ... no need to complicate the grammar 15:35:26 (c.f. RD/XML) 15:35:27 since apparently they missed it. 15:35:29 (c.f. RDF/XML) 15:35:41 Zakim, who is talking 15:35:41 I don't understand 'who is talking', gavinc 15:35:43 Zakim, who is talking? 15:35:45 ack gavinc 15:35:45 gavinc, you wanted to say nothing is wrong 15:35:53 gavinc, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Guus (14%) 15:36:45 guus: one more week to agree and on agenda next week 15:36:54 sandro: what moves this on? 15:37:04 ericP: ericP and gavinc to email on list 15:37:14 guus: editors to agree 15:37:23 ... i18n 190 15:37:37 ... " attempting to erase combining marks?" 15:38:56 PROPOSAL: i18n-190 -- No change - follow XML ed 5 15:39:27 RESOLVED: i18n-190 -- No change - follow XML ed 5 15:39:35 guus: ... 191 ... 15:39:52 ericP: editorial matters 15:40:16 ... one change proposed otherwise already covered 15:40:55 RESOLVED: i18n-191 as per http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-wg/2012Oct/0017.html 15:41:29 https://github.com/darobin/respec/blob/f7f242642de460e73dcbbb509efb582925b4c6ac/bibref/biblio.js 15:41:30 guus: ... 192 ... 15:41:53 Issue a pull request against robin's Git repo 15:42:05 gavinc: will do it (ReSpec and reference issue) 15:42:27 RESOLVED: i18n-192 Update ReSpec for doc. 15:42:57 ACTION Gavin to finish i18n-192 15:42:57 Created ACTION-189 - Finish i18n-192 [on Gavin Carothers - due 2012-10-17]. 15:42:58 action: gavinc - send an ack to the comments list an di18n for 192 15:42:58 Sorry, couldn't find gavinc. You can review and register nicknames at . 15:43:24 "anack" (noun): a state of total confusion about what to do next. 15:43:59 ericP: 193 - no change 15:44:11 ... good to have someone double check. 15:44:25 ... the escape processing text 15:44:40 gavinc: 3rd party confirms it works 15:44:55 RESOLVED: 18n-193 - no change 15:45:05 guus: ... missed 186 ... 15:45:26 zakim, unmute me 15:45:26 ivan should no longer be muted 15:45:29 gavinc: i18n suggests not just UTF-8 15:45:38 ... XML is not a good example. 15:45:52 http://www.w3.org/International/track/issues/186 15:45:58 ericP: agree - no change 15:46:27 PROPOSED: i18n-186 : keep Turtle as UTF-8 15:47:18 q+ 15:47:52 andys: a perma-issue on support lists 15:48:11 ivan: deployed practice is UTF-8 15:48:23 RESOLVED: i18n-186 : keep Turtle as UTF-8 15:49:12 action: gavin -- respond for i18n 187 15:49:13 Created ACTION-190 - -- respond for i18n 187 [on Gavin Carothers - due 2012-10-17]. 15:49:40 ACTION-190: respond for i18n 186 15:49:40 ACTION-190 -- respond for i18n 187 notes added 15:50:07 guus: other comments 15:51:02 gavinc: already done .. no response 15:51:15 ... rest minor editorial 15:51:48 ... except TTL+HTML section to separate Note 15:52:16 q+ 15:53:38 q+ 15:54:07 guus: prefer appendix 15:54:23 sandro: use of script tag? 15:54:24 q- 15:54:55 gavinc: problem is Turtle with an end script tag in content. 15:54:56 Or CDATA? 15:55:14 :-P 15:55:52 sandro: useful to put into the spec as good practice 15:56:27 manu: JSON-LD does not talk about this - not TTL specific - generic for embedding in