Input for Agenda Planning for the XML Security Working Group

Open issues with open and pending review action items

Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements)
Unbound actions:
 (edit)ACTION-128 on Konrad Lanz: document e-gov use cases - due 2009-01-06 - open
Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
Unbound actions:
 (edit)ACTION-345 on Ed Simon: Review 2.0 sig docs - due 2009-08-10 - open
 (edit)ACTION-347 on Scott Cantor: Review 2.0 sig docs - due 2009-08-10 - open
 (edit)ACTION-348 on Brian LaMacchia: Review 2.0 sig docs - due 2009-08-10 - open
 (edit)ACTION-351 on Pratik Datta: Summarize design rationale for xsd:any in note in spec - due 2009-08-18 - open
 (edit)ACTION-371 on Pratik Datta: Add id and position handling in step in draft - due 2009-09-29 - open
 (edit)ACTION-382 on Pratik Datta: Add guidance on semantic equivalence to Signature 2.0 related to ISSUE-131, which defaults, how equivalent does it get - due 2009-10-06 - open
 (edit)ACTION-409 on Pratik Datta: Revisit text() with regards to XPath profile - due 2009-10-27 - open
 (edit)ACTION-434 on Scott Cantor: Propose "final" disposition of Referencing syntax - due 2009-11-13 - open
 (edit)ACTION-456 on Scott Cantor: Review workshop papers regarding strengthening id based references with respect to wrapping attacks - due 2009-11-24 - open
Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1)
Unbound actions:
 (edit)ACTION-452 on Scott Cantor: Review the XML ENC v1.1 document - due 2009-11-24 - open

Open actions not associated to any issue/product

Action Items Pending Review

There are 0 pending review actions.

Overdue action items

There are 33 overdue actions.

ID State Title Person Due Date Associated with
ACTION-13 (edit) open Review streaming using 2nd edition Signature Konrad Lanz 2008-11-10 streaming reqmts
ACTION-128 (edit) open document e-gov use cases Konrad Lanz 2009-01-06 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements)
ACTION-171 (edit) open Draft a proposal for canonicalization improvements Konrad Lanz 2009-01-21
ACTION-238 (edit) open Update the proposal associated with ACTION-222 and send to list. Konrad Lanz 2009-03-24
ACTION-257 (edit) open Randomized Hashing (RMX) and Signing (RSA-PSS) provide a Proposal Konrad Lanz 2009-04-14
ACTION-267 (edit) open Simplify canonicalization note Konrad Lanz 2009-05-05
ACTION-280 (edit) open Produce test cases for derived keys Magnus Nyström 2009-05-19
ACTION-297 (edit) open Propose change to 1.1 to address issue-105 Konrad Lanz 2009-05-20 ISSUE-105
ACTION-332 (edit) open Review wording http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Jun/0075.html Konrad Lanz 2009-07-14
ACTION-345 (edit) open Review 2.0 sig docs Ed Simon 2009-08-10 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-347 (edit) open Review 2.0 sig docs Scott Cantor 2009-08-10 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-348 (edit) open Review 2.0 sig docs Brian LaMacchia 2009-08-10 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-350 (edit) open Propose text to align node set result treatment for XSLT and XPath in 1.1 spec Ed Simon 2009-08-04
ACTION-351 (edit) open Summarize design rationale for xsd:any in note in spec Pratik Datta 2009-08-18 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-352 (edit) open Propose concrete examples for multiple nodeset cases Ed Simon 2009-08-18
ACTION-355 (edit) open Send list of detailed comments to mail list on signature 2.0 and c14n2.0 Ed Simon 2009-08-18
ACTION-371 (edit) open Add id and position handling in step in draft Pratik Datta 2009-09-29 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-382 (edit) open Add guidance on semantic equivalence to Signature 2.0 related to ISSUE-131, which defaults, how equivalent does it get Pratik Datta 2009-10-06 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-383 (edit) open Provide reference to performance paper Sean Mullan 2009-10-06
ACTION-386 (edit) open Look at WS-I BSP constraints on DSig Hal Lockhart 2009-10-13
ACTION-391 (edit) open See if issue-131 is covered in requirements doc Gerald Edgar 2009-10-13
ACTION-400 (edit) open propose concrete next steps to address ISSUE-63 in 2.0 Hal Lockhart 2009-11-03
ACTION-404 (edit) open Draft language that codifies history why DERKeyValue is not child of KeyValue (for section 4.4 of xmldsig-core1) Brian LaMacchia 2009-10-20
ACTION-409 (edit) open Revisit text() with regards to XPath profile Pratik Datta 2009-10-27 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-411 (edit) open Perform measurement related to transform octet conversion Pratik Datta 2009-10-27
ACTION-412 (edit) open Review ISSUE-115 Ed Simon 2009-10-27
ACTION-421 (edit) open Look at the 1.1 schema Ed Simon 2009-11-12
ACTION-426 (edit) open Run performance tests on non-optimized Signature implementation Pratik Datta 2009-11-12
ACTION-434 (edit) open Propose "final" disposition of Referencing syntax Scott Cantor 2009-11-13 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)
ACTION-438 (edit) open check 1.1 requirements against enc, sig EDs Shivaram Mysore 2009-11-16
ACTION-441 (edit) open Review BSP 1.1 (http://www.ws-i.org/Profiles/BasicSecurityProfile-1.1.html) with respect to Signature 1.1 and Encryption 1.1 Cynthia Martin 2009-11-13
ACTION-442 (edit) open Propose text for RSA for Issue-82 (DSA already done) Brian LaMacchia 2009-11-14
ACTION-447 (edit) open Review wrapping attack article, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Nov/0019.html Cynthia Martin 2009-11-17

Action items due next week

There are 14 upcoming actions.

ID State Title Person Due Date Associated with
ACTION-431 (edit) open Fix "they" in RFC2119 section throughout all documents Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-432 (edit) open Talk to sean about possible resources Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-433 (edit) open Propose C14N erratum to address http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Sep/0009.html issue Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-436 (edit) open Review requirements for issue-63 text Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-439 (edit) open Draft text for xml encryption 1.1 for handing EXI Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-440 (edit) open Proposed a resolution to issue-141 Thomas Roessler 2009-11-24
ACTION-448 (edit) open Hand 1.1 bibliography to Cynthia when converted to respec Frederick Hirsch 2009-11-24
ACTION-449 (edit) open Review 1.1 bibliographies (depends on ACTION-448) Cynthia Martin 2009-11-24
ACTION-450 (edit) open Check on Suite B AES-GCM Brian LaMacchia 2009-11-24
ACTION-451 (edit) open Review the Pratik AES-GCM proposal with Magnus Brian LaMacchia 2009-11-24
ACTION-452 (edit) open Review the XML ENC v1.1 document Scott Cantor 2009-11-24 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1)
ACTION-453 (edit) open Review XML ENC v1.1 Ed Simon 2009-11-24
ACTION-455 (edit) open Review plans for RNG schema Frederick Hirsch 2009-11-24
ACTION-456 (edit) open Review workshop papers regarding strengthening id based references with respect to wrapping attacks Scott Cantor 2009-11-24 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0)

Issues discussed over the last week

There are 33 recently discussed issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-9 (edit) OPEN Review WS-I BSP constraints on DSig 2008-07-17 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-43 (edit) OPEN Improvements to XML Signature schema 2008-07-29 v.next (Design for XML Signature V Next) 0
ISSUE-47 (edit)
XAdES Signature Reference
CLOSED XAdES references latest XML Signature, depends on ds:Object and ds:KeyInfo 2008-08-13 v.next (Design for XML Signature V Next) 0
ISSUE-63 (edit)
namespace rqmts
OPEN Namespace requirements: undeclarations, QNames, use of partial content in new contexts 2008-10-08 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-68 (edit)
algorithms
CLOSED Enable generic use of randomized hashing 2008-11-03 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-69 (edit) CLOSED Update example file to avoid empty XPath result 2008-11-03 Best Practices for XML Signature 0
ISSUE-82 (edit) OPEN Should 1.1 spec mandate support for range of RSA key sizes (and DSA)? 2009-01-13 Sig11 (XML Signature 1.1) 0
ISSUE-87 (edit) CLOSED Determine approach to RetrievalMethod in 2.0 with regard to transforms, if any, or if revised transform approach 2009-01-14 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-91 (edit) OPEN ECC can't be REQUIRED 2009-01-26 Enc11 and Sig11 and Security Algorithms Summary 0
ISSUE-104 (edit) CLOSED Carry existing ds:References into new XMLDSIG 2.0 2009-02-24 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-106 (edit) CLOSED see what you sign requirement in transform simplification vs external workflow 2009-02-24 v.next (Design for XML Signature V Next) 0
ISSUE-115 (edit) CLOSED XPath Filter Transform and Namespace Declarations for Qualified Nodes, see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xmlsec/2009Apr/0025.html 2009-04-21 Sig11 (XML Signature 1.1) 0
ISSUE-119 (edit) CLOSED Erratum for Signature 1.0 and use of SHA256 in favor of SHA1 2009-05-05 Errata-XML Signature 0
ISSUE-122 (edit) OPEN Explain why peformance improvements and rationale, relationship to earlier work 2009-05-12 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-123 (edit) OPEN How in 2.0 to disallow SHA-1 when algorithm URI currently defined 2009-05-12 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-131 (edit) CLOSED Is semantic equivalence robustness in requirements document 2009-05-13 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-132 (edit) OPEN Keep 2.0 xenc transform feature in sync with signature 2.0 2009-06-02 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-136 (edit) CLOSED Is normalization of prefixes a goal for 2.0 c14n 2009-07-07 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-139 (edit) CLOSED Need to collect streaming XPath requirements 2009-09-08 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-140 (edit) OPEN Clarify how XPath is interpreted relative to entire document and ds:Reference 2009-09-08 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-141 (edit)
c14n11nodeprocessing
OPEN C14N 1.1 processing of non-element, non-PI nodes in a node set 2009-09-28 Maint-C14N11 0
ISSUE-144 (edit) OPEN XML Schema and DTD inconsistency for SPKISexp element 2009-10-01 Errata-XML Signature 0
ISSUE-146 (edit) CLOSED Determine impact of 2.0 transform model on XML Encryption, and any needed changes to XML Encryption 2009-10-01 Sig20 (XML Signature 2.0) 0
ISSUE-147 (edit) OPEN XML Encryption 1.1 table of contents incomplete, some headings not numbered correctly in document 2009-10-06 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1) 0
ISSUE-148 (edit) CLOSED Define PartyUInfo with XML structure, SP80056AConcatKDF in XML Encryption 1.1 2009-10-19 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1) 0
ISSUE-149 (edit) OPEN Link requirements to features 2009-10-20 Rqmts (XML Security Use Cases and Requirements) 0
ISSUE-150 (edit) OPEN Use of XML encryption type encoding in EXI 2009-11-05 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1) 0
ISSUE-151 (edit) OPEN Review XML SIgnature 2.0 and Canonical XML 2.0 for testable assertions 2009-11-05 0
ISSUE-152 (edit) OPEN Add pratik as author to xpath subset document if produced by ws-ra 2009-11-06 0
ISSUE-153 (edit) OPEN Change Canonicalization 2.0 to replace the pseudo code snippets with descriptive text, and move all the pseudo code to another non normative section 2009-11-07 0
ISSUE-154 (edit) OPEN Links to references need to be updated 2009-11-15 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1) 0
ISSUE-155 (edit) OPEN Add AES-GCM to XML Encryption 1.1 2009-11-16 Enc11 (XML Encryption 1.1) 0
ISSUE-156 (edit) OPEN Threat for signature from use of namespace prefixes with corresponding unsigned namespace declarations leading to wrapping like attacks 2009-11-17 0

Frederick Hirsch <frederick.hirsch@nokia.com>, Chair, Thomas Roessler <tlr@w3.org>, Staff Contact
Tracker, originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: agenda.php,v 1.36 2009/09/25 07:32:25 dom Exp $