FeaturesTable

From Media Annotations Working Group Wiki
Revision as of 15:34, 10 December 2008 by Vrodrgue (Talk | contribs)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Ontology Features Discussion Table








FEATURE DESCRIPTION FORMATS DISCUSSION (DatatypeProperty/ObjectProperty ,suggested name, ...) INCLUSION (Y/N) F2F DISCUSSION
NEW REFERENCE METADATA FORMAT ?
YES

(Requirement "Allowing for a simple API, ..."

  • clarification: (currently) the ontology does not describe a new metadata format, just defines the API terms and provides facilities to implement the API over the different formats (mapping to API fields, etc.)

  • Ruben: I would suggest to separate this discussion in two different topics:
  • Ruben: Typical APIs for accessing data use to be related to a data model (a data schema to be stricter), in fact the API and the data schema use to be someway isomorphic. In our case, as I understand now, we do not plan to declare an explicit data schema (e.g. with XML, RDFS or OWL) to which the MAWG API refers. However, IMO, the data schema will be implicit anyway.
  • Felix: Note also another option which we have not discussed yet: using an existing format like the XMP RDF format as the basis. I know it's not real RDF, but it is already being deployed in many areas, and we said at the F2F we put XMP in the center anyway. What do you or others think about that?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

NO
  • Only a common API as the cornerstone of our interoperability strategy.
  • A base metadata format will be implicit in the API, but not formalised.
  • The ontology will clarify the meaning of API terms (e.g. with definitions), and will provide facilities to implement the API over the different metadata format.

  • Felix Sasaki: We have not yet decided whether we need to develop our own format, no matter if structured or flat. IMO our main focus should be on interoperability between existing formats, without defining a simple or complex new one. http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-media-annotation/2008Nov/0122.html
  • Felix Sasaki: I think we can design an ontology without a practical data structure. The current API / ontology proposal does just that: defining a list of terms *as prose*. The data structure related parts are only in the API, and in the prose mapping descriptions.
  • Werner Bailer: I agree that we should design an ontology and an API without specifying a metadata format. However, this does not mean that the onotlogy definition needs to be as prose. We can define a conceptual model (e.g. using OWL) which has a kind of native representation using RDF but can be represented in a number of formats using the mapping defined in the specification.
  • Felix Sasaki: From our charter: http://www.w3.org/2008/01/media-annotations-wg.html Success criteria: "Abilitity to convert core metadata information from one metadata standard to an other". This does not talk about roundtripping, so information loss is OK. Out of scope: "Full coverage of all metadata elements in EXIF, IPTC, XMP, MPEG-7, and similar broad vocabularies, is out of scope". I interpret this as "it's OK to loose the structure of ID3 tags is lost in the mapping to ID3.".


Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

MAWG does not aim at describing new formats.

Preeminence of XMP is acknowledge, taking it as the main reference.

STRUCTURED (THE API)? (e.g. name=surname+familyname, address=street+ZIP...)
NOT STRUCTURED
  • 1 annotation : 1 flat metadata record (no hierarchy, no other linked objects within the annotation)
  • Properties are literals
  • Properties can point to IDs or URIs of other resources which are somewhere else
  • Properties can point to IDs or URIs of other type of objects which are somewhere else and externally specified
  • Properties can be repeated to allow multivalued fields

(requirements on the annotation)

Dublin Core 1.1
EXIF
ID3

  • Ruben Tous: One-step metadata paths to literal values (PRO)
  • Ruben Tous: Sometimes structured data are embedded within a literal (e.g. names, addresses, arrays). Special text grammars need to be defined. Need for special software for checking validity. (CON)
  • Ruben Tous: Collections and whole/part (e.g. tagging a video region) are difficult to model this way. (CON)

Werner Bailer:NO
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:NO
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:NO
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:NO
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:NO
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

STRUCTURED
  • 1 annotation = 1:N metadata records and/or other data structures (e.g. PersonType)
  • Properties can be hyerarchically structured (XML) or can point to other data structures (e.g. another resource in RDF) within or outside the annotation.

XMP
DCMI-Terms
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
VRA
CableLabsVOD2.0
EBU P_Meta

  • Ruben Tous: No need for special software for checking validity (e.g. XML). (PRO)
  • Ruben Tous: Collections and whole/part (e.g. tagging a video region) are easy to model this way. (PRO)
  • Ruben Tous: Long metadata paths to literal values (e.g. Mpeg7/.../CreationInformation/Creation/Title) (CON)
  • Ruben Tous: Can be embedded within resources.
  • Pierre-A. Champin: So, wouldn't it keep the best of both worlds to provide:
    • a structured conceptual model (e.g. an RDFS or OWL ontology)
    • a simple (ideally flat) syntax that would allow to represent the most common patterns of that conceptual model.

http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-media-annotation/2008Nov/0112.html

Werner Bailer:YES
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:YES
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:YES
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

FORMALISM FOR THE ONTOLOGY (Relational Model, XML Infoset, RDF graph model, independent)
independent
  • clarification: In principle the ontology does not describe a new metadata format, just defines the API terms and provides facilities to implement the API over the different formats (mapping to API fields, etc.). This section seems to be related to the possibility to extend the ontology scope to the definition of our own metadata format.
  • we use our high-level textual formalisation, not couples with XML, RDF, Relational Model, etc.

DCMI-Terms

  • Felix Sasaki: Nevertheless, it lets me more and more think that we should not be format specific in our ontology, but use just a prose description as the normative outcome, that is in the "Ontology 1.0" Recommendation. If people want to write non-normative RDF- and XML-formats, they are free to do so.
  • Ruben Tous: It seems a good idea. However, even in this case we need to decide about structured/not.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:YES
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:YES
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

After long discussing, the following image gathers some consensus. Specification.png Generally, the version of the specification can be enough, while further XML or RDF representationscan be present or not.

XML
  • Structured metadata is expressed as an XML tree.
  • The WG could (is that in scope) provide a basic schema (Q: in what syntax? DTD? XML-schema?) for some structured type (e.g. Person), but should probably allow other schemas to be used (for scalability and evolution).
  • PRO: parsers included in all major browsers. (Q: are they always able to validate? on DTDs? XML-schemas? Relax-NG?)
  • CON: the interoperability problem is pushed a step further, but is still there: if two application do not use the same schema for describing, e.g., persons, they will not interoperate well. .

MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:NO
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:NO
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

RDF
  • Structured metadata is named with a URI, which can then be described in an external (or integrated, if possible?) RDF graph.
  • PRO: In order to be interoperable with Semantic Web technologies, we should in all cases provide an RDF "reading" of our metadata (e.g. using http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/). Using RDF in the first place makes this straightforward.
  • CON: RDF parsing is less deployed than XML parsing.

DCMI-Terms
PhotoRDF

  • Pierre-A. Champin: Integrates well with "not structured" legacy schemas: all one has to do is to use a URI in a textual value. (PRO)
  • Pierre-A. Champin: Although the interoperability problem is still there for the structured data (i.e. applications using different vocabularies for describing persons), I (Pierre-Antoine) think it is easier to cope with RDF heterogeneity than XML heterogeneity: (PRO)
    • The same URI can be described (either in the same graph or in different graphs) with several vocabularies (while there is no standard way to mix XML trees from arbitrary schemas)
    • We could make mandatory some very basic properties (e.g. rdfs:label) to provide a minimal common basis (textual in this case)
  • Werner Bailer: If we decide for RDF we should specify the vocabularies to be used at least for a basic set of properties. Resolving URIs to actual values could then built into the API and user could use getters/setter with values and do not need to care about URIs.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:YES
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

ABSTRACTION LEVELS (different classes for WORK, INSTANCE, COPY...)
1-LEVEL DESCRIPTION
  • Only one type of data structure for representing a media object (independently if it is structured or not)
  • Normally referring to the most specific thing : The physical media file, a book exemplar, etc.
  • Similar resources (e.g. different versions of the file) repeat some data (e.g. the author name)
  • Some properties can be used to keep the conceptual linking between resources (e.g. versionOf, etc.)
  • Makes sense when having embedded annotations of isolated media objects
  • PRO: Simplicity
  • CON: Consistency among the common data need to be enforced

Dublin Core 1.1
MPEG-7
EXIF
CableLabsVOD2.0

  • Silvia Pfeiffer: Do we want to create an ontology that can be multiplexed into a video stream (e.g. as a header file in ID3 and vorbiscomment fashion, or as time-aligned text in the data section like TimedText or subtitles)? or do we want to create an ontology that can describe video stream collections? I am mostly interested in the earlier one.
  • Véronique Malaisé: So we would need a property like "has_type" to link a single description's identifier to the correct level of multilevel description schemes.
  • Véronique Malaisé: Anyway, we would need to map informally the way these levels are expressed, in order to provide possible relevant "types" for the description of each single element.
  • Silvia Pfeiffer: [...]I don't think we need to overly concern ourselves with whether we normalise our data structure. This is an "implementation" issue. [...] we should focus on identifying which information is important to keep about a video or audio file.
  • Véronique Malaisé:

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

N-LEVELS DESCRIPTION
  • More than one type of data structure for representing a multimedia content (independently if it is structured or not)
  • Different levels of specificity (e.g. "Blade Runner, the movie" vs. "the DVD special edition of Blade Runner".
  • Common data related to a set of related resources is placed within a single annotation
  • Where to place this high-level annotations? Makes sense when dealing with media collections or annotations not embedded within media objects
  • PRO: Helps ensuring consistency among the common data.
  • CON: Complexity


FRBR
DMP
MPEG-21 MVCO
VRA (work-image)
XMP (document-instance)

  • Tobias Bürger: The FRBR schema has a bibliographic background and its intention was to document more classical forms of artistic works which might often be available in different representations and instantions. For me this model is fairly complex and from my personal point of few at least the item level is not very relevant for the digital world. (CON)
  • Joakim Söderberg: I believe that it would be nice if we could help application developers to find out what type of metadata they could obtain; if it is an image, video clip or "simple" text. Dublin Core has a classification scheme for that - DCMIType (http://dublincore.org/documents/dcmi-type-vocabulary/), e.g. Collection, Image, InteractiveResource, MovingImage, Software, Sound, Text etc. Or we could use MIME types...
  • Víctor Rodríguez: I think the "multilevel descprition" may be relevant to other Use Cases. For example in the Multimedia Adaptation or the Media Analysis. (PRO)
  • Werner Bailer: Support for multiple levels would enable the use of the model in more use cases, however it should be possible to create a flat description for simple scenarios.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

Multilevel description is needed (and also acknowleged by XMP). Bindings to other standards in needed i.e. FRBR model etc. Victor is going to review it again
RESOURCE CLASS SPECIALISATION (different classes for Video, Audio, etc.)
RESOURCE CLASS SPECIALISATION (NO)
  • One generic class for representing a media object (or more than one if differnt abstraction levels are defined). E.g. resource.
  • simplicity
  • class of media object could also be expressed as property of generic object

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

RESOURCE CLASS SPECIALISATION (YES)
  • Several different classes for representing a media object (Video, Audio, etc.)
  • Each class defines a different set of properties

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Joakim Söderberg: I believe that it would be nice if we could help application developers to find out what type of metadata they could obtain; if it is an image, video clip or "simple" text. Dublin Core has a classification scheme for that - DCMIType (http://dublincore.org/documents/dcmi-type-vocabulary/), e.g. Collection, Image, InteractiveResource, MovingImage, Software, Sound, Text etc. Or we could use MIME types...

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

Metadata can be more than text and this has to be here reflected.

FRAGMENTS DESCRIPTION
RESOURCE CLASS SPECIALISATION (NO)
  • Properties of specific fragments (e.g. tags about regions of interest in Facebook).

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Pierre-A. Champin: One line might be missing: the issue of annotating fragments http://www.w3.org/2008/11/25-mediaann-minutes.html

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:YES
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

A declaration has been made, by which fragment metadata -spatial or temporal- as annotated by the Media Fragments Working Group can be inserted here.

PROPERTIES
15 Dublin Core 1.1 Metadata Elements (and XMP-DC) in alphabetical order
(resource) contributor An entity responsible for making contributions to the (resource)

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Pierre-A. Champin: more general than creator, hence useful as a common ancestor to specialized roles defined in other schemas.

Werner Bailer:YES
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:YES
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) coverage The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Werner Bailer: this definition seems quite fuzzy

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) creator An entity primarily responsible for making the (resource)

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Ruben Tous: ObjectProperty (AgentType: givenname, familyname, ...)
  • Werner Bailer: could be a specialisation of contributor with a specific role assigned?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) date Point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Ruben Tous: In MPEG-7 appears the more specific element CreationDate
  • Werner Bailer: we could add the option to quality the data (e.g. creation, digitisation, etc)

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) description A textual description of the content of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:YES
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) format The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the (resource)

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • overlaps with the many of the xmpDM properties (same information, but structured)

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) identifier Unique identifier of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) language A language of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Ruben Tous: In XMP is an array of languages (I don't understand why not allowing more than one occurrence as with the other fields...)

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) publisher An entity responsible for making the resource available.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) relation A related resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) rights Information about rights held in and over the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Victor Rodriguez: I would advice either link to CreativeCommons license, or to a ODRL license (see the corresponding W3C Technical Report etc.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) source A related resource from which the described resource is derived.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) subject The topic of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) title A name given to the (resource)

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

  • Ruben Tous: DatatypeProperty, xsd:string

Werner Bailer:YES
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

(resource) type The nature or genre of the resource.

Dublin Core 1.1
XMP
MPEG-7
PhotoRDF
EXIF

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Basic schema
xmp:baseURL

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:CreateDate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:CreatorTool

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:Label

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:MetadataDate xmp:ModifyDate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:Rating

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:NO
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:Thumbnails

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:YES
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Rights Management schema
XMP Rights Management schema

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:NO
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Media Management schema
xmpMM:DerivedFrom

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: This property is related to a 3 level description model, do we go for it or not?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:YES
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:DocumentID

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Ruben Tous: It is not overlapped with dc:identifier?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:YES
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:NO
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:History

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:NO
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:NO
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:Ingredients

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: yes, but maybe keep a more generic name (partOf? it is a composition-type of part-of)
  • I agree. Besides, when dealing with whole/part issues, we should differentiate between compositions/collections (groups of independent elements) and segmentations (logical partition of the resource).

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:YES
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:InstanceID

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: this property is related to a 3 level description model, do we go for it or not?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:MM:ManageUI

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: yes, if we go for metadata in a different file than the document itself

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:DEPENDS
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:OriginalDocumentID

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: this way of naming the unique URI can be misleading: how about a simpler name? We still have to decide on the levels that such a URI will adress (different versions? Instances?)
  • Véronique Malaisé: yes, but what about naming it hasURI?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:YES
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:DEPENDS
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:MMPantry

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: this seems to be the way to refer to different (descriptions of) instances related to the same document.
  • Véronique Malaisé: yes, if we go for a description model that takes into account different levels

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:DEPENDS
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:DEPENDS
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmp:MMRenditionClass

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: yes if we represent the rendition as a property

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:DEPENDS
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpMM:VersionID

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Véronique Malaisé: yes if we go for a 3 level description scheme

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:DEPENDS
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Basic Job Ticket schema
xmpBJ:JobRef This property references an external job management file for a job process in which the document is being used. Typical use would be to identify all documents that are part of a particular job or contract.

XMP
MPEG-7

  • WonSuk Lee: We don't need this. This is out of scope. Because this is related to describe a link among the document and job process in terms of workflow.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:NO
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Paged-text schema
XMP Paged-text schema This schema is used for text appearing on a page in a document.

XMP
MPEG-7

  • WonSuk Lee: we don't need below all properties. Because these are properties for showing the document.

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:NO
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:?
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

XMP Dynamic Media schema
xmpDM:album The name of the album

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Joakim Söderberg: Connection to DC?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:artist

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Ruben Tous: Connection to DC?

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:audioModDate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:audioSampleRate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:audioChannelType

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:engineer

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:audioCompressor

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:composer

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:duration

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:fileDataRate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:genre

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:instrument

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:key

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:loop

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:numberOfBeats

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:metadataModDate

XMP
MPEG-7

  • Overlapped with a similar property

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:NO
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:projectRef

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:scaleType

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:scene

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:shotLocation

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:shotName

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:contributedMedia An unordered list of all media used to create this media

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:YES
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:startTimecode The timecode of the first frame of video in the file, as obtained from the device control.

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:tapeName The name of the tape from which the clip was captured, as set during the capture process.

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:tempo

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:timeScaleParams

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:trackNumber

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:Tracks An unordered list of tracks. A track is a named set of markers, which can specify a frame rate for all markers in the set.

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:markers

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoAlphaMode straight / pre-multiplied

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM: videoAlphaPremultipleColor A color in CMYK or RGB to be used as the pre-multiple color when alpha mode is pre-multiplied.

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM: videoAlphaUnityIsTransparent When true, unity is clear, when false, it is opaque.

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoColorSpace

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoCompressor Video compression used. For example, jpeg

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoFieldOrder

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoFrameRate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoFrameSize

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoModDate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoModDate

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoPixelDepth

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?

xmpDM:videoPixelAspectRatio

XMP
MPEG-7

Werner Bailer:?
Tobias Bürger:?
Pierre-A. Champin:?
Jaime Delgado:?
Jean-Pierre Evain:?
Ralf Klamma:?
WonSuk Lee:?
Véronique Malaisé:?
Erik Mannens:?
Hui Miao:?
Thierry Michel:?
Frank Nack:?
Soohong Daniel Park:?
Silvia Pfeiffer:?
Víctor Rodríguez:?
Felix Sasaki:?
Joakim Söderberg:YES
Ruben Tous:?
Raphaël Troncy:?
Vassilis Tzouvaras:?
Davy Van Deursen:?