Comments
From SPARQL Working Group
(Difference between revisions)
(→WD comments) |
(→WD comments) |
||
| Line 554: | Line 554: | ||
| DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT? | | DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT? | ||
| Holger Knublauch | | Holger Knublauch | ||
| - | | | + | | [http://www.w3.org/2009/sparql/wiki/CommentResponse:HK-2 Draft response HK-2] |
| Paul Gearon | | Paul Gearon | ||
| <span style="color:red">open</span> | | <span style="color:red">open</span> | ||
Revision as of 17:46, 7 February 2011
Comments to SPARQL documents
- Key to columns
- Owner: WG member who is addressing issues and/or drafting response email
- Response: links to response email and to subsequent acknowledgment from commenter
- Status: should be "open", "Response sent", "ACK", "ACK - OK", or "ACK - NOT OK".
Current policy is to write proposed response in the wiki (below), send to WG mailing list, wait 2-3 business days, get some +1s from the WG, then reply.
Earlier comments
TBD: check mails May and previous...
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SG-1, SG-2 | 2009-06-09 | Problem with Schema, Errata for Protocol | Simon Gibbs | ? | Protocol 1.1 | |||
| CB-1 | 2009-07-03 | Free-text search | Chris Bizer | Kjetil Kjersmo | Response sent | response | Query 1.1 | |
| AL-1 | 2009-07-10 | RDF dataset/SPARQL endpoint descriptions | Andreas Langegger | Gregrory Williams | ? | response | Service Description 1.1 | |
| DB-1 | 2009-07-28 | SPARQL spec layout | Daniel Barclay | ? | Query 1.1 | |||
| TI-1 | 2009-09-08 | clarifying OPTIONALs | Toby Inkster | Lee Feigenbaum | ACK - OK | ack | Query 1.0 |
WD comments
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SR-1 | 2009-11-09 | Inferencing on graph patterns | Simon Reinhardt | reinhardt-inference-1 | Ivan Herman | ACK - OK | response, ack. | None (was comment on inference regimes) |
| LD-1 | 2009-10-24 | Comments on Query 1.1 FPWD | Leigh Dodds | ldodds-query-1 | Andy Seaborne | ACK - OK | response ack | Query 1.1 |
| LD-2 | 2009-10-24 | Comments on Service Description 1.1 FPWD | Leigh Dodds | ldodds-sd-1 | Gregory Williams | Response sent | response, ack | Service Description 1.1 |
| LD-3 | 2009-10-24 | Comments onSPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol FPWD | Leigh Dodds | draft | Chime Ogbuji | Response sent | response | Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1 |
| BL-1 | 2009-11-05 | Comments on general directions of FPWD | Ben Lavender | BL | Axel Polleres | Response sent | response | Update 1.1, Protocol 1.1, Service Description 1.1 |
| RV-1 | 2009-11-13 | Comments on SPARQL 1.1 | Rob Vesse | RV | Steve Harris | ACK - OK | response ack | Query 1.1 |
| EF-1, EF-2, EF-3 | 2009-11-13 | Comments on Entailment Regimes | Enrico Franconi | EF | Birte Glimm | Response sent | response | None (was comment on inference regimes) |
| JC-1 | 2009-11-02 | LET or AS for "assignment" | Jeremy Carroll | Lee Feigenbaum? | ? | Query 1.1 | ||
| HK-1 | 2009-10-25 | Missing LET assignment | Holger Knublauch | Lee Feigenbaum? | ? | Query 1.1 | ||
| TI-2 | 2009-11-30 | Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Aggregates | Toby Inkster | (answer sent directly) | Axel Polleres | Response sent | response | Query 1.1 |
| RN-1 | 2010-01-09 | Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Update | Richard Newman | RN-1 | Paul Gearon | open | Update 1.1 | |
| N3-1 | 2010-01-27 | SPARQL paths and N3 paths: some quick thoughts | Dan Connolly, Tim Berners-Lee | Andy Seaborne | Response sent | response | Property Paths | |
| DR-1 | 2010-01-29 | Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths | Doug Reid | DR-1 | Andy Seaborne | ACK - OK | response -- ack | Property Paths |
| JC-2 | 2010-02-06 | non-formal question on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths | Jeremy Carroll | Axel Polleres | ACK - OK | response ack | Property Paths | |
| ED-1 | 2010-02-06 | SPARQL 1.1 Query Aggregates syntax | Emanuele Della Valle | ED-1 | Axel Polleres | Response sent | response | Query 1.1 |
| RV-2 | 2010-02-09 | Comments on latest SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts | Rob Vesse | RV2 | Gregory Williams | ACK - OK | response ack | Query 1.1, PropertyPaths 1.1, Service Description 1.1 |
| JC-3 | 2010-02-17 | Comments on Property Paths FPWD (not indented as formal comment, though) | Jeremy Carrol | JC-3 | Andy Seaborne | Response sent | response | Property Paths |
| ST-1 | 2010-02-19 | Request for named graph templates "everywhere" (e.g. named graph creation/modification in CONSTRUCT like in INSERT) | Sebastian Trueg | ST-1 | Paul Gearon | open | Query 1.1, Update1.1 | |
| NH-1 + NH-2 + NH-3 | 2010-02-23 | way of describing the supported results formats in SPARQL 1.1 Service Description (like e.g. in SADDLE) | Nicholas J Humfrey | NH-1 | Gregory Williams | ACK - OK | response ack | Service Description 1.1 |
| RV-3 | 2010-02-25 | Aggregates and property paths further comments | Rob Vesse | Steve Harris | open | Query1.1, Property Paths | ||
| NA-1 | 2010-03-18 | Update syntax | Nikolai Anissimov | NA-1 | Axel Polleres | Response sent | Response | Update 1.1 |
| RV-4 | 2010-03-23 | Aggregates and property paths more comments | Rob Vesse | Draft response CommentResponse:RV-4 | Steve Harris | ACK - OK | PropertyPaths, Query | |
| RH-1 | 2010-03-31 | abstract syntax for Update | Ross Horne | RH-1 | Axel Polleres, Paul/Alex to check | Response sent | response | Update 1.1 |
| KK-1 | 2010-04-23 | ISSUE-49 | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Response sent | Chimezie Ogbuji | response | Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1 | |
| MH-1 TI-3 | 2010-06-03 | suggested addition to SPARQL 1.1 Service Description "well-known endpoint" | Michael Hausenblas | MH-1 | Gregory Williams | Response sent | Response | Service Description 1.1 |
| PA-1 | 2010-06-03 | IRI creation and encoding | Peter Ansell | PA-1 | Axel Polleres | Response sent | response | Query 1.1 |
| OH-1 | 2010-06-04 | wrong example in the Fed.Ext. document | Olaf Hartig | Eric Prud'hommeaux | Response sent | response | SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extensions | |
| PA-2 | 2010-06-23 | semantics of DESCRIBE | Peter Ansell | PA-2 | Gregory Williams | ACK | response ack | Service Description 1.1 |
| DS-1 | 2010-06-22 | Brief comment on sd:name | Damian Steer | Gregory Williams | open | Service Description 1.1 | ||
| JB-1 | 2010-07-27 | RIF review of Entailment Regimes | Jos De Bruijn | Chime | Response sent | response | Entailment | |
| RK-1 | 2010-07-27 | Feedback to some SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts | Reto Krummenacher | RK-1 | Axel | ACK - OK | Update, Protocol, Federation, Service Description | |
| TL-1 | 2010-08-09 | Comments on "SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs" | Tim Berners-Lee | Chime | Response sent | response | http-rdf-update | |
| GK-1 , GK-2 | 2010-09-28 | Comments on aggregation in SPARQL 1.1 | Graham Klyne | SteveH | open | Query 1.1 | ||
| RC-1 | 2010-09-29 | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: HTTP status code for QueryRequestRefused | Richard Cyganiak | open (postponed until Protocol has settled) | Protocol 1.1 | |||
| RC-2 | 2010-09-29 | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: Format of fault messages | Richard Cyganiak | open (postponed until Protocol has settled) | Protocol 1.1 | |||
| GK-3 | 2010-10-01 | Explanation of OPTIONAL vs { OPTIONAL } | Graham Klyne | Draft response GK-3 | Axel | Response sent | response | Query 1.1 |
| JP-1 | 2010-10-29 | Comments about the semantics of property paths | Jorge Perez | Response JP-1 | Andy Seaborne | ACK - OK | response Partial ack ack | Query 1.1 |
| JP-2 | 2010-12-15 | Comments about the semantics of property paths | Jorge Perez | Response JP-2 | Andy Seaborne | ACK - OK | response ack (see also JP-3) | Query 1.1 |
| JP-3 | 2011-01-25 | Comments about the semantics of property paths (cont) | Jorge Perez | Response JP-3 | Andy Seaborne | Response Sent | response | Query 1.1 |
| JG-1 | 2010-11-16 | Comments about functions and LET | Jacek Gajek | Draft response JG-1 | Axel | open | Query 1.1 | |
| KK-2 KK-3 KK-4 KK-5 | 2010-11-01 | No content-type on payload, What to do if no payload? Proper escaping of URIs and payload on update operations, HTTP DELETE | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Chime? | open | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs | ||
| MS-1 | 2010-10-25 | Behavior of SPARQL Update INSERT on default graphs | Michael Schneider | Draft response MS-1 | Alex | open | SPARQL 1.1 Update | |
| DB-1 | 2010-10-14 | Permit LOAD from a SPARQL CONSTRUCT endpoint | David Booth | Draft response DB-1 | Alex | ACK-OK | Response | SPARQL 1.1 Update |
| DBeckett-1 | 2010-12-05 | Aggregates, Bindings and other comments | David Becket | Draft response DBeckett-1 | Carlos | open | SPARQL 1.1 query and Fed extension | |
| ID-1 | 2010-12-15 | Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 | Ian Davis | Response-ID-1 | Chime | Response sent | response | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol |
| GR-2, GR-1 | 2011-01-05, 2011-01-6 | "RDF Knowledge" (Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs) | Gregg Reynolds | Response-GR-1 Response-GR-2 | Chime | open | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | |
| HK-2 | 2011-01-05 | DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT? | Holger Knublauch | Draft response HK-2 | Paul Gearon | open | SPARQL 1.1 Update | |
| BD-1 | 2011-01-12 | comments on SPARQL 1.1 14 October 2010 Working Draft (editorial comments) | Bob DuCharme | Editorial | Andy Seaborne | Done | Response/Done | SPARQL 1.1 Query |
| SM-1 | 2011-01-13 | [Query-errata] error in example query in SPARQL recommendation | Sjoerd Mullender | Editorial | Andy Seaborne | Done | Response/Done | SPARQL 1.1 Query |
| KK-6, GR-3 | 2011-01-14 (first message in thread) | HTTP DELETE operation | Kjetil Kjernsmo, Gregg Reynolds | Chime? | open | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | ||
| KK-7 | 2011-01-19 | Uniqueness of blank node labels | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Axel | open | SPARQL 1.1 Query | ||
| JB-2 | 2011-01-20 | NOT EXISTS vs. MINUS | Jeen Broekstra | Axel | open | SPARQL 1.1 Query | ||
| MH-2 | 2011-01-21 | LC comments on 'Serializing SPARQL Query Results in JSON' | Michael Hausenblas | Draft response | Andy Seaborne | open | SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format | |
| RC-1 | 2011-01-21 | Comments on SPARQL Results in JSON | Richard Cyganiak | Draft response | Andy Seaborne | open | SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format |
Other comments that I think don't need a separate response, as resolved by discussions on the list already, but we might send a ping to the original sender to ask whether it's ok:
* BINDINGS in SPARQL Query 2010-10-14 Dave Beckett ... answered by Peter Ansell * typo in SPARQL 1.1 Query Language WD: invalid property "rdf:next" Michael Schneider ... answered by Andy
