Responses to Comments
From OWL
(Difference between revisions)
IanHorrocks (Talk | contribs) (→Comments requiring responses) |
|||
| Line 238: | Line 238: | ||
|[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Jan/0031.html 24] | |[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Jan/0031.html 24] | ||
| 2009-Jan-23 | | 2009-Jan-23 | ||
| - | | Non disjoint XSD | + | | Non disjoint XSD datatypes |
| RIF WG | | RIF WG | ||
|[[LC_Responses/RIF1|RIF1]] | |[[LC_Responses/RIF1|RIF1]] | ||
|pfps | |pfps | ||
| - | | | + | |<span style="color: green;">ACK - OK</span> |
| - | |[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Mar/0040.html RtRIF1] | + | |[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Mar/0040.html RtRIF1], [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Mar/0065.html RtRIF1-ack] |
|[[Syntax]], [[Semantics]], maybe others, disjointness for primitive datatypes | |[[Syntax]], [[Semantics]], maybe others, disjointness for primitive datatypes | ||
|- | |- | ||
Revision as of 08:37, 20 March 2009
- Please see the response protocol and Ian's note about comments from WG members
- Email reply template
- Email chasing for Ack template
- Search for wg email with subject "draft response"
- Search the comments list for "LC Response"
- public-owl-comments archive
- How to edit the tables more easily (short version: Bookmark Wiki Table Editor from here. Select it when editing and cursor is somewhere in table. Click new button
that is added to editing controls.)
Comments requiring responses
- Key to columns
- Owner: WG member who is addressing issues and/or drafting response email
- Response: links to response email and to subsequent acknowledgment from commenter
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,2 | 16-Dec-08 | Anonymous classes as annotation values | Alan Rector | ALR1 | Bijan | ACK - OK | RtALR1, [http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-owl-comments/2009Mar/0064.html RtALR1-ack | None |
| 3 | 05-Jan-09 | Datatypes | Cecil O. Lynch | COL1 | N/A | Withdrawn | N/A | N/A |
| 4 | 06-Jan-09 | RDF Mapping bug | Mike Smith | MS1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtMS1,RtMS1-ack | Mapping-to-RDF, minor change to reverse mapping |
| 5 | 07-Jan-09 | Unicode | Martin Duerst | MD1 | Bijan | ACK - OK | RtMD1,RtMD1-ack | Several, references changed, editorial, probably still needs a check to see that all docs have been updated |
| 6 | 07-Jan-09 | Keys | Jim Hendler | JH1 | Bijan | Sent 25 Feb | RtJH1 | Syntax, editorial; NF&R, possible in future |
| 7 | 13-Jan-09 | Imports | Timothy Redmond | TR1 | Bijan | ACK - OK | RtTR1,RtTR1-ack | None |
| 8 | 13-Jan-09 | Facet Space | Michael Schneider | MS2 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtMS2,RtMS2-ack | Syntax, editorial |
| 9 | 09-Jan-09 | Examples for Global restrictions | Ivan Herman | IH1 | Boris | ACK - OK | RtIH1,RtIH1-ack | Syntax, editorial |
| 10 | 08-Jan-09 | Document introduction | Ivan Herman | IH2 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtIH2,RtIH2-ack | Abstract for all documents |
| 11 | 09-Jan-09 | RFC2119 | Michael Schneider | MS3 | N/A | No action required | N/A | None |
| 12 | 09-Jan-19 | RL Theorem PR1 | Boris Motik | BM1 | Boris | ACK - OK | RtBM1,RtBM1-ack | Profiles, editorial/bug fix |
| 13 | 09-Jan-15 | Font size | Zhe Wu | ZW1 | pfps | No action required | N/A | None |
| 14 | 09-Jan-15 | Entailment question | Mike Smith | MS4 | Mike Smith | ACK - OK | RtMS4,RtMS4-ack | None |
| 15 | 09-Jan-20 | RL Theorem PR1 | Michael Schneider | MS5 | Boris | ACK - OK | RtMS5,RtMS5-ack | Profiles, editorial / bug fix (see 2) |
| 16 | 2009-Jan-08 | 'lexical form' versus 'lexical value' | Michael Schneider | MS6 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtMS6,RtMs6-ack | Syntax, Direct_Semantics, RDF Semantics, Conformance, editorial |
| 17 | 2009-Jan-21 | Resolution of Issue 97 | Tom Morris | TM1 | Tri-partite GRDDL solution | |||
| 18 | 2009-Jan-21 | OWL-2 QL typos/extensions | Maurizio Lenzerini | ML1 | Uli? | Response Drafted | Profiles, add in missing property axioms | |
| 19 | 2009-Jan-21 | OWL-2 QL comments | Michael Zakharyaschev | MZ1 | Uli? | Response Drafted | Profiles, add in missing property axioms | |
| 20 | 2009-Jan-23 | OWL-2 RL datatypes (& other features) | Jos de Bruijn | JDB1 | pfps | Sent 18 Mar | RtJDB1 | Profiles, change to datatypes in OWL 2 RL (see 43b) |
| 21 | 2009-Jan-23 | Mostly editorial | Jos de Bruijn | JDB2 | pfps (Syntax, Profiles, Direct), Michael Schneider (RDF) | Sent 18 Mar | RtJDB2 | Syntax, Direct Semantics, Profiles, RDF-Based Semantics, editorial |
| 22 | 2009-Jan-23 | OWL/RIF datatypes | M. Scott Marshall | MSM1 | pfps | Sent 18 Mar | RtMSM1 | Syntax, Semantics, maybe others, disjointness for primitive datatypes |
| 23 | 2009-Jan-23 | Annotations questions | Jeremy Rogers | JR1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtJR1.RtJR1-ack | None |
| 24 | 2009-Jan-23 | Non disjoint XSD datatypes | RIF WG | RIF1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtRIF1, RtRIF1-ack | Syntax, Semantics, maybe others, disjointness for primitive datatypes |
| 25 | 2009-Jan-23 | Supported datatypes | RIF WG | RIF2 | pfps | Sent 4 March, Chased 18 Mar | RtRIF2 | None |
| 26a | 2009-Jan-23 | Hard to select/use profiles | Susie Stephens/Lilly | SS1a | pfps | ACK - OK | RtSS1,RtSS1-ack | None |
| 26b | 2009-Jan-23 | Various, mainly editorial | Susie Stephens/Lilly | SS1b | pfps | ACK - OK | RtSS1,RtSS1-ack | None non-trivial |
| 27 | 2009-Jan-23 | Design decisions + editorial | Frank van Harmelen/Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | FH1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtFH1,RtFH1-ack | None |
| 28 | 2009-Jan-23 | Consistent use of OWL2 DL/OWL2 Full | Frank van Harmelen/Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | FH2 | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtFH2 | Syntax, Document Overview, Editorial |
| 29 | 2009-Jan-23 | Opposing OWL/XML format | Frank van Harmelen/Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | FH3 | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtFH3 | NF&R |
| 30,addendum | 2009-Jan-23 | Opposing named bnodes | Frank van Harmelen/Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | FH4 | Ivan | ACK - OK | RtFH4,RtFH4-ack | NF&R, possible in future |
| 31 | 2009-Jan-23 | Wanting ontology annotations to name profile/Issue 111 | Frank van Harmelen/Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | FH5 | pfps | ACK - OK (minimally) | RtFH5,RtFH5-ack | None |
| 32 | 2009-Jan-24 | Documentation of OWL2-RL | Chimezie Ogbuji | CO1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtCO1,RtCO1-ack | Profiles, editorial |
| 33 | 2009-Jan-24 | SSFSS Editorial comments | Jonathan Rees | JR2 | Boris | Sent 18 Mar | RtJR2 | Syntax, editorial |
| 34, 35,36, [db1], [jc3] | 2009-Jan-24 | Comments from TopQuadrant | Jeremy Carrol; Ian Davis & David Booth concurring | JC1a | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtJC1a | NF&R |
| 34, 35, 36, [db1], [jc3] | 2009-Jan-24 | Comments from TopQuadrant | Jeremy Carrol; Ian Davis & David Booth concurring | JC1b | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtJC1b | Mapping-to-RDF,RDF Semantics, Change to property chains NF&R |
| 37 | 2009-Jan-23 | Too many profiles (supporting Lilly's comment) | Frank van Harmelen | FH6 | pfps | ACK - OK (minimally) | RtFH6,RtFH6-ack | None |
| 38 | 2009-Jan-24 | Syntax, Editorial | Kaarel Kaljurand | KK1 | Boris | ACK - OK | RtKK1,RtKK1-ack | Syntax, editorial |
| 39 | 2009-Jan-23 | Hidden Axioms | Bijan Parsia/Manchester | BP1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtBP1,RtBP1-ack | None |
| 40 | 2009-Jan-23 | OWL/XML | Bijan Parsia | BP2 | Bijan | Changes to XML Syntax | XML Serialization, Schema changes, no language changes | |
| 41 | 2009-Jan-23 | Named Axioms | Bijan Parsia/Manchester | BP3 | pfps | Withdrawn | N/A | N/A |
| 42 | 2009-Jan-25 | Editorial-Guide to documents desired | Andrea Splendiani | AS1 | ivan | Sent 5 Mar, Chased 19 Mar | RtAS1 | Document Overview, new non-normative document |
| 43a | 2009-Jan-22 | Editorial comments from Oracle | Zhe Wu/Oracle | ZW2a | pfps, Boris | Sent 4 March, Chased 18 Mar | RtZW2aPt1,RtZW2a | Mapping_to_RDF_Graphs, editorial; Profiles, editorial |
| 43b | 2009-Jan-22 | RL Datatypes: + xsd:posint - owl:rational (4,8) | Zhe Wu/Oracle | ZW2b | pfps | ACK - OK | RtZW2b,RtZW2b-ack RtZW2b-add,-ack, | Profiles, change to datatypes in OWL 2 RL |
| 44 | 2009-Jan-26 | Structures, elements of the structural specification, and equivalence | Jonathan Rees | JR3 | Boris | Sent 18 Mar | RtJR3 | Syntax, editorial |
| 45 | 2009-Jan-26 | OWLlink | Marko Luther | ML2 | Uli | Sent 16 Mar | RtML2 | |
| 46 | 2009-Jan-26 | Wants N-Ary | Jan Hladik | JH2 | Uli | ACK - OK | RtJH2,RtJH2-ack | N-ary note, WG note forthcoming |
| 47 | 2009-Jan-29 | hasKey question | Marijke Keet | MK1 | pfps | ACK - NO | RtMK1,RtMK1-ack | None |
| 48 | 2009-Jan-29 | SWD proposed comments | SWD | SWD1 | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtSWD1 | Syntax, Document Overview, Editorial |
| 49 | 2009-Jan-30 | Roadmap | Jonathan Rees | JR4 | Ian & Ivan | Sent 5 Mar, Chased 19 Mar | RtJR4 | Document Overview, new non-normative document |
| 50 | 2009-Jan-26 | Sameness and Namedness | Jonathan Rees | JR5 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtJR5,RtJR5-ack | Syntax, Direct_Semantics, editorial |
| 51a | 2009-Jan-27 | (1) Functional Data Properties | Ralf Moeller | RM1a | Michael_Schneider, pfps | ACK - NO 2nd Reply Sent 18 Mar | RtRM1,RtRM1-ack RtRM1-2 | None |
| 51b | 2009-Jan-27 | (2) Datatype Restriction RDF-Syntax / (3) Named Datatype Restrictions | Ralf Moeller | RM1b | pfps | Sent 18 Mar | RtRM1b | Syntax, ..., Naming data ranges (IP) |
| 52a | 2009-Feb-01 | RDF Semantics editorials | Jonathan Rees | JR6a | Michael Schneider | Editorial & Drafting Response | ||
| 52b | 2009-Feb-01 | OWL naming issues | Jonathan Rees | JR6b | pfps | Response Drafted | Syntax, Document Overview, Others?, Editorial | |
| 53 | 2009-Feb-01 | Imports closure | Jonathan Rees | JR7 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtJR7,RtJR7-ack | RDF-Based Semantics, coincidental change, possible editorial changes in future |
| 54 | 2009-Feb-01 | Triples and OWL | Jan Wielemaker | JR8 JR8-2 | ivan | ACK - YES (minimally and in two rounds) | RtJR8, RtJR8-ack, RtJR8-2, RtJR8-2ack | Syntax, XML_Serialization (maybe), editorial |
| 55 | 2009-Feb-02 | octets vs. characters | Jonathan Rees | JW1 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtJW1,RtJW1-ack | Mapping_to_RDF_Graphs, editorial |
| 56,57 | 2009-Feb-03 | OWL2 and RDF | Taylor Cowan | TC1 | Ivan | ACK - OK | RtTC1,RtTC1-ack | Syntax (future editorial) |
| 58 | 2009-Feb-03 | Strong typing of functional syntax | Matthew Horridge | MH1 | Ian | ACK - OK | RtMH1, RtMH1-ack | Syntax, Direct Semantics, XML Serialization, fully typed functional syntax |
| 59 | 2009-Feb-03 | OWL 2 QL sameAs | Ivan Herman | IH3 | Uli (& Ivan?) | Response Drafted | Profiles, editorial | |
| 60 | 2009-Feb-05 | Syntactic Conformance | Jeremy Carroll | JC2 | Ian | Sent 19th March | RtJC2 | Conformance |
| 61 | 2009-Feb-05 | RL Semantics | Jos de Bruijn | JDB3 | Boris & Ian | ACK - OK | RtJDB3,RtJDB3-ack | Conformance, editorial |
| 62 | 2009-Feb-09 | naming of datatypes | Jonas von Malottki | JM1 | pfps | Sent 18 Mar | RtJM1 | Syntax, ..., Naming data ranges (IP) |
| 63 | 2009-Feb-12 | XML syntax | Jacco van Ossenbruggen | JO1 | pfps | Sent 18 Mar | RtJO1 | Document Overview, new non-normative document; Syntax, editorial |
| 64 | 2009-Feb-23 | Syntactic Conformance OWL 2 DL | Michael Schneider | MS7 | Ian | ACK - OK | RtMS7, RtMS7-ack | Conformance, editorial |
| 65 | 2009-Mar-2 | Datatype declaration | Michael Schneider | MS8 | pfps | ACK - OK | RtMS8,RtMS8-ack | Syntax, ... , Naming data ranges (IP) |
| 66 | 2009-Feb-24 | Datatype conformance map | Alan Ruttenberg | AR1 | pfps | Response Drafted | None |
Comments not requiring any response
| Comment | Date | Author |
|---|---|---|
| JB1 | 2009-Jan-21 | Jesus Barrasa, Ontology Systems |
| CG-G1 | 2009-Jan-22 | Carlos Gonzalez-Cadenas, ExperienceOn |
| JR1 | 2009-Jan-22 | Jeremy Rogers, NHS Connecting for Health |
| MI1 | 2009-Jan-23 | Maurice Israel, Thales Communication |
| JG1 | 2009-Jan-23 | John Goodwin, Ordnance Survey |
| CW1 | 2009-Jan-23 | Chris Wroe, BT Health |
| JD1 | 2009-Jan-23 | John Davies. BT Innovate |
| SB1 | 2009-Jan-29 | Sam Brandt, SIEMENS Medical Solutions |
| AMIA1 | 2009-Feb-09 | Stefan Schulz, Ronald Cornet, AMIA KR-WG (Working Group of Formal Biomedical Knowledge Representation) |
| AB1 | 2009-Feb-10 | Christian Jacquelinet, Agence de la biomédecine |
