15:21:47 RRSAgent has joined #mmsem 15:21:47 logging to http://www.w3.org/2006/07/20-mmsem-irc 15:22:36 raphael has changed the topic to: Multimedia Semantics XG - Telecon 20-07-2006 15:42:33 JeffP has joined #mmsem 15:42:53 hi raphael 15:49:51 giovannit has joined #mmsem 15:49:57 1,2,3 in the place to be 15:50:09 (-: 15:50:25 Hi giovannit 15:50:30 Zakim, greet me plenty! 15:50:30 I don't understand 'greet me plenty!', giovannit 15:50:36 hi Jeff :-) 15:52:06 giovannit, I hope we can sort out the wiki issue soon 15:52:48 I am impressed by the apparent complexity of it all :-) 15:53:05 anadiotis has joined #mmsem 15:54:00 Hi Giovanni 15:54:27 zakim, wha conferences? 15:54:27 I don't understand your question, raphael. 15:54:31 zakim, what conferences? 15:54:31 I see VB_(ForEach)11:00AM, INC_MMSEM()12:00PM, WS_DescWG()11:00AM, SW_HCLS()11:00AM, WAI_Team()10:45AM, GA_WebCGM()11:00AM, XML_PMWG()11:00AM, DIG_TAMI(F2F)9:00AM active 15:54:35 also scheduled at this time are I18N_Core_WG(WS-I18N)11:00AM, SYMM_TTWG()12:00PM, VB_VBWG()10:00AM, GA_SVGWG()3:00AM 15:54:55 zakim, this is INC_MMSEM 15:54:55 ok, raphael; that matches INC_MMSEM()12:00PM 15:55:02 jrvosse has joined #mmsem 15:55:44 Meeting: Multimedia Semantics XG - Telecon 20-07-2006 15:55:59 Chair: JeffP 15:56:17 Scribe: Jacco, Raphael 15:56:41 ScribeNick: raphael, jrvosse 15:56:45 +GiorgosStoilos 15:57:26 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-mmsem/2006Jul/0022.html 15:57:37 zakim, GiorgosStoilos is Vassilis 15:57:37 +Vassilis; got it 15:58:24 zakim, who is here? 15:58:24 On the phone I see [CWI], Vassilis 15:58:25 On IRC I see jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 15:58:39 +??P34 15:58:51 zakim, [CWI] is Raphael 15:58:52 +Raphael; got it 15:59:05 vassilisT has joined #mmsem 15:59:10 +??P26 15:59:14 +Vassilis.a 15:59:20 vasileios has joined #mmsem 15:59:22 zakim, ??P26 15:59:22 I don't understand '??P26', JeffP 15:59:35 zakim, ??P26 is me 15:59:35 +JeffP; got it 15:59:59 zakim Vassilis.a is Yannis 16:00:06 +[UMD] 16:00:10 zakim, who is here? 16:00:16 zakim, ??P34 is Giovanni 16:00:17 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, ??P34, JeffP, [IVML], [UMD] 16:00:21 On IRC I see vasileios, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:00:29 +Giovanni; got it 16:00:31 zakim [UMD] is Crhis 16:00:32 chalaschek has joined #MMSEM 16:00:36 zakim, [UMD] is Crhis 16:00:43 zakim mute me 16:00:48 +Crhis; got it 16:00:53 christian has joined #mmsem 16:00:58 zakim, [UMD] is chalaschek 16:01:04 sorry, raphael, I do not recognize a party named '[UMD]' 16:01:17 +??P6 16:01:18 zakim, Crhis is Chris 16:01:18 hello there 16:01:18 +Chris; got it 16:01:27 zakim, who is here? 16:01:27 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni, JeffP, [IVML], Chris, ??P6 16:01:29 On IRC I see christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:01:32 + +30231046aaaa 16:01:34 +??P14 16:01:39 zakim, [IVML] is Yannis 16:01:40 +Yannis; got it 16:01:43 IoannisPratikakis has joined #mmsem 16:02:04 zak 16:02:06 zakim, who is here? 16:02:08 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni, JeffP, Yannis, Chris, ??P6, +30231046aaaa, ??P14 16:02:10 On IRC I see IoannisPratikakis, christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:02:47 zakim, who is talking? 16:02:57 jrvosse, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Raphael (65%), Vassilis (6%), Giovanni (9%), Yannis (53%) 16:02:59 could someone remind me which is thecode to enter the teleconf? 16:03:04 alessio has joined #mmsem 16:03:44 zakim, +30231046aaaa is Vasileios 16:03:44 +Vasileios; got it 16:04:11 vasileios has joined #mmsem 16:04:25 zakim, ??P6 is Melli 16:04:25 +Melli; got it 16:04:30 zakim, who is here? 16:04:30 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni, JeffP, Yannis, Chris, Melli, Vasileios, ??P14 16:04:32 On IRC I see vasileios, alessio, IoannisPratikakis, christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:04:36 Massimo has joined #mmsem 16:04:40 hi, this is vasileios and stamatia from ITI Thessaloniki 16:05:38 Topic: ADMIN 16:05:44 hello all, i have some technical issues with the phone connection, and i don't know when/if i'll be able to join you by phone, but i'm here 16:05:45 cgi-irc has joined #mmsem 16:05:57 Regrets: Ovidio, Patrizia, Pasquale, Thierry, Paul, Stephan, Thomas 16:06:06 zakim, who is talking 16:06:06 I don't understand 'who is talking', raphael 16:06:08 zakim, who is taking 16:06:08 I don't understand 'who is taking', JeffP 16:06:08 hi All 16:06:13 zakim, who is talking? 16:06:21 zakim, who is talking? 16:06:23 raphael, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Raphael (4%), ??P14 (10%), Giovanni (32%) 16:06:26 zakim, mute me 16:06:28 sorry, giovannit, I do not see a party named 'giovannit' 16:06:33 jrvosse, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Melli (4%), Raphael (59%), Vasileios (9%), ??P14 (10%), Vassilis (10%), JeffP (9%), Giovanni (68%), Yannis (7%) 16:06:49 hello, from IIT / NCSR"Demokritos", Athens, Greece 16:06:58 zakim, mute Giovanni, 16:06:58 sorry, jrvosse, I do not see a party named 'Giovanni,' 16:07:00 zakim, mute Giovanni 16:07:00 Giovanni should now be muted 16:07:22 PROPOSED to accept the minutes of the 22 June 2006 telecon: 16:07:22 http://www.w3.org/2006/06/22-mmsem-minutes.html 16:07:30 ACCEPTED 16:07:38 PROPOSED to accept the minutes of the 10-11 July 2006 F2F meeting: 16:07:38 http://www.w3.org/2006/07/10-mmsem-minutes.html 16:07:38 http://www.w3.org/2006/07/11-mmsem-minutes.html 16:07:48 ACCEPTED 16:07:58 PROPOSED next telecon 31 August 2006 16:08:26 ACCEPTED 16:08:44 Topic: LIAISON (SWBPD) 16:09:07 http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-mmsem/2006Jul/0043.html 16:09:13 Comments on working draft, Jeff and Massimo have sent comments, these have been addressed 16:09:16 yup .. its not something you can comment that quickly i think 16:09:35 +[IPcaller] 16:09:39 Jeff: It is really important, please have a look 16:09:51 Melli: it is on my todo list for next week 16:10:34 +[CWI] 16:11:09 zakim, [CWI] is anadiotis 16:11:09 +anadiotis; got it 16:11:20 zakim, mute yannis 16:11:20 Yannis should now be muted 16:12:12 http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/mmsem/wiki/Liaison 16:12:29 Still important to get comments as soon as possible 16:12:48 there is big echo 16:12:57 yup 16:13:02 Jeff: Liasons are important 16:13:31 zakim, mute me 16:13:31 sorry, vassilisT, I do not see a party named 'vassilisT' 16:13:32 zakim, mute me 16:13:32 sorry, jrvosse, I do not see a party named 'jrvosse' 16:13:55 Rapael: this also depends on the use cases 16:14:01 jacco what is going on? 16:14:08 zakim, who is talking? 16:14:18 giovannit, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: anadiotis (50%), Raphael (9%) 16:14:30 zakim, mute anadiotis 16:14:30 anadiotis should now be muted 16:14:33 so its anediotis :-) 16:14:39 thanks 16:14:39 busted.. ;-) 16:15:00 yup and I would have in fact started.. 16:15:09 Raphael: We should also put the resource pages on the wiki 16:15:57 Rapael: Giovanni volunteered, are there any others? 16:16:06 zakim, mute giovanni 16:16:06 Giovanni was already muted, giovannit 16:16:10 +??P1 16:16:16 not much work, just maintain on basis of input of others 16:16:29 yannis has joined #mmsem 16:16:33 zakim, P1 is SusanneBoll 16:16:33 sorry, jrvosse, I do not recognize a party named 'P1' 16:16:43 zakim, ??P1 is SusanneBoll 16:16:43 +SusanneBoll; got it 16:18:28 Raphael explains Resource, Tools and Vocabularies to Susanne 16:19:00 zakim, who is one the phone? 16:19:00 I don't understand your question, jrvosse. 16:19:05 zakim, who is there 16:19:05 I don't understand 'who is there', jrvosse 16:19:07 zakim, who is there? 16:19:07 I don't understand your question, jrvosse. 16:19:16 Of course I voulunteered automatically along with giovanni :-) 16:19:26 zakim, who is here? 16:19:26 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni (muted), JeffP, Yannis (muted), Chris, Melli, Vasileios, ??P14, [IPcaller], anadiotis (muted), SusanneBoll 16:19:30 On IRC I see yannis, cgi-irc, Massimo, vasileios, alessio, IoannisPratikakis, christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:20:05 zakim, unmute me 16:20:05 Yannis should no longer be muted 16:20:20 Yannis about MPEG7 liason 16:21:28 There is a MPEG this week in Austria, colleague of yannis is visiting this and talk to people for liason work 16:21:33 zakim, mute me 16:21:33 Yannis should now be muted 16:21:40 zakim, mute me 16:21:40 sorry, christian, I do not see a party named 'christian' 16:21:58 action for Yannis to report back to the group about the outcome of the MPEG7 liason attempts 16:22:09 action: Yannis to report back to the group about the outcome of the MPEG7 liason attempts 16:22:22 Topic: XG UPDATES 16:22:44 Jeff explains about the WIKI pages being about work in progress 16:23:06 zakim, who is talking? 16:23:17 jrvosse, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: [IPcaller] (76%), Raphael (13%) 16:23:27 zakim, mute [IPcaller] 16:23:27 [IPcaller] should now be muted 16:23:40 Music Use Case 16:23:52 Action: iovanni to coordinate write up of a use case on music 16:23:55 zakim, unmute Giovanni 16:23:55 Giovanni should no longer be muted 16:24:16 DONE, see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xg-mmsem/2006Jul/0036.html 16:25:12 ACTION: Giovanni to coordinate write up of a use case on music: CONTINUED 16:26:17 Action: Patrizia to find pointer to the Vienna tool (music use case): DONE 16:26:30 ACTION: Thierry to write up limitations of MPEG-7 description schemes: CONTINUED 16:27:24 all, please comment on the use cases using the wiki pages directly 16:27:44 Susanne: can new use cases still be added 16:27:53 YES 16:27:54 zakim, mute giovanni 16:27:54 Giovanni should now be muted 16:27:54 raphael: sure! 16:27:57 zakim, unmute me 16:27:57 anadiotis should no longer be muted 16:28:12 Tagging Use Case 16:28:48 Action: George to write up a use case around tagging: CONTINUED 16:28:54 ar ethere URI for the use cases already? 16:29:29 Giovanni: http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/mmsem/wiki/Tagging_Use_Case 16:29:58 Susanne: there will be an paper on the ACM multimedia conference on averaging/harmonizing the ratings on images of different websites 16:30:53 Susanne: this is just a first step, but having exchangable metadata would be the next 16:31:46 Susanne: title should be something along the lines of "Media tagging" 16:31:55 Susanne will join the effort on this use case 16:32:02 zakim, mute anadiotis 16:32:02 anadiotis should now be muted 16:32:09 News Use case: 16:32:54 ACTION: Raphael to write up use case in the news domain: PENDING (waiting for IPTC green light) 16:33:19 Algorithm representation Use case: 16:33:41 http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/mmsem/wiki/Algorithm_representation_Use_case 16:33:47 Massimo ? 16:33:52 yes 16:34:04 zakim, who is here ? 16:34:04 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni (muted), JeffP, Yannis (muted), Chris, Melli, Vasileios, ??P14, [IPcaller] (muted), anadiotis (muted), SusanneBoll 16:34:06 (sorry for the phone) 16:34:07 On IRC I see yannis, cgi-irc, Massimo, vasileios, alessio, IoannisPratikakis, christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 16:34:30 i join Jacco in his request for more details about this use case 16:34:30 massimo do you have comment on the use case ? 16:34:57 massimo, I put a comment on the wiki, could you respond to that 16:35:15 i'm going to see it 16:35:21 i agree with jacco too 16:35:50 Low level feature extraction Use case: 16:36:00 ACTION: Massimo to write up use case on analysis and reproducing: CONTINUED 16:36:26 rrsagent, pointer? 16:36:26 See http://www.w3.org/2006/07/20-mmsem-irc#T16-36-26 16:36:46 rrsagent, make logs public 16:36:49 zakim, unmute me 16:36:49 Yannis should no longer be muted 16:36:56 please someone who can create the wiki page :-) 16:37:48 Vassilis: two contributions from ITI, one emphasising on the low level, the other on the bridge between the low and high level ones 16:38:44 Raphael: Please note the W3C policies, do not attach unless necesarry, if you need to do so, please in HTML 16:38:52 actually, one contribution is from NCSR (Ioannis) and the other from ITI Thessaloniki (Vasileios) 16:39:29 thanks, vasileios 16:39:43 Raphael: is it possible to merge the 2 use cases? 16:41:05 VasillisT: Maybe should continue to work like this, can merge later 16:42:14 For the moment, I agree with VasillisT 16:42:18 Ionnis: I think it would be good to merge these 16:43:34 It's better that the current documents become more mature 16:43:53 After a second round we merge them 16:44:06 Topic: 3.6 Other use case ? 16:44:37 ACTION: Iioanis to write up use case showing the need for semantic interpretation of low level features (Ioannis and Vasileios, 2 documents): CONTINUED 16:44:41 Media Use case 16:44:54 zakim, who is talking? 16:44:59 zakim, mute me 16:44:59 Yannis should now be muted 16:45:05 christian, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: SusanneBoll (4%), Raphael (19%), Vasileios (13%), Yannis (18%) 16:46:00 Raphael: how realistic is that we can get datasets for this use case? 16:46:21 VassilisT: we have data from a national project and think it is feasible 16:46:29 ACTION: Vassilis to continue the Media use case 16:47:42 Raphael: for everyone not at the f2f: feel free to join activity on existing use cases or add a new use case 16:48:07 If you are not assigned to a use case yet, please speak up 16:48:23 Chris: will read through the current use cases 16:48:28 Melli: same for me 16:48:46 q+ on medical use case 16:48:48 zakim, unmute me 16:48:49 Yannis should no longer be muted 16:48:55 q+ to speak on medical use case 16:49:24 raphael: yannis, what are your plans on the use case? 16:49:41 to help taking decisions 16:50:04 zakim, ack jvross 16:50:04 I see jrvosse on the speaker queue 16:50:21 zakim, ack jvrosse 16:50:21 I see jrvosse on the speaker queue 16:50:40 zakim q- 16:50:42 zakim, q- 16:50:42 I see jrvosse on the speaker queue 16:51:20 Yannis: I think the low level uses cases are covered, might think about a new one 16:52:07 Jacco on medical use case, forgot that there was already a use case on the image annotation draft from SWBPD WG 16:52:10 Actkion: Melli propose a use case on bio-medicale images 16:52:15 Action: Melli propose a use case on bio-medicale images 16:52:16 4. Future Metings: 16:52:36 zakim, mute me 16:52:36 Yannis should now be muted 16:52:45 Susanne: will read through use cases and decide later 16:53:04 @ISWC! 16:53:08 zakim, unmute me 16:53:08 Yannis should no longer be muted 16:53:13 ack jrvosse 16:53:13 jrvosse, you wanted to speak on medical use case 16:53:42 At ISWC would be better for me and Giovanni 16:53:46 Next f2f meeting: two proposals: athens greece, SAMT or athens georgia, at ISWC 16:53:50 I also vote for ISWC 16:54:00 Susanne: is ACM MM an option? 16:54:18 Raphael: October is too early ... 16:54:57 Chris: the two venues I checked only have a room for one day 16:55:51 Raphael: most participants come from europe, only 2 from US. Also there are (too) many events already around ISWC 16:56:36 Raphael: for the US particpants, is there any possibility you could make it to Europe? 16:57:11 Melli & Chris: we could, just depends on budget issues, needto get improval first 16:58:29 Yannis: On the 7th of December we have two rooms, on the 8th we have one extra room available 16:58:42 Jeff, how big is this room? 16:59:05 Yannis: smallest rooms are around 25, that should be sufficient 16:59:47 Just consider that NCSR"Demokritos", could also host the f2f meeting 16:59:58 Raphael: PROPOSAL: co-locate next f2f with SAMT in Athens, Greece. 17:00:40 zakim, who is here? 17:00:40 On the phone I see Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni (muted), JeffP, Yannis, Chris, Melli, Vasileios, ??P14, [IPcaller] (muted), anadiotis (muted), SusanneBoll 17:00:43 On IRC I see yannis, cgi-irc, Massimo, vasileios, alessio, IoannisPratikakis, christian, chalaschek, vassilisT, jrvosse, anadiotis, giovannit, JeffP, RRSAgent, Zakim, raphael 17:00:58 Yannis: network access might be a problem, we are currently negociating about wlan network access 17:01:47 Yannis: it is in a hotel, we do not have everything under control 17:02:46 Vassilis: we could do it just after samt, on the campus 17:02:46 Vassilis: during SAMT or right after 17:02:56 zakim, unmute Giovanni 17:02:56 Giovanni should no longer be muted 17:02:59 zakim, unmute me 17:02:59 anadiotis should no longer be muted 17:03:31 zakim, mute me 17:03:31 Yannis should now be muted 17:03:35 sorry.. was away.. they're both fine. I'd rather @iswc though 17:03:49 zakim,mute me 17:03:49 sorry, giovannit, I do not see a party named 'giovannit' 17:03:56 zakim, mute giovanni 17:03:56 Giovanni should now be muted 17:04:01 I agree with giovanni, ISWC would be better but it ok anyway 17:04:12 echo again 17:04:34 zakim, who is talking? 17:04:44 massimo: SAMT ? or ISWC for the next F2F ? 17:04:46 raphael, listening for 11 seconds I heard sound from the following: anadiotis (50%), SusanneBoll (8%), Raphael (54%), Vassilis (8%) 17:04:59 zakim, mute anadiotis 17:04:59 anadiotis should now be muted 17:05:36 Raphael: PROPOSAL: co-locate next f2f with SAMT in Athens, Greece. 17:05:39 ACCEPTED 17:05:55 Votes for SAMT: Raphael, Vassilis, Jacco, Vassileios, Susanne, George 17:06:21 I also vote for SAMT 17:06:32 I also vote for SAMT 17:06:39 Votes for ISWC: Giovanni, Chris 17:06:46 Topic: AOB 17:07:04 same, i vote for SAMT 17:07:05 Susanne: can the mail subjects be prefixed? 17:07:07 Action: Jeff, Raphael to contact Yannis for the practical SAMT details 17:08:34 action: jeff and raphael to start discussion on email subject prefixes 17:08:34 bye 17:08:35 by all! :-) 17:08:39 -Vassilis 17:08:39 bye 17:08:40 bye: 17:08:40 -SusanneBoll 17:08:41 zakim, unmute me 17:08:41 cioa a tutti 17:08:41 Yannis should no longer be muted 17:08:43 -Chris 17:08:44 -Raphael 17:08:45 -??P14 17:08:46 -Vasileios 17:08:48 -anadiotis 17:08:50 -JeffP 17:08:52 -Giovanni 17:08:52 bye ! 17:08:54 -Melli 17:08:56 bye 17:09:00 bye 17:09:06 Massimo has left #mmsem 17:09:09 rrsagent, draft minutes 17:09:09 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/07/20-mmsem-minutes.html jrvosse 17:09:12 \quit 17:10:16 -[IPcaller] 17:10:34 rrsagent, pointer 17:10:34 See http://www.w3.org/2006/07/20-mmsem-irc#T17-10-34 17:11:44 -Yannis 17:11:46 INC_MMSEM()12:00PM has ended 17:11:47 Attendees were Vassilis, Raphael, JeffP, Giovanni, Chris, Yannis, Vasileios, Melli, [IPcaller], anadiotis, SusanneBoll 17:13:18 Present: Raphael, Vassilis, Giovanni, JeffP, Yannis, Chris, Melli, Vasileios, Susanne, Jacco, Ioannis, Stamatia, Massimo (IRC), Allessio (IRC), 17:13:21 rrsagent, draft minutes 17:13:21 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/07/20-mmsem-minutes.html jrvosse 17:16:15 bye, see you next time :) 17:16:18 alessio has left #mmsem 19:12:13 Zakim has left #mmsem 19:54:48 rellero_ has joined #mmsem 19:55:00 rellero_ has left #mmsem 19:59:48 rellero__ has joined #mmsem 20:00:17 rellero__ has joined #mmsem 20:01:22 rellero__ has joined #mmsem 20:01:35 rellero__ has left #mmsem