IRC log of tpac on 2010-11-03

Timestamps are in UTC.

07:11:27 [RRSAgent]
RRSAgent has joined #tpac
07:11:27 [RRSAgent]
logging to http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-irc
07:12:33 [Jean-Gui]
Zakim, call Forum_2
07:12:33 [Zakim]
sorry, Jean-Gui, I don't know what conference this is
07:13:31 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
07:14:05 [wcarr]
will the audio stream be listed here?
07:14:38 [anne]
anne has joined #tpac
07:15:05 [anne]
what is the room for the plenary day?
07:15:25 [martin]
martin has joined #tpac
07:15:56 [hsivonen]
hsivonen has joined #tpac
07:23:26 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
07:25:04 [anne]
no mention of RDF
07:25:12 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
07:25:46 [anne]
RDF draws first blood?
07:26:38 [Wuk]
Wuk has joined #TPAC
07:26:39 [ddeutsch]
ddeutsch has joined #tpac
07:26:48 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
07:26:58 [Nobu]
Nobu has joined #tpac
07:27:20 [jeanne]
jeanne has joined #tpac
07:27:35 [bubbles]
bubbles has joined #tpac
07:27:38 [glazou]
glazou has joined #tpac
07:27:39 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
07:27:55 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
07:28:02 [dsr]
dsr has joined #tpac
07:28:38 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
07:28:43 [jun]
jun has joined #tpac
07:28:43 [burnsy]
burnsy has joined #tpac
07:28:53 [marie]
marie has joined #tpac
07:28:54 [kaz]
kaz has joined #tpac
07:29:11 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
07:29:15 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
07:29:26 [ilkka]
ilkka has joined #tpac
07:29:29 [glazou]
nobody minuting ?
07:29:29 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
07:29:36 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
07:29:40 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
07:29:43 [paulc]
paulc has joined #tpac
07:29:46 [Norm]
Norm has joined #tpac
07:29:47 [MichaelC_]
MichaelC_ has joined #tpac
07:29:57 [glazou]
... fill the WBS form and give us feedback
07:30:01 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
07:30:01 [amy]
meeting: TPAC
07:30:03 [rigo]
rigo has joined #tpac
07:30:05 [amy]
scribe: amy
07:30:06 [glazou]
... now moderator for first session
07:30:16 [glazou]
tx amy
07:30:18 [amy]
agenda: http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/ACAgenda
07:30:31 [masinter`]
masinter` has joined #tpac
07:30:41 [amy]
Noah: as Jeff said, the theme for this session is integration
07:31:03 [sasan]
sasan has joined #tpac
07:31:14 [kojiishi]
kojiishi has joined #tpac
07:31:16 [jeff]
jeff has joined #tpac
07:31:24 [ArtB]
ArtB has joined #tpac
07:31:32 [amy]
... one other thing. many of you know I am chair of the TAG. it is the senior technical body responsible for the web. the reason I mention this is that 5 of our 9 members are chosen by election. This year 3 are up for election. Having you choose the best people is important to our success.
07:31:40 [martin]
martin has joined #tpac
07:31:42 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
07:31:55 [mnot]
mnot has joined #tpac
07:31:59 [amy]
... it's always the case when I someone says "you should work on security", I think "do we have security experts on the TAG."
07:32:25 [anne]
anne has joined #tpac
07:32:29 [danielp_]
danielp_ has joined #tpac
07:32:43 [libby]
libby has joined #tpac
07:32:45 [amy]
... skills which are needed are both technical ones and integration. we also need to solve real problems for real people. we need people who can work well with others (and who can also write)
07:33:13 [Steven]
Steven has joined #tpac
07:33:27 [Nobu]
Nobu has left #tpac
07:33:40 [amy]
... it's important we have a good slate of strong candidates. current or former TAG are here, i encourage you to speak to them, and to look at the TAG pages. Raman asked me to say that he is one of the incumbents who is not running. You'd be welcome to speak to him
07:33:47 [ted]
ted has joined #tpac
07:34:00 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
07:34:02 [pererik]
pererik has joined #tpac
07:34:19 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
07:34:31 [lgombos_w]
lgombos_w has joined #tpac
07:34:36 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
07:34:45 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
07:34:54 [johnjan]
johnjan has joined #tpac
07:35:10 [amy]
... our first speaker is Jeni Tennison. The Semantic Web has had increasing success in government, etc. The SW has not seemed to reach the same velocity as early web. We've invited Jeni as she's one of people that the smartest, most tasteful people look up to
07:35:19 [davy]
davy has joined #tpac
07:35:23 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
07:35:26 [mgylling]
mgylling has joined #tpac
07:35:32 [nick]
nick has joined #tpac
07:35:33 [MikeSmith]
MikeSmith has joined #tpac
07:35:37 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
07:35:41 [amy]
Jeni: Thank you for that kind introduction. One of my roles is that I am the linked data advisor on Linked Data gov. uk
07:35:43 [jeanne]
zakim, code?
07:35:43 [Zakim]
sorry, jeanne, I don't know what conference this is
07:35:54 [koalie]
koalie has joined #tpac
07:36:22 [amy]
.... I'm not a SW evangelist. years ago I thought SW was a pipe dream. now i view my role as making sure not just to used linked data "because Tim Berners-Lee says so". I want to make sure that RDF works.
07:36:26 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
07:36:38 [amy]
... I don't particularly care whether RDF or SW reach escape velocity. I care whether data is useful.
07:36:55 [amy]
... working w/ gov sites is like working w/ the WWW but with more committees
07:37:11 [amy]
... I'll explain what i see as the the hurdles, and where the community and W3C should focus
07:37:30 [amy]
... I've taken this as an excuse to have a bit of a rant and say things i wouldn't normally say to people's faces
07:37:40 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
07:37:45 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
07:37:54 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
07:38:04 [amy]
... the world is very different from 10 years ago when I said SW wouldn't work. there is a lot of effort to use data in many ways
07:38:18 [amy]
... many of these uses, visualization, they're like pre-web. no way to go deeper into the data
07:38:22 [eliot]
eliot has joined #tpac
07:38:32 [dvdeurse]
dvdeurse has joined #tpac
07:38:38 [paoloba]
paoloba has joined #tpac
07:38:41 [dom]
dom has changed the topic to: TPAC Plenary day http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/PlenaryAgenda | Back channel in #tpac-chat
07:38:41 [pauld]
pauld has joined #tpac
07:38:44 [Steven]
zakim, list
07:38:44 [Zakim]
I see no active conferences and none scheduled to start in the next 15 minutes
07:38:51 [wonsuk]
wonsuk has joined #tpac
07:38:52 [amy]
... I think we're heading toward a world where we'll want deeper interaction w/ data. "data you can click on" (a Stuart Williams phrase) will be useful
07:38:58 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
07:39:09 [amy]
... However, just because you can get a hold of data doesn't mean you can use it
07:39:11 [shepazu]
shepazu has joined #tpac
07:39:15 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
07:39:17 [amy]
... (shows excel on crime data)
07:39:22 [adrianba]
adrianba has joined #tpac
07:39:57 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
07:40:04 [amy]
... What do these rows relate to? what is the definition of an acquaintance? what we often find w/ gov data is that the data is available but how you interpret it is hidden so there's no way of finding what it means
07:40:37 [Norm]
Norm has joined #tpac
07:40:51 [amy]
... also, to understand changes we need either links or implicit information. to get deeper interaction we need more sources
07:41:18 [nick]
nick has joined #tpac
07:41:41 [amy]
... RDF is a good approach to tackle these challenges. identifying things w/ uris helps in several ways. you can create mashups which link to things. you can also get extra info at the link, extra context
07:41:49 [claudio_]
claudio_ has joined #tpac
07:41:52 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
07:42:00 [amy]
... you get a value model that lets you combine extra value w/out terms, end user agreements, etc
07:42:20 [amy]
... The other thing is that info w/ uris can be referenced not copied. For eg: BBC uses wikipedia
07:42:49 [sasan]
sasan has joined #tpac
07:42:50 [amy]
... There are huge opportunities for the reference vs. copy info. Prevents out of date info too. Referencing using URIs is increasingly familiar
07:42:56 [yongil_jang]
yongil_jang has joined #tpac
07:43:08 [raman]
raman has joined #tpac
07:43:11 [amy]
... Why is it that RDF is not being used? Let's see what developers say
07:43:15 [francois]
francois has joined #tpac
07:43:35 [amy]
... I was delighted that the Guardian data blog "it's not great fun learning to develop with the semantic web today"
07:43:49 [amy]
... i'm going to try to put myself in dev shoes and see why not
07:44:02 [raman]
network going up and down like a yoyo
07:44:03 [amy]
... (shows RDF stack) it even looks like it's going to fall over on you
07:44:22 [amy]
... they get to see the ugliest syntax first. They think they have to use OWL
07:44:41 [amy]
... none fo this is really true but it's what people assume when they think they have to start here
07:45:04 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
07:45:08 [callie_]
callie_ has joined #TPAC
07:45:12 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
07:45:24 [amy]
... If you're consuming this data, is it fun and atttractive? if you compare to JSON, there's an easy map. there are parsers on every platform. even on XML there are standard APIs and simple path languges like CSS
07:45:31 [davy]
davy has joined #tpac
07:45:43 [Nobu]
Nobu has joined #tpac
07:45:47 [amy]
... The RDF situtaiton is different. there are multiple syntaxes (lists names)
07:46:03 [Yves]
Yves has joined #tpac
07:46:25 [shepazu]
great slides.
07:46:29 [amy]
... It's really hard to know as a publisher what to target and as a developer to know what to expect. There's no standard API to use in code, there's no path language. SPARQL is as close as you get but this is just another language for people to learn.
07:46:33 [shepazu]
and great point.
07:46:37 [janina]
janina has joined #tpac
07:46:38 [amy]
... as a consumer of data it's not fun to use
07:46:51 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
07:46:52 [amy]
... Another question. Is it painless, is it likely to go wrong?
07:47:08 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
07:47:11 [libby_]
libby_ has joined #tpac
07:47:17 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
07:47:20 [amy]
... Generally if you're generating RDF from another structure, you're using technologies like trying to use string cancatonation
07:47:21 [plh]
plh has joined #tpac
07:47:32 [amy]
... there are a vast array of formats, difficult to use
07:47:53 [paoloba]
s/cancatonation/concatenation/
07:48:17 [amy]
... Microdata, new proposal is quite verbose. look at RDFa, using a single vocabulary, having to fudge between languages
07:48:24 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
07:48:41 [amy]
... I've covered the issues, now I"ll look at what we should do
07:49:01 [amy]
... if Developers are going to be pursuaded to work w/ RDF, RDF needs to meet them
07:49:09 [amy]
... we need easy to follow recipes
07:49:23 [amy]
... we need to focus on the benefits that can be brought to end users
07:49:35 [amy]
... we need to be able to reach behind a visualization for the source of data
07:50:11 [igarashi]
igarashi has joined #tpac
07:50:15 [amy]
... we need to make sure that using RDF increases the value of data, that it gives the ability to control context. a good argument for gov
07:50:24 [amy]
... the more people who use it, the more powerful it becomes
07:50:39 [amy]
... we now have some core hubs - dbpedia, musicBrainz, BBC
07:50:59 [amy]
.. and we have vocabularies which reduces the need for invention which ups the rate of use
07:51:00 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
07:51:04 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
07:51:18 [amy]
... also we have the "everyone else is using it, I should too"
07:51:28 [vivien]
vivien has joined #tpac
07:51:36 [amy]
... Linked Data focuses on the useful core technologies. they've created guides and best practices
07:51:54 [glazou_]
glazou_ has joined #tpac
07:52:04 [amy]
... we need the publication of data easier for cosumers. then people can make educated choices about how to publish data
07:52:16 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
07:52:24 [amy]
... On the consumption side, there's a generic RDF API w/in API. There's a potential for a path language
07:52:39 [amy]
... What we need is something accessible and fun and easy to use, not XML's DOM
07:52:42 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
07:52:46 [amy]
... it needs to be used in other contexts
07:52:50 [fjh]
fjh has joined #tpac
07:52:57 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
07:52:59 [paoloba]
s/cosumers/consumers/
07:53:06 [amy]
... On the mapping of relational structures in RDF - my concern if they'll be used
07:53:22 [amy]
I've tried to focus on meeting the challenges on this gradually blossoming Web of Data.
07:53:40 [toto]
toto has joined #tpac
07:53:50 [amy]
... I think it's powerful but it's being avoided due to stigma and misperception. Focus on logic etc. which for publishing data is irrelevant
07:54:02 [kaz]
kaz has joined #tpac
07:54:05 [AnnBassetti]
AnnBassetti has joined #tpac
07:54:21 [amy]
... What role can W3C play? I've thought long and hard. it's hard to answer. the biggest gaps are in implementations. W3C blessing can help w/ what implemantions to use
07:54:30 [tlr]
tlr has joined #tpac
07:54:40 [amy]
... Supporting the profile of RDF - what is currently considered relevant and primers on this
07:55:02 [dom_bis]
dom_bis has joined #tpac
07:55:06 [amy]
... W3C could also provide a home for community standards. it's hard to trust a vocabularly run by a single person, especially from a gov perspective
07:55:28 [Ian]
Jeni: W3C could sideline "sem web" term and focus on linked data
07:55:33 [amy]
... W3C could also help by sidelingin on 'Semantic web' term and focus on "Linked Data"
07:55:36 [Bert]
Bert has joined #tpac
07:55:47 [cmsmcq]
cmsmcq has joined #tpac
07:55:49 [dom_bis]
s/gin/ing/
07:56:01 [amy]
... like every community, Linked data is insular and in some ways deaf to outside concerns. We only grow if we listen and change
07:56:01 [dom_bis]
s/Linked Data/Web of Data/
07:56:12 [hYamada]
hYamada has joined #tpac
07:56:25 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
07:56:29 [dom_bis]
s/Web of Data is insular/Linked Data is insular/
07:56:31 [amy]
... W3C has a wide range of members, it's you, not the SW community, to listen to. Look again at SW, help the web of data blossom into something beautiful
07:56:32 [fjh]
effectively repositioning from technology focus to application focus?
07:56:40 [dom_bis]
s/"Linked Data"/"Web of Data"/
07:57:05 [masao]
masao has joined #tpac
07:57:18 [jose-lap]
jose-lap has joined #tpac
07:57:31 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
07:57:59 [Klaus]
Klaus has joined #tpac
07:58:17 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
07:58:24 [amy]
Doug Shepers, W3C: I've tried SW w/ SVG. I keep bumping into not finding the right ontology to solve the problem I"m trying to solve. I've seen some efforts to consolidate ontologies. I want a reference - publishing, animals, etc. - to tell me where related ontologies exist. It's impossible to dig into all fo them . Do you think there's value in W3C making an effort into unifying ontologies
07:58:29 [scottvesey]
scottvesey has joined #tpac
07:59:29 [amy]
Jeni: I do think that there's legs to that. There's something in the Gov data IG to help recommend to govs which ontologies to use. and how to assess whether one is good to use. it's hard to understand which to use, it's about community and acceptance. what tools are available, is it maintained.
07:59:38 [amy]
... I think this means you need to have curated vs. searchable lists
07:59:46 [amy]
... I think this is role W3C can play
08:00:14 [amy]
Jeff: great talk. great graphics. thank you. You talked about insularity of W3C and SW technoglogies. This is a fair comment. a lot of problems are implimentation
08:00:55 [amy]
... Can you recommend one specific tangible thing we could do tomorrow to break insularity? getting the topic on the table is one step. but how do we change this?
08:01:08 [nick]
nick has joined #tpac
08:01:38 [amy]
Jeni: Good question. i did on a previous set of slides that developers won't get involved w/ something they dont' care about. The only time people would get involved is when you start reaching out and affect other things. Eg: people looked at RDFa when it was encroaching on HTML
08:01:59 [amy]
... a subversive thing would be to go into other areas, to listen to any objections
08:02:10 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
08:02:28 [amy]
... I've found the best way to work out what is wrong w/ a technology is to try to teach it. creating primers helps you understand where people might struggle
08:03:40 [nick1]
nick1 has joined #tpac
08:03:46 [amy]
Noah: You've made clear that ease of use is a challenge and implementations. two threads in how to make complex technolgies easier to use is to simplfy. the other is to keep underlying technology complex but to have tools
08:03:52 [caroline]
caroline has joined #tpac
08:04:06 [amy]
... does W3C need to make simplier technologies or do people need to make tools?
08:04:07 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
08:04:11 [AnnBassetti]
AnnBassetti has joined #tpac
08:04:17 [amy]
Jeni: I think if you need tools it's too complex
08:05:12 [amy]
Roger Cutler, Chevron: You said that the W3C doesn't do things like implementation. Suppose that w3C might do something because there's no place else it's going to get done. if you took that as a starting point, what then could the W3C do along these lines to aid?
08:05:59 [amy]
Jeni: I think that creating a target language a really good parser and API that was well packaged, easy to install. That would be my suggestion. Something actually finished and completed w/ professional quality
08:06:05 [fsasaki]
fsasaki has joined #tpac
08:06:22 [nick]
nick has joined #tpac
08:06:34 [seungjae]
seungjae has joined #tpac
08:06:58 [amy]
Noah: our next talk is by Tim to discuss an effort by him and the TAG on aligning XML and HTML
08:07:35 [amy]
TimBL: This is a topic that's been discussed on lists and meetings like here at length, difficult and hard decisions
08:07:40 [mcf]
mcf has joined #tpac
08:07:58 [amy]
... it tends to be a rat hole because there are lots of related intertwined issues both technically and historically
08:07:58 [koalie]
Topic: XML/HTML convergence, by Tim Berners-Lee
08:08:00 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
08:08:21 [amy]
... what happened recently is that Raman sent a message saying we should fix it. "form a TF to look at the problem"
08:08:25 [lgombos_w_]
lgombos_w_ has joined #tpac
08:08:43 [amy]
... at the end of this presentation there are links including one to this message
08:09:12 [amy]
... there's a serious need for this, a whole community using XML tools to produce their websites. Sometimes they produce XHTML, sometimes XML, often serve as HTML mime type.
08:09:24 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
08:09:25 [laurent]
laurent has joined #tpac
08:09:35 [FabGandon]
FabGandon has joined #tpac
08:09:45 [amy]
... they've benefited from the stuff being in XML, they can scrape site in XML. There's a community used to using these tools. Meanwhile the def of HTML has divorced itself from XML
08:09:46 [dom]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/ TimBL's slides
08:10:01 [amy]
... you can serialize this stuff in XML but most webpages can't be straighforwardly parsed
08:10:18 [Kai]
Kai has joined #tpac
08:10:39 [amy]
... one way to define a goal for this work Raman asked for is: 1. to see how much power we can give to the community that uses XML tools 2. to look at the future, to see whether divergence can be decreased, have convergence later on
08:11:18 [hendry]
hendry has joined #tpac
08:11:21 [amy]
... what i"m not going to do is go into details of the technical arguments. The TAG has gone into a number of them. There have been lots of suggestions to tweak HTML or XML. This is just an announcement that we'll make this TF - we'll have people on TAG and people not on TAG
08:11:44 [amy]
... I'm not yet announcing who is on the TF. but for those who are new, there are various areas where HMTL and XML have diverged
08:12:00 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
08:12:01 [amy]
... HTML will cope w/ <b> <i> </b></i>
08:12:28 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
08:12:57 [glazou]
+1 !!!!
08:12:58 [amy]
... there are tricky things where you can send page to XML and XHTML parser, but the famous one is <tbody> inserted by XML parser. but if you write a script that goes through the DOM it will miss the first <tr>
08:13:00 [kennyluck]
kennyluck has joined #tpac
08:13:00 [dom]
http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/#%283%29
08:13:06 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
08:13:18 [amy]
... tricky little things like that. The center of this is in difference in irC
08:13:28 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
08:14:01 [amy]
... it's a complicated issue w/ syntax w/out namespaces but a namespace gets generated
08:14:17 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
08:14:27 [Steven]
Steven has joined #tpac
08:14:35 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
08:14:37 [amy]
... One trick is for mime types which use XHTML, could have parts set up by default. you know you'll get namespaces every time by default
08:14:49 [amy]
... doesn't have to be sent across net every time
08:15:00 [Ralph]
[slide 3]
08:15:07 [Ralph]
[slide 3: Divergence Dimensions]
08:15:37 [amy]
... I put in completely separate bullet is that XML requires attributes. dont' ask me why. it's down on the list as it's a silly problem. easy to see how to map
08:15:52 [amy]
... The last one is a big issue - distributed extensibility
08:16:14 [Ralph]
i/... tricky little things/[slide 3: Divergence Dimensions]
08:16:24 [dom]
http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/#%284%29 slide 4
08:16:28 [amy]
... what does this mean anyway? The need is that if one WG makes a spec, that a sub community using the spec, eg: HTML. they can use HTML and put in tags
08:16:44 [Ralph]
[slide 4: Polyglot]
08:16:51 [amy]
... Let me mention that the polygot document is important
08:16:58 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
08:16:58 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
08:17:00 [MichaelC_]
MichaelC_ has joined #tpac
08:17:22 [amy]
... this document describes how to generate an XML document and put on web as though both XML and HTML there are traps to avoid. this polygot spec tells you what they are
08:17:28 [koalie]
RRSAgent, make logs public
08:17:53 [amy]
... It constrains the syntax (eg: lower case here). don't put in noscript. If you're trying to do this sometimes there are choices eg: <tbody>
08:18:40 [dom]
[slide5: Polygot] http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/#%285%29
08:18:41 [amy]
... Polygot document very useful. I find the stuff I write is polygot. i forget and tidy them as HTML but keep them as XML
08:18:43 [Ian]
Note to TPAC participants: Please no flash photos.
08:18:43 [Ian]
Thank you.
08:18:46 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
08:18:48 [johnjan]
johnjan has joined #tpac
08:19:00 [amy]
... Polygot is important.
08:19:19 [koalie]
chair: Jeff
08:19:36 [dom]
[slide6: Distributed Extensibility] http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/#%286%29
08:19:37 [amy]
... Distributed extensibility isn't just a quirk. It's a difference in values and what people felt were important things to optimize for
08:20:27 [amy]
... On one hand, you say to have interoperability use one syntax. on the other hand, use different syntax, new functionality creeps into system
08:20:45 [amy]
... it's how internet protocols and HTML has arisen in the past. I'd like to look at different examples
08:20:49 [user]
user has joined #tpac
08:21:02 [amy]
... one example of extensibility is adding SVG to HTML. SVG has always been something which should be in HTML
08:21:32 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
08:21:34 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
08:21:38 [amy]
... now SVG has been adopted by HTML5. the HTML5 spec now tells you how to put in SVG (instead of pointing at SVG spec). now you can put an SVG tag in by itself
08:21:46 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
08:21:53 [nwidell]
nwidell has joined #tpac
08:21:59 [amy]
... SVG is being incorporated and a discussion of how to make this happen is happening in HTML
08:22:02 [Steven]
http://www.w3.org/TR/XHTMLplusMathMLplusSVG/ XHTML+SVG+MathML (2002)
08:22:18 [Ralph]
s/in HTML/in the HTML Working Group
08:22:18 [amy]
... OTher issue is RDFa, a way to put explicit semantics in a web page. There's a different WG. should be an extension to HTML
08:22:35 [amy]
... Design Authority for this extension is a different group. There's a framework for coordination
08:22:59 [amy]
... Now you have Facebook ML, we found out about it. they use namespaces, they didn't ask us, they didn't check w/ HTML
08:23:35 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
08:23:36 [amy]
... lots of such examples. If an editor saves information about it's current state or version info, there are many things people put in HTML. groups don't want to come and check w/ W3C
08:23:56 [amy]
.... Distributed extensibility means there are a lot of ppl out there who need to use namespaces.
08:24:10 [amy]
... if you have a domain name, you can have a namespace
08:24:28 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
08:24:38 [caribou]
caribou has joined #tpac
08:24:46 [amy]
... Important to note there is a scale - distributed to extensible
08:24:56 [amy]
... video tags in HTML is obviously happening.
08:25:16 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
08:25:18 [amy]
... The philisophical question is how to value the needs of the people at the bottom of the list vs people at the top of the list
08:25:21 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
08:25:34 [Ralph]
[slide 7: Scope/Timescale]
08:25:34 [masinter]
masinter has joined #tpac
08:25:39 [danbri]
danbri has joined #tpac
08:25:39 [amy]
... This is not a short term thing. won't be expected to produce comments for last call (maybe will, who knows)
08:25:46 [amy]
... Look for a future path to minimize damage
08:25:49 [dom]
[slide 7 Scope/Timescale] http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/1103-tpac-tbl/#%286%29
08:25:50 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:26:15 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html kennyluck
08:26:19 [amy]
... i respect Raman for raising the temperature here. He said: this is important. everything which has two stacks which is divergent, there's pain for engineering.
08:26:23 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
08:26:43 [amy]
... We should look at this, we have large number of people in groups working on low level. it's good to step back and ask whether this is right
08:26:51 [Ralph]
[slide 8: Links]
08:27:33 [amy]
Daniel Glazman, ? : HTML had issues in the start. i think that what you call divergence is XML 2.0 where namespaces are less important
08:28:04 [amy]
... I think this is the future. it's possibly the right time to start thinking about the future of XML. XML as the way it is now is maybe not the best thing for the web on a daily baiss
08:28:14 [RogerChevron]
RogerChevron has joined #tpac
08:28:28 [amy]
@@Henri S?@@
08:28:47 [Yves]
s/@@Henri S?@@/Henri Sivonen/
08:28:51 [tlr]
tlr has joined #tpac
08:28:55 [yjang]
yjang has joined #tpac
08:29:06 [amy]
Henri: I've impleimented an HTML 5 parser that exposes the API and co-erces the doc tree into an @@. you can connect them. There's also an HTML serializer
08:29:19 [amy]
... I think this is a solved problem w/ parsers and tools and serializers
08:29:55 [Steven]
s/imple/impl/
08:30:25 [Steven]
s/implimented/implemented/
08:30:27 [amy]
Noah: next speaker Janina Sajka and expert on accessibility. She'll give us an overview in integrating accessibility features
08:30:49 [dsinger]
dsinger has joined #tpac
08:30:53 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
08:31:03 [weinig]
weinig has joined #tpac
08:31:18 [Steven]
rrsagent, make minutes
08:31:18 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Steven
08:31:26 [amy]
Janina: thank you for the invitation to be here. I'm not going to try to talk about everything going on in accessibility
08:31:38 [mgylling_]
mgylling_ has joined #tpac
08:31:58 [amy]
... i'm going to try to talk about things I want the wider W3C community to be aware of. HTML is giving us opportunities we haven't previously had w/ specifications which do their best to support accessibility
08:32:05 [toto_]
toto_ has joined #tpac
08:32:41 [dom]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/JS-HTML_A11Y-20101103/ Janina's slides
08:32:46 [amy]
... We've heard the word accessibility. when I say it I'm talking about people who don't see or hear. There's a newer group of those who don't see or hear as well as most in this room. This group is coming and the implications are exciting but let's get there
08:33:02 [dom]
[slide 1: Introduction]
08:33:05 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
08:33:10 [amy]
... I'm Janina Sajka. I chair PFWG and co-facilitate HTML Accessibility TF
08:33:49 [amy]
... also at the Linux foundation and editing a document for ISO
08:33:54 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
08:34:15 [amy]
... a lot of background in advocacy and in systems deployment
08:34:38 [amy]
... that the professional side but i come first as a consumer
08:35:29 [amy]
... Accessibility really does change lives, it doesn't make them see gives them info they might have seen. doesn't make people see, but gives them words. We want to make sure you don't need a mouse. We're looking to the same things as everyone else on the web. regardless of sensory or motor ability
08:35:35 [dom]
[slide 2: WAI-ARIA—Our 1.0 Story]
08:35:59 [Hixie]
Hixie has joined #tpac
08:36:17 [amy]
... In PF we have ARIA. We're closing in on 1.0. It gives us a language independent way to support access
08:36:26 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
08:36:27 [jjeon]
jjeon has joined #tpac
08:36:47 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
08:37:05 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
08:37:13 [amy]
... it gives a series of standard kinds of tool, controls, interfaces. It's going to be very important. it's our consistent way of dealing w/ similar things regardless of host language
08:37:18 [dom]
[slide 3 : Intentional Events—Our Newest Story]
08:37:22 [pdengler]
pdengler has joined #tpac
08:37:34 [amy]
... Something brand new to us, not to W3C, we've got the opportunity to do "intentional events"
08:37:42 [MMichel76]
MMichel76 has joined #tpac
08:37:48 [Ralph]
s/3 :/4 :/
08:38:14 [amy]
... (undo, zoom, etc). how to map keyboard for undo or zoom, or intentional events common in application interfaces but very different in languages
08:38:29 [AnnB]
AnnB has joined #tpac
08:38:49 [johnjan]
johnjan has joined #TPAC
08:39:00 [fjh_]
fjh_ has joined #tpac
08:39:01 [amy]
... idea is to get to work on developing technology. We're being driven here because it's not just mouse, etc. but voice interfaces, etc. It's a whole range of different ways we don't need authors to stumble across
08:39:31 [amy]
... It looks like this will happen in Web Events. this may change but it's our newest story. so stay tuned. we think the implications are far wider than just accessibility
08:39:32 [dom]
[slide 5: The HTML Accessibility Task Force Story]
08:39:49 [Luca_]
Luca_ has joined #tpac
08:39:50 [timbl_]
timbl_ has joined #TPAC
08:40:01 [amy]
... Moving on the HTML 5 TF. We formed this together w/ PF + HTML. to work on accessibility recommendations for HTML spec.
08:40:28 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
08:40:45 [amy]
... many of our recommendations have been picked up. A few to highlight: Aria. you can not incorporate so have to map ARIA to HTML
08:41:04 [Luca_]
Luca_ has left #tpac
08:41:06 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:41:28 [amy]
... we hope at the end of the day we'll have essentially the same technology for Aria 1.0. We're not quite there yet. this is key expectation esp for applications new in HTML5. should make browsing far more compelling
08:41:31 [davy]
davy has joined #tpac
08:41:57 [amy]
... Canvas - bitmap, no concept of structure, no @@carrot@@. We've got some solutions there
08:42:13 [Ralph]
s/@@carrot@@/caret/
08:42:13 [hsivonen]
s/carrot/caret/
08:42:16 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
08:42:22 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:42:31 [amy]
... We want to make sure that canvas technologies are taken to an extent that HTML5 might rather they weren't. Eg: write @@ text in canvas
08:42:51 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:42:53 [Ralph]
Janina: without a caret to focus on, how can one programmatically know where to focus a screen magnifier for partially-sighted people?
08:42:58 [amy]
... we are pleased to say this is much further along. Lastly, media. This is one of the most transformative changes in HTML5
08:43:26 [yuma_1985]
yuma_1985 has joined #tpac
08:43:26 [amy]
... You can see this happening. go shopping for a TV, you can see some come w/ an RJ45 connector. is this just google or another interface?
08:43:48 [amy]
... a convergence of technologies. We think this will be transformative not just for web but for education
08:44:01 [rahul]
rahul has joined #tpac
08:44:14 [dom]
[slide 6: Meeting User Needs on Accessible Media]
08:44:15 [dezell]
dezell has joined #tpac
08:44:25 [amy]
... It's an enormous challenge to get things right on behalf of accessibility. Fortunately, there's a history here even before the web.
08:44:46 [tlr]
tlr has joined #tpac
08:44:51 [Ralph]
[slide 6: Meeting User Needs on Accessible Media]
08:45:00 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
08:45:07 [amy]
... Analog broadcasting, we call that video description. During the time when no one is talking another, very characteristic voice, describes what is happening so you can grok what is happening or captions on screens.
08:45:27 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
08:45:41 [amy]
... Captions really took off ~25 years ago as result of a law which said that tvs must be sold w/ capacity for decoders
08:46:28 [amy]
... Eg: in a noisy bar, you can turn on caption thing and follow along. This whole area of media accessibility was being called 'captioning'. This is just part of the story. it's improved media capacity
08:46:54 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:46:59 [shawn]
use inclusive language (not just captions) so that we realize the breadth of issues to be addressed
08:47:09 [amy]
... We also have things such as clear audio, now w/ digital broadcasting you can create a submix to take out most of other sound effects to focus mostly on key portions
08:47:12 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
08:47:32 [amy]
... It's a production level thing and being used in UK.
08:48:06 [vtoman]
vtoman has joined #tpac
08:48:10 [amy]
... slides to show how people w/ disabilities are being accommodated in Media
08:48:23 [dom]
[slide 7: Tieing it all Together with Media]
08:48:25 [amy]
... successful industry: e-publishing
08:48:40 [amy]
.. not so important for short YouTube clips, very important for longer lectures, for eg
08:49:00 [naomi]
naomi has joined #tpac
08:49:18 [amy]
... What do these technologies mean in the spec? It's not quite rocket science, it's more like building a bike. Synchronizing media streams
08:49:46 [amy]
... Streamable text, Secondary Audio, Secondary Video
08:50:28 [masinter]
masinter has joined #tpac
08:50:30 [amy]
... We think this is transformative, we think we can deliver in HTML5. Laws have begun to show up, esp in the US, to make sure that devices support access. We'd like to be the solution for the environment instead of having them invent this for us
08:50:38 [dom]
[slide 8: Thank you]
08:51:02 [amy]
... If any of this interests you the Accessibly TF is an open environment. we want the community to be involved. You are welcome and thank you.
08:51:20 [amy]
Noah: we'll take questions
08:51:46 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
08:51:57 [amy]
Sarah @@?: I know there are many different sign language dialects. how do you prevent getting the wrong one
08:52:13 [Ralph]
s/@@/Hart
08:52:16 [amy]
Janina: we hope that there is an option to choose which one to use. There are many which have been defined
08:52:22 [amy]
s/?/
08:52:26 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
08:52:41 [Johnson]
Johnson has joined #tpac
08:53:03 [amy]
Thomas: Alexey is having travel problems
08:53:09 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
08:54:02 [amy]
Noah: Thomas will be speaking for Alexey on the theme of integration and how we work w/ other standards organizations. IETF is one of the most important connections we have. We invited him to speak from the IETF perspective on what it is like to partner w/ us and how to make this more effective
08:55:31 [amy]
Thomas: These slides were prepared by Alexey Melnikov, peter Saint-Andre and Mark Nottingham
08:55:32 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
08:56:00 [amy]
... I'll give a brief intro to the IETF, about how W3C and IETF work together and then Conclusions
08:56:32 [amy]
... You probably all know that the Internet Society is not just helping us but is giving the general framework to IAB, IESG,
08:56:42 [Steven]
Janina mentioned that W3C had earlier tried to define abstract events. Here is an earlier attempt: http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/1.1/intent-based-events.html
08:56:58 [Steven]
(Nov 2003)
08:57:05 [amy]
... IAB - appeals function, architectural guidance.
08:57:33 [amy]
... IETF, we mostly work w/ Applictions. There are directors who manage WG. Collectively they act as IES
08:57:57 [mnot]
s/IES/IESG/
08:58:05 [amy]
... they also fulfill function of reviewing and approving documents. Area directors are reaching out to community for help
08:58:33 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
08:58:34 [amy]
... there are areas of overlap. they're looking for volunteers for review team
08:59:03 [amy]
... Standardization is like and non-alike W3C. You can see cultural difference in slides. you always pick default of slides. There are no formal membership
08:59:06 [shan__]
shan__ has joined #tpac
08:59:09 [noah]
We are working on getting Jeni's slides posted.
08:59:30 [pdengler]
pdengler has joined #tpac
08:59:31 [noah]
Sorry for the delay, we thought we had it covered before the start of the session.
09:00:10 [amy]
... You can go to meeting (paid), participate on lists, etc. Decisions are made on the mailing lists never in the meetings (often in the bar). Of course the physical idea of the meetings are critical however decisions will be ratified in email. similar to how some W3C WG work (thinking Web Apps).
09:00:16 [masinter]
masinter has joined #tpac
09:00:39 [amy]
... They dont' have a royal free policy. They rely on disclosure. There are stringent rules and happen early
09:00:58 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
09:01:18 [amy]
... as you look at implementation experience, if there are IPR issues, it simply won't get traction. This is different than our work but has a bearing on joint work
09:01:39 [amy]
... they have an active tools team which are held in high regard
09:01:50 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
09:02:08 [amy]
... There are hard topics where several people meet to hash out issues. the name for this is "design team"
09:02:19 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
09:03:13 [amy]
... RFCs - it's not a standard. different types. it may be published by an individual, may be published by a group. not all IETF products. even of IETF products may be historical documents 30 years ago, wide variety
09:03:27 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
09:03:41 [amy]
... Some notes on why it functions. They focus on interoperability format. What bits go over the wire. what bits need to go over wire to work
09:03:42 [chaals]
chaals has joined #tpac
09:03:49 [amy]
... Socket API is a notable exception
09:04:00 [amy]
... Traditionally IETF does not do local APIs
09:04:11 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
09:04:26 [amy]
... Attracts a broad range, they're fairly proud of review they get when the process works
09:05:07 [amy]
... Another issue, vast scale of work. In terms of sheer volume there's more going on at IETF. Sometimes competing proposals. They try not to have competing protocols so it's not always possible
09:05:23 [hYamada]
hYamada has joined #tpac
09:05:27 [amy]
... (gives examples). Alexey notes that the IETF usually regrets this
09:05:35 [libby_]
libby_ has joined #tpac
09:05:40 [yuma_1985]
yuma_1985 has joined #tpac
09:05:51 [amy]
... Decision making: there is no voting at IETF. A famous ritual when an issue comes up is the "hum"
09:06:05 [amy]
... a way to get consensus
09:06:15 [amy]
... Why does the IETF not work so well?
09:06:53 [amy]
... W3C is a consumer of IETF standards. MIME, Language tags, IDNA, etc
09:07:03 [amy]
... (skips language text)
09:07:08 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
09:07:28 [amy]
... URI important. now seeing a formal specification for about:
09:07:57 [amy]
... IDNA, allows new characters. permits a few exotic/vital alphabets. That is recent work now seeing deployment
09:08:13 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
09:08:28 [amy]
... Other recent publications. including: well-known URIs. there is now a standard for putting metadata in URI
09:08:40 [naomi]
naomi has joined #tpac
09:08:48 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
09:08:49 [amy]
... Activities: internationalization, URN, OAuth
09:09:07 [Kai]
s/... Why does the IETF not work so well?/... Why does the IETF not work so well? See the previous 2 slides.
09:09:16 [masinter]
masinter has joined #tpac
09:10:02 [amy]
... also joint work, broad definition. XML Signature. started as a joint group. spec currently revising in W3C group that we keep IETF advised on. one issue why we don't do more joint work is our patent policy. on IETF you have disclosure, here we have Patent Policy.
09:10:33 [amy]
... ask Yves Lafon and Julian @@ to stand. they are doing work on @@
09:10:49 [dom]
s/@@ to/Reschke to/
09:10:53 [dom]
s/@@/HTTPBis spec/
09:10:57 [Yves]
s/@@/Reschke/
09:11:01 [amy]
... Joint projects: Cookies are being specified, WebSec, HYBI known as Web Sockets.
09:11:13 [Ralph]
Alexey/Thomas: note that there is finally a formal specification of 'about:' ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/internet-drafts/draft-holsten-about-uri-scheme-04.txt
09:11:29 [amy]
... these are areas where for core architectural issues we work together
09:11:59 [amy]
... Ongoing projects: Workshop on Internet Privacy coming up in December
09:12:09 [amy]
... differences between email and HTTP in MIME type
09:12:23 [amy]
... contact API, several groups working on this
09:12:44 [timeless_xchat]
timeless_xchat has joined #tpac
09:12:58 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
09:13:00 [amy]
... Conclusions: we have a well functioning relationship. it is valued on both sides. some on management/strategic level. some on technical issues. both very important
09:13:04 [FabGandon]
FabGandon has joined #tpac
09:13:21 [amy]
... any questions for the IETF side, I'm happy to introduce Alexey. If questions on W3C please see me
09:13:29 [amy]
Noah: thanks to all speakers
09:13:40 [amy]
... Tim said he's got some specific quesitons
09:14:02 [marie]
marie has joined #tpac
09:14:15 [timeless_mbp]
timeless_mbp has joined #tpac
09:14:15 [amy]
TimBL: I got two comments which I appreciate. One was about architecture in which separate XML and HTML parsers and one on @@
09:14:23 [dezell]
dezell has joined #tpac
09:14:44 [amy]
... when I spoke in 2007 I spoke about this about greater length. Over three and half years, the situation has not gotten simpler.
09:15:07 [dsinger]
dsinger has joined #tpac
09:15:15 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
09:15:18 [paoloba]
paoloba has joined #tpac
09:15:29 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
09:15:33 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
09:15:52 [amy]
... There I discussed moving from both directions, looking for common ground, looking at XML 2.0. There's a significant community who do work on XML but you don't see their work. You don't see this on the web because it's enterprise. We have to make sure that even if we don't see it on the web that we listen to them.
09:16:17 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
09:16:31 [amy]
... Eg: parser that didn't work. You can't just move community to XML 2.0. Personally, I'd do it like a shot. I can see it's a mistake to @something about quotes@
09:17:02 [amy]
... In retrospect we should have done xML way back when DanC asked me is HTML and SGML application or not? and I said yes. He held my feet to the fire but I should have said yes
09:17:06 [windauer]
windauer has left #tpac
09:17:13 [amy]
... There are a huge amount of systems and users we can't forget
09:17:27 [amy]
... It's hugely expensive if it's not compatible.
09:17:31 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
09:17:46 [amy]
... On the other hand there are people in the HTML community who assume XML should come to them because "hello, we're HTML!".
09:17:56 [amy]
... same way, XML community "hello, we're XML"
09:18:01 [Kai]
s/He held my feet to the fire but I should have said yes/He held my feet to the fire but I should have said no
09:18:17 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
09:18:20 [yuma_1985]
yuma_1985 has joined #tpac
09:18:27 [danielp]
danielp has joined #tpac
09:18:44 [amy]
... It's hard to see the point of view of the other side. it's very rarely the people who have gone into all the intricacies of the spec (many in this room have). That is why, I'm afraid, I'm sorry, I took the comments but didn't make a response. I hope this counts as one
09:18:56 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
09:18:56 [amy]
s/rarely the/rare that
09:19:23 [amy]
Noah: announcements: we're about to take a break. I'd strongly encourage you to talk to friends and think of good TAG nominees or speak to current/past TAG members
09:20:04 [amy]
... this room will likely have W3C staff here, we don't know whose machines are whose but there will be people in the room if that helps you make your decision
09:20:11 [amy]
... the break is right outside
09:20:18 [amy]
... be back by 10:45am please
09:20:24 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
09:20:36 [jeff]
jeff has joined #tpac
09:22:47 [ed_tmp]
ed_tmp has joined #tpac
09:23:41 [david_carlisle]
david_carlisle has joined #tpac
09:24:26 [oa]
oa has joined #tpac
09:24:36 [ed]
ed has joined #tpac
09:25:16 [yuma_1985]
yuma_1985 has joined #tpac
09:25:20 [oa]
oa has left #tpac
09:26:44 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
09:27:20 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
09:27:53 [najib]
najib has joined #tpac
09:28:03 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
09:28:03 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
09:28:14 [ed_tmp]
ed_tmp has joined #tpac
09:28:48 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
09:31:00 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
09:31:00 [laurent]
laurent has joined #tpac
09:31:48 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
09:31:48 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
09:32:09 [anthony_work]
anthony_work has joined #tpac
09:33:37 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
09:33:47 [Luca_]
Luca_ has joined #tpac
09:34:18 [Luca_]
Luca_ has left #tpac
09:35:36 [ivan]
ivan has joined #tpac
09:36:10 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
09:37:18 [Fradley]
Fradley has joined #tpac
09:37:32 [beverloo]
beverloo has joined #tpac
09:38:04 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
09:38:17 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
09:39:27 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
09:40:13 [toto]
toto has joined #tpac
09:41:48 [pk2004]
pk2004 has joined #tpac
09:42:47 [Fradley]
can someone expand on what this is about and when everything is going to start?
09:44:29 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
09:46:26 [glazou]
glazou has joined #tpac
09:50:52 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
09:50:53 [jun]
jun has joined #tpac
09:50:58 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
09:51:00 [Jean-Gui]
Jean-Gui has joined #tpac
09:51:16 [amy]
BOF (Birds of a Feather) sign up sheets are in the reception area. please feel free to sign up topics and for lunchs
09:51:23 [alexmilowski]
alexmilowski has joined #tpac
09:51:28 [amy]
s/lunchs/lunches
09:53:00 [alain]
alain has joined #tpac
09:53:20 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
09:53:22 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
09:54:28 [burnsy]
burnsy has joined #tpac
09:54:52 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
09:55:08 [MikeSmith]
scribe: MikeSmith
09:55:31 [Norm]
Norm has joined #tpac
09:55:36 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
09:55:36 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
09:55:37 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
09:55:44 [anne]
anne has joined #tpac
09:55:46 [MikeSmith]
Topic: The New Open Web Client Platform: HTML5, CSS3, and other goodies in action
09:55:56 [rahul]
rahul has joined #tpac
09:56:08 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
09:56:15 [MikeSmith]
[Philippe Le Hégaret introduces the session]
09:56:22 [mgylling]
mgylling has joined #tpac
09:56:33 [MikeSmith]
[Frank Olivier of Microsoft IE team comes to mic]
09:56:48 [martin]
martin has joined #tpac
09:57:00 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
09:57:25 [libby]
libby has joined #tpac
09:57:34 [MikeSmith]
FO: we have been releasing new versions of IE9 platform preview at regular intervals with new standards-based features being added
09:57:40 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
09:57:59 [MikeSmith]
[Frank demos a HTML5/CSS3-based site]
09:58:13 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
09:58:25 [MikeSmith]
FO: we run everything through graphics acceleration, through GPU
09:58:36 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
09:58:44 [MikeSmith]
FO: Performance is one feature that everyone seems to like.
09:59:03 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
09:59:09 [MikeSmith]
[FO shows some SVG love]
09:59:38 [MikeSmith]
FO: critically imporant: developers want to create once, run anywhere
09:59:43 [sasa]
sasa has joined #tpac
09:59:48 [MikeSmith]
… interoperability is imporant
09:59:57 [MikeSmith]
FO: We need more and more test suites.
10:00:08 [FabGandon]
FabGandon has joined #tpac
10:00:16 [MikeSmith]
[FO demos how to zoom around the world over the Web]
10:00:28 [MikeSmith]
FO: this site uses HTML5 canvas
10:00:48 [MikeSmith]
FO: we have been updating our preview every 8 weeks
10:00:59 [darobin]
darobin has joined #tpac
10:01:01 [MikeSmith]
FO: We released IE9 beta on Sep 15
10:01:13 [raphael]
The sites that Frank is demoing: http://www.thekillersmusic.com / http://makethemost.roughguides.com
10:01:18 [MikeSmith]
FO: added 2D transforms recently
10:01:36 [MikeSmith]
FO: http://ie.microsoft.com/testdrive/
10:01:48 [MikeSmith]
[Haakon is on next]
10:02:06 [MikeSmith]
[Haakon Lie on now]
10:02:28 [raman]
raman has joined #tpac
10:02:37 [MikeSmith]
HL: by adding two lines of code in your CSS stylesheets, you can have downloadable fonts in your content
10:02:41 [vivien]
vivien has joined #tpac
10:03:03 [MikeSmith]
HL: text shadow was in CSS in 1998
10:03:13 [MikeSmith]
HL: CSS3 border radius
10:03:23 [MikeSmith]
… this was an request in the CSS1
10:03:39 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
10:03:39 [MikeSmith]
HL: in 1995, I told Bert, nobody is going to want rounded borders
10:03:52 [MikeSmith]
… that is _so_ 1970s
10:04:04 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
10:04:05 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
10:04:10 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
10:04:12 [MikeSmith]
HL: we need to communicate through aesthetics
10:04:27 [MikeSmith]
HL: this is stuff that people used to spend hours and hours doing in Photoshop
10:04:39 [MikeSmith]
… and it can now be done in one line of CSS
10:04:43 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
10:05:37 [MikeSmith]
HL: CSS lets you avoid the need to use images for cases where you don't really need them
10:06:10 [MikeSmith]
HL: Media Queries let you say stuff like, when the screen is narrow, style the content differently
10:06:24 [MikeSmith]
HL: forms are easier now with HTML5
10:06:37 [koalie]
h&kon++ for scary photo in extra narrow window
10:06:47 [kennyluck]
h&kon++
10:06:47 [MikeSmith]
… you can add "autofocus" and "required" attributes
10:06:58 [MikeSmith]
… to form elements
10:07:05 [DanD]
DanD has joined #tpac
10:07:06 [MikeSmith]
… you can specify ranges
10:07:11 [MikeSmith]
… the browser can help you
10:07:17 [Yves]
hkon++ indeed
10:07:36 [MikeSmith]
HL: how many hours have been wasted in the western world creating date pickers?
10:07:40 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
10:07:46 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
10:07:50 [MikeSmith]
… not the user agent can generate the date picker for you
10:07:55 [adrianba]
adrianba has joined #tpac
10:07:57 [MikeSmith]
s/not/now/
10:08:08 [MikeSmith]
HL: this page has text with logical flow
10:08:29 [MikeSmith]
HL: this next page shows SVG
10:08:53 [MikeSmith]
HL: video is the next battle
10:09:00 [MikeSmith]
… we need to find a common format
10:09:22 [MikeSmith]
HL: Google spent a lot of money to acquire WebM, and I think this is it
10:09:36 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
10:09:42 [MikeSmith]
HL: this is the Wikipedia Lexion
10:09:55 [MikeSmith]
… CSS has a paged media module
10:09:59 [wonsuk]
wonsuk has joined #tpac
10:10:15 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
10:10:24 [MikeSmith]
… two years from now, half the books on the NY Time bestseller list will be formattted using HTML and CSS
10:10:34 [MikeSmith]
HL; the printing press
10:10:47 [koalie]
s/HL;/HL:/
10:10:55 [MikeSmith]
… we would know how to use a Gutenberg bible if we had one here today
10:11:14 [MikeSmith]
HL: we need to create standards that will last for 500 years
10:11:18 [Nobu]
Nobu has joined #tpac
10:11:22 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
10:11:22 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
10:11:26 [Peter`]
Peter` has joined #tpac
10:11:27 [rigo]
rigo has joined #tpac
10:11:30 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
10:11:35 [MikeSmith]
[Jonas Sicking from Mozilla]
10:11:50 [MikeSmith]
JS: we are going to show some fancy demos containing lots of fluff
10:11:58 [MikeSmith]
JS: we need to get video on the Web working
10:12:10 [MikeSmith]
JS: we are using CSS transitions in this demo
10:12:32 [MikeSmith]
JS: this demo shows video interacting with the rest of the Web page
10:12:47 [Zakim]
Zakim has left #tpac
10:12:55 [MikeSmith]
JS: we using SVG clipping in here too
10:13:01 [igarashi]
igarashi has joined #tpac
10:13:02 [MikeSmith]
… filters
10:13:02 [Zakim]
Zakim has joined #tpac
10:13:16 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
10:13:21 [marie]
marie has joined #tpac
10:13:28 [MikeSmith]
JS: here is another example that shows a drive through Dubai
10:13:53 [MikeSmith]
… because it is an HTML video instead of a plugin video, we can interact with it much more
10:13:58 [MikeSmith]
… this uses WebGL
10:14:12 [MikeSmith]
… to give a 3D view
10:14:26 [hhalpin]
hhalpin has joined #tpac
10:14:47 [martin]
martin has joined #tpac
10:14:55 [MikeSmith]
[JS turns of CSS to show that the video is displaying 3D at all times, and CSS is used to transform it to an interactive view]
10:15:05 [MikeSmith]
JS: fractals
10:15:11 [MikeSmith]
… real time
10:15:22 [MikeSmith]
… calculated
10:15:28 [MikeSmith]
… and ray tracing
10:15:31 [MikeSmith]
… fully real time
10:15:49 [MikeSmith]
… we are using the graphics cards to do the heavy lifting, all the calculations
10:16:00 [MikeSmith]
[David Baron joins the fray]
10:16:03 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
10:16:03 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
10:16:16 [MikeSmith]
DB: demo of OpenType font features
10:16:22 [MikeSmith]
… fonts have these features already
10:16:38 [MikeSmith]
… but you couldn't use them in Web pages before
10:16:59 [MikeSmith]
… this font in this demo has proportional numerals and automatic fractions
10:17:09 [MikeSmith]
… and for tabular data
10:17:30 [MikeSmith]
… font has better numerals for use in tables, to make it line up nicely
10:17:43 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
10:17:47 [MikeSmith]
… also can access fun features from fonts
10:18:12 [MikeSmith]
DB: can combine WebGL and Audio API
10:18:27 [MikeSmith]
… audio API allows you to get data out of audio elements in the browser
10:19:23 [MikeSmith]
JS: this demo is all WebGL
10:19:35 [MikeSmith]
… integrates with FlickR and Twitter
10:19:57 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
10:20:07 [MikeSmith]
[audio plays while WebGL stuff renders]
10:20:22 [MikeSmith]
JS: We are using the Audio API to do beat detection
10:20:32 [MikeSmith]
… in real time in Javascript
10:20:48 [MikeSmith]
… and then using WebGL to do visualization
10:21:03 [MikeSmith]
[images pulse in time to audio track]
10:21:15 [MikeSmith]
[Philippe Le Hégaret is bak]
10:21:26 [MikeSmith]
PLH: I take questions now
10:21:32 [eliot]
eliot has joined #tpac
10:21:40 [MikeSmith]
[Doug Schepers comes to mic]
10:21:54 [MikeSmith]
shepazu: we are starting an Audio Working Group
10:22:09 [MikeSmith]
shepazu: not just an Incubator group
10:22:23 [timeless_mbp]
s/bak/back/
10:22:32 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
10:22:38 [MikeSmith]
RogerCarlson: Haakon, what are you using for the music notation
10:22:50 [yongil_jang]
yongil_jang has joined #tpac
10:22:53 [MikeSmith]
HL: we are using ABC notation
10:22:53 [koalie]
s/Carlson/Cutler/
10:23:00 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
10:23:09 [IceGuest_77]
IceGuest_77 has joined #tpac
10:23:14 [koalie]
[Claudio Venezia, Telecom Italia]
10:23:18 [MikeSmith]
Claudio: do you plan to address Augmented Reality use cases?
10:23:22 [timeless_mbp]
[ABC - http://abcnotation.com ]
10:23:58 [MikeSmith]
JS: big missing piece is pulling data from a video camera and/or audio input… and getting it into the browser
10:23:59 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
10:24:04 [MikeSmith]
… and how to do streaming
10:24:14 [MikeSmith]
… work is being done on this
10:24:27 [MikeSmith]
PLH: HTML.next session will talk about the proposed <device> element
10:24:34 [koalie]
[Roger Cutler, Chevron]
10:25:01 [MikeSmith]
Roger: there is no standards-based music notation that exports/imports well
10:25:04 [timeless_mbp]
[Sibelius - http://www.sibelius.com/]
10:25:20 [timeless_mbp]
[Finale - http://www.finalemusic.com/]
10:25:24 [MikeSmith]
HL: point is, with a little bit of markup, you can generate music
10:25:26 [francois]
francois has joined #tpac
10:25:35 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
10:25:35 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
10:25:52 [MikeSmith]
Roger: would be nice if some standards body provided a standard for music notation
10:26:08 [MikeSmith]
shepazu: MusicXML guy is in the Audio XG
10:26:12 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
10:26:12 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
10:26:23 [MikeSmith]
[round of applause for the panelists]
10:26:48 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
10:26:51 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/audio/ Audio XG
10:26:54 [MikeSmith]
[next session starts]
10:27:06 [MikeSmith]
[Paul cotton at the mic]
10:27:14 [koalie]
Topic: HTML.next
10:27:19 [timeless_mbp]
[MusicXML - http://www.recordare.com/musicxml ]
10:27:28 [zhang-chinaunicom]
zhang-chinaunicom has joined #tpac
10:27:39 [MikeSmith]
PC: PLH, you owe me 12 minutes
10:27:50 [MikeSmith]
PC: We stand between you all and lunch…
10:28:01 [MikeSmith]
Topic: HTML.next
10:28:09 [koalie]
[Lunch will take place in Forum 3, right next to our room]
10:28:10 [MikeSmith]
PC: I am one of the co-chairs of the HTML WG
10:28:37 [timbl_]
timbl_ has joined #TPAC
10:28:39 [IceGuest_77]
IceGuest_77 has joined #tpac
10:28:40 [rigo]
background http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext.pdf
10:28:42 [MikeSmith]
PC: this session is about answering some of the questions from teh previous session
10:28:52 [MikeSmith]
PC: each speaker gets 10 minutes
10:29:06 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
10:29:11 [MikeSmith]
PC: Patrick Dengler from MSFT will be first
10:29:27 [MikeSmith]
… Larry Masinter has a series of questions to ask you later
10:29:35 [Stuart]
Stuart has joined #tpac
10:29:36 [MikeSmith]
… and this may involve humming, IETF-style
10:29:42 [kohei]
kohei has joined #tpac
10:29:51 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
10:29:52 [mgylling]
mgylling has joined #tpac
10:29:59 [MikeSmith]
[Patrick Dengler steps up to the mic… then steps back]
10:30:14 [MikeSmith]
PD: what an amazing amount of technology is in HTML5 today!
10:30:22 [MikeSmith]
PD: so fantastic
10:30:23 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext.pdf HTML.NEXT PANEL DISCUSSION background materials
10:30:27 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
10:30:30 [MikeSmith]
PD: tectonic shift
10:30:58 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
10:31:08 [MikeSmith]
PD: I believe there is an opportunity for us to finish HTML5
10:31:23 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
10:31:30 [MikeSmith]
PD: developers see a lot of technologies coming together in HTML
10:31:52 [MikeSmith]
PD: we have a chance to bring these together, establish a plateau
10:32:03 [MikeSmith]
PD: ask, are we done with SVG 1.1?
10:32:24 [MikeSmith]
PD: can we agree, these are the modules we can all agree to depend on?
10:32:45 [MikeSmith]
PD: communication is not yet where it needs to be
10:32:53 [wuj]
wuj has joined #tpac
10:33:05 [MikeSmith]
PD: can we find that plateau, just as we did with HTML 3.2 and HTML4
10:33:28 [MikeSmith]
PD: what are the features that I as a developer can depend upon?
10:33:40 [MikeSmith]
PD: we owe more testing to the developers
10:33:51 [yuma_1985]
yuma_1985 has joined #tpac
10:34:19 [MikeSmith]
PD: we don't apply the engineering practices that we have, and take those to the standards committees that we participate in?
10:34:30 [Steven_]
Steven_ has joined #tpac
10:34:32 [MikeSmith]
s/we don/why don/
10:34:34 [wuj]
wuj has joined #tpac
10:34:44 [MikeSmith]
PD: I am not talking about stifling innovation
10:34:59 [MikeSmith]
… some things are vendor-prefixed and still in development
10:35:03 [MikeSmith]
… we don't want to stifle that
10:35:21 [MikeSmith]
PD: let's do a fast, forced pushed with specific timelines
10:35:35 [plh]
plh has joined #tpac
10:35:40 [MikeSmith]
PD: we want "write once" to the @@something@@ WEb
10:35:58 [DKA]
DKA has joined #tpac
10:36:01 [MikeSmith]
PD: this is sorta what's in my paper, see that
10:36:09 [MikeSmith]
[time for questions]
10:36:16 [matt]
s/@@something@@/Ubiquitous/
10:36:20 [MikeSmith]
Jeff Jaffe steps up
10:36:44 [MikeSmith]
JJ: after a release with an incredible amount of functions, the next release is typically a bug-fix release
10:36:52 [francois_]
francois_ has joined #tpac
10:36:52 [MikeSmith]
PD: yeah, there could be a dot release
10:37:01 [MikeSmith]
… but we do not want to spend years on that
10:37:28 [DanD]
DanD has joined #tpac
10:37:35 [MikeSmith]
PD: let's lead with test-driven specs so that we don't have to spend as much time in development next time
10:37:43 [MikeSmith]
Daniel Glazman steps up
10:37:43 [timeless_mbp]
s/WEb/Web/
10:38:00 [MikeSmith]
DG: we have 20,000 test we have been working on for CSS
10:38:09 [darobin]
Election results in SVG, as Patrick requested: http://election2010.talkingpointsmemo.com/all
10:38:09 [MikeSmith]
DG: for HTML5, you are going to have 150,000
10:38:24 [MikeSmith]
… you are not going to finish this until 5 years
10:38:35 [Ralph]
darobin++
10:38:36 [jeff]
jeff has joined #tpac
10:38:42 [MikeSmith]
PD: could we do it on a scenario basis?
10:39:04 [MikeSmith]
… do test-driven development on your specs, and you do not run into these problems
10:39:07 [pauld]
pauld has joined #tpac
10:39:11 [MikeSmith]
DG: I don't think so.
10:39:22 [MikeSmith]
DG: developers are going to do things that you do not expect
10:39:28 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
10:39:37 [MikeSmith]
… you cannot ahead of time extract a scenario
10:39:53 [MikeSmith]
PC: I was chair of the XML Query WG
10:40:03 [MikeSmith]
… that test suite has 20,000 tests
10:40:10 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
10:40:22 [MikeSmith]
PC: I agree that testing is important
10:40:25 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
10:40:38 [adamretter]
adamretter has joined #tpac
10:40:42 [MikeSmith]
… and you not going to be able to do it with just the current resources
10:40:54 [MikeSmith]
… we should be having a dialog about *how* we are going to do it
10:41:00 [MikeSmith]
DG: I don't disagree.
10:41:15 [MikeSmith]
… but writing tests requires a lot of knowledge, and a lot of time
10:41:22 [MikeSmith]
… the workforce required is huge
10:41:31 [hYamada]
hYamada has joined #tpac
10:41:32 [MikeSmith]
DG: but that is not what my comment was about
10:41:35 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
10:41:36 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
10:41:52 [vivien]
vivien has joined #tpac
10:41:52 [MikeSmith]
DG: users are always going to go deeper than what you have in your scenarios
10:42:00 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
10:42:00 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
10:42:03 [sasan]
sasan has joined #tpac
10:42:10 [burnsy]
burnsy has joined #tpac
10:42:14 [Marco_Ranon]
Marco_Ranon has joined #tpac
10:42:19 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
10:42:46 [rigo]
Real World HTML: the <device> element, by Adam Bergkvist (Ericsson AB) [slides]
10:43:03 [rigo]
slides -> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-DeviceElement.pdf
10:43:06 [MikeSmith]
AB: I have been asked to talk about the <device> elements
10:43:08 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
10:43:12 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-DeviceElement.pdf Real World HTML: the <device> element slides
10:43:13 [MikeSmith]
s/elements/element/
10:43:30 [mgylling]
mgylling has joined #tpac
10:43:31 [MikeSmith]
AB: the device element represents a device selector
10:43:50 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
10:43:54 [MikeSmith]
… allows the developer to access devices that aren't normally exposed to Web applications
10:43:58 [MikeSmith]
… device picker
10:44:39 [Ralph]
Ralph has changed the topic to: TPAC Plenary day feedback requested in http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35125/tpac2010-feedback/ | Agenda is http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/PlenaryAgenda | Back channel in #tpac-chat
10:44:45 [Liam]
Liam has joined #tpac
10:44:45 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
10:44:47 [MikeSmith]
AB: when you install Skype, you know ahead of time that it is going to access your microphone and camera, and that is why you are installing it
10:44:51 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
10:45:18 [MikeSmith]
AB: but when you access a Web app, you don't necessarily know what it might be going to access
10:45:22 [tlr]
tlr has joined #tpac
10:45:24 [Stuart]
Stuart has left #tpac
10:45:43 [kaz]
kaz has joined #tpac
10:45:48 [MikeSmith]
AB: input element was judged to be not sufficient for the use cases we needed to address
10:45:57 [MikeSmith]
… hence, the device element
10:46:09 [MikeSmith]
AB: the device element itself is just a first step
10:46:22 [MikeSmith]
… you then need APIs that go along with the element
10:46:33 [MikeSmith]
AB: so far we have only one such API
10:46:43 [MikeSmith]
… and that is a "stream" API
10:46:54 [MikeSmith]
AB: event triggers on the device element
10:47:17 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
10:47:21 [MikeSmith]
AB: set the stream to the video source
10:47:24 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
10:47:25 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
10:47:31 [MikeSmith]
… can record while I am showing it
10:47:31 [rigo]
AB: can record
10:47:47 [MikeSmith]
AB: brings a lot of new possibillities
10:47:50 [Ralph]
s/…/AB:/g
10:47:55 [MikeSmith]
… upload videos to a video blog
10:48:02 [MikeSmith]
… adding communication to a game
10:48:05 [adamretter]
adamretter has joined #tpac
10:48:17 [MikeSmith]
AB: but in addition you need a way to share streams
10:48:39 [MikeSmith]
…there is a proposal/applications of some kind for that
10:48:43 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ralph
10:49:01 [MikeSmith]
AB: we did some prototyping this spring and summer at Ericsson Research
10:49:21 [MikeSmith]
AB: we used the device element and stream API to develop a prototype
10:49:46 [MikeSmith]
AB: along with some media element extensions
10:49:47 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
10:51:11 [MikeSmith]
AB: we invented something we called "media stream transceivers"
10:51:22 [MikeSmith]
… using HTML5 WebSocket
10:51:41 [MikeSmith]
AB: there is a lot of work to be done before this can be made real
10:52:16 [MikeSmith]
AB: if you once allow a Web app to access your camera, how do you revoke that permission later?
10:52:16 [AnnB]
AnnB has joined #tpac
10:52:34 [Ralph]
s|s/…/AB:/g||
10:52:37 [MikeSmith]
[Adam concludes, floor is open to questions]
10:52:39 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ralph
10:52:52 [MikeSmith]
PC: where is this in the W3C today?
10:52:54 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
10:53:22 [MikeSmith]
AB: this work started [in discussions on the WHATWG mailing list]
10:53:25 [mischat]
mischat has joined #tpac
10:54:03 [MikeSmith]
Dom: Ian Hickson has proposed this <device> elements, and there have been discussions about it in the DAP WG
10:54:12 [MikeSmith]
s/elements/element/
10:54:24 [MikeSmith]
Robin Berjon arrives at the mic
10:54:48 [jmarting]
jmarting has joined #tpac
10:54:51 [MikeSmith]
RB: DAP is quite willing to work on this, we can get discussion going
10:55:01 [MikeSmith]
Tim Berners-Lee at the mic
10:55:01 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
10:55:48 [MikeSmith]
AB: this could be done something like we have now with the file-upload feature
10:56:11 [MikeSmith]
… it can be done as a [replaced element], rendered natively by the browser
10:56:27 [MikeSmith]
Dan Appelquist at the mic
10:56:28 [adam]
TimBL: you mentioned security, should the security be part of the html mark up thereby phishable or part of a drop down from the browser
10:56:41 [MikeSmith]
DA: I think this belongs in the DAP WG
10:56:48 [adamretter]
adamretter has joined #tpac
10:57:01 [MikeSmith]
… because they are already working on the related APIs for device interaction
10:57:09 [MikeSmith]
… and that also have privacy and security issues
10:57:12 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
10:57:18 [MikeSmith]
PC: Why not do it in the HTML WG?
10:57:34 [MikeSmith]
DA: Why *would* it be done in the HTML WG
10:57:46 [MikeSmith]
s/HTML WG/HTML WG?/
10:57:55 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
10:58:11 [MikeSmith]
DA: I don't think the HTML WG is where the expertise is. (Is this where the blood starts?)
10:58:20 [MikeSmith]
Thomas Roessler at the mic
10:58:47 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
10:58:56 [MikeSmith]
TLR: This is a bit like the discussions about where the work on RDFa should take place
10:58:58 [rigo]
PC: rechartering HTML we have to put all those things on the agenda
10:59:03 [MikeSmith]
PC: queue is closed
10:59:10 [MikeSmith]
David Rogers from WAC
10:59:17 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
10:59:29 [MikeSmith]
DR: I think it is folly to put everything in one working group
10:59:38 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
10:59:45 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
11:00:00 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
11:00:01 [MikeSmith]
… we are looking at related use cases for Widgets
11:00:03 [timeless_mbp]
[WAC - http://www.wholesaleappcommunity.com ]
11:00:03 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
11:00:09 [MikeSmith]
PC: my point was about the element
11:00:13 [MikeSmith]
… not about the APIs
11:00:38 [MikeSmith]
DR: maybe we just need to work more closely
11:00:46 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has left #tpac
11:00:48 [MikeSmith]
Jeremy Orlow from Google at the mic
11:01:06 [MikeSmith]
JO: I think this clearly does not belong in the DAP WG
11:01:12 [chaals]
[DAP and Web Apps (and a couple of special-purpose groups) share responsibility for the APIs]
11:01:58 [MikeSmith]
… the APIs that you need in Web browsers are necessarily very different from the ones you need for browsers
11:02:04 [chaals]
[/me wonders what Jeremy thinks browsers are doing...]
11:02:18 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
11:02:26 [MikeSmith]
[the word "bullshit" is heard…]
11:02:40 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
11:02:46 [dezell]
dezell has joined #tpac
11:02:51 [rigo]
XG Audio: Advanced audio functionality for Web browsers, by Chris Lowis (BBC) [slides]
11:02:53 [MikeSmith]
s/need for browsers/need for Widgets/
11:03:00 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
11:03:03 [Joshue]
Joshue has joined #tpac
11:03:09 [rigo]
slides -> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-xgaudio.pdf
11:03:18 [SteveH_]
SteveH_ has joined #tpac
11:03:34 [MikeSmith]
PC: we are having BOFs at lunch, sign up outside
11:03:39 [DKA]
+1 to Robin
11:03:52 [libby]
libby has joined #tpac
11:03:54 [MikeSmith]
[speaker needs a macbook pro video adapter]
11:03:55 [ibrahima]
ibrahima has joined #tpac
11:04:00 [DKA]
-1 to Google's attempt to sow FUD on the work of DAP.
11:04:46 [MikeSmith]
Chris Lowis from BBC at the mic
11:04:51 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
11:05:02 [koalie]
[Audio XG: Advanced audio functionality for Web browsers, by Chris Lowis (BBC)]
11:05:02 [shepazu]
shepazu has joined #tpac
11:05:33 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
11:05:33 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
11:05:51 [koalie]
-> Advanced audio functionality for Web browsers, by Chris Lowis (BBC)
11:06:16 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-xgaudio.pdf Audio XG slides
11:06:19 [MikeSmith]
CL: the demos I'm showing were created by others
11:06:32 [joakim]
joakim has joined #tpac
11:06:51 [DanD]
DanD has joined #tpac
11:06:55 [MikeSmith]
CL: this XG is chartered in part to explore synthesizing audio/speech
11:07:14 [MikeSmith]
[Chris shows a demo]
11:08:12 [Ralph]
[scrolling numbers]
11:08:17 [Ralph]
[dynamic audio waveform]
11:08:18 [MikeSmith]
CL: the API gives direct access to raw samples from the audio stream
11:08:27 [Ralph]
[different dynamic audio waveform]
11:08:31 [MikeSmith]
… so you can create visualizations
11:08:38 [MikeSmith]
… and you can create filters
11:08:45 [MikeSmith]
… and this is all done in Javascript
11:08:56 [MikeSmith]
… doing DSP in Javascript
11:09:01 [MikeSmith]
… visualization of FFT
11:09:06 [Ralph]
[other visualizations]
11:09:09 [MikeSmith]
… WinAmp-style
11:09:24 [MikeSmith]
… filter out the frequencies, do beat detection
11:09:25 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
11:09:26 [Ralph]
[flashing text sync'd with music beats]
11:09:54 [MikeSmith]
CL: can do visualizations using 3D canvas [WebGL]
11:10:08 [MikeSmith]
CL: Chris Rogers at Google has come up with a proposed API
11:10:37 [MikeSmith]
CL: one difference with the Mozilla API is that all of the processing needs to be done in the Javascript engine
11:11:04 [MikeSmith]
CL: Chris Rogers proposed API is based on the conceptual model of audio "nodes"
11:11:16 [MikeSmith]
… that can be passed around, chained together
11:11:47 [MikeSmith]
… e.g, using a connect() method to connect a low-pass filter and gain node together
11:12:22 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
11:12:26 [MikeSmith]
… this code is in the WebKit code [and you need to build/compile it in yourself or use a special build to enable it]
11:12:42 [MikeSmith]
s/or use a/or download and run a/
11:12:44 [rigo]
music: An die ferne Geliebte
11:13:06 [jorlow]
richt: I don't think I explained very well. I'm not saying that DAP is fluff or anything like that. My thesis was intended to be that cmera access is a good example of why we need 2 APIs, not just one because the security requirements are pretty fundamentally different
11:13:20 [jorlow]
security/usability that is
11:13:36 [MikeSmith]
[demo of music playing along with score]
11:13:47 [MikeSmith]
[demo of drum machine]
11:14:20 [MikeSmith]
CL: can apply audio effects in real time
11:14:39 [Ralph]
[Chris manipulates sliders in the browser to adjust the effects]
11:14:46 [MikeSmith]
CL: those are demos from both camps in the Audio XG
11:15:20 [MikeSmith]
CL: we would like to talk to people in the [DAP and WebApps WG] and also [WAI]
11:15:56 [MikeSmith]
CL: Al McDonald is involved with plans for setting up a full WG for this
11:16:11 [richt]
s/richt:/richt,/
11:16:17 [MikeSmith]
Roger Cutler steps up to the mic
11:16:37 [wcarr]
wcarr has joined #tpac
11:16:43 [MikeSmith]
RC: it's more in the spirit of the Web to go after the notation
11:17:13 [MikeSmith]
CL: the markup in the demo I showed is using MusicXML
11:17:14 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
11:17:27 [MikeSmith]
RC: MusicXML [doesn't go far enough]
11:17:38 [MikeSmith]
Larry Masinter now speaking
11:18:02 [MikeSmith]
LM: program has me talking about future directions for HTML
11:18:10 [rigo]
HTML6: Core Web Standards: Renewed Perspectives, by Larry Masinter (W3C TAG, Adobe)
11:18:24 [rigo]
-> slides http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-perspectives.pdf
11:18:31 [MikeSmith]
… but hearing the desire to see some "blood on the floor", I prepared a different talk
11:18:31 [Junliao]
Junliao has joined #tpac
11:18:32 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-perspectives.pdf Larry's slides
11:18:46 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
11:19:10 [MikeSmith]
LM: I would like to try to categorize some of the issues that have embroiled the standards community, and the HTML WG in particular
11:19:23 [MikeSmith]
LM: plan is to hum for the statement that you hate most
11:19:45 [alexmog]
alexmog has joined #tpac
11:19:46 [MikeSmith]
LM: first, should standards "match reality"?
11:20:26 [MikeSmith]
[inclusive humming]
11:20:41 [MikeSmith]
s/inclusive/inconclusive/
11:21:01 [shepazu_]
shepazu_ has joined #tpac
11:21:01 [MikeSmith]
LM: point is, people arrive with different assumptions
11:21:18 [hhalpin]
there is also the disturbing possibility that standards neither match reality or have any principles :)
11:21:19 [MikeSmith]
LM: next, reverse engineering
11:21:35 [homata_]
homata_ has joined #tpac
11:21:36 [hhalpin]
but no-one wants that luckily!
11:22:44 [MikeSmith]
LM: Precision… how precisely should standards specify [UA] behavior?
11:22:54 [timeless_mbp]
"Standards should be [as] loose as possible"
11:23:20 [noah]
Mr. Session Chair: you're not distinguishing the case where two different people hum for the two choices, vs. the case where the >same< people like (or dislike) both
11:23:27 [MikeSmith]
[rousing hum for standards precisely defining UA behavior]
11:23:49 [MikeSmith]
LM: Leading… should standards lead the community, or follow innovation
11:24:12 [MikeSmith]
[hums show more support for standards being driven by innovation]
11:24:37 [MikeSmith]
LM: Extensibility… are non-standard extensions valuable?
11:24:37 [shan__]
shan__ has joined #tpac
11:24:56 [MikeSmith]
LM: Modularity… is modularity valuable, or disruptive?
11:25:00 [francois_]
francois_ has joined #tpac
11:25:01 [noah]
Larry's slides at: http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLnext-perspectives.pdf
11:25:05 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
11:25:05 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
11:25:12 [noah]
He's on the one with the title: 6.Modularity
11:25:34 [noah]
That's slide 7, Timely
11:25:45 [MikeSmith]
LM: Timely… do standards take too long to develop?
11:26:20 [mcf]
mcf has joined #tpac
11:27:01 [mattur]
mattur has joined #tpac
11:27:18 [MikeSmith]
LM: Authors ignore standards… can we expect standards to include "authoring conformance" requirements?
11:28:03 [MikeSmith]
s/can we expect standards to/can we expect authors to follow standards that/
11:28:05 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #tpac
11:28:22 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
11:28:25 [MikeSmith]
LM: Always-On Committee…
11:28:38 [noah]
I feel that Larry is doing a very useful service by pointing out different perspectives that people have...I feel that 'voting' on these is confusing and counterproductive. In many cases, these are two sides of the same coin, and it's important to trade them off case by case.
11:28:42 [MikeSmith]
LM: are open-source implementations important?
11:28:49 [junliao]
junliao has joined #tpac
11:29:29 [MikeSmith]
LM: Browsers and the Web… how important are browsers? are other application classes equally important?
11:30:11 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
11:30:37 [MikeSmith]
LM: Forking… is forking harmful, or does it enable further innovation?
11:30:48 [Ian]
[Forking harmful won out]
11:30:57 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
11:31:03 [chaals]
[Hmm. I am finding a lot of these questions are setting up false dichotomies...]
11:31:06 [noah]
Why ask whether >browser< can depend on patented technology? Geez, they all run on patented chips. I think you >mean< to ask, should the specifications >require< the use of patented technology in order to produce a viable implementation.
11:31:10 [MikeSmith]
LM: Accessibility… how critical is it to address accessibility needs?
11:31:44 [MikeSmith]
LM: Architecture… how important are architectural concerns?
11:32:17 [MikeSmith]
LM: We are going to to get HTML5 out without solving these issues
11:32:26 [MikeSmith]
… so we need to address them in HTML.next
11:32:39 [MikeSmith]
… maybe we will need two specs
11:32:57 [MikeSmith]
LM: you can't solve thse problems unless you first acknowledge them
11:33:02 [MikeSmith]
Jonas Sicking at the mic
11:33:24 [MikeSmith]
JS: there was not a single one of these questions where there is only one answer
11:33:36 [MikeSmith]
… it all [depends on the context]
11:33:46 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
11:34:08 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
11:34:13 [MikeSmith]
JS: there is, for example, no clear answer to the question about "Should standards lead, or should the follow?"
11:34:31 [MikeSmith]
JS: there was a clear undertone in these slides, about HTML5
11:34:37 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
11:34:50 [MikeSmith]
… and HTML5 approached all of them in a variety of ways
11:35:31 [Steven_]
+1 to Noah
11:35:32 [pk2004]
pk2004 has joined #tpac
11:35:37 [MikeSmith]
Noah Mendelsohn at the mic
11:35:49 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
11:36:08 [MikeSmith]
NM: you have given us some valuable things to think about it, but I think it was a mistake to [do the voting thing]
11:36:15 [MikeSmith]
Harry Halpin
11:36:39 [MikeSmith]
HH: I think there is a false dichotomy behind [a lot of the questions in your slides]
11:36:52 [MikeSmith]
… maybe there is a 3rd option
11:37:09 [MikeSmith]
… which is, drive things based on what actual users really want
11:37:27 [MikeSmith]
LM: I think the issues of modularity need to be addressed
11:37:54 [MikeSmith]
LM: unfinished old business comes up and bites you in uncomfortable places
11:38:01 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
11:38:01 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
11:38:15 [wonsuk]
wonsuk has left #tpac
11:38:20 [burnsy]
burnsy has left #tpac
11:38:22 [MikeSmith]
someone asks, "Is the room secure?" (for lunch)
11:38:35 [MikeSmith]
Paul Cotton replies, Is the Web secure?
11:38:41 [MikeSmith]
[we break for lunch]
11:38:50 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
11:38:50 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
11:38:53 [MikeSmith]
RRSAgent, make minutes
11:38:53 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html MikeSmith
11:44:51 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
11:45:19 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
11:48:26 [Laura]
Laura has joined #tpac
11:49:40 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
11:53:42 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
11:58:01 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
11:59:11 [danbri]
danbri has joined #tpac
12:09:19 [Rotan]
Rotan has joined #tpac
12:25:25 [MacTed]
MacTed has joined #tpac
12:25:54 [david_carlisle]
david_carlisle has joined #tpac
12:31:40 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
12:35:10 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
12:36:37 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
12:37:43 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
12:38:52 [Vagner-br]
Vagner-br has joined #tpac
12:40:27 [masahiro]
masahiro has joined #tpac
12:48:59 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
12:49:05 [Joshue]
Joshue has joined #tpac
12:50:35 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
12:50:58 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
12:53:36 [jeff]
jeff has joined #tpac
12:53:47 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
12:54:41 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
12:55:14 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
12:55:51 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
12:57:20 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
12:58:56 [wcarr]
wcarr has joined #tpac
13:00:12 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
13:00:39 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
13:00:45 [mischat_]
mischat_ has joined #tpac
13:01:11 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
13:02:35 [yongil_jang]
yongil_jang has joined #tpac
13:03:54 [ibrahima]
ibrahima has joined #tpac
13:04:15 [koalie]
Topic: Bringing new work (Part I)
13:04:38 [windauer_]
windauer_ has joined #tpac
13:04:49 [rahul]
rahul has joined #tpac
13:05:11 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
13:05:15 [glazou]
glazou has joined #tpac
13:05:29 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
13:05:47 [Zakim]
Zakim has left #tpac
13:06:11 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
13:06:14 [jmarting]
jmarting has joined #tpac
13:06:28 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
13:06:28 [laurent]
laurent has joined #tpac
13:06:37 [Wuk]
Wuk has joined #TPAC
13:06:43 [kennyluck]
kennyluck has joined #tpac
13:06:44 [darobin]
darobin has joined #tpac
13:06:54 [dsinger]
dsinger has joined #tpac
13:07:19 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
13:07:26 [Liam]
Liam has joined #tpac
13:07:29 [koalie]
scribenick: Liam
13:07:38 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
13:07:42 [Liam]
[jeff gives sumary of morning]
13:07:42 [paolobag]
paolobag has joined #tpac
13:07:44 [Liam]
integration is hard
13:07:48 [Liam]
HTML 5 is cool
13:07:48 [koalie]
[Jeff Jaffe summarizing the morning messages]
13:07:52 [Liam]
there is life after HTML 5
13:08:28 [burnsy]
burnsy has joined #tpac
13:08:38 [Nobu]
Nobu has joined #tpac
13:08:56 [Liam]
[Jeff thanks organizers, programme committee, and others involved in making the meeting]
13:09:03 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
13:09:03 [raman]
raman has joined #tpac
13:09:41 [Eduardo]
Eduardo has joined #tpac
13:10:01 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
13:10:07 [francois]
francois has joined #tpac
13:10:12 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Liam
13:10:25 [toto]
toto has joined #tpac
13:10:28 [Liam]
[Jeff thanks various people by name]
13:10:31 [Kangchan]
Kangchan has joined #tpac
13:10:49 [tlr]
tlr has joined #tpac
13:11:01 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
13:11:28 [Liam]
Topic: panel discussion
13:11:32 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
13:11:40 [Liam]
s/panel discussion/lightning talks/
13:11:53 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
13:12:21 [Liam]
Marc Schröder, DFKI, EmotionML
13:12:28 [Liam]
[slide 2]
13:12:29 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
13:12:39 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/EmotionML.pdf Slides
13:12:47 [libby]
libby has joined #tpac
13:12:48 [jun]
jun has joined #tpac
13:12:56 [martin]
martin has joined #tpac
13:12:57 [Liam]
"emotions are the social glue in human experience"
13:13:08 [FabGandon]
FabGandon has joined #tpac
13:13:16 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
13:13:26 [koalie]
[Emotion Markup Language was a W3C Incubator Group from Nov. 2007 to Nove. 2008]
13:13:35 [Liam]
[slide 3]
13:13:41 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/emotion/ W3C Emotion Markup Language Incubator Group
13:13:42 [davy]
davy has joined #tpac
13:13:43 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
13:13:45 [Liam]
screen shots of various Web sites
13:13:53 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
13:14:51 [Liam]
e.g. social web annotations; automatically sensing emotional behaviour; voice/avatar generation with emotion
13:14:59 [Liam]
[slide 4]
13:15:04 [Liam]
research labs
13:15:06 [Liam]
[slide 5]
13:15:21 [Liam]
we've done 2 incubator groups, MMI WG now going towards Last Call
13:15:25 [Liam]
[slide 6]
13:15:28 [Liam]
[slide 7]
13:15:31 [Liam]
[scribe blinked]
13:15:34 [Liam]
[slide 8]
13:15:36 [alexmilowski]
alexmilowski has joined #tpac
13:15:43 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
13:15:53 [richt_]
richt_ has joined #tpac
13:15:54 [Liam]
manual annotation of data / automatic recognition / generation
13:16:13 [Liam]
questions...
13:16:16 [shepazu]
shepazu has joined #tpac
13:16:35 [Liam]
ark: EmotionalML is very diverse, broad variety of contexts
13:16:51 [jeff]
Jeff said: What would he have said if he had another minute
13:16:51 [Liam]
s/ark/Marc/
13:17:04 [adam]
*there wasn't a question
13:17:08 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
13:17:19 [Liam]
Harry Halpin, co-chair of Social Web incubator group
13:17:22 [Liam]
[slide 1]
13:17:39 [Liam]
Knowledge is (potential power)
13:17:45 [Liam]
"things are looking grimp"
13:17:48 [Liam]
[slide 2]
13:17:55 [Liam]
facebook is taking over
13:17:59 [Liam]
but SN is larger than fb
13:18:07 [Liam]
central to how we use the Web
13:18:14 [koalie]
-> http://www.ibiblio.org/hhalpin/homepage/presentations/tpac2010/ Slides
13:18:22 [KaiS]
KaiS has joined #tpac
13:18:29 [Liam]
but most social nets are very insecure, using cookies
13:18:38 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
13:18:46 [Liam]
[slide, too many solutions]
13:18:53 [Liam]
[slide final report]
13:19:07 [Liam]
30 pages report to summarise the social web space...
13:19:17 [danielp]
danielp has joined #tpac
13:19:19 [Liam]
need work on Identity in the Browser
13:19:42 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/socialweb/ W3C Social Web Incubator Group
13:19:42 [chaals]
chaals has joined #tpac
13:19:45 [danielp_]
danielp_ has joined #tpac
13:19:50 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
13:20:08 [Liam]
recommending an over-arching privacy activity at W3C
13:20:24 [SteveH_]
SteveH_ has joined #tpac
13:20:52 [scottv]
scottv has joined #tpac
13:21:07 [Liam]
Dan Applequist: as co-chair... please do ask us about the content of the report
13:21:16 [Marco_Ranon]
Marco_Ranon has joined #tpac
13:21:19 [Liam]
it has some important ideas about what W3C should be doing about the space
13:21:32 [Liam]
and risks about the way people identify themselves on the Web...
13:21:39 [MacTed]
MacTed has joined #tpac
13:21:45 [Liam]
I've just tried firesheep and now I look like Anne Bassetti.
13:22:04 [Ralph]
s/look like/can impersonate/
13:22:05 [AnnB]
luckily my named is spelled "Ann"
13:22:18 [Liam]
Harry: if these issues are not addressed it could be the i-9/11 forcing people to closed platforms
13:22:31 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
13:22:39 [fantasai]
fantasai has joined #tpac
13:22:56 [fantasai]
very coherent presentation by harry imo
13:22:57 [Liam]
Dan Burnett, Voxeo - Speech-enabling your web pages
13:22:58 [fantasai]
:)
13:23:10 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/HTMLspeech.pdf Slides
13:23:14 [Liam]
hands up if you're using mobile devices that let you input data with speech
13:23:16 [Liam]
[lots of hands]
13:23:22 [Liam]
hands up only if they use standards
13:23:26 [Liam]
[no hands]
13:23:34 [Liam]
[slide 2]
13:23:39 [Liam]
HTML Speech Incubator Group
13:24:05 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/htmlspeech/ W3C HTML Speech Incubator Group
13:24:21 [Liam]
[ Social Web XG report at http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/socialweb/wiki/Main_Page ]
13:24:30 [Liam]
[slide 3, So Far...]
13:24:33 [adrianba]
adrianba has joined #tpac
13:24:36 [Norm]
Norm has joined #tpac
13:24:39 [Liam]
collected use cases, etc
13:24:43 [MichaelC]
MichaelC has joined #tpac
13:24:44 [Liam]
[slide 4, Next steps]
13:24:49 [Liam]
no results yet
13:24:55 [Liam]
just getting started
13:25:08 [Liam]
want to propose our spec to HTML WG
13:25:16 [rigo]
rigo has joined #tpac
13:25:20 [Liam]
[slide, <html>speech</html>]
13:25:30 [glazou]
glazou has joined #tpac
13:25:43 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #tpac
13:25:58 [Liam]
How is this related to VoiceXML? - it's a separate group and work, intended to be lightweight, VoiceML is for longer-term spoken dialogues
13:26:06 [Liam]
we're still working out the boundaries
13:26:15 [Liam]
s/lightweight/light-weight and intended to go into HTML/
13:26:18 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
13:26:23 [Liam]
Roger Cutler, Chevron
13:26:31 [Liam]
Why Semantic Web in th Oil and Gas Industry
13:26:36 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/SW-OilandGas-Industry.pdf Slides
13:26:45 [koalie]
s/in th/in the/
13:26:47 [Liam]
[slide 1, Why is SW Different?]
13:27:01 [Liam]
scalable... and, open world assumption
13:27:09 [Liam]
[slide, open & closed worlds]
13:27:27 [Liam]
[slide - Oil & Gas closed or open?]
13:27:47 [Liam]
[slide, data silos]
13:27:52 [Liam]
"bad, evil"
13:27:52 [seungjae]
seungjae has joined #tpac
13:27:57 [Liam]
[slide, tower of babel]
13:28:10 [eliot]
eliot has joined #tpac
13:28:11 [Liam]
[slide, SW, connect the silos]
13:28:33 [Liam]
silos are effective, so SW recognises this and conncts them with ontologies
13:28:41 [Liam]
[slide, HCLS linked data cloud]
13:28:52 [Liam]
[slide, chevron SW Activity]
13:29:02 [Liam]
[slide CiSoft proposal]
13:29:15 [Julian]
Julian has joined #tpac
13:29:18 [Liam]
[slide, blank]
13:29:23 [Liam]
questions...
13:29:42 [Liam]
Ian Jacobs - Roger, can you describe what it's like being inside Chevron communicating the beauty of SQ to your colleagues?
13:29:55 [Liam]
Roger: The idea of SQ is highl visible to our executives
13:30:00 [koalie]
s/Jacobs -/Jacobs:/
13:30:05 [Liam]
2 reasons... we emphasized what you can do right now
13:30:09 [Ian]
s/Jacobs:/Mr. Jacobs:
13:30:13 [koalie]
s/SQ/SW/
13:30:21 [Liam]
e.g. metada managements
13:30:21 [igarashi]
igarashi has joined #tpac
13:30:26 [koalie]
s/SQ/SW/g
13:30:30 [Liam]
and strategically in the centre of some of our big projects
13:30:37 [Liam]
talking about workflows that span domains
13:30:45 [Liam]
so it resonates, the big picture resonates very strongly
13:31:00 [Liam]
s/Ian Mr/Mr/
13:31:14 [Liam]
Ashok Malhotra, Why map relational data to RDF?
13:31:16 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/Mapping-Relational-Data-to-RDF.pdf Slides
13:31:19 [Liam]
[slide 1]
13:31:22 [Suresh]
Suresh has joined #tpac
13:31:33 [DKA]
DKA has joined #tpac
13:31:39 [Liam]
s/Why/Oracle: Why/
13:32:11 [Liam]
RDB2RDF WG is going to write mappings...
13:32:33 [Liam]
you can do the mapping and store it, or a virtual mapping and translate from SPARQL to SQL on the fly
13:32:36 [manyoung]
manyoung has joined #tpac
13:32:43 [Liam]
there's a huge amount of relational databases
13:32:47 [Liam]
[slide]
13:32:50 [mischat]
mischat has joined #tpac
13:33:02 [Liam]
15 Billion Dollar Business...
13:33:03 [Liam]
[slide]
13:33:11 [Liam]
Relational data wants this 'cos it wants to have semantics
13:33:29 [Liam]
connect the silos
13:33:32 [Liam]
[slide skipped]
13:33:34 [Liam]
slike History
13:33:39 [jeff]
jeff has joined #tpac
13:33:43 [Liam]
[slide, Work in Progress]
13:33:48 [koalie]
s/slike/slide/
13:33:50 [Liam]
we have requirements and Usecases
13:34:06 [Liam]
just published Custom Mapping - lets you use the Full Power of SQL to translate from relational data to RDF
13:34:16 [Liam]
and in next month or two, FPWD of default mapping
13:34:28 [Liam]
fairly simple db, press a button, and rdf comes ouot
13:34:31 [Liam]
s/ouot/out/
13:34:41 [Liam]
and maybe we'll write a formal semantics for the mapping
13:34:54 [Liam]
[slide, details, not covered in talk]
13:35:20 [Liam]
questions...
13:35:30 [Liam]
person: When you're moving info from your silos up to RDF to the SW...
13:35:38 [Liam]
in the silo it's easy to find a unique ID
13:35:45 [Liam]
e.g. a person's name
13:35:55 [Liam]
but in the SQ they may not be unique, how do you deal with that?
13:36:08 [Liam]
Ashok: that was on my last slide which I skipped!
13:36:15 [Liam]
for default mapping we have a scheme to generate URIs
13:36:23 [Liam]
but it's an open question we're working on
13:37:05 [DKA]
On Firesheep: I was scanning actively for about 5 minutes and I picked up credentials enabling me to masquerade as Ann Bassetti, Phil Archer, Richard Ishida and 3 others (all now cleared). TO PREVENT THIS FROM HAPPENING TO YOU: use https: whenever possible (Twitter and Facebook both have https versions) or go through a VPN whenever you are on an unsecured (by WPA) wireless LAN.
13:37:36 [Liam]
Henry Story, on Social Web XG, trying to get an Open ID IG going
13:38:04 [sylvaing]
sylvaing has joined #tpac
13:38:05 [Liam]
[response from Harry, scribe could not hear]
13:38:15 [Liam]
Roger Cutler - hoping that kind of question can be a push and pull
13:38:20 [DanD]
DanD has joined #tpac
13:38:35 [Liam]
I don't view it as a technical question of how you do it automatically
13:38:45 [Liam]
person2: webid is a very low-level specific technology
13:38:49 [dsr]
Harry saying that an identity workshop is under consideration
13:38:53 [koalie]
s/scribe could not hear/there will be a workshop on this/
13:39:05 [Liam]
Harry: Harry: we're planning on looking at Henry's work with OpenID foundation
13:39:09 [Liam]
and all sots of groups
13:39:11 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
13:39:19 [Liam]
it would be good to talk with people who are here
13:39:24 [koalie]
s/Story,/Story:/
13:40:00 [Liam]
Phil Archer: I think today was the first redacted slide I've seen, thank you Roger!
13:40:06 [chaals]
Scribe: Chaals
13:40:11 [koalie]
Topic: Web and TV
13:40:15 [chaals]
Topic: TV and the Web panel
13:40:48 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
13:41:07 [chaals]
Phil: I have worked on lots of things, including radio, so they thought I would be good at chairing this panel. Go figure...
13:41:13 [yongil_jang]
yongil_jang has joined #tpac
13:41:49 [chaals]
... Large panel, reflecting the fact that there are a lot of different threads in the relationship between TV and Web.
13:41:59 [Wuk]
Wuk has joined #TPAC
13:42:29 [chaals]
... Speaker: Kazuyuki Ashimura W3C, Tristan Fern BBC, Libby Miller NoTube, Yosuke Funahashi, Dongyeon LG,
13:42:42 [chaals]
... Mark Vickers - castcom.
13:43:02 [chaals]
... Kaz, can you set the scene and talk about the workshop in Tokyo and possible repeat in Berlin?
13:43:07 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
13:43:09 [raphael]
s/castcom/comcast
13:43:49 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
13:43:59 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
13:44:20 [chaals]
Kaz: Held workshop in Tokyo, September on TV and Web and possibilities for smarter integration of the technologies. We had 150 people, and got a lot of interesting and somewhat complicated use cases to motivate work. Conclusion included creating an Interest group as a first step, and that is now being brought to W3M for charter review.
13:44:29 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
13:44:49 [chaals]
Tristan: Work for BBC Research and Development, in a prototyping team looking at the intersection of audience and technology. Can be TV, Radio, Web, ...
13:45:09 [chaals]
... BBC is interested in delivering TV via Web, and how to deliver web applications to TV devices.
13:45:20 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
13:45:39 [cmsmcq]
cmsmcq has joined #tpac
13:45:39 [Eduardo1]
Eduardo1 has joined #tpac
13:45:44 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
13:45:46 [chaals]
... Personally interested in how we create new experiences to combine TV and Web things. How can we join passive TV audiences to active Web audiences.
13:46:11 [chaals]
... and how do I get BBC talent to make stuff for the Web. Can we join search and recommendation from teh Web with TV programming, archives, schedules, ...?
13:46:50 [chaals]
... Right now working on "second screen" app, using another device to talk around what people are watching.
13:46:51 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
13:47:22 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
13:47:38 [chaals]
Lib: NoTube is a social web and TV program. We're interested in what people are doing now - using second screen and social media at the same time, commonly watching it with other people in a room.
13:47:58 [chaals]
... Making it easier to find and share cool stuff.
13:48:32 [chaals]
... Looking at things like realtime voting, interest level for long-tail content, and so on. Things like the mix between broadcast services and URLs...
13:48:45 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
13:48:50 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
13:49:02 [chaals]
... Interested in persistent pointers to TV things, metadata, ...
13:49:35 [burnsy]
burnsy has joined #tpac
13:49:43 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
13:50:35 [chaals]
Yosuke: Tomo-digi (our company) is about Web and TV convergence. Established 1999, when internet services on TV started in Japan. Now over 120 million DTV sets, and doing a vast range of internet services with broadcasters, so we have market experience about Web and TV.
13:51:12 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
13:51:32 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
13:51:53 [chaals]
... My interest in Web/TV IG - Web is spatial concept, but TV is a temporal concept, with a timeline. When Digital TV started, there were several kinds of web standards. Broadcasters developed based on Web stuff plus broadcast extensions...
13:52:46 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
13:53:08 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
13:53:18 [chaals]
... Braodcasters extended different things. Now is a time of convergence for broadcasters. HTML5 is coming, and TV broadcasters should think of "one TV" in the sense of "one Web". This will be a really new approach that will bring us really new technology
13:53:29 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
13:53:53 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
13:54:05 [chaals]
Phil: Product cycle for phones and laptops are measured in months - but TV's stay there for years.
13:54:06 [DenisBoulay]
DenisBoulay has joined #tpac
13:54:30 [scangiano-br]
scangiano-br has joined #tpac
13:54:43 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
13:54:48 [chaals]
DY: LG make phones, TVs, etc. We want some web technology as a platform for smart TV. I want 3 things:
13:55:13 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
13:55:18 [chaals]
... unfragmented market. Not different specs in different markets
13:55:26 [chaals]
... realistic standards.
13:55:31 [Ian]
(as global vendor need unfragmented standards)
13:55:35 [koalie]
i/DY:/Dong Young (LG Electronics)/
13:55:37 [chaals]
... Royalty-free standards
13:55:46 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
13:56:15 [chaals]
... TV is different to PC or phone. Harder to do input, big screen, ...
13:56:23 [Eduardo]
Eduardo has joined #tpac
13:56:30 [chaals]
... We want new standards from W3C that are free, unfragmented and realistic.
13:56:31 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
13:56:42 [Ian]
"and are willing to do this work here"
13:56:52 [chaals]
s/Dongyeon LG/DongYoung (LG Electronics)/
13:57:19 [chaals]
Phil: Note that you might have a good screen on your TV, but the electronics inside are dedicated to the picture, not processing power.
13:57:36 [Kangchan]
s/Dong Young/Dongyoung/
13:57:42 [manyoung_]
manyoung_ has joined #tpac
13:57:49 [koalie]
[Mark Vickers (Comcast)]
13:58:02 [chaals]
MV: Got involved in TV/Web stuff in mid 90's. Produced stuff for IETF, and so on.
13:58:16 [chaals]
... pretty sure none of that is in HTML5 - that's what happens when you are too early.
13:58:42 [chaals]
... Comcast started doing stuff on set-top boxes but is now focused on delivering to any device, and we're looking to HTML5.
13:59:10 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
13:59:29 [chaals]
... We currently use plugins for the web, but would like to deliver through HTML5, and we want 'one web'. Will only happen if the standards and support needed for TV is done in W3C. Otherwise we have today's mess of different extensions in different groups.
14:00:13 [chaals]
... We've been studying HTML5 and it looks promising. Video, Timed tracks, canvas, webGL, web sockets are all critical things. Javascript performance is important.
14:00:38 [chaals]
... Looks like KeyCodes are going to be OK (was a challenge). Access to content on set-top boxes via LAN is a challenge.
14:01:07 [chaals]
... External challenges include dealing with codecs that support captioning (for regulation requirements) and protected content, ...
14:01:41 [chaals]
Phil: Recurring theme - multiple screens with different devices. People are still passively watching TV, but there are things people do on the side of that.
14:02:00 [chaals]
... Libby, can you talk about the use of hash-tagging and social networking in relation to TV?
14:02:12 [kaz]
kaz has joined #tpac
14:02:37 [kohei]
kohei has joined #tpac
14:02:38 [chaals]
Lib: This may be just UK phenomenon, would like feedback. In UK, you can get 8 of twitter's top ten trending topics about a single TV show.
14:02:58 [chaals]
... programs are picking up on it, giving hashtags in programs, having people talk at the TV through twitter.
14:03:04 [wonsuk]
wonsuk has joined #tpac
14:03:43 [chaals]
... When digital economy bill went through parliament there was a boring misinformed debate in parliament, but a lot of chatter and further information around it from people watching and interacting.
14:03:55 [chaals]
... The further information can be used later...
14:04:10 [chaals]
Phil: Do other countries have this twitter phenomenon?
14:04:18 [chaals]
[scribe hears 'france']
14:04:52 [chaals]
Kaz: TBS in Japan also did some stuff with live feedback around elections.
14:04:59 [AnnB]
I don't watch TV .. but I thought that tweeting in realtime phenomena might have gone on with program "Lost"....??
14:05:40 [chaals]
YF: Purpose of the program is to bring people not currently using Web, e.g. older people not accustomed to the Web, and show them what happens with twitter.
14:05:57 [AnnB]
that was the real me ... muhahaaa
14:06:09 [AnnB]
I'll never tweet again, now that I know about firesheep
14:06:10 [yongil_]
yongil_ has joined #tpac
14:06:47 [henri]
henri has joined #tpac
14:06:54 [chaals]
Phil: 2 devices, one showing program, one being used to chat on web about it. DongYoung, do you want to see multiple devices? What sort?
14:07:56 [chaals]
DY: We make these kinds of products, so would like to see them develop. If you have loose linkage (e.g. share a URL) between 2 streams of information, we can't do tightly-linked applications.
14:08:29 [chaals]
... We can put real information on TV, put with twitter can go the other way. Incorporate what user does with mobile device and reflect it in TV content.
14:08:40 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
14:08:42 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
14:09:06 [chaals]
... Could want somethign more advanced than twitter. Our priority is standardising extensions - APIs for TV. And other use cases.
14:09:26 [chaals]
Phil: So if the APIs are in place we could do something more interesting and exciting than just tweeting.
14:09:57 [kaz]
i/Phil:/[ kaz remembers the impressive demonstrations by Japanese broadcasters during the September workshop ]/
14:10:06 [kaz]
s/somethign/something/
14:10:07 [chaals]
Mark: Have bee recently showing an app where you can use your tablet to read the program guide and change the channel. Basic 2-screen interaction.
14:10:26 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
14:10:41 [sven_b__]
sven_b__ has joined #TPAC
14:10:49 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
14:10:50 [chaals]
... When TV program producers integrate this into content will be interesting. Above a certain age people ust watch TV, but younger people almost all have a device with them when they are watching TV.
14:11:03 [chaals]
... Good examles in video game world, but nothing like that in TV yet.
14:11:24 [chaals]
Phil: Phone as remote control...
14:12:23 [chaals]
Mark: Comcast is a cable company, but also have some program channels. We're in process of acqiring NBC and Universal studios. All this content is going to be available in some downloadable form on the web. Convergence in delivery is leading to convergence in how companies are formed.
14:12:47 [Steven]
q+chaals
14:13:00 [chaals]
Phil: Can you give us some blue-sky thinking of what you would do if the APIs are there...
14:13:30 [chaals]
Tristan: Normally think of how to use exiting technology. Interestin to think of new technology.
14:14:02 [chaals]
... Lots of intereactive gameshow stuff - kind of obvious. We are looking at what you would do with e.g. documentary content and second screen to make it more interesting.
14:14:17 [chaals]
... Radio is interesting - at particular times of day it has massive live audiences in UK.
14:14:21 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
14:14:36 [DKA]
DKA has joined #tpac
14:14:38 [chaals]
... Definitely social stuff around that, and extra information you could add by web.
14:14:45 [chaals]
Phil: What's missing, or hard?
14:15:36 [chaals]
Tristan: Finding and recommending TV content. Isdone for web, do we need anything special for TV? How do you synchronise web content and live TV - delivering a picture relevant to program synch is not so important. Delivering captions or subtitles have to be very tightly synchronised.
14:15:43 [jpcs]
jpcs has joined #tpac
14:16:34 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
14:16:38 [chaals]
Phil: I'm share name with a character who has been in a radio program forever. Am in a group of twitter people who are tweeting about the radio program. Rule is not to tweet spoilers, because we are using time shifting.
14:17:01 [koalie]
scribenick: koalie
14:17:12 [koalie]
chaals: Web has a lot to do for accessibility
14:17:13 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
14:17:18 [dom]
s/Web/Web on TV/
14:17:28 [koalie]
... minimum thing we have to do. What can we do beyond that?
14:17:31 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
14:17:34 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
14:17:36 [koalie]
scribenick: chaals
14:17:46 [chaals]
s/have to do/have to do to be as good as TV already is/
14:18:32 [chaals]
MV: There are basic things already - captioning is required. Requirement in US is to have parental control system built into TVs sold. Those will arrive in Web when government wakes up.
14:18:41 [Klaus]
Klaus has joined #tpac
14:18:51 [chaals]
... Also multiple audio, e.g. for second language, or for descriptive audio.
14:19:19 [chaals]
... Another requirement is emergency alert - you have to be able to take over the content and provide emergency information like "torndao comng".
14:19:32 [chaals]
... what oes that mean on the web - how do we do that push, do we need to do them?
14:19:58 [chaals]
... Right now, things like captions and parental control are done on the TV device itself. Even a set-top box just passes that directly through.
14:20:19 [chaals]
... If a TV has a browser, does it use that to do captioning, or does it pass it into the codec?
14:20:34 [chaals]
... these are unanswered questions.
14:21:05 [chaals]
Phil: It is depressing to hear 'we do accessibility because government requires...' - is there anything more that people do?
14:21:52 [chaals]
MV: Now we are looking at things that go beyond requirements, can be easily delivered for relatively low cost. Using intereactive programs to delvier annotations adapted to individual users. These are exciting steps forward.
14:22:08 [chaals]
... We start with government stuff because we are not allowed to deliver signal until we have done them.
14:22:49 [chaals]
JeffJ: TV industry is diverse - people make devices, software, content, regulations and requirements. And these often differ by country. How do I think about getting a consensus of this industry.
14:23:08 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
14:23:08 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
14:23:14 [Denis]
Denis has joined #tpac
14:23:39 [marie]
marie has joined #tpac
14:23:43 [chaals]
... You talked about multiple configurations and models and use cases. Is there a succinct use case hat needs to be focused-on by a subset of the industry to bring TV to the web, or is this a complex multiple-stakeholder topic that requires us to get each group of stakeholders at the table....
14:24:25 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
14:24:37 [chaals]
DY: I think there is a consensus that we as the TV industry have urgent need for some minimal spec platform for smart TV. What we need to do here is unify the various existing specs and defragment them. Quickly, before it is too late.
14:24:41 [kliehm]
kliehm has joined #tpac
14:25:25 [chaals]
MV: There is a way to liaise with other groups, and think that is important: DLNA (TV manufacturers and broadcasting delivery folks) is one. They don't write standards they pick among existing ones.
14:25:35 [chaals]
... driving more unified requirements to thos groups would be helpful.
14:25:56 [henri]
henri has left #tpac
14:26:18 [chaals]
YF: From content provider viewpoint there is a huge value chain, and in different countries the shape of the value chain is different. I think we can reach agreement about "one TV, one Web" around HTML5...
14:26:56 [chaals]
... We worked on java-based system 5 years ago, and compared to BML (XHTML1.1-based, used in Japan).
14:27:45 [chaals]
... We conclude that both languages can meet use cases. So constraints are resources, and the viewing styles of audiences. There ar many syntaces, but the semantics are the same at the base.
14:27:52 [adrianba]
adrianba has joined #tpac
14:28:41 [chaals]
Kaz: Please note that requirements are different by country. We held workshop in japan, we are planning another one in Europe in March.
14:29:08 [chaals]
... We have proposed IG with 4 co-chairs - Opera, NTT/ITU, Digi-Tomo and LGE.
14:29:22 [chaals]
... we want to work with broadcasters from many countries
14:29:44 [kaz]
s/Digi-Tomo/Tomo-Digi/
14:29:56 [chaals]
??: Mobile browser vendor. Many complex problems. How do we define TV streaming protocol for HTML?
14:30:17 [kaz]
s/??/Taisuke_Fukuno(Jig.jp)
14:30:47 [chaals]
s/streaming/streaming and broadcast/
14:31:33 [chaals]
Phil: The answer is that we have an Interest Group which will define working items, and hope for a full Working Group, who will answer such questions.
14:31:55 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
14:32:03 [chaals]
... We need standard APIs to unify the experience, whether from the TV on the sofa, or on the move, or ...
14:32:14 [Ian]
[Phil's phrase is quite a nice WG name: "Augmented TV Experience"]
14:32:27 [chaals]
... The Interest Group we are putting together to deal with this, and hope that if it is interesting to you, you will be there.
14:32:56 [chaals]
... When we started Mobile Web work, NTT DoCoMo came and asked 'where were you 5 years ago when we needed you?'
14:33:13 [chaals]
... Timing is critical - and we have run out of it. So please, join the IG.
14:33:47 [chaals]
[Phil apologises for misunderstanding the question which may mean it didn't get a clear answer]
14:34:17 [chaals]
[scribe is worried that he may have misunderstood it for minutes too..., but hopefully not :| ]
14:34:21 [chaals]
[Break]
14:35:54 [vivien]
!!! Announcement: if you find a "Samsung Galaxy Spica smartphone" please bring it back to the registration desk (FYI it looks like this: http://www.itechnews.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Samsung-Galaxy-Spica-Android-Phone-white-front-back.jpg)
14:37:56 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
14:38:24 [youenn_]
youenn_ has joined #tpac
14:38:54 [kensaku]
kensaku has joined #tpac
14:39:17 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
14:41:52 [mischat_]
mischat_ has joined #tpac
14:43:15 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
14:47:54 [glazou]
glazou has joined #tpac
14:51:14 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
14:56:20 [rigo]
scribenick:rigo
15:02:58 [junliao]
junliao has joined #tpac
15:04:49 [lbolstad]
lbolstad has joined #tpac
15:05:30 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
15:05:56 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
15:06:50 [MikeSmith_]
MikeSmith_ has joined #tpac
15:11:38 [Luca_]
Luca_ has joined #tpac
15:14:28 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
15:14:44 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
15:14:57 [Luca_]
Luca_ has joined #tpac
15:15:23 [Luca__]
Luca__ has joined #tpac
15:16:00 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
15:16:03 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
15:17:17 [Klaus]
Klaus has joined #tpac
15:17:22 [Luca]
Luca has joined #tpac
15:18:07 [laurent]
laurent has joined #tpac
15:18:21 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
15:18:32 [Luca_]
Luca_ has joined #tpac
15:19:03 [toto]
toto has joined #tpac
15:19:26 [myakura]
myakura has joined #tpac
15:19:26 [rigo]
Session 6: Bringing new work (Part II)
15:19:34 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
15:19:36 [rigo]
Moderators: Marie-Claire Forgue (W3C) and Ian Jacobs (W3C)
15:19:39 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
15:19:44 [alexmilowski]
alexmilowski has joined #tpac
15:19:49 [francois]
francois has joined #tpac
15:19:51 [rigo]
3D on the Web, by Kristian Sons (DFKI)
15:20:08 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/3D-on-the-Web.pdf slides
15:20:08 [Marco_Ranon]
Marco_Ranon has joined #tpac
15:20:13 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
15:20:52 [rigo]
KS: so many good graphics cards, but no 3D on the web, we have to adapt the web for 3D
15:21:04 [henri]
henri has joined #tpac
15:21:05 [rigo]
...must be in HTML to get it into the DOM
15:21:11 [shan]
shan has joined #tpac
15:21:30 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
15:21:30 [rigo]
...many developers know how to deal with DOM, javascript
15:21:39 [karen]
karen has joined #tpac
15:21:45 [rigo]
....W3C should play a role here
15:21:56 [YounSung]
YounSung has joined #tpac
15:22:01 [callie]
callie has joined #TPAC
15:22:07 [rigo]
...two project XML3D, introduce some stuff in HTML
15:22:36 [marengo_]
marengo_ has joined #tpac
15:22:38 [rigo]
....X3DOM (Johannes) X3D concept and add W3C technology to it
15:22:54 [rigo]
...specific things like 3D events
15:23:08 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
15:23:12 [rigo]
...implementations on chrome and firefox, will be a hot topic on the web
15:23:23 [rigo]
...will launch an XG and invite participation
15:23:51 [alexmilowski]
alexmilowski has joined #tpac
15:24:07 [Eduardo]
Eduardo has joined #tpac
15:24:14 [rigo]
Johannes Behr, Fraunhofer
15:24:45 [rigo]
X3D/DOM integration, W3DConsortium is a liaison since year
15:25:06 [rigo]
...added a full javascript layer, or webGL layer for rendering of HTML with 3D
15:25:31 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
15:25:32 [rigo]
... already used over the last 12 month, showing demos
15:25:39 [naomi]
naomi has joined #tpac
15:25:59 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
15:26:07 [jpcs]
jpcs has joined #tpac
15:26:10 [rigo]
...simple append child and remove child to manipulate, chain queries on your data
15:26:36 [masinter]
masinter has joined #tpac
15:26:36 [rigo]
...can also play that on top of mpeg4 movies
15:27:03 [rigo]
...very fast & easy, all animation is done with CSS3, no javascript necessary
15:27:17 [rigo]
....DOM level 2 mouse events ...
15:27:27 [Vagner-br_]
Vagner-br_ has joined #tpac
15:27:30 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
15:27:51 [mjs_]
mjs_ has joined #tpac
15:27:59 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
15:28:19 [rigo]
....so far no W3C API to access the camera of laptop, so using flash here
15:28:37 [rigo]
...to get this video into the browser
15:28:41 [rigo]
=============
15:28:44 [rigo]
questions:
15:28:52 [yjang]
yjang has joined #tpac
15:29:05 [freedom]
freedom has joined #tpac
15:29:08 [masahiro]
masahiro has joined #tpac
15:29:34 [timbl_]
timbl_ has joined #TPAC
15:30:07 [rigo]
D.Appelquist: Noting: Siggraph 1991, seen demos on computer graphics, so many demos around 3D. Since 1991 have enourmous industry building around 3D. We are at the same turning point, see an industry developing here
15:30:22 [noah]
noah has joined #tpac
15:30:23 [SteveH_]
SteveH_ has joined #tpac
15:30:42 [Ian]
"video took off when video was available on the web; waiting for the same thing for 3d"
15:30:52 [rigo]
KS: video took off when there was video on the web, we hope for the same in 3D
15:30:58 [rigo]
======================
15:31:13 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
15:31:16 [rigo]
Point of Interests for the Web, by Matt Womer (W3C)
15:31:32 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/POI.pdf slides
15:32:03 [rigo]
MW: on behalf of Andy ?? chair of the POI Group who sent me notes
15:32:07 [DKA]
...e.g.: Pixar. Who will be the Pixar of the 3d Web?
15:32:18 [rigo]
... showing tubes, getting more and more detached
15:32:21 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
15:32:24 [claudio__]
claudio__ has joined #tpac
15:32:33 [dom]
s/??/Braun/
15:32:35 [rigo]
....new user interface paradigm, augmented reality, becoming hot topic
15:32:54 [rigo]
...W3C looking into it, how web and AR could work together
15:33:25 [rigo]
....AR experts got together, where standardization is need. Information about location and ?? is needed
15:33:56 [rigo]
...more uses to POI than augmented reality, 4chan and others, navigation apps, searching, wikipedia...
15:34:29 [rigo]
....Group is doing format to represent information about places. Public mailing list, encourage everybody to join
15:34:34 [Julian]
Julian has joined #tpac
15:34:46 [rigo]
...looking for future places where AR makes sense on the Web
15:34:47 [Roger]
Roger has joined #tpac
15:35:04 [rigo]
....see how it works with web techno
15:35:15 [rigo]
see http://www.w3.org/2010/POI
15:35:21 [rigo]
==================================
15:35:33 [rigo]
Taking Accessibility to the Next Dimension: Thoughts About Canvas 3D, by Martin Kliehm
15:35:48 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
15:35:48 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/3D-Accessibility.pdf slides
15:36:12 [matt]
s/4chan/Foursquare/
15:36:16 [rigo]
MK: HMTL WG and Accessibility TF
15:36:43 [Barstow]
Barstow has joined #tpac
15:37:06 [rigo]
MK: people getting creative, space invaders in your browser in canvas
15:37:25 [rigo]
...need some fallback content for canvas
15:37:50 [rigo]
...for image here is easy, need a shadow DOM, will only be used if hte browser doesn't support
15:38:09 [rigo]
... focus on bitmap for key readers
15:38:18 [rigo]
...caret position for editing text
15:38:38 [rigo]
....games appeared (infinite adventure 3D..)
15:38:55 [claudio]
claudio has joined #tpac
15:39:09 [rigo]
...limited number of characters facing the player.. .
15:39:36 [artur]
artur has joined #tpac
15:39:38 [rigo]
...main challenge in game is reaction time, hinders disabled people to play, there are techniques, readers...
15:39:47 [wonsuk]
wonsuk has joined #tpac
15:39:56 [rigo]
....but things go directly to GPU and GPU gives no alternative access
15:40:33 [rigo]
....second life don't have alt text, so difficult to move with alternative ....
15:41:07 [rigo]
...W3C should get into contact with stakeholders as accessibility bolt on will be ugly
15:41:19 [rigo]
===========================
15:41:26 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
15:41:34 [rigo]
XML Performance, by Mohamed Zergaoui (Innovimax)
15:41:46 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
15:41:49 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/XML-Performance.pdf slides
15:42:36 [rigo]
MZ: performance is a feature that everybody wants
15:42:52 [rigo]
...who cares for XML, Web? -> many hands
15:43:02 [rigo]
...evaluate performance on the web...
15:43:22 [rigo]
could be an IG or a WG, a new way to express performance
15:43:28 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
15:43:43 [rigo]
....XML still perceived as slow, real problem
15:44:00 [Jean-Gui]
Jean-Gui has joined #tpac
15:44:01 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
15:44:04 [rigo]
...standards and products are mature, toolchain available
15:44:24 [rigo]
....native XML databases very efficient (other examples)
15:45:12 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
15:45:16 [rigo]
also on Size: EXI
15:45:19 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
15:45:36 [rigo]
...keep all the infoset and get size smaller
15:45:43 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
15:46:07 [rigo]
....missing tools to improve performance, missing communication
15:46:22 [rigo]
....encourage to organize a workshop on performance
15:46:28 [rigo]
======================================
15:47:06 [rigo]
Frederick Hirsch: XML 2.0 Signature performance
15:47:20 [rigo]
RogerC: testsuite associated on EXI
15:47:32 [rigo]
MZ: not focused on performance and tools
15:47:40 [rigo]
===========================
15:47:45 [rigo]
WOFF: Benefits beyond Beauty, by Chris Lilley (W3C)
15:48:11 [rigo]
CL: how many people (fast stunt)
15:48:19 [rigo]
...fonts not really new
15:48:36 [rigo]
...CSS2 had web fonts, intelligent matching, all sorts of stuff
15:48:37 [koalie]
s/WOFF:/[WOFF:/
15:48:41 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
15:48:41 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
15:48:55 [rigo]
...format wars, no decision where to point to
15:49:21 [rigo]
...SVG WebFonts, mandated format, on some platforms (mobile) but not on desktop
15:49:34 [rigo]
....5 years of massive confusion and we got WOFF
15:49:51 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
15:50:09 [rigo]
....font vendors coming in..... creating WG, => REC
15:50:22 [rigo]
...expect LC and CR cool
15:50:44 [rigo]
...not a format format, compressed font tables, licensing information
15:51:09 [rigo]
....can do by itself nothing, but combination with CSS it can do interesting things
15:51:29 [rigo]
....showing all kinds of scripts...
15:51:45 [rigo]
...instead of using pictures as fonts
15:51:55 [rigo]
=========================================
15:52:12 [rigo]
show off with WOFF
15:52:39 [Steven]
is there a list somewhere of available fonts?
15:52:42 [rigo]
??: Yahoo: if ?? fonts are used, if symbols are used?
15:52:53 [rigo]
...how is this addressed to the textual alternative
15:53:06 [Ralph]
s/??:/Artur Ortega:/
15:53:10 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
15:53:20 [rigo]
CL: people rely on hacks today, will have correct font in the future
15:53:29 [Ralph]
s/?? font/wingbats font/
15:53:31 [francois]
francois has joined #tpac
15:53:36 [rigo]
AO: what if you have flying pigeon?
15:54:07 [rigo]
TV: file of Unicode that has a pigeon-character
15:54:20 [rigo]
CL: you can use a freefont and embed
15:54:26 [koalie]
s/person: When/ArtOrtega_Yahoo: When/
15:54:33 [rigo]
AO: what if images
15:54:34 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
15:54:34 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
15:54:40 [rigo]
CL: you're using text
15:54:50 [rigo]
=================================
15:54:59 [rigo]
Privacy for the evolving Web Platform, by Thomas Roessler (W3C)
15:55:18 [rigo]
TLR: people have concerns
15:55:26 [rigo]
...privacy by design is on the agenda again
15:55:38 [rigo]
....evercookie is just one example of many
15:55:59 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
15:56:01 [rigo]
....canvas is also
15:56:05 [koalie]
s/person:/ArtOrtega_Yahoo:/
15:56:06 [rigo]
...fix canvas?
15:56:07 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
15:56:07 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
15:56:12 [rigo]
...no, same origin
15:56:16 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
15:56:26 [rigo]
....many people use cookies
15:56:54 [rigo]
everkookie forces tracking on people and do not allow them to use tools to get rid of it
15:57:13 [rigo]
we need to talk about what the role of the vendors is
15:57:18 [burn]
burn has joined #tpac
15:57:34 [rigo]
we need to talk about role of W3C
15:57:59 [chrislo]
chrislo has joined #tpac
15:58:05 [rigo]
W3C has organized workshops in November 09, July 10 and October 10, Next Workshop on 8-9 December
15:58:12 [rigo]
deadline is on 5 November
15:58:51 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
15:59:08 [rigo]
DA: I did not say "let's fix canvas" but I'm not saying "as intended" either. Everkookie has shown that we have to consider that question
15:59:54 [rigo]
tlr: what canvas does is that it works within a given same origin context. But how we let users control what happens in this context ...
16:00:38 [rigo]
David Singer: how penombra of privacy goes. We should not just blindly implement specifications without privacy considerations
16:00:50 [rigo]
tlr: precisely the aim of the workshop
16:00:54 [rigo]
========================================
16:01:05 [rigo]
Web and philosophy, by Alexandre Monnin (University Panthéon – Sorbonne, Paris 1)
16:01:16 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/PhiloWeb.pdf slides
16:01:53 [rigo]
AM: first web in philo event in the world organized in Paris
16:02:02 [Julian]
Julian has joined #tpac
16:02:16 [rigo]
....philoweb 2010, conducted interviews with experts on knowledge engineering
16:02:47 [rigo]
....had a mix of engineers and philosopers and computer scientists
16:03:04 [rigo]
...topics ontology ... (see slides)
16:03:21 [rigo]
...abstracts are online, slides on slideshare
16:03:46 [rigo]
IAWP International Association for Web and Philosophy cerated
16:03:47 [DKA]
+1 to Thomas's talk by the way - we need to ensure that the public perception of HTML5 is privacy++, and the current message from press is very much the opposite, eg: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/11/business/media/11privacy.html
16:04:17 [rigo]
..new installements under way, London and Mountain View
16:05:03 [rigo]
-> see conclusions on slide
16:05:07 [rigo]
===============================================
16:05:09 [Ralph]
Ralph has joined #tpac
16:05:59 [richt]
richt has joined #tpac
16:06:14 [rigo]
??: lot of web stuff seems to draw in AI, have you been using the connection that AI was drawing a lot of discussion from philosophers
16:06:23 [rigo]
...yes, Harry knows more..
16:07:03 [rigo]
tlr: privacy challenges are partly practical, but also philosophical, looking forward to hear back
16:07:07 [rigo]
=====================================
16:07:25 [rigo]
Making W3C the place for new standards, by Ian Jacobs (W3C)
16:07:36 [matt]
s/??:/ Sarah-Jane Farmer:/
16:07:44 [shepazu]
shepazu has joined #tpac
16:07:45 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/Talks/ij-ltgroups-20101103/ slides
16:07:51 [rigo]
starting MIME....
16:08:05 [rigo]
....but I'm not the MIME/type
16:08:13 [rigo]
humming....
16:08:21 [dom]
s/starting MIME/start mime/
16:08:45 [rigo]
presenting obstacles in participation of W3C (unfamiliar structure)
16:08:53 [dom]
s/structure/culture/
16:09:00 [rigo]
...new standards TF studied prob space
16:09:28 [rigo]
...primary use case, some people in W3C and outside W3C want to cooperate around a non-mature thing
16:09:43 [rigo]
...anybody can participate at zero cost
16:09:55 [rigo]
....balanced patent policy
16:10:05 [rigo]
...OWF found out a good compromise
16:10:11 [rigo]
...no time limitation
16:10:30 [rigo]
...smooth transition to standards track, but not forced to go REC track
16:10:30 [adrianba_]
adrianba_ has joined #tpac
16:10:38 [rigo]
....also bits for liaisons
16:10:52 [rigo]
...there will be a forum, with help we can make it shiny
16:10:53 [adamretter]
adamretter has joined #tpac
16:11:12 [rigo]
....momentum to create community specifications, will look differently
16:11:28 [rigo]
Community Group is zero revenue and low cost
16:11:41 [sgondo]
sgondo has joined #tpac
16:11:47 [rigo]
..created other groups called business groups with some staff
16:12:01 [rigo]
...requirements WGs to have hi bandwitdth with chairs
16:12:12 [rigo]
...constructive participation improves our work
16:12:30 [rigo]
...raises number of people coming to standards process and helps us find customers
16:12:35 [rigo]
=======================================
16:12:58 [koalie]
[free hugs, anyone?]
16:13:06 [koalie]
[Mic, anyone?]
16:13:12 [rigo]
Quickly creating new proposals to advance the Web, by Michael Champion (Microsoft)
16:13:30 [rigo]
-> http://www.w3.org/2010/11/TPAC/New-Proposals.pdf slides
16:13:50 [rigo]
MC: MSFT gives an official blessing to this new proposal
16:14:03 [rigo]
...we want to see the next generation web standards happen at W3C
16:14:09 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
16:14:12 [rigo]
...to do that there have to be process innovations
16:14:21 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
16:14:25 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
16:14:37 [rigo]
...people in the community have to be responsible, drive architecture, brainstorm for new ideas
16:14:44 [claudio__]
claudio__ has joined #tpac
16:15:14 [rigo]
....use case we see: person or group has some nice idea, want a way to get a proposal uploaded and visibility to get comments from community
16:15:38 [rigo]
.... with some confidence, this needs some straightforward IPR policy, OWF is good starting template
16:16:00 [DKA]
DKA has joined #tpac
16:16:05 [rigo]
....community spec... get to REC may even go to International Standard via W3C PAS status in ISO
16:16:30 [rigo]
...we wanted to see it under W3C umbrella, but people don't want to sell their soul in order to participate
16:16:38 [MikeSmith_]
MikeSmith_ has joined #tpac
16:16:46 [rigo]
...IJ talked about throwing ideas
16:16:57 [rigo]
...3D canvas, a lot of attention, great
16:17:22 [rigo]
....all browser have debugging API, do we need a standard for that, let's talk about it
16:17:44 [rigo]
....idea of profiling W3C REcs, e.g. for email, why not community form for profiling
16:17:47 [rigo]
....talk about it
16:18:14 [rigo]
.... Jquery note lists is a powerful idea, it is worth integrating into the other APIs?
16:18:39 [rigo]
....getting the end user and web developers/publishers into discussion what the real interoperable subset should be
16:19:25 [rigo]
IJ: mentioned OWF licenses, current proposal adapts them, are in close contact with Larry Rosen and ???
16:19:51 [rigo]
RC: what would prevent a community group to do harmful stuff
16:19:58 [rigo]
IJ: is not a business group
16:20:04 [rigo]
*laughing*
16:20:10 [dezell]
dezell has joined #tpac
16:20:23 [rigo]
...we will install mechanisms to prevent that on a social level...
16:20:38 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
16:20:53 [rigo]
.... currently also managing discussions, also talking to Tantek
16:21:35 [rigo]
DG: HTML email, had workshop, main prob is change of renderer in MSFT mailers
16:21:43 [rigo]
...problem of rendering engine
16:21:55 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
16:22:35 [rigo]
JB: at german W3C days, asked about developers fees and positive responses
16:22:40 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
16:22:50 [rigo]
...perhaps consider lower fees for developers and freelancers
16:23:19 [Ileana]
Ileana has joined #tpac
16:23:20 [rigo]
IJ: community proposal is not from scratch, have experience from XG
16:23:25 [rigo]
=======================
16:23:35 [rigo]
The inventor of the glazman-o-meter
16:23:47 [rigo]
RB: DAP image prob
16:24:27 [rigo]
... some people think that DAP is working for widget api and that it could not work with a browser
16:24:30 [rigo]
bullshit
16:24:35 [adam]
adam has joined #tpac
16:24:35 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
16:25:31 [rigo]
....caring for privacy and security, following the browser security model, looking into metaphores
16:25:42 [rigo]
...no metaphore for deleting content
16:26:14 [rigo]
...also other stuff that is not very browser centric, but does not mean that this will have prioritiess
16:26:30 [rigo]
...where comes the heat from?
16:26:40 [rigo]
...looking forward for solutions
16:26:46 [rigo]
===========================
16:27:01 [Ileana]
Ileana has left #tpac
16:27:24 [rigo]
IJ: 2 communities have started communications, some barriers were overcome, some persist
16:27:52 [rigo]
RB : those people saying DAP is not following the web model should come talk to us
16:28:07 [rigo]
IJ: I heard Robin offer to buy a beer later
16:28:20 [rigo]
MCF: many thanks to all speakers and audience
16:29:02 [koalie]
Topic: Let's not leave any stone unturned
16:29:08 [koalie]
scribenick: koalie
16:29:20 [koalie]
Jeff: Let's address whatever is on your mind.
16:29:25 [Jaehyuk]
Jaehyuk has joined #tpac
16:29:30 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
16:29:37 [koalie]
... I'm inviting Tim on stage to be available to address comments.
16:29:51 [matt]
scribenick: matt
16:30:33 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
16:30:40 [matt]
@@Innovimax: We had an item come up recently around zip. It has a fuzzy license. I'd be interested in feedback as it's being used in widgets, as the ?? working group would like help resolving this.
16:30:51 [matt]
Jefff: I don't know anything offhand. If anyone knows, please come to the mic.
16:30:51 [Ralph]
s/@@/MohamedZergaoui/
16:31:12 [youenn]
youenn has joined #tpac
16:31:13 [koalie]
[Jim Melton, Oracle]
16:31:21 [matt]
Jim: It will be addressed next week at the JTC-1 Plenary.
16:31:28 [matt]
s/Jim: /Jim Melton:/
16:31:30 [Ralph]
s/Jim:/JimMelton:/
16:31:45 [matt]
Jeff: We'll be sending someone to the plenary, so we can caucus there as well.
16:31:58 [matt]
Jeff: I take it everyone is satisfiied.
16:32:07 [matt]
s/satisfied/satisfied/
16:32:20 [matt]
??: What are you unhappy about?
16:32:22 [koalie]
[please, fill out the feedback survey: http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35125/tpac2010-feedback/ ]
16:32:40 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
16:32:43 [koalie]
s/??:/YeshaSivan:/
16:33:15 [DanD]
DanD has joined #tpac
16:33:30 [matt]
Jeff: I started just a few months ago. My tenure was still counted in days when there was the famous article in Wired magazine that declared: "The Web is Dead"
16:33:54 [matt]
Jeff: I was unhappy about that for a while. I thought TPAC would be a good personal test for me to answer the question: is the Web dead?
16:34:05 [mjs]
mjs has joined #tpac
16:34:19 [matt]
Jeff: One of my responsibilities as chair of TPAC is to summarize the day. So my summary is: the Web is not dead.
16:34:27 [ivan]
:-)
16:34:35 [matt]
Jeff: Considering the function and scope covered. We had one day, 40 people presenting. All exciting ideas.
16:34:50 [matt]
Jeff: I worry about how we'll get it all done, but it's exciting.
16:35:01 [matt]
Jeff: The subtext here is you can't believe everything you read in the press.
16:35:33 [matt]
Mohamed: I'm talking at a conference, XML @@. If people know about it, please make some noise.
16:35:45 [Ralph]
s/@@/Prague/
16:35:58 [Julian]
Julian has joined #tpac
16:36:23 [matt]
Mohamed: It will be in March in Prague. People are welcome to have w3c meetings there too. Please go to xmlprauge.??
16:36:23 [koalie]
-> http://www.xmlprague.cz/2011/index.html XML Prague
16:36:29 [matt]
s/??/cz/
16:36:40 [koalie]
s/prauge/prague/
16:36:56 [sasan]
sasan has joined #tpac
16:36:58 [matt]
Mohamed: We're pleased to have w3c participation.
16:37:28 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
16:37:41 [darobin]
-> http://www.xmlprague.cz/2011/call-for-papers.html XML Prague 2011 CfP
16:37:52 [FabGandon]
FabGandon has left #tpac
16:38:10 [matt]
??: I can't help but noticing that the IETF meeting in Prague starts right after that meeting too.
16:38:20 [matt]
Jeff: We're considering having a community group on Web meetings.
16:38:40 [homata]
homata has joined #tpac
16:38:49 [matt]
AnnB: This is probably the quietest meeting I've ever been at. The room is crowded, but quiet? What is it?
16:38:57 [masinter]
people hummed!
16:39:02 [koalie]
s/??:/JulianReschke:/
16:39:02 [matt]
glazou: There was not a lot of time for questions.
16:39:18 [matt]
timbl: I think it's the jetlag not working for people.
16:39:22 [alexmog]
alexmog has joined #tpac
16:40:02 [chrislo]
chrislo has left #tpac
16:40:14 [matt]
timbl: ?? said something positive. Everyone is busy, they've got stuff to do, but it's not at the top of people's minds to complain. By continuing to talk here we're probably even preventing people from editing documents.
16:40:33 [matt]
chaals: I think the atmosphere has been good. There's no reason to rip holes in people, they've been saying sensible things.
16:41:08 [chaals]
s/saying/mostly saying/
16:41:16 [raphael]
raphael has joined #tpac
16:41:20 [matt]
Ileana: I think it was an excellent session, many new ideas. A popping environment. At the same time though, at least 50% of this room are not native English speakers. You need some time to understand the new idea, and appreciate it, and by then the three minutes are done.
16:41:48 [matt]
AnnB: It's an important point. In the AB we have talked about this before. Anyone in the room who wants to submit suggestions, that would be really valuable.
16:42:21 [DKA]
Idea: simultaneous translation services provided remotely via amazon mechanical turk and VoIP.
16:42:31 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
16:42:32 [matt]
AnnB: I once was told a comment by someone and encouraged them to step up and ask it, but they were concerned they couldn't understand the response.
16:42:35 [chaals]
s/people, they've/people when they've/
16:43:00 [sven_b__]
sven_b__ has joined #TPAC
16:43:04 [matt]
PaulC: People asked me why the hum? It was a good way to get participation regardless of your mother tongue.
16:43:11 [koalie]
s/Idea:/Here's an Idea:/
16:43:19 [matt]
One of the rules in JTC-1 is that the meeting only goes as fast as the understanding of the slowest person.
16:43:45 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
16:43:52 [matt]
I'd like everyone to think about facilitating participation. Repeat questions slowly. Repeat answers slowly. It's simple politeness to your peers.
16:44:10 [sasan]
sasan has joined #tpac
16:44:20 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
16:44:20 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
16:44:21 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
16:44:51 [matt]
PhilA: In every sense, I'm a native English speaker. I've had the privilege of touring the world and meeting many friends around the world. I'm eternally grateful for so many hours that have been put into learning our language.
16:45:14 [matt]
PhilA: Maybe one reason for the quietness: the Web is a victim of it's own success. Look at the early specs. The people who wrote them are too busy making a living out of it.
16:45:26 [matt]
PhilA: All the RDF people are too busy making money off it to make RDF2.
16:45:29 [jun]
jun has joined #tpac
16:45:50 [koalie]
s/it's/its/
16:45:52 [matt]
timbl: I apologize for being one of the fastest and mumbly speakers around.
16:46:17 [ivan]
actually, not absolutely true, we will get some of the old rdf guys in the new group (if it is set up...)
16:46:22 [matt]
timbl: Often it is really hard for the scribes, but I wonder if one possibility would be to have the IRC channel with simultaneous scribing projected to the side?
16:46:28 [matt]
[clapping]
16:46:39 [Ian]
[lots of support for projection of IRC scribing]
16:46:40 [kris]
kris has joined #tpac
16:46:59 [matt]
Liam: One reason we have fewer questions: people are making more productive use of IRC and the 2nd channel.
16:47:08 [hidetaka]
hidetaka has joined #tpac
16:47:17 [koalie]
[+1 to project IRC scribings]
16:47:19 [matt]
Liam: We're doing very interesting things with the bots. What about experimenting with simultaneous translation?
16:47:32 [matt]
timbl: To IRC?
16:47:33 [timeless_mbp]
timeless_mbp has joined #tpac
16:47:35 [matt]
Liam: Yes.
16:47:40 [Ian]
Liam: translating minutes into multiple languages
16:47:44 [sven_b_]
sven_b_ has joined #TPAC
16:47:46 [matt]
jeff: I think it would be a great idea to do that if only we had the skilled people to do that.
16:48:01 [matt]
Jeff: It's not easy, if anyone would like to volunteer let's try it as an expertiment.
16:48:03 [Ian]
jeff: Quiconque qui veut se presenter est le bienvenue.
16:48:12 [matt]
chaals: I've been to conferences and done that.
16:48:14 [koalie]
Ian :)
16:48:58 [matt]
chaals: The trick is finding people to do it. Looking at the minutes, sometimes they're very detailed.
16:49:09 [matt]
s/expertiment/experiment/
16:49:12 [ivan]
I am, formally. bilingual, but I would never accept to do such a translation
16:49:15 [matt]
chaals: The quality is patchy, but you can try.
16:49:32 [matt]
jeff: When I was thanking earlier, I left out the scribes.
16:50:07 [Steven]
Stream the IRC through Google translate
16:50:43 [matt]
Daniel: As a non-native speaker, I appreciate Ann and others taking care to help non-native participation. We also have to take into account that there are culture differences. We need more time to speak up. I'll speak up more at next TPAC. I really appreciate W3Cs kind and helpful and good to non-native speakers. Thank you.
16:50:44 [glazou]
Steven: is it fast enough ?
16:50:56 [dom]
s/Steven:/Steven,/
16:51:10 [Steven]
I think so
16:51:19 [matt]
Kaz: Keio provided simultaneous translation for Web on TV workshop. It was very useful.
16:51:21 [koalie]
s/Daniel:/SoohongDanielPark:/
16:51:51 [matt]
hhalpin: From a broader perspective, with Ian's community group effort: I'm doing outreach from Ireland to SF and it's crap trying to communicate. I'm wondering how W3C plans to get in touch with emerging economies that might not know of W3C at all.
16:52:02 [chaals]
[+1 to usefulness of translation enabling people to just speak their preferred language]
16:52:08 [matt]
hhalpin: The 2nd thing I'd like to hear about is time based requirements for the Rec process.
16:52:21 [matt]
hhalpin: I'd like to see it clarified and feedback on what it takes to make a WG.
16:52:30 [ivan]
W3C Brazil had a meeting in Sao Paulo a few weeks ago which was translated simultaneously into Portuguese; it was really efficient, but needed two professional translators to get it working
16:52:42 [Kangchan]
s/SoohongDanielPark/Soohong Daniel Park/
16:52:47 [matt]
hhalpin: Some activities start a full scale working group based on three Universities, others need browser vendors. I'd like to hear what the right conditions would be.
16:52:56 [rahul]
s/Ireland/Scotland/
16:52:57 [DanD]
DanD has left #tpac
16:53:01 [koalie]
RRSagent, make minutes
16:53:01 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html koalie
16:53:31 [matt]
timbl: For many of the things, the questions had different attitudes. It's different in every working group. When we started this thing we had activity statements. It had to answer whether it was lead by industry or academics.
16:53:37 [plh]
plh has joined #tpac
16:53:53 [matt]
timbl: I think it's really important that W3C doesn't decide that those answers should be the same for every WG.
16:54:16 [Barstow]
+1 TBL!
16:54:18 [Kangchan]
s/Soohong Daniel Park/Soohong_Daniel_Park/
16:54:24 [aizu]
aizu has joined #tpac
16:54:26 [matt]
timbl: We should keep it as a flexible tool. Never build something that constrains it more. Within that, each different area of activity tends to have different answers.
16:54:54 [matt]
jeff: Thanks Harry for broadening the language and cultural norms. One of the norms for people to learn is coming to the mic after the queue is closed.
16:55:28 [matt]
Ian: The new community groups should have a shiny new landing page for how we get stuff done. We don't have any funding for that design.
16:55:29 [chaals]
[controversy != doing useful work]
16:55:42 [toto_]
toto_ has joined #tpac
16:55:45 [matt]
Ian: Tomorrow night we have a meetup here at the conference center between 7 and 9. Everyone is invited. 150 local developers and designers. Free food and wine.
16:56:24 [matt]
rigo: There was a lot of chat in the back channel where we searched for creative ideas for tempests for more discussion. I had an idea but you closed the queue, so I'll spare you it.
16:56:37 [timeless_mbp]
s/7 and 9/7pm and 9pm/
16:57:07 [marengo]
marengo has joined #tpac
16:57:13 [matt]
jeff: In terms of the schedule: next thing for everyone to do is fill out the evaluation survey.
16:57:20 [koalie]
-> http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35125/tpac2010-feedback/ Feedback survey
16:57:24 [matt]
jeff: Then at 7pm we have the reception on level 2.
16:57:27 [koalie]
[^ please, take the survey]
16:57:32 [amy]
Reception tonight: 19:00, Forum Level 2 (down by the lunch area)
16:57:40 [alain]
alain has left #tpac
16:57:48 [matt]
jeff: Now we've learned that in 3 minute increments we can't get people to ask questions. So people should feel free to approach people and ask questions.
16:58:04 [koalie]
[reception is at level -2]
16:58:11 [aizu]
aizu has left #tpac
16:58:15 [matt]
jeff: After that, the week isn't over, 2 more days of meetings. As Ian noted we have a public meetup.
16:58:30 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
16:59:18 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
16:59:29 [matt]
jeff: There are an unlimited number of future conferences related to Web technologies. The next Multilingual Workshop is in March in Pisa. WWW is also in March in Hyperbad. There's a Web TV related WS, date not finalized. WWW 2012 will be in this conference center.
16:59:39 [matt]
jeff: Our next AC meeting will be in May in Bilbao.
16:59:58 [matt]
jeff: It's limited to just the AC, but in this case there will also be a number of companion meetings at the same time.
17:00:15 [kaz]
xavier
17:00:15 [sven_b]
sven_b has joined #TPAC
17:00:29 [bblfish]
bblfish has joined #tpac
17:00:36 [bblfish]
ah ok got it
17:00:42 [matt]
Xavier: I wanted to present the best conference, but Mohamed already did that, so this is the second best conference.
17:00:54 [AnnB]
Xavier Uribe-Extebarria
17:01:01 [kaz]
s/Xavier/Xabier_Uribe-Etxebarria/
17:01:20 [kaz]
s/Xavier:/Xabier_Uribe-Etxebarria:/
17:01:31 [bblfish]
is there a log of this channel?
17:01:35 [matt]
Xavier: W3B conference and AC meeting. W3B Conference is the global event that brings together key experts and key organizations discussing the Present and Future of the Web.
17:01:38 [mav]
mav has joined #tpac
17:01:51 [kaz]
x/Xavier:/Xabier:/
17:01:52 [Marco_Ranon]
s/Hyperbad/Hyderabad/
17:02:02 [kaz]
s/xavier/xabier/
17:02:03 [rigo]
bblfish, yes, this is the channel where minutes are taken
17:02:29 [matt]
Xabier: Awarded World City prize.
17:02:45 [matt]
Xabier: Hotels, conference center, shopping, museum, all within half a mile.
17:03:39 [matt]
Xabier: Lots of support, the Mayor and the Spanish government, everyone involved. Euskalduna Conference Centre and Concert Hall. Awarded ??. Want to fill 2,200 people
17:03:55 [matt]
It's the biggest stage in Spain.
17:04:01 [matt]
We'll be doing webcasting.
17:04:17 [matt]
Afterwards we'll be doing a gala at the Guggenheim. Free for AC members.
17:04:28 [matt]
[tentative schedule[
17:04:35 [Bert]
(Xabier explained that "W3B" had the B of Bilbao, but also of Business.)
17:04:54 [matt]
Xabier: starts on Sunday May 15.
17:04:58 [matt]
See you there!
17:05:28 [matt]
jeff: We do not yet have the venue for TPAC 2011. We'll get that to you when it's available. See you in an hour for the reception. Thank you!
17:05:33 [rahul]
rahul has left #tpac
17:05:36 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2010/11/03-tpac-minutes.html Ian
17:06:04 [wcarr]
wcarr has left #tpac
17:06:15 [henri]
henri has left #tpac
17:06:27 [Luca]
Luca has left #tpac
17:07:48 [caribou]
caribou has left #tpac
17:08:35 [toto]
toto has joined #tpac
17:09:52 [laurent]
laurent has left #tpac
17:11:26 [SteveH_]
SteveH_ has left #tpac
17:14:28 [mav_]
mav_ has joined #tpac
17:15:25 [mav__]
mav__ has joined #tpac
17:19:22 [mav]
mav has joined #tpac
17:19:23 [Eduardo]
Eduardo has joined #tpac
17:25:23 [naomi]
naomi has joined #tpac
17:28:11 [libby]
libby has joined #tpac
17:37:30 [nord_c]
nord_c has joined #tpac
17:47:07 [Eduardo]
Eduardo has left #tpac
17:50:17 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
18:14:41 [dsinger]
dsinger has joined #tpac
18:29:04 [karl]
karl has left #tpac
18:30:16 [timbl]
timbl has joined #TPAC
18:34:55 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
18:35:30 [mischat]
mischat has joined #tpac
19:35:40 [mmielke]
mmielke has joined #tpac
19:54:46 [Ian]
Ian has joined #tpac
20:10:06 [dsinger]
dsinger has joined #tpac
20:26:24 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
20:32:35 [shawn]
shawn has joined #tpac
20:37:18 [plinss_]
plinss_ has left #tpac
20:37:46 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
20:45:03 [henri]
henri has joined #tpac
20:45:51 [henri]
henri has left #tpac
20:52:24 [windauer]
windauer has joined #tpac
21:09:55 [kennyluck]
kennyluck has joined #tpac
21:14:34 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
21:16:23 [hidetaka]
hidetaka has joined #tpac
21:19:22 [pchampin]
pchampin has joined #tpac
21:19:25 [Steven]
Steven has joined #tpac
21:26:59 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
21:30:46 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
21:34:48 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
21:52:08 [Nobu]
Nobu has joined #tpac
21:52:12 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
22:02:34 [Nobu]
Nobu has left #tpac
22:04:19 [kensaku]
kensaku has joined #tpac
22:12:10 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
22:18:59 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
22:22:22 [hjjaa]
hjjaa has joined #tpac
22:35:03 [jorlow]
jorlow has joined #tpac
22:40:20 [smaug_]
smaug_ has joined #tpac
22:41:23 [MacTed]
MacTed has joined #tpac
23:08:13 [plinss_]
plinss_ has joined #tpac
23:08:25 [bblfish]
bblfish has joined #tpac