Difference between revisions of "Data Cube LC comments"

From Government Linked Data (GLD) Working Group Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Last Call Comments Disposition: Data Cube)
(Last Call Comments Disposition: Data Cube)
Line 23: Line 23:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Franck Cotton || [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-gld-comments/2013Apr/0061.html] || 22 Editorial comments, "hesitant about the introduction of the qb:HierarchicalCodeList" || Acknowledged, no response yet || ||
 
|| Franck Cotton || [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-gld-comments/2013Apr/0061.html] || 22 Editorial comments, "hesitant about the introduction of the qb:HierarchicalCodeList" || Acknowledged, no response yet || ||
 +
|-
 +
|| Laurent Bihanic via Franck Cotton || [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-gld-comments/2013Apr/0061.html] || Two claimed errors in sdmx-*.ttl (not part of GLD products) || Responded, only one is real, will handle outside working group. || [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-gld-comments/2013Apr/0062.html] || N/A ||
 
|}
 
|}
 +
 +
 +
=== Summary ===
 +
 +
Eight responses from a broad range of contributors, four of which explicitly state that they have been using the vocabulary including several references to deployed applications of it.
 +
 +
The bulk of comments are editorial and can be addressed as such. Some of the other comments that might have been interpreted as non-editorial have been confirmed as editorial via follow up clarification.
 +
 +
The non-editorial comments are:
 +
 +
{| class="datatable sortable"
 +
|+Non-editorial comments
 +
|-
 +
! Commenter !! Comment !! Status
 +
|-
 +
|| Bill Roberts || Additional metadata properties for granularity and spacial coverage || Accepted "no change" response ||
 +
|| Bill Roberts || Need for IC-2 || Accepted "no change" response ||
 +
|| Bill Roberts || Need for IC-4/5 || Accepted "no change" response (given proposed update to sdmx* vocabs) ||
 +
|| Franck Cotton || hesitant about the introduction of the qb:HierarchicalCodeList || TDB ||
 +
|| Laurent Bihanic via Franck Cotton || Two claimed errors in sdmx-*.ttl || Not part of Data Cube specification or GLD work products. (Responded, one is not an error, one will be fixed). ||
 +
 +
 +
 +
Given the clarifying responses from Guillaume Duffes and Ulrich Atz

Revision as of 12:33, 10 April 2013

Last Call Comments Disposition: Data Cube

Comments and draft responses for Data Cube Last Call ending 2013-04-08.

Disposition of comments
Commenter Message Summary Status GLD response Acknowledgement
Frans Knibbe [1] Editorial comment on missing namespace prefix used in Example 1. Prefix added [2] None yet
Guillaume Duffes [3] Mostly editorial. Clarification sought [4]
Peter Winstanley [5] Endorsement plus evidence of use. Acknowledged, no change needed. [6] N/A
Leigh Dodds [7] Endorsement plus evidence of use. Acknowledged, no change needed. [8] N/A
Ørnulf Risnes [9] Endorsement plus evidence of use. Acknowledged, no change needed. [10] N/A
Bill Roberts [11] Endorsement, evidence of use. Suggest additional metadata properties for granularity and spatial coverage. Question need for IC-2, IC-4, IC-5. Push back on suggested changes. Resolve IC-4/5 issue by change to external resources. No changes to documents. [12] Yes [13]
Ulrich Atz [14] 15 comments believed to be all editorial and primarily related to ordering of exposition and examples Clarification sought [15] and given [16]
Franck Cotton [17] 22 Editorial comments, "hesitant about the introduction of the qb:HierarchicalCodeList" Acknowledged, no response yet
Laurent Bihanic via Franck Cotton [18] Two claimed errors in sdmx-*.ttl (not part of GLD products) Responded, only one is real, will handle outside working group. [19] N/A


Summary

Eight responses from a broad range of contributors, four of which explicitly state that they have been using the vocabulary including several references to deployed applications of it.

The bulk of comments are editorial and can be addressed as such. Some of the other comments that might have been interpreted as non-editorial have been confirmed as editorial via follow up clarification.

The non-editorial comments are:

Non-editorial comments
Commenter Comment Status
Bill Roberts Additional metadata properties for granularity and spacial coverage Accepted "no change" response Bill Roberts Need for IC-2 Accepted "no change" response Bill Roberts Need for IC-4/5 Accepted "no change" response (given proposed update to sdmx* vocabs) Franck Cotton hesitant about the introduction of the qb:HierarchicalCodeList TDB Laurent Bihanic via Franck Cotton Two claimed errors in sdmx-*.ttl Not part of Data Cube specification or GLD work products. (Responded, one is not an error, one will be fixed).


Given the clarifying responses from Guillaume Duffes and Ulrich Atz