14:01:08 RRSAgent has joined #gld 14:01:08 logging to http://www.w3.org/2012/04/05-gld-irc 14:01:10 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:01:11 Zakim has joined #gld 14:01:12 Zakim, this will be GLD 14:01:13 ok, trackbot, I see T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM already started 14:01:13 Meeting: Government Linked Data Working Group Teleconference 14:01:13 Date: 05 April 2012 14:01:18 luisBermudez has joined #gld 14:01:19 + +33.4.93.00.aadd 14:01:44 PhilA2 has joined #gld 14:01:53 Mike_Pendleton has joined #gld 14:02:01 zakim, code? 14:02:03 + +1.540.898.aaee 14:02:07 +??P34 14:02:13 Zakim, me is ??p34 14:02:25 the conference code is 45394 (tel:+1.617.761.6200 sip:zakim@voip.w3.org), PhilA2 14:02:37 sorry, BartvanLeeuwen, I do not recognize a party named 'me' 14:02:44 + +3539149aaff 14:02:53 + +1.267.481.aagg 14:02:55 Zakim, aaff is me 14:03:13 Zakim, ??p34 is me 14:03:17 +mhausenblas; got it 14:03:24 trackbot, start telecon 14:03:26 RRSAgent, make logs world 14:03:28 Zakim, this will be GLD 14:03:29 Meeting: Government Linked Data Working Group Teleconference 14:03:29 +BartvanLeeuwen; got it 14:03:29 Date: 05 April 2012 14:03:35 ok, trackbot, I see T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM already started 14:03:57 +??P44 14:04:12 Zakim, ??P44 is me. 14:04:18 zakim, who's here? 14:04:31 +olyerickson; got it 14:04:38 zakim, who is on the call? 14:04:39 +??P52 14:04:43 On the phone I see +1.202.691.aaaa, George_Thomas, +49.721.aabb, +1.202.566.aacc, +33.4.93.00.aadd, +1.540.898.aaee, BartvanLeeuwen, mhausenblas, +1.267.481.aagg, olyerickson, 14:04:46 ... ??P52 14:04:47 zakim, ??p52 is me 14:05:10 On the phone I see +1.202.691.aaaa, George_Thomas, +49.721.aabb, +1.202.566.aacc, +33.4.93.00.aadd, +1.540.898.aaee, BartvanLeeuwen, mhausenblas, +1.267.481.aagg, olyerickson, 14:05:11 zakim, aabb is BenediktKaempgen 14:05:19 ... ??P52 14:05:21 691-aaaa is DanG 14:05:23 On IRC I see Mike_Pendleton, PhilA2, luisBermudez, Zakim, RRSAgent, gatemezi, DanG, olyerickson, BartvanLeeuwen, MacTed, George, mhausenblas, danbri, BenediktKaempgen, bhyland, 14:05:26 ... trackbot, sandro 14:05:29 aagg is me 14:05:32 +PhilA2; got it 14:05:48 zakim, aaaa is DanG 14:05:50 zakim, aaaa is danG 14:05:52 +BenediktKaempgen; got it 14:06:28 +DanG; got it 14:06:32 sorry, bhyland, I do not recognize a party named 'aaaa' 14:06:40 zakim, aacc is Mike_Pendleton 14:07:08 zakim, who is here? 14:07:10 Zakim, +33.4.93.00.aadd is me 14:07:14 +Mike_Pendleton; got it 14:07:30 tinagheen has joined #gld 14:07:42 On the phone I see DanG, George_Thomas, BenediktKaempgen, Mike_Pendleton, +33.4.93.00.aadd, +1.540.898.aaee, BartvanLeeuwen, mhausenblas, +1.267.481.aagg, olyerickson, PhilA2 14:07:49 +gatemezi; got it 14:08:03 Zakim, +33.4.93.00.aadd is gatemezi 14:08:07 Scribe: olyerickson 14:08:19 On IRC I see tinagheen, Mike_Pendleton, PhilA2, luisBermudez, Zakim, RRSAgent, gatemezi, DanG, olyerickson, BartvanLeeuwen, MacTed, George, mhausenblas, danbri, BenediktKaempgen, 14:08:23 ... bhyland, trackbot, sandro 14:08:39 zakim, who is here? 14:08:42 sorry, gatemezi, I do not recognize a party named '+33.4.93.00.aadd' 14:08:47 +[LC] 14:08:53 Zakim, [LC] is me 14:08:57 Agenda: http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/wiki/Meetings:Telecon20120405 14:09:06 On the phone I see DanG, George_Thomas, BenediktKaempgen, Mike_Pendleton, gatemezi, +1.540.898.aaee, BartvanLeeuwen, mhausenblas, +1.267.481.aagg, olyerickson, PhilA2, [LC] 14:09:16 Materials published; congrats and thanks to everyone esp Sandrp 14:09:21 +tinagheen; got it 14:09:24 s/Sandrp/Sandro/ 14:09:31 s/Sandrp/Sandro 14:09:43 On IRC I see tinagheen, Mike_Pendleton, PhilA2, luisBermudez, Zakim, RRSAgent, gatemezi, DanG, olyerickson, BartvanLeeuwen, MacTed, George, mhausenblas, danbri, BenediktKaempgen, 14:09:45 ... bhyland, trackbot, sandro 14:09:47 http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-dcat/ works 14:09:48 Comments from mhausenblas 14:09:55 + +91.80.67.84.aahh 14:10:11 Now that FPWD is out, move toward ISA (?) "alignment" 14:10:45 ... PhilA: core vocabs integrated next couple weeks 14:11:16 ... ISA specs NOT currently in published versions of FPWDs 14:11:17 Biplav has joined #gld 14:11:31 mhausenblas: Planning call req'd 14:11:38 PhilA2: makes sense 14:11:48 ... needs to send mhausenblas something before WWW 14:12:07 http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-people/ works 14:12:15 q? 14:12:27 agenda+ coordination between Prov group (Luc and Paul Groth) + Mhausenblas & ?? re: agent meets people vocab 14:12:28 Guess what http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-data-cube/ 14:12:51 And http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-org/ 14:13:24 bhyland: Skip to "Org" agenda item 14:13:29 http://www.w3.org/TR/gld-bp/ :-( 14:13:37 +1 bhyland to explain... 14:14:19 ... Weds during sweb coord meeting, paul groth mentioned multiple W3C groups with RPOV concerns 14:14:58 s/RPOV/PROV/ 14:15:03 Topic: PROV tie-ins 14:15:41 mhausenblas: What is the status of PROV? 14:15:52 q+ 14:16:08 bhyland: need to keep up with our liaison with PROV 14:16:25 ... current status of PROV, not that far ahead 14:16:37 ack PhilA 14:16:41 PhilA2: would like to be involved in that discussion 14:17:10 Paul Groth mentioned these references for our consideration: 14:17:11 [1] people: https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/gld/raw-file/default/people/index.html 14:17:11 [2] org: http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/gld/raw-file/default/org/index.html 14:17:11 [3] prov-dm: http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/prov/raw-file/default/model/prov-dm.html#component2 14:17:13 ... SPARQL 1.1 is about to bring up "prov" considerations 14:17:33 q? 14:17:44 q? 14:17:48 q+ 14:18:23 George: Org "speaks to" OPMV... 14:18:55 Topic: Last week's minutes 14:18:58 +1 14:19:07 +1 14:19:10 +1 14:19:13 +1 14:19:13 +1 14:19:40 q? 14:19:46 George: Sorry to miss "geo work" discussion last week 14:19:58 ... any further discussion/comments 14:20:10 closing loop on coordinating mhausenblas, phila2, luc and paul groth, see http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/CG/track/actions/8 14:20:12 q? 14:20:16 ack olyerickson 14:20:59 olyerickson: Regarding the provenance discussion... I'm trying to understand what the issue is? Was Paul concerned that there are lots of parallel efforts on provenance, or people, or what? 14:21:04 TOPIC: Wrap up from last week's GeoLinkData Initiative ... 14:21:34 annew has joined #gld 14:21:52 bhyland: explanation of PROV question 14:22:08 bhyland: AIUI, Paul in particular, they invented "agent" and it has a lot of people attributes. We're up to 4 different ways to capture people-related info just from W3C 14:22:12 ... up to 4 ways to describe people 14:22:21 ... need to coordinate 14:22:38 ... bhyland tasked with bringing together the various parties 14:22:53 ... is there common ground, or should there be separate paths 14:22:57 +Sandro 14:23:01 (Sorry I'm late) 14:23:08 ... can/should "people" be simpler 14:23:15 Someone said schema.org ? http://philarcher.org/diary/2012/danbri/ 14:23:50 ... example schema.org w.r.t simplicity 9and role in packaging/marketing) 14:24:30 Topic: What to do w.r.t. geo vocabulary 14:24:49 George: many esp govt would like to put a "stake in the ground" 14:24:54 To remind people who were present last week (and weren't), Boris gave a great talk on work on map4rdf, see http://oegdev.dia.fi.upm.es/projects/map4rdf/ 14:24:56 ... poll the group? 14:25:30 PhilA2: Trying to notice what is going on, while being concerned about strengthing this group 14:25:41 ... BUT we do have optional item 14:25:42 @bhyland --Thanks for the link 14:25:54 ... there is much well-done current work in this area 14:25:59 q+ 14:26:16 ... thinks, OGC's (??) job 14:26:24 ... yet people bring it to use 14:26:24 Per PhilA2's reference, see http://geovocab.org/doc/neogeo/ 14:26:42 +1 to PhilA 14:26:44 ack BartvanLeeuwen 14:26:49 ... GLD is in a position to consider, yet we have it as an opt. on our charter 14:27:06 BartvanLeeuwen: concern over amt of work reqd to get it done 14:27:18 ... should at least reference the relevant vocabs 14:27:30 q+ 14:27:34 ... shouldn't write our own recommendation 14:27:42 ... there are "smarter" people to do that 14:27:53 ... best practices should be able to point to other references 14:28:02 ref: Open Geospatial Consortium http://www.opengeospatial.org/ 14:28:03 ... but maybe not... 14:28:08 q+ 14:28:26 George: If there *is* energy, there is interest in the community 14:28:40 ... there's lots of innovation going on in this area 14:28:42 bhyland: 14:28:57 bhyland: BP doc focusing on what SHOULD be done 14:29:02 ... BP not about "how" 14:29:16 ... rec'd of vocabs is new ground for W3C 14:29:53 I'm the last person to object to FOAF! 14:29:55 ... GLD approach to rec'd vocabs is new 14:30:21 q+ 14:30:22 ... need to be careful to not go beyond out core expertise 14:30:26 ack bhyland 14:30:34 ack luisBermudez 14:31:09 luisBermudez: Geo vocab standard will be published soon 14:31:34 ... important to find way to integrate e.g. geoSPARQL, etc 14:32:12 luisBermudez: geoSPARQL will be publicly available in June (from OGC) 14:32:21 ack me 14:32:34 ... luisBermudez the problem: geoSPARQL not a publicly available standard (will be) 14:32:52 +q 14:33:00 PhilA2: GLD should look at it "a little later" in the year 14:33:14 ... FOAF is now under the wing of DC 14:33:17 q? 14:33:40 q+ to ask Phil in what sense one vocab can use another 14:33:41 @PhilA2 thanks for clarifying/reminding me re: ISA People & FOAF embrace 14:33:50 ... thought question: Will FOAF be around next year? 14:34:12 DanG, the reference was to Dan Brickley, co-parent of FOAF. 14:35:43 while we're on topic, can I draw attention to some other People vocab things from this week? 14:35:44 @george, what URL would you like me to add to agenda from HR14 proposal discussion? 14:35:46 see https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/opensocial-and-gadgets-spec 14:35:48 BenediktKaempgen: Talked to supervisor, tells us that that community has tried to consolidate, question of what GLD process will be for integrating in ???geo (neogeo?) 14:36:13 Thanks to sandro for the big push last night 14:36:13 +1 thanks to Sandro 14:36:18 opensocial is a tech for making social networks, and is linked to PortableContacts, a vcard-based addressbook format. opensocial people are wondering how to address new requirements for modelling organizations, scientific info etc. 14:36:24 s/???geo/neogeo 14:36:37 um 14:36:38 e.g .https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!topic/opensocial-and-gadgets-spec/g3NyGn-8Avs 14:36:49 is there an announcement that some of us are missing? 14:37:07 sandro: What does it mean for one vocab to "use" another 14:37:13 neogeo ~ http://nuts.geovocab.org/id/nuts0.html http://nuts.geovocab.org/ ? 14:38:15 PhilA2: Issue of alignment of e.g. foaf:Person with schema.org equivalent, etc 14:38:45 ... See PhilA2 blog post (today) 14:39:09 ... motivated PhilA2 to think foaf should be retired... 14:39:20 @LuisBermudez: could you know any triple store that have implemented part of geoSPARQL requirements? 14:39:44 sandro: can't recommend The Government to use vocab that can't be used in perpetuity 14:39:50 smotivated PhilA2 to think foaf should be retired.../motivated PhilA2 to think a day may come when foaf could be retired.../ 14:39:54 s/motivated PhilA2 to think foaf should be retired.../motivated PhilA2 to think a day may come when foaf could be retired.../ 14:40:12 My blog post http://philarcher.org/diary/2012/danbri/ 14:40:27 q? 14:40:33 queue= 14:40:57 PhilA2: There may a day in our community that some sacred cows should be retired … 14:41:26 q? 14:42:03 q+ 14:42:09 q+ 14:42:21 q+ to disagree with olyerickson 14:42:51 bhyland: It's a concept called "social responsibility" 14:43:14 ... when you publish "content" you are making a commitment or 'social contract' 14:43:35 ... for the foreseeable future 14:43:48 ... BP must educate/"warn" adopters 14:44:15 ... vocabs should be from authoritative sources that make commitment 14:44:24 zakim, who is speaking? 14:44:33 sandro: doesn't agree 14:44:35 bhyland, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: George_Thomas (5%), olyerickson (9%), Sandro (57%) 14:44:41 - +91.80.67.84.aahh 14:44:56 ... W3C makes a commitment to e.g. DCAT 14:45:21 q? 14:45:25 ack bhyland 14:45:25 ... details will change, there is a process and W3C stands behind it 14:45:28 ack sandro 14:45:28 sandro, you wanted to disagree with olyerickson 14:45:29 ack bhyland 14:46:23 olyerickson: You, Sandro, were right to disagree with my words 14:46:33 olyerickson: An organisation needs to know what it is adopting 14:46:35 Sandro: Gov'ts should be able to count on key vocabs, such as DCAT, in perpetuity. 14:46:53 ... e.g. the current version of DCAT, recognising that it may evolve 14:47:12 olyerickson: They need to recognise that by using a vocan they become part of that community 14:47:27 +1 olyerickson Yes, people adopting a tech become part of the stewardship community, when things work well. That's sustainable. 14:47:32 johnerickson: Gov't need to recognize their role as stewards of vocabs [and data sets] that they publish. 14:47:34 ... they can't wine about the fact that current browsers don't working with HTML1 any more 14:47:40 q? 14:47:53 we are in fervent agreement 14:47:59 zakim, who is on the call? 14:47:59 On the phone I see DanG, George_Thomas, BenediktKaempgen, Mike_Pendleton, gatemezi, +1.540.898.aaee, BartvanLeeuwen, mhausenblas, +1.267.481.aagg, olyerickson, PhilA2, tinagheen, 14:48:02 ... Sandro 14:48:07 (if not using the most articulate language) 14:48:22 sandro: brings us back to foaf 14:48:59 Michael: I have to apologise, need to run now (need to do some fire-fighting, unforeseen incident that came up …) 14:49:02 ... might have a situation where W3C doesn't control the namespace, dereferencing, etc 14:49:16 ... need to ensure namespace is part of the community stewardship 14:49:27 q+ 14:49:30 ... community needs to have control 14:49:43 PhilA2: agrees with sandro 14:50:24 sandro: We should only use namespaces for which we have en enforcable commitment to respect some legitimate stewardship/community process 14:50:29 ... "DanBri under a bus" problem has created adoption problems for foaf in the past, seems to be resolved now 14:51:15 ... key issue is foaf:Person and schema.org allow imaginary people 14:51:29 q- 14:51:37 Topic: HR14 14:51:46 ... httpRange-14 14:51:54 (the dictionaries definition of 'person' allows imaginary people too) (imagine a dictionary where each term had 'except for pretend X's...'?) 14:51:55 -mhausenblas 14:52:13 George: any views/thoughts? 14:52:18 btw ... if GLD have expectations re what long-term preservation commitments you'd like from schema.org, do please write them down and pass them along 14:52:19 sandro: (laughs) 14:52:26 ... gave up in 2003 14:52:55 ... proposed 303 but has given up 14:53:44 I was reading also this post of Jenni http://www.jenitennison.com/blog/node/168 14:53:49 olyerickson: I've been watching in the way you watch a NASCAR race expecting a crash. A real concern is implementation efficiency 14:54:22 ... there are existential issues but the practical ones are perhaps more key - redirection, caching and so on 14:54:45 ... there are some proposals around 3xx and 200/207 14:55:02 ... I really haven't seen a convergence 14:55:15 Current state: Open for proposals 14:55:16 George: It's open for proposals on possible conversion 14:55:22 q+ 14:56:31 q+ 14:56:32 olyerickson: "I'm not interested from a fascinated academic perspective, rather a grouchy implementer." 14:56:49 ;) 14:57:47 bhyland: jenit is soliciting proposals 14:58:01 ... trying to do it sensibly 14:58:10 ... reaching out to stakeholders 14:58:31 ... jenit trying to get something done 14:58:47 ... put something in writing, not "pissy emails" 14:59:11 not(sandro) : interested in concern over performance 14:59:32 ... are there designs that deliver performance which doesn't violate semantics of 303 14:59:54 q? 14:59:55 how to engage: write it up, submit 15:00:11 ack bhyland 15:00:13 Topic: Wrap-up 15:00:59 George: Interesting how when GLD people get interested and start to engage, their Inboxes get flooded 15:01:25 Topic: Agenda items for next week 15:01:32 (none offered) 15:01:42 Adjorned 15:01:46 Thanks George and olyerickson.. 15:01:48 'Have a great day' 15:01:52 thx and bye ! 15:01:52 Thanks 15:01:55 Bye 15:02:01 PhilA2 has left #gld 15:02:07 -tinagheen 15:02:13 -DanG 15:02:17 -Mike_Pendleton 15:02:19 - +1.540.898.aaee 15:02:21 - +1.267.481.aagg 15:02:29 -PhilA2 15:02:33 RRSAgent, set logs world-visible 15:02:37 -Sandro 15:02:41 -BenediktKaempgen 15:02:46 RRSAgent, generate minutes 15:02:46 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2012/04/05-gld-minutes.html olyerickson 15:03:01 -BartvanLeeuwen 15:03:13 -gatemezi 15:05:30 http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/meeting/2012-04-05 15:10:47 -George_Thomas 15:10:48 -olyerickson 15:10:50 T&S_GLDWG()10:00AM has ended 15:10:52 Attendees were +1.202.691.aaaa, George_Thomas, +49.721.aabb, +1.202.566.aacc, +1.540.898.aaee, +3539149aaff, +1.267.481.aagg, mhausenblas, BartvanLeeuwen, olyerickson, PhilA2, 15:10:56 ... BenediktKaempgen, DanG, Mike_Pendleton, gatemezi, tinagheen, +91.80.67.84.aahh, Sandro 15:29:16 olyerickson has left #gld