13:44:36 RRSAgent has joined #dap 13:44:36 logging to http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-irc 13:44:38 RRSAgent, make logs world 13:44:38 Zakim has joined #dap 13:44:40 Zakim, this will be DAP 13:44:40 ok, trackbot; I see UW_DAP()10:00AM scheduled to start in 16 minutes 13:44:41 Meeting: Device APIs Working Group Teleconference 13:44:41 Date: 13 June 2012 13:45:08 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2012Jun/0035.html 13:45:30 fjh has changed the topic to: dap 3279 ; http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2012Jun/0035.html (fjh) 13:46:35 lgombos_ has joined #dap 13:46:40 Chair: Frederick_Hirsch 13:46:44 Present+ Frederick_Hirsch 13:46:56 Regrets+ Robin_Berjon 13:48:26 Regrets+ Travis_Leithead, Jungkee_Song, Claes_ Nilsson 13:51:19 zakim, who is here? 13:51:19 UW_DAP()10:00AM has not yet started, fjh 13:51:21 On IRC I see lgombos_, Zakim, RRSAgent, fjh, glenn, Josh_Soref, richt, mounir, lgombos, trackbot, dom, hiroto_away, ilkka 13:51:56 AnssiK has joined #dap 13:57:44 dcheng3 has joined #dap 13:58:23 UW_DAP()10:00AM has now started 13:58:29 +??P12 13:58:35 zakim, ??P12 is me 13:58:35 +fjh; got it 13:59:10 + +1.310.310.aaaa 13:59:19 + +49.173.537.aabb 13:59:40 Present+ Diana_Cheng 13:59:56 zakim, where is +1-310? 13:59:56 North American dialing code 1.310 is California 14:00:11 zakim, aabb is dcheng3 14:00:11 +dcheng3; got it 14:00:20 +??P18 14:00:39 Zakim, ??P18 is lgombos 14:00:40 +lgombos; got it 14:00:51 Present+ Laszlo_Gombos 14:01:03 Wonsuk has joined #dap 14:01:14 +??P15 14:01:22 zakim, ??P15 is me 14:01:22 +AnssiK; got it 14:01:27 Present+ Anssi_Kostiainen 14:01:39 jhawkins has joined #dap 14:01:56 zakim, aaaa is jhawkins 14:01:56 +jhawkins; got it 14:02:02 zakim, who is here? 14:02:02 On the phone I see fjh, jhawkins, dcheng3, lgombos, AnssiK 14:02:03 On IRC I see jhawkins, Wonsuk, dcheng3, AnssiK, lgombos_, Zakim, RRSAgent, fjh, glenn, Josh_Soref, richt, mounir, lgombos, trackbot, dom, hiroto_away, ilkka 14:02:58 + +46.1.07.15.aacc 14:03:16 Present+ Wonsuk_Lee 14:03:16 zakim, where is +46 14:03:16 fjh, I do not see a party named 'where'. If you meant to ask a question you need to add '?' 14:03:23 zakim, where is +46? 14:03:23 country code 46 is Sweden 14:03:31 + +1.503.542.aadd 14:03:40 zakim, aacc is niklas 14:03:40 +niklas; got it 14:04:26 zakim, where is +1-503? 14:04:26 North American dialing code 1.503 is Oregon 14:05:14 ScribeNick: fjh 14:05:19 Topic: Administrative 14:05:30 Publishing moratoria, 2H2012 https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-device-apis/2012May/0000.html 14:05:30 19 June webinos launch, http://webinos.org/launch-day 14:05:30 No DAP teleconference on 4 July 2012 (also is US holiday), and no teleconference on 18 July 2012. DAP F2F 10-12 July. 14:05:51 + +1.289.261.aaee 14:05:52 Clarke has joined #dap 14:06:07 nwidell has joined #dap 14:06:09 Zakim, aaee is me 14:06:09 +Josh_Soref; got it 14:06:13 Zakim, mute me 14:06:13 Josh_Soref should now be muted 14:06:23 Scribe: Josh_Soref 14:06:24 Cathy has joined #dap 14:06:39 Topic: Minutes Approval 14:06:45 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2012May/att-0301/minutes-2012-05-30.html 14:06:58 +??P30 14:07:02 RESOLUTION: Approve minutes from 30 May 14:07:07 Topic: Web Intents 14:07:10 zakim, ??P30 is me 14:07:10 +Clarke; got it 14:07:19 fjh: mounir submitted a proposal (Web Activities) 14:07:33 ... from the list, it sounds like they aren't as far forward as they think they are 14:07:49 ... we could talk about Intents/Activities at the F2F 14:08:07 + +1.781.266.aaff 14:08:12 ... 2 - there's the issue of Contacts and similar in DAP v. System Apps 14:08:16 zakim, aaff is me 14:08:16 +Cathy; got it 14:08:18 ... 3 - xxx 14:08:54 jhawkins: this will be my first time Chairing 14:09:02 ... i need information about FPWD 14:09:15 ... i'm ok with holding off for a couple of days 14:09:26 ... i have a reply for their counter-proposal that i hope to send off today 14:09:43 fjh: the draft is a Web Intents draft 14:09:49 ... there's nothing wrong with publishing now 14:10:08 ... a minor concern is that it solicits feedback and review 14:10:13 ... there's no reason not to 14:10:21 ... it's a matter of how long it takes to do the next thing 14:10:32 ... i'm of the impression it might take a little longer to figure things out 14:10:54 ... maybe we should add a note in the Status of Document section acknowledging the counter proposal 14:11:05 Zakim, who is speaking? 14:11:15 Josh_Soref, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: 10 (51%) 14:11:23 +??P8 14:11:23 jhawkins: i'd to get feedback from ArtB 14:11:25 -Cathy 14:11:33 zakim, ??P8 is me 14:11:33 +Cathy; got it 14:11:34 Zakim, 10 is jhawkins 14:11:34 sorry, Josh_Soref, I do not recognize a party named '10' 14:11:58 fjh: i think we need to keep moving 14:12:02 jhawkins: i agree 14:12:06 ... i'll send out my notes today 14:12:14 ... and people can get my opinions 14:12:21 fjh: and you can talk to ArtB 14:12:28 jhawkins: i agree 14:12:33 fjh: i'd like to get it done 14:12:43 ... we can use time at the F2F 14:12:54 ... i'm not sure who will be attending 14:13:03 ... i'm not sure if mounir will attend 14:13:10 jhawkins: are you concerned about lack of critical mass 14:13:17 q+ to note that dougt investigated attending 14:13:37 fjh: it can't hurt to ask mozilla about attending 14:13:42 jhawkins: i'll make an attempt to ask 14:13:50 ... but i'll note there isn't an open channel available 14:13:51 ack me 14:13:52 Josh_Soref, you wanted to note that dougt investigated attending 14:14:05 Zakim, mute me 14:14:05 Josh_Soref should now be muted 14:14:35 fjh: anyone else have comments about Web Intents? 14:14:44 ... i know Claes isn't on the call 14:15:10 q+ to note that i planned to send a response to mounir's proposal, but i'm backlogged by lots of other things 14:15:14 ack me 14:15:15 Josh_Soref, you wanted to note that i planned to send a response to mounir's proposal, but i'm backlogged by lots of other things 14:15:48 Zakim, mute me 14:15:48 Josh_Soref should now be muted 14:16:03 Topic: F2F 14:16:08 Please complete attendance questionnaire: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/43696/DAPJuly2012F2F/ 14:16:14 fjh: it's good to know 14:16:21 (results https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/43696/DAPJuly2012F2F/results ) 14:16:21 ... please complete whether you intend to attend or not 14:16:21 Logistics: http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/wiki/BurlingtonF2F2012 14:16:21 Draft Agenda: http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/wiki/F2F_Agenda_10-12_July_2012,_Burlington,_MA_USA 14:16:49 fjh: if you have questions about the agenda, please ask 14:16:53 ... anyone have any comments now? 14:16:58 Two additional calls before F2F, 20/27 June 14:17:10 Topic: Device Storage API / Gallery 14:17:11 dtran has joined #dap 14:17:18 fjh: there's a thread about file system 14:17:22 ... and where do you put stuff 14:17:29 ... i'm not sure the thread reached a conclusion 14:17:34 zakim, who is here? 14:17:34 On the phone I see fjh, jhawkins, dcheng3, lgombos, AnssiK, niklas, +1.503.542.aadd, Josh_Soref (muted), Clarke, Cathy 14:17:36 On IRC I see dtran, Cathy, nwidell, Clarke, jhawkins, Wonsuk, dcheng3, AnssiK, lgombos_, Zakim, RRSAgent, fjh, glenn, Josh_Soref, richt, mounir, lgombos, trackbot, dom, 14:17:36 ... hiroto_away, ilkka 14:17:43 q+ to note that flat file systems do not scale well 14:17:47 +Present Dzung_Tran 14:17:54 s/+Present/Present+/ 14:18:08 jhawkins: you may have seen feedback from yyy 14:18:19 zakim, who is making noise? 14:18:23 ... it's just a chrome extension api 14:18:32 fjh, listening for 12 seconds I heard sound from the following: fjh (4%), jhawkins (95%), +1.503.542.aadd (77%) 14:18:33 ... we want to wall it off from the web platform initially 14:18:39 Zakim, mute aadd 14:18:39 +1.503.542.aadd should now be muted 14:18:49 ... we need it elsewhere now 14:19:00 ... our implementation of the api is more system level than jungkee's 14:19:05 ... i like the intents based version 14:19:11 ... i haven't looked into it as much as i'd like to 14:19:18 ... it seems there are different levels of permissions 14:19:23 ... that may warrant different apis 14:19:30 ... the gallery level being more system 14:19:33 ... needs more security 14:19:39 ... whereas the intents version is safer 14:19:59 s/yyy/steve yya/ 14:20:10 fjh: do you have a URL for the chrome extension? 14:20:23 ACTION: jhawkins to send URL for gallery chrome extension to the list 14:20:29 Sorry, couldn't find user - jhawkins 14:20:41 fjh: the Web Notification WG changed Feature Permissions to 14:20:45 ... aaa? 14:21:06 ... AnssiK do you know what's going on there? 14:21:12 s/steve yya/Steve VanDeBogart/ 14:21:16 AnssiK: anne rewrote the spec to comply with pubrules 14:21:20 ... and there's been discussion 14:21:23 ... apple contributed 14:21:39 s/aaa/tie in with WebIDL/ 14:21:51 fjh: they thought about permissions 14:21:58 ... they added an attribute permitted/not 14:22:06 AnssiK: tied to a notifications model 14:22:17 ... we should not worry about that 14:22:26 fjh: we should avoid spinning things out into new WGs 14:22:46 ... it's clear we should be aware of permissions 14:22:54 ... i think it's a topic we have to work through 14:22:55 aadd is me 14:23:04 Zakim, who is on the call? 14:23:04 On the phone I see fjh, jhawkins, dcheng3, lgombos, AnssiK, niklas, +1.503.542.aadd (muted), Josh_Soref (muted), Clarke, Cathy 14:23:23 Zakim, aadd is Dzung_Tran 14:23:23 +Dzung_Tran; got it 14:23:28 Zakim, nick dtran is Dzung_Tran 14:23:28 ok, Josh_Soref, I now associate dtran with Dzung_Tran 14:23:40 lgombos_: in the case of notifications 14:23:55 ... the conclusion is that we can't ccc permisions 14:24:03 ... i think generally we want to avoid 14:24:15 ... permission requests 14:24:22 ... and favor implicit consent 14:24:38 fjh: if we can avoid permissions, and use web intents, we should 14:24:47 ... and we can roll web activities into that 14:24:52 Topic: Deliverable Review 14:25:00 Zakim, who is on the call? 14:25:00 On the phone I see fjh, jhawkins, dcheng3, lgombos, AnssiK, niklas, Dzung_Tran (muted), Josh_Soref (muted), Clarke, Cathy 14:25:04 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/ 14:25:08 fjh: it's unfortunate that darobin was unable to attend 14:25:14 ... he had something come up at the last minute 14:25:21 ... for Battery and ddd 14:25:30 s/ddd/Vibration/ 14:25:35 ... we are in CR and we can go to PR soon 14:25:43 ... AnssiK are we thinking Fall or Sooner? 14:26:00 ... maybe i should do this offline, involving dsr and darobin 14:26:06 AnssiK: what are the blockers for progress? 14:26:10 ... test suite 14:26:15 ... and a conformance report 14:26:22 fjh: thank you, we need the test suite 14:26:25 ... and formal interop 14:26:33 ... we need to figure out the time frame for that 14:26:49 ... the next step is to know who is doing what and when 14:26:54 ... HTML MC 14:27:00 ... i think we need to publish another Draft 14:27:18 ... we could go to LC, but i think it's premature 14:27:24 ... we need to figure out when to go to LC w/ it 14:27:29 ... Network Permission APIs 14:27:33 ... it's fairly simple 14:27:37 ... we published a Draft in June 14:27:42 ... but we can wait 14:27:50 ... Proximity... FPWD - we don't have one 14:28:01 ... we had activity, but it's calmed down 14:28:08 ... i think we should do a FPWD 14:28:17 ... i can't remember who the editor is 14:28:22 Anssi 14:28:24 AnssiK: i think we should go for FPWD 14:28:35 ... it has an issue of side-effects 14:28:40 fjh: i'll do a CfC for that 14:28:49 ... it's good to have frequent publications 14:29:03 ... any concern with having a FPWD for Proximity? 14:29:12 ... i'm having trouble with ReSpec, i'm not sure if it's working? 14:29:20 AnssiK: it's looking fine for me 14:29:24 no concern 14:29:28 ... I updated all my specs to use the latest ReSpec 14:29:30 action: fjh to start CfC for FPWD of proximity 14:29:31 Created ACTION-541 - Start CfC for FPWD of proximity [on Frederick Hirsch - due 2012-06-20]. 14:29:34 ... seems to work fine for me 14:29:42 fjh: i'll look into it later, it must be me 14:29:47 AnssiK: do a force-refresh 14:30:14 fjh: Contacts/Calendar 14:30:18 ... we're kind of blocked on them 14:30:24 ... i think we want to unblock them 14:30:48 ... we were using Gallery as the first test with Web Intents 14:30:50 Web Application Privacy Best Practices 14:30:58 would like to progress to Note 14:31:08 ACTION-470? 14:31:08 ACTION-470 -- Frederick Hirsch to update web application privacy best practices related to active consent -- due 2011-11-10 -- OPEN 14:31:08 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/470 14:31:15 fjh: it has been around a long time 14:31:23 ... i'd like to put out a CfC to publish it 14:31:38 gombos_ has joined #dap 14:32:02 action: fjh to review Web Application Privacy Best Practices, complete ACTION-470, put out CfC to publish as Note 14:32:02 Created ACTION-542 - Review Web Application Privacy Best Practices, complete ACTION-470, put out CfC to publish as Note [on Frederick Hirsch - due 2012-06-20]. 14:32:25 Josh_Soref: i'll try to review it at some point tomorrow 14:32:44 ack me 14:32:44 ack Josh_Soref 14:32:46 Josh_Soref, you wanted to note that flat file systems do not scale well and to stick around and hold my 14:34:47 gombos_ has left #dap 14:34:55 gombos_ has joined #dap 14:35:48 josh_soref: if you are on a trip and take thousands of photos in three different cities, you want to be able to organize by city, a flat file system simply does not work 14:36:08 josh_soref: tags may be like file folder, but whatever is done you need to organize and search does not work 14:36:17 Topic: Action Review 14:36:23 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/open 14:36:36 fjh: i'd like to do this before the F2F 14:36:46 ... i think darobin had an action to ask the Web Intents 14:36:59 Josh_Soref: i don't think we sent an email to the list 14:37:05 jhawkins: no, that's for me to do, i'll do that today 14:37:17 fjh: CfC for MC update 14:37:44 ... brian isn't on the call 14:37:49 ACTION-482? 14:37:49 ACTION-482 -- Josh Soref to contacts find() may be replaced with Intents -- due 2011-11-11 -- OPEN 14:37:49 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/482 14:37:51 ... Josh_Soref you have a bunch with contacts 14:37:59 ACTION-482? 14:37:59 ACTION-482 -- Josh Soref to contacts find() may be replaced with Intents -- due 2011-11-11 -- OPEN 14:37:59 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/482 14:38:07 ACTION-483? 14:38:07 ACTION-483 -- Josh Soref to send proposal to list for how Contacts will move forward -- due 2011-11-11 -- OPEN 14:38:07 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/483 14:38:24 ACTION-482: this can be replaced by intents 14:38:24 ACTION-482 Contacts find() may be replaced with Intents notes added 14:38:31 close ACTION-482 14:38:31 ACTION-482 Contacts find() may be replaced with Intents closed 14:40:20 Josh_Soref: i worked with greg at DAP-Shenzhen on the intents api 14:40:31 ... i thought we sent it out 14:40:52 ... in which case the resolution is to point to the email 14:40:57 fjh: can we get it done before the F2f? 14:41:02 jhawkins: we can do that 14:41:24 ACTION-491? 14:41:24 ACTION-491 -- Josh Soref to investigate using intents for Contacts, perhaps Calendar and Thermometer -- due 2011-11-30 -- OPEN 14:41:24 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/491 14:41:39 fjh: it sounds the same 14:41:57 Josh_Soref: the general consensus is to do calendar after contacts 14:42:12 ACTION-491: Calendar happens after Contacts - because it's harder 14:42:12 ACTION-491 Investigate using intents for Contacts, perhaps Calendar and Thermometer notes added 14:42:32 ACTION-491: thermometer someone could throw up a demo intent 14:42:33 ACTION-491 Investigate using intents for Contacts, perhaps Calendar and Thermometer notes added 14:42:41 close ACTION-491 14:42:41 ACTION-491 Investigate using intents for Contacts, perhaps Calendar and Thermometer closed 14:43:22 fjh: Josh_Soref i thought you sent an example to the list about that 14:43:35 Josh_Soref: i think i talked it through in Shenzhen 14:44:01 fjh: should we be creating a thermometer API 14:44:12 josh_soref: no need for an actual spec for this one 14:44:17 Josh_Soref: there's a question of whether everything should have a w3c spec 14:44:27 ... this is one i think that can just be on web intents 14:44:27 ACTION-489? 14:44:27 ACTION-489 -- Robin Berjon to prepare Requirements, SysInfo, Messaging, Gallery for shelving (wait for text from Deepanshu for Reqs) -- due 2011-11-23 -- OPEN 14:44:31 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/489 14:44:33 ... .org 14:44:39 -Dzung_Tran 14:44:42 fjh: i think that the shelving was all done 14:44:48 AnssiK: i think i've done all of those 14:44:55 ACTION-489: shelving done 14:44:55 ACTION-489 Prepare Requirements, SysInfo, Messaging, Gallery for shelving (wait for text from Deepanshu for Reqs) notes added 14:45:00 ACTION-489 closed 14:45:00 ACTION-489 Prepare Requirements, SysInfo, Messaging, Gallery for shelving (wait for text from Deepanshu for Reqs) closed 14:45:26 fjh: i don't know what UPnP is up to 14:45:31 ... Cathy ? 14:45:36 ... do we want to put it on the Agenda 14:45:46 Cathy: i think it depends on whether Claes and richt would be there 14:45:53 fjh: Claes said he'd call in 14:46:01 +1 for UPnP discussion 14:46:01 jhawkins: i'd be interested in talking about it 14:46:11 fjh: i think we should slot it in the agenda 14:46:21 ACTION-516? 14:46:21 ACTION-516 -- Josh Soref to propose Security Considerations section on SSL for Intents sepc -- due 2012-03-27 -- OPEN 14:46:21 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/516 14:47:18 Josh_Soref: i should have sent an email then 14:47:28 ... it's basically a simple email 14:48:10 action: fjh to check with Josh Soref on actions next week 14:48:10 Created ACTION-543 - Check with Josh Soref on actions next week [on Frederick Hirsch - due 2012-06-20]. 14:48:32 ACTION-519? 14:48:32 ACTION-519 -- Claes Nilsson to add a proposal for hidden disposition. -- due 2012-03-28 -- OPEN 14:48:32 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/519 14:48:51 Josh_Soref: did we finish that off? 14:49:06 jhawkins: we have some ideas, we might be able to take this on 14:49:41 ACTION-591: jhawkins - we have some ideas on this topic 14:49:41 Sorry... adding notes to ACTION-591 failed, please let sysreq know about it 14:50:09 ACTION-519: member:jhawkins - we have some ideas on this topic 14:50:09 ACTION-519 Add a proposal for hidden disposition. notes added 14:50:37 ACTION-531? 14:50:37 ACTION-531 -- Robin Berjon to draft DAP charter version 3 -- due 2012-03-29 -- OPEN 14:50:37 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/531 14:50:41 ACTION-531 closed 14:50:41 ACTION-531 Draft DAP charter version 3 closed 14:51:26 Topic: AOB 14:51:32 q? 14:51:33 fjh: anything i forgot? 14:52:03 Josh_Soref: i'll send out minutes tomorrow 14:52:29 fjh: if you have topics for the F2F Agenda, please feel free to add them to the wiki 14:52:42 ... darobin and i will shuffle things around anyway 14:52:56 ... if you have questions about logistics, please let me know 14:53:07 ... please complete the questionaire attending or not 14:53:12 Adjourned 14:53:13 -Clarke 14:53:14 -jhawkins 14:53:15 -dcheng3 14:53:17 trackbot, end meeting 14:53:17 Zakim, list attendees 14:53:17 As of this point the attendees have been fjh, +1.310.310.aaaa, +49.173.537.aabb, dcheng3, lgombos, AnssiK, jhawkins, +46.1.07.15.aacc, +1.503.542.aadd, niklas, +1.289.261.aaee, 14:53:20 ... Josh_Soref, Clarke, +1.781.266.aaff, Cathy, Dzung_Tran 14:53:20 -Cathy 14:53:20 -AnssiK 14:53:20 -lgombos 14:53:22 -niklas 14:53:22 -fjh 14:53:25 RRSAgent, please draft minutes 14:53:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-minutes.html trackbot 14:53:26 RRSAgent, bye 14:53:26 I see 4 open action items saved in http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-actions.rdf : 14:53:26 ACTION: jhawkins to send URL for gallery chrome extension to the list [1] 14:53:26 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-irc#T14-20-23 14:53:26 ACTION: fjh to start CfC for FPWD of proximity [2] 14:53:26 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-irc#T14-29-30 14:53:26 ACTION: fjh to review Web Application Privacy Best Practices, complete ACTION-470, put out CfC to publish as Note [3] 14:53:26 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-irc#T14-32-02 14:53:26 ACTION: fjh to check with Josh Soref on actions next week [4] 14:53:26 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2012/06/13-dap-irc#T14-48-10