Warning:
This wiki has been archived and is now read-only.
Teleconference.2008.04.09/Minutes
These minutes have been approved by the Working Group and are now protected from editing. (See IRC log of approval discussion.)
See also: IRC log
- Present
- Ian Horrocks, Jeremy Carroll, Bernardo Cuenca Grau, Michael Smith, Zhe Wu, Ivan Herman, Evan Wallace, Martin Dzbor, Alan Ruttenberg, Sandro Hawke, Jie Bao, Doug Lenat, Michael Schneider, Diego Calvanese, Christine Golbreich, Peter Patel-Schneider
- Regrets
- Rinke Hoekstra
- Chair
- Ian Horrocks
- Scribe
- Jeremy Carroll
Admin
Accept previous minutes?
PROPOSED: Accept previous minutes (Alan)
http://www.w3.org/2007/OWL/wiki/Teleconference.2008.03.26/Minutes
RESOLVED: accept minutes
General Discussion
Outcome of Washington F2F
Alan Ruttenberg: any questions or thoughts about F2F2?
Alan Ruttenberg: issues raised as a consequence of f2f business will be accepted.
Ian Horrocks: Sandro, what is the lastest position concerning publication?
Sandro Hawke: Needing go ahead from editors, otherwise OK
Sandro Hawke: Some editors being a bit silent.
Ian Horrocks: Boris is on holiday, so will be silent.
Ian Horrocks: Boris did his edits and left, and will not respond
Zhe Wu: asked question about intro to fragments/profiles
Zhe Wu: the new three bullets ...
Ian Horrocks: if Zhe is unhappy then we should delete this late change and leave editors note
Bernardo Cuenca Grau: this could be in primer, and perhaps not in this doc
Jeremy Carroll: I will step back if Zhe is stubborn on this!
Alan Ruttenberg: Zhe, can you suggest some repairs to this text?
Zhe Wu: but can the WG agree on any text in time.
Bernardo Cuenca Grau: in the profiles doc there is quite a few things that need to be decided (non technical)
Bernardo Cuenca Grau: The motivations relate to the names, we will need to discuss these issues
Bernardo Cuenca Grau: I think Carsten did a good job with the intro.
Bernardo Cuenca Grau: We could drop last sentence of each bullet point "... is suitable ..."
PROPOSED: For now, drop the last sentence from each bullet point in Profile's Intro. All of the form "...is suitable for...".
Ian Horrocks: Zhe are you happy with this proposed change.
Zhe Wu: yes
Ian Horrocks: so we have consensus
PROPOSED: For now, drop the last sentence from each bullet point in Profile's Intro. All of the form "...is suitable for...".
Ivan Herman: I think we also agree that the editors note from Bijan should stay
PROPOSED: For now, drop the last sentence from each bullet point in Profile's Intro. All of the form "...is suitable for...". (And keep in editor's note from Bijan)
RESOLVED: For now, drop the last sentence from each bullet point in Profile's Intro. All of the form "...is suitable for...". (And keep in editor's note from Bijan)
Ivan Herman: question to Zhe, I found some small bugs in the rules
Zhe Wu: I have fixed these
Zhe Wu: (the typed triple)
Ian Horrocks: The XML Serialization and Primer have bolier plate abstract
Ian Horrocks: The profiles doc has no boiler plate, but has editor's note
Sandro Hawke: they all were the same, but someone complained
Alan Ruttenberg: let's take this off line
Ian Horrocks: not a huge issue, but a surprise
Zhe Wu: regarding abstract. Carsten added abstract.
Zhe Wu: & he thought boiler plate no longer needed
Zhe Wu: and I think Jie did it
Ian Horrocks: but it was agreed at some point that the boiler plate should be in all docs
Ian Horrocks: in case a reader came to this doc first ....
Alan Ruttenberg: Sandro, can you fix this?
Ian Horrocks: I will sort it now.
Alan Ruttenberg: are we frozen now, modulo changes discussed now.
Sandro Hawke: three sentences have gone
Ian Horrocks: abstract is changing now
Alan Ruttenberg: Sandro, do you need anything?
Sandro Hawke: no ....
Sandro Hawke: do we want a comment date?
Sandro Hawke: let's go for four weeks
Ivan Herman: which mailing list for comments
Sandro Hawke: public-owl-comments
Alan Ruttenberg: UFDTF for Monday
Alan Ruttenberg: subject will be requirements doc
Alan Ruttenberg: Evan will work on this
Alan Ruttenberg: please send disiderata to requirements doc to list
Alan Ruttenberg: we want to narrowly address what justifies current spec
Alan Ruttenberg: largely a historical process
Alan Ruttenberg: last call before adjournment
Alan Ruttenberg: thanks to everyone
Alan Ruttenberg: adjourn