14:43:39 RRSAgent has joined #lld 14:43:39 logging to http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-irc 14:43:48 rrsagent, bookmark 14:43:48 See http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-irc#T14-43-48 14:44:16 test 14:44:40 zakim, this will be lld 14:44:40 ok, antoine; I see INC_LLDXG()10:00AM scheduled to start in 16 minutes 14:44:52 Meeting: LLD XG 14:45:04 Chair: Antoine 14:45:21 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-lld/2010Nov/0084.html 14:45:58 aconstan has joined #lld 14:46:25 Previous: 2010-11-11 http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/11/11-lld-minutes.html 14:47:38 jeff_ has joined #lld 14:47:42 Regrets: Gordon, Felix, Karen, Oreste, Monica, Lars 14:48:08 rrsagent, please make record public 14:51:01 kcoyle has joined #lld 14:51:38 regrets+ Bernard 14:51:44 rrsagent, please draft minutes 14:51:44 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html antoine 14:53:13 Scribe: Anette 14:53:20 Scribenick: AnetteS 14:55:06 INC_LLDXG()10:00AM has now started 14:55:13 +??P3 14:55:25 zakim, ??P3 is me 14:55:25 +antoine; got it 14:55:47 AnetteS has joined #lld 14:56:24 TomB has joined #lld 14:56:34 zakim, who is here? 14:56:34 On the phone I see antoine 14:56:35 On IRC I see TomB, AnetteS, kcoyle, jeff_, aconstan, RRSAgent, Zakim, antoine, kai, mhausenblas, digikim, edsu 14:56:39 +??P4 14:56:46 zakim, ??p4 is TomB 14:56:46 +TomB; got it 14:57:37 +AnetteS 14:57:51 +??P13 14:58:13 zakim, ??P13 is aconstan 14:58:13 +aconstan; got it 14:58:16 +michaelp 14:58:26 zakim, michaelp is me 14:58:26 +jeff_; got it 14:58:59 pmurray has joined #lld 14:59:12 +??P16 14:59:14 kefo has joined #lld 14:59:14 rayd has joined #lld 14:59:16 rsinger has joined #lld 14:59:17 marcia has joined #lld 14:59:19 AlexanderH has joined #lld 14:59:23 +[LC] 14:59:34 zakim, ??P16 is kai 14:59:34 +kai; got it 14:59:44 zakim, LC is kefo 14:59:44 +kefo; got it 14:59:47 zakim, mute me 14:59:47 jeff_ should now be muted 14:59:48 +??P1 15:00:00 zakim, mute me 15:00:00 aconstan should now be muted 15:00:04 zakim, mute me 15:00:05 kefo should now be muted 15:00:08 Andras has joined #lld 15:00:23 + +aaaa 15:00:25 jneubert has joined #lld 15:00:40 + +1.678.235.aabb 15:00:53 zakim, ??P1 is AlexanderH 15:00:53 +AlexanderH; got it 15:01:04 zakim, aabb is me 15:01:04 +pmurray; got it 15:01:14 + +1.423.463.aacc 15:01:18 + +44.361.279.aadd 15:01:24 +[LC] 15:01:26 i have but you can.t hear me 15:01:29 zakim, aacc is ross 15:01:29 +ross; got it 15:01:30 jodi has joined #LLD 15:01:41 not sure what.s wrong, will come in on another line 15:01:42 +marcia 15:01:46 Zakim, aacc is really rsinger 15:01:46 sorry, rsinger, I do not recognize a party named 'aacc' 15:01:48 Zakim +[LC] is Andras 15:01:49 +Jodi 15:01:51 zakim, unmute me 15:01:51 pmurray should no longer be muted 15:02:02 zakim, mute me 15:02:03 + +49.4.aaee 15:02:04 pmurray should now be muted 15:02:07 TomB: sure :) 15:02:13 - +aaaa 15:02:13 Zakim, ross is really rsinger 15:02:13 +rsinger; got it 15:02:17 zakim, aaee is jneubert 15:02:17 +jneubert; got it 15:02:25 +[LC.a] 15:02:27 zakim, who is here? 15:02:27 On the phone I see antoine, TomB, AnetteS, aconstan (muted), jeff_ (muted), kai, kefo (muted), AlexanderH, pmurray (muted), rsinger, +44.361.279.aadd, [LC], marcia, Jodi, jneubert, 15:02:31 ... [LC.a] 15:02:32 On IRC I see jodi, jneubert, Andras, AlexanderH, marcia, rsinger, rayd, kefo, pmurray, TomB, AnetteS, kcoyle, jeff_, aconstan, RRSAgent, Zakim, antoine, kai, mhausenblas, digikim, 15:02:35 ... edsu 15:02:37 +[IPcaller] 15:02:39 zakim, LC.a is edsu 15:02:41 +edsu; got it 15:02:48 zakim, IPcaller is digikim 15:02:49 +digikim; got it 15:03:15 zakim, who is here? 15:03:15 On the phone I see antoine, TomB, AnetteS, aconstan (muted), jeff_ (muted), kai, kefo (muted), AlexanderH, pmurray (muted), rsinger, +44.361.279.aadd, [LC], marcia, Jodi, jneubert, 15:03:19 ... edsu, digikim 15:03:20 On IRC I see jodi, jneubert, Andras, AlexanderH, marcia, rsinger, rayd, kefo, pmurray, TomB, AnetteS, kcoyle, jeff_, aconstan, RRSAgent, Zakim, antoine, kai, mhausenblas, digikim, 15:03:23 ... edsu 15:03:29 zakim, [LC] is me 15:03:29 +Andras; got it 15:04:07 +44 is UK 15:04:35 Whose phone number is +44.361.279.aadd ? 15:04:44 Shakespeare is from UK ;) 15:04:51 digikim++ 15:04:55 zakim, who is making noise? 15:05:05 antoine, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: antoine (25%), AnetteS (15%) 15:05:19 zakim, aadd is me 15:05:19 +Andras; got it 15:05:47 okay 15:06:04 +??P40 15:06:08 -??P40 15:07:03 Topic: Admin 15:07:30 Zakim, [LC] is not me 15:07:30 I don't understand '[LC] is not me', Andras 15:07:39 Minutes from last week are posted. 15:07:47 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/11/11-lld-minutes.html 15:07:52 emma has joined #lld 15:07:54 Nobody has objections 15:08:06 RESOLVED: Accept minutes of last week 15:08:32 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/RunningAgenda 15:08:36 + +33.1.53.79.aaff 15:08:37 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html TomB 15:08:42 zakim, aaff is me 15:08:42 +emma; got it 15:08:53 We have entered our agenda into a wiki-page as the agenda is very long 15:09:28 zakim, unmute me 15:09:28 aconstan should no longer be muted 15:09:30 We have a new member: alex 15:09:44 -> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-lld/2010Nov/0064.html 15:09:50 Alex: at University of Manchester 15:10:12 ...building a live topic ontology of computer science using the conference management system 15:10:29 ... interested in extracting semantic data from bodies of knowledge 15:10:49 Antoine welcomes Alex 15:10:57 zakim, mute me 15:10:57 aconstan should now be muted 15:11:26 +??P40 15:11:30 Topic: Use cases 15:11:40 zakim, ??P40 is kcoyle 15:11:40 +kcoyle; got it 15:12:02 We have a running action to volunteer for a cluster 15:12:29 zakim, who is making noise? 15:12:40 jodi, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: antoine (15%), TomB (18%), AnetteS (44%), emma (4%), Andras.a (8%) 15:13:00 -pmurray 15:13:19 ACTION: People who were not at the face‑to‑face meeting volunteer to join a cluster [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2010/10/28‑lld‑minutes.html#a --done 15:13:36 ACTION: People who were not at the face-to-face meeting volunteer to join a cluster [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2010/10/28-lld-minutes.html#action03] 15:13:38 --DONE 15:14:02 +pmurray 15:14:07 Topic: Six clusters 15:14:38 Antoine asks if a representative from one cluster volunteers for next week 15:14:53 next week is the thanksgiving holiday in the US, btw 15:15:12 not ready, sorry... 15:15:21 yeah, i'm not going to be in channel next week 15:15:42 discussion can be informal; nothing needs to be polished 15:16:06 q+ 15:16:13 have to discuss clusters to meet dead line at end of december 15:16:16 zakim, ack edsu 15:16:16 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:16:48 edsu: exchanges emails about citation cluster for today; not ready yet 15:17:11 ... confused about what we are supposed to be discussing when talking about cluster 15:17:14 i'm not clear about that either 15:17:50 Antoine: Focussing on issues in the cluster could be subject of discussion. 15:18:02 ... what we want to resolve with the use cases 15:18:12 ... find general goals in the use cases 15:18:17 -> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Goals 15:18:36 ... extract a list of generic goals from the use cases 15:19:23 -> http://obd.jisc.ac.uk/navigate 15:19:50 ... JISC link: find scenarios for library linked data 15:20:47 ... we are aiming at something similar: scenarios and use cases 15:21:02 i also like that they present it in a grid -- it's easy to understand 15:21:52 koyle: find goals and link back to use cases 15:22:15 ... their goals are more specific than ours 15:22:28 q+ on scenarios 15:22:44 Antoine: Need more discussion on that 15:22:57 -kcoyle 15:23:08 i got dropped. will come back in 15:23:17 +[IPcaller] 15:23:36 emma: compare jisc cases with ours; refine them 15:23:49 s/emma/jodi 15:24:01 +??P40 15:24:16 (refine both ours and potentially theirs) 15:24:19 Asaf has joined #lld 15:24:22 zakim, IPcaller is Asaf 15:24:22 +Asaf; got it 15:24:31 zakim, ??P40 is kcoyle 15:24:31 I already had ??P40 as kcoyle, antoine 15:24:39 zakim, ack emma 15:24:39 emma, you wanted to comment on scenarios 15:24:40 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:25:07 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html antoine 15:25:16 emma: use cases should become more abstract scenarios 15:25:22 +1 15:25:27 +1 15:25:49 ... then they can be part of the report 15:26:09 ... have one or two scenarios per cluster 15:26:50 +1 15:27:25 +1 re UC abstraction. 15:27:37 ACTION: Antoine to ask Monica to lead discussion about JISC use cases 15:28:24 Antoine: need shepherds for a few use cases 15:28:46 ... who will volunteer : need 2 shepherds 15:29:30 q+ 15:29:34 zakim, unmute me 15:29:34 jeff_ should no longer be muted 15:30:07 ... Bridging OWL and UML - Jeff has authored it; not really a use case, more a way of thinking about it 15:30:08 q+ to propose that we bend rules and let Jeff shepherd the OWL and UML use case 15:30:22 ack jeff_ 15:30:42 ... it can be on its own wiki page, but not as a use case 15:31:12 TomB: alternative proposal: let Jeff shepherd his own use case 15:31:17 q+ to ask if it fits a cluster 15:31:23 ack TomB 15:31:23 TomB, you wanted to propose that we bend rules and let Jeff shepherd the OWL and UML use case 15:31:25 Jeff: thats okay 15:31:26 ack emma 15:31:26 emma, you wanted to ask if it fits a cluster 15:32:21 ???: Could be part of vocabulary alignment 15:32:26 I think that is a good idea 15:32:41 +Jeff 15:32:43 s/???/Jeff 15:32:56 ksclarke has joined #lld 15:33:11 I think it is a higher level, abstract approach 15:33:20 to vocabulary alignment 15:33:44 zakim, mute me 15:33:44 jeff_ should now be muted 15:33:45 jACTION: Put use case Bridging OWL and UML to Vocabulary Alignment 15:33:57 ACTION: Put use case Bridging OWL and UML to Vocabulary Alignment 15:34:07 danbri has joined #lld 15:34:24 s/Put/Antoine to put/ 15:34:46 Use case: Academic documents: volunteers? 15:34:59 Andras volunteers 15:35:27 Action 4 done (just moved it on http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/wiki/Use_Cases) 15:35:41 Antoine: in which cluster should the UC be moved 15:36:36 -Jodi 15:36:41 ACTION: People who didn't attend the face‑to‑face should volunteer to shepherd a new use case ‑‑ i.e., the cases marked "needs shepherd" in --DONE 15:36:48 --done 15:37:00 +Jodi 15:37:21 Topic: TOPICS 15:37:39 Antoine: do we want to keep track of all discussions in relation to Topics 15:38:11 q+ 15:38:13 ... should we link between topics and discussions on the list or is it too much work? 15:38:20 zakim, ack TomB 15:38:20 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:38:54 TomB: we have a lot of valuable discussion on the list, but we should keep an eye on our goals 15:39:32 ... discussions should be boiled down to a statement of the problem; summarize the state of discussion and solution 15:39:44 ... link to thread in mailing list 15:40:01 ... our final report should be more general than the specifics of the discussion 15:40:22 agree 15:40:25 ... summary of discussions and leave details on mailing list 15:40:49 q+ 15:40:53 ack me 15:41:04 q+ 15:41:39 Jeff: example: VIAF modelling choices; discussion helped in thinking about it 15:41:53 ... importance of consensus in modelling choices 15:42:20 -AnetteS 15:42:28 ... but in the context of the LLD-Group 15:42:43 I'm off the telephone, please take over somebody else 15:43:11 ... someone will have to explain the result & how the decision was made 15:43:33 +AnetteS 15:43:39 Jeff: I'm willing to write a document 15:43:41 q+ to propose that we give Jeff an action to describe the process of design discussion 15:44:40 Emma: keeping track of discussion: linking from Wiki pages could be done on the fly, not later 15:45:53 TomB: propose to summarize discussions in one or two paragraphs that could be used in report 15:46:36 ... as examples of the dialogs that need to be made 15:46:56 I think the VIAF dilemmas (polylemma?) are and would remain typical for implementations of LLD in the coming couple of years. 15:47:04 Jeff: agrees 15:47:32 ACTION: Jeff to write one or two paragraphs on VIAF design discussions 15:47:39 zakim, mute me 15:47:39 jeff_ should now be muted 15:48:59 I suggest that when we spot sth relevant, we link it from the corresponding topic page on the wiki 15:49:08 i agree with tomB that we need to keep our eye on our specific goals 15:49:12 emma++ 15:49:19 kcoyle: agreed -- our time is getting short 15:49:26 Antoine: if someone finds a relevant thread to associate to a topic, please link to topic 15:49:45 kcoyle++ 15:49:58 ok 15:50:29 ACTION: GordonD and Antoine to study use cases that relate to vocabulary merging use case [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/10/24-lld-minutes.html#action01] 15:50:32 --CONTINUES 15:50:35 zakim, unmute me 15:50:35 jeff_ should no longer be muted 15:50:47 ACTION: Jeff to review the UK eGovernment document on identifiers. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/10/24-lld-minutes.html#action03] 15:50:50 --DONE 15:50:56 See Jeff's post: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-lld/2010Nov/0111.html 15:51:14 Action: Jeff to review the UK eGovernment document on identifiers. 15:51:25 Jeff would like feedback on it 15:51:54 Antoine: point from the topic to the discussion 15:52:04 +Jeff 15:52:10 zakim, mute me 15:52:10 jeff_ should now be muted 15:52:20 zakim, unmute me 15:52:20 jeff_ should no longer be muted 15:52:26 ACTION: Alex, Jeff, Martin, MichaelP elaborate on general purpose IT architecture for dealing with linked data with caching feature [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/10/24‑lld‑minutes.html#action04] 15:52:32 -- continues 15:52:45 zakim, mute me 15:52:45 jeff_ should now be muted 15:52:54 ACTION: Emma and Antoine to create use case DATA.SEARCH‑OPTIMIZATION [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/10/24‑lld‑minutes.html#action06] 15:52:58 -- continues 15:53:16 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html emma 15:53:21 jeff_: I'll take a look at the issue of URIs, might have some comments based on our experiences in Finland 15:53:27 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html TomB 15:53:38 digikim: thanks! 15:54:40 Antoine: in F2F meeting: long discussion in vocabulary design 15:54:44 q+ 15:55:02 i don't remember that... 15:55:06 ... has this been captured in the F2F outcomes 15:55:09 ack TomB 15:55:09 TomB, you wanted to propose that we give Jeff an action to describe the process of design discussion 15:55:15 Emma: Yes, has been captured 15:55:52 ... and distributed 15:56:13 ack me 15:56:27 q+ to clarify whether Jeff's action to review the UK document is closed - in the minutes it has been reopened as a new action 15:56:48 ACTION: for each use case champion: on the Vocabularies page, link to each URL use case that uses it [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/lld/minutes/2010/10/23‑lld‑minutes.html#action01] 15:56:56 -- continues 15:57:02 ongoing 15:57:24 zakim, ack TomB 15:57:24 TomB, you wanted to clarify whether Jeff's action to review the UK document is closed - in the minutes it has been reopened as a new action 15:57:27 I see no one on the speaker queue 15:58:19 Topic : Other wiki pages 15:58:43 NOTE: Action on Jeff re: UK eGov is DONE - "NEW" action for the same should be deleted. 15:58:46 ACTION: William: to summarize options for using CKAN to the list, before next concall [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2010/11/11‑lld‑minutes.html#action01] 15:58:49 -- continues 15:59:26 Cannot discuss other points. Will discuss next time 15:59:43 Topic : F2F after SWIB in Cologne 15:59:55 q+ to propose that Zakim be reserved for the informal meeting for purposes of scribing 16:00:01 Joachim has send an email and asked who will attend the meeting 16:00:16 ... at the moment: eight participants 16:00:41 ... should work out an agenda what to discuss 16:00:52 ... maybe: where are open ends? 16:01:07 Antoine: will be an informal meeting 16:01:17 ... don't need a formal agenda 16:01:26 -edsu 16:01:29 +1 16:01:59 -AlexanderH 16:02:13 People who shall participate at SWIB please stay on after the teleconference to discuss meeting 16:02:50 TomB: proposes that Zakim be reserved for informal meeting 16:03:00 ack TomB 16:03:00 TomB, you wanted to propose that Zakim be reserved for the informal meeting for purposes of scribing 16:03:12 Antoine: adjourns the teleconference 16:03:29 -pmurray 16:03:30 -kcoyle 16:03:31 thanks! 16:03:31 -jeff_ 16:03:33 -Andras 16:03:34 rrsagent, please draft minutes 16:03:34 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html antoine 16:03:34 -Andras.a 16:03:37 -digikim 16:03:38 -Asaf 16:03:38 rrsagent, please draft minutes 16:03:38 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/18-lld-minutes.html emma 16:03:39 jeff_ has left #lld 16:03:40 -aconstan 16:03:42 -rsinger 16:03:44 -kefo 16:03:46 -marcia 16:04:37 Antoine: I am conveying to you best regards from Dov Winer of the National Library of Israel. :) 16:04:42 (and MINERVA) 16:05:49 still here, not sure if I'll make it 16:06:22 aconstan has left #lld 16:10:06 I think we can plan a summary on the next telecon, it would be fine enough maybe 16:11:58 -TomB 16:13:59 got to run! 16:14:03 -Jodi 16:14:18 jodi has left #LLD 16:15:21 -emma 16:24:58 -kai 16:25:00 -AnetteS 16:25:08 -antoine 16:25:47 -jneubert 16:25:49 INC_LLDXG()10:00AM has ended 16:25:51 Attendees were antoine, TomB, AnetteS, aconstan, jeff_, kai, kefo, +aaaa, +1.678.235.aabb, AlexanderH, pmurray, +1.423.463.aacc, +44.361.279.aadd, marcia, Jodi, +49.4.aaee, 16:25:53 ... rsinger, jneubert, edsu, digikim, Andras, +33.1.53.79.aaff, emma, kcoyle, Asaf 18:24:24 Zakim has left #lld 18:26:08 mhausenblas has left #lld 19:56:15 danbri has joined #lld 21:31:56 danbri_ has joined #lld 21:34:08 danbri has joined #lld 21:39:13 ksclarke has left #lld 22:02:48 ksclarke has joined #lld 22:04:12 ksclarke has left #lld