Edit comment LC-1882 for Protocol for Web Description Resources (POWDER) Working Group

Quick access to LC-1879 LC-1880 LC-1881 LC-1882 LC-1883 LC-1910

Comment LC-1882

Comment Shortname:

Commenter: Jeremy Carroll <jjc@hpl.hp.com>

Message-id:

Section of the document concerned:

[Free text description]Document as a wholeProtocol for Web Description Resources (POWDER): Grouping... Protocol for Web Description Resources (POWDER): Grouping of Resources Abstract Status of this document Table of Contents 1 Introduction (Informative) 1.1 Design Goals and Constraints 1.2 Outline Methodology 2 Grouping by address 2.1 Grouping by IRI/URI component http://joe:mypasswd@www.example.com:1234/example1/example2... Table 1: Mapping between regular expression variables and U... Table 2: The RDF Properties used to define resource sets by... Table 2: The RDF Properties used to define resource sets by... Example 2-1: A Resource Set definition using three RDF prop... 2.1.1 Resource Set Definitions Referring to Ports Example 2-2: A Resource Set definition using port lists and... † 2.1.2 Resource Set Definitions Referring to Paths and/or Query Strings ‡ 2.1.3 IRI/URI Canonicalization Table 3: Examples of canonicalized IRIs and URIs Input IR... Table 3: Examples of canonicalized IRIs and URIs 2.1.4 Data encoding 2.2 Grouping by Regular Expression: The includeUriPattern and excludeUriPattern Properties Example 2-3: Set definition by regular expression (not incl... Example 2-4: Set definition by regular expression, includin... 2.2.1 Safe Use of includeUriPattern Example 2-5: An example of a bad set definition by regular... Example 2-6: A second example of a bad set definition by re... Example 2-7: An example of a correct set definition by regu... Example 2-8: A re-write of Example 2-7 without using a regu... 2.3 Grouping by IP Address Example 2-9: A Resource Set definition using the includeIPs... Example 2-10: A Resource Set definition using the includeIp... 2.3.1 Safe Usage of the includeIpRanges Property Example 2-11: Resource Set definition across several IP add... Example 2-12: Erroneous Resource Set definition across seve... 2.4 Enumerating Elements of a Resource Set: the includeResources and excludeResources properties Example 2-13 Resource Set definition using excludeResources... Example 2-14 Erroneous Resource Set definition using includ... Example 2-15 Correct Resource Set definition using includeR... 2.5 Redirection: the includeRedirection property Example 2-16 Resource Set definition using includeRedirecti... 3 Grouping by Resource Property 3.1 Basic Resource Set Definition by Resource Property: the includeConditional and excludeConditional properties Example 3-1: Basic Resource Set definition by resource prop... 3.2 Resource Set Definition by Property Look Up Example 3-2: Resource Set definition with property look up.... Example 3-3: Resource Set definition with property look up... 4 Conjunction and disjunction 4.1 Combining Definitions Within a Resource Set Example 4-1: Resource Set definition with a two element lis... Example 4-2: An invalid Resource Set definition in which a... Example 4-3: Resource Set definition with two RDF propertie... Example 4-4: Resource Set definition with two RDF propertie... 4.2 Combining Multiple Resource Sets Example 4-5: A Resource Set formed from a union of two sub... Example 4-6: A relatively complex Resource Set definition e... Example 4-7: A complex Resource Set definition using nested... Example 4-8: A more efficient way of expressing the same Re... 5 Logical Inconsistency Example 5-1 A simple Resource Set definition anticipated as... Example 5-2 A repeat of Example 5-1 with an additional line... Example 5-3: A corrected version of Example 5-2 <wdr:Resou... 6 Extension Mechanism 6.1 Extension Example 1: ISAN Example 6-1: A Resource Set Definition using an ISAN number... 6.2 Extension Example 2: Custom URL Patterns Example 6-2 A Resource Set definition using a custom URL pa... 7 References Normative References [URIS] [IRIS] [UTF-8] [PERL] [CIDR] [HTTPCODE] [HTTPRDF] [OWLSO] Sources [WDR] [VOC] [Rabin] [WCL-XG] [PUC] [URISpace] [SPARQL] [SOAP] [ROBOTS] [ISAN1] [ISAN2] [Google] 8 Acknowledgments
or

Refinement of the section concerned:

Status:

open proposal pending resolved_yes resolved_no resolved_partial other assigned to Nobody

Type: substantive editorial typo question general comment undefined

Comment:

I found example 4.6 I had to think fairly hard. If this is a standard
idiom then it may be worth spelling it out a bit.

"all resources on example.com except those on video.example.com shot in
widescreen format."
which is
"all resources on example.com except those on video.example.com, and
all resources on example.com except those shot in widescreen format."

Related issues: (space separated ids)

WG Notes:

Resolution:

(Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)