Top Supported Tags

From Media Annotations Working Group Wiki
Revision as of 13:59, 17 April 2009 by Dsinger2 (Talk | contribs)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Initial Identification

The following table shows the tags that had the broadest level of support in the group, based on a fast 'straw poll', and also the number of formats for which there is a mapping of that tag. In the following table, "Entity" is either a "Resource" (abstract concept) or a "Representation" (instance/file); It can be a single object or composed of fragments.

MAWG Attributes Description XMP Attributes Description Formats supporting Cumulative Votes
ma:title The title of the document, or the name given to the entity. dc:title The title of the document, or the name given to the resource. 19 9
ma:creator The authors of the entity (listed in order of precedence, if significant). dc:creator The authors of the resource (listed in order of precedence, if significant). 17 9
REMOVED REMOVED dc:rights Informal rights statement, selected by language 15 9
ma:contributor A pair identifying the contributor and the nature of the contribution. E.g. actor, cameraman, director, singer, author, artist (Note: subject to addition of contributor type). dc:contributor Contributors to the resource (other than the authors). 16 8
ma:description A textual description of the content of the entity. dc:description A textual description of the content of the resource. 16 8
ma:keyword A descriptive phrase or keyword that specify the topic of the content of the entity. dc:subject An unordered array of descriptive phrases or keywords that specify the topic of the content of the resource. 16 8
ma:identifier A URI identifies an entity; which can be either a "Resource" (abstract concept) or a "Representation" (instance/file). See 4.4 Annotating Media Fragments. Note: recommended practice is to use a URN as a value for this property. dc:identifier An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context. 15 8
ma:duration The actual duration of the entity. xmpDM:duration The duration of the media file. Related to dc extend (not part of basic dc set). 14 8
ma:format (Possibly extended) MIME type of the entity (wrapper, bucket media types). dc:format The file format used when saving the resource 16 7
ma:spatialDimension The spatial size of the entity. xmpDM:videoFrameSize The frame size. For example: w:720, h: 480, 10 7
ma:genre A genre of the entity. dc:type The nature of the resrouce: still image, video and sound. Or document type; novel, poem, or working paper. 17 6
REMOVED REMOVED xmpDM:genre The name of the genre. 13 6
REMOVED REMOVED dc:date External Date(s) that something interesting happened to the resource. 18 5
ma:createDate The date and time the entity was originally created. (For commercial purpose there might be an annotation of publication date). xmp:CreateDate The date and time the resource was originally created 14 5
ma:publisher Examples of a Publisher include a person, an organization, or a service; the name of a Publisher should be used. dc:publisher External Publishers. 12 5
ma:copyright The copyright statement. xmpDM:copyright The copyright information. 12 5
ma:language Specify a language used in the entity, recommended best practice is to use a controlled vocabulary such as RFC 4646. dc:language An unordered array specifying the languages used in the resource. 11 5
ma:relation A pair identifying the entity and the nature of the relationship. E.g. transcript, original_work. dc:relation Relationships to other documents. 10 5
REMOVED REMOVED xmpDM:artist 13 4
REMOVED REMOVED xmp:Identifier An unordered array of text strings that unambiguously identify the resource within a given context. 9 4
ma:compression Compression type used, e.g. H264. Note: possible instead to use extended mime type (see RFC 4281) in ma:format. xmpDM:videoCompressor Video compression used. For example, jpeg. 9 4
ma:location A geographic location associated with the entity. Can be the depicted, mentioned location or shot location. xmpDM:shotLocation 8 4
REMOVED REMOVED xmpDM:videoFrameRate 8 4
REMOVED REMOVED xmpDM:releaseDate 9 3
ma:collection A name of the collection from which the entity originates. xmpDM:album The name of the album. In dc: title 7 3
ma:rating A pair identifying the rating issuer (a person or an organization) and the rating value (normalized value between 0 and 1). xmp:Rating 7 3
ma:targetAudience A pair identifying the issuer of the classification (agency) and the classification. E.g. parental guide, targeted geographical region
ma:locator A URL from where the entity can be accessed.

Next Steps

Review the selected attributes, see

  • whether there are missing attributes that we should add to the table
  • whether there are attributes that should be combined or split
  • how the selected attributes map from all the given input formats; whether data conversion is needed etc.
  (if the call is to retrieve X and your input format is Y, then do Z)
  • is the attribute expected to have a unique value (only 0 or 1 returned result), or a plurality?
  • there are attributes (contributor, relation) where the 'nature' terms need a set definition
  • each attribute needs a bit more text on the value, explaining what it should be, to guide those doing mapping

See how the selected set helps solve the use cases

Write a document that recommends that content creators put the suitable support for these attributes in media resources