Comments 2012-05-29

From SPARQL Working Group
(Redirected from Comments All)
Jump to: navigation, search

Comments to SPARQL documents (To 2012-05-29)

  • Key to columns
    • Owner: WG member who is addressing issues and/or drafting response email
    • Response: links to response email and to subsequent acknowledgment from commenter
    • Status: should be "open", "Response sent", "ACK", "ACK - OK", or "ACK - NOT OK".

All comments up to the consolidation of May 29, 2012

See *Comments* for current status.

After 2nd Last Call Cycle

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
DB-25 2012-05-25 Whitespace should be allowed before and after a Query or Update David Booth Editorial Editors response Grammar
DB-24 2012-05-25 Please allow trailing semicolon (";") after update statement David Booth Technical point Editors response Grammar
KK-15 2012-05-17 "Fresh" blank nodes vs. RDF Merge in Update Kjetil Kjernsmo Comment Response KK-15 Axel Open Update
DBeckett-5 2012-05-13 same test named syntax-bindings-01.rq appears twice in sparql 1.1 syntax-query test manifest Dave Beckett Comment Response DBeckett-5 Greg ACK - OK Response Ack Tests
DB-23 (from DB-22) 2012-05-11 CREATE SILENT David Booth Axel ACK-OK response ack Update
MSO-1 2012-05-07 more HTTP status code in SPARQL protocol spec manuelso CommentResponse:MSO-1 Chime ACK - OK response ack Graph Store Protocol
JL-3 (cont. from JL-2) 2012-05-08 Indirect Graph Identification James Leigh CommentResponse:JL-3 Chime Open Graph Store Protocol
WW-1 2012-04-19 regular path expressions William Waites Andy Response sent Response Query
SA-3 2012-04-17 BindingClause for Subqueries Stephen Allen Comment Response SA-3 Andy Open Query
DB-22 2012-04-16 Error in illustration of WITH clause David Booth Comment Response DB-22 Axel ACK-OK response ack Update
DB-21 2012-04-11 Editorial suggestion for CREATE operation David Booth Axel ACK-OK response ack Update
SP-1 2012-04-04 Question about grammar rule [79] Serena Pallecchi Specific Answer Answered Reply Query
AH-1 2012-03-28 SPARQL 1.1 comments relating to BINDINGS (also minor editorial comments) Aidan Hogan Comment Response AH-1 Andy Open Query
DBeckett-4 2012-03-27 SPARQL 1.1 CSV result tests comment Dave Beckett Comment Response DBeckett-4 Greg ACK - OK Response Ack Tests
DBeckett-3 2012-03-23 question on sparql 1.1 test 'Protect from error in AVG' Dave Beckett Specific answer. Answered Technical question answered on list. Query
AD-1 2012-03-13 Multiple BINDING clauses in SPARQL queries Alexander Dutton Comment Response AD-1 Andy Open Query
JB-10 2012-02-21 Re: Additional comments on the semantics of property paths Jeen Broekstra Comment Response JB-10 Lee response sent response Query
WM-1 2012-02-20 Additional comments on the semantics of property paths Wim Martens Comment Response WM-1 Lee Response sent response question back for clarification clarification Query
JB-9 2012-02-18 comment on SPARQL 1.1 CSV result format: datatyped literals Jeen Broekstra Comment Response JB-9 Andy Response sent Response CSV/TSV
DRD-1 2012-02-17 Comment on Path / PName clash and Turtle impact David Robillard Comment Response DRD-1 Andy Open Query
PA-3, PA-4 2012-02-08 SPARQL 1.1 Update Delete Insert order Peter Ansell Comment Response PA-3 Axel ACK OK response ack Update
DB-20 2012-02-08 Multi-line comments David Booth Comment Response DB-20 Andy Response acknowledged. Response Ack Query

Last Call (to Feb 2012)

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
SA-2 2012-02-06 UUID String Function Stephen Allen Comment Response SA-2 Andy Response acknowledged Response, Ack Query
JP-5 2012-02-05 Comment about implementation of property paths jorge perez Comment Response JP-5 Axel ACK - OK response ack Query
DB-19 2012-01-31 Feedback on decimal syntax David Booth Comment Response DB-19 Andy Response acknowledged Response, Ack Query
DB-18 2012-01-31 Feedback on character escape sequences in the local names David Booth Comment Response DB-18 Andy Response acknowledged Response, Ack Query
DB-17 2012-01-31 Please allow percent encoding in local part of prefixed name David Booth Comment Response DB-17 Andy Response acknowledged Response, Ack Query
JP-4 2012-01-28 Comments about the semantics of property paths jorge perez Comment Response JP-4 Lee Response acknowledged Response, Ack Query
MO-1 2012-01-30 SPARQL-SD question concerning Marcel Otto Comment Response MO-1 Greg Response sent Response Service Description

Post Last Call Comments

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
PF-1 2012-01-23 Direct Graph Identification Philip Fennell Comment Response PF-1 chime Open Graph Store Protocol
DP-1 2011-12-25 SPARQL Update: Example 5 Dimi Passon (original) Response sent response Update
DW-1 2011-12-08 SPARQL, PATCH and IE's XMLHttpRequest Object David Wood Comment Response DW-1 Chime Response sent response Protocol? Graph Store?
BD-2 2011-12-05 "SPARQL 1.1 Overview" comments Bob DuCharme Comment Response BD-2 Axel ACK - OK response ok Overview
HSt-1 2011-11-30 xsd:hexBinary and xsd:base64Binary not supported by D-ent. reg. Henry Story Comment Response HSt-1 bglimm ACK - OK Response - Ack Entailment Regimes
JL-2 2011-11-28 Indirect Graph Identification James Leigh (Reply by Sandro about new draft) Continues at comment JL-3 Response (new draft) Graph Store Protocol
DMc-1 2011-11-23 SPARQL 1.1 - LeftJoin definition David McNeil Editorial Andy Response sent Response Final edit Done. Query
TI-3 2011-11-16 SPARQL 1.1 Service Description comment Toby Inkster Comment Response TI-3 Greg ACK - OK Response ack Service Description
DB-16 2010-11-08 ENCODE_FOR_LOCAL_NAME David Booth Comment Response DB-16 Axel ACK - OK response ack Query
AM-1 2010-11-03 When is HAVING processed? Alex Miller Comment Response AM-1 bglimm ACK - OK Response - Ack Query
JL-1 2010-10-28 Blank Node Ordering James Leigh Comment Response JL-1 AndyS ACK - OK Response - Ack Query
JB-8 2010-10-20 error in testcase agg-avg-02 Jeen Broekstra Comment Response JB-8 Greg ACK - OK response ack Tests
DB-11a 2011-10-18 Clarification of variable scoping David Booth Comment Response DB-11a AndyS response sent Response Query
DB-15 2011-10-18 Editorial clarification in Basic Graph Pattern intro David Booth Editorial. AndyS Response sent. Response -- ack Query
HS-1 2011-10-11 Implementation issues of OPTIONAL Hong Sun Comment response HS-1 Lee ACK - OK response, ACK Query
DBecket-2 2011-10-09 Tests assume distinct output rows are a bad idea Dave Beckett Lee response sent Responded to Tests
DB-14 DB-14a DB-14b 2011-10-05 str() function should also accept blank node argument David Booth Comment response DB-14 Comment response DB-14b AndyS ACK - OK Answer to use case presented Response1

Response2 Response3 Ack

Query
DM-1 2011-09-17 reverse directions in property paths David Mizell Comment response DM-1 Andy Response sent: 2011-10-07 Response Query
DB-13 2011-09-14 Order of applying solution sequence modifiers David Booth No WG response required. Query
DB-12 2011-09-13 SPARQL Update - Clarifying correct behavior when a graph is created implicitly David Booth Comment response DB-12 Axel ACK - OK response (sent by Lee) ack Update
DB-11 2011-09-13 Clarification of variable scoping David Booth Comment response DB-11 Andy Response sent: 2011-10-07 Response -- see DB-11a. Query
DB-10 2011-09-12 Please put FILTER in section 17 title David Booth Comment response DB-10 Andy ACK - OK Response, ACK Query
DB-9 2011-09-12 Grammar for PREFIX definitions David Booth Comment response DB-9 Axel ACK - OK response ack Grammar (Update)
DB-8 2011-09-08 Clarification needed on BIND David Booth No WG response required. Query
BT-2 2011-09-07 Aggregation w/o data? Bryan Thompson Comment response BT-2 SteveH ACK http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-dawg-comments/2011Nov/0028.html Query
BT-3 2011-09-07 Clarification on errors and Aggregates Bryan Thompson Comment response BT-3 SteveH ACK http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-dawg-comments/2012Mar/0002.html Query

Last Call comments

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
RC-5 2011-08-11 Make clear that SPARQL prefixed names are not CURIEs Richard Cyganiak Comment response RC-5 Andy Done Response -- Ack Query
DB-7 2011-08-25 SPARQL 1.1 Service Description -- Need n3 or RDF/XML David Booth Comment response DB-7 DB-7a Greg ACK-OK Response Ack Response2 Ack2 Service Description
RC-4 2011-08-15 Security issue in SPARQL string escaping in SPARQL grammar Richard Cyganiak Comment response RC-4 AndyS (Query), Paul (Update) Response sent. Query, Update
JB-7 2011-08-02 comments on SPARQL 1.1 Query Last Call WD: builtin functions Jeen Broekstra Comment response JB-7 AndyS Response sent. Response sent Query
BT-1 2011-08-01 Questions concerning 11.7 (Aggregate Example (with errors)) Bryan Thompson SteveH closed response ack Query
MS-7 2011-07-30 LC Comment: Restriction on Solutions for RDF-Based Entailment Regime Michael Schneider Comment response MS-7 Birte ACK-OK Response - ACK Entailment
DB-6 2011-07-29 SPARQL 1.1 Service Description - Comments David Booth Comment response DB-6 Greg closed response ack Service Description
DB-5 2011-07-29 SPARQL 1.1 Update - Comments David Booth Comment response DB-5 Paul Open Update
DB-4 2011-07-29 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Query Language [includes 2 update comments] David Booth Comment response DB-4 Andy(query), ?(Update) Response sent. Query
MS-6 2011-07-26 LC Comments on Entailment Regimes, D-Entailment Michael Schneider Comment response MS-6 Birte ACK-OK Response - ACK Entailment
MS-5 2011-07-26 LC Comments on Entailment Regimes, Treatment of Inconsistency Michael Schneider Comment response MS-5 Birte Response sent Response - Entailment
MS-4 2011-07-26 LC Comments on Entailment Regimes, Illegal Handling Michael Schneider Comment response MS-4 Birte Response sent Response - Entailment
MS-3 2011-07-26 LC Comments on Entailment Regimes, Insufficient Definition Michael Schneider Comment response MS-3 Birte Response sent Response - Entailment
MS-2 2011-07-26 LC Comments on Entailment Regimes - Higher Order Queries Michael Schneider Comment response MS-2 Birte ACK-OK Response - ACK Entailment
KD-1 2011-07-18 Comment on XPath operators Kathrin Dentler Comment response KD-1 Andy Response sent Response Query
SA-1 2011-07-15 SPARQL XML to HTML XSL Performance Bug Stephen Allen Lee Open  ??
SC-4 2011-07-05 Re: Comments about property paths Sebastián Conca Chairs Done Response -- Ack Query
NL-1 2011-06-24 The limitations of "CONSTRUCT WHERE" in SPARQL 1.1 Niklas Lindström Comment response NL-1 Axel ACK-OK response - ack
JB-6 2011-06-23 SUM aggregate operator and non-numeric literals Jeen Broekstra Comment response JB-6 Steve Harris closed response ack Query 1.1
KK-14 2011-06-17 Another "Limit by resource" test case Kjetil Kjernsmo Comment response KK-14 Greg ACK-OK response ack Service Description
AZ-1 2011-06-15 Various comments on SPARQL 1.1 Entailment Regimes Antoine Zimmermann Draft response AZ-1, Draft Response 2 Birte Glimm ACK-OK Response Response2 ACK Entailment
KR-1 2011-06-14 Origin of Dataset? Karim Rafes Draft response KR-1 Greg Response sent response Service Description
SC-3 2011-06-06 Comments about property paths Sebastián Conca Draft response SC-3 Andy Ack 2011Jun/0011 -- Ack Query
HK-3 2011-06-02 Comparison with non-standard datatypes Holger Knublauch Draft response HK-3 Andy ACK-OK 2011Jun/0006 ack Query
AL-1 2011-06-01 Questions and comments on SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol draft Arnaud Le Hors Draft response AL-1 Chime Response drafted Graph Store HTTP Protocol
MH-LC-1 2011-05-29 Last Call comment on SPARQL 1.1 Update Michael Hausenblas draft response Lee ACK-OK response ack Update
IH-1 2011-05-25 (Editorial) comments on the SPARQL 1.1 Query Language draft Ivan Herman Draft response IH-1 Steve, Andy Response sent 2011Jun/0005 Query
IH-2 2011-05-25 mini editorial comment on the SPARQL 1.1 query language Ivan Herman Draft response IH-2 Andy Done 2011Aug/0007 -- ack Query
IM-1 2011-05-23 Implementation details of SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol Ivan Mikhailov Draft response IM-1 Chimezie Response sent 2011Nov/0029.html Graph Store HTTP Protocol
DB-3 2011-05-19 SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol - Typos David Booth Draft Response Chimezie Response drafted Graph Store HTTP Protocol
DB-2 2011-05-19 SPARQL 1.1 Service Description - Please make classes/properties hyperlinks David Booth Draft response DB-2 Greg ACK-OK response ack Service Description
SJ-1 2011-05-19 Comments on Graph Store HTTP Protocol (20110512) Simon Johnston Draft response SJ-1 Chimezie Response drafted Graph Store HTTP Protocol

Earlier comments

TBD: check mails May and previous...

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
SG-1, SG-2 2009-06-09 Problem with Schema, Errata for Protocol Simon Gibbs ? Protocol 1.1
CB-1 2009-07-03 Free-text search Chris Bizer Kjetil Kjersmo Response sent response Query 1.1
AL-2 2009-07-10 RDF dataset/SPARQL endpoint descriptions Andreas Langegger Gregrory Williams Closed discussion Service Description 1.1
DB-1 2009-07-28 SPARQL spec layout Daniel Barclay Closed Query 1.1
TI-1 2009-09-08 clarifying OPTIONALs Toby Inkster Lee Feigenbaum ACK - OK ack Query 1.0

Pre LC-Comments (processing)

This is an extract of the main table below, done Oct 2011.

It contains the comments where they are open or open-and-drafted (but not recorded as sent).

When finished (response sent), please delete the entry in this table and update the main table.

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
RC-1 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: HTTP status code for QueryRequestRefused Richard Cyganiak Lee open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
RC-2 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: Format of fault messages Richard Cyganiak Lee open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
DBeckett-1 2010-12-05 Aggregates, Bindings and other comments David Becket Old Draft response DBeckett-1, never sent Axel response sent response SPARQL 1.1 query and Fed extension
KK-6, GR-3 2011-01-14 (first message in thread) HTTP DELETE operation Kjetil Kjernsmo, Gregg Reynolds Chime? open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
GR-4 2011-01-26 Dataset, Graph Store, etc. Gregg Reynolds Draft response Chime open  ?
KK-8, KK-9 2011-02-02,07 Re: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 Kjetil Kjernsmo Chime open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
JC-4 JC-5 2011-02-16,17 s/URI/IRI/ in http://www.w3.org/TR/sparql11-http-rdf-update/#indirect-graph-identification Jeremy Carroll open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
KK-13 2011-03-25 Comment on "Dataset HTTP Protocol": Uses of "indirect" Kjetil Kjernsmo Chime open SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol
MLR-1 2011-04-01 HTTP status codes when no result is responded Markus Luczak-Rösch Lee open SPARQL 1.1 Protocol
Demairy-1 2011-05-04 File not found: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-sparql-XMLres/result2.xsd Erwan Demairy Lee open SPARQL 1.1 Protocol
JBolleman-1 JBolleman-2 2011-05-12 Pagination in SPARQL OFFSET and LIMIT needs ORDER BY Jerven Bolleman Draft response Axel Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Query
FS-1 2011-06-27 Syntax problem in Fed document Fernando Silva Draft response Carlos Buil drafted SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extension

WD comments

Comment Date What Author Wiki Page Owner Status Response/ack Affected Documents
SR-1 2009-11-09 Inferencing on graph patterns Simon Reinhardt reinhardt-inference-1 Ivan Herman ACK - OK response, ack. None (was comment on inference regimes)
LD-1 2009-10-24 Comments on Query 1.1 FPWD Leigh Dodds ldodds-query-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1
LD-2 2009-10-24 Comments on Service Description 1.1 FPWD Leigh Dodds ldodds-sd-1 Gregory Williams Response sent response, ack Service Description 1.1
LD-3 2009-10-24 Comments onSPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol FPWD Leigh Dodds draft Chime Ogbuji Response sent response Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1
BL-1 2009-11-05 Comments on general directions of FPWD Ben Lavender BL Axel Polleres Response sent response Update 1.1, Protocol 1.1, Service Description 1.1
RV-1 2009-11-13 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Rob Vesse RV Steve Harris ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1
EF-1, EF-2, EF-3 2009-11-13 Comments on Entailment Regimes Enrico Franconi EF Birte Glimm Response sent response None (was comment on inference regimes)
JC-1 2009-11-02 LET or AS for "assignment" Jeremy Carroll Lee Feigenbaum response sent response Query 1.1
HK-1 2009-10-25 Missing LET assignment Holger Knublauch Lee Feigenbaum response sent response Query 1.1
TI-2 2009-11-30 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Aggregates Toby Inkster (answer sent directly) Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
RN-1 2010-01-09 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Update Richard Newman RN-1 Paul Gearon ACK-OK response ACK Update 1.1
N3-1 2010-01-27 SPARQL paths and N3 paths: some quick thoughts Dan Connolly, Tim Berners-Lee Andy Seaborne Response sent response Property Paths
DR-1 2010-01-29 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths Doug Reid DR-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response -- ack Property Paths
JC-2 2010-02-06 non-formal question on SPARQL 1.1 Property Paths Jeremy Carroll Axel Polleres ACK - OK response ack Property Paths
ED-1 2010-02-06 SPARQL 1.1 Query Aggregates syntax Emanuele Della Valle ED-1 Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
RV-2 2010-02-09 Comments on latest SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts Rob Vesse RV2 Gregory Williams ACK - OK response ack Query 1.1, PropertyPaths 1.1, Service Description 1.1
JC-3 2010-02-17 Comments on Property Paths FPWD (not indented as formal comment, though) Jeremy Carrol JC-3 Andy Seaborne Response sent response Property Paths
ST-1 2010-02-19 Request for named graph templates "everywhere" (e.g. named graph creation/modification in CONSTRUCT like in INSERT) Sebastian Trueg ST-1 Paul Gearon response sent response Query 1.1, Update1.1
NH-1 + NH-2 + NH-3 2010-02-23 way of describing the supported results formats in SPARQL 1.1 Service Description (like e.g. in SADDLE) Nicholas J Humfrey NH-1 Gregory Williams ACK - OK response ack Service Description 1.1
RV-3 2010-02-25 Aggregates and property paths further comments Rob Vesse Steve Harris closed http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-dawg-comments/2011Oct/0012.html Query1.1, Property Paths
NA-1 2010-03-18 Update syntax Nikolai Anissimov NA-1 Axel Polleres Response sent Response Update 1.1
RV-4 2010-03-23 Aggregates and property paths more comments Rob Vesse Draft response CommentResponse:RV-4 Steve Harris ACK - OK PropertyPaths, Query
RH-1 2010-03-31 abstract syntax for Update Ross Horne RH-1 Axel Polleres, Paul/Alex to check Response sent response Update 1.1
KK-1 2010-04-23 ISSUE-49 Kjetil Kjernsmo Response sent Chimezie Ogbuji response Uniform HTTP Protocol 1.1
MH-1 TI-3 2010-06-03 suggested addition to SPARQL 1.1 Service Description "well-known endpoint" Michael Hausenblas MH-1 Gregory Williams Response sent Response Service Description 1.1
PA-1 2010-06-03 IRI creation and encoding Peter Ansell PA-1 Axel Polleres Response sent response Query 1.1
OH-1 2010-06-04 wrong example in the Fed.Ext. document Olaf Hartig Eric Prud'hommeaux Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extensions
PA-2 2010-06-23 semantics of DESCRIBE Peter Ansell PA-2 Gregory Williams ACK response ack Service Description 1.1
DS-1 2010-06-22 Brief comment on sd:name Damian Steer Gregory Williams ACK-OK Service Description 1.1
JB-1 2010-07-27 RIF review of Entailment Regimes Jos De Bruijn Chime Response sent response Entailment
RK-1 2010-07-27 Feedback to some SPARQL 1.1 Working Drafts Reto Krummenacher RK-1 Axel ACK - OK Update, Protocol, Federation, Service Description
TL-1 2010-08-09 Comments on "SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs" Tim Berners-Lee Chime Response sent response http-rdf-update
GK-1 , GK-2 2010-09-28 Comments on aggregation in SPARQL 1.1 Graham Klyne SteveH ACK - OK ack Query 1.1
RC-1 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: HTTP status code for QueryRequestRefused Richard Cyganiak open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
RC-2 2010-09-29 SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: Format of fault messages Richard Cyganiak open (postponed until Protocol has settled) Protocol 1.1
GK-3 2010-10-01 Explanation of OPTIONAL vs { OPTIONAL } Graham Klyne Draft response GK-3 Axel Response sent response Query 1.1
JP-1 2010-10-29 Comments about the semantics of property paths Jorge Perez Response JP-1 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response Partial ack ack Query 1.1
JP-2 2010-12-15 Comments about the semantics of property paths Jorge Perez Response JP-2 Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response ack (see also JP-3) Query 1.1
JP-3 2011-01-25 Comments about the semantics of property paths (cont) Jorge Perez Andy Seaborne ACK - OK response Ack Query 1.1
JG-1 2010-11-16 Comments about functions and LET Jacek Gajek Draft response JG-1 Axel ACK-OK response ack Query 1.1
KK-2 KK-3 KK-4 KK-12 2010-11-01 No content-type on payload, What to do if no payload? Proper escaping of URIs and payload on update operations, HTTP DELETE Kjetil Kjernsmo Draft response KK-12 Axel response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs
KK-5 2010-11-01 No content-type on payload, What to do if no payload? Proper escaping of URIs and payload on update operations, HTTP DELETE Kjetil Kjernsmo Draft response KK-5 Chime Response sent SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs
MS-1 2010-10-25 Behavior of SPARQL Update INSERT on default graphs Michael Schneider Draft response MS-1 Alex response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Update
DB-1 2010-10-14 Permit LOAD from a SPARQL CONSTRUCT endpoint David Booth Draft response DB-1 Alex ACK-OK Response SPARQL 1.1 Update
DBeckett-1 2010-12-05 Aggregates, Bindings and other comments David Becket Draft response DBeckett-1 Carlos open SPARQL 1.1 query and Fed extension
ID-1 2010-12-15 Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 Ian Davis Response-ID-1 Chime Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
GR-2, GR-1 and following 2011-01-05, 2011-01-6 "RDF Knowledge" (Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs) Gregg Reynolds Response-GR-1 Response-GR-2 Response-GR-dataset-protocol-general Chime, LeeF ACK-OK response, ack SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
HK-2 2011-01-05 DELETE and INSERT redundant vs. DELETE/INSERT? Holger Knublauch Draft response HK-2 Paul Gearon ACK-OK response ACK SPARQL 1.1 Update
BD-1 2011-01-12 comments on SPARQL 1.1 14 October 2010 Working Draft (editorial comments) Bob DuCharme Editorial Andy Seaborne Done Response/Done SPARQL 1.1 Query
SM-1 2011-01-13 [Query-errata] error in example query in SPARQL recommendation Sjoerd Mullender Editorial Andy Seaborne Done Response/Done SPARQL 1.1 Query
KK-6, GR-3 2011-01-14 (first message in thread) HTTP DELETE operation Kjetil Kjernsmo, Gregg Reynolds Chime? open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
KK-7 2011-01-19 Uniqueness of blank node labels Kjetil Kjernsmo Draft response KK-7 Axel ACK-OK response ack SPARQL 1.1 Query
JB-2 2011-01-20 NOT EXISTS vs. MINUS Jeen Broekstra Draft response JB-2 Axel ACK-OK response ack SPARQL 1.1 Query
MH-2 2011-01-21 LC comments on 'Serializing SPARQL Query Results in JSON' Michael Hausenblas Draft response Andy Seaborne Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format
RC-3 2011-01-21 Comments on SPARQL Results in JSON Richard Cyganiak Draft response Andy Seaborne Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 JSON Result Format
JB-3 2011-02-05 Implementing SPARQL 1.1 Query - feedback on Oct 14 WD Jeen Broekstra Steve Harris closed Jeen indicated in personal mail that this is no longer an issue. SPARQL 1.1 Query
RV-5 2011-01-26 RE: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol and Service Description Rob Vesse Draft response Gregory Williams Response sent response SPARQL 1.1 Service Description, RDF Dataset HTTP Protocol
RV-6 2011-02-11 Fwd: Further Comment on SPARQL 1.1 Service Description Rob Vesse Draft response Gregory Williams ACK - OK response ack SPARQL 1.1 Service Description
KK-8, KK-9 2011-02-02,07 Re: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 Kjetil Kjernsmo Chime open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
LD-4 2011-02-11 Re: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 Leigh Dodds Draft response Chime Response sent SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
JC-4 JC-5 2011-02-16,17 s/URI/IRI/ in http://www.w3.org/TR/sparql11-http-rdf-update/#indirect-graph-identification Jeremy Carroll open SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol
JB-4 2011-02-25 avg testcase issues Jeen Broekstra Steve Harris closed http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-dawg-comments/2011Jun/0012.html SPARQL 1.1 Query
RV-7 2011-02-24 Re: Further Feedback on SPARQL 1.1 Test Cases Rob Vesse Draft response Axel Polleres response sent [response http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-rdf-dawg-comments/2011Aug/0008.html] Test cases/MINUS/NOT EXISTS.
GR-5 2011-03-05 RDF notes Gregg Reynolds Draft response Axel Polleres Done Lee confirmed offlist that no official response needed. -
WG-1 2011-03-14 SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extensions William Greenly Draft response Carlos Buil closed SPARQL 1.1 Federated Query
KK-10 2011-03-18 Comments on "SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol for Managing RDF Graphs" Kjetil Kjernsmo Axel Polleres Done Superseeded by KK-11 which says that no answer is needed to that specific mail... see also KK-12 above. SPARQL 1.1 RDF Dataset HTTP Protocol
JB-5 2011-03-17  !=, NOT IN and type errors Jeen Broekstra Draft response Andy Done Response, Ack SPARQL 1.1 Query
SC-1 2011-03-18 Comments about property paths Sebastián Conca Draft response Andy Ack Response -- see SC-2 SPARQL 1.1 Query
SC-2 2011-04-07 Comments about property paths Sebastián Conca Draft response Andy Ack response ack -- see SC-3 SPARQL 1.1 Query
RS-1 RS-2 2011-03-28 Service description spec - service name Robert Scanlon Draft response Gregory Williams Response sent Response SPARQL 1.1 Service Description
KK-13 2011-03-25 Comment on "Dataset HTTP Protocol": Uses of "indirect" Kjetil Kjernsmo Chime open SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol
MLR-1 2011-04-01 HTTP status codes when no result is responded Markus Luczak-Rösch Lee open SPARQL 1.1 Protocol
PFPS-1 2011-04-11 Comments about blank nodes in Editors' draft of SPARQL update Peter Frederick Patel-Schneider Draft response Axel response sent response, PFPS response SPARQL 1.1 Update
MK-1, MK-2 2011-05-02 Proposal for simplifying FILTER semantics Markus Kroetzsch Draft response Axel ACK - OK response, ack SPARQL 1.1 Query
Demairy-1 2011-05-04 File not found: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-sparql-XMLres/result2.xsd Erwan Demairy Lee open SPARQL 1.1 Protocol
FS-1 2011-06-27 Syntax problem in Fed document Fernando Silva Draft response Carlos Buil open SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extension

Other comments that I think don't need a separate response, as resolved by discussions on the list already, but we might send a ping to the original sender to ask whether it's ok: