Closed Issues

Apply the following changes to selected issues:

There are 634 closed issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-1 (edit)
define-resource
CLOSED Definition for concept 'Resource' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-2 (edit)
define-process-execution
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Process execution' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-3 (edit)
define-recipe-link
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Recipe link' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-4 (edit)
define-agent
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Agent' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-5 (edit)
define-role
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Role' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-6 (edit)
define-location
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Location' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-7 (edit)
define-derivation
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Derivation' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-8 (edit)
define-generation
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Generation' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-9 (edit)
definition-use
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Use' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-10 (edit)
define-ordering-of-processes
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Ordering of processes' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-11 (edit)
definition-version
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Version' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-12 (edit)
define-participation
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Participation' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-13 (edit)
define-control
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Control' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-14 (edit)
define-provenance-container
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Provenance container' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-15 (edit)
define-views-or-account
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Views or accounts' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-16 (edit)
define-time
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Time' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-17 (edit)
define-collections
CLOSED Definition for Concept 'Collections' 2011-05-20 0
ISSUE-18 (edit) CLOSED Someone please sign up to scribe next week. 2011-05-26 0
ISSUE-19 (edit)
definition-invariant-view-of-thing
CLOSED Definition for concept 'Invariant View or Perspective on a Thing' 2011-06-07 0
ISSUE-20 (edit)
GK
CLOSED Objections of definition? 2011-06-09 0
ISSUE-21 (edit) CLOSED Group to finish up process execution. 2011-06-09 0
ISSUE-22 (edit) CLOSED We lose which entity was used to generate which entity. 2011-07-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-23 (edit)
use-taxonomy
CLOSED Create definition of involve to complement Use 2011-07-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-24 (edit)
properties-of-generated-entity-state
CLOSED P and things used by P determine values of some of X's invariant properties (less strict) 2011-07-06 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-25 (edit) CLOSED Semantics group to incorporate ""derivation" or "partially determined by" relationship could be subjective or context-dependent assertion, not an objectively true or false statement." Derivation issue # 2 2011-07-06 0
ISSUE-26 (edit)
uses and generates questions
CLOSED How can one figure out the provenance of a given entity? 2011-07-07 0
ISSUE-27 (edit) CLOSED Consider ordering of event in model and semantics 2011-07-07 0
ISSUE-28 (edit) CLOSED We need a mechanism to assert two entity states refer to the same entity 2011-07-07 0
ISSUE-29 (edit)
mutual-iVP-of
CLOSED can two bobs be mutually "IVP of" each other 2011-07-11 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-30 (edit)
name-for-bob
CLOSED What name do we use for the BOB construct? 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-31 (edit)
standard-names
CLOSED what names do we use to refer to the language, ontology, and access/query methods 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-32 (edit) CLOSED Bob definition 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-33 (edit) CLOSED Section 3.1 and Section 3.2: example of IVPof 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-34 (edit) CLOSED Section 4: definition of "Agent" 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-35 (edit) CLOSED Section 4: How one would know that two BOBs are characterizations of the same entity? 2011-07-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-36 (edit) CLOSED Section 3.2: Accessing the provenance of HTML documents 2011-07-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-37 (edit) CLOSED Section 3.3 and Section 3.4: on provenance information specified by third-parties 2011-07-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-38 (edit) CLOSED Section 3.4: Third party services are SPARQL endpoints 2011-07-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-39 (edit)
generation-identifiable-activity
CLOSED Generation should be defined as an identifable activity 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-40 (edit)
recommended-roles
CLOSED Roles should not be SHOULD and not MUST 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-41 (edit)
distinct-roles
CLOSED Distinct roles should be SHOULD and not MUST 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-42 (edit)
derivation-agent
CLOSED Derivation should specifically mention agent in its definition 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-43 (edit)
derivation-time
CLOSED Deriviation should have associated time 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-44 (edit)
shortcuts
CLOSED Introduce widely used provenance concepts as shortcuts in the model 2011-07-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-45 (edit) CLOSED isDerivedFrom and IVPof are transitive. 2011-07-24 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-46 (edit)
where-is-D-in-provenance
CLOSED Where do I find document D in provenance 2011-07-25 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-47 (edit)
third-party-provenance
CLOSED How to obtain provenance from a third party known by the user 2011-07-25 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-48 (edit)
Provenance Concept: Revision
CLOSED Revision should be a class and not a property 2011-07-27 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-49 (edit)
Participation
CLOSED Suggested definition for Participation 2011-07-27 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-50 (edit)
Ordering of Process
CLOSED Defintion for Ordering of Process 2011-07-27 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-51 (edit)
asserter-def
CLOSED Asserter needs to be defined with respect to a provenance container/account 2011-07-28 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-52 (edit)
provenance-source-equal-treatment
CLOSED why handling provider and third parties differently? 2011-07-28 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-53 (edit)
sparql-query-is-overkill
CLOSED can't we have a lighter method to retrieve provenance-uri, given a document uri? 2011-07-28 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-54 (edit)
which-provenance-is-expected-to-be-retrieved?
CLOSED What is it we expect to obtain when we say "retrieving the provenance of something" 2011-07-29 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-55 (edit)
are-provenance-uris-needed
CLOSED Are provenance URIs really needed 2011-07-29 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-56 (edit)
derivation-definition-does-not-imply-transitivity
CLOSED Derivation as defined is not transitive 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-57 (edit)
comment-on-ivp-of
CLOSED comment on ivp of 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-58 (edit)
time-iso8601
CLOSED is reference to iso8601 appropriate? 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-59 (edit)
generation-definition
CLOSED on generation 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-60 (edit) CLOSED comments on bob 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-61 (edit)
is-revision-necessary
CLOSED is revision necessary? 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-62 (edit)
about-prov-language
CLOSED about provenance language 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-63 (edit)
about the example
CLOSED about the example 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-64 (edit)
definition-use
CLOSED definition of use 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-65 (edit)
domain-specific-info
CLOSED How is domain specific data combined with the generic model 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-66 (edit)
is-execution-a-bob
CLOSED Why is process execution not defined as a characterised entity? 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-67 (edit)
single-execution
CLOSED Why is there a difference in what is represented by one vs multiple executions? 2011-07-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-68 (edit)
http-link-domain
CLOSED Domain of HTTP links with rel=provenance 2011-08-02 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-69 (edit)
Process Execution
CLOSED Process execution occurs over a "continuous time interval"? 2011-08-04 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-70 (edit)
provenance-term
CLOSED PAQ document uses inconsistent terminology for "provenance" 2011-08-04 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-71 (edit)
Conceptual Model draft
CLOSED Section 3.2 of Conceptual Model draft (Content and Editing) 2011-08-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-72 (edit)
DGarijo
CLOSED Uses should be renamed as used 2011-08-11 Ontology 0
ISSUE-73 (edit) CLOSED Use "anchor" context URI instead of introducing a "target" relationship in HTTP 2011-08-11 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-74 (edit) CLOSED Consider renaming target-uri as context-uri to be consistent with RFC 5988 2011-08-11 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-75 (edit)
provenance-service-and-provenance-uri
CLOSED What do we do when we get both provenance service and provenance-uri? 2011-08-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-76 (edit)
xml-examples
CLOSED Shouldn't we have proper examples in XML and not RDF/XML 2011-08-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-77 (edit)
paq-terminology
CLOSED terminology issues 2011-08-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-78 (edit)
contexts-and-provenance-uris
CLOSED multiple contexts and provenance-uris 2011-08-22 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-79 (edit)
provenance-uri-contract
CLOSED what is the contract associated with provenance-uris 2011-08-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-80 (edit)
about-provenance-template
CLOSED Query about provenance template 2011-08-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-81 (edit)
identity-clash-scope
CLOSED In a given scope, are entities with same identifier but different attributes legal? 2011-08-24 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-82 (edit)
pidm-event
CLOSED Should we introduce a notion of event in the data model? 2011-08-25 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-83 (edit) CLOSED Express inverse relationships in Provenance Model as well as ontology 2011-08-25 Ontology 0
ISSUE-84 (edit)
namespace-for-properties
CLOSED What should namespace for properties be? 2011-08-26 Ontology 0
ISSUE-85 (edit)
What-is-Entity
CLOSED Definition of Entity is confusing, maybe over-complex 2011-09-01 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-86 (edit)
High-level-overview
CLOSED The conceptual model needs a high level overview 2011-09-01 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-87 (edit)
Model-concepts-formalism
CLOSED Formalism used is not explained, not applied to concepts 2011-09-01 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-88 (edit)
Provenance-container
CLOSED Provenance container seems an unnecessary concept 2011-09-01 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-89 (edit)
what-entity-attributes
CLOSED How do we find the attributes of an entity? 2011-09-02 Ontology 0
ISSUE-90 (edit)
namespace-in-ontology
CLOSED Namespace used in ontology 2011-09-06 Ontology 0
ISSUE-91 (edit)
what-to-define-for-location
CLOSED what should we define under the heading 'location' 2011-09-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-92 (edit)
remove-individuals
CLOSED Remove example individual from ontology 2011-09-07 Ontology 0
ISSUE-93 (edit) CLOSED wasDerivedFrom is an owl sub-propety of dependedOn 2011-09-09 Ontology 0
ISSUE-94 (edit)
pe-attributes
CLOSED are process executions characterized in the same way as entities? 2011-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-95 (edit)
Recipes as Classes
CLOSED Recipes as classes? 2011-09-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-96 (edit)
entities and roles
CLOSED Relating Roled Entities with non-Roled Entities 2011-09-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-97 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED define prov:wasComplementOf 2011-09-17 Ontology 0
ISSUE-98 (edit) CLOSED add "generated" to conceptual and OWL models 2011-09-19 Ontology 0
ISSUE-99 (edit) CLOSED prov:eventuallyUsed - a transitive version of prov:used. 2011-09-19 Ontology 0
ISSUE-100 (edit)
Entity definition
CLOSED Section 5.2.1 Entity 2011-09-26 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-101 (edit)
Conceptual Model
CLOSED Section 5.2.2 ProcessExecution (conceptual model document review) 2011-09-26 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-102 (edit)
hadRecipe
CLOSED Ontology is missing recipe link 2011-09-28 Ontology 0
ISSUE-103 (edit)
qualifiers-and-roles
CLOSED Qualifiers and roles in the ontology 2011-09-28 Ontology 0
ISSUE-104 (edit)
time-class
CLOSED How to relate start/end time to PE, use, generation, etc 2011-09-28 Ontology 0
ISSUE-105 (edit) CLOSED 5.3.1 Generation (current version of the conceptual model document) 2011-09-28 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-106 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Accounts are missing in the document 2011-09-28 Ontology 0
ISSUE-107 (edit)
interoperability-rdf-serialization
CLOSED is example provenance serialization in RDF inter-operable? 2011-09-28 Ontology 0
ISSUE-108 (edit)
transitivity-of-dependedOn
CLOSED derivations must take into account characterization intervals 2011-10-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-109 (edit)
Recipe-class
CLOSED Stian update hadRecipe to have range prov:Recipe - not defined any further 2011-10-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-110 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Renaming prov:Role -> prov:EntityInRole 2011-10-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-111 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Create properties prov:hadLocation and prov:assumedBy 2011-10-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-112 (edit)
prov-in-get
CLOSED provenance information in GET message 2011-10-04 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-113 (edit) CLOSED wasScheduledAfter is transitive 2011-10-04 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-114 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED is prov:wasDerivedFrom rdfs:subPropertyOf prov:dependedOn? 2011-10-04 Ontology 0
ISSUE-115 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED prov:preceded should be replaced with prov:followed 2011-10-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-116 (edit)
general-comments-on-ontology
CLOSED General Comments On Ontology 2011-10-06 Ontology 0
ISSUE-117 (edit)
general-comments-on-formal-model-document
CLOSED General Comments On Ontology Document 2011-10-06 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-118 (edit)
shortcuts-in-provont
CLOSED Ontology Does not model Shortcuts 2011-10-06 Ontology 0
ISSUE-119 (edit)
vanilla-rdf
CLOSED How does vanilla RDF work with PROV Ontology 2011-10-06 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-120 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED Renaming Formal Model (The OWL) 2011-10-06 Ontology 0
ISSUE-121 (edit) CLOSED Constraint on PE (PROV-DM and PROV-OM) 2011-10-09 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-122 (edit) CLOSED Constraint on wasGeneratedBy (PROV-DM and PROV-OM) 2011-10-09 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-123 (edit)
hadParticipant-subprops
CLOSED prov:used and prov:wasControlledby should be subproperties of prov:hadParticipant 2011-10-11 Ontology 0
ISSUE-124 (edit) CLOSED Constraints on Used Relation (PROV-DM and PROV-OM) 2011-10-11 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-125 (edit) CLOSED derivation-attributes constraint (PROV-DM and PROV-O) 2011-10-15 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-126 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.3.2 "Process Execution Independent Derivation Expression." 2011-10-16 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-127 (edit) CLOSED Constraint id= participation (PROV DM and PROV ontology) 2011-10-17 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-128 (edit)
Location-Example
CLOSED Location example uses a filesystem and not a geographical location 2011-10-20 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-129 (edit)
YolandaGil
CLOSED Definitions of "Activity"/"Event"/"ProcessExecution" should be more crisp and differentiable in Provenance Data Model (PROV-DM) Draft 2011-10-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-130 (edit)
YolandaGil
CLOSED Definition and examples of "agent" should be clarified in Provenance Data Model (PROV-DM) Draft 2011-10-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-131 (edit)
YolandaGil
CLOSED Simplify the references to "recipe" in Provenance Data Model (PROV-DM) Draft 2011-10-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-132 (edit)
YolandaGil
CLOSED Improve the examples to make them more intuitive and of broader appeal in Provenance Data Model (PROV-DM) Draft 2011-10-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-133 (edit)
YolandaGil
CLOSED Producing and delivering resources as part of provenance in Provenance Data Model (PROV-DM) Draft 2011-10-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-134 (edit) CLOSED Non-Human Agent vs. Human Agent 2011-10-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-135 (edit)
collection-names
CLOSED Collection relations have confusing names 2011-10-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-136 (edit)
collection-functional
CLOSED Collection not stated as functional 2011-10-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-137 (edit)
collection-isolation
CLOSED Collection assertions does not guarantee isolation 2011-10-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-138 (edit)
collection-collision
CLOSED Collection does not describe multiple additions/replacements 2011-10-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-139 (edit)
collection-emptylist
CLOSED Collections don't provide a way to specify empty lists 2011-10-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-140 (edit)
entity-qualifier-syntax
CLOSED ASN uses different syntax for entity attributes and qualifiers 2011-11-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-141 (edit)
agent-attributes
CLOSED Is there a way to associate attributes (e.g. a name) with an agent in ASN? 2011-11-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-142 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED Can roles only be Literals? 2011-11-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-143 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED Qualifiers - why does order matter? 2011-11-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-144 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED how is "reserved attribute 'type'" related to rdf:type? 2011-11-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-145 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED qualified identifiers may not work well with named graphs 2011-11-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-146 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED wasAttributeTo 2011-11-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-147 (edit)
Replace recipe
CLOSED Change the name of "Recipe" 2011-11-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-148 (edit)
WasScheduledAfter
CLOSED wasScheduledAfter definition is difficult to understand 2011-11-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-149 (edit)
revision-asserter
CLOSED Why does revision record include an asserter? 2011-11-11 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-150 (edit) CLOSED question on formal semantics of role in wasGeneratedBy relation 2011-11-14 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-151 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Rename wasQuoteOf to wasQuotedFrom 2011-11-16 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-152 (edit)
QualifiedInvolvement
CLOSED will the QualifiedInvolvement approach work for other relations? 2011-11-18 Ontology 0
ISSUE-153 (edit)
complementarity
CLOSED Complementarity description differs from model definition 2011-11-18 Primer 0
ISSUE-154 (edit)
RDF-provenance-service-uri
CLOSED Include provenance-service-uri for RDF resources 2011-11-19 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-155 (edit)
prov-o-pre-fpwd
CLOSED general comments on prov-o document 2011-11-21 Ontology 0
ISSUE-156 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED information flow ordering record - no temporal constraints? 2011-11-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-157 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED wasInformedBy's non-transitivity 2011-11-21 Ontology 0
ISSUE-158 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Cite temporal ordering constraint 2011-11-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-159 (edit)
Tlebo
CLOSED note on how PROV-O inteprets DM's "type" and "subtype" 2011-11-21 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-160 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Redundant terminology in new wasDerivedFrom classification scheme 2011-11-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-161 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Quotation: quoting agent should be done with Accounts 2011-11-22 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-162 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Entities can only be web resources? 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-163 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED What does provenance information describe? 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-164 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED pre-determined versus determined 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-165 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Enforcing non-contradictory provenance. 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-166 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Sufficient _what_? 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-167 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED What is a "normal web resource"? 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-169 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Motivating provenance services in PAQ 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-170 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Resources are "represented", not "presented" 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-171 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED HTTP in RDF 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-172 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED purpose of prov:hasAnchor 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-173 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED representations versus formats 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-174 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Replace http://example.info with http://example.{com,org} 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-175 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED 4.3 Provenance service discovery 2011-11-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-176 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED wasInformedBy's non-transitivity example is confusing 2011-12-02 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-177 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED wasStartedBy's name is overloaded? 2011-12-02 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-178 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED wasStartedBy constraint between started and generated entity 2011-12-02 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-179 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED defaults to prov:steps="n" causes issue in PROV-O 2011-12-02 Ontology 0
ISSUE-180 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED defaults to prov:steps="n" causes issue in PROV-O 2011-12-02 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-181 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED include reference to SPARQL service description 2011-12-02 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-182 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED stronger name for "wasAssociatedWith" 2011-12-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-183 (edit)
prov-dm-identifiers
CLOSED identifiers in prov-dm 2011-12-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-184 (edit) CLOSED Section 2.1.2 (PROV-DM version as on Nov 28th) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-185 (edit) CLOSED Section 3 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-186 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.2.1 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-187 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.2.2 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-188 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.2.3 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-189 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.2.4 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-190 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.1.1 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-191 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.1.2 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-192 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.2.1 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-193 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.2.2 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-194 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.3.1 and Section 5.3.3.2 (PROV-DM as on Nov 28) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-195 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.3.3 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-196 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.3.4 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-197 (edit) CLOSED Section 5.4.1 and Section 5.4.2 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-198 (edit) CLOSED Section 6.1 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-199 (edit) CLOSED Section 6.2 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-200 (edit) CLOSED Section 6.3 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-201 (edit) CLOSED Section 8 (PROV-DM as on Dec 5) 2011-12-07 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-202 (edit)
PROV-AQ-coverage-summary
CLOSED PROV-AQ give brief map of contents in introduction 2011-12-09 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-203 (edit) CLOSED Proposal to amend definition and usage of Plan in PROV-DM 2011-12-15 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-204 (edit)
end-of-entity
CLOSED What marks the end of an entity? 2011-12-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-205 (edit)
optional-activity-in-generation-record
CLOSED optional activity in generation record 2011-12-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-206 (edit)
agent-asserted-not-inferred
CLOSED agents should not be inferred, and wasAssociatedWith should also work with entities 2011-12-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-207 (edit)
start and end records
CLOSED start and end records 2011-12-21 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-208 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED "5.4.2 Record Container" is misleading 2012-01-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-209 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED broken anchor 2012-01-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-210 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED 7.1 PROV-DM Interpretation diagram and interpretation definitions disorderly 2012-01-05 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-211 (edit)
Incremental-discovery-description
CLOSED Possible revision to description of incremental discovery 2012-01-09 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-212 (edit)
three-vs-two-levels
CLOSED Shold we distinguish between things, entities and entity records in the semantics or just have entities and entity records 2012-01-12 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-213 (edit)
prov-sem-events
CLOSED Alignment of events in PROV-DM vs PROV-SEM 2012-01-12 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-214 (edit)
prov-sem-event-activities
CLOSED PROV-SEM: Linking events to activities 2012-01-12 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-215 (edit)
ProvenanceOfW3CReport
CLOSED An example to discuss identifiers 2012-01-13 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-216 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED qualified wasAttributedTo? 2012-01-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-217 (edit)
account-asserter
CLOSED What is the asserter of an account? 2012-01-16 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-218 (edit) CLOSED Clarification on the transitivity of Traceability Record 2012-01-16 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-219 (edit)
prov:label
CLOSED label attribute is required in PROV 2012-01-17 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-220 (edit)
remove-summary
CLOSED Remove wasSummaryOf relation 2012-01-17 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-221 (edit)
constraint-was-associated-with
CLOSED What are the constraints for wasAssociatedWith and actedOnBehalfOf? 2012-01-17 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-222 (edit)
used-objectproperty
CLOSED Datatype property for used? 2012-01-18 Best Practice Cookbook 0
ISSUE-223 (edit)
definition-of-entity
CLOSED What is the definition of entity 2012-01-19 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-224 (edit)
unified-prov-namespace
CLOSED Can we use a single namespace for the PROV family of specs? 2012-01-19 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-225 (edit)
objects-in-universe-of-discourse
CLOSED What are the objects in the universe of discourse? 2012-01-19 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-226 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED domain of the qualifiedDelegation property? 2012-01-20 Ontology 0
ISSUE-227 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Diagrams are not consistent in prov-o html 2012-01-20 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-228 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Prov-o & prov DM alignement 2012-01-20 Ontology 0
ISSUE-229 (edit)
Refactor-and-sub-edit
CLOSED Document would benefit from refactoring and editing 2012-01-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-230 (edit)
Name-scoping
CLOSED Name scoping in DM is wrong concept 2012-01-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-231 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Remove owl:Time from prov-o 2012-02-02 Ontology 0
ISSUE-232 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED activity start/end: direct time upgrades to instantaneous events 2012-02-03 Best Practice Cookbook 0
ISSUE-233 (edit)
paq-dm-and-accounts?
CLOSED If not in DM, should there be some form of account support in the paq? 2012-02-05 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-234 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED id identifies entity, not the record 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-235 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED add MAY to namespace defining "schema" 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-236 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED rendered provenance is a thing in the world 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-237 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Rename Relation to Involvement 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-238 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED order relation sections to suit a natural traversal of the Relation table 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-239 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED is wasGeneratedBy(e) meaningful? 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-240 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED highlight optionals in wasGeneratedBy([id],e,a,[t],[attrs]) 2012-02-06 prov-n 0
ISSUE-241 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED remove ex:order=2 in generation example 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-242 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED generated twice? 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-243 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED how to interpret ASN assertions with incomplete arity? 2012-02-06 prov-n 0
ISSUE-244 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED wasGeneratedBy(x,a,attrs,t) transposed arguments 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-245 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED entity was used -> __started__ to be used 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-246 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED add plan example: web page tutorial 2012-02-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-247 (edit) CLOSED Regarding Collections in prov-dm 2012-02-08 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-248 (edit)
string-as-entity
CLOSED How to model strings? 2012-02-09 Ontology 0
ISSUE-249 (edit)
two-derivations
CLOSED Why do we have 3 derivations? 2012-02-09 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-250 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED respond to Eric's comments 2012-02-10 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-251 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED put "location" attribute into prov: prefix 2012-02-14 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-252 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Examples for prescribed prov attributes location and time 2012-02-14 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-253 (edit) CLOSED misc issues with the ontology 2012-02-16 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-254 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED rename QualifiedInvolement to Involvement 2012-02-20 Ontology 0
ISSUE-255 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED rename ALL hadQualifiedXXX to simply prov:qualified 2012-02-20 Ontology 0
ISSUE-256 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED change namespace of prov-o 2012-02-20 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-257 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED rename "Account"/"Bundle"/"AccountEntity" to "Provenance" 2012-02-22 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-258 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED consolidate Association / Responsibility / Affiliation 2012-02-22 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-259 (edit) CLOSED hadTemporalExtent domain and range 2012-02-22 Ontology 0
ISSUE-260 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED In Note section: cite prov:Provenance as better practice to annotate assertions. 2012-02-22 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-261 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED alternateOf is not owl:sameAs (rephrase definition) 2012-02-22 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-262 (edit)
qualifier-property
CLOSED entity used entity? 2012-02-22 Ontology 0
ISSUE-263 (edit)
implicit-subject-problem
CLOSED Implicit subject in Involvement causes mis-alignment 2012-02-23 Ontology 0
ISSUE-264 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED citing an Involvement and not a more specific Involvement. 2012-02-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-265 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED RL, why? 2012-02-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-266 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED RL, why? 2012-02-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-267 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED annotate all subproperty axioms to justify them 2012-02-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-268 (edit)
two-level-ontology
CLOSED Two Level Ontology? 2012-02-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-269 (edit) CLOSED involved property need to be renamed and its sup-properties need to be structured in a better manner 2012-02-26 Ontology 0
ISSUE-270 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED automate HTML for OWL constructs 2012-02-27 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-271 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV examples collection 2012-02-28 0
ISSUE-272 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED DUPLICATE: DO NOT USE. PROV examples collection 2012-02-28 0
ISSUE-273 (edit)
name-for-asn
CLOSED what name for the provenance notation 2012-02-28 prov-n 0
ISSUE-274 (edit)
wd4-feedback
CLOSED feedback on WD4 2012-02-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-275 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Not all prov:Bundles are sd:NamedGraphs 2012-02-29 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-277 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Supporting property chains 2012-03-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-278 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Quotation does not follow hierarchy of wasQuotedFrom 2012-03-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-279 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Model subclasses of Derivation 2012-03-04 Ontology 0
ISSUE-280 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED {started,ended,used,wasGenerated}At <-> prov:qualified [ prov:atTime ] pattern 2012-03-04 Ontology 0
ISSUE-281 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED prov-o namspaces are not dereferencable 2012-03-04 Ontology 0
ISSUE-282 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED no RDF/XML in PROV-O HTML; use Turtle 2012-03-04 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-283 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Account, Note, Plan and Location subclasses of Entity? 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-288 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED ProvRDF issues for Usage 2012-03-05 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-290 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED duplicate wasStartedBy 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-291 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Entity owl:disjointWith Activity 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-292 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Responsibility mapping [ a EntityInvolvement, ActivityInvolvement ] ? 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-293 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED "subordinate and responsible" agents DM vs ASN 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-294 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Derivation mapping needs to be updated 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-295 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED hasAnnotation [ a prov:Note ] 2012-03-05 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-296 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED prov:Location rdfs:subClassOf wgs:SpatialThing ? 2012-03-05 Best Practice Cookbook 0
ISSUE-297 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED ProvenanceFormalModel.html#wascheduledafter 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-298 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED ProvRDF#Revision issues 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-299 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED ProvRDF#Attribution issues 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-300 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED Quote vs Quotation (Involvement versus Activity) 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-301 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED ProvRDF#Collections issues 2012-03-05 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-302 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (1/6) Paolo 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-303 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (2/6) Paul 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-304 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (3/6) Simon 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-305 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (4/6) Jun 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-306 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (5/6) Luc 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-307 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED PROV-O OWL review (6/6) StephenC 2012-03-05 Ontology 0
ISSUE-308 (edit)
prov-o-w3c-style
CLOSED PROV-O HTML must conform to W3C Style 2012-03-08 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-309 (edit)
TLebo
CLOSED using owltime:before on prov:InstantaneousEvents pattern 2012-03-09 Best Practice Cookbook 0
ISSUE-310 (edit)
map-dmwd4-provrdf
CLOSED sync dm wd4 with provrdf page 2012-03-09 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-311 (edit)
clarify-optionals
CLOSED Clarify optional arguments in DM 2012-03-13 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-312 (edit)
TLEBO
CLOSED acknowledge developers of tools used to create PROV-O HTML 2012-03-14 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-313 (edit)
TLEBO
CLOSED organization of PROV-O classes/properties 2012-03-14 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-314 (edit)
TLEBO
CLOSED inconsistent comment location in PROV-O HTML cross referencing 2012-03-14 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-316 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Typo on prov:Trace 2012-03-14 Ontology 0
ISSUE-317 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED the domain of hadRole includes Derivation 2012-03-14 Ontology 0
ISSUE-318 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Collections missing 2012-03-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-319 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Domain of hasAnnotation 2012-03-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-320 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Change the name of prov:Quotation 2012-03-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-321 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Instances of involvements can be expressed without a subclass. 2012-03-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-322 (edit)
dmwd4-provrdf-sync
CLOSED sync ProvRDF to DM WD4 2012-03-15 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-323 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Update text in 2.1.1.2 2012-03-16 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-324 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Leave prov:Account out of the initial release of provo.html 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-325 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Update missing properties in the current prov-o.html structure 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-326 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Update temporal properties in the current prov-o.html structure 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-327 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED prov:Note as a core term in prov-o.html 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-328 (edit)
jhao
CLOSED prov:wasStartedBy and prov:wasEndedBy as the core provenance terms 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-329 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED prov:wasStartedByActivity sub-property of prov:wasInformedBy? 2012-03-16 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-330 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Sanity check of the current prov-o.html structure 2012-03-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-331 (edit)
review-dm-wd5
CLOSED issue to collect feedback on prov-dm wd5 2012-03-29 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-332 (edit)
review-prov-n-wd5
CLOSED issue to collect feedback on prov-n wd5 2012-03-29 prov-n 0
ISSUE-333 (edit)
review-prov-dm-constraints-wd5
CLOSED issue to collect feedback on prov-dm-constraints wd5 2012-03-29 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-334 (edit)
define-qualification-pattern
CLOSED Qualification Pattern was used, used in bold font in its first occurrence, but never defined. 2012-04-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-335 (edit)
provo-html-code-style
CLOSED use <code> and <a href="#Entity> consistently. 2012-04-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-336 (edit)
provo-2WD-feedback
CLOSED Incorporate WG feedback into PROV-O 2WD 2012-04-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-337 (edit)
agent-and-entity
CLOSED agent should not be a subclass of entity 2012-04-02 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-338 (edit) CLOSED explain prov:agent vs. prov:hadPlan naming convention 2012-04-09 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-339 (edit)
dgarijo
CLOSED Domain of "activity" property 2012-04-09 Ontology 0
ISSUE-340 (edit)
start-by-activity-is-comm
CLOSED Start by Activity is Communication; drop it. 2012-04-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-341 (edit)
revision-approver
CLOSED revision approver - why? 2012-04-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-342 (edit)
location-of-usage
CLOSED prov:location is an optional attribute of entity and activity - others okay? 2012-04-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-343 (edit)
account-objections
CLOSED Objections regarding Account 2012-04-11 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-344 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Missing definitions of terms in section 4 2012-04-11 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-345 (edit)
delineate-constraints
CLOSED style hinders readability: constraints not separated clearly enough 2012-04-11 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-346 (edit)
distinguish-constraints
CLOSED types of constraints unclear 2012-04-11 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-347 (edit)
review-provo-luc
CLOSED feedback from Luc on prov-o WD 2012-04-13 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-348 (edit)
prov-o-propery-name-conventions
CLOSED maintain property naming conventions 2012-04-14 Ontology 0
ISSUE-349 (edit)
prov-o-html-egs
CLOSED examples for each term in cross-reference section 2012-04-15 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-350 (edit)
xref-with-unions
CLOSED cross references with union domains fail 2012-04-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-351 (edit)
membership-complete
CLOSED memberOf complete attribute missing 2012-04-19 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-352 (edit)
rename-WasQuotedFrom
CLOSED A better name for wasQuotedFrom 2012-04-19 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-353 (edit)
optional-id-syntactic-marker
CLOSED Introduce a syntactic marker for when optional id is expressed 2012-04-19 prov-n 0
ISSUE-354 (edit)
all-or-nothing-for-optional-arguments
CLOSED Adopt an all-or-nothing approach to optional positional arguments 2012-04-19 prov-n 0
ISSUE-355 (edit)
convenient-notation-for-qualified-names
CLOSED introduce a convenience notation for qualified names 2012-04-19 prov-n 0
ISSUE-356 (edit)
replace-hadquoter
CLOSED Replace hadQuoter by reusing wasAttributedTo 2012-04-19 mapping prov-dm <-> prov-o 0
ISSUE-357 (edit)
author-in-quotation
CLOSED author in definition of quotation 2012-04-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-358 (edit)
web resource
CLOSED Avoid using the term "Web resource" in PAQ 2012-04-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-359 (edit)
provenance query service URI
CLOSED Avoid the term "provenance query service URI" 2012-04-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-360 (edit)
SPARQL example for 5.1.3
CLOSED SPARQL example for obtaining provenance information directly 2012-04-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-361 (edit)
definition target-uri
CLOSED no relationship between resource and provenance information in definition of target-uri 2012-04-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-362 (edit)
altOf-www
CLOSED alternateOf is to handle levels of specificity, not the wild wild west of WWW URI selection 2012-04-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-363 (edit)
prov-value-pun
CLOSED prov:value punned on KeyValuePair and Entity's literal value 2012-04-20 Ontology 0
ISSUE-364 (edit)
collection-constraints-bugs
CLOSED Collection constraint has wrong syntax for memberOf 2012-04-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-365 (edit)
membership-as-insertion-too-limitting
CLOSED Collection constraint membership-as-insertion too limitting 2012-04-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-366 (edit) CLOSED Approving agent in a qualified wasRevisionOf 2012-04-25 Ontology 0
ISSUE-367 (edit)
hadActivity-domain-and-comments-unclear
CLOSED prov:hadActivity domain and usage unclear 2012-04-26 Ontology 0
ISSUE-368 (edit)
no-responsibility-in-derivation
CLOSED No responsibility in derivation 2012-04-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-369 (edit)
drop-startByActivity
CLOSED Should we drop wasStartedByActivity? 2012-04-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-370 (edit)
tracedTo-inference-only
CLOSED Should tracedTo be moved to prov-constraints and be defined as a binary relation that can be inferred 2012-04-30 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-371 (edit)
junzhao
CLOSED timestamped provo.owl 2012-05-01 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-372 (edit)
qualified-property-chains
CLOSED ( prov:qualifedUsage prov:entity ) rdfs:subPropertyOf prov:used 2012-05-07 0
ISSUE-373 (edit) CLOSED trim qualified from "3.2 expanded" 2012-05-07 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-374 (edit)
member-membership-indirection
CLOSED indirection for Dictionary members 2012-05-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-375 (edit)
owl-property-links
CLOSED link to OWL property types in PROV-O 2012-05-15 Ontology 0
ISSUE-376 (edit)
rename-responsibility
CLOSED Renaming Responsibility (to Behalf?) 2012-05-15 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-377 (edit)
rl-plus-plus-justify
CLOSED All RL "violations" justified appendix 2012-05-16 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-378 (edit)
clarifyHadActivity
CLOSED clarify hadActivity 2012-05-18 Ontology 0
ISSUE-379 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Update provo html section 3.1 2012-05-22 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-380 (edit)
start-hadActivity
CLOSED Missing hadActivity reference on Start 2012-05-22 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-381 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Feedback and refactoring suggestion to prov-o section 3.2 2012-05-23 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-382 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Qualification patters in prov-o section 3.3 2012-05-23 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-383 (edit)
how-to-handle-subtypes
CLOSED How to handle subtypes in PROV-DM 2012-05-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-384 (edit)
prov-role-in-attribution
CLOSED prov:role in attribution or not? 2012-05-24 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-385 (edit)
haProvenanceIn-complexity
CLOSED The hasProvenanceIn relation is over-complicated 2012-05-28 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-386 (edit) CLOSED 3.2 missing terms in turtle examples 2012-05-30 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-387 (edit)
unique-generation
CLOSED generation 2012-06-01 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-388 (edit)
tools-and-demos
CLOSED tools and demos 2012-06-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-389 (edit) CLOSED existing prov-o extensions? 2012-06-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-390 (edit) CLOSED Does PROV-O need to provide terms for PAQ? 2012-06-02 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-391 (edit)
jzhao
CLOSED Reflecting Membership in the Collection Component 2012-06-03 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-392 (edit) CLOSED model hasProvenanceIn / isReferencedBy / isTopicOf in PROV-O 2012-06-03 Ontology 0
ISSUE-393 (edit) CLOSED The properties prov:key and prov:value need to be replaced by prov:pairKey and prov:pairValue 2012-06-04 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-394 (edit) CLOSED is alternateOf symmetric? 2012-06-05 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-395 (edit) CLOSED Rename hadOriginalSource to "originatedFrom"? 2012-06-05 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-396 (edit) CLOSED Rename "wasRevisionOf" to "revisedFrom"? 2012-06-05 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-397 (edit) CLOSED Remove external <a> links in PAQ body; move to [REF] 2012-06-05 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-398 (edit) CLOSED Is ProvenanceService rdfs:subClassOf prov:SoftwareAgent ? 2012-06-05 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-399 (edit)
paq-relation-defs
CLOSED Define relations in prov-aq in a technology independent way 2012-06-07 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-400 (edit)
DistinguishExternalLinks
CLOSED Links to external web pages/documents should be distinguished 2012-06-08 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-401 (edit)
ScopePruning
CLOSED Exclude features for which consensus has not been found 2012-06-09 0
ISSUE-402 (edit)
Feedback_SM
CLOSED Feedback on the feedback from Simon Miles 2012-06-09 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-403 (edit)
Feedback_TL
CLOSED Feedback on the mapping from Tim Lebo 2012-06-09 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-404 (edit)
Feedback_SS
CLOSED Feedback on the mapping from Satya Sahoo 2012-06-09 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-405 (edit)
Feedback_AI
CLOSED Feedback on the mapping from Antoine Isaac (DC community) 2012-06-09 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-407 (edit)
provenance_def
CLOSED Link to provenance definition 2012-06-13 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-408 (edit)
prov-n-review-for-LC
CLOSED feedback on PROV-N document (for last call release) 2012-06-14 prov-n 0
ISSUE-409 (edit)
prov-dm-review-LC
CLOSED feedback on PROV-DM document (for last call release) 2012-06-14 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-410 (edit)
prov-primer-review
CLOSED Feedback on Primer document 2012-06-14 Primer 0
ISSUE-411 (edit)
tracedto-inference
CLOSED Should tracedTo allow tracing across specialization relation 2012-06-19 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-413 (edit)
prov-o-time-chains
CLOSED property chains for time? 2012-06-19 Ontology 0
ISSUE-414 (edit)
must-may-paq
CLOSED Check usage of MUST & MAY in the paq 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-415 (edit)
concept ordering
CLOSED reorder section 1.1 list of concepts 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-416 (edit)
contentnegotiation
CLOSED how does prov-aq work with content negotiation 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-417 (edit)
defs-of-verbs
CLOSED provide definitions of the verbs used in prov-aq 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-418 (edit)
sparql-service-example
CLOSED add example in sparql using provenance-service-uri 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-419 (edit)
urlencoding
CLOSED specification for url encoding 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-420 (edit)
other-params
CLOSED usage of other params in paq service description 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-421 (edit)
consumer-producer
CLOSED maker the roles explicit in the paq 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-422 (edit)
balance-service-and-lookup
CLOSED make sure that the two mechanisms two access provenance are presented equally 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-423 (edit)
multipleheaders
CLOSED What does it mean to receive multiple headers? 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-424 (edit)
summary-table
CLOSED Table summarizing the usage of uris per access method 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-425 (edit)
service-description-rdf
CLOSED Why does the service description need to be rdf? 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-426 (edit)
arbitrary-data
CLOSED Section 3.4 provides too much guidance 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-427 (edit)
multiple anchors
CLOSED Section 3.2 clarify how multiple anchors should be treated 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-429 (edit)
hasAnchor-contextualization
CLOSED how does hasAnchor relate to contextualization 2012-06-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-430 (edit) CLOSED Primer should link to PAQ 2012-06-22 Primer 0
ISSUE-431 (edit)
prov-o-only-dm
CLOSED prov-o to suit prov-dm, not prov-constraints 2012-06-22 Ontology 0
ISSUE-432 (edit)
post-or-get
CLOSED Is http get the correct form for the provenance service 2012-06-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-433 (edit) CLOSED Can the protocol be decoupled from the service definition in prov-aq 2012-06-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-434 (edit)
service-description-rdf
CLOSED Look at wadl or some other description language for the service - is it possible? do we have time? paq 2012-06-23 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-435 (edit) CLOSED "specialized entity" in specialization definition 2012-06-23 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-436 (edit)
prov-datatypes
CLOSED adopting data types from a given version of rdf 2012-06-27 0
ISSUE-437 (edit)
prov-dm-post-f2f3-review
CLOSED Final review before last call vote 2012-06-28 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-438 (edit)
prov-n-post-f2f3-review
CLOSED Final review before last call vote 2012-06-29 prov-n 0
ISSUE-439 (edit) CLOSED Reference to dateTime in prov-n 2012-06-29 prov-n 0
ISSUE-442 (edit)
prov-o-html-term-coverage
CLOSED Identify prov.owl terms that can be omitted in prov.html 2012-07-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-443 (edit)
prov-n-extensibility
CLOSED prov-n-extensibilty 2012-07-03 prov-n 0
ISSUE-444 (edit)
prov-o-to-last-call
CLOSED Review PROV-O for last call 2012-07-03 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-445 (edit)
wasGeneratedAtTime
CLOSED Erroneous wasGeneratedAtTime 2012-07-06 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-446 (edit) CLOSED prov:involvee not documented in PROV-O 2012-07-06 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-447 (edit) CLOSED subactivity relation 2012-07-06 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-448 (edit)
Security-considerations
CLOSED Provide proper discussion of security considerations 2012-07-09 cross-document 0
ISSUE-449 (edit) CLOSED Better definition of prov:value 2012-07-09 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-450 (edit) CLOSED DM tables "incomplete" (specifically: activity ending activity) 2012-07-11 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-451 (edit)
revision-is-alternate
CLOSED Keep or drop revision-is-alternate 2012-07-18 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-452 (edit)
optional-plan
CLOSED what is plan in association inference 2012-07-18 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-453 (edit)
influence identifiers
CLOSED influence inference and uniqueness 2012-07-18 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-454 (edit)
key across relations/objectss
CLOSED can the same identifier be used for different relations objects 2012-07-18 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-455 (edit)
Dong
CLOSED Type mismatch between PROV-O and PROV-DM 2012-07-18 Ontology 0
ISSUE-456 (edit) CLOSED Simplify union domain of hadRole using InstantaneousEvent 2012-07-19 Ontology 0
ISSUE-457 (edit) CLOSED qualifiedInfluence domain does not match domain of wasInfluencedBy 2012-07-19 Ontology 0
ISSUE-458 (edit) CLOSED wasInfluencedBy is not irreflexive 2012-07-20 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-459 (edit)
prov-constraints-lc-review
CLOSED PROV-CONSTRAINTS review 2012-07-20 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-460 (edit) CLOSED prov-o egs should be <=97 characters 2012-07-23 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-461 (edit) CLOSED provo cross reference inadequate in printed form 2012-07-23 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-462 (edit)
entity-definition-precision
CLOSED Definition o entity may be too liberal 2012-07-25 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-463 (edit)
freimuth
CLOSED comments from robert freimuth 2012-07-25 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-464 (edit)
dont-need-normalize
CLOSED Applications do *not* need to normalize PROV 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-465 (edit)
avoid-infinite-inferences
CLOSED Avoid infinite loops in inferences 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-466 (edit)
must-entities-invalidate
CLOSED Must all entities invalidate? 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-467 (edit)
activity-start-req-trigger
CLOSED Do activity start/end always require trigger? 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-468 (edit)
remove-wasStartedByActivity-figure
CLOSED Remove figure for wasStartedByActivity 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-469 (edit)
zero-timespan-entity
CLOSED Can entity's have zero timespan? 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-470 (edit)
wasDerFrom-strictly
CLOSED wasDerivedFrom requires use strictly before generation - why? 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-471 (edit)
wrong-wasAttributedTo-constraints
CLOSED wasAttributedTo constraints not sensical 2012-08-06 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-472 (edit)
Feedback_IH
CLOSED Review of the DC-NOTE by Ivan Herman 2012-08-06 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-473 (edit)
generating-activity
CLOSED Unique generation events and activities 2012-08-09 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-474 (edit)
instances-and-bundles
CLOSED Bundles and valid instances 2012-08-09 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-475 (edit) CLOSED Request to drop "mention" and related elements 2012-08-09 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-476 (edit) CLOSED (Editorial comment) hadOriginalSource still occurs in LC documents 2012-08-09 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-477 (edit)
rename toplevel-bundle
CLOSED rename toplevel-bundle to dataset 2012-08-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-478 (edit)
type-table
CLOSED informative "type table" 2012-08-14 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-479 (edit) CLOSED cite TriG for examples 2012-08-14 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-480 (edit) CLOSED XSD Validator returns schema parser error when reading prov.xsd 2012-08-15 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-481 (edit) CLOSED PROV-XSD Entity complexType does not support prov:value child element 2012-08-20 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-482 (edit) CLOSED [external question] bundle IDs on insertion, context 2012-08-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-483 (edit) CLOSED For delegation PROV-DM uses word "delegate" XSD uses word "subordinate" 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-484 (edit) CLOSED activity should be optional in ActedOnBehalfOf 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-485 (edit) CLOSED For communication, PROV-DM uses different words than XSD 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-486 (edit) CLOSED The XSD for communication includes an optional element for time 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-487 (edit) CLOSED Remove WasQuotedFrom 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-488 (edit) CLOSED Specialization uses different words than PROV-DM 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-489 (edit) CLOSED Alternate uses different language than PROV-DM 2012-08-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-490 (edit)
prov-constraints-lc-editorial
CLOSED PROV-CONSTRAINTS pre-Last Call editorial issues 2012-08-30 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-491 (edit) CLOSED [external] feedback on prov:agent explanation. 2012-09-04 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-492 (edit) CLOSED typo in example 2012-09-04 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-493 (edit) CLOSED prov:type has type Value; valid values too general, include number, datetime, boolean, etc. 2012-09-04 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-494 (edit) CLOSED Make prov:ref a required attribute for Ref complexTypes 2012-09-07 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-495 (edit) CLOSED ivan's feedback on prov-dm LC 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-496 (edit) CLOSED ivan's feedback on prov-n LC 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-497 (edit)
edge-labeled-by-concept
CLOSED prov-dm: Data Model Figure 1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-498 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Table 2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-499 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 2.1.1, semantics 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-500 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 2.1.1, hierarchies 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-501 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 2.1.1, example 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-502 (edit)
derivation
CLOSED Data Model Section 2.1.2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-503 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 2.2.1.2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-504 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 2.2.2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-505 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-506 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 4.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-507 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Tables 4 and 5 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-508 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Table 5 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-509 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Figure 5 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-510 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-511 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.4 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-512 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.5 (Example 21) 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-513 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.6 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-514 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.7 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-515 (edit)
invalidation
CLOSED Data Model Section 5.1.8 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-516 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.2.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-517 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Sections 5.2.2 and 5.2.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-518 (edit)
primary-source
CLOSED Data Model Section 5.2.4 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-519 (edit)
inheritance-influence
CLOSED Data Model Figure 8 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-520 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.3.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-521 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.3.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-522 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.3.4 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-523 (edit)
inheritance-influence
CLOSED Data Model Section 5.3.5 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-524 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.4.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-525 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.5.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-526 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.5.2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-527 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.5.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-528 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.5.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-529 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.6.1 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-530 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.7.2 (Table 6) 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-531 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.7.2.2 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-532 (edit) CLOSED Data Model Section 5.7.2.3 2012-09-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-533 (edit) CLOSED Notation, of attributes 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-534 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 2.1 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-535 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 2.2 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-536 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 2.3 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-537 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 2.4 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-538 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 2.4, example 2 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-539 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3, EBNF format 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-540 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3, structure of documentation 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-541 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.1.3 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-542 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.1.4 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-543 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.5 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-544 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.7 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-545 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.7.2 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-546 (edit) CLOSED Notation Section 3.7.4 2012-09-10 prov-n 0
ISSUE-547 (edit) CLOSED prov:records requires a specific order of elements 2012-09-10 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-548 (edit) CLOSED XSD MentionOf, change terms to match PROV-DM 2012-09-10 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-549 (edit) CLOSED XML Schema Bundle vs. NamedBundle 2012-09-10 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-550 (edit) CLOSED Bundles have required records, why not optional? 2012-09-10 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-551 (edit) CLOSED Flatten XML Schema removing records and/or dependencies? 2012-09-12 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-552 (edit)
subclass-prov-o
CLOSED Check subclass definitions in prov-o 2012-09-13 Ontology 0
ISSUE-553 (edit) CLOSED QNames are too restrictive as identifiers 2012-09-13 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-554 (edit)
time-qualification
CLOSED public comment: should qualfied and unqualified versions the same 2012-09-17 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-555 (edit)
time-qualification
CLOSED public comment: should qualfied and unqualified versions the same 2012-09-17 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-556 (edit)
time-qualification
CLOSED public comment: should qualfied and unqualified versions the same 2012-09-17 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-557 (edit) CLOSED why collectionMemberOf instead of hadMember? 2012-09-18 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-558 (edit) CLOSED Introducing commonAttributes allows role/value on objects which dm does not allow for 2012-09-18 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-559 (edit) CLOSED For delegation, two agents need to have some overlap in their lifetime. 2012-09-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-560 (edit) CLOSED type overlap question 2012-09-26 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-561 (edit)
primer-figure-sync
CLOSED Primer Section 2 figure 2012-09-26 Primer 0
ISSUE-562 (edit)
primer-specialization-inheritance
CLOSED Primer Section 2.9 specialization 2012-09-26 Primer 0
ISSUE-563 (edit)
primer-alternates-figure
CLOSED Primer Section 3.9 Alternates 2012-09-26 Primer 0
ISSUE-564 (edit)
primer-version-copy
CLOSED Primer Section 2.9 Versions and copies 2012-09-26 Primer 0
ISSUE-565 (edit)
rdfa-check
CLOSED Do the suggested way of pointing to provenance work in rdfa 2012-09-27 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-566 (edit)
fix-images
CLOSED HTML images still have references to the bundles as named graphs 2012-10-01 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-567 (edit)
Link-to-inverse-prop-missing
CLOSED The link ti the inverse property file is missing in the ontology 2012-10-02 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-568 (edit)
hadRole-domain
CLOSED domain of prov:hadRole 2012-10-08 Ontology 0
ISSUE-569 (edit)
changing resources
CLOSED How do we deal with resources that change? 2012-10-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-570 (edit)
changing resources
CLOSED How do we deal with resources that change? 2012-10-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-571 (edit)
changing resources
CLOSED How do we deal with resources that change? 2012-10-10 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-572 (edit) CLOSED What constraints should we have on ordering of elements within the main complexTypes? 2012-10-11 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-573 (edit)
mime-type
CLOSED mime type registration feedback 2012-10-15 prov-n 0
ISSUE-574 (edit)
primer-figure
CLOSED Update primer overview figure 2012-10-16 Primer 0
ISSUE-575 (edit) CLOSED identifier field 2012-10-22 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-576 (edit) CLOSED logical definition and comments on prov-constratins 2012-10-23 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-577 (edit)
valid-vs-consistent
CLOSED Terminology: valid vs. consistent 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-578 (edit)
equivalence
CLOSED Use of "equivalent" incompatible with common uses of the term in logic/mathematics 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-579 (edit)
declarative-fol-specification
CLOSED Suggestion to replace procedural specification with (equivalent, but shorter and less prescriptive) declarative theory in First-Order Logic 2012-10-25 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-580 (edit)
drop-syntactic-sugar-definitions
CLOSED Suggestion to drop definitions in section 4.1 since they are not needed if the semantics is defined more abstractly 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-581 (edit)
avoid-specifying-algorithm
CLOSED Suggestion to avoid wording that 'almost requires' using normalization to implement constraints 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-582 (edit)
document-instance
CLOSED 'of their respective documents.' should be '... of their respective instances.' 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-583 (edit)
equivalent-instances-in-bundles
CLOSED Questions concerning what it means for applications to treat equivalent instances 'in the same way', particularly in bundles. 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-584 (edit)
merging
CLOSED The nonstandard/procedurally defined 'merging' operation on terms 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-585 (edit)
applying-satisfying-constraints
CLOSED Suggestion to avoid discussing how to 'apply' constraints; clarify what it means to 'satisfy' constraints 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-586 (edit)
toplevel-bundle-description
CLOSED The description of 'toplevel bundle' as 'set of statements not appearing in a named bundle' is unclear 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-587 (edit)
rdf-analogies
CLOSED Concerns about analogies to RDF blank nodes/semantics 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-588 (edit)
strictly-precedes-irreflexive
CLOSED It is never specified explicitly that "strictly-precedes" is irreflexive 2012-10-25 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-589 (edit) CLOSED scope of prefixes in prov-n documents 2012-11-01 prov-n 0
ISSUE-590 (edit) CLOSED wasInfluencedBy should not be used directly 2012-11-01 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-591 (edit) CLOSED delegation PROV-O example missing activity reference 2012-11-01 Primer 0
ISSUE-592 (edit) CLOSED [external] wasInfluencedBy is confused with wasInformedBy 2012-11-04 Primer 0
ISSUE-593 (edit) CLOSED [editorial] hadActivity in Delegation example 2012-11-07 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-594 (edit) CLOSED Error in wasInformedBy property chain 2012-11-08 Ontology 0
ISSUE-595 (edit) CLOSED Prov-xml subtyping needs to be marked in the document 2012-11-09 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-596 (edit)
Bundle-access
CLOSED Should PROV-AQ discuss mechanisms for accessing bundles? 2012-11-09 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-598 (edit)
remove-query-section-query
CLOSED Should we remove the best practice section in PROV-AQ and handle in FAQ? 2012-11-14 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-599 (edit)
provenance-description
CLOSED Should "provenance description" be formally defined? 2012-11-20 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-601 (edit)
provenance-information
CLOSED Rename provenance information to provenance description? 2012-11-20 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-602 (edit)
Luc's FB DC Note
CLOSED Luc's Feedback on the DC-Note 2012-11-23 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-603 (edit)
Craig's FB DC Note
CLOSED Craig's M Feedback on the DC- Note 2012-11-23 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-605 (edit)
fpwd-prov-overview
CLOSED reviews of prov-overview for fpwd 2012-11-27 PROV-OVERVIEW 0
ISSUE-607 (edit)
dc-smiles-review
CLOSED Review of the Dublin Core mapping document 2012-11-28 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-608 (edit) CLOSED How do we accomodate extensions from other notes into PROV-XML schema 2012-11-29 XML Serialization 0
ISSUE-610 (edit) CLOSED prov-o query profiles and use cases not normative 2012-12-14 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-612 (edit)
constraints-in-owl-public
CLOSED Encoding of Constraints in OWL 2013-01-08 Ontology 0
ISSUE-613 (edit)
prov-aq-draft-review
CLOSED Review paq for release as last call working draft 2013-01-10 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-614 (edit) CLOSED PROV-DICTIONARY internal review for first public working draft 2013-01-11 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-615 (edit) CLOSED Provide explanation to constraint 47(3) 2013-01-16 prov-dm-constraints 0
ISSUE-616 (edit)
quoted-in-primer
CLOSED Confusing use of wasQuotedFrom in primer 2013-01-23 Primer 0
ISSUE-617 (edit) CLOSED Why are some prov-constraint inferences in prov-o, but not others? 2013-01-24 Ontology 0
ISSUE-619 (edit)
json-ld-service-description
CLOSED Should PRIV-AQ bless use of JSON-LD for service description? 2013-01-31 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-620 (edit)
json-ld-service-description
CLOSED Should PRIV-AQ bless use of JSON-LD for service description? 2013-01-31 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-621 (edit)
json-ld-service-description
CLOSED Should PRIV-AQ bless use of JSON-LD for service description? 2013-01-31 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-622 (edit)
json-ld-service-description
CLOSED Should PROV-AQ bless use of JSON-LD for service description? 2013-01-31 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-623 (edit) CLOSED outdated definition of prov:wasDerivedFrom 2013-01-31 Ontology 0
ISSUE-624 (edit)
URI-specified-or-REST
CLOSED Should PROV-AQ specify PROV service URI or always use template? 2013-02-07 Accessing and Querying Provenance 0
ISSUE-625 (edit)
fix-images
CLOSED Fix images of the DC Note 2013-02-07 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-626 (edit)
clarify-date-text
CLOSED The text about the dates is difficult to understand 2013-02-07 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-629 (edit)
rephrase-abstract
CLOSED Rephrase abstract in prov-dc note 2013-02-25 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-630 (edit)
prov-sem-fpwd-review
CLOSED PROV-SEM review for FPWD 2013-02-25 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-631 (edit)
dct:replaces
CLOSED Remove dct:replaces as direct mapping, add it as a complex mapping 2013-02-25 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-633 (edit)
Minor Issues
CLOSED Minor Issues of the PROV-DC document 2013-02-26 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-634 (edit)
small issues-paul
CLOSED Small issues to fix in the DC Note 2013-02-27 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-635 (edit)
prov-sem-completeness
CLOSED Completeness and scope of prov-sem 2013-03-01 Formal Semantics 0
ISSUE-636 (edit)
PROV-DC has provenance
CLOSED Include has_provenance in PROV-DC 2013-03-03 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-637 (edit)
resolve dct:references
CLOSED Discuss dct:references 2013-03-04 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-638 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Notation of set of key-value pairs in contraints of PROV Dictionary 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-639 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Notation of hadDictionaryMember 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-640 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Namespace and prefix in PROV Dictionary 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-641 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Should qualifiedInsertion/Removal imply qualifiedDerivation? 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-642 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Include example of provenance of a dictionary in the document 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-643 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Include additional constraint hadMember implies hadDictionaryMember with unknown key 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-644 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED (Editorial) Make sure production rules in grammar are regular text instead of CSS 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-645 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Should we add a new constraint on EmptyCollection and Dictionary? 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-646 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED (Editorial) Layout of the document (and specifically Section 4) 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-647 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Make prov:pairValue a subproperty of prov:entity? 2013-03-07 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-649 (edit) CLOSED typo in alternateOf example. 2013-03-12 PROV-O HTML 0
ISSUE-650 (edit) CLOSED dictionary insertion, with or without id/attrs? 2013-03-13 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-653 (edit) CLOSED typo in example 2013-03-25 prov-dm 0
ISSUE-654 (edit)
primer-ducharme
CLOSED Various clarifications and comments (Bob DuCharme) 2013-03-26 Primer 0
ISSUE-656 (edit)
TB review
CLOSED Tom Baker's review on PROV-DC 2013-04-01 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-657 (edit)
PG DC review
CLOSED Review of DC Note- Paul Groth 2013-04-03 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-659 (edit)
dc-prov-namespace
CLOSED Namespace in DC Mapping Note, dereferenceability of URIs 2013-04-09 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-660 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Constraints of PROV-Dictionary 2013-04-11 PROV-DICTIONARY 0
ISSUE-662 (edit)
stian-FB-DC
CLOSED Stian's Feedback on PROV-DC 2013-04-16 Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core 0
ISSUE-668 (edit)
TomDN
CLOSED Disambiguated DBPedia URIs to QNames in XML example 2013-04-17 PROV-DICTIONARY 0

Raise an issue .


Chair, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: closed.html,v 1.1 2013-06-20 07:38:01 vivien Exp $