12:59:30 RRSAgent has joined #swxg 12:59:30 logging to http://www.w3.org/2009/06/24-swxg-irc 12:59:32 +??P20 12:59:34 zakim, ??P20 is me 12:59:34 +AndreaP; got it 12:59:36 +DKA 12:59:47 zakim, mute me 12:59:47 AndreaP should now be muted 12:59:55 renato has joined #swxg 12:59:57 i called in before IRCing 13:00:03 + +1.510.931.aabb 13:00:04 +??P24 13:00:06 mib_b1a6jx0a has joined #swxg 13:00:06 DKA has joined #swxg 13:00:06 zakim, who's on the phone 13:00:07 zakim, unmute me 13:00:12 I don't understand 'who's on the phone', rreck 13:00:13 \nick mattroweshow 13:00:14 AndreaP should no longer be muted 13:00:20 Zakim, ??P24 is HarryH 13:00:20 +HarryH; got it 13:00:26 zakim, mute me 13:00:27 +Phil_Archer 13:00:27 AndreaP should now be muted 13:00:37 zakim, who is on the phone 13:00:37 I don't understand 'who is on the phone', rreck 13:00:56 zakim, who is here? 13:00:56 On the phone I see pchampin, +1.203.858.aaaa, ??P18, AndreaP (muted), DKA, +1.510.931.aabb, HarryH, Phil_Archer 13:00:58 On IRC I see DKA, mattroweshow, renato, RRSAgent, rreck, PhilA2, jsalvachua, mischat, hhalpin, melvster, AndreaP, FabGandon, Zakim, trackbot, Cloud, dom 13:00:58 bblfish has joined #swxg 13:01:19 renato on irc only 13:01:22 +??P28 13:01:33 +jsalvachua 13:01:33 hi 13:01:43 zakim, ??P18 is me 13:01:44 +rreck; got it 13:02:03 + +4222aacc 13:02:12 hajons has joined #swxg 13:02:22 Zakim, +4222aacc is me 13:02:23 +mattroweshow; got it 13:03:08 Zakim, read agenda from http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/socialweb/weekly-agenda.rdf 13:03:09 working on it, hhalpin 13:03:10 done reading agenda, hhalpin 13:03:41 + +46.1.08.01.aadd 13:04:20 Zakim, who's here? 13:04:22 On the phone I see pchampin, +1.203.858.aaaa, rreck, AndreaP (muted), DKA, +1.510.931.aabb, HarryH, Phil_Archer, ??P28, jsalvachua, mattroweshow, +46.1.08.01.aadd 13:04:28 On IRC I see hajons, bblfish, DKA, mattroweshow, renato, RRSAgent, rreck, PhilA2, jsalvachua, mischat, hhalpin, melvster, AndreaP, FabGandon, Zakim, trackbot, Cloud, dom 13:04:36 pchampin has joined #swxg 13:04:58 Convene SWXG WG meeting of 2009-06-24T13:00-15:00Z 13:05:14 caribou has joined #swxg 13:05:21 zakim, call carine-617 13:05:21 ok, caribou; the call is being made 13:05:23 +Carine 13:05:24 Zakim, pick a scribe? 13:05:24 I don't understand your question, hhalpin. 13:05:28 Zakim, pick a scribe 13:05:28 Not knowing who is chairing or who scribed recently, I propose jsalvachua 13:05:41 Who volunteered for scribing? 13:05:47 Scribe: Cloud 13:05:56 Chair: hhalpin 13:06:05 PROPOSED: to approve SWXG WG Weekly -- 17 June 2009 as a true record 13:06:14 scribenick cloud 13:06:15 Minutes from the last meeting, chair asks if everyone happy 13:06:16 +1 13:06:18 +1 13:06:19 +1 13:06:30 +1 to PhilA's scribing. 13:06:31 ACCEPTED approve SWXG WG Weekly -- 17 June 2009 as a true record 13:06:51 2. General Organization and Task Forces 13:06:52 oshani has joined #swxg 13:06:55 Invited speaker will join fairly shortly, go through some actions in the meantime 13:07:08 There was a discussion about context, and also about the portability task 13:07:11 +MIT531 13:07:22 Joe Queen wrote a very nice scoping statement 13:07:31 + +1.510.472.aaee 13:07:32 Have first portability task meeting after our July 1st meeting next week 13:07:41 No comments on portability? 13:07:45 hhalpin: Any comments from anyone on that? 13:07:54 hope to have comments on the mail 13:08:18 Zakim, aaee?? is kaliya 13:08:18 sorry, hhalpin, I do not recognize a party named 'aaee??' 13:08:23 Zakim, aaee is kaliya 13:08:23 +kaliya; got it 13:08:26 +FabGandon 13:08:52 hhalpin: Joe, are you happy to have that task force meeting after next week's one? 13:08:55 Joe: Yes 13:08:59 RESOLVED: Task force meeting next week after the regular telecon 13:09:13 3. User Stories 13:09:34 hhalpin: User stories; Tim can't make it; Harry asks if anyone would like to help Tim to turn the user stories into a more coherent document 13:09:49 MacTed has joined #swxg 13:10:08 I helped out, and am interested 13:10:14 ... This tasks involves editing the W3C doc, going through stories on the wiki, seeing what overlaps, abstract functionality - need volunteers to help out - think on this please 13:10:23 hhalpin: Deadline is end of the year 13:10:36 I can work on it during summer. 13:10:37 +OpenLink_Software 13:10:40 Fabien? 13:10:42 hhalpin: Good to have one person who did it before and one new person 13:10:53 Zakim, OpenLink_Software is temporarily MacTed 13:10:53 +MacTed; got it 13:11:01 Zakim, mute me 13:11:01 MacTed should now be muted 13:11:02 +??P36 13:11:03 FabGandon: Can work on it during July 13:11:22 ACTION: hhalpin to create draft use-case document in W3C CVS 13:11:22 Created ACTION-44 - Create draft use-case document in W3C CVS [on Harry Halpin - due 2009-07-01]. 13:11:27 4. Context 13:11:42 hhalpin: Moving on to context, big discussion that Harry missed due to timing errors - looking for summar 13:11:47 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-socialweb/2009Jun/0121.html 13:12:20 Dan? Took a look at discussion that took place, and wrote an e-mail yesterday about it. Integrated comments that came back. 13:12:26 ... suggesting a charter for the task force 13:12:44 ... aims to create a vocabulary, looking at existing ones for the ubiquitous web 13:12:48 i agree look for existing vocabularies 13:12:54 ... very close link between context and privacy 13:13:20 ... should be link between task forces that look at privacy where privacy issues are due to when context is the cause 13:13:24 sounds good. Starting with a vocab, would help find out what the whole thing covers 13:13:41 s/Dan/PhilA/ 13:13:59 hhalpin: DKA, you were talking about a geolocation API too, so may be related 13:14:43 DKA: Ask Lars or Eric or some other chair to come and discuss issues with privacy in the Geolocation WG 13:14:50 ACTION: DKA to invite Dan to W3C Social Web XG for context comm call 13:14:50 Created ACTION-45 - Invite Dan to W3C Social Web XG for context comm call [on Daniel Appelquist - due 2009-07-01]. 13:15:17 hhalpin: Will this be part of the task force or the main concall? 13:15:26 s/hhalpin/PhilA/ 13:15:26 ... want to have this discussion before August 7th 13:16:15 August 7th - Nathan Eagle. 13:17:00 5. Invited Guest Invitations 13:17:02 :-) 13:17:03 hhalpin: Skip everything else and go to invited speaker 13:17:08 [CONTINUES] ACTION: danbri to find someone from Opera to talk Widgets 13:17:15 [CONTINUES] ACTION: danbri and karl to contact Evan of identi.ca over OpenMicroblogging and W3C. 13:17:33 hhalpin: Invited speaker is Kaliya Hamlin 13:17:36 ... aka IdentityWoman 13:17:50 ... http://www.identitywoman.net/ 13:17:57 [CONTINUES] ACTION:Renato and DanBri and hhalpin to schedule DataPortability.org/XMPP 13:18:03 http://www.w3.org/2001/01/cgi-irc 13:18:07 http://www.w3.org/2001/01/cgi-irc 13:19:46 6. Creating User Stories on the Wiki 13:19:54 [CONTINUES] ACTION: tpa to W3C-style "edit" user stories 13:20:05 [CONTINUES] ACTION: tinkster to document danbri's microblogging provenance question as a user story. 13:20:18 [CONTINUES] ACTION: danbri write up orkut/i18n/"looking for" issue. 13:20:33 [CONTINUES] ACTION: tinkster to document developer stories on wiki. 13:22:46 7. Social Network Matrix 13:22:53 [CONTINUES] ACTION: hhalpin to retrieve top X social networking sites from the top 500 sites of Alexa 13:22:59 [CONTINUES] ACTION: cperey to make list of top 30 to do profiles on, to merge with hhalpin's list on alexa 13:23:08 [CONTINUES] ACTION: karl to create the matrix to be filled 13:23:38 kaliya: Hi everybody! Asks how many people here 13:23:42 hhalpin: About 20 people 13:23:48 there are 22 people on irc 13:24:09 Kaliya is from Internet Identity Workshop 13:24:14 kaliya: I sent you a lot of links, hope you read them, didn't send additional ones with history and context of the community 13:24:26 Which has been a quite important community and event in creating notions of digital identity, openID. 13:24:33 kaliya: history is that Identity Commons came together to see how individuals could manage and control their own identities 13:24:44 ... so that they could own this layer of the web 13:24:56 ... Community formed in 2004/2005 was really focussed on user-centric identity 13:25:30 ... Harry asked me to talk about high level strategies, key terms are in the community lexicon which defines shared language (e.g. the word identity) 13:25:46 ... community stopped arguing about what identity meant, and focussed more on identifiers 13:26:14 ... and came to definitions of what claims where, in that they are really just attributes 13:26:45 ... claims can be made by yourself for yourself or by other entities (e.g. companies, non-profits) for other people 13:26:49 seems the important concepts so far: identifier (not necessarily a URI) and entity (anything that can make a statement about an identifier) 13:27:09 ... separation between authentication and authorisation, and enrolment 13:27:24 entity ~ foaf:Agent? (just trying to align my own vocabulary...) 13:27:26 I added the Social Web XG to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_web 13:27:30 ... In the same article about community, user-centric, company-centric and card?-centric 13:27:40 also added foaf+ssl to http://wiki.idcommons.net/Identity_Landscape 13:27:42 user-centric/card-centric/organization-centric 13:27:47 Infocard 13:27:56 ... references informationcards.net 13:28:15 http://informationcard.net/ 13:28:28 ... Misunderstanding that the only org involved is Microsoft, but the open source grassroots community has embraced and extended it even further 13:28:55 ... That project is called the "Hidden Project"? Available on Adobe Air 13:29:07 ... Interesting journey to get to where we are today 13:29:08 Venn diagram: http://www.xmlgrrl.com/publications/IEEESecPriv-MarApr2008-MalerReed-Venn.pd 13:29:11 http://www.xmlgrrl.com/publications/IEEESecPriv-MarApr2008-MalerReed-Venn.pdf 13:29:38 ... All social networking platforms show up at their events; very market driven; "what are users tell us are what we will do" 13:29:40 Higgins Project 13:29:52 ... They are working really well together to support portability and open authentication 13:29:58 nn Diagram Identity 13:30:09 http://www.eclipse.org/higgins/ 13:30:13 ... PortableContacts for standardising the info people have in their networks 13:30:33 contacts or context? 13:30:41 q+ 13:30:42 kaliya: Ready to answer questions on what they've read and what they want to know about the community 13:31:04 hhalpin: We haven't thought about the notion of identity so far 13:31:17 ... Haven't talked about Information Cards 13:31:30 ... Will be more asking for guidance about the identity landscape 13:31:36 ... User versus card versus organisation 13:31:53 kaliya: that is an old model, but now we have gotten to the Venn of identity 13:32:13 ... evolution of our thinking is to help SWXG get to where they have gotten to, or at least to see how to get there 13:32:34 hhalpin: Through the link out on IRC to the paper Harry has read and suggests other in SWXG do too 13:32:34 hajons has joined #swxg 13:32:55 hhalpin: A lot of backgrounds in this group are from portability from Semantic Web and also mobile phones + social networking 13:33:02 ack 13:33:03 q+ 13:33:06 Azakim, ack 13:33:08 Zakim, ack 13:33:08 I don't understand 'ack', hhalpin 13:33:11 Zakim, q- 13:33:12 I see bblfish, caribou on the speaker queue 13:33:22 bblfish: Henry in a cafe 13:33:36 ... added to the identity landscape wiki about foaf+ssl work 13:33:42 ... using URIs for identity 13:33:49 ack bblfish 13:33:54 ... interesting to hear how that work can integrate more into the identity commons 13:33:56 lubna has joined #swxg 13:34:23 kaliya: has heard about foaf - wants to bring more info about it to the Identity Commons community 13:34:35 bblfish: Is it enough to add to the wiki? 13:34:53 kaliya: Join the community list, 500-600 people, was the mailing list that got the community started 13:35:04 Do we have anyone on that identity commons mailing-list? 13:35:05 ... Say hey do you know about this, we're working on it, and get people to interact with you 13:35:10 bblfish: Will try that 13:35:13 Perhaps we should get a liason? 13:35:38 kaliya: More formal process 13:35:44 hhalpin: Asks what this process is 13:36:56 kaliya: Unique organisation as described in charter (non-proscriptive), have a monthly call 13:37:06 ack caribou 13:37:10 hhalpin: Might discuss if we should have someone join from SWXG 13:37:47 caribou: Do you have links to the ISO work on identity management 13:38:07 kaliya: Haven't to her knowledge 13:38:17 +q 13:38:23 ack hajons 13:38:24 hhalpin: Any more questions? 13:38:30 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27 WG5 working on an Identity Management framework 13:39:02 caribou - should we ask ISO to present on what they are up to? 13:39:31 hajons: In telecommunications, have IMF - identity management - connect telecommunications network through the internet - has there been participation from IMF vendors etc. 13:40:10 kaliya: Has been participation from European telecommunications vendors 13:40:14 s/IMF/IMS 13:40:44 kaliya: Our community is mainly made up of web portal folks and large enterprises 13:40:58 kaliya: Y!, Google, MySpace, Facebook, Plaxo, etc. 13:41:01 q+ 13:41:05 ack hhalpin 13:41:37 notes that W3C PLING has a liaison under way with ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27 WG5 13:41:58 hhalpin: One thing we're trying to do is something similar to IC - you pointed out abstract functionality, separations that came out of IC - authentication, authorisation, validation - where is this written up? 13:42:36 kaliya: Article about cultivating community and shared language links to the lexicon; one of the first things they did 13:43:07 zakim, mute me 13:43:07 DKA should now be muted 13:43:12 hhalpin: Seems that what has happened in Internet Identity workshops is that you have technology that is filling these functionalities; in W3C groups, we are not sure how they all fit together 13:43:59 ... need details of how technology X with functionality Y and are thinking of a matrix that could be used in our final report to W3C 13:44:48 identifier: OpenID - an anchor 13:44:54 kaliya: What are we managing? Step back and ask why are we managing for people. e.g. identifiers, openid gives people an anchor on the web 13:44:58 via their own domain name or an identity provider 13:45:02 ... either as their own domain name or a facebook url 13:45:15 ... another key thing that came out of the community was discovery 13:45:25 ... how do you find out what came out of the endpoint? 13:45:38 ... Does it point to where my photos, IMs, etc. area? 13:45:45 s/area/are 13:45:59 kaliya: Kind of spun out into it's own spec and part of XRI tech committee at OASIS 13:46:12 ... How can people link their different accounts together without giving away their passwords 13:46:18 kaliya: XRD = discovery, what does an endpoint do, take a phone call, etc. 13:46:19 ... Data portability / user control ideas 13:46:33 -Phil_Archer 13:46:40 PhilA2 has left #swxg 13:46:54 ... Hand me a card that allows some claims to be made 13:47:01 ... Different from the physical version 13:47:17 ... In real world, they don't take a photocopy of your driver's license 13:47:24 ... In digital world, just want to share some info 13:47:38 ... It's enough to know age, not eye colour - selective disclosure 13:47:53 ... MS bough Qidentica who does this selective disclosure 13:48:35 ... Another wing of community is focussed on how individuals could have tools that help them manage relationships with companies they do business with (productCRM) 13:48:53 http://projectvrm.net/ 13:49:05 ... Midack? in the UK and lots of activity in London around VRM hub 13:49:24 ... Identities never happen in isolation - in context of a group or entity or other individuals 13:49:40 blackley relationship paper 13:49:43 ... Great paper by Bob Blakley 13:49:49 ... relationship paper 13:50:02 http://identityblog.burtongroup.com/bgidps/2009/02/relationship-paper-now-freely-available.html 13:50:24 hhalpin: Great pointers and info 13:50:34 mib_57c6teqa has joined #swxg 13:50:48 ... after telecon we will go through these notes and try to extract general points 13:51:05 ... Idea of invited speakers makes more and more cross-community conversations 13:51:23 ... Internet Identity Workshop is happening in November in California at around the same time as the W3C meeting 13:51:38 ... Asks Kaliya for format of the IIW 13:51:42 +1 IIW 13:51:43 sounds good. 13:51:44 ... and asks if anyone is planning to go 13:51:46 +1 13:51:52 +0.5 13:52:00 http://www.internetidentityworkshop.com/ 13:52:09 kaliya: Twice a year 13:52:21 ... Same place 13:52:29 ... Where all the big Social Web companies are 13:52:36 ... in Silicon valley 13:52:45 ... Don't have an agenda ahead of time, bring communities together 13:53:07 ... In the morning after an intro section, community makes the agenda 13:53:11 I think I went there a year ago 13:53:30 ... Different technical activities are happening and they want to cover it F2F during the meeting 13:53:41 ... So unlike conferences where real work happens in the hallways 13:53:46 ... Super productive! 13:53:56 ... Also reduces a lot of the politics, no committee deciding who gets to speak 13:54:11 ... November 3-5 http://www.internetidentityworkshop.com/ 13:54:12 Nov 3-5th. 13:54:36 ... have discussed having it all week with different industry areas - not fully decided 13:54:55 Oh yes, I did go there last year http://blogs.sun.com/bblfish/entry/3_weeks_of_conferences_and 13:54:55 TPAC = http://www.w3.org/2009/11/TPAC/Overview.html 13:55:13 hhalpin: Asks it it's okay to come for 1-2 days 13:55:15 kaliya: Yes 13:55:43 hhalpin: Will have a few people there financial cuts permitting 13:55:58 hhalpin: What would you see is the best way for us to continue future interactions apart from joining mailing list 13:56:12 ... Who would Kaliya suggest we talk to next - e.g. Higgins project 13:56:57 ... What could W3C do? Report about Social Web in general, but a lot of work is happening not with W3C partially because of structural issues with W3C - IRC is viewed as a pain, membership fees are really high 13:57:07 -mattroweshow 13:58:09 kaliya: Sense in Silicon valley that market adoption is what a standard is, so don't care as much about standards organisations 13:58:40 kaliya: Community around Open Web Foundation interesting (Messina, Smarr); community around OpenSocial is interesting (KevinMarks et al.) 13:58:55 ... Chris Messina is working on distributed social networking (DiSo) 13:59:13 ... Mentions some names from Higgins Project, missed who as audio not great 14:00:04 hhalpin: As an XG, main task is to write a report. One year to do so (or 3/4 at this point). To bootstrap, when we have invited speakers, someone will clean up the minutes to summarise it for the report 14:00:18 ... Just so we don't lose track of everything that's happened 14:00:51 hhalpin: Throw minutes by kaliya for review 14:01:06 kaliya: Is on list 14:01:30 hhalpin: Asks for volunteers to edit minutes 14:01:41 mhh 14:01:50 we could do it 14:02:12 one definition of identity was mentioned as being particularly good, but I couldn't quite hear what it was called (venner??), and didn't see it in the script either. What was it? 14:02:16 kaliya: one of the challenges is that there is so much stuff happening in community and quite broad so hard to summarise it 14:02:35 ok 14:02:44 mhh 14:02:45 ok 14:02:47 yes. 14:02:50 hhalpin: Henry to do first draft, Harry to go over it, and then send to Kaliya 14:02:50 have to go sorry, a lot of information to digest :) thanks. 14:02:52 Good reading 14:03:02 -jsalvachua 14:03:20 bblfish: Was at IIW a year ago, gave a talk about FOAF+SSL at Mountain View 14:03:32 ACTION: bblfish and hhalpin to write up kaliya's talk for future report 14:03:32 Created ACTION-46 - And hhalpin to write up kaliya's talk for future report [on Henry Story - due 2009-07-01]. 14:04:19 community@lists.idcommons.net 14:04:22 community@list.idcommons.net 14:04:24 kaliya: community@lists.idcommons.net 14:04:30 lots of activity on OASIS and concordia lists 14:04:32 + +04610801aaff 14:04:34 ... there is also an interop list 14:05:11 hhalpin: Kaliya to send links to listserv, at next meeting can go over the principles 14:05:26 I must leave the call -- thanks very much to our guest speaker for great info though! (And thanks for waking up so early!) 14:05:32 ack me 14:05:34 ... any final questions, now over 1 hour 14:05:46 hhalpin: Thanks the invited speaker 14:05:54 thanks 14:05:59 thanks! 14:06:01 thanks 14:06:06 thanks 14:06:13 thanks :-) 14:06:37 Meeting Adjourned 14:06:44 -DKA 14:06:45 -kaliya 14:07:01 very informative kaliya 14:07:26 - +1.510.931.aabb 14:07:27 - +1.203.858.aaaa 14:07:28 -FabGandon 14:07:29 -??P28 14:07:29 -HarryH 14:07:31 -rreck 14:07:32 -oshani 14:07:36 -MacTed 14:07:38 - +46.1.08.01.aadd 14:07:39 -??P36 14:08:13 -AndreaP 14:08:23 - +04610801aaff 14:08:31 RSSAgent, generate minutes 14:08:36 RRSAgent, generate minutes 14:08:36 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2009/06/24-swxg-minutes.html hhalpin 14:08:52 Cloud - are you OK cleaning those up and mailing them to the list-serv? 14:10:23 hhalpin: Do I just edit the text and send it in the message body? 14:11:54 caribou has left #swxg 14:12:08 Cloud: ah, do you not have CVS access 14:12:23 Cloud: If you don't, then I can clean them up probably quicker in CVS. 14:12:35 Okay thanks 14:13:19 Cloud: So don't worry about it. 14:33:08 oshani has joined #swxg 14:47:59 pchampin has left #swxg 14:48:27 AndreaP has joined #swxg 14:51:24 RRSAgent, make logs public 14:52:02 jsalvachua has joined #swxg 14:52:35 jsalvachua_ has joined #swxg 14:52:41 -pchampin 14:54:41 jsalvachua has joined #swxg 14:57:30 jsalvachua_ has joined #swxg 14:59:21 jsalvachua has joined #swxg 15:02:53 jsalvachua has joined #swxg 15:04:49 jsalvachua_ has joined #swxg 15:05:01 disconnecting the lone participant, Carine, in INC_SWXG()9:00AM 15:05:03 INC_SWXG()9:00AM has ended 15:05:06 Attendees were pchampin, +1.203.858.aaaa, AndreaP, DKA, +1.510.931.aabb, HarryH, Phil_Archer, jsalvachua, rreck, mattroweshow, +46.1.08.01.aadd, Carine, oshani, +1.510.472.aaee, 15:05:08 ... kaliya, FabGandon, MacTed, +04610801aaff 16:13:42 jsalvachua has joined #swxg