Reviewing

From OWL
Jump to: navigation, search

Round 7

Important Dates and Information

No later than Wednesday 6th May, 2009 Editor's drafts ready for reviewing
No later than Wednesday 13th May Reviews due
1st June, 2009 Publish non-rec-track documents as Last Call; rec-track documents to CR

Changes Since April 2009

Documents and Reviewers

Document Status Review/Check Review/Check Review/Check Comments addressed
Overview Ready - few changes, so full review not needed pfps - OK Ivan - OK Ian - OK
Primer Ready for review Mike Smith (review) Deborah McGuinness (review) Michel Dumontier (review) R1, R2, R3
NF&R Ready for review Peter (review) OK Rinke (review) OK R1, R2
QRG Ready for review Peter (review) OK! Ian (review) OK! R1, R2
Manchester Syntax Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Mike Smith - OK
DRE (aka N-ary) ???
SS-FS Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Ivan - OK Bernardo - OK
RDF Mapping Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Michael Schneider - OK Evren Sirin - OK Markus Krötzsch - OK
Direct Semantics Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Michael Schneider - OK Thomas Schneider - OK
RDF-Based Semantics Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Ivan - OK modulo vocab. changes pfps - OK Zhe - OK
Conformance Ready - unchanged since LC draft pfps - OK
Profiles Ready - few changes, so full review not needed pfps - OK
XML Serialization Ready - few changes, so full review not needed Rinke Hoekstra - OK
(modulo <pre> bug)
Mike Grove - OK
(modulo <pre> bug)
rdf:text ???

Round 6

Important Dates and Information

No later than Wednesday 25th March, 2009 Editor's drafts ready for reviewing
No later than Tuesday 7th April Reviews due
15th April, 2009 Publish rec-track specification as Last Call; other docs as PWDs

Changes Since December 2008

Documents and Reviewers

Document Status Reviewer 1 Reviewer 2 Reviewer 3 Comments addressed
Document Overview Ready to review pfps Review Ivan (Considered done) Ian Review R1, R3
SS&FS Ready to review Bernardo Review Ivan Review N/A (OK) R1, R2
RDF Mapping Ready to review Michael Schneider Review Markus Krötzsch Review Evren Sirin Review R1, R2, R3
Direct Semantics Ready to review Michael Schneider Review Thomas Schneider Review N/A (OK) R1 R2
RDF-Based Semantics Ready to review Ivan Review pfps Review Zhe Wu Review R1, R2, R3
Conformance and Test Cases Ready to review Allen Ruttenberg Review pfps Review Jonathan Rees Review R1-pt1, R1-pt2, R2, R3
Profiles Ready to review Achille Fokoue Review Jie Bao Review N/A (OK) R1, R2
Primer Ready to review Ivan Review Deborah McGuinness Michel Dumontier
New Features and Rationale Ready to review Elisa Review Alan Ruttenberg Review pfps General Review R2, R3
Quick Reference Guide Ready to review pfps Preliminary Review Bernardo Review
Ivan Herman
Christine Golbreich Review
Bijan Parsia Review
R1-PP R2-IH R2-BG R3-CG R3-BP
XML Serialization Ready to review Rinke Hoekstra Review Kendall Clark/C&P Review N/A (OK) R1, R2
Manchester (note) Ready to review Alan Ruttenberg Mike Smith Review N/A (OK) R2
N-ary Extension (note) Ready to review Boris Review Michel Dumontier Review N/A R1, R2
rdf:text Ready to review pfps Review Alan Ruttenberg N/A (OK)

Round 4

Dates

Dates for initial set of Reviews

No later than 25th August Editor's drafts ready for reviewing
8th September Reviews due
15th September Publish as Public Working Drafts
23rd October Transition to Last Call

Dates for reviews of Manchester Syntax

Due 8 October


Documents and Reviewers

Document Reviewer 1 Reviewer 2 Reviewer 3 Comments addressed
Syntax Mike Smith DONE Vojtech Svatek DONE Bijan Parsia DONE YES
Direct Semantics Michael Schneider DONE Thomas Schneider DONE Markus Krötzsch DONE YES
RDF-Based Semantics Jie Bao DONE Peter Patel-Schneider DONE Zhe Wu DONE YES
Mapping to RDF Alan Ruttenberg Uli Sattler DONE Evren Sirin DONE YES
Profiles Jim Hendler DONE Ian Horrocks DONE Jeff Pan DONE YES
XML Serialization Rinke Hoekstra DONE Achille Fokoue DONE Kendall Clark DONE YES
Test and Conformance Bernardo Cuenca Grau DONE Mike Smith DONE Michael Schneider DONE YES
Manchester Syntax Rinke Hoekstra DONE Mike Smith DONE Alan Ruttenberg
Quick Reference Peter Patel-Schneider DONE Ivan Herman DONE Uli Sattler DONE
Boris Motik I'll be happy to provide another review of the Quick Reference before next publication
Requirements Elisa Kendall DONE Ivan Herman DONE
MOF-Based Metamodel Elisa Kendall
N-ary Data predicates Boris Motik DONE Bernardo Cuenca Grau DONE Markus Krötzsch DONE
Primer Boris Motik I'll be happy to provide a review before next publication