13:53:20 RRSAgent has joined #dap 13:53:20 logging to http://www.w3.org/2009/09/23-dap-irc 13:53:22 RRSAgent, make logs world 13:53:22 Zakim has joined #dap 13:53:24 Zakim, this will be DAPW 13:53:24 ok, trackbot; I see UW_DAP()10:00AM scheduled to start in 7 minutes 13:53:25 Meeting: Device APIs and Policy Working Group Teleconference 13:53:25 Date: 23 September 2009 13:54:03 Chair: Robin Berjon, Frederick Hirsch 13:54:11 brianleroux has joined #dap 13:54:52 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2009Sep/0069.html 13:56:07 Regrets: Dominique_Hazael-Massieux, Anssi_Kostiainen 13:56:10 AnssiK has joined #dap 13:56:40 Present: Robin Berjon, Frederick Hirsch 13:56:45 marengo has joined #dap 13:56:51 Hui_Miao has joined #dap 13:57:22 hui_miao has joined #dap 13:57:58 dtran has joined #dap 13:58:59 present+ arve 13:59:14 zakim, who is here? 13:59:14 UW_DAP()10:00AM has not yet started, arve 13:59:16 On IRC I see dtran, hui_miao, marengo, brianleroux, Zakim, RRSAgent, fhirsch, arve, ilkka, arg, blassey, maxf, trackbot, dom 13:59:27 JonathanJ has joined #DAP 13:59:27 hello =) 13:59:37 I'm on the call as well. 13:59:48 dtran is Dzung Tran 13:59:51 hello 14:00:00 regrets+ maxf 14:00:00 marengo is Marco Marengo 14:00:02 Present+ hui_miao 14:01:37 zakim, who is muted? 14:01:37 sorry, hui_miao, I don't know what conference this is 14:01:49 zakim not picking up on people calling in? 14:02:54 darobin has joined #dap 14:03:03 Claes has joined #dap 14:03:07 Kangchan has joined #dap 14:03:21 zakim, who is here? 14:03:21 UW_DAP()10:00AM has not yet started, arve 14:03:22 On IRC I see Kangchan, Claes, darobin, JonathanJ, dtran, hui_miao, marengo, brianleroux, Zakim, RRSAgent, fhirsch, arve, ilkka, arg, blassey, maxf, trackbot, dom 14:03:57 LauraArribas has joined #dap 14:05:10 Zakim, who's making noise? 14:05:10 sorry, darobin, I don't know what conference this is 14:05:15 this is DAP 14:05:18 the bridge is recursive echoing 14:05:18 zakim, this is DAP 14:05:18 ok, darobin; that matches UW_DAP()10:00AM 14:05:25 Zakim, who's making noise? 14:05:25 marcin3 has joined #dap 14:05:36 darobin, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: ??P0 (59%), [Vodaphone] (52%), Frederick_Hirsch (8%) 14:05:36 zakim, who is here 14:05:38 arve, you need to end that query with '?' 14:05:39 Zakim, who's here? 14:05:39 On the phone I see +1.604.685.aaaa, marengo, ??P0, arve, DzungTran, [ETRI], +035850486aabb, Ingmar_Kliche, richt, [Vodaphone], +03468697aacc, Frederick_Hirsch 14:05:42 On IRC I see marcin3, LauraArribas, Kangchan, Claes, darobin, JonathanJ, dtran, hui_miao, marengo, brianleroux, Zakim, RRSAgent, fhirsch, arve, ilkka, arg, blassey, maxf, trackbot, 14:05:44 ... dom 14:05:46 + +1.801.756.aadd 14:05:48 + +1.425.214.aaee 14:05:50 + +0777541aaff 14:05:52 zakim, mute me 14:05:54 marengo should now be muted 14:05:55 Zakim, [Vodafone] holds me 14:05:58 sorry, darobin, I do not recognize a party named '[Vodafone]' 14:05:58 zakim, [ETRI] is Kangchan 14:06:00 +Kangchan; got it 14:06:09 Zakim, [Vodaphone] holds me 14:06:09 +darobin; got it 14:06:12 Zakim, [Vodaphone] holds marcin3 14:06:12 +marcin3; got it 14:06:21 Preset+ LauraArribas 14:06:30 Present+ Brian LeRoux 14:06:33 Bryan has joined #dap 14:06:35 zakim, who is muted? 14:06:35 I see marengo, ??P0 muted 14:06:40 Present+ LauraArribas 14:06:41 ingmar has joined #dap 14:06:43 Present+ 14:06:43 Present+ RobinBerjon 14:06:45 zakim, ??P0 is hui_miao 14:06:45 +hui_miao; got it 14:06:50 Present+ MarcinHanclik 14:07:02 present+ 14:07:14 Present+ IlkkaOksanen 14:07:17 present+ DzungTran 14:07:20 + +04610801aagg 14:07:20 Present+ MarcoMarengo 14:08:11 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/victims-list.html 14:08:26 Scribe: marcin3 14:08:27 zakim, +0777541aaff is LauraArribas 14:08:27 +LauraArribas; got it 14:08:33 Scribe: Marcin 14:08:40 ScribeNick: marcin3 14:08:46 Present+ IngmarKliche 14:08:48 Chair: Frederick, Robin 14:09:17 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2009Sep/0069.html 14:09:20 richt has joined #dap 14:09:24 http://www.w3.org/mid/48336177-B0CC-456C-A1BF-C276AE299034@nokia.com 14:09:35 Topic: Welcome, agenda review, scribe selection 14:09:44 no changes to the agenda 14:09:46 Topic: Announcements, meeting planning, logistics 14:09:47 +1425.214.aaee is Bryan 14:09:51 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-device-apis/2009Sep/0000.html 14:10:00 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-device-apis/2009Sep/0003.html 14:10:19 reminder to register to TPAC meeting and book the hotel 14:10:36 Topic: Minutes approval 14:10:40 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2009Sep/0050.html 14:10:52 zakim, +1.425.214.aaee is Bryan 14:10:52 +Bryan; got it 14:11:17 zakim, +035850486aabb is ilkka 14:11:17 +ilkka; got it 14:11:19 resolution: minutes approved 14:11:37 action: robin to link minutes from the group page 14:11:37 Created ACTION-14 - Link minutes from the group page [on Robin Berjon - due 2009-09-30]. 14:11:44 Topic: Editorial Team report 14:12:03 The list of editors was sent 14:12:30 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2009Sep/0084.html 14:12:52 Robin's reSpec.js to get more attention, reviewed. Robin welcomes feedback. 14:13:40 actions discussed, just a few actions are left 14:14:17 Topic: Policy Segment 14:14:21 issue-18? 14:14:21 ISSUE-18 -- Determine security policy starting points for review and comparison -- RAISED 14:14:21 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/18 14:15:08 not many changes introduced within 1.01 as compared to 1.0 14:15:51 Dom did earlier comparison 14:15:52 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2009Jul/0015.html 14:16:25 FH: questions to the policy 14:17:01 FH: do we want features and capabilities? 14:17:11 FH: BONDI has both 14:17:33 FH: hierarchies of the features 14:17:37 Still unclear the differences 14:17:49 q+ marcin3 14:17:56 FH: discussion needed about features and capabilities 14:18:06 Bryan will help out there 14:18:08 capability; something the device can do (has a camera). features: camera api 14:18:10 ack 14:18:15 ack marcin3 14:18:45 FH: any volunteers to compare capabilities and features? 14:19:05 So for a certain client, that camera api might not be implemented because the client does not have the capability 14:19:08 ACTION: Marcin to review/compare device capabilities and features 14:19:08 Created ACTION-15 - Review/compare device capabilities and features [on Marcin Hanclik - due 2009-09-30]. 14:19:20 dtran: I think so yes 14:19:27 ACTION: Bryan to help review/compare device capabilities and features 14:19:27 Created ACTION-16 - Help review/compare device capabilities and features [on Bryan Sullivan - due 2009-09-30]. 14:19:30 q+ 14:19:44 ack Bryan 14:20:17 BS: Marcin and me may contributes 14:20:31 FH: requirements to be prepared for features/caps 14:21:08 comparison should probably include Lewontin workshop paper as well Bondi 1.01 and Nokia submissions 14:21:30 FH: Marcos did some stuff about reputation, other suggestions are welcome 14:21:42 FH: the group is open to new suggestions 14:22:00 FH: please send anything what could help to the list 14:22:23 FH: Robin to continue with the APIs 14:22:25 Topic: API Segment 14:23:01 RB: The initial requirements were provided on the list. Discussion points to be identified. 14:23:18 RB: Richard's input 14:23:28 issue-13? 14:23:28 ISSUE-13 -- Gathering requirements -- OPEN 14:23:28 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/13 14:23:33 issue-7? 14:23:33 ISSUE-7 -- Gathering requirements -- OPEN 14:23:33 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/7 14:23:37 http://www.w3.org/mid/355A518BC0575547B2A3D6773AAF8EEF3F39A2@ftrdmel1 14:24:01 RB: it is about messaging, coverage. Is it clearer, Richard? 14:24:15 RT: what is the concept of the ubiquitos Web? 14:24:31 q+ 14:24:44 RT: should telephony/SMS be included? 14:24:57 RB: ubiquitos means "it runs everywhere" 14:25:24 RB: screens in watches, urinals are also Web 14:25:30 yes, telephony/SMS should be 14:25:41 RB: capabilities of the device are important 14:26:12 RB: ubiquitos and not capable do not necessarily clash 14:26:54 RB: the existing messaging proposals (Nokia, BONDI etc) may suggest want we need 14:27:19 RB: messaging must be able to address different transports, capabilities and related details 14:27:47 RB: emails need attachments, differences may suggest the design 14:28:59 BS: the goal of ubiquitos Web is to address potential environment, awareness, context 14:29:25 RB: Richard, will you be able to proceed for the next week 14:29:26 q- 14:29:39 RB: Calendar API, issue-7 14:29:47 issue-7? 14:29:47 ISSUE-7 -- Gathering requirements - calendar -- OPEN 14:29:47 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/7 14:30:04 RT: some feedback provided 14:30:23 RT: a lot to be done on the high level 14:30:25 rrsagent, draft minutes 14:30:25 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2009/09/23-dap-minutes.html JonathanJ 14:30:43 RT: should we support more than 1 calendars? 14:30:48 RB: there are pros and cons 14:31:00 RB: it should be clarified over email 14:31:04 RB: Arve has comments 14:31:19 RB: what does it mean to support iCalendar 14:31:31 Resolution: let's continue over email 14:31:33 multiple calendars for family, work, play calendars 14:31:46 crobiso1 has joined #dap 14:31:58 +??P12 14:32:05 ABe to send comments 14:32:23 issue-14? 14:32:23 ISSUE-14 -- Gathering requirements -- OPEN 14:32:23 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/14 14:32:50 RB: the long list of requirements about NavigatorPlatform 14:33:51 TRAN: it stems from geolocation, I will send another email 14:33:52 zakim, +??P12 is JonathanJ 14:33:52 sorry, JonathanJ, I do not recognize a party named '+??P12' 14:34:21 zakim, who is here ? 14:34:21 On the phone I see +1.604.685.aaaa, marengo (muted), hui_miao, arve, DzungTran, Kangchan, ilkka, Ingmar_Kliche, richt, [Vodaphone], +03468697aacc, Frederick_Hirsch, 14:34:24 On IRC I see crobiso1, richt, ingmar, Bryan, marcin3, LauraArribas, Kangchan, Claes, darobin, JonathanJ, dtran, hui_miao, marengo, brianleroux, Zakim, RRSAgent, fhirsch, arve, 14:34:25 RB: a good requirement would be to have: the interface must provide the information about battery level 14:34:26 Zakim, P12 is JonathanJ 14:34:28 ... +1.801.756.aadd, Bryan, LauraArribas, +04610801aagg, ??P12 14:34:30 ... ilkka, arg, blassey, maxf, trackbot, dom 14:34:31 [Vodaphone] has marcin3 14:34:33 sorry, arve, I do not recognize a party named 'P12' 14:35:06 RB: functional requirements to be provided 14:35:11 http://dev.w3.org/2009/dap/camera/Overview.html 14:35:22 ACTION: TRAN to provided more functional requirements 14:35:22 Created ACTION-17 - Provided more functional requirements [on Dzung Tran - due 2009-09-30]. 14:35:26 crobiso1 is Clayne Robison 14:35:35 http://dev.w3.org/2009/dap/contacts/Overview.html 14:35:39 http://dev.w3.org/2009/dap/file-system/Overview.html 14:35:59 RB: does anyone want to take care of contact, FS? 14:36:29 ACTION: Arve to review Contacts requirements 14:36:29 Created ACTION-18 - Review Contacts requirements [on Arve Bersvendsen - due 2009-09-30]. 14:36:29 ACTION: Bryan Leroux to review contact, camera, file-system 14:36:29 Created ACTION-19 - Leroux to review contact, camera, file-system [on Bryan Sullivan - due 2009-09-30]. 14:36:42 action-6? 14:36:42 ACTION-6 -- Robin Berjon to send a reminder about TPAC -- due 2009-09-09 -- CLOSED 14:36:42 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/6 14:36:53 action-19? 14:36:53 ACTION-19 -- Bryan Sullivan to leroux to review contact, camera, file-system -- due 2009-09-30 -- OPEN 14:36:53 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/actions/19 14:37:15 BS: I will be providing general comments 14:37:24 mib_jts3v7h1 has joined #dap 14:37:35 issue-6? 14:37:35 ISSUE-6 -- Gathering requirements -- OPEN 14:37:35 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/6 14:37:36 http://www.w3.org/mid/op.u0pjj6d2byn2jm@galactica 14:37:53 issue-6 is applauncher 14:38:13 ABe: my proposal is controversial 14:39:03 ACTION: Marcin to send comments about Arve's requirements for ISSUE-6 14:39:03 Created ACTION-20 - Send comments about Arve's requirements for ISSUE-6 [on Marcin Hanclik - due 2009-09-30]. 14:39:23 ACTION: Bryan to send comments about Arve's requirements for ISSUE-6 14:39:23 Created ACTION-21 - Send comments about Arve's requirements for ISSUE-6 [on Bryan Sullivan - due 2009-09-30]. 14:39:43 issue-5? 14:39:43 ISSUE-5 -- Gathering requirements -- OPEN 14:39:43 http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/5 14:39:57 issue-5 is Application Configuration 14:40:18 Arve: we probably drop the AppConfig from the deliverables 14:40:28 mib_jts3v7h1 has left #dap 14:40:33 q+ 14:41:10 ack Bryan 14:41:18 MH: BONDI considers dropping AppConfig once A&E and Storage specs are ready 14:42:27 BS: we need some local storage. If it is HTML5 or widget context, it shall be enough. We should not leave it to the other groups. 14:42:45 RB: DAP does not specify what HTML-X browser shall support 14:43:07 RB: we just re-use other specification. 14:43:11 mib_jts3v7h1 has joined #dap 14:43:24 mib_jts3v7h1 has left #dap 14:43:57 BS: it is important to address the related requirements 14:44:10 http://www.w3.org/TR/webstorage/ 14:44:11 RB: W3C already takes care 14:44:12 q+ 14:44:59 ack arve 14:45:03 BS: we should not confuse people, requirements document should specify that AppConfig is not in the scope of DAP, if it is the fact 14:45:30 Arve: then we should specify the same for other specs, like e.g. Geolocation. We do not do this on purpose. 14:46:07 BS: it should be documented what was NOT done 14:46:17 RB: the APIs are independent 14:46:24 RB: where should we document that? 14:46:35 BS: in the Scope section of the documents 14:46:48 BS: rationale should be documented 14:47:14 RB: should we publish a note about why something was dropped? 14:47:20 q+ 14:47:41 ack arve 14:47:41 BS: my point is: we are silent upon some important aspects 14:48:00 Arve: we are not silent, other specification resolve the problems 14:48:16 q+ 14:48:26 ack Kangchan 14:48:36 Zakim, who's making noise? 14:48:49 darobin, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Kangchan (30%), Bryan (70%), +04610801aagg (9%), JonathanJ (44%) 14:48:58 the resolution should document clearly why we drop the item, and be put on the issue's tracker 14:49:02 DanielColoma has joined #dap 14:49:06 +1 14:49:10 BS: we should not stay silent 14:49:37 Kangchan: I agree, I propose to make a primer document that would clarify the scope of DAP. 14:49:55 RB: people are welcome non-normative docs/primers 14:50:13 RB: we are heading for many specs, we need editors. 14:50:19 q+ 14:50:36 RB: the docs should be put into CVS for further discussion 14:50:38 ack fhirsch 14:50:40 q+ 14:50:48 FH: what is wrong with the note in the document? 14:50:56 RB: we never published a req document 14:51:32 RB: if we reach consensus on concise req docs, we would result in better specs 14:52:18 Arve: what about an umbrella requirements document? 14:52:25 ISSUE: Should we have an umbrella requirements document? 14:52:25 Created ISSUE-22 - Should we have an umbrella requirements document? ; please complete additional details at http://www.w3.org/2009/dap/track/issues/22/edit . 14:52:30 q- 14:53:15 PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Drop the work item on AppConfig; discuss on list whether and where to document that as part of ISSUE-22 14:53:37 wonsuk has joined #dap 14:53:38 RESOLUTION: Drop the work item on AppConfig; discuss on list whether and where to document that as part of ISSUE-22 14:53:46 no objection to the resolution 14:53:58 RB: no further reqs 14:54:02 ClaesN has joined #dap 14:54:43 RB: do we do action/issue review? 14:54:51 FH: no need now 14:54:56 RB: AOB 14:54:59 Topic: AOB 14:55:07 q+ 14:55:09 No AOBs. 14:55:46 Kangchan: in Korea there will be a device API related workshop tomorrow 14:56:07 Kangchan: we will have phonegap and similar inputs 14:56:20 RB: feedback from the meeting will be welcome 14:56:25 No AOBs. 14:56:29 ADJOURNED 14:56:29 -Bryan 14:56:30 We adjourn. 14:56:30 bye 14:56:32 - +1.801.756.aadd 14:56:33 - +03468697aacc 14:56:33 bye 14:56:33 -arve 14:56:34 -LauraArribas 14:56:34 -ilkka 14:56:34 -richt 14:56:35 -marengo 14:56:37 -Kangchan 14:56:39 - +1.604.685.aaaa 14:56:41 -[Vodaphone] 14:56:43 -Ingmar_Kliche 14:56:45 -hui_miao 14:56:46 richt has left #dap 14:56:47 -DzungTran 14:56:48 RRSAgent: make minutes 14:56:48 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2009/09/23-dap-minutes.html darobin 14:56:49 -Frederick_Hirsch 14:56:51 - +04610801aagg 14:56:53 -JonathanJ 14:56:55 UW_DAP()10:00AM has ended 14:56:57 Attendees were +1.604.685.aaaa, marengo, arve, DzungTran, Ingmar_Kliche, richt, +03468697aacc, Frederick_Hirsch, +1.801.756.aadd, Kangchan, darobin, marcin3, hui_miao, 14:57:00 ... +04610801aagg, LauraArribas, Bryan, ilkka, JonathanJ 14:57:26 fhirsch: brilliant, thanks! 14:59:30 RRSAgent: stop