01:19:42 miketaylr has joined #css 01:24:14 dbaron has joined #css 01:24:20 nimbu has joined #css 01:26:47 nimbu has joined #css 02:29:23 cabanier has joined #css 03:29:04 miketaylr has joined #css 03:30:06 glenn has joined #css 04:13:46 cabanier has joined #css 05:19:27 antonp has joined #css 07:26:32 antonp has joined #css 07:43:15 heycam has joined #css 08:18:16 Ms2ger has joined #css 08:25:27 victor has joined #css 08:43:52 drublic has joined #css 09:03:16 SimonSapin has joined #css 09:39:16 cn=Simon Sapin,ou=People,dc=keleos,dc=fr 09:39:46 nevermind, wrong channel 11:38:35 dbaron has joined #css 12:38:48 miketaylr has joined #css 13:59:38 Ms2ger has joined #css 15:00:32 koji has joined #css 15:14:50 fantasai: ping 15:31:53 glazou has joined #css 15:32:10 Zakim has joined #css 15:32:28 Zakim, this will be Style 15:32:28 ok, glazou; I see Style_CSS FP()12:00PM scheduled to start in 28 minutes 15:32:33 RRSAgent, make logs public 15:34:37 glazou: I just wrote to w3c-css-wg to ask about editing specs 15:34:56 hi SImon ; looking 15:35:18 not received yet 15:36:29 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-css-wg/2012JulSep/0381.html 15:37:28 yep saw it 15:38:09 TabAtkins: ping 15:38:12 yt ? 15:38:36 SimonSapin: ask fantasai or TabAtkins about how-to documents 15:39:04 I found stuff on the wiki about publishing to /TR 15:40:05 SimonSapin, also, https://www.w3.org/Style/Group/ 15:40:31 florian has joined #css 15:40:31 And https://www.w3.org/Style/Group/css3-src/bin/postprocess 15:41:33 Ms2ger: the latter builds Overview.html from a Overview.src.html, right? 15:41:40 Yep 15:42:13 and you use curl or something to automate it? 15:43:16 I believe some people have Makefiles in the public repo 15:43:35 curl is ok 15:43:41 the basis is HTTP PUT 15:44:16 see bottom of https://www.w3.org/Style/Group/css3-src/bin/README.html 15:45:56 Ms2ger: scripts in the repo, in http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/csswg/ ? 15:46:07 Yes 15:47:03 ./css3-regions/Makefile, for example 15:47:09 cabanier has joined #css 15:47:42 oh, per spec 15:48:15 Yeah 15:49:20 hum, css3-page/Makefile includes ../Makefile … which does not exist 15:49:23 I’ll look around 15:50:06 Heh 15:50:09 not sure I'll be able to chair ; I can barely speak 15:50:13 so sore throat 15:51:29 Ok for the tools. The question remains: should I just push small fixes or talk to the editors first? 15:52:01 the latter 15:52:25 the usual way is to send the typos by email directly to the editors or, if they're important, www-style 15:52:44 in that latter case, it's archived and that's why it does matter 15:52:59 the former is not archived and verifiable 15:53:07 by anyone I mean 15:53:24 well, the hg history is public 15:53:54 hg logs are far less easy to get than www-style archive… 15:53:59 and they don't have URIs 15:54:07 Molly has joined #css 15:54:13 hey Molly 15:54:33 paul_irish: yt? 15:54:39 There's always hgweb 15:54:53 Hey Daniel! I'm IRCing in from a plane, so no phone today 15:55:03 from a plane ?!? 15:55:05 wow 15:55:31 Relevant: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8r1CZTLk-Gk 15:55:49 at this time, I could use a plane ticket to bora-bora 15:55:55 Yep, on my way home from Chicago to Tucson, 5 dollar wifi all day on Southwest :) 15:56:01 nice 15:56:15 Style_CSS FP()12:00PM has now started 15:56:25 +[IPcaller] 15:56:38 Zakim, I am [UPcaller] 15:56:41 sorry, florian, I do not see a party named '[UPcaller]' 15:56:44 Zakim, I am [IPcaller] 15:56:44 ok, florian, I now associate you with [IPcaller] 15:56:49 +??P33 15:56:56 Zakim, ??P33 is me 15:56:56 +glazou; got it 15:57:26 + +1.415.308.aaaa 15:57:43 krit has joined #css 15:57:53 Zakim, aaaa is krit 15:57:53 +krit; got it 15:58:05 np 15:58:44 SimonSapin has joined #css 15:58:47 even embedded in 15:59:14 glazou: sounds save 15:59:18 sick 15:59:28 glazou: :( 15:59:43 oyvind has joined #css 15:59:54 +bradk 16:00:00 bradk has joined #css 16:00:11 Molly: a good tea with honey will do the trick 16:00:35 CesarAcebal has joined #css 16:00:41 +lstorset 16:00:53 :) Done! But I'll have to make it a torrent for optimal plane to cup xfer 16:01:09 lstorset has joined #css 16:01:14 +[Microsoft] 16:01:32 +Stearns 16:01:37 JohnJansen has joined #css 16:01:44 +Bert 16:02:25 +CesarAcebal 16:02:33 rhauck has joined #css 16:02:45 +??P64 16:02:49 +antonp 16:03:02 Zakim, ??P64 is SimonSapin 16:03:03 +CesarAcebal.a 16:03:03 Zakim, ??P64 is me 16:03:05 +plinss 16:03:11 +SimonSapin 16:03:13 zakim, Microsoft has JohnJansen 16:03:28 + +1.415.615.aabb 16:03:38 +SimonSapin; got it 16:03:39 antonp1 has joined #css 16:03:42 I already had ??P64 as SimonSapin.a, SimonSapin 16:03:45 Zakim, aabb is me 16:03:48 +JohnJansen; got it 16:04:10 Zakim, who is here 16:04:21 + +1.415.832.aacc 16:04:25 +leaverou 16:04:26 +rhauck; got it 16:04:40 antonp1, you need to end that query with '?' 16:04:44 +[Apple] 16:04:47 How can I resolve SimonSapin.a vs. SimonSapin? 16:04:47 Zakim, aacc is rossen 16:04:49 antonp1 has left #css 16:04:50 Zakim, Apple is me 16:05:04 antonp1 has joined #css 16:05:31 Zakim, who is on the phone? 16:05:37 antonp1 has left #css 16:05:58 antonp1 has joined #css 16:06:01 +rossen; got it 16:06:03 +hober; got it 16:06:08 On the phone I see [IPcaller], glazou, krit, bradk, lstorset, [Microsoft], Stearns, Bert, CesarAcebal, SimonSapin.a, antonp, CesarAcebal.a, plinss, SimonSapin, rhauck, rossen, 16:06:10 ... leaverou, hober 16:06:12 [Microsoft] has JohnJansen 16:06:31 +fantasai 16:07:09 Seems like Zakim is seeing me twice, again 16:07:20 SimonSapin: nevermind 16:07:26 drublic has joined #css 16:07:46 ScribeNick: fantasai 16:08:00 glazou: any extra items? 16:08:13 +[Microsoft.a] 16:08:16 krit: Would like editor to Masking 16:08:24 zakim, microsoft has me 16:08:24 +arronei; got it 16:08:34 krit: Would like to add Brian Birtles from Mozilla 16:08:41 krit: He's already worked on SVG masking spec 16:08:45 glazou: Any objections? 16:08:56 RESOLVED: Brian Birtles added as editor to CSS3 Masking 16:09:16 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Sep/0464.html 16:09:17 glazou: Request from fantasai and Tab to publish FPWD of counter-styles 16:10:06 Florian: This is split out for CSS3 Lists? 16:10:08 fantasai: yes 16:10:34 Florian: It's removed all the stuff except CSS2.1 / CSS2.0 stuff? 16:11:13 tantek has joined #css 16:11:23 fantasai: Yes, except ethiopic-numeric, because it can't be represented by @counter-style. This is marked as an issue. 16:11:41 -rhauck 16:11:51 Florian: What about katakana / hiragana? 16:12:00 good morning 16:12:08 hi tantek 16:12:09 Florian: There was some question of how they behave, why not look at the implementations that exist? 16:12:13 TabAtkins_ has joined #css 16:12:13 fantasai: No disagreement there 16:12:21 Florian: If there's no implementation, then remove them. 16:12:33 glazou: We have enough time to remove them in the future 16:13:02 glazou: Noticed one of the latest edits was edit to type attribute in CSSOM (changed to system) 16:13:07 glazou: There was some discussion about that 16:13:20 glazou: Change seems good to me. 16:13:35 Bert: Can we change the shortname? Seems odd for CSS3 shortnames to be inconsistent 16:13:44 Florian: Didn't we resolve to change it to the new pattern? 16:14:00 Yes, it's the new pattern that we'll change everything to. 16:14:08 me too Tab, just dropped from call and can't get back in 16:14:09 Florian: Eventually we will migrate everything to the new scheme 16:14:16 glazou: We resolved on that last week 16:14:29 Bert: Think there's better things to do, but ok. 16:14:42 glazou: We need to. The current naming scheme has been inconsistent, and it's confusing people. 16:15:09 +rhauck 16:15:32 + +1.281.305.aadd 16:15:39 zakim, aadd is me 16:15:39 +TabAtkins_; got it 16:15:52 Florian: I will object if they are not marked at-risk 16:15:56 fantasai: They're marked 16:16:00 glazou: It's in the status section 16:16:06 Florian: Ok, I'm good. 16:16:13 RESOLVED: FPWD CSS Counter Styles Level 3 16:16:28 Topic: Viewport Size for Reftests 16:16:30 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2012Sep/0020.html 16:16:35 +[IPcaller.a] 16:16:43 zakim, [ipcaller.a] is me 16:16:43 +koji; got it 16:16:52 leif: Deferred so I could investigate what Opera needed. 16:17:00 leif: Essentially have no problem with 600x600 16:17:53 leif: Might need different size in the future, but probably would prefer to mark that with metadata 16:18:10 s/releases/released 16:18:40 fantasai: If we need a smaller size, then we should figure that out now, not go back and mark tests that fit within the smaller size and say the others can't be run on that size 16:19:06 leif: ... viewport tests probably need a special keywords ... 16:19:33 arronei: We should add a flag for tests that don't fit within 600x600 16:20:02 lstorset has joined #css 16:20:28 rossen: From past experience, when we had tests that rely on a square container, sometimes this can hide some buggy implementations, especially when dealing with different permutations of directions / writing modes / etc 16:20:47 rossen: when both containing width and height are the same, might hide a buggy implementation there 16:20:51 +1 16:21:04 rossen: if you're settled on 600x600, that's fine, but a square container is prone to hiding some bugs 16:21:23 krit: Mozilla uses 1000x1000, and Webkit uses 800x600 16:21:47 rossen: 1000x1000 doesn't solve the issue I was talking about, but 800x600 would be perfect 16:21:52 +1, I had such bugs. (Non-square viewport is better) 16:22:14 rossen: also @media aspect ratios, setting square viewport can hide some things that you want to find out sooner than later 16:23:28 fantasai: This isn't the size to use, it's the smallest size that you can make the viewport and still capture all relevant data in a screenshot 16:23:35 glazou: Enough info to make a decision? 16:23:51 molly has joined #css 16:23:55 fantasai: Yeah. We'll go with 600x600, and recommend that UAs use a rectangular size that is larger than that if possible. 16:24:06 Florian: I'm mildly surprised no one needs a smaller size for mobile testing 16:24:35 leif: Often the desktop viewport size is used 16:24:50 leif: If we wanted to go with the smallest mobile screen size, we'd be at 240 16:24:56 leif: that's a bit small 16:25:03 RESOLVED: as fantasai summarized above 16:25:15 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012Jul/0598.html 16:25:19 Topic: Multi-column Shrink-to-fit 16:25:35 this is SimonSapin speaking 16:25:46 Sapin: The part of multicol about shrink-to-fit doesn't make sense. We should just remove it. 16:26:10 fantasai: I agree with removing any implication that css3-multicol defines multicol intrinsic sizing 16:26:13 I am wondering is the size limit implies constrains on the fonts that you can use when running the tests, as some fonts may cause the text to overflow 16:26:21 Sapin: We can define it later in css3-sizing if necessary. 16:26:23 s/is the/if the/ 16:26:35 Bert: I didn't understand what the problem is 16:27:05 Sapin: css3-multicol sizing uses shrink-to-fit sizing when available size is none, but CSS2.1 [...] 16:27:14 glazou: You said there is little interop in your email 16:27:29 Sapin: If we we make float multicol elements, we can see intrinsic size without defining width 16:27:37 Sapin: Results are all over the place 16:28:32 fantasai: I raised an issue about multicol intrinsic sizing that håkon thought was in the spec not making sense anyway 16:28:42 glazou: Impact on the spec? 16:28:48 Sapin: [...] 16:28:54 anton: Make it explicitly undefined? 16:29:02 Sapin: Yes, we can add that it's undefined 16:29:20 Sapin: I don't know if, for example, Flexbox explicitly says the preferred width is undefined 16:29:26 fantasai: No, we define it. 16:29:44 Florian: Easier for us and implementers if we make it explicitly undefined 16:30:06 rossen: Have another question here, can you elaborate what you meant by "results are all over the place?" 16:30:09 Rossen has joined #css 16:30:19 Sapin: For example, some browsers takes the preferred width as if the element were not multi-column, and just use that 16:30:29 Sapin: Some browsers multiply the results by the column-count 16:30:41 Rossen: Were there any browsers doing what the spec is asking for? 16:30:47 Sapin: I don't know what the spec is supposed to be asking for 16:31:32 fantasai: I think we should make it's undefined, because the desired behavior is unclear/unknown, and we don't have interop 16:31:45 Bert: It's already undefined in the spec, what did you want to change? 16:31:46 -[Microsoft] 16:32:08 Sapin: I don't know how having an unknown available-width is useful 16:32:58 glazou: Seems to me some people need to do more investigation to rsolve this 16:33:10 rossen: We did a bit of work on this, I need to test a little on that 16:33:21 rossen: We read the spec at the time, and it kinda made sense 16:33:37 rossen: I would prefer if we can take this next week and then have a few days to look around and see what exactly would that mean 16:33:53 glazou: We'll return next week 16:34:01 anton: Ca we get confirmatio exactly what the proposal is 16:34:27 Sapin: Remove lines 3-10 inclusive 16:34:58 Florian: Seems we have to remove something, but unsure what the scope of that its 16:34:59 http://www.w3.org/mid/4FBB2B56.9080805@mcc.id.au 16:35:14 Topic: URL notation and IRIs 16:35:44 TabAtkins_: We just have to make sure our definition of URLs includes IRIs 16:36:04 URLs are ASCII only (and even more restrictive than that) 16:36:27 glazou: How many changes do we need? 16:36:30 TabAtkins_: Just in css3-values 16:36:44 Florian: Some people complained that we shouldn't use the term URL when we mean IRI 16:36:59 TabAtkins proposes ignoring that 16:37:04 TabAtkins: That's what everyone calls them 16:37:26 krit: CSS3 Images need to update to CSS3 Values and Units instead of CSS2.1 then 16:37:55 glazou: Editing CR? 16:38:04 fantasai: This qualifies as a clarification, since this is what was meant 16:38:50 fantasai: I think I even had an issue marked on what the correct terminology should be to include IRIs, and nobody every commented on it 16:38:56 fantasai: So I just removed the issue. 16:38:58 RFC 3987 instead of RFC 3986 16:39:21 glazou: Also need to update the prose of the spec 16:39:33 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-css-wg/2012JulSep/0372.html 16:39:37 Topic: Line Grid proposal 16:39:47 Florian: At the Kyoto F2F, fantasai made a line grid proposal 16:40:08 Florian: Everybody liked it, and since there was the Line Layout module, people wanted to put Line Grid into Line Layout 16:40:20 Florian: But since then it seems Line layout is complicated and moves slowly 16:40:30 Florian: Propose making it its own module, and moving it forward 16:40:44 Szilles: Line grid is equally complicated, because you don't know what to align with the line gride 16:40:58 Florian: I agree there are ambiguities in what will happen until Line Layout is finished 16:41:03 rhauck1 has joined #css 16:41:14 florian: But [...] 16:41:22 szilles: No, it's because of the way line-height is defined 16:41:35 szilles: You don't know where the baseline is within a line 16:41:37 drublic has joined #css 16:41:51 fantasai: Isn't that only true when someting is vertical-align: bottom or top ? 16:42:02 szilles: don't recall, but not about differing baselines 16:42:19 Florian: Seems to me in generalized situation what you're saying is right, but there are a lot of cases that would work 16:42:42 szilles: I guess I disagree, since if you don't figure this out from the beginning you won't get it right 16:43:04 szilles: But I will commit to having a Line Module layout by Lyon 16:43:58 Florian: Couldn't we still have different modules that depend on each other? Or is dependency too strong? 16:44:19 szilles: you need a definition of lines that works 16:44:33 anton: I think you'll end up relying on dependencies that aren't thought through 16:44:44 glazou: Since Steve's committed to giving us a module by Lyon, I suggest waiting until then 16:44:51 Florian: Ok, that's fine 16:45:14 glazou: end of agenda, anything else to discuss? 16:45:21 fantasai: Do we have dates for F2F in February yet? 16:45:38 molly? 16:45:49 glazou: Proposed 4-6 of February in Tucson 16:45:54 Florian: pending confirmation 16:46:11 glazou: I have an exclusion in February, there's a W3C workshop about EPUB in NYC 15-16 of February 16:46:18 glazou: So would like to avoid those dates if we ever change 16:46:30 szilles: don't think molly can do those dates anyway 16:46:51 fantasai: So just need Molly to confirm dates? 16:46:56 glazou: Anything else? 16:47:11 Florian: Yes, about your priority lists, seems to me there were some specs missing. Maybe re-issue an updated list? 16:47:29 glazou: People already commented that they were missing, so I hope responses included them 16:47:35 It is dependent upon availability and sponsors - but I will leave those days out 16:47:40 fantasai: If they didn't include them, need to go back and ask 16:48:01 Florian: Public responses missed e.g. CSS Variables 16:48:36 glazou: Ok, I'll deal with that 16:49:19 glazou: Peter and I will go through responses before TPAC so we can discuss, so really need responses soon so we can aggregate data 16:50:15 fantasai: For CSS3 Conditional, Tab and I plan to request LC on October 10th telecon, that's in 2 weeks. Please review and send issues before then. 16:51:07 -krit 16:51:08 -hober 16:51:08 -TabAtkins_ 16:51:09 -antonp 16:51:09 -leaverou 16:51:11 -rossen 16:51:11 -glazou 16:51:12 -Stearns 16:51:14 -CesarAcebal 16:51:15 -lstorset 16:51:18 -koji 16:51:19 -CesarAcebal.a 16:51:22 -bradk 16:51:23 -rhauck 16:51:23 antonp1 has left #css 16:51:25 -SimonSapin 16:51:27 -[IPcaller] 16:51:35 -plinss 16:51:38 Meeting closed. 16:51:46 -[Microsoft.a] 16:52:11 -Bert 16:52:14 -fantasai 16:52:22 miketaylr has joined #css 16:55:11 -SimonSapin.a 16:55:12 Style_CSS FP()12:00PM has ended 16:55:12 Attendees were [IPcaller], glazou, +1.415.308.aaaa, krit, bradk, lstorset, Stearns, Bert, CesarAcebal, antonp, plinss, SimonSapin, +1.415.615.aabb, JohnJansen, +1.415.832.aacc, 16:55:12 ... leaverou, rhauck, rossen, hober, fantasai, [Microsoft], arronei, +1.281.305.aadd, TabAtkins_, koji 16:55:37 SimonSapin1 has joined #css 16:57:43 lstorset has joined #css 16:59:37 oyvind has left #css 16:59:48 Anyways, don't worry too much, just had to ask when I had you there :) 16:59:53 oops, wrong window 17:05:07 bradk has joined #css 17:05:30 nimbu has joined #css 17:39:11 rhauck has joined #css 17:40:47 rhauck1 has joined #css 17:45:06 nimbu has joined #css 18:07:39 krit has joined #css 18:08:19 Rossen has joined #css 18:42:52 Zakim has left #css 18:43:41 nimbu has left #css 19:13:14 rhauck has joined #css 19:14:14 rhauck has left #css 19:19:23 tpod has joined #css 19:34:20 tantek has joined #css 20:44:28 nimbu has joined #css 20:47:17 drublic has joined #css 21:08:33 nimbu has joined #css 21:11:40 nimbu has joined #css 22:23:17 nimbu has left #css 22:28:42 dbaron has joined #css 23:01:31 nimbu has joined #css 23:39:23 nimbu has joined #css 23:44:13 nimbu has joined #css 23:54:30 nimbu has joined #css 23:59:13 nimbu has joined #css