16:58:48 RRSAgent has joined #indie-ui 16:58:48 logging to http://www.w3.org/2012/10/03-indie-ui-irc 16:58:50 RRSAgent, make logs 175 16:58:50 Zakim has joined #indie-ui 16:58:52 Zakim, this will be INDIE 16:58:52 ok, trackbot; I see WAI_Indie()1:00PM scheduled to start in 2 minutes 16:58:53 Meeting: Independent User Interface Task Force Teleconference 16:58:53 Date: 03 October 2012 16:59:11 WAI_Indie()1:00PM has now started 16:59:18 +??P0 16:59:26 zakim, code? 16:59:26 the conference code is 46343 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), shepazu 16:59:57 zakim, ??P0 is Janina_Sajka 16:59:57 +Janina_Sajka; got it 16:59:59 +[Google] 17:00:05 Meeting: IndieUI Task Force telecon 17:00:05 Chair: Janina_Sajka 17:00:05 agenda+ Admin: Telecon Time Survey http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0001.html 17:00:08 agenda+ Admin: IndieUI Overview Page http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0002.html 17:00:11 agenda+ admin: WAI IndieUI WG Telecon on 10 October 17:00:14 agenda+ Admin: TPAC; agenda+ Admin: Pointer Events Submission [See 17:00:16 Below] 17:00:17 Zakim, [Google] is me 17:00:17 +shepazu; got it 17:00:19 agenda+ Editor's Draft? https://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/track/actions/open 17:00:21 agenda+ Use Cases Walk-Through; Continued http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/wiki/Use_Cases_and_Requirements 17:00:24 agenda+ Scribe for our Next Teleconference (on 17 October) 17:00:27 agenda+ Be Done 17:01:18 +[Apple] 17:01:21 Zakim, Apple is me 17:01:21 +hober; got it 17:01:52 andy has joined #indie-ui 17:02:31 +??P3 17:02:33 clown has joined #indie-ui 17:02:42 +??P4 17:02:45 zakim, ??P4 is Michael_Cooper 17:02:45 +Michael_Cooper; got it 17:03:07 zakim, mute me 17:03:07 sorry, andy, I do not know which phone connection belongs to you 17:03:13 +[GVoice] 17:03:22 zakim, GVoice is Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:03:22 +Joseph_Scheuhammer; got it 17:03:25 zakim, ??P3 is Andi_Heath 17:03:25 +Andi_Heath; got it 17:03:32 zakim, I am Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:03:32 ok, clown, I now associate you with Joseph_Scheuhammer 17:03:44 +Art_Barstow 17:03:46 zakim, Andi is Andy_Heath 17:03:46 +Andy_Heath; got it 17:03:54 zakim, andy is Andy_Heath 17:03:54 +Andy_Heath; got it 17:03:56 zakim, mute me 17:03:56 Andy_Heath.a should now be muted 17:04:05 richardschwerdtfe has joined #indie-ui 17:04:23 ArtB has joined #indie-ui 17:05:21 +Rich 17:05:23 ScribeNick: hober 17:05:31 + +1.626.841.aaaa 17:05:35 zakim, take up item 1 17:05:35 agendum 1. "Admin: Telecon Time Survey http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0001.html" taken up [from janina] 17:05:35 zakim, unmute me 17:05:38 Andy_Heath.a should no longer be muted 17:06:01 janina: fyi, we've surveyed about different/rotating telcon schedule 17:06:07 +Katie_Haritos-Shea 17:06:13 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/54997/2012_meetings/results 17:06:21 janina: the current schedule is late in the day for europe and middle of night for asia 17:06:27 janina: survey is open through tomorrow 17:06:39 janina: we'll talk it over on the list and on the call 17:07:10 Ryladog has joined #indie-ui 17:07:13 richardschwerdtfe: what sort of conflicts do we have? 17:07:27 janina: [describes global interest] 17:08:09 MichaelC: each of the two times in the survey would gain us one person who is not currently attending this time 17:08:20 ... gain of one person might not be worth it; need more people to vote 17:08:54 zakim, next item 17:08:54 agendum 2. "Admin: IndieUI Overview Page http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0002.html" taken up [from janina] 17:09:39 janina: the education and outreach wai wg maintains overview pages for each wai activity 17:09:46 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0002.html 17:09:52 janina: they've drafted an overview page for the wai indie-ui wg 17:10:02 ... please take a look, check for accuracy, etc. 17:10:10 ... audience is non-technical 17:10:28 ... should be readily understandable, accurate, and comprehensive 17:11:02 Zakim, who is on the phone? 17:11:02 On the phone I see Janina_Sajka, shepazu, hober, Andy_Heath.a, Michael_Cooper, Joseph_Scheuhammer, Art_Barstow, Rich, +1.626.841.aaaa, Katie_Haritos-Shea 17:11:15 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-indie-ui/2012Oct/0002.html 17:11:19 janina: any questions about this page? 17:11:40 actual page is here: http://www.w3.org/WAI/EO/wiki/IndieUI_Overview 17:12:00 http://www.w3.org/WAI/EO/wiki/IndieUI_Overview 17:12:05 shepazu: could we take a minute now to skim? 17:12:08 janina: yes 17:13:30 +Shawn 17:13:32 richardschwerdtfe: the introduction only talks about device independent events and not the user context 17:13:49 richardschwerdtfe: could also mention scroll wheel in scrolling example 17:13:59 janina: [introduces Shawn] 17:14:51 +1 to include AT in Intro 17:14:56 Shawn: we're trying to cover what this is for in the introduction, and then we talk about each document in the documents section 17:15:06 jcraig has joined #indie-ui 17:15:10 Shawn: the intro captures the idea, why we're doing this 17:15:37 richardschwerdtfe: in the first sentence, not just a wide range of devices, but also a wide range of users and the contexts in which they operate 17:16:13 +[Apple] 17:16:23 q+ 17:16:24 Zakim, [Apple] has jcraig 17:16:25 +jcraig; got it 17:16:44 richardschwerdtfe: could use more of a "command" example like "open", instead of a device-tied example like "scroll" 17:17:01 richardschwerdtfe: you might have an "open" event, top open a folder, to open a new row in your document 17:17:13 richardschwerdtfe: or other high-level examples like zoom in, zoom out 17:17:28 q+ to suggest escape/dismiss example 17:17:44 shepazu: scroll seems less compelling, it usually has a lot of existing affordances 17:17:57 Shawn: for either zoom or open, what would the sentence be like? 17:18:19 hoper - sorry - just saw this - I suggested "wide range of user needs and devices" 17:18:22 q+ to say "open" will be too easily confused with "click" 17:18:51 richardschwerdtfe: "a user operating a web application may wish to open a folder using a broad range of device commands such as a gesture, a voice command, etc. Indie-UI allows the device to send a simple 'open' event to the application regardless of how the user signaled..." 17:19:04 richardschwerdtfe: in both the intro and the documents section 17:19:25 Shawn: would this be an additional example or replacing the existing one? 17:19:33 q? 17:19:33 shepazu: combine the two 17:19:59 shepazu: [expands on that] 17:20:15 q? 17:20:28 ack ryl 17:20:29 - +1.626.841.aaaa 17:20:42 ack jcraig 17:20:43 jcraig, you wanted to suggest escape/dismiss example and to say "open" will be too easily confused with "click" 17:20:47 Better to use the word 'Context' (as Rich suggests) with (use needs, preferences, access device) in parans after it. Example: 'Context' (as Rich suggests) with (use needs, preferences, access device) 17:20:50 jcraig: wordsmithing is probably not the best use of telcon time 17:21:02 Soory, somehow I muted myself 17:21:06 jcraig: rich's example of open is also confused, like scroll 17:21:12 q+ Katie 17:21:15 Zakim unmute me 17:21:16 jcraig: we could use an escape or dismiss gesture 17:21:27 jcraig: lots of people capture ESC key 17:21:38 ack k 17:21:39 q? 17:21:44 ack Ryladog 17:21:55 Ryladog: the word 'context' as rich suggested is key 17:21:58 Caroline_Jay has joined #indie-ui 17:22:11 Ryladog: important to make this broader, and 'context' does that 17:22:20 q? 17:22:38 Shawn: scroll seems so much stronger for novices 17:22:59 Shawn: could you say the same sort of thing for escape or dismiss? 17:23:10 s/example of open is also confused/example of open could also be confused by users/ 17:23:23 janina: we're not sure what to call it, so it might not be a good example 17:23:29 q+ to suggest a checkbox as a very concrete case. 17:23:35 janina: zoom is also common, like scroll 17:23:37 q+ 17:23:43 q? 17:23:48 q+ 17:23:55 Shawn: do you want me to draft wording for zoom? 17:24:04 Shawn: is it ok to put out a draft of this with scroll? 17:24:06 shepazu: that's fine 17:24:16 janina: you can send it to the mailing list 17:24:40 clown: if we want to replace the scroll event example, we could use a checkbox 17:24:42 q? 17:24:52 clown: [describes various ways of toggling a checkbox] 17:25:00 ack clown 17:25:07 jcraig: checkbox is already covered by click events 17:25:16 ... scroll is fine for now, zoom too 17:25:29 ack joseph 17:25:29 Joseph_Scheuhammer, you wanted to suggest a checkbox as a very concrete case. 17:25:38 ... some examples of escape or dismiss: kbd ESC, voice over has a gesture, android has a back button 17:25:40 ack jcraig 17:25:44 ack andy 17:25:53 q? 17:26:34 andy: re: the "indie ui: user context" paragraph, user settings is too narrow, maybe 'preferences' would be better? 17:26:48 Shawn: we could swap them around, would decouple it from AT 17:26:58 andy: the word 'settings' doesn't say what sort of settings 17:27:11 shepazu: can we wordsmith over email? 17:27:20 janina: i think we should 17:27:27 Shawn: will try to get an email out today 17:27:33 -Shawn 17:27:35 zakim, next item 17:27:35 agendum 3. "admin: WAI IndieUI WG Telecon on 10 October" taken up [from janina] 17:28:02 janina: those of you who are in the wai wg, we have a brief telcon next week 17:28:12 ... for administrative topisc 17:28:19 s/topisc/topics/ 17:28:43 +??P8 17:29:28 zakim, ??P8 is Caroline_Jay 17:29:28 +Caroline_Jay; got it 17:30:04 janina: re: TPAC, our agenda is on our wiki page 17:30:16 -> http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/wiki/Meetings/TPAC2012 IndieUI TPAC 2012 meeting page 17:30:22 zakim, next item 17:30:22 agendum 4. "Admin: TPAC; agenda+ Admin: Pointer Events Submission [See" taken up [from janina] 17:30:52 janina: we've had a submission; ac is considering it 17:31:15 ArtB: web events wg welcomes the submission 17:31:36 ... if we assume the wg gets created, it affects some web events work 17:31:43 ... and our participation in indi-ui tf 17:31:56 ... web events will continue working on the touch events v1 17:31:58 ... to CR 17:32:05 ... we will stop work on touch events v2 17:32:22 ... instead we'll work with pointer events wg 17:32:35 ... once touch events v1 rec is published, web events wg will close 17:32:54 ... so how do web events participants continue participating in this tf? 17:33:08 ... most straightforward way would be to ask web events folks to join the wai wg 17:34:17 q? 17:34:21 shepazu: [talks about the pointer events model; prefers it to the touch events model] 17:35:18 q+ 17:35:20 shepazu: if web events shuts down, don't know what that will mean wrt my involvement in this tf 17:35:28 ack MichaelC 17:35:41 MichaelC: if that happens, should this tf become joint with pointer events wg? 17:35:43 shepazu: no 17:36:05 ... they want to be very focused, don't want to veer off on high-level events 17:36:10 q+ to ask how pointer events will handle multip-finger touch events 17:36:43 janina: how does the pointer events model handle multiple finger events? 17:36:57 shepazu: it doesn't do gestures, it does multiple fingers 17:37:14 q? 17:37:23 ack janina 17:37:23 janina, you wanted to ask how pointer events will handle multip-finger touch events 17:37:38 ArtB: we should keep pointer events really narrowly scoped 17:38:20 MichaelC: web events wg participants in this tf are invited to join the wai indie-ui tf 17:39:36 janina: AC voting goes on through the 25th 17:39:45 ... not a done deal yet 17:40:07 MichaelC: 4 or 5 people would be affected 17:40:29 zakim, next item 17:40:29 agendum 5. "Editor's Draft? https://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/track/actions/open" taken up [from janina] 17:40:47 -Art_Barstow 17:40:51 -shepazu 17:40:54 ArtB has left #indie-ui 17:41:01 janina: jcraig, let's have a regular check-in; any updates on the draft? 17:41:11 jcraig: working through the open issues as i have time 17:41:27 action-5? 17:41:27 ACTION-5 -- Joseph Scheuhammer to author draft spec. change for james craig to include place holders for agreed upon events today in -- due 2012-08-29 -- OPEN 17:41:27 http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/track/actions/5 17:41:28 jcraig: there's one action item on joseph 17:41:50 clown: can close it or assign it to jcraig: 17:42:05 janina: any questions? 17:42:16 zakim, next item 17:42:16 agendum 6. "Use Cases Walk-Through; Continued http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/wiki/Use_Cases_and_Requirements" taken up [from janina] 17:42:40 janina: we should focus a significant amount of time at tpac on use cases 17:44:01 richardschwerdtfe: pick back up at use case 6 17:44:12 http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/wiki/Use_Cases_and_Requirements#S6:_Command_move_the_focus_point_within_a_UI_component_down_to_the_next_focusable_item_within_a_UI_component 17:44:15 http://www.w3.org/WAI/IndieUI/wiki/Use_Cases_and_Requirements#S6:_Command_move_the_focus_point_within_a_UI_component_down_to_the_next_focusable_item_within_a_UI_component 17:45:01 richardschwerdtfe: if you're in a widget and want to move down in the widget, could have a command for that 17:45:29 jcraig: do we already have something like this? 17:45:51 q+ to suggest next/previous instead of up/down 17:46:05 jcraig: it says "move down to the next *focusable* item" instead of just "the next item" 17:46:14 jcraig: basically the equivalent of TAB or Shift-TAB 17:46:37 richardschwerdtfe: what terminology would be better? 17:47:04 jcraig: we could just remove the word "focusable" 17:47:18 richardschwerdtfe: if you have a list box, going to each of the items 17:47:44 jcraig: following para might need some wordsmithing, or a note that says this isn't the same as TAB/Shift-TAB 17:48:10 richardschwerdtfe: maybe "within a ui component"? 17:48:27 janina: isn't this about local navigation? "local next"/"local previous" 17:48:32 FYI........Many User cases in this doc have the typo "supports supports" in the first sentence 17:48:39 jcraig: let's start by taking the word "focusable" out and go from there 17:48:43 +1 remove word Focus 17:49:01 richardschwerdtfe: do we need an action item to get this into the spec? 17:49:14 jcraig: i think the use cases are clear; we should keep working on them in the wiki 17:49:25 ... some of them are already covered, some aren't 17:49:35 ... i will do a comparison with the spec 17:49:50 jcraig: use case 7 also needs that same change 17:50:13 clown: it shouldn't be down/up, it should be next/previous 17:50:39 clown: set of items, there's a next/prev relative to where you are 17:50:56 richardschwerdtfe: left & right v. up & down, we need this separate for two-dimensional widgets 17:50:56 q+ 17:51:11 q+ 17:51:28 Ryladog: also 3D 17:51:33 janina: we decided to put 3D off 17:51:46 clown: in grid, next/prev in row, next/prev in col 17:52:04 richardschwerdtfe: what about a flow diagram? 17:52:17 clown: suppose you have a tree like OS X's Finder 17:52:41 clown: could be rendered on an iPhone as swiping left/right 17:52:44 clown: still a tree 17:52:50 q+ to mention s8 and s9. I like Joseph's idea of vertical vs linear 17:52:58 clown: shouldn't be tied to the rendering 17:52:59 ack jo 17:52:59 Joseph_Scheuhammer, you wanted to suggest next/previous instead of up/down 17:53:06 janina: agree with clown 17:53:09 ack R 17:53:15 Ryladog: for the moment, yes 17:53:41 q? 17:53:45 richardschwerdtfe: how about "in a horizontal direction, next and previous"? 17:53:52 ack car 17:54:10 Caroline_Jay: i think this important for grid widgets like date pickers 17:54:23 Caroline_Jay: i tend to agree with clown 17:54:53 jcraig: use case 6 through 9 are all in this "linear directional navigation" context 17:55:10 jcraig: clown had the right idea, this is a general next/previous 17:55:21 q+ 17:55:27 jcraig: visual left/right is locale dependent 17:55:50 what about vertical languages? 17:55:51 jcraig: "general next" and "general previous", which might be left/right in ltr languages 17:56:08 jcraig: grids might need special directional navigation events 17:56:34 jcraig: once you're in a managed focus widget like a grid or a tree, then the next/prev is like "change selected value" 17:56:47 q+ 17:56:56 jcraig: need to indicate that there's a multi-dimensional value change 17:57:06 q? 17:57:12 ack jcraig 17:57:12 jcraig, you wanted to mention s8 and s9. I like Joseph's idea of vertical vs linear 17:57:16 richardschwerdtfe: you might be moving in increments? 17:57:31 jcraig: something like a slider, next notch in slider is incrementing the value of the slider 17:57:56 jcraig: but tree widgets have a selection state; current use case for incrementing slider may also apply for these sorts of cases 17:58:45 jcraig: we should focus on the primary next/previous instead of left/right 17:58:55 jcraig: would be good to have special-cased "vertical next/previous" 17:59:00 jcraig: vertical v. linear 17:59:08 andy: isn't this just like tab order anyway? 17:59:28 "it's" 17:59:36 andy: the case for general next/previous within some order 17:59:55 andy: what does next/previous mean in a tree with unordered subnodes 18:00:08 q+ to mention this might already be covered by 'point of regard' or AT focus events 18:00:08 andy: next/prev gets parameter that varies depending on the kind of object 18:00:12 ack andy 18:00:14 ack Ryladog 18:00:22 Ryladog: definitely don't use right/left due to vertical and rtl languages 18:00:44 richardschwerdtfe: we've agreed on a next and previous; should i separate out vertical and horizontal? 18:00:54 jcraig: i'll send an email to the list 18:01:01 janina: yes, let's do this on the list 18:01:12 jcraig: it's possible that this is just covered by focus events 18:01:29 jcraig: we can have a separate at focus (point of regard focus) different from the kbd focus 18:01:51 jcraig: then we don't need next/prev, we just alert the app "this is the item i'm on" 18:02:03 Ryladog: richardschwerdtfe, there's diagonal too 18:02:29 richardschwerdtfe: they had directional work in SVG 1.2 tiny, could look at that 18:02:52 janina: let's try to figure out how to group these for better tpac time 18:03:01 janina: next meeting in 2 weeks, wai wg in 1 week 18:03:16 -hober 18:03:18 -[Apple] 18:03:18 -Katie_Haritos-Shea 18:03:20 -Caroline_Jay 18:03:21 -Joseph_Scheuhammer 18:03:23 -Andy_Heath.a 18:03:29 jcraig has left #indie-ui 18:03:33 -Michael_Cooper 18:03:35 -Janina_Sajka 18:03:39 RRSAgent, generate minutes 18:03:39 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2012/10/03-indie-ui-minutes.html hober 18:04:03 -Rich 18:04:04 WAI_Indie()1:00PM has ended 18:04:04 Attendees were Janina_Sajka, shepazu, hober, Michael_Cooper, Joseph_Scheuhammer, Andi_Heath, Art_Barstow, Andy_Heath, Rich, +1.626.841.aaaa, Katie_Haritos-Shea, Shawn, jcraig, 18:04:04 ... Caroline_Jay 18:04:16 RRSAgent: make logs public 18:04:25 RRSAgent, generate minutes 18:04:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2012/10/03-indie-ui-minutes.html hober 18:20:46 janina has left #indie-ui 18:29:20 Lachy has joined #indie-ui 18:33:15 clown has joined #indie-ui 20:39:48 clown has left #indie-ui 20:56:05 smaug_ has joined #indie-ui 21:51:43 jcraig_ has joined #indie-ui 22:19:08 jcraig has joined #indie-ui 23:26:43 MichaelC has joined #indie-ui