IRC log of rif on 2006-02-27

Timestamps are in UTC.

07:49:58 [RRSAgent]
RRSAgent has joined #rif
07:49:58 [RRSAgent]
logging to http://www.w3.org/2006/02/27-rif-irc
07:50:10 [FrankMcCabe]
FrankMcCabe has joined #rif
07:59:13 [patranja]
patranja has joined #rif
07:59:32 [AxelPolleres]
AxelPolleres has joined #rif
08:00:33 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
08:00:48 [sandro]
topic: introduction
08:00:54 [sandro]
scribe: sandro
08:01:00 [sandro]
chair: Christian
08:01:07 [sandro]
RRSAgent, make minutes
08:01:07 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/02/27-rif-minutes.html sandro
08:02:30 [sandro]
Christian: My objective is to finalize discussion on use cases. If we can't do then, then we need to agree on what to publish.
08:02:42 [sandro]
s/then/that/
08:03:13 [josb]
josb has joined #rif
08:03:47 [sandro]
Christian: We're obvsiously starting late. The agenda may need to shift.
08:03:56 [sandro]
(long line at registration, although really only about 10 minutes.)
08:04:10 [sandro]
Christian: We might or might not do the split sessions
08:04:54 [sandro]
... One of the objectives of this meeting is to have people talk to each other, including in small groups. Thus the long lunch break.
08:05:07 [sandro]
sandro has changed the topic to: RIF F2F2: http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/wiki/F2F2
08:05:45 [mdean]
can someone dial in to Zakim?
08:06:28 [sandro]
We seem to not have a speakerphone, Mike. Sorry. I'll try to figure it out during the break.
08:06:44 [Francois]
Francois has joined #rif
08:06:56 [mdean]
ok - thanks
08:07:16 [sandro]
(We were supposed to have one, and are paying for one.)
08:11:35 [sandro]
Christian: Scribes! One scribe for short sessions, two for long. Not much more than one hour or maybe 1.5 hours.
08:11:39 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/wiki/ScribesList
08:11:46 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
08:12:11 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
08:12:18 [PaulaP]
PaulaP has joined #rif
08:12:21 [ivan]
ivan has joined #rif
08:13:34 [JosDeRoo]
JosDeRoo has joined #rif
08:13:57 [ivan]
ivan has joined #rif
08:14:02 [AxelPolleres]
AxelPolleres has joined #rif
08:16:50 [GaryHallmark]
GaryHallmark has joined #rif
08:17:17 [sandro]
First session scribe: Gary, then Giorgos Stamou
08:18:03 [EliasT]
EliasT has joined #rif
08:18:12 [sandro]
Attendance
08:18:15 [sandro]
* Sandro Hawke <sandro@w3.org> (W3C/MIT) : attending monday, tuesday
08:18:29 [sandro]
* Peter F. Patel-Schneider <pfps@inf.unibz.it> (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano) : attending monday, tuesday
08:18:50 [sandro]
* François Bry <bry@ifi.lmu.de> (REWERSE) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:00 [sandro]
* Jos de Bruijn <jos.debruijn@deri.org> (DERI Innsbruck at the Leopold-Franzens-Universität Innsbruck, Austria) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:08 [sandro]
* Igor Mozetic <igor.mozetic@ijs.si> (Jozef Stefan Institute) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:17 [sandro]
* Axel Polleres <axel.polleres@uibk.ac.at> (DERI Innsbruck at the Leopold-Franzens-Universität Innsbruck, Austria) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:23 [sandro]
* John Hall <john.hall@modelsys.com> (Object Management Group, Inc. (OMG)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:25 [LeeF]
LeeF has joined #rif
08:19:29 [sandro]
* Paula-Lavinia Patranjan <paula.patranjan@ifi.lmu.de> (REWERSE) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:36 [sandro]
* Michael Sintek <sintek@dfki.uni-kl.de> (German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI) Gmbh) : attending monday, tuesday
08:19:43 [sandro]
* Giorgos Stamou <gstam@softlab.ntua.gr> (Image Video & Multimedia Systems Laboratory of National Technical University of Athens (IVML-NTUA)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:00 [sandro]
* Hassan Ait-Kaci <hak@ilog.com> (ILOG, S.A.) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:12 [sandro]
* Francis McCabe <frank.mccabe@us.fujitsu.com> (Fujitsu Limited) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:17 [sandro]
(Frank)
08:20:35 [sandro]
* Jos De Roo <jos.deroo@agfa.com> (Agfa-Gevaert N. V.) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:39 [sandro]
* Christian de Sainte Marie <csma@ilog.fr> (ILOG, S.A.) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:45 [sandro]
* Gary Hallmark <gary.hallmark@oracle.com> (Oracle Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:20:54 [sandro]
* Markus Krötzsch <mak@aifb.uni-karlsruhe.de> (Forschungszentrum Informatik (FZI)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:21:09 [sandro]
coming late: * Andreas Harth <andreas.harth@deri.org> (DERI Galway at the National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland) : attending monday, tuesday
08:21:22 [sandro]
not here: * Sergio Tessaris <tessaris@inf.unibz.it> (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano) : attending monday, tuesday
08:21:29 [sandro]
* Allen Ginsberg <aginsberg@imc.mitre.org> (MITRE Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:21:45 [sandro]
mistake: * Eric Miller <em@w3.org> (W3C/MIT) : attending monday, tuesday
08:21:56 [sandro]
* Uli Sattler <Ulrike.Sattler@manchester.ac.uk> (University of Manchester) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:01 [sandro]
* Paul Vincent <paulvincent@fairisaac.com> (Fair Isaac Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:07 [sandro]
* Michael Kifer <kifer@cs.sunysb.edu> (W3C Invited Experts) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:12 [sandro]
* Donald Chapin <Donald.Chapin@btinternet.com> (Object Management Group, Inc. (OMG)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:20 [sandro]
* Deepali Khushraj <deepali.khushraj@nokia.com> (Nokia Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:25 [sandro]
* Harold Boley <Harold.Boley@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca> (National Research Council Canada) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:34 [sandro]
* Giorgos Stoilos <gstoil@image.ntua.gr> (Image Video & Multimedia Systems Laboratory of National Technical University of Athens (IVML-NTUA)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:43 [sandro]
Not coming: * Dieter Fensel <dieter.fensel@deri.ie> (DERI Galway at the National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:50 [sandro]
* Darko Anicic <darko.anicic@deri.org> (DERI Innsbruck at the Leopold-Franzens-Universität Innsbruck, Austria) : attending monday, tuesday
08:22:54 [sandro]
* Mala Mehrotra <mm@pragati-inc.com> (Pragati Synergetic Research Inc.) : attending monday, tuesday
08:23:04 [sandro]
* Jeff Pan <pan@cs.man.ac.uk> (University of Manchester) : attending monday, tuesday
08:23:09 [sandro]
* Jeremy Carroll <Jeremy.Carroll@hp.com> (Hewlett Packard Company) : attending monday, tuesday
08:24:52 [sandro]
coming late: * Christopher Welty <cawelty@frontiernet.net> (IBM Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:24:52 [sandro]
* Vassilis Tzouvaras
08:24:53 [sandro]
(not yet registered)
08:24:57 [sandro]
Observers:
08:24:59 [sandro]
* Christine Golbreich <Christine.Golbreich@univ-rennes1.fr> (<strong>not affiliated to a W3C Member</strong>) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:06 [sandro]
(not here) Eric Miller
08:25:08 [sandro]
(not here) Danny Weitzner
08:25:13 [sandro]
(not here) * Thomas Roessler <roessler@w3.org> (W3C/ERCIM) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:14 [sandro]
* Lee Feigenbaum <feigenbl@us.ibm.com> (IBM Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:15 [JeffP]
JeffP has joined #rif
08:25:16 [sandro]
* Elias Torres <eliast@us.ibm.com> (IBM Corporation) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:31 [sandro]
(not here) * Susan Lesch <lesch@w3.org> (W3C/MIT) : attending monday
08:25:38 [sandro]
(not here) * Andy Seaborne <andy.seaborne@hp.com> (Hewlett Packard Company) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:44 [sandro]
(not here) * Fabien Gandon <Fabien.Gandon@sophia.inria.fr> (Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et en Automatique) : attending monday, tuesday
08:25:45 [Darko]
Darko has joined #rif
08:26:19 [sandro]
(not here) * Carine Bournez <carine@w3.org> (W3C/ERCIM) : attending monday, tuesday
08:26:40 [sandro]
s/(not here)//
08:26:49 [sandro]
* Ivan Herman <ivan@w3.org> (W3C/ERCIM) : attending monday
08:27:20 [sandro]
* Alistair Miles <a.j.miles@rl.ac.uk> (Council for the Central Laboratory of the Research Councils (CCL)) : attending monday, tuesday
08:27:29 [sandro]
* Eric Prud'hommeaux <eric@w3.org> (W3C/ERCIM) : attending monday, tuesday
08:28:45 [sandro]
* Brian McBride
08:29:12 [sandro]
Attendees complete.
08:29:54 [mdean]
Mike Dean on IRC and phone
08:30:13 [GaryHallmark]
ScribeNick: GaryHallmark
08:30:14 [sandro]
Topic: 09:00-10:30 - Review Use Cases (section 2 of [WWW] UC&R draft)
08:31:09 [sandro]
rrsagent, make minutes
08:31:09 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/02/27-rif-minutes.html sandro
08:32:29 [GaryHallmark]
ScribeNick: GaryHallmark
08:35:09 [GaryHallmark]
christian: forus on the purpose of rule interchange
08:35:23 [GaryHallmark]
... e.g. it could be compliance
08:36:18 [GaryHallmark]
... or negotiation to refine the rule
08:37:16 [GaryHallmark]
... or to extend and published ontology
08:37:18 [GaryHallmark]
s/and/an
08:37:28 [GaryHallmark]
s/an/a
08:37:41 [ericP]
ericP has joined #rif
08:37:50 [Harold]
Harold has joined #rif
08:38:02 [ericP]
sandro, would you like me to chekc on the speaker phone?
08:38:22 [ivan]
s/forus/focus/
08:38:39 [GaryHallmark]
... RIF could be used without interchange, e.g. persitance
08:38:48 [sandro]
Sure, EricP, but coordinate with Carine, who might be checking as well.
08:39:11 [GaryHallmark]
s/persitance/persistence
08:39:32 [sandro]
Christian: 1. Purpose of Publish/Interchange of Rule
08:39:32 [sandro]
Christian: 2. Purpose of Translating the Rules into RIF
08:39:32 [sandro]
08:39:35 [GaryHallmark]
... look for gaps and overlaps in UCs
08:39:36 [aliman]
aliman has joined #rif
08:42:47 [GaryHallmark]
allen: would like OWL use cases as a model for ours
08:43:50 [GiorgosStamou]
GiorgosStamou has joined #rif
08:44:02 [GaryHallmark]
... uses cases should drive design requirements but not be over-analyzed
08:44:41 [sandro]
+1 on Frank & Allen (don't worry about UC's being idiosyncratic -- just use them to drive Goals/Requirements.)
08:45:36 [GaryHallmark]
... use case names should catch people's interest
08:47:00 [DaveReynolds]
DaveReynolds has joined #rif
08:49:42 [GaryHallmark]
GaryHallmark has joined #rif
08:50:16 [GaryHallmark]
frank: look for fundamental drivers and issues rather than more cases
08:52:03 [GaryHallmark]
sandro: use cases should drive design decisions
08:52:52 [ericP]
in the DAWG, use cases lead directly to requirements
08:52:56 [JeremyCarroll]
JeremyCarroll has joined #rif
08:53:21 [ericP]
the two were cross-ref'd, which allowed us to drop redundant use cases
08:53:42 [Zakim]
Zakim has joined #rif
08:54:07 [sandro]
zakim, who is here?
08:54:07 [Zakim]
sorry, sandro, I don't know what conference this is
08:54:09 [Zakim]
On IRC I see JeremyCarroll, GaryHallmark, DaveReynolds, GiorgosStamou, aliman, Harold, ericP, Darko, JeffP, LeeF, EliasT, AxelPolleres, ivan, PaulaP, MarkusK, msintek, Francois,
08:54:11 [sandro]
zakim, this is rifwg
08:54:11 [Zakim]
... josb, FrankMcCabe, RRSAgent, sandro, mdean
08:54:12 [Zakim]
ok, sandro; that matches SW_RIF(TP)3:00AM
08:55:10 [GaryHallmark]
topic: information integration use case
08:55:31 [GaryHallmark]
allen: now named business process design
08:56:08 [GaryHallmark]
... rif would help redesign or improve biz process
08:57:26 [GaryHallmark]
frank: tried to make the case more compelling
08:57:34 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/wiki/UCR/Information_Integration
08:57:37 [GaryHallmark]
... driver: dynamic integration of information
08:58:39 [GaryHallmark]
... explore synergy of biz processes and rules
08:59:43 [sandro]
Uli: is this about integrating data (via rules), or integrating rules?
08:59:48 [GaryHallmark]
... about integrating rules, not using rules to integrate data
08:59:54 [sandro]
Frank: integrating rules.
09:01:06 [sandro]
Frank: We need access to business rules of supply chain partners.
09:02:37 [GaryHallmark]
francois: rule integration should be a central theme of several use cases
09:03:09 [GaryHallmark]
s/rule/ruleset
09:03:28 [sandro]
Francois: "Integrating rule sets"
09:04:32 [sandro]
Jeremy: HP wants integration of data!
09:05:04 [josb]
+1 agree with Jeremy; RIF should support information integration
09:05:21 [sandro]
Christian: Yes -- if this section turns into Ruleset Integration, we need data mapping someone else.
09:05:43 [sandro]
s/someone/somewhere
09:06:05 [GaryHallmark]
frank: Hendler argues that RIF is for rule interchange, not information integration
09:07:35 [GaryHallmark]
francois: rif is for both information integration and rule set integration
09:08:20 [GaryHallmark]
... rule sets will need to be integrated sometime after they exist
09:09:22 [GaryHallmark]
... because the rule sets are developed in parallel
09:11:09 [sandro]
Christian: if each user does the data mapping rules on their own, ... that doesn't scale.
09:11:44 [sandro]
... I need to import that rules.
09:12:22 [sandro]
Jeremy: If I can publish my mappings in a publically understanding format, then it *does* scale.
09:12:59 [sandro]
...: But Jena rules doesn't solve the problem -- we need RIF so people can publish the rules for re-use.
09:13:28 [sandro]
Frank: Is RIF yet another rule language for describing mappings.
09:13:53 [ivan_]
ivan_ has joined #rif
09:14:46 [GaryHallmark]
francois: porting rules is hard
09:15:04 [GaryHallmark]
... but we can enable publishing
09:17:51 [GaryHallmark]
sandro: would like more concrete details about possible data mapping use case
09:19:23 [sandro]
sandro: I specifically heard Frank say "We need access to business rules of supply chain partners" -- and I like that as a concrete, motivated use case
09:19:41 [sandro]
sandro: And Jeremy seems to be motivated on data mapping.
09:19:46 [GaryHallmark]
frank: familiar with product that uses rules to map biz terms to IT term, but it doesn't involve rule exchange
09:21:11 [sandro]
Jeremy: Is enterpirse information integration problem done in one giant leap (millions paid to SAP), or does one do it in a distributed small-steps manner? The latter requires publishing rules.
09:21:30 [sandro]
sandro; Call that "Grassroots Data Integration"
09:21:40 [sandro]
s/;/:/
09:23:13 [sandro]
sandro: I'm hearing two use cases here : ruleset integration (eg for supply chain); grassroots data integration (eg vocabulary mapping business -to- IT vocabularies)
09:23:47 [sandro]
"access to business rules of supply chain partners"
09:25:42 [GaryHallmark]
frank: supplier and customer relationships are different
09:26:16 [sandro]
christian: do you need to execute the rules?
09:26:32 [sandro]
frank: not clear
09:27:08 [GaryHallmark]
... i.e. the rules are not aggregated
09:28:44 [GaryHallmark]
frank: relationships are dynamic - data may come from you or partner, rules may be executed by you or partner
09:29:40 [sandro]
portability vs publication
09:30:18 [GaryHallmark]
sandro: need to move to another use case
09:31:56 [sandro]
topic: Coffee Break until 11:00
09:33:35 [MalaMehrotra]
MalaMehrotra has joined #rif
09:48:16 [deepalik]
deepalik has joined #rif
10:02:10 [sandro]
RRSAgent, make minutes
10:02:10 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/02/27-rif-minutes.html sandro
10:03:41 [Zakim]
+??P3
10:03:42 [Zakim]
+Dave_Reynolds (was ??P3)
10:03:58 [sandro]
topic: UCR - Decision Support
10:04:06 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/wiki/UCR/Decision_Support
10:09:05 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
10:09:35 [sandro]
ScribeNick: deepalik
10:10:48 [igor]
igor has joined #rif
10:11:11 [sandro]
Christian: 15 minutes on Decision Support use case
10:11:37 [sandro]
... note Leora is not here
10:12:45 [sandro]
... Decision Support -> Integrating Rules from Multiple Knowledge Sources for Decision Support
10:13:19 [deepalik]
csma: key focus of use case is integrating rules from multiple knowledge sources for decision support
10:13:39 [MarkusK]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/wiki/UCR/Decision_Support
10:14:13 [deepalik]
might want to distinguish between interoperation and integration
10:14:48 [MarkusK]
s/might/Uli Sattler: might"
10:15:10 [MarkusK]
s/might/Uli Sattler: might/
10:18:14 [sandro]
csma: will anyone argue for keeping the E-Learning use cases?
10:18:34 [deepalik]
csma: this is clearly a use case of aggregation-- the doctore scenario does not add value to this. Hence, might want to drop this
10:18:44 [deepalik]
s/doctore/doctor
10:19:40 [deepalik]
s/doctor/E-learning use case
10:21:48 [josb]
+1 on Sandro's comment; use case descriptions should be concise
10:27:04 [deepalik]
this section needs some review to cover important points covered in straw poll comments
10:29:10 [FrankMcCabe]
FrankMcCabe has joined #rif
10:31:11 [deepalik]
csma: what are the key dimensions of this use case?
10:31:29 [sandro]
suggested: 2.2 Ruleset Integration for Medical Decision Support
10:32:45 [sandro]
suggested: 2.* Interative User Training Via Reactive Rules
10:33:36 [sandro]
Francois: Main title as one axies, subtitle as another axis -- doesn't really matter which is which.
10:34:21 [deepalik]
Need to rename this section with maybe a subtitle.
10:34:31 [sandro]
Uli: another heading: added value from RIF
10:37:32 [sandro]
Francois: Give me an appplication based on Rules, and half a day, and I'll show you how you'll end up with rule interchange!
10:37:47 [sandro]
+1
10:39:20 [josb]
+1 agree with last comment Francois
10:42:28 [sandro]
sandro: does the WG agree that aggregating rules for decision support -- eg for drug proscribing -- is in scope for us, something to do.
10:42:43 [deepalik]
sandro: vote on who thinks that aggregating rules for decision support systems is in scope
10:43:37 [sandro]
paul: are they cases where you do the integration by hand now?
10:46:46 [sandro]
Christine: you need to aggregate onotologies (as in Charter use case) as well as rules.
10:47:51 [sandro]
accessing and integrating rules from many sources to support decision -- is this a RIF Use Case?
10:48:19 [sandro]
resolved: in scope
10:50:16 [sandro]
Christian: different from Frank's case in that you're integrating the rules here.
10:50:31 [sandro]
Hassan: Digest the rules.
10:51:03 [deepalik]
different from integration use case is you take ownership on rules
10:51:10 [sandro]
Gary: really want a few simple examples of rules in each use case!!
10:51:27 [sandro]
(widely seconded)
10:52:08 [deepalik]
2-3 people don't think it should be done
10:52:16 [sandro]
why not: Peter -- examples could be another source of contention, or could be wrong, or could concentrate attention on things that don't matter.
10:52:52 [sandro]
Peter: eg endless arguments about the service syntax.
10:53:23 [sandro]
Allen: as long as it's clear, examples not needed. Might even be offputting.
10:53:29 [deepalik]
Allen: Did not support it because it is not crucial to formalize them
10:54:23 [deepalik]
Use don't have to use a formal syntax-- it could be in natural language
10:54:24 [sandro]
josb: rules can be in pseudocode
10:54:35 [deepalik]
s/Use/Rules
10:54:39 [sandro]
josb: this is rule 1: (in english)
10:55:50 [sandro]
Francois: be careful that people might read too much into examples -- like that this is the syntax we'll be using!
10:56:19 [sandro]
(I wonder if each example could be captioned "Pseudo-code example")
10:56:29 [deepalik]
mala: the interchange aspects are not brought out by examples.
10:57:03 [deepalik]
csma:examples could be more like protocols (?)
10:59:05 [jeremy]
jeremy has joined #rif
11:02:36 [jeremy]
jeremy has joined #rif
11:03:46 [AxelPolleres]
AxelPolleres has joined #rif
11:04:01 [JosDeRoo]
JosDeRoo has joined #rif
11:04:28 [GaryHallmark]
GaryHallmark has joined #rif
11:05:35 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
11:07:01 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
11:08:03 [ivan]
ivan has joined #rif
11:16:37 [Zakim]
-Dave_Reynolds
11:17:48 [msintek]
msintek has left #rif
11:17:54 [PaulaP]
PaulaP has joined #rif
11:17:58 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
11:18:09 [EliasT]
EliasT has joined #rif
11:18:13 [josb]
josb has joined #rif
11:18:49 [sandro]
sandro has joined #rif
11:21:13 [PaulaP]
PaulaP has left #rif
11:28:45 [Zakim]
-Mike_Dean
11:31:15 [csma]
csma has joined #rif
11:31:41 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/diff-20060215-20060227.html
11:51:28 [jeremy]
jeremy has joined #rif
11:53:47 [JosDeRoo]
JosDeRoo has joined #rif
12:12:30 [sandro]
sandro has joined #rif
12:40:12 [patranja]
patranja has joined #rif
12:42:27 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
12:44:38 [josb]
josb has joined #rif
12:49:28 [aharth]
aharth has joined #rif
12:55:06 [Zakim]
+Mike_Dean
12:55:18 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
12:55:50 [Francois]
Francois has joined #rif
12:56:03 [Vassilis]
Vassilis has joined #rif
12:57:36 [bwm]
bwm has joined #rif
12:58:16 [FrankMcCabe]
FrankMcCabe has joined #rif
12:58:26 [Zakim]
+??P4
12:58:30 [Zakim]
+Dave_Reynolds (was ??P4)
12:59:44 [tlr]
tlr has joined #rif
13:01:46 [Vassilis]
\me, Hello
13:02:34 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
13:02:35 [sandro]
RRSAgent, make minutes
13:02:35 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2006/02/27-rif-minutes.html sandro
13:04:06 [sandro]
Note for the record that we have real network problems -- some people can't get on IRC.
13:07:43 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/draft-20060227.html
13:08:00 [sandro]
http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/draft-20060227.html#Cross-Platform_Rule_Development_and_Deployment
13:09:02 [AxelPolleres]
AxelPolleres has joined #rif
13:10:24 [sandro]
Mala: My objection was about the importance of templates, which help highlight differences between rules.
13:10:33 [EliasT]
EliasT has joined #rif
13:12:40 [Darko]
Darko has joined #rif
13:13:31 [ivan]
ivan has joined #rif
13:15:07 [LeeF]
LeeF has joined #rif
13:15:43 [sandro]
PaulV: We use have parameterized templates-- design patterns for rules -- but they are orthogonal to rules themselves. It might be useful to pass around templates, sure.
13:18:01 [GaryHallmark]
GaryHallmark has joined #rif
13:18:01 [sandro]
Harold: These are rule schemes
13:18:11 [sandro]
s/mes/mas/
13:20:29 [aharth]
aharth has joined #rif
13:24:52 [igor]
igor has joined #rif
13:25:56 [sandro]
Francois: Rule signatures
13:44:57 [sandro]
RESOLVED: approve 2.3 as modified on wiki and with new title (as shown on csma's slide)
13:45:50 [sandro]
(where Approval means for next editor's draft --- objections might still come from member's orgs -- not quite approval for publication yet.)
13:47:07 [sandro]
old version (straw poll version) is http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/draft-20060215
13:48:00 [sandro]
diff of section 2.4 (this one) is http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/diff-20060215-20060227.html#Policy-Based_Transaction_Authorization_and_Access_Control
13:53:19 [GiorgosStamou]
GiorgosStamou has joined #rif
13:53:27 [sandro]
sandro has left #rif
13:53:34 [sandro]
sandro has joined #rif
13:55:32 [Keeper]
Keeper has joined #rif
13:56:41 [RalphS]
RalphS has joined #rif
13:58:35 [sandro]
Donald: RIF needs to pick a standard language for its facts, eg RDF
14:12:08 [tlr]
tlr has joined #rif
14:12:35 [JosDeRoo]
JosDeRoo has joined #rif
14:17:45 [JosDeRoo]
changes at http://www.w3.org/2005/rules/wg/ucr/diff-20060215-20060227.html
14:18:24 [LeeF]
LeeF has left #rif
14:20:03 [MalaMehrotra]
MalaMehrotra has joined #rif
14:22:06 [sandro]
RESOLVED: approve 2.4
15:03:33 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
15:15:19 [tlr]
tlr has joined #rif
15:26:08 [AllenG]
AllenG has joined #rif
16:00:04 [Zakim]
-Dave_Reynolds
16:01:05 [msintek]
msintek has joined #rif
16:10:17 [FrankMcCabe]
FrankMcCabe has joined #rif
16:13:32 [PaulaP]
PaulaP has joined #rif
16:17:19 [josb]
josb has joined #rif
16:19:06 [bwm]
bwm has joined #rif
16:21:16 [EvanWallace]
EvanWallace has joined #rif
16:28:44 [MalaMehrotra]
MalaMehrotra has joined #rif
16:30:20 [GaryHallmark]
GaryHallmark has joined #rif
16:32:47 [bwm]
bwm has joined #rif
16:39:07 [MarkusK]
MarkusK has joined #rif
16:41:13 [sandro]
sandro has joined #rif
16:46:35 [ivan]
ivan has joined #rif
17:03:00 [Zakim]
-Mike_Dean
17:08:00 [Zakim]
disconnecting the lone participant, TPRivieraC, in SW_RIF(TP)3:00AM
17:08:03 [Zakim]
SW_RIF(TP)3:00AM has ended
17:08:05 [Zakim]
Attendees were Mike_Dean, TPRivieraC, Dave_Reynolds
17:10:04 [Zakim]
Zakim has left #rif
17:10:14 [mdean]
mdean has left #rif