Difference between revisions of "Comments"

From SPARQL Working Group
Jump to: navigation, search
(WD comments)
(WD comments)
Line 554: Line 554:
 
| DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT?
 
| DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT?
 
| Holger Knublauch
 
| Holger Knublauch
|  
+
| [http://www.w3.org/2009/sparql/wiki/CommentResponse:HK-2 Draft response HK-2]
 
| Paul Gearon
 
| Paul Gearon
 
| <span style="color:red">open</span>
 
| <span style="color:red">open</span>

Revision as of 17:46, 7 February 2011

Comments to SPARQL documents

  • Key to columns
    • Owner: WG member who is addressing issues and/or drafting response email
    • Response: links to response email and to subsequent acknowledgment from commenter
    • Status: should be "open", "Response sent", "ACK", "ACK - OK", or "ACK - NOT OK".

Current policy is to write proposed response in the wiki (below), send to WG mailing list, wait 2-3 business days, get some +1s from the WG, then reply.

Earlier comments

TBD: check mails May and previous...

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
SG-1, SG-2 2009-06-09 Problem with Schema, Errata for Protocol Simon Gibbs ? Protocol 1.1
CB-1 2009-07-03 Free-text search Chris Bizer Kjetil Kjersmo Response sent response Query 1.1
AL-1 2009-07-10 RDF dataset/SPARQL endpoint descriptions Andreas Langegger Gregrory Williams ? response Service Description 1.1
DB-1 2009-07-28 SPARQL spec layout Daniel Barclay ? Query 1.1
TI-1 2009-09-08 clarifying OPTIONALs Toby Inkster Lee Feigenbaum ACK - OK ack Query 1.0

WD comments

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
SR-1 2009-11-09 Inferencing on graph patterns Simon Reinhardt reinhardt-inference-1 Ivan Herman ACK - OK response, ack. None (was comment on inference regimes)
LD-1 2009-10-24 Comments on Query 1.1 FPWD Leigh Dodds ldodds-query-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1
LD-2 2009-10-24 Comments on Service Description 1.1 FPWD Leigh Dodds ldodds-sd-1 Gregory Williams Response sent response, ack Service Description 1.1
LD-3 2009-10-24 Comments onSPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol FPWD Leigh Dodds draft Chime Ogbuji Response sent response Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1
BL-1 2009-11-05 Comments on general directions of FPWD Ben Lavender BL Axel Polleres Response sent response Update 1.1, Protocol 1.1, Service Description 1.1
RV-1 2009-11-13 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Rob Vesse RV Steve Harris ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1
EF-1, EF-2, EF-3 2009-11-13 Comments on Entailment Regimes Enrico Franconi EF Birte Glimm Response sent response None (was comment on inference regimes)
JC-1 2009-11-02 LET or AS for "assignment" Jeremy Carroll Lee Feigenbaum? ? Query 1.1
HK-1 2009-10-25 Missing LET assignment Holger Knublauch Lee Feigenbaum? ? Query 1.1
TI-2 2009-11-30 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Aggregates Toby Inkster (answer sent directly) Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
RN-1 2010-01-09 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Update Richard Newman RN-1 Paul Gearon open Update 1.1
N3-1 2010-01-27 SPARQL paths and N3 paths: some quick thoughts Dan Connolly, Tim Berners-Lee Andy Seaborne Response sent response Property Paths
DR-1 2010-01-29 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths Doug Reid DR-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response -- ack Property Paths
JC-2 2010-02-06 non-formal question on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths Jeremy Carroll Axel Polleres ACK - OK response ack Property Paths
ED-1 2010-02-06 SPARQL 1.1 Query Aggregates syntax Emanuele Della Valle ED-1 Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
RV-2 2010-02-09 Comments on latest SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts Rob Vesse RV2 Gregory Williams ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1, PropertyPaths 1.1, Service Description 1.1
JC-3 2010-02-17 Comments on Property Paths FPWD (not indented as formal comment, though) Jeremy Carrol JC-3 Andy Seaborne Response sent response Property Paths
ST-1 2010-02-19 Request for named graph templates "everywhere" (e.g. named graph creation/modification in CONSTRUCT like in INSERT) Sebastian Trueg ST-1 Paul Gearon open Query 1.1, Update1.1
NH-1 + NH-2 + NH-3 2010-02-23 way of describing the supported results formats in SPARQL 1.1 Service Description (like e.g. in SADDLE) Nicholas J Humfrey NH-1 Gregory Williams ACK - OK response ack Service Description 1.1
RV-3 2010-02-25 Aggregates and property paths further comments Rob Vesse Steve Harris open Query1.1, Property Paths
NA-1 2010-03-18 Update syntax Nikolai Anissimov NA-1 Axel Polleres Response sent Response Update 1.1
RV-4 2010-03-23 Aggregates and property paths more comments Rob Vesse Draft response CommentResponse:RV-4 Steve Harris ACK - OK PropertyPaths, Query
RH-1 2010-03-31 abstract syntax for Update Ross Horne RH-1 Axel Polleres, Paul/Alex to check Response sent response Update 1.1
KK-1 2010-04-23 ISSUE-49 Kjetil Kjernsmo Response sent Chimezie Ogbuji response Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1
MH-1 TI-3 2010-06-03 suggested addition to SPARQL 1.1 Service Description "well-known endpoint" Michael Hausenblas MH-1 Gregory Williams Response sent Response Service Description 1.1
PA-1 2010-06-03 IRI creation and encoding Peter Ansell PA-1 Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
OH-1 2010-06-04 wrong example in the Fed.Ext. document Olaf Hartig Eric Prud'hommeaux Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extensions
PA-2 2010-06-23 semantics of DESCRIBE Peter Ansell PA-2 Gregory Williams ACK response ack Service Description 1.1
DS-1 2010-06-22 Brief comment on sd:name Damian Steer Gregory Williams open Service Description 1.1
JB-1 2010-07-27 RIF review of Entailment Regimes Jos De Bruijn Chime Response sent response Entailment
RK-1 2010-07-27 Feedback to some SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts Reto Krummenacher RK-1 Axel ACK - OK Update, Protocol, Federation, Service Description
TL-1 2010-08-09 Comments on "SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs" Tim Berners-Lee Chime Response sent response http-rdf-update
GK-1 , GK-2 2010-09-28 Comments on aggregation in SPARQL 1.1 Graham Klyne SteveH open Query 1.1
RC-1 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: HTTP status code for QueryRequestRefused Richard Cyganiak open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
RC-2 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: Format of fault messages Richard Cyganiak open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
GK-3 2010-10-01 Explanation of OPTIONAL vs { OPTIONAL } Graham Klyne Draft response GK-3 Axel Response sent response Query 1.1
JP-1 2010-10-29 Comments about the semantics of property paths Jorge Perez Response JP-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response Partial ack ack Query 1.1
JP-2 2010-12-15 Comments about the semantics of property paths Jorge Perez Response JP-2 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response ack (see also JP-3) Query 1.1
JP-3 2011-01-25 Comments about the semantics of property paths (cont) Jorge Perez Response JP-3 Andy Seaborne Response Sent response Query 1.1
JG-1 2010-11-16 Comments about functions and LET Jacek Gajek Draft response JG-1 Axel open Query 1.1
KK-2 KK-3 KK-4 KK-5 2010-11-01 No content-type on payload, What to do if no payload? Proper escaping of URIs and payload on update operations, HTTP DELETE Kjetil Kjernsmo Chime? open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs
MS-1 2010-10-25 Behavior of SPARQL Update INSERT on default graphs Michael Schneider Draft response MS-1 Alex open SPARQL 1.1 Update
DB-1 2010-10-14 Permit LOAD from a SPARQL CONSTRUCT endpoint David Booth Draft response DB-1 Alex ACK-OK Response SPARQL 1.1 Update
DBeckett-1 2010-12-05 Aggregates, Bindings and other comments David Becket Draft response DBeckett-1 Carlos open SPARQL 1.1 query and Fed extension
ID-1 2010-12-15 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 Ian Davis Response-ID-1 Chime Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
GR-2, GR-1 2011-01-05, 2011-01-6 "RDF Knowledge" (Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs) Gregg Reynolds Response-GR-1 Response-GR-2 Chime open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
HK-2 2011-01-05 DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT? Holger Knublauch Draft response HK-2 Paul Gearon open SPARQL 1.1 Update
BD-1 2011-01-12 comments on SPARQL 1.1 14 October 2010 Working Draft (editorial comments) Bob DuCharme Editorial Andy Seaborne Done Response/Done SPARQL 1.1 Query
SM-1 2011-01-13 [Query-errata] error in example query in SPARQL recommendation Sjoerd Mullender Editorial Andy Seaborne Done Response/Done SPARQL 1.1 Query
KK-6, GR-3 2011-01-14 (first message in thread) HTTP DELETE operation Kjetil Kjernsmo, Gregg Reynolds Chime? open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
KK-7 2011-01-19 Uniqueness of blank node labels Kjetil Kjernsmo Axel open SPARQL 1.1 Query
JB-2 2011-01-20 NOT EXISTS vs. MINUS Jeen Broekstra Axel open SPARQL 1.1 Query
MH-2 2011-01-21 LC comments on 'Serializing SPARQL Query Results in JSON' Michael Hausenblas Draft response Andy Seaborne open SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format
RC-1 2011-01-21 Comments on SPARQL Results in JSON Richard Cyganiak Draft response Andy Seaborne open SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format

Other comments that I think don't need a separate response, as resolved by discussions on the list already, but we might send a ping to the original sender to ask whether it's ok:

* BINDINGS in SPARQL Query 2010-10-14 Dave Beckett ... answered by Peter Ansell
* typo in SPARQL 1.1 Query Language WD: invalid property "rdf:next" Michael Schneider ... answered by Andy